1. Easy (0,99 stars, 26 notes)
2. Extra (5,64 stars, 174 notes)
3. Hard (3,01 stars, 112 notes)
4. Insane (4,76 stars, 153 notes)
5. Normal (1,93 stars, 64 notes)

kookoo11 wrote:

from my nm qq

Extra

General: you need a kiai in there, hitsounds need to be better, and volume should be switched instead of only having 50% through the entire song. the kiai isn't needed and since a the billion ranked granat sets dosent have a kiai id say no also you are right about the hitsounds i feel like should check them again

• 00:01:275 (5,6) - should be a slider like 00:00:281 (1) - imo it looks ugly , 00:00:612 (2) - should be changed into circles ^

• 00:02:270 (5,6) - blanket either of these to make it look better agreed that this pattern can be better but blanket one of the sliders isnt good looking imo

• 00:03:596 (1,2,3,4) - sounds off, sounds better with 1/12 snap but I'm not one to talk ;/ dosen't sound off when you put at 25% speed

• 00:05:586 (4,5) - blanket one of these looks ok imo

• 00:05:254 (2,6) - ugly overlap fixed

• 00:06:249 (6,7,8) - make these jumps larger so people can tell the difference between the notes fixed

• 00:07:243 (1,2) - is weird, just remove 00:07:741 (2) - because there's a sound on 00:07:906 - which should be click-able fixed

• 00:11:554 (2) - should start 00:11:885 - placed a circle here 00:12:051 (1) - instead

• 00:12:217 (1,2) - blanket this? or revise it revised instead

• 00:14:206 - should be click-able; nc should be 00:14:704 (3) -, 00:15:201 (3) - , etc. ur right about the nc one

• 00:16:196 (1,2) - ugly looks ok imo but i will see in future mods

• 00:17:688 (6,7) - fix blanket wtf it wasn't supposed to be a blanket, changed the way it flows instead

• 00:18:185 (1,2) - blanket this or revise it blanket instead

• 00:20:174 (1,2) - terrible blanket fixed

• 00:23:656 (1) - ????? removed the spinner; also why nc 00:23:490 (1) - ur right removed the nc ? feels like this passage is lazy i do agree that it's lazy but not necessary map this part imo

• 00:29:790 (1,2,3) - why sv change? it's unnecessary what do you mean, its for that slider 00:30:121 (2) -

• 00:31:890 (5) - sound is on 00:31:945 - if you listen closely but then the playability will look awful i might revise it later

• 00:41:892 - point should be 00:42:058 - well i dont think it matters anyways lol and nc on 00:42:058 (7) - fixed

Ametrin wrote:

nm from my q

ok another Granat

normal

stack leniency should not lower than 4
00:00:363 - unsnaped green tick not necessary but fixed
00:01:938 (4) - don't put a long white tick at the end of a slider as long as it dosen't start on a red tick in this song i don't see the problem imo
00:12:217 (5) - NC whoops fixed
00:40:068 (1) - don't put spinner after a spinner in normal... map something done

insane

00:04:038 (9) - actually it should be 00:04:093 - fixed
00:06:249 (1,2,3,) - should be more intense it looks good as it is right now imo i don't think it should be more intense
00:18:185 (4) - NC
00:19:180 (7) - ^
00:22:993 (1) - remove NC
00:23:158 (2) - NC here. you should follow music like you did in extra
all the nc suggestions are fixed except the last one

Extra

00:02:270 (5) - NC fixed
00:06:249 (6) - ^ fixed
00:31:890 (5) - 00:31:945 - changed the pattern slightly

GL! thanks for the mod!

Fyre wrote:

play terraria with me ive been waiting like 3 months Fucking bro<3

Extraaaaaaaaaaaa Dfiiicutly

00:00:944 (3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4) - this whole section looks REALLY ugly and plays pretty badly, id change it remapped
00:03:265 (4) - add clap hs Sorry bro i forgot
00:20:174 (1,2) - this looks pretty bad too Nigga how DARE you say this looks bad bro wanna FIGHT son ill fuck u up bro
00:28:132 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - so does this remapped
00:31:448 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^ same

insane

00:16:527 (1,2,3,4) - looks ugly try to replace this slider with circles or something 00:16:859 (3) - remapped
00:22:661 (1) - remove nc fixed Bro
00:42:058 (7) - nc like u did with extra diff Same bro

hard

00:08:238 (1,2) - make the circle closer to the slider so the player can tell when to click or make it farther from the last note lol Fixed bro
00:22:661 (3,4,1) - ^ Fixed bro
00:31:448 (2,1) - sounds a tiny bit off but idk idk it dosent sound if u put speed at 25%
00:40:068 (1) - u should probably map the ending instead of placing a spinner Yes bro

normal

00:10:891 (2,3) - fix blanket Pls looks fine imo tbh

easy

00:18:185 (2) - nc? Ok bro
00:22:495 (1) - u should probably mkae the spinner start slightly earlier or remove it alltogether honestly made it earlier instead

fucking bro<3

My Angel Eugen wrote:

Henlo

General:
00:32:111 (1) - I think there's kiai start. End at 00:42:058 (1)

Easy:
00:22:495 (1) - Move spinner to 00:21:832 (1) and then put the circle to 00:24:153 (1). It will sound better done the spinner one i dont think it would sound better with the circle one
00:38:079 (1) - This spinner is too long. How about standart slider there and spinner from 00:40:068 (1)? fixed

Normal:
00:00:612 (2) - This slider sounds weird. Just put shorter slider and circle done
00:04:591 (2,3,4) - This pattern could allot same sounds, but there's not fixed
00:14:206 (1,2) - Straight sliders isnt cool >w<. Go make it a bit curved like this kinda prefer it straight since it looks more clean imo

Hard:
00:00:281 (1) - No, this sounds weird. Replace this slider to circle and move second slider to the end of the previous. Then put the circle
00:04:922 (2) - Replace this slider to two circles. It will sound better
fixed everything

Good map thanks!
Where's my supporter tag oh i guess i owe someone a supporter

-GN wrote:

hey i saw this on twitter and decided i wanted a kudosu

[extra or something]
00:01:441 (6,1,2,3,4) - the angle going from 6 to 1 doesn't feel right, maybe make these 5 a pentagondone
00:02:270 (1,2,3) - you could make these more interesting i remapped them into a better structure hopefully
00:03:430 (5) - clicking this doesn't work well when there's a held note in the music starts replaced by a slider
00:10:227 (5,1) - this antijump sucks remapped to a better one hopefully
00:12:714 (3) - this shouldn't be this long, there's this ascending guitar in the bg that should be mapped, i think it'd fit well if you made a jump pattern that ended on 00:13:212 (1) - here, 00:13:377 (2) - is overmap as well remapped
00:13:875 (5) - the sliderend here should be a circle, see even 00:14:372 (1,2) - is too short compared to the other triangles and it's sad i think i'll leave this for now since i have no idea what to change to
00:15:201 (1,2,3,1,2,3) - make this some geometrical pattern like the first half of the jumps, doesn't need to be where the others are though i should have used ds xd
00:16:030 (3,1) - also don't stack these ok done
00:16:196 (1,2) - unsnapped ends, also same as 00:12:714 (3) remapped
00:22:661 (1) - don't NC this ok
00:23:324 - should be mapped unecessary since one of the 500 ranked granat mapset have a diff that didn't even map this part but i'll leave this unmapped until there is more suggestions from mods about mapping it
00:25:148 (1,2,3) - this is pretty boring, you should map the foreground melody since you start mapping it at (4)
00:29:790 (1) - the slider speedup here feels arbitrary and you only use three sliders here anyway changed the first slider into 2 circles hopefully it play better
00:32:111 (1) - all the jumps up to the back and forths are pretty randomly placed... their flow works but they are pretty ugly done a slight change for now but ill just remap the whole thing when i have the time
00:40:068 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - you should make these look more like a pattern, the two last ones feel out of place coming after the square ok done

[insane]
00:00:281 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - would be better with these symmetric what do you mean? i think those patterns looks good the way they are imo
00:02:270 (1,2,3) - spacing here is random fixed hopefully
00:05:088 (5) - the end here should be clickable, it even has a clap sound fixed
00:11:719 (6,1) - antijump here doesn't work well i think, readable but doesn't carry the weight of the melody added a circle i hope its better now
00:13:212 (5,1,2) - i'd consider these three the same pattern and should have equal spacing
00:16:527 (1,2,3,4,5) - this zigzag is irregularchanged the whole pattern
00:17:522 (1,2,3) - triangle is irregular
00:18:185 (1,2,3) - copypaste one of these sliders and replace them with the rest, rotate 60 degree or so and it'll be less off(protip copypaste two sliders, match the first one you're pasting with the second one placed, remove the first pasted one and you'll have a perfectly regular three slider pattern) done hopefully
00:19:180 (1,2,1) - if you want it like this you should make it symmetrical, but i think 00:20:174 (1) - should be 1/2 long and have two extra clickable circles for the rhythm here slightly changed the pattern hopefully it plays better
00:22:330 (1,2,1,2,3,4) - more circles here than the Extra... idk don't think this is necessary we'll see in future mods
00:26:143 (1,1) - these are NCed unlike Extra, make consistent unNCed
00:34:100 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - these are linear, at this spacing this is probably by far the hardest pattern in the map(except the final star). also you should probably divide these into triples instead, it's the only pattern divided by two beats instead of three in this difficulty made them look like the rest of the section
00:38:742 (1,2,3,4,5) - this is a pretty huge difficulty spike nerfed a bit

i think you're better off remapping most of these two diffs, you might wanna look at it in a macro scale and just go through the song finding the beats that would be good to click on to have a solid foundation, then maybe remove some of them for the Insane(or maybe not).

also to be fair, this is mapped a lot already and my personal opinion is you shouldn't try to rank a set of it unless you have a good gimmick or something for it. good way to practice mapping though i suppose to be fair this was already submitted before the second granat even gets ranked it just happens that i finish de mapset this year unlucky

- Squishi wrote:

ExuTera
00:03:265 (4) - extend this to the white tick and remove the circle already there. Like Fg Bro why end it on the blue tick.thats gay and vonfusing
00:07:906 (5,1) - add in a filler rhythm? <3
00:16:030 (3,1) - meh do this --> https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8731055
00:28:298 (5,6,7,8,9,10) - pls keep consistency and remove all this. keep the 4 tho
but if im wrong because of 00:29:956 (2,3,4,5,6) - pls feel free to not do anything about it
00:33:603 (1,2,3,1,2,3) - HUGE difference in terms of spacing, and it doesnt even come with the song.. its just there
00:34:597 (1,2,3) - same with this
and speaking of spacing changes, there are numerous places in the last part, so i suggest fixing that
00:38:079 (1,2,3,4) - back and forth jumps are really borin, do something a bit more interesting
@00:29:624 Why The Inherited point? ?????????????? the msuiic doesnt get any quieter or any louder and its even 1.5x too,Please Dont

fixed everyhting lole also about the 4th suggestion i made it into a superior pattern hopefully


Nae nae insane
00:03:927 (8) - 00:04:922 (4) - fix overlap :_ Ok
00:09:233 (5,1) - maybe overlap these? Nope those clearly arent meant to be overlaps
00:13:543 (1,2) - WHAT ARE U DOING Ok changed the pattern i hope ur happy now
00:21:335 (8) - delet this. the circle already ends the rhythm there and its not even good filler rhyth, M !!!!!!!!!!
00:21:998 (10,1,2,1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - doesnt fit the music, fix ok changed the entire pattern but whetever its better or not its debatable
00:28:132 (1) - literally just do the same thing that i said in the extra

Hard
00:07:243 (4,5) - make these a bit closer together nope cause then the spacing will look even more random
00:19:180 (5) - meh just do this - _ - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8731108 no difference -_ -
00:23:158 (1) - Fix Triangle like this , https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8731113 what do u mean

ok im done give me kudos grr