150P - Shuuen no Shiori [Taiko|Osu]

posted
Total Posts
77
show more
Gaia
Heey~ From my queue

[General]
I think Insane with 4.2 stars to suddenly jump to an extra of 5.5 is too big o-o Just my 2 cents so yea

[Hard]
00:15:339 (4) - bend towards the left instead of right?
00:17:624 (4) - Curve this more
00:26:767 (1,2) - ^
01:37:767 (1) - quite a jump even for hard
02:09:767 (1) - Ctrl + G
02:16:481 (4) - Why not curve this?
02:23:339 (4) - ^
02:23:767 (5) - not mirror with 02:22:910 (3) -
02:27:910 (1) - not perfect
02:57:624 (4) - Curve inside (left)?
02:59:910 (4) - curve this maybe
03:08:339 (2,3,4) - keep the same ds
03:30:624 (4) - NC here instead?
03:31:196 (1) - so no nc here if u take ^
03:34:196 (3) - curve more?
03:42:339 (1) - this is pretty short..

[Insane]
00:58:196 (6) - stack with 00:56:339 (5) -
01:09:053 (1) - shape looks awkward
01:40:910 (4) - ctrl + g?
01:42:339 (1) - curve more?
01:43:481 (1) - ^
01:49:767 (3) - Ctrl + G
01:54:481 (3) - unnecessary overlap
02:02:624 (8) - Ctrl + G
02:17:624 (1) - end this further up http://puu.sh/9YjDS/3d95b7b348.jpg
02:18:767 (1) - sth like this? http://puu.sh/9Yk0k/6a44850f9e.jpg
02:47:481 (1) - Music gets softer here so u could slow down SV to 0.75x or sth?
02:53:481 (1,2,3) - Not parallel
02:49:624 (1) - blanket
02:52:339 (2,4) - ^
03:03:767 (2) - Ctrl + G
03:15:481 (3) - ^
03:42:339 (1) - a bit short

[Demise]
00:02:767 (1) - curve more
00:06:910 (3) - (44,44) or sth?
00:08:053 (3) - (160, 352) ? ^ (these 2 are just suggestions)
00:09:624 (1) - blanket?
00:19:053 (2,4) - put it somewhere like (296, 192) and blanket with 00:19:196 (3) -
00:23:339 (1) - Ctrl + G
00:36:339 (2,4,5,6) - weird shape.
00:41:767 (1) - blanket
01:05:053 (7,8,9) - Ctrl + G
01:06:767 (1) - blanket more
01:07:910 (1) - ^
01:09:053 (1) - ^
01:52:481 (6) - crooked shape (and stack with 01:53:696 (7) -) so (448,240)
02:07:767 (2) - Ctrl + G
02:14:196 (1) - curve more?
02:54:196 (1) - blanket this more
03:10:481 (2) - put in middle? (256, 192)
03:20:481 (1) - not good mirror of 03:20:767 (2) - (Ctrl + >)
03:51:481 (3) - Don't think you need this

Fun jumps ^^ GL with ur map!
Topic Starter
Yasora

Mystyk wrote:

Hi! Mod from my queue!

General:
There is nothing wrong with the mapset as I can see, however I would suggest you to change the red color, it blends too much with the background.
Combo colors must not blend in with the map's background/storyboard/video.
Normal:

The mod for this difficulty will probably be kind of nazi sorry about that, but in my opinion that's one of the ways how you could improve this difficulty :3

00:01:767 (1,2) - this doesn't look nice, try to improve the blanket, middle point: x:232 y:280, end point: x:216 y:232 (for 00:02:767 (2) - this slider) - http://puu.sh/9XGEk/cb9ade2e4c.jpg (afterwards you'll have to replace 00:03:481 (3) - a little bit)
00:03:481 (3,1) - same as above ^ - http://puu.sh/9XHmm/9d6cb3b6fe.jpg
00:14:339 (1,2) - same ^ middle point: x:408 y:84 - end point: x:476 y:84 (for slider (1)) then replace 00:15:481 (2) - a little bit because of the distance
00:27:196 (4,5) - ^ 00:27:767 (5) - end point: x:40 y:100
01:06:624 (2,3,4) - ^ 01:07:196 (3) - middle point: x:140 y:304 - end point: x:208 y:292 - http://puu.sh/9XHI4/fa28a27546.jpg
01:10:053 (1) - add finish to the beginning of the slider, it will fit better because there is a finish sound in the music too
01:11:767 (2) - move the end point of the slider to x:296 y:60 the blanket will look nicer
02:15:196 (1) - add finish to the beginning of the slider, same reason as 01:10:053 (1) -
02:53:767 (2,3) - improve the blanket 02:55:481 (3) - move the middle point of the slider to: x:160 y:116 - end point to x:224 y:84 - http://puu.sh/9XIcR/4c149b389a.jpg
03:10:053 (1,2) - same as above ^ 03:10:053 (1) - move the end point of the slider to x:312 y:312 - http://puu.sh/9XIjQ/f36a483a87.jpg
03:32:624 (1) - I think you could make this look nicer, and also because of the standard ranking criteria
Slider anchors/nodes must not be used to manipulate slider speeds
it would be safer to change this a little bit, an example - http://puu.sh/9XKog/ed557c4768.jpg or maybe http://puu.sh/9XKLM/3dc338d1c5.jpg
03:35:196 (4) - add finish to the beginning of the slider because there is a finish sound in the music too

Hard:
00:02:624 (3) - this would feel better to play if you replaced it here 00:02:481 - because of the vocals changed it with slider
00:03:767 (1) - same as above ^ replace it here 00:03:624 (1) - because of the vocals, I know there is something in the music so that's why you put those notes there, but imo it really plays better if you follow the vocals there especially because 00:02:767 (4,2) - these 2 notes will get a bigger emphasis
00:02:767 (4,2) - add finish to the beginning of both sliders, the music also has these loud sounds so it will fit buutt I want it only whistle in this part xD
00:05:053 (5) - same as above ^ add finish because of the same reason ^
00:07:339 (1,1,1) - same for these ^ ^
00:11:767 (4,1) - this feels weird to play in my opinion, why don't you try something like this? http://puu.sh/9XSQz/6dfb8b7d1a.jpg - it feels a lot better to play imo
00:34:910 (4,5,6) - I think this plays better and it follows the vocals better as well - http://puu.sh/9XYgt/69f810e671.jpg
00:49:481 (5,1) - small thing but you could make this look nicer - http://puu.sh/9Y91t/8e2bd43a87.jpg
01:07:339 (4,5) - this plays a little weird, maybe because you start the slider on the red tick, maybe you could try this - http://puu.sh/9Y9iv/2450d1502b.jpg or this - http://puu.sh/9Y9ne/2e4009cd45.jpg
02:05:196 (1,2) - again small thing but you could make this look nicer - http://puu.sh/9Y9Az/9f87bb55d2.jpg
02:09:196 (2,1,2) - I think you could improve the flow here because of this http://puu.sh/9Y9Ie/748a09894b.jpg - so I would suggest you to do something like this - http://puu.sh/9Y9KR/0d063beee0.jpg - http://puu.sh/9Y9P7/9318cb066f.jpg
02:21:767 (6,1) - again a small thing but this would look nicer if (6) and (1) didn't reach :P like this: http://puu.sh/9Y9VM/a61c547258.jpg and afterwards you can just change 02:22:910 (3) - accordingly --> https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1787376
02:32:910 (1,2) - again nazi stuff but you can also make this look nicer: http://puu.sh/9Yadj/727c2db2ff.jpg nn, will keep it like this tehe
02:50:624 (6) - this is similar to what I have said at the beginning, put it here 02:50:481 - it follows the vocals better (and this part isn't so loud anyway so following the vocals would be better in my opinion) change it reverse slider :3
03:28:196 - add hit circle? it might play better, it follow the vocals better so it won't feel empty
03:30:624 (4) - you should shorten this slider because there is a big beat in the middle of the slider that you don't hit and it feels weird to play, try a reverse slider maybe? - http://puu.sh/9YaMo/bcd1511067.jpg or this - http://puu.sh/9YaRZ/9e5d1c6caa.jpg
03:39:910 (1) - add finish to the beginning of the slider, it fits to the song
03:41:767 (6) - this is confusing and it would also fit better if you added a hit circle instead of the last repeat because it plays better and there is a big beat that should be emphasized with a hit circle - http://puu.sh/9Yb1h/0f20df1b4b.jpg (and add finish to the hit circle)

Insane:

00:21:481 (2) - this is only my opinion but while playing this confused me, so unstack it? http://puu.sh/9YcwI/dae11cf7df.jpg - I think it will still flow nicely and it won't be confusing, but of course it's an insane so "confusing" is not that big of a reason, it's up to you :P
00:34:910 (6) - add new combo because this feels like it's similar to 00:36:053 (1) - but you didn't place a nc so to make it consistent I would recommend to add nc
01:33:196 (1,2) - nazi but blanket could be improved here - http://puu.sh/9Yd5E/148496128f.jpg
02:06:339 (5) - why don't you shorten this and add a hit circle? it will fit better to the vocals, and this is an insane anyway so it's not a problem and you can also hear a beat in the music in the middle of the slider, so it will fit nicely imo :3 - http://puu.sh/9Ydma/e003db72c8.jpg not bad idea but I still like it like this :3
02:10:624 (4,1) - I personally don't really like the flow here because - http://puu.sh/9YdZF/c9fbde6bb6.jpg - so you could try a little bit different pattern maybe? well just an example: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1787500 and http://puu.sh/9Yeei/0d56b68839.jpg try to change 2nd one with my way
03:01:910 (3) - nazi again but put this a few grids down to make it a nicer blanket - http://puu.sh/9Yerj/1fcf8f4c79.jpg
03:41:910 (4) - try this http://puu.sh/9YeBn/3682bd6796.jpg - it feels better to play because the music has a loud sound there which should be emphasized with a hit circle and not with a slider end, it feels good to hit it (also add finish to the hit circle) dunno why I want it reverse xD

Hitsounds:
Add finish to the beginning of the sliders (or hit circles), because you can hear loud sounds in the music too and there some a bigger emphasis in the vocals too at these places:
00:02:767 (4) -
00:03:910 (1) -
00:05:053 (4) -
00:07:339 (4) -
00:08:481 (1) -
00:09:624 (1) -
00:11:910 (1) -
00:13:053 (1) -
00:14:196 (1) -
00:15:339 (1) -
00:16:481 (1) -
00:17:624 (1) -
as I said before I want keep this part just whistle (:3

00:19:196 (1,2) - use soft sampleset on these objects, because the music isn't loud here, so normal sampleset doesn't sound nice

00:22:196 (1) - add finish to the beginning of the slider because of the reason I have already mentioned nah
00:26:767 (1) - ^ ^
02:08:481 (6) - ^ ^
03:39:910 (1) - ^

That's all for insane, it's a pretty nice diff, I enjoyed playing it!

Demise:
00:26:767 (1,2) - this doesn't look nice imo (in my opinion) so try to place it differently, example: http://puu.sh/9YhVc/046def9d69.jpg
00:41:767 (1) - this would flow better imo if it had a different direction, like this: http://puu.sh/9Yi5w/2f81c2af52.jpg
02:12:767 (6,1) - try to avoid overlaps like this, they don't look nice imo >.< this looks a lot better :3 http://puu.sh/9YiEY/3959db9a22.jpg
02:56:410 - add hit circle? there is a soft but fast sound in the music, so I think adding a hit circle here would fit pretty well but the current seems more fit to follow vocal :''
02:59:839 - same as above ^ add hit circle ^
03:47:196 (2,3) - I this doesn't flow well, so I would suggest this - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1787658 - because http://puu.sh/9YjbV/49180439c5.jpg --> http://puu.sh/9YjfG/3eb0833031.jpg

Hitsounds:
Add finish to the beginning of these sliders, same reason that I said in the Insane difficulty
00:02:767 (1) -
00:03:910 (1) -
00:05:053 (1) -
00:07:339 (1) -
etc...I think you know what I mean so try to follow these just like on Insane, but if it's unclear just ask me and I'll try to point out all of them!
same as in insane lol
00:19:196 (3,4) - use soft sampleset (similar to what I've already mentioned in the previous diff)


I can't really say anything else about this difficulty, I'm too noob to play it X_X it's fine :''3

I hope my mod will be helpful, good luck!

Gaia wrote:

Heey~ From my queue

[General]
I think Insane with 4.2 stars to suddenly jump to an extra of 5.5 is too big o-o Just my 2 cents so yea I guess it's fine since extra diff orz

[Hard]
00:15:339 (4) - bend towards the left instead of right?
00:17:624 (4) - Curve this more I don't like it's too curve xD
00:26:767 (1,2) - ^ ^
01:37:767 (1) - quite a jump even for hard
02:09:767 (1) - Ctrl + G fixed from Mystyk's mod
02:16:481 (4) - Why not curve this? cuz it will seems boring
02:23:339 (4) - ^ ^
02:23:767 (5) - not mirror with 02:22:910 (3) - indeed
02:27:910 (1) - not perfect ;w;
02:57:624 (4) - Curve inside (left)?
02:59:910 (4) - curve this maybe no
03:08:339 (2,3,4) - keep the same ds already?
03:30:624 (4) - NC here instead?
03:31:196 (1) - so no nc here if u take ^
03:34:196 (3) - curve more? nah
03:42:339 (1) - this is pretty short.. xD

[Insane]
00:58:196 (6) - stack with 00:56:339 (5) - it will have weird spacing imo
01:09:053 (1) - shape looks awkward lol always forgot to change this
01:40:910 (4) - ctrl + g? no
01:42:339 (1) - curve more? ^
01:43:481 (1) - ^ ^
01:49:767 (3) - Ctrl + G ^
01:54:481 (3) - unnecessary overlap it's hard to place it in another place
02:02:624 (8) - Ctrl + G no
02:17:624 (1) - end this further up http://puu.sh/9YjDS/3d95b7b348.jpg move it a bit up
02:18:767 (1) - sth like this? http://puu.sh/9Yk0k/6a44850f9e.jpg nice but I don't want :'3
02:47:481 (1) - Music gets softer here so u could slow down SV to 0.75x or sth? um.. nah
02:53:481 (1,2,3) - Not parallel indeed
02:49:624 (1) - blanket no
02:52:339 (2,4) - ^ ^
03:03:767 (2) - Ctrl + G ^
03:15:481 (3) - ^ ^
03:42:339 (1) - a bit short wanna keep it like in hard diff

[Demise]
00:02:767 (1) - curve more honestly I don't really like too curve slider :''
00:06:910 (3) - (44,44) or sth? nah ;A;
00:08:053 (3) - (160, 352) ? ^ (these 2 are just suggestions) ^
00:09:624 (1) - blanket? ^
00:19:053 (2,4) - put it somewhere like (296, 192) and blanket with 00:19:196 (3) - wanna keep it like this
00:23:339 (1) - Ctrl + G looks weird orz
00:36:339 (2,4,5,6) - weird shape. (4,5,6) is triangle and nothing to do with (2) o.o
00:41:767 (1) - blanket
01:05:053 (7,8,9) - Ctrl + G
01:06:767 (1) - blanket more no
01:07:910 (1) - ^ no
01:09:053 (1) - ^ no
01:52:481 (6) - crooked shape (and stack with 01:53:696 (7) -) so (448,240) weird for me :''(
02:07:767 (2) - Ctrl + G no
02:14:196 (1) - curve more? ^
02:54:196 (1) - blanket this more
03:10:481 (2) - put in middle? (256, 192) move a bit by myself
03:20:481 (1) - not good mirror of 03:20:767 (2) - (Ctrl + >)
03:51:481 (3) - Don't think you need this why?

Fun jumps ^^ GL with ur map!
thanks a lot both of you XD
Celizavia
NM~

Normal
  1. 00:05:624 considering adding a 1/2 reversed slider here? it follows the vocals though
  2. 00:30:053(2,3,4) those beats didnt follows the vocals, i think 1/2 sliders at 00:29:910 and the rest http://puu.sh/a2tKE/69943c98f7.jpg
  3. 00:32:481 add a 1/2 slider here to fill akeward gap?
  4. 00:36:053 ^
  5. 00:58:339 ^
  6. 00:58:624(1) i think u should move it too 00:58:767, the vocals suits there better
  7. 01:00:339(3) Same issues, move to 01:00:053
  8. 01:17:767 add a note here? a beat would be nice to make the players expected that was there
    same issues towards this diffs, so i pointed out a few


Hard

  • seems nice to me


hope this little mod helps a bit :)
Topic Starter
Yasora

Celizavia wrote:

NM~

Normal
  1. 00:05:624 considering adding a 1/2 reversed slider here? it follows the vocals though trying to avoid 1/2 in here (since bpm is high)
  2. 00:30:053(2,3,4) those beats didnt follows the vocals, i think 1/2 sliders at 00:29:910 and the rest http://puu.sh/a2tKE/69943c98f7.jpg ik, but it will more easier for normal :3
  3. 00:32:481 add a 1/2 slider here to fill akeward gap? mm I guess more better if changed (2) into slider
  4. 00:36:053 ^ same as 00:05:624
  5. 00:58:339 ^ ^
  6. 00:58:624(1) i think u should move it too 00:58:767, the vocals suits there better ^
  7. 01:00:339(3) Same issues, move to 01:00:053 same as 00:32:481
  8. 01:17:767 add a note here? a beat would be nice to make the players expected that was there
    same issues towards this diffs, so i pointed out a few


Hard

  • seems nice to me


hope this little mod helps a bit :)
thank you!
Mao
Modding this soon~
-Nya-
Hey! I modded your Normal and Hard.
Well, here's my mod:

Normal:
1) 00:14:339~ Remove NC here, and then add NC here: 00:15:481.
2) 00:18:910~ I suggest rather straightening this slider, so that it looks something like this:

It'll support the previous sliders more. Remember to also keep distance snap in mind if you decide to make this change.
3) 00:34:624~ NC here, and then remove NC here: 00:35:196.
4) 00:44:910~ NC here, and then remove NC here: 00:45:481.
5) 01:05:196~ Maybe NC here?
6) 01:21:481~ NC here. (It'll fit in with the music better)
7) 01:23:481~ NC here, then it will be like this hitcircle: 01:28:053.
8) 01:38:624~ NC here, and then remove NC here: 01:39:196.
9) 01:42:624~ Remove NC here, and then add NC here: 01:43:196.
10) 01:48:910~ NC here, and then remove NC here: 01:49:481.
11) 02:09:767~ Maybe NC here?
12) 02:26:624~ NC here.
13) 02:28:624~ NC here.
14) 02:51:481~ NC here, and then remove NC here: 02:52:053.
15) 03:00:624~ Maybe NC here?
16) 03:23:481~ NC here.
17) 03:40:910~ NC here.
I know it's a lot of new combo suggestions, but it's just my opinion.

Hard:
1) 00:15:339~ NC here.
2) 00:17:624~ NC here.
3) 00:18:910~ I suggest removing this slider and this hitcircle: 00:19:624 and replacing them with a spinner that reaches this point: 00:19:624. (It's just my opinion.)
4) 00:21:053~ NC here.
5) 00:23:339~ NC here.
6) 00:25:624~ NC here.
7) 00:27:910~ NC here.
8) 01:01:196~ Maybe NC here as well?
9) 01:04:767~ NC here.
10) 01:23:767~ I don't really like this triplet. Maybe a repetitive slider instead?
Like this:

11) 02:21:053~ NC here.
12) 02:24:339~ Remove NC here, and then add NC here: 02:24:481.
13) 02:26:767~ NC here.
14) 02:28:910~ A repetitive slider instead?
Like this again:

Just my opinion.
15) 02:50:767~ Remove NC here, and then add NC here: 02:51:910.
16) 03:23:767~ Repetitive slider again instead?
17) 03:29:624~ Add a hitcircle here? (The flow sort of gets disrupted without a hitcircle at that point)
18) 03:41:767~ NC here.

Well, that's that.
Very good mapset so far. Keep it up!
Good Luck! :D
Topic Starter
Yasora

LizeKotze wrote:

Hey! I modded your Normal and Hard.
Well, here's my mod:

Normal:
1) 00:14:339~ Remove NC here, and then add NC here: 00:15:481. no, cuz I make previous and next combo (1-5) so.. :3
2) 00:18:910~ I suggest rather straightening this slider, so that it looks something like this:

It'll support the previous sliders more. Remember to also keep distance snap in mind if you decide to make this change.
3) 00:34:624~ NC here, and then remove NC here: 00:35:196. same as 00:14:339
4) 00:44:910~ NC here, and then remove NC here: 00:45:481. ^
5) 01:05:196~ Maybe NC here? no need imo
6) 01:21:481~ NC here. (It'll fit in with the music better)
7) 01:23:481~ NC here, then it will be like this hitcircle: 01:28:053. um, will keep it non-nc
8) 01:38:624~ NC here, and then remove NC here: 01:39:196. no
9) 01:42:624~ Remove NC here, and then add NC here: 01:43:196. ^
10) 01:48:910~ NC here, and then remove NC here: 01:49:481.^
11) 02:09:767~ Maybe NC here? ^
12) 02:26:624~ NC here.
13) 02:28:624~ NC here. no
14) 02:51:481~ NC here, and then remove NC here: 02:52:053.
15) 03:00:624~ Maybe NC here? no
16) 03:23:481~ NC here. ^
17) 03:40:910~ NC here. ^
I know it's a lot of new combo suggestions, but it's just my opinion.

Hard:
1) 00:15:339~ NC here.
2) 00:17:624~ NC here.
3) 00:18:910~ I suggest removing this slider and this hitcircle: 00:19:624 and replacing them with a spinner that reaches this point: 00:19:624. (It's just my opinion.) I don't think it's fit orz
4) 00:21:053~ NC here. no
5) 00:23:339~ NC here. ^
6) 00:25:624~ NC here. ^
7) 00:27:910~ NC here. ^
8) 01:01:196~ Maybe NC here as well? ^
9) 01:04:767~ NC here. ^
10) 01:23:767~ I don't really like this triplet. Maybe a repetitive slider instead? k since some people bothering with this :''v
Like this:

11) 02:21:053~ NC here. ^
12) 02:24:339~ Remove NC here, and then add NC here: 02:24:481. ^
13) 02:26:767~ NC here. ^
14) 02:28:910~ A repetitive slider instead?
Like this again:

Just my opinion.
15) 02:50:767~ Remove NC here, and then add NC here: 02:51:910. no
16) 03:23:767~ Repetitive slider again instead?
17) 03:29:624~ Add a hitcircle here? (The flow sort of gets disrupted without a hitcircle at that point) changed it w/ another way
18) 03:41:767~ NC here. no

Well, that's that.
Very good mapset so far. Keep it up!
Good Luck! :D
thank you!

hell ya new page combo
Mao


Mod request by ingame PM making a new post to make it better for you to reply :V


  1. Unrankable Issue/Highly Suggested
  2. Comment/Opinion
General
  1. Clean :3
Normal
  1. Please let the spinners after the Kiais start 1/2 earlier since the sound starts there and you just didn't do that in the other diffs since you've mapped the tick by another hitobject. But being blank here makes the spinner feel late.
  2. 00:04:624 (2) - Perhaps you can move this a bit lower to improve the flow here since this would cause a way smoother cursor movement.
  3. 00:11:481 (2) - Move this to 165|170 to get a better flow from 00:10:767 (1) - 's curve into the object due to it following the Slider's path (:
  4. 00:19:624 - I'm not sure if it's just me but I'd add a note here in order to 1. Cover the drums as well as the Voclas here and to 2. get the polarity better which would make it much more readable here imo.
  5. 00:24:339 (3) - The Music here is basically the same as at 00:19:910 (1) - where you've mapped the red tick which would feel here way better as well if you ask me since ignoring this red tick feels so off >.<
  6. 00:57:481 (2,3,4) - /Minor/ - Try to move these a bit to the upper right to get them into a line in order to improve the flow slightly.
  7. 01:03:481 (2) - The rhythm here sounds so extremely weird since you've mapped the ticks with the smallest emphasis on them. There's almost nothing played neither by instruments nor vocals on these ticks. Maybe you can try somthing like:
  8. 01:10:053 (1) - Perhaps you can move this a bit to the lower left for a better following of the curve with the Slider to improve the overall movement.
  9. 01:19:196 (3) - Meh, too low Ds to the previous object considering your normal DS is 1,00.
  10. 01:35:767 (1) - Check your DS.
  11. 01:36:624 (2) - This comes a bit rapid if you ask me which ruins the flow of the pattern. Try to move it lower so that you have a fluent transition from the previous slider into it.
  12. 01:40:053 (2) - Maybe it's just me but ignoring the beat here feels pretty weird since the note on it is rather strong. If you can agree with me try something like this.
  13. 02:03:767 (2) - DS to the next object is quite high
  14. 02:58:339 (2) - /Minor/ - Why isn't this placed on the coordinate's origin which is 256|192? Also the symmetry between 02:56:624 (1,3) - is messed up as you can see if you CTRL+H
  15. 02:58:910 (3) - The rhythm here sounds really messed up since there's nothing on the big white tick that could be mapped which makes it sound off since the tick where the instruments are is 1/2 before.
  16. 03:20:053 (2) - Even out your Spacing here
  17. Sorry for the nazi mod but as Mystyk already said, this is way better to adjust the diff. Also I don't know, the song provides a very hard to map rhythm but some parts of the rhythm you've mapped are not reasonable to me. If I'm wrong (maybe because I'm tired) call me ingame and we can discuss that a bit.

    ► All suggestions mentioned for the original parts go for copy & pasted (and maybe slightly changed) parts as well so that I don't have to repeat myself ;b
Hard
  1. 00:15:339 (4) - /Minor/ - Try to move this note more right to get a fluent transition by letting it follow the slider's track.
  2. 00:18:910 (1) - /Highly Suggested/ - Meh, the rhythm here is so weird due to some important notes being ignored. I've provided a suggestion in the Screenshot below. First of all that 1/2 Slider follows the Instrument, the 1/1 Slider then follows the Hold of the Vocals. I don't really understand what you were following here...it sounds so unfitting ;_;
  3. 00:29:767 (2) - Hm, this sound seems rather unimportant to me since it's really quiet and not that recognizable while playing other than the red ticks next to it. These are kinda strong which makes it feel weird that you've ignored them. I'd go for something as seen below since it represents the instruments as well as the vocals and drums way better here. (This stuff happens all over the section and makes it rhythm feel rather weird to me but since you are consistent with it should make it okay :/)
  4. 00:35:767 (7) - Perhaps you can move this a bit to the right like this to improve the flow into 1 by giving the player a smooth transition.
  5. 00:39:767 (4) - Maybe it's just me but a CTRL+H'd version of this would flow way better in my eyes
  6. 00:49:767 (1) - This would be pretty neat if you could rearrange it a bit so that it forms a pentagon with the previous objects. Just an idea here, nothing you have to apply but it would be cool imo (:
  7. 01:13:196 (3) - Maybe you can try to relocate this a bit to get an oval-/"O"-shaped Pattern with 01:13:481 (4,5) - here.
  8. 01:18:910 (1,2) - The transition here plays really harsh since it's not really fluent but a bit rapid instead if you ask me. The are two ways to change this to improve the flow: 1. Get a wavy movement by placing a CTRL+J'd verion of the Slider or 2. Rotate the Slider and get a circular movement.

  9. 01:21:910 - Considering that you've always mapped drums or vocals on beats like this I'd do it here as well for the sake of consistency.
  10. 01:27:767 (1,2) - /Comment/ - Well, if you already place a finish on 2's tail then don't you agree that the note is so strong that it should be clicked? If you want to, please try [url=http://puu.sh/a5cOH/bccb20b76f.jpg]this[/ulr].
  11. 01:42:053 (5,1) - Maybe it's just me but I think the higher DS between these two doesn't really make sense since 1 isn't that strong that it would need such a special emphasis :<
  12. 01:46:910 (1) - A symmetrical Slider would fit the symmetrical pattern very well, don't you think so? :3 Try out the code :b
    316,44,106910,6,0,B|260:28|260:28|188:52,1,120,2|8,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
  13. 02:05:624 (2) - /Minor/ - First of all adjust the spacing a bit. It looks like it's touching the previous slider which doesn't really fit the hard as you've used gaps between all the Objects. Second thing is that I'd personally place 02:05:624 (2,3) - higher so that it's easier to play considering the player has to turn downwards pretty fast here.
  14. 02:15:339 (1) - Hm, the jump felt rather unintuitive to me due to the unexpected fast tapping here. Well, you could make it a bit more natural if you'd flip it vertically to make the transition not almost horizontal since this feels pretty rough ;w;
  15. 02:32:910 (1,2) - Same as I've said for 01:27:767 (1,2) -
  16. 02:47:481 (1) - /Highly Suggested/ - I was extremely surprised after the break to have this sharp turn at the start of the Slider x-x Please consider to try something not so "steep". I recommend you to change this since it was really unexpected to play. (My suggestion would be this but I guess you can do something better there than I can :V)
  17. 02:53:053 (1) - Uhm, what happened to this Slider? Why the hell is it 5/4, that doesn't make sense within the music here...
  18. 03:23:481 (2,3) - Try to get a bigger spacing between these since it looks kinda weird ingame due to Stack Leniency.
  19. Very well done flow. Love this diff <3
Insane
  1. 00:12:910 (4) - Put this to 420|289 to 1. get it into a line with 00:12:767 (3,4,1) - which would look way better and 2. to get due to this line the flow into 00:13:053 (1) - more intuitive.
  2. 00:17:196 (3,4,5,1) - Get the Spacing consistent here to improve the square. (Place 5 at 385|62)
  3. 00:18:053 (2,3) - Maybe it's just me but I'd actually switch them for a better flow due to a smoother turn from 1 into 2 as seen on the arrows in the Screenshot below.
  4. 00:34:481 (4) - Consider to place that at 282|340 to improve the jump into 00:34:624 (5) - by giving the playera lower range of moving to the left so that he has to focus more onto the jump upwards which would improve the flow a lot here.
  5. 00:43:196 (2,3,4) - Wah, the wavy movement between 2 and 4 over 3 feels really odd. Try to place 00:43:481 (3) - at 244|211 to improve the flow here a lot! <:
  6. 01:02:339 (5,6,7) - The flow here didn't work that well to me to be honst :< The problem is that 01:02:910 (7) - is slowing the player down since s/he expects a zigzag pattern here, but for a zigzag pattern 01:02:910 (7) - should be lower. So either you put 01:02:767 (6,7) - in a line with 5's tail or place 7 lower, like this.
  7. 01:08:624 (4) - Perhaps you can place this a bit higher to let its track follow the curve provided by 01:08:339 (2,3) - for a smoother flow here.
  8. 01:14:624 (4) - I know that this is part of a triangle but I'd suggest you to move it more right to introduce the jump to the right better. As it is now it feels really unexpected and unnatural to me :/
  9. 01:34:053 (3,4,5) - Please even out the spacing here since there's no reason for the spacing between 3 and 4 being bigger than the one between 4 and 5 since 5 is the strongest beat here. The second thing I'd like you to do is not having the curve the circles are placed in so strong as this kills the flow here for me and makes it play weird. To solve both Problems place 01:34:339 (5) - at 378|268.
  10. 01:37:053 (6,7) - The rhythm here sounds really messed up due to 01:37:339 - being ignored but the quiet 01:37:196 - being mapped. Try to CTRL+G them in terms of rhythm. (You can also leave the placement as it is after CTRL+G'ing since the flow is actually pretty good like this o-o)
  11. 01:42:767 (2) - Meh, try to CTRL+J this for an intuitive wavy movement here.
  12. 02:11:624 (4) - Try to rotate this about 25° (Selection Centre) to improve the flow here. The transition slows the player down in order to get the tail right which makes it feel pretty harsh.
  13. 02:48:481 (1) - /Minor/ - Consider to move the last anchor point of this Slider to 424|464 in order to make it face 02:48:910 (2) - directly to get a smooth flow into it.
  14. 03:34:624 (1,2,3,4,5) - /Comment/ - As you can see if you CTRL+H, the symmetry is messed up. Since I have no idea if this was intentional I'll mark this as a comment~
  15. Nice Insane, very clean :3 Not much to say here :V Don't forget to check the copy&pasted sections yourself though.


    ► All suggestions mentioned for the original parts go for copy & pasted (and maybe slightly changed) parts as well so that I don't have to repeat myself ;b
Demise
  1. 00:06:053 (8,1) - The transition between this two object slows the player down which feel unnatural due to the emphasis on (1). Consider to enlarge the spacing to 1,7 or 1,8 as you did for the previous ones. You could also try to rearrange the pattern like this by using rotated Sliders (:
  2. 00:11:196 (2) - Why does this Slider have 4 Anchorpoints? I don't really see a reason for this here tbh. Try to get a normal 3 anchor point curve here and maybe adjust it a bit as seen in the Screenshot below for a better flow into the following Curve.
  3. 00:16:053 (3,4,5) - Meh, the rhythm feels a bit weird since there's no sound at 00:16:196 - . Mapping this with a Circle feels so wrong. If you really want to keep it map it at least with a Slider's Tail but I'd prefer a 1/1 Slider as seen in the Screenshot below.
  4. 00:19:910 (1) - Try to move this slightly to the lower right as seen in the Screenshot to adjust the flow from 00:19:624 (4) - into this here. This would also create a neat circular shape together with 00:19:196 (3) - !
  5. 00:28:624 (3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - Your Spacing is kinda messed up. Try to adjust it a bit since it looks a bit messy >.<
  6. 00:33:767 (1,2,3) - Try to listen closely to the music here. Maybe you can agree that there's a way louder note at 00:33:981 - instead of 00:33:839 - so it makes this sound really weird.
  7. 00:37:910 (5,6,7) - Please consider to reduce the spacing of this triplet since this plays really bad due to the so fast unintuitive movement because there wasn't such fast triplet movement on similiar parts in this section before ;_; Maybe it's just me though :/
  8. 00:46:339 (2) - Try to make the curve a bit stronger here (so that it looks like a 90° rotation of 00:46:624 (3) - ) to 1. make the turn a bit stronger as well to give a better feeling for the following objects and 2. to make this not look that much like 00:46:053 (4) - since that looks a bit "blocky" to me.
  9. 00:51:910 (1,2,3) - perhaps you can move this a bit higher so that the Slider's curve follows the movement of the previous objects for a smoother flow here.
  10. 00:56:124 (5,6) - The spacing between these two notes is 0,30 larger than the spacing of the overall stream which makes the notes just touch so slightly. This looks really messy so please fix the spacing here :/
  11. 01:20:767 (2) - Try to move this a bit higher (somewhere around 200|280) so that 1 points onto the slider which would result into a more fluent turn downwards.
  12. 01:22:767 (1) - /Minor/ - I don't know if this shape is on purpose but I'd definitely adjust it so that it is a smooth wave shape. Try to keep the first and the third line parallel to do that.
  13. 01:23:481 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - Messed up stream spacing, this looks very very messy so I'm marking this as highly suggested. Try either to use a constant distance snap or "Convert Slider to Stream". (Not going to list this for further streams, check them yourself please ^^")
  14. 01:27:767 (1,3) - /Minor/ - If you CTRL+H them and see that the symmetry is messed up. If it was thought to be symmetrical please fix this :/ (Same goes for 02:32:910 (1,3) - )
  15. 01:38:053 (4,5,6,7) - It would be really cool if you could rearrange them a bit as a Square. Nothing you have to fix, just an idea to tidy the pattern up a bit (:
  16. 01:42:053 (5) - I'm not sure if it's just me but I think the really strong curve shape doesn't fit the shape of 01:41:624 (2) - which makes this look a bit out of place :V Maybe you could try to replace it with a 30° rotated version of 01:41:624 (2) - ?
  17. 01:51:196 (7) - Hm, the short spacing here doesn't work for me since it slows me down due to that rather fast movement between 01:50:910 (5,6) - . Please consider to CTRL+G 01:51:196 (7) - . That would fit the pattern way better and would also even out the spacing a bit! c:
  18. 01:54:910 (5,6,7) - Maybe you can try to use a bigger spacing to 01:55:339 (1) - in order to make the movement more natural after the stop for the triplet. I had actually trouble with playing that due to the really slowing down low spacing here ;/
  19. 02:06:696 (3) - Maybe it's just me but I'd rather see this Circle at 02:06:553 - sinced the note there in terms of the drums is way stronger so that it feels weird to ignore such a "strong" (it isn't that strong but stronger than the other one) but map such a quiet noise :/
  20. 02:10:910 (1) - As you might agree with me the note at 02:10:910 - is really strong since it's the start of the kiai so why don't you emphasize it by giving it a bigger spacing from 02:10:910 (1) - ? All the previous ones had a bigger spacing even though they weren't such important notes which makes this feel pretty weird :/
  21. 02:16:481 (1) - In my opinion this shape doesn't really fit the other ones in the Kiai as you've mostly used curved or line#ish shapes for your Slider.
  22. 02:27:624 (5,6,7) - /Minor/ - Messed up 1/4 Spacing looks really ugly ingame :V
  23. 03:00:196 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1) - Just an idea here: How about placing these in a giant triangle by moving 03:00:339 (2,4,5) - to y:92 and by lowering the positions of 03:00:910 (6,1) - like this. That would be really cool imo! (:
  24. 03:07:481 (4,5,6) - This comes way too rapid after the pretty big jump from 03:07:339 (3) - which makes the play pretty bad. The reason why it is so rapid is that it goes back left in such a small angle. It would be way more intuitive if you'd left it go to the right with a wider range for the player to react.
  25. 03:14:839 (4,5) - If you listen closely you can hear the there is no sound (or such a quiet unrecognizable one) where you've mapped 4 and 5. I'd suggest a 1/1 Slider starting at 3's position to cover the vocal's hold for a way better feeling rhythm here.
  26. 03:33:910 (4) - Move this to 180|320 for: 1. An Improval in flow because now the Slider track follows the curve of the previous Circles as seen here and 2. to create an equal triangle with 03:34:196 (1,2) - as well as a diamond including these and 03:33:767 (3) - .
  27. You've done an overall great job on this diff. Even though that some patterns need to be tidied up imo. (:

Please reply! I hope it was helpful and good luck! :3
Topic Starter
Yasora

Mao wrote:



Mod request by ingame PM making a new post to make it better for you to reply :V


  1. Unrankable Issue/Highly Suggested
  2. Comment/Opinion
General
  1. Clean :3
Normal
  1. Please let the spinners after the Kiais start 1/2 earlier since the sound starts there and you just didn't do that in the other diffs since you've mapped the tick by another hitobject. But being blank here makes the spinner feel late.
  2. 00:04:624 (2) - Perhaps you can move this a bit lower to improve the flow here since this would cause a way smoother cursor movement.
  3. 00:11:481 (2) - Move this to 165|170 to get a better flow from 00:10:767 (1) - 's curve into the object due to it following the Slider's path (:
  4. 00:19:624 - I'm not sure if it's just me but I'd add a note here in order to 1. Cover the drums as well as the Voclas here and to 2. get the polarity better which would make it much more readable here imo.
  5. 00:24:339 (3) - The Music here is basically the same as at 00:19:910 (1) - where you've mapped the red tick which would feel here way better as well if you ask me since ignoring this red tick feels so off >.<
  6. 00:57:481 (2,3,4) - /Minor/ - Try to move these a bit to the upper right to get them into a line in order to improve the flow slightly.
  7. 01:03:481 (2) - The rhythm here sounds so extremely weird since you've mapped the ticks with the smallest emphasis on them. There's almost nothing played neither by instruments nor vocals on these ticks. Maybe you can try somthing like:
  8. 01:10:053 (1) - Perhaps you can move this a bit to the lower left for a better following of the curve with the Slider to improve the overall movement.
  9. 01:19:196 (3) - Meh, too low Ds to the previous object considering your normal DS is 1,00.
  10. 01:35:767 (1) - Check your DS.
  11. 01:36:624 (2) - This comes a bit rapid if you ask me which ruins the flow of the pattern. Try to move it lower so that you have a fluent transition from the previous slider into it.
  12. 01:40:053 (2) - Maybe it's just me but ignoring the beat here feels pretty weird since the note on it is rather strong. If you can agree with me try something like this.
  13. 02:03:767 (2) - DS to the next object is quite high
  14. 02:58:339 (2) - /Minor/ - Why isn't this placed on the coordinate's origin which is 256|192? Also the symmetry between 02:56:624 (1,3) - is messed up as you can see if you CTRL+H
  15. 02:58:910 (3) - The rhythm here sounds really messed up since there's nothing on the big white tick that could be mapped which makes it sound off since the tick where the instruments are is 1/2 before.
  16. 03:20:053 (2) - Even out your Spacing here
  17. Sorry for the nazi mod but as Mystyk already said, this is way better to adjust the diff. Also I don't know, the song provides a very hard to map rhythm but some parts of the rhythm you've mapped are not reasonable to me. If I'm wrong (maybe because I'm tired) call me ingame and we can discuss that a bit.

    ► All suggestions mentioned for the original parts go for copy & pasted (and maybe slightly changed) parts as well so that I don't have to repeat myself ;b
Hard
  1. 00:15:339 (4) - /Minor/ - Try to move this note more right to get a fluent transition by letting it follow the slider's track.
  2. 00:18:910 (1) - /Highly Suggested/ - Meh, the rhythm here is so weird due to some important notes being ignored. I've provided a suggestion in the Screenshot below. First of all that 1/2 Slider follows the Instrument, the 1/1 Slider then follows the Hold of the Vocals. I don't really understand what you were following here...it sounds so unfitting ;_;
  3. 00:29:767 (2) - Hm, this sound seems rather unimportant to me since it's really quiet and not that recognizable while playing other than the red ticks next to it. These are kinda strong which makes it feel weird that you've ignored them. I'd go for something as seen below since it represents the instruments as well as the vocals and drums way better here. (This stuff happens all over the section and makes it rhythm feel rather weird to me but since you are consistent with it should make it okay :/)
  4. 00:35:767 (7) - Perhaps you can move this a bit to the right like this to improve the flow into 1 by giving the player a smooth transition.
  5. 00:39:767 (4) - Maybe it's just me but a CTRL+H'd version of this would flow way better in my eyes
  6. 00:49:767 (1) - This would be pretty neat if you could rearrange it a bit so that it forms a pentagon with the previous objects. Just an idea here, nothing you have to apply but it would be cool imo (:
  7. 01:13:196 (3) - Maybe you can try to relocate this a bit to get an oval-/"O"-shaped Pattern with 01:13:481 (4,5) - here.
  8. 01:18:910 (1,2) - The transition here plays really harsh since it's not really fluent but a bit rapid instead if you ask me. The are two ways to change this to improve the flow: 1. Get a wavy movement by placing a CTRL+J'd verion of the Slider or 2. Rotate the Slider and get a circular movement.

  9. 01:21:910 - Considering that you've always mapped drums or vocals on beats like this I'd do it here as well for the sake of consistency.
  10. 01:27:767 (1,2) - /Comment/ - Well, if you already place a finish on 2's tail then don't you agree that the note is so strong that it should be clicked? If you want to, please try [url=http://puu.sh/a5cOH/bccb20b76f.jpg]this[/ulr]. seems weird for me :<
  11. 01:42:053 (5,1) - Maybe it's just me but I think the higher DS between these two doesn't really make sense since 1 isn't that strong that it would need such a special emphasis :<
  12. 01:46:910 (1) - A symmetrical Slider would fit the symmetrical pattern very well, don't you think so? :3 Try out the code :b
    316,44,106910,6,0,B|260:28|260:28|188:52,1,120,2|8,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
  13. 02:05:624 (2) - /Minor/ - First of all adjust the spacing a bit. It looks like it's touching the previous slider which doesn't really fit the hard as you've used gaps between all the Objects. Second thing is that I'd personally place 02:05:624 (2,3) - higher so that it's easier to play considering the player has to turn downwards pretty fast here.
  14. 02:15:339 (1) - Hm, the jump felt rather unintuitive to me due to the unexpected fast tapping here. Well, you could make it a bit more natural if you'd flip it vertically to make the transition not almost horizontal since this feels pretty rough ;w;
  15. 02:32:910 (1,2) - Same as I've said for 01:27:767 (1,2) - same too
  16. 02:47:481 (1) - /Highly Suggested/ - I was extremely surprised after the break to have this sharp turn at the start of the Slider x-x Please consider to try something not so "steep". I recommend you to change this since it was really unexpected to play. (My suggestion would be this but I guess you can do something better there than I can :V)
  17. 02:53:053 (1) - Uhm, what happened to this Slider? Why the hell is it 5/4, that doesn't make sense within the music here...
  18. 03:23:481 (2,3) - Try to get a bigger spacing between these since it looks kinda weird ingame due to Stack Leniency.
  19. Very well done flow. Love this diff <3
Insane
  1. 00:12:910 (4) - Put this to 420|289 to 1. get it into a line with 00:12:767 (3,4,1) - which would look way better and 2. to get due to this line the flow into 00:13:053 (1) - more intuitive.
  2. 00:17:196 (3,4,5,1) - Get the Spacing consistent here to improve the square. (Place 5 at 385|62)
  3. 00:18:053 (2,3) - Maybe it's just me but I'd actually switch them for a better flow due to a smoother turn from 1 into 2 as seen on the arrows in the Screenshot below.
  4. 00:34:481 (4) - Consider to place that at 282|340 to improve the jump into 00:34:624 (5) - by giving the playera lower range of moving to the left so that he has to focus more onto the jump upwards which would improve the flow a lot here.
  5. 00:43:196 (2,3,4) - Wah, the wavy movement between 2 and 4 over 3 feels really odd. Try to place 00:43:481 (3) - at 244|211 to improve the flow here a lot! <:
  6. 01:02:339 (5,6,7) - The flow here didn't work that well to me to be honst :< The problem is that 01:02:910 (7) - is slowing the player down since s/he expects a zigzag pattern here, but for a zigzag pattern 01:02:910 (7) - should be lower. So either you put 01:02:767 (6,7) - in a line with 5's tail or place 7 lower, like this.
  7. 01:08:624 (4) - Perhaps you can place this a bit higher to let its track follow the curve provided by 01:08:339 (2,3) - for a smoother flow here.
  8. 01:14:624 (4) - I know that this is part of a triangle but I'd suggest you to move it more right to introduce the jump to the right better. As it is now it feels really unexpected and unnatural to me :/
  9. 01:34:053 (3,4,5) - Please even out the spacing here since there's no reason for the spacing between 3 and 4 being bigger than the one between 4 and 5 since 5 is the strongest beat here. The second thing I'd like you to do is not having the curve the circles are placed in so strong as this kills the flow here for me and makes it play weird. To solve both Problems place 01:34:339 (5) - at 378|268.
  10. 01:37:053 (6,7) - The rhythm here sounds really messed up due to 01:37:339 - being ignored but the quiet 01:37:196 - being mapped. Try to CTRL+G them in terms of rhythm. (You can also leave the placement as it is after CTRL+G'ing since the flow is actually pretty good like this o-o)
  11. 01:42:767 (2) - Meh, try to CTRL+J this for an intuitive wavy movement here.
  12. 02:11:624 (4) - Try to rotate this about 25° (Selection Centre) to improve the flow here. The transition slows the player down in order to get the tail right which makes it feel pretty harsh.
  13. 02:48:481 (1) - /Minor/ - Consider to move the last anchor point of this Slider to 424|464 in order to make it face 02:48:910 (2) - directly to get a smooth flow into it. I guess y: 164 o-o
  14. 03:34:624 (1,2,3,4,5) - /Comment/ - As you can see if you CTRL+H, the symmetry is messed up. Since I have no idea if this was intentional I'll mark this as a comment~
  15. Nice Insane, very clean :3 Not much to say here :V Don't forget to check the copy&pasted sections yourself though.


    ► All suggestions mentioned for the original parts go for copy & pasted (and maybe slightly changed) parts as well so that I don't have to repeat myself ;b
Demise
  1. 00:06:053 (8,1) - The transition between this two object slows the player down which feel unnatural due to the emphasis on (1). Consider to enlarge the spacing to 1,7 or 1,8 as you did for the previous ones. You could also try to rearrange the pattern like this by using rotated Sliders (:
  2. 00:11:196 (2) - Why does this Slider have 4 Anchorpoints? I don't really see a reason for this here tbh. Try to get a normal 3 anchor point curve here and maybe adjust it a bit as seen in the Screenshot below for a better flow into the following Curve.
  3. 00:16:053 (3,4,5) - Meh, the rhythm feels a bit weird since there's no sound at 00:16:196 - . Mapping this with a Circle feels so wrong. If you really want to keep it map it at least with a Slider's Tail but I'd prefer a 1/1 Slider as seen in the Screenshot below.
  4. 00:19:910 (1) - Try to move this slightly to the lower right as seen in the Screenshot to adjust the flow from 00:19:624 (4) - into this here. This would also create a neat circular shape together with 00:19:196 (3) - !
  5. 00:28:624 (3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - Your Spacing is kinda messed up. Try to adjust it a bit since it looks a bit messy >.<
  6. 00:33:767 (1,2,3) - Try to listen closely to the music here. Maybe you can agree that there's a way louder note at 00:33:981 - instead of 00:33:839 - so it makes this sound really weird.
  7. 00:37:910 (5,6,7) - Please consider to reduce the spacing of this triplet since this plays really bad due to the so fast unintuitive movement because there wasn't such fast triplet movement on similiar parts in this section before ;_; Maybe it's just me though :/
  8. 00:46:339 (2) - Try to make the curve a bit stronger here (so that it looks like a 90° rotation of 00:46:624 (3) - ) to 1. make the turn a bit stronger as well to give a better feeling for the following objects and 2. to make this not look that much like 00:46:053 (4) - since that looks a bit "blocky" to me.
  9. 00:51:910 (1,2,3) - perhaps you can move this a bit higher so that the Slider's curve follows the movement of the previous objects for a smoother flow here.
  10. 00:56:124 (5,6) - The spacing between these two notes is 0,30 larger than the spacing of the overall stream which makes the notes just touch so slightly. This looks really messy so please fix the spacing here :/
  11. 01:20:767 (2) - Try to move this a bit higher (somewhere around 200|280) so that 1 points onto the slider which would result into a more fluent turn downwards.
  12. 01:22:767 (1) - /Minor/ - I don't know if this shape is on purpose but I'd definitely adjust it so that it is a smooth wave shape. Try to keep the first and the third line parallel to do that.
  13. 01:23:481 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - Messed up stream spacing, this looks very very messy so I'm marking this as highly suggested. Try either to use a constant distance snap or "Convert Slider to Stream". (Not going to list this for further streams, check them yourself please ^^")
  14. 01:27:767 (1,3) - /Minor/ - If you CTRL+H them and see that the symmetry is messed up. If it was thought to be symmetrical please fix this :/ (Same goes for 02:32:910 (1,3) - )
  15. 01:38:053 (4,5,6,7) - It would be really cool if you could rearrange them a bit as a Square. Nothing you have to fix, just an idea to tidy the pattern up a bit (:
  16. 01:42:053 (5) - I'm not sure if it's just me but I think the really strong curve shape doesn't fit the shape of 01:41:624 (2) - which makes this look a bit out of place :V Maybe you could try to replace it with a 30° rotated version of 01:41:624 (2) - ?
  17. 01:51:196 (7) - Hm, the short spacing here doesn't work for me since it slows me down due to that rather fast movement between 01:50:910 (5,6) - . Please consider to CTRL+G 01:51:196 (7) - . That would fit the pattern way better and would also even out the spacing a bit! c:
  18. 01:54:910 (5,6,7) - Maybe you can try to use a bigger spacing to 01:55:339 (1) - in order to make the movement more natural after the stop for the triplet. I had actually trouble with playing that due to the really slowing down low spacing here ;/
  19. 02:06:696 (3) - Maybe it's just me but I'd rather see this Circle at 02:06:553 - sinced the note there in terms of the drums is way stronger so that it feels weird to ignore such a "strong" (it isn't that strong but stronger than the other one) but map such a quiet noise :/
  20. 02:10:910 (1) - As you might agree with me the note at 02:10:910 - is really strong since it's the start of the kiai so why don't you emphasize it by giving it a bigger spacing from 02:10:910 (1) - ? All the previous ones had a bigger spacing even though they weren't such important notes which makes this feel pretty weird :/
  21. 02:16:481 (1) - In my opinion this shape doesn't really fit the other ones in the Kiai as you've mostly used curved or line#ish shapes for your Slider.
  22. 02:27:624 (5,6,7) - /Minor/ - Messed up 1/4 Spacing looks really ugly ingame :V
  23. 03:00:196 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1) - Just an idea here: How about placing these in a giant triangle by moving 03:00:339 (2,4,5) - to y:92 and by lowering the positions of 03:00:910 (6,1) - like this. That would be really cool imo! (: wait not really understand this lol
  24. 03:07:481 (4,5,6) - This comes way too rapid after the pretty big jump from 03:07:339 (3) - which makes the play pretty bad. The reason why it is so rapid is that it goes back left in such a small angle. It would be way more intuitive if you'd left it go to the right with a wider range for the player to react.
  25. 03:14:839 (4,5) - If you listen closely you can hear the there is no sound (or such a quiet unrecognizable one) where you've mapped 4 and 5. I'd suggest a 1/1 Slider starting at 3's position to cover the vocal's hold for a way better feeling rhythm here.
  26. 03:33:910 (4) - Move this to 180|320 for: 1. An Improval in flow because now the Slider track follows the curve of the previous Circles as seen here and 2. to create an equal triangle with 03:34:196 (1,2) - as well as a diamond including these and 03:33:767 (3) - .
  27. You've done an overall great job on this diff. Even though that some patterns need to be tidied up imo. (:

Please reply! I hope it was helpful and good luck! :3
thanks a lot XD
btw not yet fix anything in normal, wanna discuss it though since not really confident about dat diff :''
CelsiusLK
Hello there from my modding queue

[General]
Check letter box during breaks because your map has break time

[Demise]
00:44:624 (4) - NC
00:57:196 (4) - ^
01:38:624 (8) - NC then delete NC 01:38:910 (1) -
02:01:196 (5) - NC
02:55:910 (3) - NC

[Insane]
If my NC suggestions aren't useful ignore it
00:05:339 (1,2) - How about convert to stream?
00:32:624 (5) - NC
00:44:053 (1) - Delete NC then NC 00:44:481 (2) -
00:48:624 (1) - Delete NC then NC 00:49:053 (2) -
00:53:196 (1) - Delete NC then NC 00:53:624 (2) -
00:57:767 (5) - NC
01:00:053 (5) - ^
01:02:339 (5) - ^
01:15:910 (5) - ^
01:32:624 (2,3) - How about convert to stream?
01:34:339 (5) - NC
01:38:910 (6) - ^
01:48:053 (1) - Delete NC then NC 01:48:481 (2) -
01:50:910 (7,8) - How about convert to stream?
01:52:624 (1) - Delete NC then NC 01:53:053 (2) -
01:57:196 (1) - Delete NC then NC 01:57:624 (2) -
02:57:624 (5) - NC and delete NC 02:58:053 (1) -
02:58:767 (4) - NC
03:00:767 (3) - NC
03:11:339 (5) - ^
03:32:624 (2) - How about convert to stream?
The patterns are okay

[Normal]
00:48:624 (2,4) - Make these look same
skip NC mod

[Hard]
Patterns are fine but skip NC mod

[Overall]
I skip NC mod on normal and hard or they will be too much mod on NC , it's just somehow look like the same idea of where to NC in Insane
Also I give this map a star, good map

Good luck
Topic Starter
Yasora

CelsiusLK wrote:

Hello there from my modding queue

[General]
Check letter box during breaks because your map has break time

[Demise]
00:44:624 (4) - NC no
00:57:196 (4) - ^ ^
01:38:624 (8) - NC then delete NC 01:38:910 (1) -
02:01:196 (5) - NC no
02:55:910 (3) - NC ^

[Insane]
If my NC suggestions aren't useful ignore it
00:05:339 (1,2) - How about convert to stream? I like slider like this :''3
00:32:624 (5) - NC no
00:44:053 (1) - Delete NC then NC 00:44:481 (2) -
00:48:624 (1) - Delete NC then NC 00:49:053 (2) - no
00:53:196 (1) - Delete NC then NC 00:53:624 (2) - ^
00:57:767 (5) - NC ^
01:00:053 (5) - ^ ^
01:02:339 (5) - ^ ^
01:15:910 (5) - ^ ^
01:32:624 (2,3) - How about convert to stream? ^
01:34:339 (5) - NC ^
01:38:910 (6) - ^ ^
01:48:053 (1) - Delete NC then NC 01:48:481 (2) -
01:50:910 (7,8) - How about convert to stream? no
01:52:624 (1) - Delete NC then NC 01:53:053 (2) - ^
01:57:196 (1) - Delete NC then NC 01:57:624 (2) - ^
02:57:624 (5) - NC and delete NC 02:58:053 (1) - ^
02:58:767 (4) - NC ^
03:00:767 (3) - NC ^
03:11:339 (5) - ^ ^
03:32:624 (2) - How about convert to stream? ^
The patterns are okay

[Normal]
00:48:624 (2,4) - Make these look same changed that part lol
skip NC mod

[Hard]
Patterns are fine but skip NC mod

[Overall]
I skip NC mod on normal and hard or they will be too much mod on NC , it's just somehow look like the same idea of where to NC in Insane
Also I give this map a star, good map

Good luck
thank you for mod and star!
Charlotte
Hi from Charlotte's Taiko Modding Queue

d
k
D(big d)
K(big k)

Betsu's Muzukashii

SV1.5→1.4 OD6→OD4or5 HP6→5
Song Setup→Design→Letter box (uncheck)

00:28:481 (130) - change k
02:35:624 (774) - ^

Betsu's Oni

SV1.5→1.4
Song Setup→Design→Letter box (uncheck)

01:05:272 - add k
02:06:624 (757) - change k
02:06:767 (759) - change d
02:06:910 (761) - change k
02:10:624 (792) - change k

It is a great overall 8-)

good luck :)
toara_fict
Hi. Taiko Mod request from Yasora.

[ about]
  1. d is don note
  2. k is kat note
  3. D is Finish don note
  4. K is Finish kat note

  5. Purple is UnRankable , Please change
  6. Green is I would strongly recommend
  7. black is Pointed out that



[ General]
  1. all recheck this

  2. SV : 1.5 => 1.4

  3. BG : Change Video => BG


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -


[ Betsu's Oni]
  1. 00:28:696 - add note here ( have drum sound. )


  2. 00:46:196 (263,264) - swap ( 00:46:339 (264) - have Cymbals? sounds. )


  3. 00:56:339 (320) - Change d ( 00:56:339 (320,321) - some sounds. )


  4. 01:27:481 (523) - Change k ? ( have Cymbals? sounds. )


  5. 01:50:196 (664,665,666,667) - if you follow drum sound => swap ? ( if vocal follow => no change plz. )


  6. 02:10:053 (783) - d ( not k sounds. this note d )


  7. 02:19:410 (851) - delete & 02:19:553 - 02:19:696 - add k here ? ( Want to follow drum sound >< )


  8. 02:40:624 - add k here ? ( 02:40:339 (991,992) - some sounds. )


  9. 03:22:553 (121) - why k ? this note d.


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -
Muzu is fine.

Good Luck ~ :3
[I]MMoRTal[S]
From my queue

00:03:481 (11,12) - Ctrl+G
03:41:767 (204) - k
00:15:196 (78) - d
00:56:339 (320) - d
03:33:053 (192) - d
03:41:767 (260,261,262,263,264,265,266) - ddkkddk


Good Luck ~ :)
-Famous-
Mod request from my Queue

Normal
  1. The distance seems too close. Maybe try a distance that's larger than one.
  2. 00:13:196 (4,5) - Seems like blanket. Try to blanket 00:12:053 (3,4).
  3. 00:32:339 (4) - Add NC and remove NC 00:32:624 (1)? That's easier to read, because of the longer break between the notes. But I'm not sure about it.
  4. 00:33:481 (3) - Add NC, same reason as above.
  5. Suggestion: add NC 00:34:624 (3); remove NC 00:34:910 (1); add NC 00:36:910 (5); remove NC 00:37:196 (1); add NC 00:39:196 (5); remove NC 00:39:481 (1). That fits more to the singing.
  6. 01:15:767 and 01:16:910 feels like a note is missing.
  7. 01:21:481 (2) - is a little bit close to 01:20:624 (1).
  8. 01:33:196 to 02:37:196 - Did you copy & paste the whole part? If yes, copy & paste it again after the changes.
  9. 03:42:339 (1) - I guess the spinner is too short for Normal. Enpoint: 03:45:767?
Hard
  1. The spacing between 00:12:339 (2,3) and 00:13:624 (3,4) is too small.
  2. 01:02:053 (6,1) - Blanket.
  3. 01:10:053 (7,1) - The spacing is too huge. Compare it with 01:10:624 (2,3).
  4. 01:12:910 (2,3) - The spacing is too small again.
  5. 01:39:624 (6,1) - Spacing too big.
Insane

Looks fine, except some blankets:
  1. 00:32:624 (5,6) - Blanket.
  2. 00:54:339 (3,4) - Make better blanket.
  3. 00:57:196 (3) - Move to x:92 ; y:156. Blanket looks better.
  4. 00:57:481 (4,5) - Fix blanket.
  5. 00:59:624 (3,4) - ^
  6. 01:02:767 (6,7) - ^
  7. 01:48:053 (6,1) - ^
  8. 02:04:053 (5) - Move the last slider point to x:300 ; y:48 for better blanekt
Demise

Nothing to say, except 03:14:624 (1,2,3,4,1,2). Sounds wrong to me.

Nice mapset, I like it. Good luck! :)
Topic Starter
Yasora

-Famous- wrote:

Mod request from my Queue

Normal
  1. The distance seems too close. Maybe try a distance that's larger than one. seems fine like this for me o3o
  2. 00:13:196 (4,5) - Seems like blanket. Try to blanket 00:12:053 (3,4).
  3. 00:32:339 (4) - Add NC and remove NC 00:32:624 (1)? That's easier to read, because of the longer break between the notes. But I'm not sure about it.
  4. 00:33:481 (3) - Add NC, same reason as above.
  5. Suggestion: add NC 00:34:624 (3); remove NC 00:34:910 (1); add NC 00:36:910 (5); remove NC 00:37:196 (1); add NC 00:39:196 (5); remove NC 00:39:481 (1). That fits more to the singing.
  6. 01:15:767 and 01:16:910 feels like a note is missing. try to following vocal in here..
  7. 01:21:481 (2) - is a little bit close to 01:20:624 (1).
  8. 01:33:196 to 02:37:196 - Did you copy & paste the whole part? If yes, copy & paste it again after the changes.
  9. 03:42:339 (1) - I guess the spinner is too short for Normal. Enpoint: 03:45:767? seems too long, changed until 03:44:481 instead
Hard
  1. The spacing between 00:12:339 (2,3) and 00:13:624 (3,4) is too small.
  2. 01:02:053 (6,1) - Blanket. it's not blanket from beginning..
  3. 01:10:053 (7,1) - The spacing is too huge. Compare it with 01:10:624 (2,3).
  4. 01:12:910 (2,3) - The spacing is too small again.
  5. 01:39:624 (6,1) - Spacing too big.
Insane

Looks fine, except some blankets:
  1. 00:32:624 (5,6) - Blanket.
  2. 00:54:339 (3,4) - Make better blanket.
  3. 00:57:196 (3) - Move to x:92 ; y:156. Blanket looks better.
  4. 00:57:481 (4,5) - Fix blanket.
  5. 00:59:624 (3,4) - ^
  6. 01:02:767 (6,7) - ^
  7. 01:48:053 (6,1) - ^
  8. 02:04:053 (5) - Move the last slider point to x:300 ; y:48 for better blanekt fix it by myself
Demise

Nothing to say, except 03:14:624 (1,2,3,4,1,2). Sounds wrong to me.why? I heard a bit fast drum sound in there o.o

Nice mapset, I like it. Good luck! :)
thank you :3!

for taiko modders, pls be patience for waiting betsu' reply..
Betsuto
here I come ~
a lot of fix

Betsu's Muzukashii : http://puu.sh/ahy1v/8fae8ffd23.osu
Betsu's Oni : http://puu.sh/ahy4e/91306bd913.osu

Thanks XD
Topic Starter
Yasora
updated~
mliencheng
Taiko mod from mod queue request ~


00:40:339(191,192) ctrl G

00:45:053(216,217) ctrl G

01:02:767 k, high pitch here

01:40:339(496,497) ctrl G

02:00:196(591,592) k. Normally there's only 1/4 ddd or kkk in muzukashii diffs

02:05:481 add d

02:10:624 slider finishes here looks better ?
00:22:839 I suggest removing this note if there's no clear sound (same for 00:27:410)

01:17:910 k

01:20:481 D in consistency with 01:19:339

01:29:839 move to 01:29:696 following guitar sound

02:06:481 the stream here is according to the background sound, which is Inner Oni style. Maybe simplify it to something following the vocal.
As for the stream here 02:09:767, since there's no vocal , I think it's ok to follow drum sounds

02:25:624 D, consistency with 02:24:481

02:26:481(902,903,904) kkk would be nice
Moo-Chan
From my modding queue~

[Insane]
  1. I think you should make it AR9
  2. 00:26:767 (1,2) - Blanket this
  3. 00:45:196 (1,2) - ^^
  4. 02:58:624 (3,4,5) - ^^
  5. 02:59:196 (5) - Sounds like there's a whistle on this slider that shouldn't be there
  6. 03:42:339 (1) - Should drag this out to 03:45:767 and then make the ending of this spinner quieter

That's all I see c: Good luck with ranking~
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply