Fixed my Mod, sorry for the huge delay.

y no Miku's

[Inner Oni]
tbh I expected moar streams o3o but I didn't say anything!
00:05:983 (35) - I know the sound here is smaller but a big note would make a nice compliment to the pattern. (This goes for all diffs that have this note)
02:04:806 (703) - I'd suggest to make this a big kat, you have the same intensity in vocals so a don isn't really fitting imo, and we make it big due the big drum sound there :p (This goes for all diffs that have this note)
02:49:512 (982,989) - Here you could remove these two notes to emphasize better this oooo oo rhythm there o3o
02:54:218 (1022) - Move it 1/4 beat forward due the same as above.
In fact I'd suggest to follow this rhythm because is very catchy, but I noticed you also mapped for that other-sound-that-I-don't-know-how-it's-called so do keep if you like.
02:59:708 (1065,1066) - Move them 1/4 beat backwards? I think they'd fit the same structure as 02:56:179 (1037,1038,1039,1040,1041), which would be better imo.
04:21:081 (1) - I really feel this spinner kills the emphasis of the last note, remove pls ;w; (This goes for all diffs)
Also the 1/6 really threw me off, but that's just my usual ranting

[Oni]
00:46:767 - I feel this stringy instrument a bit ignored, some changes would help here

01:45:688 - No 5-note stream here?
01:49:512 - Similar as in the first suggestion
04:17:159 - The stream here feels really odd beginning in a red tick while it begins in a white one in the music, you could add the missing note on the empty tick, or do something similar to this:


[Muzukashii]
00:04:414 (19) - I feel this note could work better 1/2 beat backwards along with the string instrument there
00:06:767 - 00:18:532 - I'm going to say this felt this section a bit weird the first play as vocals are more catchier here, just wanting to say this (/w\). You may want to reduce the 5-note streams o3o
00:17:356 (72,73,74) - Shouldn't this be 1/2 beat back?
03:01:179 (81) - I feel this note could fit better in 03:00:982 with the beginning of the drums in 1/4.
03:26:767 - I'd expect this part to be a less dense, it's not very different from the kiai so this doesn't reflect too nice the calmness here, getting rid of the 3/4 notes and removing some more notes here and there while keeping the stronger vocals here would help here. Example:

04:16:963 (94,95,96,97,98,99) - d o kkkkk -> d d kkk k. This would follow better the music here as the 5-note stream feels a bit off here ;w;

[Futsuu]
00:05:787 (17) - I'd suggest to remove this note 1/2 beat forward, this may be a weaker beat, but it marks the end of the section, so it'd be better to have a note here instead, maybe removing the finish.
00:06:767 - 00:18:532 - Same comment as in Muzukashii (/w\)
00:54:414 (139) - Removing this note would help to emphasize better the next.
00:55:198 (140) - Move this 1/2 beat backward, this would match nicely with vocals, only do if you followed what I said above.
01:00:688 (152) - Something similar as in 00:54:414 (139) -
01:02:061 - Add a note here if you followed 00:55:198 (140) -
02:04:414 (307) - This note feels a bit odd, as this part is like "map all or none" for the vocals here (except for the first note ofc), I think it'd be better to remove it.
02:42:845 - 02:47:551 - This part would play better as o o o x o than o x o o o imo.
04:00:100 - Add a note here?
04:12:649 - ^
A bit difficult from my point of view, but this fits with the whole spread so I won't complain too much about it.

[Kantan]
00:17:356 (24) - Move this 1 beat backward, it'd match better with vocals, which are easier to follow here.
01:14:610 (113) - Remove this note? You did it in the second kiai.
03:26:375 (314) - ^
03:26:767 - Similar as in Muzukashii, this part is mapped the same as the kiai but song is calmer aaaa.
I feel this diff could be spiced up a bit with a few 4/1 breaks and 5-notes in 1/1 patterns when possible, not many though :p

I guess that'd be all from my part o3o

Stefan wrote:

[Futsuu]
02:13:630 - d? The Beat by the circle here sounds pretty neat and fitting well. eh, I had this kind-of dense, so I want to leave this out.

[Muzukashii]
00:10:983 - It feels and sounds better by having a Triplet here. done
02:56:963 (65,66,67,68,69) - I'd find it better to map this like 02:55:394 (60,61,62,63,64), this connect much better to each together. The only change I would suggest is to make at 02:57:943 if there is kd to switch into dk, it sounds better to the music. this kinda felt weird, so I'll reject that.

DakeDekaane wrote:

y no Miku's
hard to find a song that really catches my mind for a map XD

[Inner Oni]
tbh I expected moar streams o3o but I didn't say anything! trying to lay low on the streams for this one XP
00:05:983 (35) - I know the sound here is smaller but a big note would make a nice compliment to the pattern. (This goes for all diffs that have this note) really feels weird knowing the vocals aren't present here to empower it, so no to this.
02:04:806 (703) - I'd suggest to make this a big kat, you have the same intensity in vocals so a don isn't really fitting imo, and we make it big due the big drum sound there :p (This goes for all diffs that have this note) done
02:49:512 (982,989) - Here you could remove these two notes to emphasize better this oooo oo rhythm there o3o done
02:54:218 (1022) - Move it 1/4 beat forward due the same as above.
In fact I'd suggest to follow this rhythm because is very catchy, but I noticed you also mapped for that other-sound-that-I-don't-know-how-it's-called so do keep if you like. I'll just add a d instead since the long off-beat really throws me off.
02:59:708 (1065,1066) - Move them 1/4 beat backwards? I think they'd fit the same structure as 02:56:179 (1037,1038,1039,1040,1041), which would be better imo. I moved this then added a k on 02:59:806, it just seemed like a better alternative.
04:21:081 (1) - I really feel this spinner kills the emphasis of the last note, remove pls ;w; (This goes for all diffs) reduced the volume to 5%, I hope that's better.
Also the 1/6 really threw me off, but that's just my usual ranting XD

[Oni]
00:46:767 - I feel this stringy instrument a bit ignored, some changes would help here did something very related.

01:45:688 - No 5-note stream here? I actually started to ignore these a bit more since it felt really weird to doubletime with a double into a quintuple
01:49:512 - Similar as in the first suggestion done just like before
04:17:159 - The stream here feels really odd beginning in a red tick while it begins in a white one in the music, you could add the missing note on the empty tick, or do something similar to this: done


[Muzukashii]
00:04:414 (19) - I feel this note could work better 1/2 beat backwards along with the string instrument there done and changed to a d for the taiko hit there.
00:06:767 - 00:18:532 - I'm going to say this felt this section a bit weird the first play as vocals are more catchier here, just wanting to say this (/w\). You may want to reduce the 5-note streams o3o fixed to the preference that I was going for.
00:17:356 (72,73,74) - Shouldn't this be 1/2 beat back? added a d 1/2 before this
03:01:179 (81) - I feel this note could fit better in 03:00:982 with the beginning of the drums in 1/4. most of my triples start on a red tick, it's just something that I think fits a bit more and just a personal preference.
03:26:767 - I'd expect this part to be a less dense, it's not very different from the kiai so this doesn't reflect too nice the calmness here, getting rid of the 3/4 notes and removing some more notes here and there while keeping the stronger vocals here would help here. Example: done

04:16:963 (94,95,96,97,98,99) - d o kkkkk -> d d kkk k. This would follow better the music here as the 5-note stream feels a bit off here ;w; done

[Futsuu]
00:05:787 (17) - I'd suggest to remove this note 1/2 beat forward, this may be a weaker beat, but it marks the end of the section, so it'd be better to have a note here instead, maybe removing the finish.
00:06:767 - 00:18:532 - Same comment as in Muzukashii (/w\) changed, lets see if that works.
00:54:414 (139) - Removing this note would help to emphasize better the next.
00:55:198 (140) - Move this 1/2 beat backward, this would match nicely with vocals, only do if you followed what I said above.
01:00:688 (152) - Something similar as in 00:54:414 (139) -
01:02:061 - Add a note here if you followed 00:55:198 (140) - all done above besides the one since the next part I have is pretty dense.
02:04:414 (307) - This note feels a bit odd, as this part is like "map all or none" for the vocals here (except for the first note ofc), I think it'd be better to remove it. done
02:42:845 - 02:47:551 - This part would play better as o o o x o than o x o o o imo. done
04:00:100 - Add a note here?
04:12:649 - ^ not adding these to keep this a little less dense.
A bit difficult from my point of view, but this fits with the whole spread so I won't complain too much about it.

[Kantan]
00:17:356 (24) - Move this 1 beat backward, it'd match better with vocals, which are easier to follow here.
01:14:610 (113) - Remove this note? You did it in the second kiai.
03:26:375 (314) - ^
03:26:767 - Similar as in Muzukashii, this part is mapped the same as the kiai but song is calmer aaaa.
I feel this diff could be spiced up a bit with a few 4/1 breaks and 5-notes in 1/1 patterns when possible, not many though :p
applied all

I guess that'd be all from my part o3o

Thanks

About the spinners I really feel it doesn't fit, as in, you have a really strong ending that would feel better with that last strong note as the end, than continue to hitting the drums, but if you feel it necesary, I won't force you
btw, you forgot to change the volume in all diffs.
And the thing I mentioned about the big kat in 02:04:806 - in all diffs too.

[Futsuu]
00:15:591 (35) - I think this could be better being in 00:15:983 or removed, the 1/2 triple feels a bit random, but maybe it's just me.

[Kantan]
02:04:414 (188) - I forgot to tell you to remove this one too, as in Futsuu previously.

o3o

DakeDekaane wrote:

About the spinners I really feel it doesn't fit, as in, you have a really strong ending that would feel better with that last strong note as the end, than continue to hitting the drums, but if you feel it necesary, I won't force you
btw, you forgot to change the volume in all diffs. yeah, was really tired when applying mods XP
And the thing I mentioned about the big kat in 02:04:806 - in all diffs too. changed

[Futsuu]
00:15:591 (35) - I think this could be better being in 00:15:983 or removed, the 1/2 triple feels a bit random, but maybe it's just me.

[Kantan]
02:04:414 (188) - I forgot to tell you to remove this one too, as in Futsuu previously.

o3o

updated everything.

Bubbled~

This hype is real (hbd miku \:3/)

Qualified

Congratulations!

wow speedddd gratz ! !

Happy Birthday Miku!
Gratz~

oh god i love wagakki band. thanks for mapping this song, also grats

<3

gz : D

YESSSSSSSSSSS congratulations!

WOW Love Fast Rank
Congratulations !

Oh that was something fast! Congrats!

godaamnit so fast :/
Gratz! ovo

Reason for Disqualification

1. Disqualified for consecutive mapping in all lower difficulties.
2. Concerns also apply to Oni which aren't as urgent as in lower diffs., but which should be noted to avoid having a too big spread from Muzu to Oni after changes are made. Since Inner and Oni have in some parts a big similarity; deleting notes would make this less noticeable and save the spread to Muzu automatically.

___________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

Additional Modding

[General]
First of all let me say that in my opinion the set is pretty good. I would even go so far to say it is -more or less- flawles. Spread is overall also pretty good, even though it becomes a bit denser in upper diffs, but that's fine. Beside that, the consecutive mapping doesn't endanger the spread since all lower diffs are mapped in this way. Well, talking about this(and as it's stated above), the set has been disqualified due to consecutive mapping which concerns are mainly dedicated to the lower difficulties. Reason for this is the beatwise mapping; the beat is constantly going on and you are mapping to it -more or less- strictly. The good thing is because of this, the maps have a well structure. So it shouldn't be problematic to delete some notes. I will give some suggestions in the K+F+M up to the end of the first kiai which can be applied in upcoming parts in a similar way. I might add some other suggestions as well.

Purple-like coloured points are set related concerns / suggestions / ..., which can be checked at the same time.

[ Kantan]
[ Futsuu]
[ Muzukashii]
[ Oni]
Looks big, huh? Well, overall I mentioned the same points an concerns since it's mainly about the consecutive mapping.
As I said, in my opinion the maps are made decent, but mapping in the lower diffs for such a long time in one row is problematic. Also the similarity in Inner and Oni is rather questionable to me, but not a problem after all. In general I didn't touch your patterns - just suggested deletions (which are in most cases suggestions since you might have better ideas).

Ah... now I wish I would have modded this earlier. But anyway, I'm pretty sure this gets soon requalified once the needed changes are done.
Good luck.

To grave we go.

This is a game that primarily uses keyboard, each difficulty represents how a difficulty plays. The "consecutive mapping" you speak of does not exist as I did leave logical spacing and breaks for each difficulty. The BPM is low enough for a good amount of 1/1 usage on the Kantan, which was used accordingly. I've had people test my Muzu and some test my Oni, some both and they thought it was great. The way you're stating things are more "authentic" which this isn't the original game. We have perks for being based around a keyboard. With that said, I'm not going to make any changes.

PS. I also requested you to look at this a week before this was qualified. I understand that you have been busy, but I gave extra time so this would've been prevented.

...

btw i think that you should remove a space between Wagakki and band.
also it should be lower-case imo because of the official website.



official twitter is using WagakkiBand as a name. but in this case, maybe we should prioritize the official website.

I'll do WagakkiBand instead if I ever feel like updating.

Which is never.

I don't get why this had to happen this late. Just like I don't get how that is a reason for unqualify.


rip best Oni 2014

This will still be the best mapset of 2014 in my book ;_;7

Nwolf wrote:

I don't get why this had to happen this late. Just like I don't get how that is a reason for unqualify.


rip best Oni 2014

Well, the disqualify already added more to my bad day anyways. Forever updated on 8/31.

rip best taco set of 2014 ;w;

nice job trying to fix something not broken.

Jeez, every good map is getting disqualified lately.

why is the drain in inner oni so unforgiving i failed with 91% accuracy Q.Q
(granted, i suck at taiko)

probably missed too much at one spot to recover enough

Apologies for missing the WagakkiBand thing @ Love.

Also there's nothing wrong with the difficulty spread, stop being a hardass for no reason.

This should have never been unqualified other than for the title fix.

Tasha wrote:

Apologies for missing the WagakkiBand thing @ Love.

Also there's nothing wrong with the difficulty spread, stop being a hardass for no reason.

This should have never been unqualified other than for the title fix.

Actually, the Artist will still be placed as Wagakki Band, everywhere it is listed as such.

I think I didn't researched more about the band orz (yeah it says Wagakki Band everywhere, but we can't ignore their official websit)

I should say I agree a bit on Ono as Kantan was like more 2/1 which was a bit monotonical as I told you, but didn't want to force that opinion, so I guess I have some guilt too.

Please next year ;w;

DakeDekaane wrote:

I think I didn't researched more about the band orz (yeah it says Wagakki Band everywhere, but we can't ignore their official websit)

I should say I agree a bit on Ono as Kantan was like more 2/1 which was a bit monotonical as I told you, but didn't want to force that opinion, so I guess I have some guilt too.

Please next year ;w;

Thing is about their website, I'd rather go with a ton of places, especially how it's listed on last.fm with the most scrobbles. It uses the unicode 和楽器バンド but there it's translated to Wagakki Band, so this will not change.

finally it's graved

This modding thread has been migrated to the new "modding discussions" system. Please make sure to re-post any existing (and unresolved) efforts to the new system as required.