Xinely wrote:

Kwan made me realized that 00:07:321 (3,4) - 1/3 is wrong lol
sorry im so baka
i tried to confirm but hard to confirm this.. sounds like 1/4 but kwan said 1/4 still off whenever Hinsvar said the snap is 1/4. so my decision is 00:06:234 - until 00:07:756 - make spinner like Hard diff for safe way

i hope you can understand and fix it, i'll rebubble after that

Video,-1200,"tonakoivideo.avi"

1. The video quality is not that high as it should be. What I mean is when it is zoomed over 1080p monitor or higher, it transforms to pixelart and additionally, because it is H.264, it should use fast-decode as it is more friendly to osu!, especially on slower machines, so in some cases, the game and the video might lag. I recommend using this video file instead. Offset shall be -465 if you decided to use this.
2. Some important tags are missing, for example yozuca*, 戸田章世 (Toda Akiyo), project lights, Peak A Soul+ as they all participated in this song (lyrics, composition), thus they are definitely part of important credits.
3. 01:36:283 - Use Style -> Omit first bar line on this one timing point, so it does not show a downbeat here when someone uses this map to play taiko, even though it is not taiko map, it is more correct.

1. 01:35:365 (1) - The slider ends on 01:35:800 while the new timing point is on 01:35:810 and as the sound is really moved in the song, you have to map it like that, infact, else the timing point is insensible at all. So you have to for example use this rhythm.
   SPOILER

   
2. I won't force you, but because of high usage of sliders, you couldn't use a lot of hitsounding. Because of that, I think you might do a simple thing, use this file as a soft-slidertick2.wav and use custom 2 hitsounds on these places, then obviously, after 1/4 swap back to custom 1, I think this makes the map sound a lot more better and consistent, thus it also improves the way player will hold the rhythm:
   00:12:104 - 00:19:930 - 00:33:843 -00:38:191 - 00:39:930 - 01:07:756 - 01:11:234 - 01:14:713 - 01:16:452 - 01:19:930 - 01:21:452 - 01:23:408 - 01:30:365 - 01:33:843
   It is actually not an issue, but if you compare hitsounding of insane and this, this is the poor version, which might be improved. I do not think it is really that much and as it will also help to hold constant rhythm, it is really appropriate.

1. 00:06:235 (1) - The spinner is not much appropriorate as it is shorter than slider on hard and insane, thus it obviously is harder to play, especially for newbies. I know if you make it same long as hard and insane, there will be 1/1 gap, but I suppose you can find a solution to this in your style, it should not be that hard.
2. 01:35:810 (3) - The slider ends on 01:36:282, while the timing point is on 01:36:283, I suppose it was just timing point mistake, so I would move the timing point -1ms.

1. 00:21:017 (6) - The idea is nice, but hiding more than half of a slider is not really fine if we consider the diff is really nice to read and suddenly something like this appears, as it was not used frequently, I recommend to remake it like this or something similar.
   SPOILER

   
2. 00:35:582 (8) - Exactly the same as above.
3. 01:35:810 (1) - The slider ends on 01:36:282, while the timing point is on 01:36:283, I suppose it was just timing point mistake, so I would move the timing point -1ms.

1. 01:35:810 (3) - The slider ends on 01:36:282, while the timing point is on 01:36:283, I suppose it was just timing point mistake, so I would move the timing point -1ms.

Wafu wrote:

1. The video quality is not that high as it should be. What I mean is when it is zoomed over 1080p monitor or higher, it transforms to pixelart and additionally, because it is H.264, it should use fast-decode as it is more friendly to osu!, especially on slower machines, so in some cases, the game and the video might lag. I recommend using this video file instead. Offset shall be -465 if you decided to use this.　sorry. I use present video. Because that's rankable.
2. Some important tags are missing, for example yozuca*, 戸田章世 (Toda Akiyo), project lights, Peak A Soul+ as they all participated in this song (lyrics, composition), thus they are definitely part of important credits.　no. I don't add it because the tag isn't functioning.
3. 01:36:283 - Use Style -> Omit first bar line on this one timing point, so it does not show a downbeat here when someone uses this map to play taiko, even though it is not taiko map, it is more correct. OK

Easy

1. 01:35:365 (1) - The slider ends on 01:35:800 while the new timing point is on 01:35:810 and as the sound is really moved in the song, you have to map it like that, infact, else the timing point is insensible at all. So you have to for example use this rhythm.
   SPOILER

   
2. I won't force you, but because of high usage of sliders, you couldn't use a lot of hitsounding. Because of that, I think you might do a simple thing, use this file as a soft-slidertick2.wav and use custom 2 hitsounds on these places, then obviously, after 1/4 swap back to custom 1, I think this makes the map sound a lot more better and consistent, thus it also improves the way player will hold the rhythm:
   00:12:104 - 00:19:930 - 00:33:843 -00:38:191 - 00:39:930 - 01:07:756 - 01:11:234 - 01:14:713 - 01:16:452 - 01:19:930 - 01:21:452 - 01:23:408 - 01:30:365 - 01:33:843
   It is actually not an issue, but if you compare hitsounding of insane and this, this is the poor version, which might be improved. I do not think it is really that much and as it will also help to hold constant rhythm, it is really appropriate.　

Insane

1. 01:35:810 (3) - The slider ends on 01:36:282, while the timing point is on 01:36:283, I suppose it was just timing point mistake, so I would move the timing point -1ms. OK

KSHR wrote:

Let me clarify at least Wafu's suggestion with the red color in Japanese and English so that mappers and he can understand what I mean.

Genocide wrote:

Qualify! lol jk
good luck with it CakiP

Garven wrote:

CakiP:

[Insane]
00:32:104 (5) - There's a hitsound error here where your sliderslide is audible and it sounds pretty bad. Do you want to get this fixed?