1. Challenging (4.47 stars, 344 notes)
2. Mind-Boggling (4.97 stars, 482 notes)
3. Puzzling (2.11 stars, 192 notes)

1. This collaboration begun as a list of interest for those who wanted to map. All spots were claimed 2 weeks afterwards.
2. Matma Rex was the one who made the skin elements and RandomJibberish did the SB. (Except the introduction which was done by me)
3. All the parts, introduction and break split into a perfectly even 20 seconds. Pretty cool.
4. LuigiHann was the last to hand his parts in while Dusty was the first to finish all his parts.
5. For a live version, there's only one BPM.

Matma Rex wrote:

Pretty awesome SB, but I think the names scale too much (on hitfinish). Use 1.05 instead of 1.1? Maybe, thinking about it.

And for some modding:
[Puzzling/Derekku] 03:30:058 (1) - D: Derek's decision.
[Challenging/RandomJibberish] 02:53:677 (1) - does not fit D: move 1/2 earlier and add a note 1/2 later? Done too.
[Mingboggling/me] 01:00:083 (1) - why is that new combo? D: Changed
[Mingboggling/Dusty] 02:28:990 (4) - nice piece of slider art, but for more awesomeness you might try to rearrange it to make ticks land in corners. Dusty.
[Mindboggling/RandomJibberish] 02:41:490 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - whoa, that's intense. Done

Matma Rex wrote:

[Mingboggling/Dusty] 02:28:990 (4) - nice piece of slider art, but for more awesomeness you might try to rearrange it to make ticks land in corners.

Krisom wrote:

Hi

[general]
The combobursts have those ugly white pixels around 'em ._.
03:21:480 - This section of the SB made me feel dizzy o_o

[Puzzling]
00:21:490 (1) - Remove the sliderwhistle Done.
00:26:490 (1) - ^ Done.
02:21:490 (1) - I saw this slider before the "Dusty" appeared and I said "Dusty was here ._." Whistle the end (?) [It's there because of the low OD. Since the notes come on more quicker, that's why it looks like that. And I don't think I'm going to put the whistle at the end of this.]
02:51:490 (1,2,3) - The fact that this combo hits the HP Gauge, while no other combo on the entire diff does, makes it look out of place. Pull it all a bit down? (Including (4) ) Done.
02:56:490 (1) - Whistle Done.
02:57:740 (1) - ^ Done.

[Challenging]
00:22:740 (3) - Remove the sliderwhistle Done.
00:26:490 (1) - ^ Done.
00:28:990 (3) - ^ Done.
00:32:740 (3) - Whistle at the start (?) Done.
01:08:208 (x) - Add a note? I can't help but to hit 01:08:365 (7) Early. I think it's following the Violins NoHItter's Decision.
01:13:208 (x) - ^ ^
02:27:740 (1) - Remove the sliderwhistle Done.
Amazing ._.

[Mind-Boggling]
My mind was blown, I cannot play like this yet, sorry ._."

Please tell me when it's ready so that I can recheck. It's certain- IT'S FRIKIN' GREAT ._. All the mappers here are top-quiality. I <3 you all o_o!

Oh, I think the offset is a bit off in some places ._., that may be me though. It is off in places.

I <3 this. Boom!

NoHItter wrote:

Move this to pending already...

Larto wrote:

Mind-Boggling:
That spacing matma, [...] used at times was just outright weird. I'd rank it, but I'd not feel 100% comfortable.

Matma Rex wrote:

Larto wrote:

Mind-Boggling:
That spacing matma, [...] used at times was just outright weird. I'd rank it, but I'd not feel 100% comfortable.

You mean those windmill sliders? I like them ;_;

Larto wrote:

Overall:
Remove brown from the combo colours, it blends in very badly with RJ's background. Need another person's opinion.

challenging:
03:30:058 (1) - That's quite short. Fixed as Derek's said. Hope that's better?

Puzzling:
01:08:990 (1) - Also feels quite short for an Easy. NoHItter.
02:43:990 (3,1) - Maybe a little too jumpy for nubs. RandomJibberish.
03:00:240 (5) - This slider doesn't make any sense to me ^ But I think it DOES make sense.
03:30:058 (1) - way way way way WAAAY too short for an easy Is Derek's way good enough?

Mind-Boggling:
That spacing matma, MB and dusty used at times was just outright weird. I'd rank it, but I'd not feel 100% comfortable. Matma had a say already, I've changed my problem and... what's wrong with Dusty's? Wait, I see it now...

Larto wrote:

Mind-boggling:
00:46:177 (5,6,7,8,9,10,1,2,3) - Takuma agrees that this spacing is stupid.