Btw to quote in the top right corner of a post/reply there should be a button that says "Quote post for reply", just click that and you can get really nice quotes
RealDeathmatch wrote:
you're acting like to be considered an alt player you have to have to alt EVERY. SINGLE. NOTE. Without fail, I'd even say the full alt definition isn't this strict, like yes of COURSE alt players will singletap extremely slow gameplay, and of course they will start streams on the same finger,
I'm just guessing but I think we're operating on different definitions of what "full-alt" means.
I'll give my definitions:
Full-alt: A style of alternating where you alternate every single note, regardless of the pattern.
Semi-alt: A style of alternating where you don't alternate every single note, eg. you start all bursts and streams on the same finger.
I'm guessing yours are somewhere along these lines:
Full-alt: Alternating all the time for the most part.
Semi-alt: Alternating some of the time, maybe you singletap some maps.
If I'm right, then the difference between our two definitions is that I'm talking about how you specifically alt when you do alt, and you're talking about how often you alt. If I'm wrong please clarify.
Under my definitions, out of the top 10 only gnahus full-alts, and they also seem to full-alt lower bpm patterns that can be easily singletapped. Chicony seems to similarly alt all the time, but only plays semi-alt because he starts all bursts and streams on the same finger. I also saw that nyanpotato played semi-alt in every replay I checked even for maps that players like mrekk might singletap, but I didn't watch a replay of him not playing some super high bpm dt map to confirm whether he alts all the time or just with dt.
Also, I've never really thought about what specifically makes an "alt player". I always just thought that an alt player was someone who alts everything they can all the time (doesn't matter whether they full-alt or semi-alt, those are both alt), while a singletapper would singletap everything that they were able to/were comfortable with and switch to alt for high bpms. Of course this isn't binary but instead a spectrum of at what point do you switch to alting, and idk where exactly in this spectrum the distinction between "alt player" and someone who isn't an "alt player" lies.
RealDeathmatch wrote:
but for most good players 95% of maps in their skill range they will be alting for most of said map. Again, there are exceptions (singletap demons like akolibed xooty etc) but it's just a general note that a lot of good players alt
This is completely anecdotal because I can't be bothered to gather numbers but this doesn't feel right, because it feels like most top players (and also most non top players) will singletap anything within their "singletap bpm range" and alt anything outside of that or alt to conserve stamina. Maybe this is skewed from seeing players like mrekk and lifeline seemingly singletap as much as possible. Honestly I can't speak too well on how singletapping works because I switched to full-alting all the time as a 6 digit.
RealDeathmatch wrote:
about the whole speed thing, speed I consider to be my best (mechanical) skill and I full alt,
I'd be interested to hear if you full-alt in the way I described it, because if you do, with a sample size of 12 we have now found a break in the pattern. And as you touched on, if we were doing an actual study it would be wrong to not factor in ranks as a possible variable to how good you are with speed relative to your other skills when you full-alt vs don't full-alt.
RealDeathmatch wrote:
I'm sure if you ran a poll among all 4/3 digits a majority of them would say they alt, at least to some extent.
I'd go even further and say that there'd be barely anyone that can't alt at 4/3 digits, and if they can't they'll see it as an overwhelmingly massive weakness in their skillset.
RealDeathmatch wrote:
also telling someone that wants to learn how to alt to avoid alt maps so smart lol...
To clarify, I didn't say to avoid alt maps, just that playing alt maps wouldn't be advice I'd specifically give because I don't really think it's that relevant to learning how to alt initially. I just said to start off by learning the muscle memory by alting on easy maps and moving towards harder maps as you get better. Btw this is how I learnt to full-alt, I just played easy maps and worked my way up. I don't even think I was good enough to play alt maps, or at least play alt maps that couldn't be played easily by singletapping or were in terms of fingercontrol just low bpm burst maps with some flow aim.
RealDeathmatch wrote:
lifeline seems to alt on very high bpm stuff
From what I've seen, Lifeline seemingly singletaps literally everything he can and is pretty vocal about being bad at alting, I don't think he's the best example of a "full-alt" player according to either of our definitions (he starts all bursts and streams on the same finger). I don't know much about the tapping habits of the other players you listed, but if you were just looking for top players that alt at least to some extent, literally all of them should. I can personally confirm that the entirety of the top 10 alts to some extent. I'd be extremely surprised if you could find a top player who can't alt.