EvianBubble wrote:

QUESTION TO MODDERS: For the slow section (0.5 inherited), is there a way to increase slider tick rate? I think it only does a tick every 2 beats instead of every 1 ... can I change this?

Odaril wrote:

Major issues in the map: it is highly recommended to fix them.
Minor issue in the map: you don't have to follow them exactly, but I recommend you to.
Suggestions: those are personal opinions, feel free to follow them or not.
Comments.
If there's one red line in the whole mod post, or three blue lines, I won't star the map.

Traveller:
00:17:958 (1) - Move three grids (lvl 3) left.
00:19:684 (3,4) - Move one grid (lvl 3) up. This seems OK to me
00:22:706 (3) - Move one grid (lvl 3) right. Kept this but ...
00:23:138 (4) - Move one grid (lvl 3) down and right. Might have to move it a little more if you fixed ^. ... changed this
00:24:217 (5) - Move one grid (lvl 3) right. Done as well
00:24:864 (6) - ^
00:30:044 (3) - Move one grid (lvl 3) down. Okay
01:20:979 (3) - Move the end point four grids (lvl 3) up and one left so that the star is perfectly symmetrical (you'll have to use a storyboarded arrow to tell which way the slider's going to though). And make it linear ç_ç[/color] Oh snap, I think I'll just leave this ... I have NO experience with storyboarding whatsoever X_X

Hero:
^

Legend:
^

Legendary Hero:
^

That's a lot better than when I modded it first ! Star.

Kecco wrote:

Hello.
I'm a bit worried about the timing. Ask someone who is good in those stuff. Done, PMed someone

•Insane•
The beginning is eggpain-like! Is this a good or a bad thing? XD
00:16:728 (1,2,3,4) - 1 grid up? O_O? I don't have that number or timing in my map ... perhaps you typed the wrong thing? :S

I can keep to modding it, the timing's issues are A LOT, you should ask Lybydose or ask in #modHelp to find a better timing.
When you get it, PM me and I'll remod this map.

I give you star.

Garven wrote:

EvianBubble wrote:

QUESTION TO MODDERS: For the slow section (0.5 inherited), is there a way to increase slider tick rate? I think it only does a tick every 2 beats instead of every 1 ... can I change this?

Nope. Darn. Well, thanks for answering :S

As per your request:

[General]
You have soft whistles on sliderslides that I really don't like the sound of. Others may, but I don't. I'd remove them, but I'll just leave this note and move on. I'll keep an ear out for them ...

[Traveller]
Just at first glance, all I see is a break right at the beginning. :/ Ah well ... not quite sure what else I could do here, and there probably should be a break in a song, right?
00:42:130 (2) - I don't like seeing .5 sections in easy modes, tbh Yea, I PMed Alace about this, I've got it covered (hopefully) XD
There are some semi-complex rhythms in here... but it's not bad enough to complain, really. This is my pro mapping skillz at work. Ahahahaha (... thanks?)

[Hero]
Yeah, I'm not liking that beginning break. :S
In general, fine, though I still don't like the .5 section in this one too. Just makes it feel really cramped and kind of boring to play. :(

[Legend]
00:28:102 (1,2) - Doesn't look very good. :/ Maybe do them in a straight line, curve the slider? Well it's a diagonal straight line, and I WOULD curve the slider but it's kind of short to be curved, IMO

[Legendary Hero] Running out of diff names? Though I guess when the subtext is the Legend of the Legendary Heroes... Shhhh, don't spill all my secrets! D:
00:06:195 (1) - Holy crap, a spinner! Woo! Inorite!? I was debating this actually, but I figured ... well, why not? XD
Nothing terrible, but nothing that stands out to me.

I guess, for the most part, I just really don't like the .5 sections in any of these diffs. It just kills the pace. Maybe I should have thought it through a bit more :S It just sounded like a slow section to me, is all

Garven wrote:

Maybe increase the distance snap a little bit for the .5 sections instead of just letting it do half? Ah well, they were just my thoughts on it anyway, hehe. No need to follow unless you actually agree with me (for some odd reason ).

aesopl19193 wrote:

[General]
Delete the .osb file and full-upload , since you don't need it Oh right, thanks

[Legendary Hero]
00:14:936 (4) - too close (compare with (1,2,3) ) Moved one grid down
00:15:368 (5,6,7) - ^ Moved one grid right
00:35:548 (2) - move to 00:35:656 to fit the vocal? It's on the vocal now, it's on "no" I think
00:42:130 (3) - add finish..? I don't think it really fits here :S
01:04:576 (7) - new combo I don't think this combo is too long, so I'll leave it

Other diff seem fine.
star

In my view , you should make some creation into your rhythm.
It is quite boring if you just follow the vocal.

roflninja wrote:

hi,

[hero]
00:02:418 (2) - stack the end with the end of (1) a bit better? I tried, but you know how the ends of slider don't really fit on the grid so ... not much to be done here unfortunately :S

only that one suggestion, awsome map

animelover1432 wrote:

here's my mod...

?=suggestion

Traveler:
00:21:411 (1): move a little further from 00:20:332 (4) ? Moved the beginning slider point one down and one right
00:24:217 (5): one grid down so it aligns with (4) Well (4 - 6) all supposed to all go up one grid, so I'm leaving it
00:33:497 (4): ^ Ehm ... I think the spacing here is fine O_O
00:34:361: if you do ^ move other notes so they still fit
00:44:720 (4,5,1): move one grid up Done, moved (2, 3) as well so spacing isn't weird
00:55:943 (2): add another repeat? Don't think this fits, IMO
01:08:893: add a note here with finish sound? (6) already has finish ... I think this would be overdoing it :S
01:09:756 (2): align with (1)? I think this is OK


Hero:
00:02:418 (2):redo this slider so its aligned with (1)? I flipped (1), so it should be aligned
01:08:030 (8):stack under (7)? This is just me but I'm not a big fan of stacking notes and sliders, so I'm keeping it


Legend:
00:06:303: add a spinner lasting until 00:07:166? There's one in Legendary Hero ... okay that's not a good reason, but no :S
00:40:404: add a spinner lasting until 00:41:699 and delete the slider? This is supposed to be sort of a mini break, since it's too short for an actual one, so I want this here
00:54:217 (7,8): move 1 grids to the left? I feel this part should be "messy" so I'll keep it

legendary Hero
00:14:936 (4):align with the last slider? Actually I find it looks better like this, (3) is kind of curving and pointing towards (4), so I think it'd feel better
00:16:231 (8): align with the last circle? (5 - 7) are already in a straight line ... I don't want it to feel too "fixed" (left right, up down, etc.)
00:18:389: add a note? Uhm, there already IS a note here O_O
00:18:605: spacing? There's er ... nothing here?
00:20:332 (9,10): i think this would look better stacked with the last slider Yea, this is just me again with my stacking slider / note thing :S
00:41:699 (1): move so its above 2? This is me again not wanting it to be "fixed"
00:48:821 (1,2,3): 1 grid to the left? Okay, done
00:50:332 (6): i find this note very hard to see, change it into a slider lasting from 00:49:900-00:50:332 I think it's OK ... this is supposedly an "insane" anyway (another bad excuse ... what's wrong with me?!) but if too many other people are against it then I'll change it I suppose

there's an OSB file, but there's no storyboard, so delete that and full submit (I think) Done

great map ^.^
*star*

wanhyrzh wrote:

Hihi~here's the mod!
They're just my opinions, so feel free to take some or ignore them~
Now let's go!

General:

SPOILER

1.Set a preview point: timing->set current position as preview point O_O I thought I did already, but did again just to make sure
2.You may not always use the same pattern at every diffs, such as 01:20:979(3). Other than that, all diffs are still too similar. Try to be more creative. Okay, I will look to expand my horisons! *shot* I like the slider, but will try to change the patterns and such
3.Try to add at least 1 spinner at each diff. O_O I'm not a big fan of spinners, is all. I don't really think there's a place to put it either ... I guess that's just me, though

Traveller

SPOILER

I find you using different distance snap (like 0.8x and 0.9x). Since it's an Easy, You'd better keep one distance snap and move all the notes to the correct place. Er, well I may have changed it for smaller vs. larger time intervals, because otherwise I thought it was too cluttered, but I'll take note of this, thanks
And as an easy diff, I strongly suggest you not to follow the song lyrics. NOT to follow the lyrics?! O_O Uh, okay then ...
00:00:692(1) remove whistle and add finish This is just me again, but I don't like overusing finishes. I feel whistle is better here
00:02:418(2) remove whistle Okay
00:04:145(3) add whistle Added
00:16:879(4) I suggest you to remove this short slider then add a note at 00:17:094, since you just don't follow the song lyrics in other places(and as an Easy, you may not have so many 1/2 notes. The point is, I feel you just using a standard Easy-style in some place, which don't focus on the song lyrics, but then you change to another style which focus on song lyrics. I think you'd better just keep the style consistent). Then you may add clap on that note. I kind of get what you're trying to say, but I think just a note here wouldn't fit as well. I think the slider is better here
00:20:332(4) ^
00:21:411(1) shorten this slider to 00:21:843 I'm going to keep this but ...
00:24:217(5) move the note to 00:24:433 ... I'll do this
00:24:864(6) lengthen this slider to 00:25:296 I don't like this :S
00:29:181(2) same as 00:21:411
00:30:692(4) move this to 00:30:476 then lengthen to 00:30:907 This doesn't really fit with me either
00:35:224(1) lengthen this to 00:35:656 Okay
00:36:950(1) ^
00:39:325(5) remove this slider, then add a reverse at 00:38:677(4) Ehrm, no :S
00:44:720(4) remove this note then lengthen 00:43:857 so that the reverse at 00:44:289 and the end at 00:44:720, the remove the whistle. I think this is fine as well. 1/2 beats aren't going to kill. They're even overlapping O_O
00:49:900(2) remove the note then lengthen the shorten 00:49:037(1) to 00:49:468, then add a reverse on it. I think this is better, what you suggested isn't as interesting IMO
00:50:332(x) add note with clap I actually really like this idea and would add it in, but I want this part to be "calmer"
00:51:627(3) remove the note, then lengthen 00:50:763(2) to 00:51:627
00:52:058(x) add note with clap
00:55:943(2) lengthen this slider so that the reverse is at 00:56:375, the end is at 00:56:807 I don't really see a reason for this, it fits the words perfectly
01:03:713(2) same as 00:49:900(2)
01:05:440(2) ^
01:05:871(x) add note I don't think I need to, it doesn't "feel" good to me
01:09:756(2) same as 00:55:943(2)
01:19:253(x) add note?

This diff is meant as an easy, not a beginner one note every bar difficulty. 1/2 beats aren't that hard. I asked my bro, who has played Osu! pretty much twice before (also when playtesting for me, actually) and asked his opinion, and he said it was fine. Personally I think it's pretty easy as well, but each to their own, I suppose

Hero:

SPOILER

I still find you using different distance snap. An easy or a normal should not use random spacing. You'd better keep one distance snap and move all the notes to the correct place. This might come as a shock, but I really don't like distance snap (okay, not that much of a shock). I only use it for more than one beat away. I do the shorter ones manually, because I feel I have greater control over what I'm doing. Again, just my personal preference
I still suggest you to keep a consistent style when adding notes. I do think if you want to follow the song lyrics, follow them from the beginning to the end. Otherwise it will be very strange when playing. I do think that I followed the lyrics pretty much all the way through ...
Other than that, this diff is much better.
00:00:692(1) add finish at the start Yea, I don't really like the start with finish, so ... :S
00:02:418(2) close grid snap then try to make the end stack perfectly with slider1's end. Okay, done ... or at least I tried >_<
00:04:145(3) add whistle Okay, added
00:05:008(4) ^

Legend:

SPOILER

In my opinion, still too many random spacing, though it's a hard. I feel weird when playing. I strongly suggest you to use new combo to let people pay attention when changing the spacing. I actually think I'm pretty consistent ... I mean, even if it's werid, at least it's CONSISTENTLY weird, you know?
00:00:692(1) add finish at the start
00:17:850(x) add note? This is for "variety"
00:23:785(6) move this note to 00:23:569 It feels better on an offbeat here to me
00:24:217(7) new combo I don't think so, no
00:41:699(T) 0.5x bpm should start here Actually this feels like more of a pickup to the 0.5x to me ... but since timing is pretty important, if others think so as well I'll change it
00:41:699(1) combine this slider with the next slider to a long slider. I want to distinguish between the pickup and the slow section so no, but again if others feel otherwise, I suppose it'll have to change :S
01:19:900(x) add note I think it's OK ... :S

Legendary Hero:

SPOILER

This diff is the best of 4 imo.
00:00:692(1) add finish
And I suggest to think about some patterns to put the notesin a more beautiful way. I'm not the greatest at patterns >_< I'll try though!

I think the map needs a lot more work....But it has the potential.
Go on~star.

Zetsubou Sensei wrote:

Hey! Go through all your difficulties and recheck your spacing! It appears off at parts! Fixed
...The video seems laggy a bit to me...

Delete the osb. file and then fully submit.

[Legend]
00:14:289 (1) - make this a repeating slider and remove the 2 Okay, done
00:17:742 (1) - ^ same thing I'll leave this one
00:28:102 (1) - ^
01:02:634 (1) - add a repeat I like this idea but I like mine too, so I'll do it ...
01:02:850 (2) - move this slider to 01:03:066 (shorten it) and make it end at 01:03:497
01:04:361 (1) - add a repeat ... here
01:04:576 (2) - move this slider to 01:04:792 (shorten it) and make it end at 01:05:224

[Legendary Hero]
00:17:742 (1) - make this a repeating slider and remove the 2 (seems better this way) I think it's fine, to be honest :S
00:42:130 (3) - remove the repeat and extend the slider to end at 00:42:454 (sounds better to me) I don't think this really fits :S
00:57:562 (x) - maybe add a note here? Okay, done
01:02:634 (1) - do as I said in Legend I think this is OK as well
01:02:850 (2) - ^


Overall...Its a good map! Fix up the spacing...Its actually pretty bad...

~STAR Here ya go!

Neo Adonis wrote:

(!) - Very important for me ( !! = MUST BE CORRECTED)
(*) - Not so relevant, but maybe helpful.
(?) - Suggestion or in doubt.

[General]
(*) Add "DenYuuDen" as a tag. Okay sure O_O

[Traveller]
(!) I don't like custom spacing. But well, it's (most of the times) well donde. Thanks, I think? I went over spacing last night I think, tried to make it consistent
(?) 00:26:591 (2,3) - Add finish sound? I think it's fine since (1) right after has finish
(?) 01:26:375 (1,2) - I don't like this for a easy. (What do you think, modders?) Personally I think it's fine, but if a lot of people don't like it, then ... do tell, future modders!

[Hero]
(!) 00:22:274 (2,3,4) - For a normal diff, it's confusing. Try using another slider like 00:21:411 (1). Oh, is the spacing change not clear enough? I think it's OK personally, but if more people tell me then I'll change it
(?) 00:26:591 (2,3) - Add finish sound?
(!!) 00:35:224 (1,2,3) - Another confusing part. I suggest a slider with repetition for the first three beats and a slider or two hit circles for the other two beats. Or even better: USE DISTANCE SNAP. It's pretty clear isn't it? One beat away is 3 squares, and 3/4 is 2 ... I don't think this is very hard IMO :S
(!!) 00:36:950 (4,5,6) - ^ -_-
(!) 00:41:267 - Add a hitcircle here. It's confusing trying to hit 00:41:699 (1). Again, I don't really know how this is confusing ... it's the same as all the other difficulties and it's pretty clear to me :S
(!) 01:20:116 (2,3) - Confusing. Replace them with a slider from (2) to (3).} What? It's just a slider then a circle on the beats ...

[Legend]
(*) 00:19:684 (6) - Move this one grid to the left. Trust me, it's a big difference. Okay, done
(!) 00:21:735 (2) - NO. Confusing. Replace it with hit circles. :S I think this is fine as well ...
(?) 00:23:785 (6) - Confusing, but maybe you can use it. Just because it's on an off beat? I think it sounds better than if it's on the strong beat IMO
(?) 00:26:591 (2,3) - Add finish sound?

[Legendary Hero]
(?) I dunno. It doens't like me. But I can't think on a form to get it better.
(!) 00:33:497 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - Do another form using distance snap. This don't like me. I've stuck to the same distance for pretty much the entire song, but I think for here it's fine ...
(!) 00:35:871 (3,4,5,6) - ... and here. Use distance snap, too. Few notes later, this confuse you, but not at the tolerable level for an Insane diff. ... this is nothing compared to other maps I've seen ... :S

This is important. Please correct it.
But well, being good your intentions... Star.

banvi wrote:

hello
Traveller
00:04:145 (3) new combo? (& because there is a spacing problem) I think I will keep the combo and OK I moved further away from (2)
Hero
ok
Legend
ok
Legendary Hero
ok , but...
01:26:375 (1,2) all diff this same pattern. change pattern? Notes added at white and blue ticks

no problem , great!
star

Lissette wrote:

Legendary Hero
There are some parts in this diff that confuses me bit, maybe because i don't like following the vocals too much, but the map is technically fine Ehm, that's good I think?

Traveller
This is too hard for the easiest diff (slider velocity to high imo)
00:55:943 (2,3,4) - wrong spacing (look at time-line) 3 should be a bit far from 2 Ahh, thank you for catching that! Fixed

Star

Lizbeth wrote:

Well I don't see technical problems with the map.
I think notes on blue ticks are a lil hard to hit though, but don't listen to me with this, I guess I'm a bad player, that's it >.<
So have a star

Mashley wrote:

Wow! Nice star slider! Thanks, I really like this as well XD
The background is a little dull, could we have something more exciting? I was thinking of taking a SS of the picture in the middle of the anime (where the break is), should have it up tomorrow hopefully

Traveller
No problems

Hero
No problems either

Legend
00:42:130 (2) - The change in the music doesn't hit until right on the note, so it's impossible to tell that the speed is going to change. Please add a warning. I'm hoping people would know by now (since it's there for the two previous difficulties), but erm, how would I add a warning? :S

Legendary Hero
Same slowdown problem.

loser101 wrote:

Video: BAD What?! What's wrong with it?! T_T

Travler
Great

Hero
Great

Legend
Great

Legendary Hero
Awsome

loser101 wrote:

its all glitchy

pandabun wrote:

Traveller:

00:43:857 (3) - ew what is this make this soft hitsound >:| Lol okay, done

Other than that, me and the pandas approve.

H-boy wrote:

kill .osb file~ Rawr, done

Traveller
Not bad
suggestion..
00:55:943(2) - stop at 00:56:807 I think it's better like this
00:59:397(2) - add finish at the begin I don't think it sounds good here :S
01:09:756(2) - stop at 01:10:620
01:13:209(2) - add finish at the begin

Hero
suggestion..
01:00:260(4) - add finish at the begin I just don't think it fits here >_<
01:14:073(4) - ^

Legend
not bad

Legendary Hero
suggestion..
00:59:397(2) - finish Okay
01:13:209(2) - ^

starrr

James2250 wrote:

Just some small hitsound suggestions, you can ignore them if you want

Traveller:
00:14:504 (1) - put this as finish? I think whistle is good here
00:25:727 (1,2,3) - add whistles? Yes, don't know why I didn't do this before O_O
00:42:130 (2) - add finish to the start? Done

Hero:
00:25:727 (1,2,3) - add whistles? Done
00:42:130 (2) - add finish to the start? Lalala

Legend:
00:25:727 (1,2,3) - add whistles? Added
00:42:130 (2) - add finish to the start This too

Legendary Hero:
00:42:130 (3) - add finish Done

actually surprised BAT's allowed 01:20:979 (6) but I think its nice Yea I PMed about it but no reply -_-" I'm hoping it's OK though because I like it too
no problems with the maps *star*

EvianBubble wrote:

Hiya there! Will you mod my map please?
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/18249 (wait smiley HERE? I usually add them at the end but whatever lol) <- That's you, Djnn lols XD
Yuuki Aira - LAMENT ~Yagate Yorokobi wo~
It's currently +34 (at the time of my posting, anyway)
Thank you very much! Finally a queue without star restrictions lol

Arusha Shuna wrote:

Request Accepted

Traveller
01:20:979 (3) - change this slider to linear type (click the slider then press A)? I like it better slightly curvy like
Hero
00:16:015 (5) - spacing, move it a little bit to the left Done, moved one grid left, reshaped the end
00:22:598 (3) - ^ move it a little bit upward Moved one up
00:22:922 (4) - ^ move it a little bit to the left Moved one grid left
01:20:979 (4) - change this slider to linear type (click the slider then press A)?
Legend
01:19:900 (x) - add a note I think it's OK as is
01:20:979 (6) - change this slider to linear type (click the slider then press A)?
Legendary Hero
01:15:799 (7,8,9) - stack them? I think it's better unstacked
01:20:979 (6) - change this slider to linear type (click the slider then press A)?

good map
STAR!

Djnn wrote:

EvianBubble wrote:

Hiya there! Will you mod my map please?
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/18249 (wait smiley HERE? I usually add them at the end but whatever lol) <- That's you, Djnn lols XD
Yuuki Aira - LAMENT ~Yagate Yorokobi wo~
It's currently +34 (at the time of my posting, anyway)
Thank you very much! Finally a queue without star restrictions lol

Okai!
You passed the test.
Djnn Modding:

[Traveller]:
- Diff is misspelled XD should be traveler. I was unsure about this as well, I looked it up and it's correct with both one "L" and two
00:39:325 (5): maybe delete, add a hit circle, then spinner to fill the empty space? Well this part is meant as a rest since the only break is at the beginning, so I'm leaving it

[Hero]:
00:02:418 (2): remove grid snapping to make the slider ends match each other. OK, fixed I hope
00:27:454 (3): grid size 3: up 2 and right 1 to match with (1): I like it better un - aligned
00:47:310 (3): spinner instead? Ehmm I think I like just a note here instead

[Legend]:
Nothing found.

[Legendary Hero]:
00:41:915 (2): spacing is different from 3-6 That might be because of the 0.5xBPM, but I'm afraid I don't really know how you mean :S

[All Maps]: Endings are all too similar, change them a bit. Added another note in Legend between the last two

star~

adron zhero wrote:

Hmm...
[*]Change?
[>]Change!

All diffs:
* Add a spiner from 1:27:022 to 1:29:612... Personally I don't think it fits, and if I do then extra video will be played >_< (yea I had some issues with it)

Well, rank it as soon as possible

fartownik wrote:

[Traveller]

Decrease HP Drain and OD by 1 tick? I think HP drain is OK but I did OD-1


[Hero]

01:09:756 (2) - End this on the previous red tick (fits the music better). Maybe you are thinking of a different part? This slider does end on a red tick, but the previous one would only make it half a beat long :S
01:20:979 (5) - These 'stars' from the hardness of the difficulty raising are getting uglier and uglier. Yea, slider velocity and circle size probably is to blame for that :S Moved the top onegrid right, hope it looks better now


[Legendary Hero]

00:35:548 (2,3) - SPACING. Oops. (3) moved one down, (4) moved one down and left



cool map, not much visible issues
+star

Xgor wrote:

Ok, here's the mod you requested

[General]
The video is around 18 MB! Don't you think it's a bit too big? Meh, well ... meh :S Everything's under 20MB, that's all that matters to me XD

[Traveller]
00:33:066 (3) - Add clap here. I don't think this sounds good here ...
00:57:238 (3) - Add clap here Oh yea, thanks
01:02:418 (6) - ^ Not here I think
01:14:936 (4) - Add clap at the last part of the slider? Done

[Hero]
00:33:497 (4) - Add clap at the last part of the slider? Okay
00:39:540 (8) - ^ It sounds too heavy here for me
01:14:073 (4) - ^ Added
01:17:526 (2) - ^

[Legend]
00:25:727 (1,2,3) - This is ugly and asymmetric right now, try this instead http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/20679 All right, fixed the shape, hope it looks better :S
00:33:066 (6) - Add clap? Yes
00:34:361 (8) - Add clap at the last part of the slider? Okay, done
00:39:540 (7) - ^ Not going to add it here
01:14:936 (5) - ^

[Legendary Hero]
00:33:066 (4) - Remove whistle, add clap Fixed
00:36:519 (6) - Add clap Done
00:39:540 (8) - Add clap at the last part of the slider? Added
00:57:670 (9) - ^ I don't like it here :S
01:00:260 (5) - ^

Pretty good, I mostly tried to make the claps more consistent at some parts and I didn't find much else
*star*

adron zhero wrote:

I've alredy moded, remenber...

Click there >http://osu.ppy.sh/forum/viewtopic.php?f=6&t=33902&p=498657#p498657 or go some inches up :3

1. I would use offset: 702. Yours feels a bit early.