forum

MAHO-Dou - Ojamajo Carnival (TV Size)

posted
Total Posts
92
Topic Starter
wring
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on 2010年12月9日 at 1:38:06

Artist: MAHO-Dou
Title: Ojamajo Carnival (TV Size)
Source: Ojamajo Doremi
Tags: Opening karenying
BPM: 147.5
Filesize: 11006kb
Play Time: 01:28
Difficulties Available:
  1. Hard (4.64 stars, 173 notes)
  2. Insane (5 stars, 299 notes)
  3. Normal (3.09 stars, 115 notes)
  4. ying's Easy (1.34 stars, 89 notes)
Download: MAHO-Dou - Ojamajo Carnival (TV Size)
Download: MAHO-Dou - Ojamajo Carnival (TV Size) (no video)
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
i love this

Thank you diff ' karenying '
Thank you mp3 ' MoonShade '


plz ledownload
gowww
fight 8-)
Leorda
Konnichiwa

My favorite anime :)

[General]
1) Source : Ojamajo Doremi
2) Delete "Anime" in tags, since that word in Genre when this map get ranked. And delete "Ojamajodoremi" since that word in Source

[Normal]
Can you add clap when the object on 2nd and 4th white tick?

00:14:396 (5) - Finish at start?
00:15:620 (1) - FInish?
00:17:251 (1) - oxox (x = clap)
00:59:875 (B) - This break are too short, remove it?
01:01:303 (1) - Finish?
01:12:724 (4,5,6) - ^

[Hard]
Needs more hitsound....

00:13:580 (4) - Move 1 grid left?
00:57:020 (x) - Add note?
00:59:977 (B) - This break are too short, remove it?

[Insane]
No BG??

Good song
STAR
Topic Starter
wring
oh,thank you very much :)
i fixed
Sakura
[osz File Scan!]
Empty .osb file, please delete and full submit.
ojasec.jpg and oja.jpg are very small backgrounds this will cause them to be pixelated in play
The video appears to have some black borders around it, crop?

[General]
All difficulties have different lead-in times, please make them the same
[Insane] Has a preview time of 60529 while the others have a preview time of 60691 Please make all the preview times the same (You can do this by editing the .osu file)

[Timing]
Offset +18 ms, Dont forget to resnap all notes
Kiai should start at 01:01:139, since that's the enphasis note that starts the chorus, right now your covering the lead in too

[Insane]
00:05:817 (1,2) - Spacing too far Also you should try to make (2) be more curvy
00:14:359 (4) - What form is this supposed to be? looks kind of funny o.o
00:18:020 (3,4) - Spacing too close. I recommend you select (4) and reverse selection.
00:21:478 (2) - New combo
00:25:342 (2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Doesnt feel like a stream to me
00:35:715 (X) - Add a note? there's a Lyric here and seems like your following the lyrics, hear how they say "wa" here?
00:40:800 (1,2) - Spacing too far, to avoid, you can make (3) into a new combo
00:45:681 (5,6) - I recommend you swap those 2 to make a 6 point star hexagon without spacing errors
00:46:088 (7) - Stack Below (4) Instead to avoid spacing errors, or make into a new combo
00:47:919 (4) - New combo
01:01:952 (5) - This looks kind of weird, try to make the edges less sharp and more smooth?
01:05:207 (1,2,3,4,5) - As for this combo it looks kind of weird since (2) is also part of the Lyrics, to keep the jumps somewhat similar rearrange the previous combo and (1,2) of this combo so that (2) is at the bottom of the 4 point parallelogram, then swap (2) and (1) from new combo or you can make (2) closer to (1) and form a triangle with the other 3 notes then make (3) into a new combo, either way (1) cant really be a new combo, because it's still part of the previous combo section of the Lyrics, i do recommend you do the latter since it makes more sense with the song since it seems like a new musical pattern should be there.
01:08:054 (3,4) - If you want to have spacing acceleration, this pattern doesnt hint much to it, try something like a pyramid
or reduce the spacing between those 2 notes.
01:10:902 (3) - Making an slider like this looks kind of ugly, i suggest you rethink this pattern to make something prettier outta it like for example

01:15:986 (3,4,5) - Spacing too close, and it's not hinting me to a jump on (1,2) either.
01:18:630 (1,2) - Swap new combo.

[Hard]
00:18:834 (3) - Burai slider is unrankable (An slider cant overlap itself)
00:25:342 (5) - ^
00:48:122 (3) - Although its better than the previous burai sliders, it's kinda ugly because it touches itself like that.
01:27:986 (1,2,3,4,5) - Try moing (2) and (3) closer

[Normal]
Save the few intentional overlaps, this plays more like an Easy.
00:29:817 (4) - Try to make this slider not be overlapped by the previous one like this for example:
00:38:359 (7,1) - There shouldn't be any jumps on the easiest diff, i recommend you flip everything from here until 00:53:817 (1) (without including it) horizontally to fix.
01:03:580 (6,1) - Try to avoid overlaps like theese on the easiest diff

[Overall]
Really nice and fun maps, i'll be looking forward to rechecking this in the future, Good Luck!~
Topic Starter
wring

Sakura Hana wrote:

[osz File Scan!]
Empty .osb file, please delete and full submit.
ojasec.jpg and oja.jpg are very small backgrounds this will cause them to be pixelated in play Oh,i fixed as i can, but i cant get osb :cry:
The video appears to have some black borders around it, crop? sry, i cant do it :cry:

[General]
All difficulties have different lead-in times, please make them the same
[Insane] Has a preview time of 60529 while the others have a preview time of 60691 Please make all the preview times the same (You can do this by editing the .osu file) fixed

[Timing]
Offset +18 ms, Dont forget to resnap all notes
Kiai should start at 01:01:139, since that's the enphasis note that starts the chorus, right now your covering the lead in too fixed

[Insane]
00:05:817 (1,2) - Spacing too far Also you should try to make (2) be more curvy fixed
00:14:359 (4) - What form is this supposed to be? looks kind of funny o.o fixed
00:18:020 (3,4) - Spacing too close. I recommend you select (4) and reverse selection. fixed
00:21:478 (2) - New combo added
00:25:342 (2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Doesnt feel like a stream to me
00:35:715 (X) - Add a note? there's a Lyric here and seems like your following the lyrics, hear how they say "wa" here? added
00:40:800 (1,2) - Spacing too far, to avoid, you can make (3) into a new combo fixed
00:45:681 (5,6) - I recommend you swap those 2 to make a 6 point star hexagon without spacing errors fixed
00:46:088 (7) - Stack Below (4) Instead to avoid spacing errors, or make into a new combo
00:47:919 (4) - New combo fixed
01:01:952 (5) - This looks kind of weird, try to make the edges less sharp and more smooth? fixed
01:05:207 (1,2,3,4,5) - As for this combo it looks kind of weird since (2) is also part of the Lyrics, to keep the jumps somewhat similar rearrange the previous combo and (1,2) of this combo so that (2) is at the bottom of the 4 point parallelogram, then swap (2) and (1) from new combo or you can make (2) closer to (1) and form a triangle with the other 3 notes then make (3) into a new combo, either way (1) cant really be a new combo, because it's still part of the previous combo section of the Lyrics, i do recommend you do the latter since it makes more sense with the song since it seems like a new musical pattern should be there. fixed
01:08:054 (3,4) - If you want to have spacing acceleration, this pattern doesnt hint much to it, try something like a pyramid or reduce the spacing between those 2 notes. fixed
01:10:902 (3) - Making an slider like this looks kind of ugly, i suggest you rethink this pattern to make something prettier outta it like for example fixed

01:15:986 (3,4,5) - Spacing too close, and it's not hinting me to a jump on (1,2) either. fixed
01:18:630 (1,2) - Swap new combo. fixed

[Hard]
00:18:834 (3) - Burai slider is unrankable (An slider cant overlap itself)
00:25:342 (5) - ^
00:48:122 (3) - Although its better than the previous burai sliders, it's kinda ugly because it touches itself like that. fixed
01:27:986 (1,2,3,4,5) - Try moing (2) and (3) closer fixed

[Normal]
Save the few intentional overlaps, this plays more like an Easy. changed Easy
00:29:817 (4) - Try to make this slider not be overlapped by the previous one like this for example: fixed
00:38:359 (7,1) - There shouldn't be any jumps on the easiest diff, i recommend you flip everything from here until 00:53:817 (1) (without including it) horizontally to fix. 00:40:818 (1,2,3) -
01:03:580 (6,1) - Try to avoid overlaps like theese on the easiest diff fixed

[Overall]
Really nice and fun maps, i'll be looking forward to rechecking this in the future, Good Luck!~
Thank you!! :)
Kotone
all
Delete .osb
Change title : Ojamajo Carnival (TV size)
I think it is TV size...?
I don't like the slider like Hard diff 00:44:886...try make them beautiful~

Easy
00:09:089(1)- no clap
00:12:343(1)- ^
01:23:733(2)- ^
01:25:564(1)- add finish(hitsound)
01:26:784(1)- ^
01:28:004(1)- ^

Hard
00:11:733(6)- no clap
00:38:377(1)- Extend to 00:39:801

Insane
01:05:835(x)-add a circle
Topic Starter
wring

karenying wrote:

all
Delete .osb
Change title : Ojamajo Carnival (TV size)
I think it is TV size...?
I don't like the slider like Hard diff 00:44:886...try make them beautiful~ fixed
It is error , because i already have 2 pending. If i want to change the title , should wait other goto Graveyard ?

karenying wrote:

Easy
00:09:089(1)- no clap
00:12:343(1)- ^
01:23:733(2)- ^ fixed
01:25:564(1)- add finish(hitsound)
01:26:784(1)- ^
01:28:004(1)- ^ fixed

Hard
00:11:733(6)- no clap fixed
00:38:377(1)- Extend to 00:39:801 fixed

Insane
01:05:835(x)-add a circle fixed
Thank you! :)
KRZY
Hi!

[General]
There is no way whatsoever [Easy] can pass as an Easy, change it to [Normal] and map an Easy difficulty.

[Easy]
01:23:733 (2) - Adjust this slider so that it starts at 01:23:937 and ends at 01:24:343. Also, add a note at 01:23:733.

[Hard]
00:08:276 (1) - Remove new combo. Also, add a clap at the middle of the slider.
00:57:699 (1) - Move this spinner to 00:57:903. Also, add a note at 00:57:699.

[Insane]
I have a feeling this difficulty is slightly overmapped..
00:53:937 (1) - Is this note really necessary...?
01:12:547 ~ 01:13:360 - This section should be mapped in 1/3.
01:22:106 (X) - Add a note here.


Overall, great map.
Star!
Kotone

wring wrote:

It is error , because i already have 2 pending. If i want to change the title , should wait other goto Graveyard ?
see this :3
viewtopic.php?f=56&t=24443
Topic Starter
wring

KRZY wrote:

Hi!

[General]
There is no way whatsoever [Easy] can pass as an Easy, change it to [Normal] and map an Easy difficulty. Changed

[Easy]
01:23:733 (2) - Adjust this slider so that it starts at 01:23:937 and ends at 01:24:343. Also, add a note at 01:23:733. Fixes

[Hard]
00:08:276 (1) - Remove new combo. Also, add a clap at the middle of the slider. Fixes
00:57:699 (1) - Move this spinner to 00:57:903. Also, add a note at 00:57:699. Fixes

[Insane]
I have a feeling this difficulty is slightly overmapped..
00:53:937 (1) - Is this note really necessary...? Fixes
01:12:547 ~ 01:13:360 - This section should be mapped in 1/3. Fixes
01:22:106 (X) - Add a note here. Fixes


Overall, great map.
Star!

Thank you :)


karenying wrote:

see this :3
viewtopic.php?f=56&t=24443

Oh! I could do it!Thanks :)
brikel
Hi~

[Normal]
01:04:004 (1) - Um.. the end point add clap?
01:19:869 (5) - Use clap?

[Hard]
00:23:733 (1) - add whistle the end?
00:25:157 (4) - add whistle?
00:27:394 (2) - add clap the end?
01:28:818 (5) - Um... use finish?

[Insane]
00:12:953 (3,5,7) - add whistle?
00:17:631 (2,4) - add whistle the end?
00:19:055 (2,4) - add whistle?
00:24:547 (6,8) - ^
00:25:360 (2,6) - ^
00:26:174 (4,8) - ^
00:26:784 (9) - use clap?
00:26:987 (1,3) - add whistle the first?
00:42:242 (4) - add whistle?
00:45:496 (4) - ^

I watched this ani on tv the past. It's fun :)
Ok nice song. Star! :)
Topic Starter
wring
All fixed
Thank you!! :)
Arusha Shuna
Request Accepted, sorry for the delay
General
your map needs an easy difficulty (star rating less than 3.00)
hard
00:35:733 (x) - add a note
01:05:835 (x) - ^

Good map!
STAR!

no kudosu please~
Topic Starter
wring
Thank you!
Ok,i'll make Easy.
Zetsubou Sensei
Hey.

[Normal]
Check AIMOD for spacing problems...
Seems fine.

[Hard]
Use 1.60 Silder Velocity on this diff...So it will take a little remapping...Since Insane's SV is 2.00...and Hard's is 1.90...I'd fix it.

[Insane]
Kiai Time at the beginning is pointless...Remove it.
01:12:547 (1-7) - These notes aren't on ticks properly
Seeks fine.

~STAR
Kotone
Hey, can I make easy diff?
Soaprman
All the maps played well to me. I didn't spot any errors. If you want, I can come back and look again once you get an easy difficulty up since you seem to be making one?

At any rate, starred~
Topic Starter
wring

Zetsubou Sensei wrote:

Hey.

[Normal]
Check AIMOD for spacing problems...
Seems fine.

[Hard]
Use 1.60 Silder Velocity on this diff...So it will take a little remapping...Since Insane's SV is 2.00...and Hard's is 1.90...I'd fix it.
Wmm,i think 1.90 is good because i guess this map is not so difficult.
But another or more will say it should fix, i must fix it!


[Insane]
Kiai Time at the beginning is pointless...Remove it. Fixed
01:12:547 (1-7) - These notes aren't on ticks properly Fixed
Seeks fine.
Thank you!!
Topic Starter
wring

karenying wrote:

Hey, can I make easy diff?

Oh!! :)
Plz ahead :D



Soaprman wrote:

All the maps played well to me. I didn't spot any errors. If you want, I can come back and look again once you get an easy difficulty up since you seem to be making one?

At any rate, starred~

Thank you star and I really hope so :)
Kotone
:D
Topic Starter
wring
thx :)
wmfchris
[insane]
0:37:767 (9) maybe right 1 grid?
0:54:242 (2,3,4,...) right 1 grid
0:54:852 (6) up 1 grid, next combo (3) down 1 grid
1:20:377 (2,3,4) uneven spacing
1:24:750 (6) unsnapped?

[hard]
0:24:750 (2) left 1 grid
0:25:360 (5) down 1 grid
1:26:174 (6) left 1 grid

star~
Topic Starter
wring

wmfchris wrote:

[insane]
0:37:767 (9) maybe right 1 grid? Fixed
0:54:242 (2,3,4,...) right 1 grid Fixed
0:54:852 (6) up 1 grid, next combo (3) down 1 grid Fixed
1:20:377 (2,3,4) uneven spacing Fixed
1:24:750 (6) unsnapped?

[hard]
0:24:750 (2) left 1 grid Fixed
0:25:360 (5) down 1 grid Fixed
1:26:174 (6) left 1 grid Fixed

star~
Thank you!! :)
DJPop
Artist should be MAHO-Dou (MAHO堂)
Topic Starter
wring

DJPop wrote:

Artist should be MAHO-Dou (MAHO堂)

Thank you ,fixed :)
IceBeam
[Easy]
Eh,reduce Slider Tick Rate?
00:20:276 (x) - Remove this break,it's unrankable.
01:09:292 (3) - 1 grid up.
01:19:055 (3) - Why it's so close? Place further.

[Normal]
00:50:581 (1) - Too close,fix distance.

[Hard]
00:18:852 (3) - Distance is wrong,cause distance snap counts it as 0.5x spacing,but it's not right.Place further.

[Insane]
00:30:242 (1) - This circle is hidden by repeat and it's unrankable.

The rest is fine,good luck with it.
Star~
aRiskOfRain
I think I'm going to vomit from the weeabooery.

Turn up your hitsounds a bit.

Easy;

00:02:581 - Map this break; all the other difficulties have it mapped, why shouldn't Easy?
00:48:140 (3,1) - Spacing.
00:55:055 (2,3) - This would be better 1/1 earlier, on the previous white tick, don't you think?

Normal;

Tick rate 2?
00:09:903 (3,4) - Spacing.
00:25:360 (3) - Make the red tick of this slider be exactly on the slidertick.
00:29:021 (3,4) - Spacing.
01:06:038 (1,2,3) - Jumps on a Normal?! No, no, no.

Hard;

Could you make all the 0.5x slowdowns something like 0.75? They're tricky to read as of right now.
Tick rate 2?
00:41:631 (1,1) - Too soon after the spinner, even for a Hard.
00:44:885 (1,1) - ^
01:19:259 (7) - Delete.

Insane;

00:25:360 (2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - What the hell is this following?
00:36:852 (5) - Delete.
00:43:462 (2,3,4) - What is this following?
00:44:886 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - These jumps make no sense.
00:49:970 (2,3,4) - What is this following?
00:54:648 (4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5) - ^
00:59:733 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,1,2,3,4,5) - ^
01:04:004 (1,2,3,1,2) - These jumps are a bit severe.

Call me back.
Dotsu
Star ~
;)
Topic Starter
wring

IceBeam wrote:

[Normal]
00:50:581 (1) - Too close,fix distance. Fixed

[Hard]
00:18:852 (3) - Distance is wrong,cause distance snap counts it as 0.5x spacing,but it's not right.Place further. Fixed

[Insane]
00:30:242 (1) - This circle is hidden by repeat and it's unrankable. Fixed

The rest is fine,good luck with it.
Star~

Thank you :)
Topic Starter
wring

DiamondCrash wrote:

I think I'm going to vomit from the weeabooery.

Turn up your hitsounds a bit. Added

Normal;

Tick rate 2? Changed 1
00:09:903 (3,4) - Spacing. Fixed
00:25:360 (3) - Make the red tick of this slider be exactly on the slidertick. Fixed
00:29:021 (3,4) - Spacing. Fixed
01:06:038 (1,2,3) - Jumps on a Normal?! No, no, no. Fixed

Hard;

Could you make all the 0.5x slowdowns something like 0.75? They're tricky to read as of right now. Changed & Fixed
Tick rate 2? Changed
00:41:631 (1,1) - Too soon after the spinner, even for a Hard. Fixed
00:44:885 (1,1) - ^ Fixed
01:19:259 (7) - Delete. Fixed

Insane;

00:25:360 (2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - What the hell is this following?
00:36:852 (5) - Delete. Fixed

00:43:462 (2,3,4) - What is this following?
00:49:970 (2,3,4) - What is this following?
I think the back like this.

00:44:886 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - These jumps make no sense.
If it is possible to keep these , i hope so.

00:54:648 (4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5) - ^
00:59:733 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,1,2,3,4,5) - ^
I wanna express the back ballottement.Should remove?

01:04:004 (1,2,3,1,2) - These jumps are a bit severe. Fixed

Call me back.

Thank you :D
Topic Starter
wring

impossiblexu wrote:

Star ~ ;)
Thank you star :)
Garven
As per your request:

[General]
Offset 941 feels better to me.
Add karenying to tags.
The hit sounds feel so randomly used to me.

[ying's Easy]
00:02:174 - A single slider straight into a 14 second break. Fun.
00:57:496 (3) - You may as well center this in the 4 slider. Don't worry about breaking distance snap.

[Insane]
00:25:360 (2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - Is this really necessary?
This difficulty felt a bit overdone with all those streams, to be honest.

It's alright, but the insane is just way over the top for the type of song. :/
Kotone

IceBeam wrote:

[Easy]
Eh,reduce Slider Tick Rate? k
00:20:276 (x) - Remove this break,it's unrankable. k
01:09:292 (3) - 1 grid up. k
01:19:055 (3) - Why it's so close? Place further. k

DiamondCrash wrote:

Easy;

00:02:581 - Map this break; all the other difficulties have it mapped, why shouldn't Easy? :/
00:48:140 (3,1) - Spacing. k
00:55:055 (2,3) - This would be better 1/1 earlier, on the previous white tick, don't you think? k

Garven wrote:

[ying's Easy]
00:02:174 - A single slider straight into a 14 second break. Fun. OK I know :/
00:57:496 (3) - You may as well center this in the 4 slider. Don't worry about breaking distance snap.k
Topic Starter
wring

Garven wrote:

As per your request:

[General]
Offset 941 feels better to me. Fixed
Add karenying to tags. Added
The hit sounds feel so randomly used to me. Fix

[Insane]
00:25:360 (2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - Is this really necessary? Fixed
This difficulty felt a bit overdone with all those streams, to be honest.

It's alright, but the insane is just way over the top for the type of song. :/
Thank you :)
Joon
hi

my modding

[ying's Easy]
00:02:568 (1) - add finish
00:09:076 (1) - ^
00:13:957 (3) - End Notes change finish
00:18:839 (2) - 3 grid up
00:41:212 (2) - add clap
00:44:466 (2) - ^
00:47:720 (2) - ^
00:48:127 (3) - End Notes add clap
00:50:974 (2) - add clap
00:51:381 (3) - End Notes add clap
01:05:618 (3) - add clap
01:06:025 (4) - change finish
01:19:042 (3) - ^
01:22:703 (4) - change clap

[Normal]
00:06:635 (2,3,4) - End Notes change clap
00:09:483 (2) - change clap
00:09:483 (2) - ^
00:32:669 (3) - add whistle
00:54:635 (3) - change clap
00:57:483 (8) - ^
01:06:025 (1,2) - change finish
01:07:652 (1) - ^
01:08:466 (3) - End Notes change clap
01:09:279 (4) - ^
01:10:093 (5) - remove clap
01:10:500 (1) - change clap
01:18:635 (3) - End Notes change finish
01:19:449 (4,5) - change finish

[Hard]
00:02:568 (1) - change finish
00:09:076 (1) - Start Notes change finish
00:12:330 (1) - change finish
00:20:466 (1) - change whistle
00:56:466 (2,4,6,8) - add clap
01:01:551 (3,4) - change clap
01:06:025 (6,7) - change finish
01:07:652 (1) - ^
01:08:059 (3,4) - change clap
01:08:873 (6) - End Notes chnage clap
01:12:534 (1,2) - chnage finish
01:19:042 (6,7) - ^
01:25:551 (4) - Start Notes change finish
01:25:957 (5) - change finish
01:26:161 (6) - change clap
01:26:364 (7) - change finish
01:26:771 (1,2) - Start Notes change finish
01:27:585 (3) - change finish
01:27:991 (1,2) - change clap
01:28:398 (3,4) - change finish

[Insane]
00:02:568 (1) - change finish
00:09:076 (1) - Start Notes change finish
00:12:940 (3,5,7) - change clap
00:15:585 (1) - Start Notes change finish
00:41:618 (1) - change finish
00:48:127 (2) - Start Notes add finish
00:45:076 (2,4,6) - change clap
00:48:534 (3,5) - chagne clap
00:51:381 (4,5) - End Notes change clap
01:07:652 (1) - change finish
01:12:534 (1) - ^
01:12:940 (4) - ^
01:20:669 (5) - ^
01:23:924 (3) - End Notes remove clap
01:25:551 (1) - change finish
01:25:957 (4) - Start Notes change finish
01:27:991 (1,2) - change clap
01:28:398 (3,4) - change finish

Ojamajo!!! >w< +Star GL
Topic Starter
wring

hujune wrote:

hi

my modding

[Normal]
00:06:635 (2,3,4) - End Notes change clap
00:09:483 (2) - change clap
00:09:483 (2) - ^
00:32:669 (3) - add whistle
00:54:635 (3) - change clap
00:57:483 (8) - ^
01:06:025 (1,2) - change finish
01:07:652 (1) - ^
01:08:466 (3) - End Notes change clap
01:09:279 (4) - ^
01:10:093 (5) - remove clap
01:10:500 (1) - change clap
01:18:635 (3) - End Notes change finish
01:19:449 (4,5) - change finish

[Hard]
00:02:568 (1) - change finish
00:09:076 (1) - Start Notes change finish
00:12:330 (1) - change finish
00:20:466 (1) - change whistle
00:56:466 (2,4,6,8) - add clap
01:01:551 (3,4) - change clap
01:06:025 (6,7) - change finish
01:07:652 (1) - ^
01:08:059 (3,4) - change clap
01:08:873 (6) - End Notes chnage clap
01:12:534 (1,2) - chnage finish
01:19:042 (6,7) - ^
01:25:551 (4) - Start Notes change finish
01:25:957 (5) - change finish
01:26:161 (6) - change clap
01:26:364 (7) - change finish
01:26:771 (1,2) - Start Notes change finish
01:27:585 (3) - change finish
01:27:991 (1,2) - change clap
01:28:398 (3,4) - change finish

[Insane]
00:02:568 (1) - change finish
00:09:076 (1) - Start Notes change finish
00:12:940 (3,5,7) - change clap
00:15:585 (1) - Start Notes change finish
00:41:618 (1) - change finish
00:48:127 (2) - Start Notes add finish
00:45:076 (2,4,6) - change clap
00:48:534 (3,5) - chagne clap
00:51:381 (4,5) - End Notes change clap
01:07:652 (1) - change finish
01:12:534 (1) - ^
01:12:940 (4) - ^
01:20:669 (5) - ^
01:23:924 (3) - End Notes remove clap
01:25:551 (1) - change finish
01:25:957 (4) - Start Notes change finish
01:27:991 (1,2) - change clap
01:28:398 (3,4) - change finish

Ojamajo!!! >w< +Star GL

All fixed!
Thank you :)
Kotone

hujune wrote:

[ying's Easy]
00:02:568 (1) - add finish k
00:09:076 (1) - ^ k
00:13:957 (3) - End Notes change finish k
00:18:839 (2) - 3 grid up k
00:41:212 (2) - add clap k
00:44:466 (2) - ^ k
00:47:720 (2) - ^ k
00:48:127 (3) - End Notes add clap k
00:50:974 (2) - add clap k
00:51:381 (3) - End Notes add clap k
01:05:618 (3) - add clap no
01:06:025 (4) - change finish no
01:19:042 (3) - ^ no
01:22:703 (4) - change clap k
:D thanks
Shiro
Sorry for the late mod... I have been very busy so far, and it's not going to stop.

Modding legend:

Unrankable.
Major issues in the map: it is highly recommended to fix them.
Minor issue in the map: you don't have to follow them exactly, but I recommend you to.
Suggestions: those are personal opinions, feel free to follow them or not.
Possible fix suggestion.

If there's one black bold line in the whole mod post, I won't star the map. PLEASE NOTE THAT THIS DOESN'T MEAN I WILL STAR THE MAP IF THERE IS NO BLACK BOLD LINE. Learn to mathematical implication.

ying's Easy:
First thoughts: ugly sliders.
00:25:347 (3) - Ugly slider.
00:34:500 (1) - ^
00:34:500 (1,3) - This overlap looks ugly and can be easily avoided.
00:41:618 (3) - This slider can be better !
00:44:873 (3) - ^
00:47:313 (1,2,3) - This overlap looks meh.
01:06:025 (4) - This sounds better with Finish hitsounds - maybe even soft finish.
01:19:042 (3) - This slider is too high and is partially overlapped by the HP bar.
01:25:551 (1) - This spinner hardly makes sense - I'd rather see circles here.

I know I'm very picky about slider forms, but ugly sliders just make a map less enjoyable than it could be. Likewise, good sliders make a map appear better. I'm willing to help you anytime for these sliders, if you need, or just want. Just catch me in-game (I'll be only on IRC so I won't appear in the user panel list) and I will gladly help you.

Normal:
First thoughts: some of the hitsounds sounded random.
00:05:822 (1) - The Finish on this slider doesn't sound right. Remove it.
00:14:364 (5) - Same for the clap.
00:21:483 (1) - This whistle sounds too loud to me. Lower the volume by something like 5 half ticks.
00:25:347 (3) - Make the curve nicer before the anchor point.
00:31:246 (1) - This slider doesn't look good.
00:33:076 (4) - ^
00:37:551 (6) - That one is ugly.
00:48:127 (3) - Why did you suddenly change to linear sliders ? It looks really bad in my humble opinion, and it breaks the flow, because the eye got used to somewhat nice curves, and suddenly, you throw sharp angles at it, not for the best.
00:51:381 (3) - ^
01:03:178 (5,6) - These two finishes don't really make sense.
01:10:907 (2) - Why is it linear ? Make it a Bézier curve, it will look a lot better.
01:16:602 (4) - This sudden normal hit doesn't sound right.
01:22:703 (3,4) - These two finishes don't really make sense.
01:25:551 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - This pattern is really good, both placement wise and hitsounds wise. Good job on it.

Hard:
First thoughts: the rythms aren't well done in this diff. Sometimes, you add notes where you shouldn't have, and you don't place notes where there should have been.
00:05:008 (7) - This is a clear spacing error. Nothing calls for a jump here, and the suddenness of that jump is confusing and rage-inducing.
00:20:466 (1) - This is an example of notes that were added that shouldn't have been. That peculiar part of the songs calls for a small break in the patterns - a simple slider, maybe, or a few circles, but something that is silent and easy to play. But that slider you made just makes things unnecessarily loud and doesn't cool off the map.
00:34:500 (1,2,3,1,2,3,4,5) - This whole pattern has too many circles in it - notes that shouldn't have existed.
00:48:127 (3) - Although I hate these sliders, I don't consider them a problem, except this one's curve is bad at the top.
00:51:381 (3) - ^
01:17:008 (1,2,3,4,5) - This is a pattern that lacks circles - you mapped the others with more circles, why wouldn't you map it the same way ?

Insane:
First thoughts: that's a pretty good diff, although the random streams make it feel weird.
00:04:703 (3) - This slider should end earlier ! 1/4 earlier to be more precise.
00:06:229 (2) - Too far from previous object.
00:21:483 (1) - This note made me smile. It's a single note with two short parts without notes before and after. Please do not ever change it, it's really a good thing for the map.
00:30:229 (1,2) - Reduce this jump.
00:44:873 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - At my own surprise, I 100%'d this pattern first try. Though I still think it's confusing.
00:47:924 (1) - Stack that with (2). I expect it to be stacked, sent my mouse there - except there was no note. It's very confusing.
00:52:195 (6) - Very ugly slider.
00:54:635 (4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5) - These two streams make no sense.
01:11:924 (1,2,3) - Unexpected and confusing jumps.
01:12:534 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Make the spacing less wide.
01:13:551 (1,2,3,4) - These make no sense.

A very long mod post for a short map. If there are things you don't understand, or you want more details about, feel free to ask me ingame. I usually delete the maps I mod, but I won't delete this one, in the case you or karenying need further help.
Kurai
:)

Green = Suggestion
Orange = You should fix it
Red = You need to fix it

[General]

Remove the useless .osb file and fullsubmit.
Offset 946ms

[ying's Easy]
00:38:771 (Break) - Insert break time here ? (If you do that, disable the "Letterbox during breaks" in all difficulty. Song setup => Storyboarding => Misc. Toggles)
01:19:042 (3) - Too close to the top border, that's hide by the lifebar, you should move it~

[Normal]
00:11:110 (5) - Remove whistle and add clap
00:12:737 (2) - ^

01:12:940 (5,6) - Hided by the lifebar~

[Hard]

00:15:585 (1) - Bad Spacing

[Insane]

Fine~

Star :D
Topic Starter
wring
Thanks Odaril and KuraiPettan!!
I fixed most of them :)
But now I retry the offset.
vivere
Hi wring

[ying's Easy]:

00:57:483- Add clap
-------------------------
[Normal]:

00:55:856- New combo
01:12:534- ^
-------------------------
[Hard]:

01:06:025- New combo
01:25:551- ^
-------------------------
good map

star ;)
banvi
:)
Niva
Random mod :D

[General]
-> This song seems familiar, is there any connection with this song?
-> End kiai time at 88.805 ms.

[Easy]
00:30:432 (x) - Add circle?
00:31:856 (2) - Add hitsound finish?
00:33:686 (5) - Add circle?
00:44:873 (3,1) - Not perfectly stacked (Don't follow distance spacing here, nobody will realize)

[Normal]
00:11:517 (6) and 00:13:144 (3) - Not perfectly stacked, turn off grid snap
00:25:347 (3) - Beautiful ^_^

[Hard]
00:02:974 (2) - Switch hitsound between these two?
00:14:364 (7,1) - Spacing
00:28:602 (2) - Change hitsound to finish?
00:33:076 (4) - Linear slider in the mapset. Change it to bezier, linear feels weird for a happy song.
00:55:246 (5) - ^
01:09:279 (7,8,9) - Just place in triangle pattern, current pattern feels weird...

[Insane]
00:11:110 (2,3) - Lengthen (2) by 1/4, and shorten (3) by 1/4.
00:25:347 (2) - I don't think it needs to be silenced
00:29:313 (2,3) - Start 1/4 earlier.
01:19:042 (1,2,3) - Copy (1) to (2), and rotate by 120°. Copy (1) to (3), and rotate by 240°.

Nice mapset overall, feels fun while playing this.
Star!
MoonShade
It's nice to see how the map develops :3

Here a few suggestions for the easy and normal diff, maybe i will comment the other diffs later:

SPOILER
Think about just having one picture for all diffs when you have a video
Maybe you can reduce the video file size

[ying's Easy]
Maybe you should reduce the slider velocity
You should think about using the clap sound more often, for example:
00:05:008 (4)
00:03:381 (2)
00:06:635 (2)
00:07:856 (3)
00:08:669 (3)
00:16:398 (2)
00:18:025 (1)
...


00:20:466 (3) - Put a circle here?
00:26:974 (4) - ^

00:36:737 (3) - whistle sound on the beginning + the slider
00:38:364 (3) - finish sound
00:43:042 (3) - End slider here?
00:46:296 (3) - ^
00:49:551 (3) - ^
00:52:805 (3) - ^

00:59:517 (3) - Delete the whistle sound on the end of the slider
01:19:042 (3) - maybe put this somewhere else
01:25:144 (2) - end slider here
01:25:144 (3) - delete this
01:25:551 (x) - maybe put something else here, for example:
01:25:551 (1) - circle
01:26:364 (2) - circle
01:26:771 (1) - circle
01:27:585 (2) - circle
01:27:991 (1) - circle
01:28:398 (2) - circle


[Normal]
00:02:568 (1) - add finish, remove whistle
00:02:974 (2) - add clap, remove whistle

00:03:381 (3) - whistle at the beginning
00:09:076 (1) - add finish, remove whistle
00:15:178 (5) - why not use a normal soft sound here?
00:20:263 (2) - I don't think a normal finish sound fits
00:26:771 (3) - ^

00:28:602 (2) - finish sound
00:29:008 (3,4) - try to make these slider more like this:

00:34:500 (1) - this sounds weird
01:01:957 (3) - remove clap
01:02:364 (3) - add clap
01:02:771 (4) - remove clap
01:03:585 (6) - maybe use a finish sound instead
01:26:364 (2) - use a finish sound here
01:27:585 (2) - ^
01:28:805 (2) - ^
For your effort in this map: Star!
Topic Starter
wring

Nivalis wrote:

-> This song seems familiar, is there any connection with this song?
Yeah, this is the original one :)

MoonShade wrote:

Think about just having one picture for all diffs when you have a video
Maybe you can reduce the video file size
Umm.. , I'll try to.

Thank you mod , I all fixed :)
Kotone
SPOILER

Odaril wrote:

ying's Easy:
First thoughts: ugly sliders.
00:25:347 (3) - Ugly slider.
00:34:500 (1) - ^
00:34:500 (1,3) - This overlap looks ugly and can be easily avoided.
00:41:618 (3) - This slider can be better !
00:44:873 (3) - ^
00:47:313 (1,2,3) - This overlap looks meh.
01:06:025 (4) - This sounds better with Finish hitsounds - maybe even soft finish.
01:19:042 (3) - This slider is too high and is partially overlapped by the HP bar.
01:25:551 (1) - This spinner hardly makes sense - I'd rather see circles here.

I know I'm very picky about slider forms, but ugly sliders just make a map less enjoyable than it could be. Likewise, good sliders make a map appear better. I'm willing to help you anytime for these sliders, if you need, or just want. Just catch me in-game (I'll be only on IRC so I won't appear in the user panel list) and I will gladly help you.
all fixed
I tried to make they beautiful :D

KuraiPettan wrote:

[ying's Easy]
00:38:771 (Break) - Insert break time here ? (If you do that, disable the "Letterbox during breaks" in all difficulty. Song setup => Storyboarding => Misc. Toggles) no thanks

vivere wrote:

[ying's Easy]:
00:57:483- Add clap k

Nivalis wrote:

[Easy]
00:30:432 (x) - Add circle? k
00:31:856 (2) - Add hitsound finish? k
00:33:686 (5) - Add circle? k
00:44:873 (3,1) - Not perfectly stacked (Don't follow distance spacing here, nobody will realize) :/

MoonShade wrote:

[ying's Easy]
Maybe you should reduce the slider velocity no thanks
You should think about using the clap sound more often, for example:
00:05:008 (4)
00:03:381 (2)
00:06:635 (2)
00:07:856 (3)
00:08:669 (3)
00:16:398 (2)
00:18:025 (1)
...
no
Gonzvlo
General
  1. OK~
ying's Easy
  1. 00:12:330 (1) - It looks better if you move it 1 grid left & 2 grids up imo.
  2. Pretty Solid.
Normal
  1. 00:09:076 (1,3) - Align (3) with (1)
  2. 00:35:924 (1) - New Combo
  3. 00:40:805 (1,2,3) - Suggestion: For this streams I think that "Finish" sounds better than "Clap" at the end of the sliders, (If you decide to change it , apply to all the sliders)
  4. 01:28:805 (2) - Suggestion: Change to Finish
Hard
  1. 00:16:602 (4,1) - Suggestion: Unstack (1) , It belongs to a different combo.
Insane
  1. 00:21:483 (1) - Suggestion: Add "Finish"
  2. 00:30:229 (1) - Remove New Combo
  3. 00:46:093 (1) - ^
Fun to play & The song is catchy, STAR~
fartownik
offset +9-12ms

[Insane]

The consistency of new combos and hitsounds feels really random on this diff.

00:11:110 (2,3) - Sounds off. Especially the 1/4 slider.
00:21:483 (1) - Delete new combo.


[Hard]

Pretty nice diff. Mapped far better than Insane for sure.

Decrease OD by 1 tick.

01:01:957 (5) - Add a repeat.


Other diffs are fine.
star
Topic Starter
wring
I changed offset.
Thanks mod Gonzvlo and fartownik :)
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply