forum

YUI - Rolling star [OsuMania]

posted
Total Posts
199
show more
Protastic101
oki, about a month late, but Im here to help with an old bubble \o/

euhjlow;.dnrabgv,z

General


  1. Would consider replacing the normal-hitwhistle since you can barely hear it tbh. Might try this one instead http://puu.sh/t0wA1.wav
  2. Might consider bringing up the HP of HD to 7.5 or so since 7 is really too forgiving at the moment.

Diffs


[EZ]00:14:645 - 00:15:018 - Might consider adding another note at these places to make them into jumps for the crashes, and also because it signals the start and end of a new section.
00:20:421 - 00:20:794 - I might consider adding a note in 2 and 4 respectively to represent the guitar there. It also acts a bit like a transition too.
00:32:533 (32533|3) - Might be a cool idea to turn this into a 1/1 LN to act as a transition into the next sentence like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/6898242
00:38:869 - to 00:42:223 - You've ignored column 3 D: I'd consider moving some notes like 00:40:359 (40359|1) - to 3
01:15:763 (75763|0) - Similar to how I mentioned that 1/1 LN a while ago, I'd apply it here too
01:48:372 (108372|2,108931|0) - I might consider swapping the columns here, so that the LN is in 1 and the short note in 3 since the cap at 01:48:931 (108931|0,108931|3) - is uncomfortable to hit on weaker fingers like the middle finger (talking about the note in 4 mostly)
02:45:949 - to 02:48:558 - Stop ignoring columns :< I'd consider moving 02:47:813 (167813|0) - to restore balance.

[NM]00:13:713 - 00:14:272 - I can't really understand why you wouldn't have notes here for the drum kicks like at 00:11:291 (11291|0,11477|1) - for example.
01:03:651 - 01:04:024 - Why not add notes for the guitar like you did at 00:20:421 (20421|2,20794|3) - ?
01:22:844 - Column 3 feels a little left out, maybe try something like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/6903536
02:37:751 - 02:37:937 - Add notes here for the snare, because the sound is similar to 02:31:788 (151788|1,151974|2,152161|0) -

[HD]00:27:502 (27502|1,27502|0,28061|0,28434|0,28434|3) - I'd consider arranging the notes like this since it's easier to play this way in my opinion https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/6903588
01:48:372 (108372|3,108465|2,108558|1,108651|0,108744|1,108838|2) - More just my personal opinion, but I'm not a really big fan of how this stair plays. Maybe try something like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/6903617

[Nowsmart's MX]00:37:564 (37564|0) - I'd consider moving this to 3 since hitting a ministack in 1 while holding an LN in 2 is pretty uncomfortable imo
00:59:412 (59412|1) - Why. Remove this note, there's literally no reason for it to be here cause you already have a double at 00:59:365 - and there's no delay to the sound
01:15:018 (75018|3,75018|2,75204|3,75763|3) - Imo, might be easier to play this if you swapped columns, so like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/6904055
01:43:713 (103713|0) - Consider moving this to 3 since I think it's easier to hit that way when the LNs are only on the left hand and everything else on the right.

Hitsounds


[EZ]00:26:943 (26943|1) - Add whistle

[NM]dunno if Im just bad at checking hitsounds or if you're a really good hitsounder, but no inconsistencies here

[HD]00:17:813 (17813|3) - Dunno why you needed to apply the hitnormal to this note when it automatically plays if there's no assigned hitsound lol
01:41:105 (101105|0,101477|2,101850|1) - Add finishes
01:42:223 (102223|0,102595|0) - ^
01:43:341 (103341|1,103713|1,104086|1,104459|1,104831|0,105204|0) - ^
01:46:322 (106322|0,106695|0,107067|0,107440|0,107813|0,108185|0) - ^

[Nowsmart's MX]01:39:055 (99055|1) - You have 2 hitfinishes here. Replace this one with a hitclap for the snare
Topic Starter
EFP
hoa, i'll just mod it without updated to the last update aaaa
how lucky i am still have the last file before i edited, i'll remod asap!~


Protastic101 wrote:

oki, about a month late, but Im here to help with an old bubble \o/

euhjlow;.dnrabgv,z

General


  1. Would consider replacing the normal-hitwhistle since you can barely hear it tbh. Might try this one instead http://puu.sh/t0wA1.wav
  2. Might consider bringing up the HP of HD to 7.5 or so since 7 is really too forgiving at the moment. all fixed, thanks~!

Diffs


[EZ]00:14:645 - 00:15:018 - Might consider adding another note at these places to make them into jumps for the crashes, and also because it signals the start and end of a new section. it's kinda weird for adding note there
00:20:421 - 00:20:794 - I might consider adding a note in 2 and 4 respectively to represent the guitar there. It also acts a bit like a transition too.
00:32:533 (32533|3) - Might be a cool idea to turn this into a 1/1 LN to act as a transition into the next sentence like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/6898242
00:38:869 - to 00:42:223 - You've ignored column 3 D: I'd consider moving some notes like 00:40:359 (40359|1) - to 3
01:15:763 (75763|0) - Similar to how I mentioned that 1/1 LN a while ago, I'd apply it here too
01:48:372 (108372|2,108931|0) - I might consider swapping the columns here, so that the LN is in 1 and the short note in 3 since the cap at 01:48:931 (108931|0,108931|3) - is uncomfortable to hit on weaker fingers like the middle finger (talking about the note in 4 mostly)
02:45:949 - to 02:48:558 - Stop ignoring columns :< I'd consider moving 02:47:813 (167813|0) - to restore balance.

[NM]00:13:713 - 00:14:272 - I can't really understand why you wouldn't have notes here for the drum kicks like at 00:11:291 (11291|0,11477|1) - for example.
01:03:651 - 01:04:024 - Why not add notes for the guitar like you did at 00:20:421 (20421|2,20794|3) - ? i just follow kick sounds here
01:22:844 - Column 3 feels a little left out, maybe try something like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/6903536
02:37:751 - 02:37:937 - Add notes here for the snare, because the sound is similar to 02:31:788 (151788|1,151974|2,152161|0) - i just added here 02:37:751 - like 02:43:713 -

[HD]00:27:502 (27502|1,27502|0,28061|0,28434|0,28434|3) - I'd consider arranging the notes like this since it's easier to play this way in my opinion https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/6903588
01:48:372 (108372|3,108465|2,108558|1,108651|0,108744|1,108838|2) - More just my personal opinion, but I'm not a really big fan of how this stair plays. Maybe try something like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/6903617

Hitsounds


[EZ]00:26:943 (26943|1) - Add whistle

[NM]dunno if Im just bad at checking hitsounds or if you're a really good hitsounder, but no inconsistencies here eek theres many people who help me for this

[HD]00:17:813 (17813|3) - Dunno why you needed to apply the hitnormal to this note when it automatically plays if there's no assigned hitsound lol my bad
01:41:105 (101105|0,101477|2,101850|1) - Add finishes
01:42:223 (102223|0,102595|0) - ^
01:43:341 (103341|1,103713|1,104086|1,104459|1,104831|0,105204|0) - ^
01:46:322 (106322|0,106695|0,107067|0,107440|0,107813|0,108185|0) - ^
the rest accepted
i think you should do re-check, 'cause i'm not sure there are some that you miss xd sorry~
and thankyouuuu \o/
Topic Starter
EFP

Protastic101 wrote:

oki, about a month late, but Im here to help with an old bubble \o/

euhjlow;.dnrabgv,z

General


  1. Would consider replacing the normal-hitwhistle since you can barely hear it tbh. Might try this one instead http://puu.sh/t0wA1.wav
  2. Might consider bringing up the HP of HD to 7.5 or so since 7 is really too forgiving at the moment.

Diffs


[Nowsmart's MX]00:37:564 (37564|0) - I'd consider moving this to 3 since hitting a ministack in 1 while holding an LN in 2 is pretty uncomfortable imo
00:59:412 (59412|1) - Why. Remove this note, there's literally no reason for it to be here cause you already have a double at 00:59:365 - and there's no delay to the sound
01:15:018 (75018|3,75018|2,75204|3,75763|3) - Imo, might be easier to play this if you swapped columns, so like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/6904055
01:43:713 (103713|0) - Consider moving this to 3 since I think it's easier to hit that way when the LNs are only on the left hand and everything else on the right.

Hitsounds


[Nowsmart's MX]01:39:055 (99055|1) - You have 2 hitfinishes here. Replace this one with a hitclap for the snare

updated~
Protastic101
Alright, rechecked diffs and hitsounds, should be good to go~
Topic Starter
EFP
\o/
- Ly0572 -
grats ed o// woooooh
PANDAAAAAAAA
Rank it now
Topic Starter
EFP

- Ly0572 - wrote:

grats ed o// woooooh
thanks ly~

nowsmart wrote:

Rank it now
yesyesyes
Maxus
Qualify Check
Will make this quick since this is already great.
No kudosu since i already mod this a while ago.

Reminder: Please take care all of your Hitsound while applying my suggestion.
[EZ]
00:28:993 (28993|2) - this should be at col.4 to avoid too much stacking at 00:27:875 (27875|2,28434|2,28993|2,29552|2) - i know you did it consistently on part after this, but better make it balance.
00:32:906 (32906|1,33279|2) - switch column here to avoid stacking at col.2.
01:12:223 (72223|0) - move to col.2
01:16:136 (76136|2,76508|1) - switch column , samer reason as before.
01:24:334 (84334|0) - better move to col.2 for balance.
01:48:185 (108185|3,108931|2) - move to the left 1 time. the jack at 01:48:931 (108931|2,109303|2) - doesn't fit the song..
02:22:471 (142471|3) - move to col.3 so you get smoother transition towards next pattern.
02:28:434 (148434|0) - move to col.2 same reason as above.

[NM]
01:34:024 - add one more note to be consistent with 02:44:086 -
02:25:825 (145825|1,146198|3,146570|1) - i would make these col 4-2-4 to avoid the pattern being the same as 02:22:844 - .

[HD]
00:54:334 - http://puu.sh/t4mng/59af589f8e.png try this, your jacking at col 3 is too much, this will balance it out.
01:42:595 - i personally think the way it conveys the jack a bit weird, i think you can make it fitting better for guitar: http://puu.sh/t4mHg/c2f6d655fc.png

[Nowsmart's MX]
01:43:341 - delete one note? i don't see why it has to be double with such weak sound here.
02:05:142 - just want to say that 02:05:328 - 02:05:701 - 02:06:074 - are the same cymbal sound, better make them the same column, like http://puu.sh/t4nke/253a8727af.png
02:26:384 (146384|1) - try move this to col 3 so the left hand doesn't get pressured after hitting 02:26:011 (146011|0,146105|1,146198|0) -
03:04:676 - just curious, is this intentionally made empty when HD have full stream?

Reply to the mod, and i will qualify it afterwards :D
Topic Starter
EFP

Maxus wrote:

Qualify Check
Will make this quick since this is already great.
No kudosu since i already mod this a while ago.

Reminder: Please take care all of your Hitsound while applying my suggestion.
[EZ]
00:28:993 (28993|2) - this should be at col.4 to avoid too much stacking at 00:27:875 (27875|2,28434|2,28993|2,29552|2) - i know you did it consistently on part after this, but better make it balance.
00:32:906 (32906|1,33279|2) - switch column here to avoid stacking at col.2.
01:12:223 (72223|0) - move to col.2
01:16:136 (76136|2,76508|1) - switch column , samer reason as before.
01:24:334 (84334|0) - better move to col.2 for balance.
01:48:185 (108185|3,108931|2) - move to the left 1 time. the jack at 01:48:931 (108931|2,109303|2) - doesn't fit the song..
02:22:471 (142471|3) - move to col.3 so you get smoother transition towards next pattern.
02:28:434 (148434|0) - move to col.2 same reason as above.

[NM]
01:34:024 - add one more note to be consistent with 02:44:086 -
02:25:825 (145825|1,146198|3,146570|1) - i would make these col 4-2-4 to avoid the pattern being the same as 02:22:844 - .

[HD]
00:54:334 - http://puu.sh/t4mng/59af589f8e.png try this, your jacking at col 3 is too much, this will balance it out.
01:42:595 - i personally think the way it conveys the jack a bit weird, i think you can make it fitting better for guitar: http://puu.sh/t4mHg/c2f6d655fc.png

[Nowsmart's MX]
01:43:341 - delete one note? i don't see why it has to be double with such weak sound here.
02:05:142 - just want to say that 02:05:328 - 02:05:701 - 02:06:074 - are the same cymbal sound, better make them the same column, like http://puu.sh/t4nke/253a8727af.png
02:26:384 (146384|1) - try move this to col 3 so the left hand doesn't get pressured after hitting 02:26:011 (146011|0,146105|1,146198|0) -
03:04:676 - just curious, is this intentionally made empty when HD have full stream? because there isn't any space to add more notes

Reply to the mod, and i will qualify it afterwards :D
the rest accepted~!
thankyou Maxusss :D
Maxus
Congrats for your first qualified map.
Finally after 1,5 years ^^
Topic Starter
EFP
YESSSSS~!
THANKYOUU!!
PANDAAAAAAAA
Finally!
Syadow-
Wew finally :v gratz >w<
AchsanLovers
grats ~
Topic Starter
EFP

nowsmart wrote:

Finally!
it's been a long day, without you my rank~ lmao

Syadow- wrote:

Wew finally :v gratz >w<
yoootz~

AchsanLovers wrote:

grats ~
terimakasih~
erlinadewi-
Lagu fav jaman SD owo)b

Gratz on qualified :)
Amiichii
Gratz ET~
Topic Starter
EFP

erlinadewi- wrote:

Lagu fav jaman SD owo)b

Gratz on qualified :)
masih jadi fav sampe sekarang~
terimakasih mba/mas xd

Amiichii wrote:

Gratz ET~
sangkyuu~
hmm et
troke
wih udah ranked nih ye gratz EFP :D
Topic Starter
EFP

-Troke- wrote:

wih udah ranked nih ye gratz EFP :D
udah ranked nih yea, setelah 2tahun kurang lamanya
okey, makasoyy :D
Suzuko-P
omg gratz!!
Please sign in to reply.

New reply