[Clyine's Extra]
- This difficulty needs better flow. I'm going to cite some examples in the diff that could use better flow.
- 00:00:735 (3,4) - The slider and the note afterward do not show good flow. The slider is pointed to the upper-right corner but the note follow up is to it's lower-right instead. Either make the slider point to the note or move the note to where the slider will point. Example of a pattern with a better flow would be http://puu.sh/aA17r/60620ef0fd.jpg.
- 00:01:985 (1) - The S-shape at the end of the slider doesn't really fit. IMO change to a regular curved slider. Also, the finish at the end doesn't fit either.
- 00:02:521 (2) - Also an example of bad flow. The slider end is nowhere near or pointing to this note.
- 00:02:521 (2,3,4,5) - The spacing is a confusing. (2,3) are 1/1 apart, while (3,4) and (4,5) are 1/2 apart. Wrong spacing and since you stacked (4) on (2), it may be more confusing.
- 00:04:664 (1,2,3) - Bad flow. Flip it horizontally and lower a bit for better flow. http://puu.sh/aA1l5/3c3ac3437b.jpg
- 00:04:753 (2) - Incidentally, this (2) should be moved up a bit so that the (1,2,3) will form a straight line (along with the slider).
- 00:07:878 (1,2) - Same comment about flow. I suggest you change the pattern altogether. Using a two-repeat long slider here on a difficulty higher than Hard seems a bit boring.
- 00:10:021 (5) - Not perfectly symmetrical, also blanket the note better.
- 00:09:307 (1,2) - Place these notes at the center?
- 00:09:664 (3,4,8,10) - I think it would be better if you stacked these notes. It looks neater. http://puu.sh/aA1C0/6074bab18c.jpg
- 00:11:450 (1,2,3,4,1) - Regarding this pattern, it would be better if it encompasses the previous one. http://puu.sh/aA1Il/914c4584dd.jpg I adjusted the edges of the square so it would fit and centered it. I also moved the slider and pointed it so that it would make a line with the previous patterns.
- 00:12:521 (2) - Make sure the end of this slider points to the end of your previous one. It provides some aesthetic flow. http://puu.sh/aA1MV/ac1382cd3b.jpg
- 00:13:593 (7) - This slider would be better if it was aligned with the line you formed with your previous combos. http://puu.sh/aA1Wy/4326f4f785.jpg (On that note, move (8) as well)
- 00:19:664 (2,3) - A thing to note about stacks is that they change the flow. ATM, the stack here kills the continuous flow you had. IMO space these normally.
- 00:21:985 (7) - Why a straight-edge slider instead of a curve? Suddenly looks odd if you place one there.
- 00:23:949 (4,1,2,3,4,5) - I highly recommend you rework this pattern based on what I said about flow earlier.
- 00:27:164 (2,1) - Don't make these two overlap.
- 00:30:735 (1,2) - Looks like you just copied the pattern at 00:27:878 (1,2) and rotated it >.>
- 00:38:592 (2,1) - Same comment about the flow.
- 00:40:735 (1,1,1) - This does not work musically. There is no music at the 1/4 ends of those sliders, and it sounds odd. The overlaps also look ugly IMO.
- 00:42:878 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,1) - Wow this just pops out of nowhere. There's no build up whatsoever in the parts leading to this.
- 00:43:593 (1,2) - Same comment about flow. I suggest making the slider face the other way.
- 00:49:217 (2) - Remove this and save the 1/4 triples after the music changes at 00:49:485
- 01:17:878 (2,2,2) - These speed changes don't really fit at all. I suggest you remove them.
- That's all for now. There are a ton more issues I can see, but I've spent too much time on this diff already. Maybe if you call for a recheck I can check this again.
[TestApple's Extra]
- Some issues here, but I do like the flow for some parts.
- You really need more hitsounds here. Add some claps especially in that kiai part
- 00:25:735 (6,7,8,9) - I feel this part is a tad bit overmapped. The music isn't that heavy on the rhythm here yet you used 1/4 slider-stream jumps.
- 00:29:307 (3) - This would look better if it were all in a straight line. http://puu.sh/aA5Bx/222ddc4029.jpg
- 00:30:735 (1,2,3,4) - This part is also overmapped. The vocals follow the red ticks (1/2) only here.
- 00:40:200 (8) - Ctrl+G for better flow here.
- 00:43:057 (3,4) - I recommend making them straight instead of curved. As is, they look too scrunched up and ugly IMO.
- 00:50:914 (5,6) - The overlapping here with the combo makes it cluttered and confusing. Please move this elsewhere.
- 00:58:950 () - I was expecting a note here.
- 00:59:307 (5,6,7,1) - This spacing is just confusing. (1) is 1/2 after yet spaced the same as (6) which is only 1/4 after. Not to mention, (6) is a big spacing increase compared to your previous 1/4s.
- 01:06:093 (1,2,3,4,5,1) - When you reach the downbeat at 01:06:450, you should stop with the 1/4s since it's purpose of buildup is already over.
- 01:08:414 (1) - The finish is out of place here. It belongs usually in the downbeat. It's a stretch but 01:08:593 (2) can also use a finish.
- Same as before, I proceed to next difficulty.
[Insane]
- 00:07:878 (7,2) - They overlap Looks ugly IMO.
And I apologize, but I have to stop now. I'll continue modding this. (If I forget please prompt me.)
-
- This difficulty needs better flow. I'm going to cite some examples in the diff that could use better flow.
- 00:00:735 (3,4) - The slider and the note afterward do not show good flow. The slider is pointed to the upper-right corner but the note follow up is to it's lower-right instead. Either make the slider point to the note or move the note to where the slider will point. Example of a pattern with a better flow would be http://puu.sh/aA17r/60620ef0fd.jpg.
- 00:01:985 (1) - The S-shape at the end of the slider doesn't really fit. IMO change to a regular curved slider. Also, the finish at the end doesn't fit either.
- 00:02:521 (2) - Also an example of bad flow. The slider end is nowhere near or pointing to this note.
- 00:02:521 (2,3,4,5) - The spacing is a confusing. (2,3) are 1/1 apart, while (3,4) and (4,5) are 1/2 apart. Wrong spacing and since you stacked (4) on (2), it may be more confusing.
- 00:04:664 (1,2,3) - Bad flow. Flip it horizontally and lower a bit for better flow. http://puu.sh/aA1l5/3c3ac3437b.jpg
- 00:04:753 (2) - Incidentally, this (2) should be moved up a bit so that the (1,2,3) will form a straight line (along with the slider).
- 00:07:878 (1,2) - Same comment about flow. I suggest you change the pattern altogether. Using a two-repeat long slider here on a difficulty higher than Hard seems a bit boring.
- 00:10:021 (5) - Not perfectly symmetrical, also blanket the note better.
- 00:09:307 (1,2) - Place these notes at the center?
- 00:09:664 (3,4,8,10) - I think it would be better if you stacked these notes. It looks neater. http://puu.sh/aA1C0/6074bab18c.jpg
- 00:11:450 (1,2,3,4,1) - Regarding this pattern, it would be better if it encompasses the previous one. http://puu.sh/aA1Il/914c4584dd.jpg I adjusted the edges of the square so it would fit and centered it. I also moved the slider and pointed it so that it would make a line with the previous patterns.
- 00:12:521 (2) - Make sure the end of this slider points to the end of your previous one. It provides some aesthetic flow. http://puu.sh/aA1MV/ac1382cd3b.jpg
- 00:13:593 (7) - This slider would be better if it was aligned with the line you formed with your previous combos. http://puu.sh/aA1Wy/4326f4f785.jpg (On that note, move (8) as well)
- 00:19:664 (2,3) - A thing to note about stacks is that they change the flow. ATM, the stack here kills the continuous flow you had. IMO space these normally.
- 00:21:985 (7) - Why a straight-edge slider instead of a curve? Suddenly looks odd if you place one there.
- 00:23:949 (4,1,2,3,4,5) - I highly recommend you rework this pattern based on what I said about flow earlier.
- 00:27:164 (2,1) - Don't make these two overlap.
- 00:30:735 (1,2) - Looks like you just copied the pattern at 00:27:878 (1,2) and rotated it >.>
- 00:38:592 (2,1) - Same comment about the flow.
- 00:40:735 (1,1,1) - This does not work musically. There is no music at the 1/4 ends of those sliders, and it sounds odd. The overlaps also look ugly IMO.
- 00:42:878 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,1) - Wow this just pops out of nowhere. There's no build up whatsoever in the parts leading to this.
- 00:43:593 (1,2) - Same comment about flow. I suggest making the slider face the other way.
- 00:49:217 (2) - Remove this and save the 1/4 triples after the music changes at 00:49:485
- 01:17:878 (2,2,2) - These speed changes don't really fit at all. I suggest you remove them.
- That's all for now. There are a ton more issues I can see, but I've spent too much time on this diff already. Maybe if you call for a recheck I can check this again.
[TestApple's Extra]
- Some issues here, but I do like the flow for some parts.
- You really need more hitsounds here. Add some claps especially in that kiai part
- 00:25:735 (6,7,8,9) - I feel this part is a tad bit overmapped. The music isn't that heavy on the rhythm here yet you used 1/4 slider-stream jumps.
- 00:29:307 (3) - This would look better if it were all in a straight line. http://puu.sh/aA5Bx/222ddc4029.jpg
- 00:30:735 (1,2,3,4) - This part is also overmapped. The vocals follow the red ticks (1/2) only here.
- 00:40:200 (8) - Ctrl+G for better flow here.
- 00:43:057 (3,4) - I recommend making them straight instead of curved. As is, they look too scrunched up and ugly IMO.
- 00:50:914 (5,6) - The overlapping here with the combo makes it cluttered and confusing. Please move this elsewhere.
- 00:58:950 () - I was expecting a note here.
- 00:59:307 (5,6,7,1) - This spacing is just confusing. (1) is 1/2 after yet spaced the same as (6) which is only 1/4 after. Not to mention, (6) is a big spacing increase compared to your previous 1/4s.
- 01:06:093 (1,2,3,4,5,1) - When you reach the downbeat at 01:06:450, you should stop with the 1/4s since it's purpose of buildup is already over.
- 01:08:414 (1) - The finish is out of place here. It belongs usually in the downbeat. It's a stretch but 01:08:593 (2) can also use a finish.
- Same as before, I proceed to next difficulty.
[Insane]
- 00:07:878 (7,2) - They overlap Looks ugly IMO.
And I apologize, but I have to stop now. I'll continue modding this. (If I forget please prompt me.)
-