forum

BoA - Mamoritai -White Wishes- (Tales of Graces Version)

posted
Total Posts
23
Topic Starter
blissfulyoshi
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on Sunday, April 04, 2010 at 11:54:53 PM

Artist: BoA
Title: Mamoritai -White Wishes- (Tales of Graces Version)
Source: Tales of Graces
Tags: ToG
BPM: 108
Filesize: 19845kb
Play Time: 02:08
Difficulties Available:
  1. Easy+ (2.88 stars, 138 notes)
  2. Hard (4.77 stars, 287 notes)
  3. Normal (3.35 stars, 215 notes)
Download: BoA - Mamoritai -White Wishes- (Tales of Graces Version)
Download: BoA - Mamoritai -White Wishes- (Tales of Graces Version) (no video)
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
Tales of Graces opening.
Big thanks to alvisto for the hitsound help.

Enjoy!

Edit 3/21: Shinxyn and simplistiC updates
Edit 3/21 2: alvisto updates
Edit 3/21 3: yuckothegreat updates
Edit 3/23: ztrot skin updates
Edit 3/24: FuukoLover updates
Edit 3/22: alvisto hitsound update
Edit 3/27: yeahyeahyeahhh update
Edit 4/4: whymeman update
simplistiC
nice song/map

some things i noticed when i played hard, but they are only suggestions.

00:02:939 (1,2,3) - maybe stack this in the middle?
00:05:161 (2) - move 1 grid to the left?
02:09:466 (1) - end spinner 1/2 later? in my opinion it sounds better (same of other diffs)

bah, what do i know ._. star~ :3
Topic Starter
blissfulyoshi

simplistiC wrote:

nice song/map

some things i noticed when i played hard, but they are only suggestions.

00:02:939 (1,2,3) - maybe stack this in the middle? I sort of wanted a distanced snap path. Also, the map is pretty much absent of stacks, so adding a stack would be weird
00:05:161 (2) - move 1 grid to the left? Sure.
02:09:466 (1) - end spinner 1/2 later? in my opinion it sounds better (same of other diffs) I liked ending the spinner right when the vocals were about to fade out, but I would to hear what others say on this, so no change for now but maybe some in the near future.


bah, what do i know ._. star~ :3
Thanks for modding simplistiC.
alvisto
y:oshi ! :O :3 :3 :3

Nice map. Your "slider-more-focused" style, I like it.

A few tiny things to point out for you though.

Offset 439 ms ? So that the heavy drum sounds fall on white tick.

HARD
02:09:189 (7) - I think you should place this note further than 6, since it is on blue tick, and with the current spacing, I thought it is snapped to red tick. xD

HARD & EASY
00:51:550 (1) - Spinner end at different place compared to NORMAL. For me, I personally like how the spinner end at NORMAL more, and also I think it sounds better if you place a soft finish at it with lowered volume.

I will talk to you later about the hitsounds. xD

Star~~ :3 :3 :3 :3 :3 :3
yuckothegreat
This is an awesome beatmap!
A few things would make it even better:

1:27 - This spinner could end 1/2 later. I think it sounds better ending when the vocals stop.
02:09 - this spinner also sounds better 1/2 later.

Other then that its amazing.
Topic Starter
blissfulyoshi

alvisto wrote:

y:oshi ! :O :3 :3 :3 alvis <3

Nice map. Your "slider-more-focused" style, I like it.

A few tiny things to point out for you though.

Offset 439 ms ? So that the heavy drum sounds fall on white tick. Discussed on irc.

HARD
02:09:189 (7) - I think you should place this note further than 6, since it is on blue tick, and with the current spacing, I thought it is snapped to red tick. xD Fixed, talked on irc about it.


HARD & EASY
00:51:550 (1) - Spinner end at different place compared to NORMAL. For me, I personally like how the spinner end at NORMAL more, and also I think it sounds better if you place a soft finish at it with lowered volume. Why did I not notice this? Fixed.

I will talk to you later about the hitsounds. xD xD Ty.

Star~~ :3 :3 :3 :3 :3 :3
Thanks for modding alvis, esp. for the hitsound help


yuckothegreat wrote:

This is an awesome beatmap!
A few things would make it even better:

1:27 - This spinner could end 1/2 later. I think it sounds better ending when the vocals stop. I personally like the spinner to end where the vocals start fading, especially if it is a whole note, but I will see what other ppl say.
02:09 - this spinner also sounds better 1/2 later. Since you are the second person who said this, done.

Other then that its amazing.
Thanks for modding yuckothegreat.
alvisto
Okay, done with all the hitsounds. Just copy everything from this .rar and replace them into your folder. You may have to full resubmit it since I utilize custom hitsound. Also 1 more mod point for you when I was hitsounding,

HARD
01:11:550 (1) - End this spinner at 01:13:494, so that it can be hitsounded ? If you do so, please make it either a soft-finish with lowered volume or a soft custom clap. :P

Good luck with the map ! ^_^

y:oshi :O :3 :> :) orz

Download: 14179 BoA - Mamoritai -White Wishes- (Tales of Graces Version).rar
Topic Starter
blissfulyoshi

alvisto wrote:

Okay, done with all the hitsounds. Just copy everything from this .rar and replace them into your folder. You may have to full resubmit it since I utilize custom hitsound. Also 1 more mod point for you when I was hitsounding,

HARD
01:11:550 (1) - End this spinner at 01:13:494, so that it can be hitsounded ? If you do so, please make it either a soft-finish with lowered volume or a soft custom clap. :P Done.

Good luck with the map ! ^_^

y:oshi :O :3 :> :) orz
Thanks a lot for the hitsounds alvis.They sound great, so thanks for the time and effort.
(Not exactly sure how to respond to all the emoticons, but thanks anyway)
ztrot
looks good
Use them if you want too.





Fuuko
Fuuko's mod DEKIMASHITA! <33'

General:

Silence soft slider roll.
Move first kiai to 00:56:272.
Move second kiai to 01:49:605.
Easy:

02:07:105 (1,2,3,4,5) - Since this is an easy, why don't make this a slider of 1/2 beat that repeats 4 times?
02:08:772 (1) - Silence the end of this spinner.
Normal:

00:23:494 (6) - New combo.
00:25:716 - Weird blank space, I guess mapping this would make it better.
00:34:050 - Spinner here.
01:47:383 - ^
02:05:171 - ^
02:08:772 (1) - Silence the end of this spinner.
Hard:

00:14:050 (3) - Remove clap.
00:25:716 - Weird blank space, map something.
00:34:050 - Spinner here.
02:08:772 (1) - Silence the end of this spinner.
That's it, an awesome star for you and keep up the good work.
Topic Starter
blissfulyoshi

FuukoLover wrote:

Fuuko's mod DEKIMASHITA! <33'

General:

Silence soft slider roll.
Move first kiai to 00:56:272.
Move second kiai to 01:49:605.
Easy:

02:07:105 (1,2,3,4,5) - Since this is an easy, why don't make this a slider of 1/2 beat that repeats 4 times? Since there are no multiple repeats anywhere else in the song, this would be weird.
02:08:772 (1) - Silence the end of this spinner. Lowered the volume a bit.
Normal:

00:23:494 (6) - New combo. Since my current setup is consistent with the next verse, I don't see a reason to add the combo.
00:25:716 - Weird blank space, I guess mapping this would make it better. I like my short blank spaces. It gives time for players to recover. I don't want to force more notes or spinners on an easy diff, so no change here or for the spinners.
00:34:050 - Spinner here.
01:47:383 - ^
02:05:171 - ^
02:08:772 (1) - Silence the end of this spinner. Lowered the volume a bit.
Hard:

00:14:050 (3) - Remove clap. Done.
00:25:716 - Weird blank space, map something. Same as Normal.
00:34:050 - Spinner here.
02:08:772 (1) - Silence the end of this spinner.Lowered the volume a bit.
That's it, an awesome star for you and keep up the good work.[/color]
Thanks for modding FuukoLover.
yeahyeahyeahhh
Hi yoshi<3333

All diffs:
Start first kiai on 00:56:272 -
second kiai on 01:49:605 -

Hard:
General:
Not a big deal, but I think 1 tick below normal is good for hit circles. I personally think they're too big. I dont think the hardest diff should have the biggest hit circles.

Hitsound suggestions:
00:17:939 (10,11,12,13) - Claps on these 4?

Suggestions:
00:40:439 (1,2,3,4,5) - Personal taste, but make these symmetrical? Eg. have 00:41:272 (4,5) - ctrl+h from 00:40:439 (1,2) -
01:14:050 (1,2,3) - Space these a bit more? example..
01:16:272 (1,2,3) - Same thing cept mirrored
02:08:772 (6,7) - Space these further apart.

Normal:
Fine!

Easy:
You can use the biggest hit circles here if you wanna ^^
Topic Starter
blissfulyoshi

yeahyeahyeahhh wrote:

Hi yoshi<3333 HAI yyy <3

All diffs:
Start first kiai on 00:56:272 - Since you are second modder who said this. Done.
second kiai on 01:49:605 - ^

Hard:
General:
Not a big deal, but I think 1 tick below normal is good for hit circles. I personally think they're too big. I dont think the hardest diff should have the biggest hit circles. I like large hit circles, so I shrunk the hitcircles 1 notch

Hitsound suggestions:
00:17:939 (10,11,12,13) - Claps on these 4? Done.

Suggestions:
00:40:439 (1,2,3,4,5) - Personal taste, but make these symmetrical? Eg. have 00:41:272 (4,5) - ctrl+h from 00:40:439 (1,2) - Done.
01:14:050 (1,2,3) - Space these a bit more? example.. These notes are distance snapped and I did not hear the song suggest a higher spacing here, so I do not want to change this. Still if another modder wants this to be changes, I guess I will change it.
01:16:272 (1,2,3) - Same thing cept mirrored ^
02:08:772 (6,7) - Space these further apart. ^ (same line of logic)

Normal:
Fine!

Easy:
You can use the biggest hit circles here if you wanna ^^
Thanks for modding yyy.
mrtn
bubbled.

drain rate in hard is pretty low but it's not unrankable :).
arien666
Yay! BoA XD
Good luck to be ranked soon :3
whymeman
The map seems fine so far, but the Easy (2.88 stars, 138 notes) is a bit misleading. Its not really simple enough to pass through as an "Easy". At least look into fixing that and i'll rebubble.

Another note, not that critical, but is there a way to find a BG that fits the whole window? If not, don't worry too much on it.
Topic Starter
blissfulyoshi

whymeman wrote:

The map seems fine so far, but the Easy (2.88 stars, 138 notes) is a bit misleading. Its not really simple enough to pass through as an "Easy". At least look into fixing that and i'll rebubble. Changed to easy+

Another note, not that critical, but is there a way to find a BG that fits the whole window? If not, don't worry too much on it. I did not change the bg because it is official art from the game, and I could not find a good version of it that fills the whole screen. If you want me to, I can crop the pic.
Thanks for modding whymeman.
whymeman
Fair enough. Bubbled then.
Mafiamaster
Ranked!
yeahyeahyeahhh
congrats yoshi<3
alvisto
Yeshi !
Lilac
Beat me to it. Dang.
Sallad4ever
Another ranked tales map
I like this :)
Please sign in to reply.

New reply