this game is depressingly dead

can you prod deathxshinigami and diamondcrash please

0_o wrote:

Well I read through everything and I nothing new really popped out at me. I really don't think Two is mafia as I believe all of his actions so far are justified (if not a little overconfident). I don't have any hard evidence against anyone else, but for some reason NoHItter's posts have been rubbing me the wrong way and I can't put my finger on exactly why. So for now I'm just gonna go with my gut and vote NoHItter.

Relying on your gut?
It's Day 2. There should be some amount of proof right now.
You can go back to Day 1 and check the actions of everyone.

DiamondCrash has seemed the most suspicious overall to me, but I would rather we lynch Lybydose or deathxshinigami so we can still have some semblance of activity day 3.

Prodding me while not prodding lybydose. @_@ What a shame...

Unvote
After reading through, I have to say that my reasons for voting for Two were not very justified at all. I think I was finding him as arrogant and that was why I voted for him, but now I understand that being aggressive towards everyone is just the way he plays. And getting rid of inactives would be a better thing to do. However, I will wait till we see Lybydose's replacement before voting.

NoHItter wrote:

Relying on your gut?
It's Day 2. There should be some amount of proof right now.
You can go back to Day 1 and check the actions of everyone.

I already did go and read through everything. The focus of all the conversation was either on Two, Nataka or Mashley, the first whom I believe is innocent while the other two are dead. They were the three most active players (with the possible exception of strager, whom I have no reason at the moment to think is mafia) so there really isn't a lot of hard evidence to go on. So yes, for now my vote goes towards gut instinct.

DxS do you have any opinions at all about anyone? If you're gonna join you might as well contribute.

Hello everyone. I am Malachite and I come from the great beyond to play your sport.

I don't have the time to read now, but I hope to get some content to y'all tomorrow.

Oh great, some one shot player just joined, like that's totally better than Lybydose.

DeathxShinigami wrote:

Oh great, some one shot player just joined, like that's totally better than Lybydose.

He's been about at useful as you so far.

Sizzle!

Two wrote:

DiamondCrash has seemed the most suspicious overall to me, but I would rather we lynch Lybydose or deathxshinigami so we can still have some semblance of activity day 3.

Can you explain why you find DiamondCrash suspicious?

@Wojjan
You still haven't answered my question.

It's mostly this post that gave it away.

just to remind you all, the day ends tomorrow

y

When I fix some things IRL I'll be able to do a re-read and get involved in this game again.

I've been trying to contact some players via IRC and it hasn't been working. Maybe I'll PM them on the forums.

n

I was just a silent replacement anyways.

n

I'd wait another day at least, might as well get another round of night actions in before calling it quits.

So y

y
I want to at least be able to see what will happen. But we need more people talking today.

y

I'm only not posting cause I've already said everything I have to say. D:

I'm working on a re-read of the game thread. Here's what I have so far:

(link) meronmyon is impatient to get the game started; aux/Mafia tell
(link) Oyashiro Beatrice not amused by RVS
(link) Nakata Yuji role fisher baiting
(link) matthewtck votes without bolding, even after SFG explicitly stated in the thread earlier; shows less care about the game thread; Mafia tell
(link) Nakata Yuji "want[s] the day to end"; aux/Mafia tell; hindsight: response to Two's comment about getting more information after Night (link)
(link) Nakata Yuji tries to reverse the effects of her actions; either the aux/Mafia tell was an accident and she's trying to show she's vanilla (more likely, given her little Mafia experience) or she's trying to cover up that she's an aux or Mafia (and if she was Mafia this possibility would be more likely)
(link) (and in a few of the following posts by Nakata) Nakata Yuji shows her inexperience at Mafia
(link) Faceman steps in, showing he's following the thread, bu
t makes no contributions to the discussion at all; aux/Mafia tell
(link) Nakata Yuji clear doesn't know the game... or assumes everyone else playing is a noob (which is highly unlikely)
(link) Faceman plans for the town; Town tell, given my knowledge of his meta; Faceman is the first to use the term "predator", which is odd (as not even SFG has used that word, until the vote count); Mafia tell
(link) Two misses the point of Faceman's argument, perhaps purposefully to discredit Faceman
(link) WIFOM setup?
(link) rust45 makes the naïve statement that lynching always helps the Town; Mafia or newb Town tell (and IIRC rust45 isn't a newb to Mafia)
(link) Oyashiro Beatrice shows detatchment from the game; Mafia tell
(link) Nakata Yuji's "game turning" post
(link) Two's reaction (an unvote), unexplained; in hindsight this is consistent with what Two said Day 2
(link) pieguy1372 expresses his reaction to Two's unvote (namely him thinking Nakata Yuji holds an important role); in hindsight this plays into Two's plan as well; perhaps Two and pieguy1372 were in communication in an attempt to set this up?; even still, pieguy1372 voted for Two, so I don't suspect buddying
(link) Two builds a case against Mashley, mostly based on Two's belief that Mashley emotionally influences readers of his posts; Mashley and Wojjan comment on this rediculous claim as well; something this weak for a relatively experienced player is a definite Mafia tell
(link) Wojjan also uses "predator"; possible Mafia tell
(link) Two's actions seem consistent with the plan he explained Day 2, in hindsight
(link) Nakata Yuji hints at the Splash ability of her role
(link) Two makes a *possible* Freudian slip, stating "when they posted their role"; this is slightly inconsistent with Two's Day 2 explanation in hindsight
(link) Oyashiro Beatrice jumps in without saying anything useful (again)
(link) >_>
(link) Nakata Yuji shows so much naïvity to how the game operates it kinda disturbs me...

I'll post conclusions after I'm done.

well I vote yes

I think the issue with inactivity is the actual content of the posts that people make, and not their frequency. We're getting a lot of "I'll re-read the thread and get back to you all kthx" posts, and you should all have a decent enough grasp of how the game has progressed to not even need to do that (though with the confusion you all seem to have it is a good idea). Posts like that widen the gap between posts with actual value and stifle discussion.

On the subject of the game, what is with DeathxShinigami's complete unwillingness to post anything at all? Did you join the game just to annoy us or something? And it's not surprising that DiamondCrash would vote no after I said he was the most suspicious.

And strager I disagree that detachment from the game is a "mafia tell". A lot of people are immature and don't like it when they get roles without much importance, and so they have little interest in the game.

Y
Come on guys we need activity here.

strager wrote:

(link) Faceman plans for the town; Town tell, given my knowledge of his meta; Faceman is the first to use the term "predator", which is odd (as not even SFG has used that word, until the vote count); Mafia tell
I'll post conclusions after I'm done.

Actually SFG used "predator" in the opening post. I doubt that it's a mafia tell per se.
Though now that you mention it, we never used predator to refer to scum before. Really odd why Faceman would use that term.

Yes, let's highlight the fact that predator was likely in his role pm. That's super smart and pro-town. (I didn't even notice strager pointing it out)

edit: since today is the last day? and everyone seems reluctant to vote on anything except the continuation of this game, I'm going to just unvote, vote: NoHItter

if it's between me and you dawg I'm going to pick me

In chronological order:

strager

Vote: Two

pieguy1372

Vote: Two

Wojjan

oh, vote: NoHItter

0_o

So for now I'm just gonna go with my gut and vote NoHItter.

Two

I'm going to just unvote, vote: NoHItter

DeathxShinigami

Vote: Two

So, we both had 2 votes before the final two posts, and I voted for NoHItter before DeathxShinigami voted for me. I shouldn't have been lynched, game is broken etc.

It would have been 5 town 2 mafia day 3, so it's a mafia win in my opinion. I don't want to see that bs Ace pulled when town clearly won that game

To illustrate: 10:3 -> 5:2 -> 0:1, 1 = won

Not much you can do now that I've flipped? Don't you mean that there's not much you can do now that you posted my role without double checking votes? See my "illustration" for why the mafia won thx.

Yes but now that is has ended, when you look at the standings, mafia are in the positive and town are in the negative. They've lost 5 to our 1. We win.

No, you don't understand. To win, the town has to eliminate all mafia before they are eliminated themselves. The town has not done their end, either. However, there is a side 'in the lead', and that's mafia. The only part you could argue is that an aux could have killed one of us overnight, and so I propose that we settle this by having whoever would have killed someone tonight take a stab at the last mafia member. If they guess right, town wins. If not, we win.

Well I guess this is as good of a time as any to claim cop and tell you DC is guilty.

DC's guilty what.

Nice try Wojjan, but that little gambit isn't gonna work. Unless you're some kind of Insane Cop, which I somehow doubt. Pray tell who else you investigated and why.

If no one else claims Cop we can assume Wojjan is one because I'd figure there is one, and one hasn't died yet. Anyway, just in case I would like to know who Wojjan checked if he really is Cop.

Good god pieguy! why out of all the avatars you choose you choose that one as your first avatar !_!

Anyways... just saying since Wojjan almost never has a civilian role, he/she must have cop. I'm not a cop btw.

No I'm not actually cop I was just testing for reactions.
Vote: DC

How odd, could Wojjan actually be civilian? Only time will tell. I'll hold my vote for another IRL day.

No I'm not a civvie, my role is an anemone. Whoever targets me at night gets automatic protection.

Ha, that says a lot, forget what I said earlier.

Vote: DC

Why are you voting for me again

gee whiz cause you're mafia?

Hey piegguy where the hell are you?

Whoa, did we figure something out? o_O

Also, I personally find it suspicious that you said DC was Mafia when the killer who's left is almost certainly a Serial Killer. o_o

well that's because I'm not cop. How could I know

Anyways~ if you're sure about yourself wojjan then vote again for DC.

I never unvoted.

And we wait even more so we can move on...

So I'm town. Discuss.

noway lol

with a face like this I have to be

Aaaaaa

Let's just get this over with. Vote: DiamondCrash

Jeez guys. Have you even communicated outside of the thread?

Just end the game now, please.

well no one ever says anything unless they're being voted.
It's 4-way mylo without cops, we can't win this.

wow dxs youd figure you'd at least kill me because lolololol mafia bond

Sorry darling but this time I wanted the spotlight

so who killed me and what's a reflex doctor?

autoprotect upon visits, for both cops and mafia

Lol.

I knew DC wasn't the killer, I just wanted the game over with. D:

EDIT: I just realized the game shouldn't have ended here. If there was a Doctor remaining, there was a chance of no one dying (if I target the Doctor and the killer targets me), where it would be 2 town:1 killer and we'd have another chance of winning. (Unless I'm mistaken)

I knew DxS was the SK btw. You didn't respond to my PM

I was really stupid in this game. I trusted strager with my role, and I killed faceman.

SFG: Night actions and role PMs?

rust45 wrote:

I was really stupid in this game. I trusted strager with my role, and I killed faceman.

\:D/

Two wrote:

rust45 wrote:

strager was really stupid in this game.

I was after making the game fun (for me), not systematically winning the game.

Night actions

N1
- NoHitter tracks 0_o
- 0_o splashes matthewtck
- Nakata Yuji splashes strager
- Two kills Nakata Yuji
- Pieguy refrains from actioning
- Strager splashes Mashley, which doesn’t work because Mashley is dead. Instead, splashes DiamondCrash
- Rust45 refrains from actioning
- Matthewtck, DiamondCrash, Lybydose, and Meronmyon fail to submit actions
o Matthewtck randomly splashes matthewtck
o DiamondCrash randomly splashes pieguy
o Lybydose randomly splashes pieguy
o Meronmyon randomly kills matthewtck

N2
- 0_o splashes DeathxShingami
- DeathxShinigami kills strager
- Strager kills rust45
- Pieguy1372 refrains from actioning
- Rust45 kills 0_o
- DiamondCrash fails to submit an action (DiamondCrash randomly splashes rust45)

SFG wrote:

Strager

...

o Meronmyon randomly kills matthewtck

next time don't make it obvious that he died before the night even started

And rust, don't make it obvious you're aux Day 1.

Two wrote:

o Meronmyon randomly kills matthewtck

next time don't make it obvious that he died before the night even started

Two, darling, I rolled the die to determine who meronmyon killed, as well as all other night actions that were not submitted, at the end of Night 1, not before Day 1 ended.