forum

Noriko Kawahara - Odin Sphere's Theme

posted
Total Posts
87
show more
Lilac
Lower HP Drain and I'm not changing that slider.

Plus hitsound additions. ^_^ You got to love them.

Download: Noriko Kawahara - Odin Sphere's Theme (Dusty) [MarioBros777's Heroic].osu

Now if you excuse me, I'll help myself to some cake.
alvisto
The timing and 1/6 beat snap divisor scares me... ;_;. Sorry, but I won't touch on timing then. However, I thought there should not be any notes before the initial offset ?

This song reminds me of Final Fantasy Tactics. =O

A star for yea, since I really have no idea how to mod a 1/6 map, but I have test play all of them, seems fine to me if the timing is correct.
Topic Starter
Dusty

alvisto wrote:

This song reminds me of Final Fantasy Tactics. =O
Hitoshi Sakimoto composed both this song and the songs in FFT, so that's why they're similar.
alvisto

Dusty wrote:

alvisto wrote:

This song reminds me of Final Fantasy Tactics. =O
Hitoshi Sakimoto composed both this song and the songs in FFT, so that's why they're similar.
:O No wonder ! xD
Kytoxid
[General]

Turn MB's diff's lead-in down to 1985 to be consistent with Hard.
I'd recommend adding a black layer in the storyboard so that the video fades in from black instead of from the current background; looks better in my opinion.

[Normal]

00:27:692 - Excess timing section.

[Hard]

Has a lot of random uninherited timing sections, please fix.

01:21:810 (2) - A little non-symmetrical.

[MB777]

00:05:634 (3,4,5) - Inconsistent spacing.

Geez, that's a lot of spinners... With only 1:19 of draining time, you have a spinner every 6 seconds. Might want to tone that down a bit.

Still a cool map though. :)
Topic Starter
Dusty

Kytoxid wrote:

I'd recommend adding a black layer in the storyboard so that the video fades in from black instead of from the current background; looks better in my opinion.
Done. (that's actually really cool)

Kytoxid wrote:

[Hard]
Has a lot of random uninherited timing sections, please fix.
aah, how did that happen?...

Kytoxid wrote:

01:21:810 (2) - A little non-symmetrical.
It's better now.

Have to bug MB777 about his diff.
rust45
I love this game even though I haven't beaten the first story yet. I modding without even being asked for this reason.

[Normal]
00:56:810 (3) - Pushed into the lifebar looks wrong and on hard rock it's slightly offscreen.

[Hard]
The speed up seems really uncalled for and yet it seemed really good.

Great maps, and wonderful hitsounds, you get a star.
Topic Starter
Dusty

rust45 wrote:

[Normal]
00:56:810 (3) - Pushed into the lifebar looks wrong and on hard rock it's slightly offscreen.
Oops, that shouldn't happen. Fixed.

rust45 wrote:

[Hard]
The speed up seems really uncalled for and yet it seemed really good.
If it seemed good, then I guess it was called for?

Also, thanks for modding
Kytoxid
Since I've modded this already, I'll mod the one last thing I didn't before. (and I'll pubble once this mod and MB777's diff are fixed).

[Easy]

01:26:810 - Unused timing section.

[Normal]

01:20:781 - Unused timing section.
01:21:369 - ^

[Hard]

01:31:369 - Unused timing section.

[MB777's Heroic]

(remember to make sure you change the lead-in time, currently the black background flashes in late because there's too much lead-in)

01:36:389 - Unused timing section.
yeahyeahyeahhh
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
DeathxShinigami
LOVE !_!
Topic Starter
Dusty

yeahyeahyeahhh wrote:

Easy
>> 01:09:163 (1,1,1) - Don't really see the need for new combos like this on an easy, but your call.
Fixed, thanks.

DeathxShinigami wrote:

LOVE !_!
Thanks!
Gens
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
Topic Starter
Dusty
Thanks for modding!

Gens wrote:

[Normal]
  1. OD feels a tad too high.
OK, lowered by 1.

Gens wrote:

[Hard]
  1. Shouldn't a 2x warning be there somewhere?
I guess...

Gens wrote:

01:28:134 - Kiai fountain? unfitting :[
whoops, forgot to add Kiai to the timing section before it, fixed

Gens wrote:

EDIT: Oh yes, check the Audio lead in in Mario's diff, the background is not black when it starts
MB hasn't sent me an updated version, but fixed just so people stop pointing this one out
Lilac
oh crud, I didn't submit anything yet? I swear I did.

Let's get this ranked!

Oh...and I can do those jumps, Gens. And I suck at osu!

Download: Noriko Kawahara - Odin Sphere's Theme (Dusty) [MB's Heroic].osu
Gens

MarioBros777 wrote:

Oh...and I can do those jumps, Gens. And I suck at osu!
Yes but they don't fit the music imo
also they're the only jumps in the whole diff =/
Lilac
The only jumps in diff? That should be fine, shouldn't it?

And it does fit with the song. She takes 3 syllables to say "and".

Don't you think that fits well enough?
Kytoxid
Pre-pubble mod.

[Hard]

01:19:457 (2,3) - Difficult to read, combined with a jump. Kinda concerning, since the rest isn't as hard.

[MB's Heroic]

The fact that his name suddenly disappears is weird; fade it out?

00:33:281 (1,2,3) - 2 grids down to center?
00:41:810 (4) - Use Bezier and make it look nicer?
00:51:516 (3,4,5) - Stack 5's endpoint on 6, just to be consistent?
01:28:134 - Unnecessary timing section.

Almost there, although I'm concerned about the timing; I concur with Gens, I think offset is late.
Topic Starter
Dusty

Kytoxid wrote:

[Hard]

01:19:457 (2,3) - Difficult to read, combined with a jump. Kinda concerning, since the rest isn't as hard.
Fixed not being able to tell which way the slider goes. (But that whole section is a big mess now, argh, I'll look at it again when I'm not tired)

[MB's Heroic]

The fact that his name suddenly disappears is weird; fade it out?
I like it that way. (If there's a consensus that other people don't like it I'll change it.)

Almost there, although I'm concerned about the timing; I concur with Gens, I think offset is late.
what a pain :?
Sonnyc
Star(since it's pre-bubbled)
Topic Starter
Dusty
It's not pubbled yet.

And just because something's pubbled/bubbled/(sometimes even ranked) doesn't mean you can't mod anymore...
Lilac
Oh yes.

Herp derp.

And it was meant to be a catmull slider.

Download: Noriko Kawahara - Odin Sphere's Theme (Dusty) [MB's Heroic].osu
Topic Starter
Dusty
uploaded, thanks
Shulin
General:

-- Okay, I see 4 pages of mod posts and not a single one offering a definitive timing... It's annoying me because I can't find a good timing either. I used offset 366 but I'm definitely not confident with it >:(

Maybe try posting here for more opinions.

Hard:

00:46:222 (2) - Slider slide noise intentional?

MB's Heroic:

00:07:987 (7) - Remove new combo. (This looks silly when reading the lyrics)
00:19:751 (1) - ^
01:04:016 (1) - Maybe delete this and extend the spinner to this point?
01:28:575 (1) - A lot of inheriting sections on this spinner with slight volume reductions that aren't really noticeable, tidy this up? (Also delete the last one its uneeded).

Too many spinners imo, and also a lot of added notes that don't coincide with anything in the music, otherwise a good difficulty.

Great job with the maps, it's changed a lot since the last time I looked at it :D

~ Kudos Star.
Topic Starter
Dusty

Shulin wrote:

-- Okay, I see 4 pages of mod posts and not a single one offering a definitive timing... It's annoying me because I can't find a good timing either. I used offset 366 but I'm definitely not confident with it >:(

Maybe try posting here for more opinions.
I actually did try there already, actually

Shulin wrote:

Hard:
00:46:222 (2) - Slider slide noise intentional?
Yeah, that was. Does it sound bad?
Shulin

Dusty wrote:

Shulin wrote:

-- Okay, I see 4 pages of mod posts and not a single one offering a definitive timing... It's annoying me because I can't find a good timing either. I used offset 366 but I'm definitely not confident with it >:(

Maybe try posting here for more opinions.
I actually did try there already, actually
Oh right, well I didn't see a result so...

Dusty wrote:

Shulin wrote:

Hard:
00:46:222 (2) - Slider slide noise intentional?
Yeah, that was. Does it sound bad?
Imo yes, at least it might be a little too loud, that's why I asked lol.
Topic Starter
Dusty
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
Lilac
Removed those new combos... I will, unfortunately, reject that suggestion because I've tried it before and it doesn't sound good.

Also, changed the inherited timings. And left the ones that I think are important.

Really, I kinda like my insane... but I'll probably never do one again.

Download: Noriko Kawahara - Odin Sphere's Theme (Dusty) [MB's Heroic].osu
Topic Starter
Dusty
And updated.
Gens
Totally forgot to post here.

MarioBros777 wrote:

The only jumps in diff? That should be fine, shouldn't it?

And it does fit with the song. She takes 3 syllables to say "and".

Don't you think that fits well enough?
Yeah well, you don't seem to get it... why to pull out jumps like that out of nowhere? :|
It maybe fits the song timeline-wise, but the music doesn't have that kind of impact calling for jumps.
If you're going to take my maps as an example, I always make the whole map jumpy instead, even if they don't fit, so I think they're fine.

It's OK if you want to leave it like that anyway, I just wanted to get my point across.
Lilac
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
Zerostarry
[Normal]
01:20:928 (2,3,4,5) - Perhaps redo the spacing here?

[Heroic]
00:39:457 (5) - Spacing
00:51:516 (3,4,5) - Make this all one slider? Seems a bit overmapped.
01:16:222 (1) - Whistle intentionally left out?
01:20:634 (1,2,3) - Hard maps are great, but this just seems out of place.
Agnes
Wooo, second part of Zerostarry's modding. 8D

[Easy]

No errors.

[Hard]

00:22:545 (9,10) - Fix spacing?
00:37:251 (2,3) - ^

Star'd.
Sushi
Nothing to say

Star~
Lilac
A mod here and a mod there... and what do we have?

Download: Noriko Kawahara - Odin Sphere's Theme (Dusty) [MB's Heroic].osu
Topic Starter
Dusty
Updated.
Starrodkirby86
Hm...
RemmyX25
Popping bubble.

I highly recommend removing the video if it is not being used. If it is supposed to, it doesnt, and probably needs to be reecoded.
Topic Starter
Dusty

RemmyX25 wrote:

Popping bubble.

I highly recommend removing the video if it is not being used. If it is supposed to, it doesnt, and probably needs to be reecoded.
I'm not sure what the problem is, because it's been working for me. How should I encode it?

(also, I can't upload anything right now, but I'm sure this map can wait another week)

mm, I have no idea, going to try to get a good-quality .flv once I'm in a place which doesn't have youtube blocked.

All right. I don't know anything about video editing, hopefully it works for you now?
RemmyX25
The video works this time, but can you cut the white.png part of the storyboard shorter? it unnecessarily drags out the end of the map, causing players to wait or just skip it all together
Topic Starter
Dusty
Sure
RemmyX25
bubble worthy
kingcobra52
Normal

01:01:810 (1) - I would remove the finish here.

Fix and I'll rank.

Edit: Done.
Topic Starter
Dusty
Next one will have an actual storyboard.

kingcobra52 wrote:

Normal

01:01:810 (1) - I would remove the finish here.

Fix and I'll rank.

Edit: Done.
Thanks!
Lilac
I just want to say I had a really good time mapping for this.

Unless there's a high demand, I will not be making an Insane ever again.

So you got lucky, Dusty.

The reason being is that it's just not my style. I can't just go overmapping something or making it challenging because I'm self conscious that I can't complete it myself. I don't map things that I can't play myself.

It really was fun.
Topic Starter
Dusty
Yeah, I get what you mean. If you can't really play your beatmap, how do you know if it's good? and stuff

thanks for doing it, though
Xgor
How is this a (instrumental) song?
I think is (Other) or (Japanese)
Topic Starter
Dusty
It's French with a heavy Japanese accent, really.
Scar

Dusty wrote:

It's French with a heavy Japanese accent, really.
It's not french.
Topic Starter
Dusty
Well, she's trying but her accent sucks and makes stuff unintelligible
Scar

Dusty wrote:

Well, she's trying but her accent sucks and makes stuff unintelligible
true, sorry for my mistake...
Please sign in to reply.

New reply