Hiya Spy! On behalf of the QAT we must disqualify this mapset over the following reasons:
- Inappropriate Spread - specifically between NOVICE and ADVANCED.
The spread is really a bit too big. There are often instances in this case where people have SS'd the NOVICE diff but get a B on the ADV diff, which is quite worrying.
This is because NOVICE features
at most basic 1/4 no longer than 5 notes, and not many chords, whereas ADVANCED is really dense, containing 1/4 whilst holding LNs, and chordstreams. For reference, look at the density charts in the editor for both difficulties.
A few examples:
http://puu.sh/invXx/ea4a54cfd4.jpg http://puu.sh/inw0A/46b9cdc0b8.png http://puu.sh/inw75/d9deb95576.jpg http://puu.sh/inw8k/83b38be14e.jpgAnother thing to point out is the HPOD spread of all the difficulties. EXHAUST shouldn't be OD9 at all. (For reference, someone has SS'd INFINITE and GRAVITY, but no one has SS'd EXHAUST over the past 6 days, which is very unusual). This is because it has a very large amount of short LNs. For EXHAUST, it's recommended to change the OD to OD8, where INFINITE should be changed to OD8.5, as it contains a lot more LNs than GRAVITY does.
Overall, EXH generally appears to be a bit harder than INFINITE and GRAVITY despite the star rating, which is concerning.
- Snapping Errors.
There are a few questionable snaps which have caught our attention:
00:56:732 - All diffs, I don't really think 1/16 is suitable for this note as it appears to be too early. Consider revising this snap to perhaps 1/8 instead. ( 00:56:751 - )
01:31:814 (91814|0,91851|1,91889|2,91926|3,91964|0,92001|1,92039|2,92076|3) - In EXHAUST - there is no clear 1/8 sound here, but instead, only a distinct 1/4 sound from the drum. It's suggested you follow that instead.
01:50:414 (110414|3,110451|0,110489|1,110526|2,110564|3,110601|0,110639|1,110676|2,110714|3) - In EXHAUST - this should be 1/4. This is because the 'ringing' noise slows down after that point, and becomes 1/4. If you find it quite hard to hear, you can even check the original Team Grimoire - croiX song for reference, where it's a lot more clearer there. (You can use other difficulties for reference, as they all follow it correctly.)
The BNG will handle this mapset from now on. Goodluck~