RandomEffect wrote:

From my queue~

[Normal]

1. this diff is a little hard for beginner. I suggest to reduce some notes starting at 1/2 rhythm (red line) I'm going to add an Easy so I think it should be fine
2. 00:39:573 (4,1) - for normal diff, you should not make jump pattern like this oops, didn't even notice
3. 01:19:268 (1) - end at 01:20:914 done
4. 01:34:085 (1,2) - make symmetric fixed
5. 02:07:195 (3,1) - how about blanketting? ok
   
   SPOILER

   
6. 02:18:536 (2) - end at 02:18:902 idk i kind of want it to end on the clap. if someone else suggests ill change
7. 02:25:122 (3) - curved slider is better i think im gonna keep it like this
8. 02:29:329 (3,2) - stack corrctly fixed
9. 03:56:402 (5) - twice reverse sider is confusing for beginner i'll keep for now but if suggested again ill change
10. 04:01:158 (1,2) - avoid overlap ^

[Hard]

1. 00:14:146 (5,1) - because of after many times revese, make DS smaller done
2. 00:37:744 (4,1) - not stack on purpose? didn't notice, fixed
3. 01:12:683 (2) - x:409 y:225 done
4. 01:50:366 (1) - x:294 y:189 ^
5. 01:50:000 (5,1,2,3,4,1) - it is better to conform DS fixed
6. 02:28:048 (6,1) - blanket correctly ^
7. 02:30:975 (2) - x:152 y:146 ^
8. 02:39:939 (1) - too short spinner. I prefer to end at 02:41:036 done
9. 02:58:963 (4,1) - swap NC done
10. 03:53:475 (6) - clap added
11. 04:01:158 (3,2) - this overlap is not good changed

[Insane]

1. 00:11:585 (2) - I prefer to divide into 2 circles done
2. 00:19:085 (4,5) - I prefer to exchange their positions niceee idea!
3. 00:34:451 (3) - x:344 y:270 done
4. 01:50:183 (1,2,3,4,5) -how about regular pentagon? done, thanks for the code
   
   SPOILER

   
   

   354,315,110183,5,0,0:0:0:0:
   453,179,110366,1,0,0:0:0:0:
   354,146,110548,1,8,0:0:0:0:
   453,283,110731,1,0,0:0:0:0:
   293,231,110914,1,0,0:0:0:0:

5. 02:39:939 (1) - same as hard ok
6. 03:10:670 (4) - Ctrl+G done
7. 03:15:609 (5,6) - blanket correctly ok

Tommy is so cute <3
~Good Luck~

No Dap wrote:

So, is someone making an Easy diff? your normal is still not below 3.25 star rating :3

Knotts wrote:

No Dap wrote:

So, is someone making an Easy diff? your normal is still not below 3.25 star rating :3

Yeah but he said he's not 100% sure he'll finish it so I'm kind of confused.

Desperate-kun wrote:

Ohh it's sad to tell you ;w; But I am not able to finish it, because I got stuck with the rhythm and I kind of lost the motivation to finish it. I'm very, very sorry

1. 00:01:890 (5) - try to create symmetry with 00:01:524 (4) - maybe?
   (cause 00:00:427 (1,2,3) - create a nice symmetrical pattern, too)
2. 00:02:256 (6) - move to 177|186 (cause 00:03:170 (1) - )
3. you could increase curve here a bit
   screen

   
   imo, that'd look better with 00:03:170 (1) -
4. 00:09:024 (1,2) - blanket better
   comparison

   
   
5. 00:11:951 (4) - move end to ~ 350|176? just looks better to me. >:
   (+ similar shape to 00:12:866 (7) - )
6. 00:20:548 (4,1) - blanket better
   same here - 00:23:109 (4) - and 00:23:841 (1) -
   and - 00:25:305 (6,7,8,9) -
   there are more, but I'm lazy, so you might wanna check your diff for thsoe blankets and fix them real quick
   this might be nitpicking and a lot of people might not even notice this things,
   but to some (like me.. xD) this looks just sloppily mapped. (not saying you did, but it looks like it.)
7. 00:44:878 (4,5,6,7,8,9) - create 'correct' polygon pattern? if it's supposed to be one, it's off by a bit. o-o
8. 01:20:914 (6) - move to 152|238 to match better with 01:20:183 (4) -
9. 02:52:561 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - curve out like some other streams? it's a bit.. angular atm. o,o
   same here - 03:01:524 (2,3,4,5) - (is it intentional?)
10. 03:38:658 (5) - ctrl+g? have the feeling it flows better (by movement) and jump to 03:39:024 (6) - looks legit (to me).

1. same about the blankets
   .. I know it's tiring to refine shapes here and there and move objects 1 or 2 pixels, but it's woth it!
2. 00:08:658 (5,1) - just wanted to say I like these overlaps. pls keep them! xD
3. 00:10:670 (6) - shape looks kinda weird here. o_o Idk why, but the middle is so.. I really don't know. I think it should look more like this? -
   screen

   
4. 00:11:219 (1,2,3,4,5) - polygon pattern? .o.
5. 00:22:195 (1) - shape looks a bit random, cause it's angular.. if you wanna keep angularity, maybe refine it a bit
   example

   
   (and pay attention to having the red anchors on a red/blue tick, maybe! in most cases sliders look more structured then.)
6. 00:51:463 (4) - ctrl+g maybe? (movement/flow is better I think.)
7. 01:58:780 (4) - refine shape (curvy part)
8. 02:49:817 (1,2) - this overlap is kinda.. unexpected. maybe think of sth different? (if there's no specific reason for it)

1. 00:17:256 (3) - rotate a bit (36° by selec centre), it looks better with 00:17:987 (1) - I think
   (it's ok if it goes 'against the movement' indicated by 00:16:524 (1,2) - cause the slider is so short, you actually don't have to move the cursor, so.. yah. xD)
2. oh, and same about blankets. :b
3. another thing - you have some parts where you follow the vocals and some where you follow the actual beat
   this might be extremely confusing for beginner players, so Idk.. you might wanna take a look at that.
   it's mostly at those white/red tick changes, where you end one object on the red and start the next on a white tick again (or vice versa)
   since you are working on an Easy diff, it's kinda okay.. buuut still. just keep in mind it's hard to read!
4. 02:11:951 (4) - place further up, so you don't break movement/flow so abruptly here ( ~ 296|8)
5. 02:15:061 (5) - ctrl+g, adjust following objects?
6. 02:24:756 (2,3) - really close, move 3's end a bit to the right?

1. combo colours - this yellow is sooo bright, maybe you find a less neon-like yellow?
   or choose a light blue instead (like the blue something's .. on the right side of the background image.. Idk what it is, but the colour is nice!)
   example

   
   
   and

   [Colours]
   Combo1 : 167,84,63
   Combo2 : 255,255,255
   Combo3 : 142,244,217
   Combo4 : 177,183,165

Squirrel wrote:

hi there!
mod by req~
eveyrthing is just suggestions, feel free to ignore me. :b xD

[Insane]
lol this is the first time I'm looking at the highest difficulty first.. kinda nervous. O-O

1. 00:01:890 (5) - try to create symmetry with 00:01:524 (4) - maybe? done
   (cause 00:00:427 (1,2,3) - create a nice symmetrical pattern, too)
2. 00:02:256 (6) - move to 177|186 (cause 00:03:170 (1) - ) done
3. you could increase curve here a bit
   screen

   
   imo, that'd look better with 00:03:170 (1) -
4. 00:09:024 (1,2) - blanket better fixed
   comparison

   
   
   did that but changed the pattern a little
5. 00:11:951 (4) - move end to ~ 350|176? just looks better to me. >: ok
   (+ similar shape to 00:12:866 (7) - )
6. 00:20:548 (4,1) - blanket better ^
   same here - 00:23:109 (4) - and 00:23:841 (1) - ^
   and - 00:25:305 (6,7,8,9) - ^
   there are more, but I'm lazy, so you might wanna check your diff for thsoe blankets and fix them real quick
   this might be nitpicking and a lot of people might not even notice this things,
   but to some (like me.. xD) this looks just sloppily mapped. (not saying you did, but it looks like it.)
7. 00:44:878 (4,5,6,7,8,9) - create 'correct' polygon pattern? if it's supposed to be one, it's off by a bit. o-o ok
8. 01:20:914 (6) - move to 152|238 to match better with 01:20:183 (4) -
9. 02:52:561 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - curve out like some other streams? it's a bit.. angular atm. o,o i think this is good enough to keep
   same here - 03:01:524 (2,3,4,5) - (is it intentional?) i curved this one a little bit more.
10. 03:38:658 (5) - ctrl+g? have the feeling it flows better (by movement) and jump to 03:39:024 (6) - looks legit (to me). done.

well, except for these blankets this looks totally fine.
& even tho the draining time is rather long and you have only one small break I didn't get tired while playing this diff. gj. :3

[Hard]

1. same about the blankets
   .. I know it's tiring to refine shapes here and there and move objects 1 or 2 pixels, but it's woth it!
2. 00:08:658 (5,1) - just wanted to say I like these overlaps. pls keep them! xD :D
3. 00:10:670 (6) - shape looks kinda weird here. o_o Idk why, but the middle is so.. I really don't know. I think it should look more like this? fixed -
   screen

   
4. 00:11:219 (1,2,3,4,5) - polygon pattern? .o. nah im going to keep as is
5. 00:22:195 (1) - shape looks a bit random, cause it's angular.. if you wanna keep angularity, maybe refine it a bit ehh i just scraped the design and made a regular curved slider.
   example

   
   (and pay attention to having the red anchors on a red/blue tick, maybe! in most cases sliders look more structured then.)
6. 00:51:463 (4) - ctrl+g maybe? (movement/flow is better I think.) it looks kinda weird both ways but ill take your word that this is better
7. 01:58:780 (4) - refine shape (curvy part) i don't know what you want it to look like but i tried my best :3
8. 02:49:817 (1,2) - this overlap is kinda.. unexpected. maybe think of sth different? (if there's no specific reason for it) idk i feel like it somewhat feels the vocals but a lot of people are telling me to change it. once more and i'll change it for sure

aaaand, just a really quick look at
[Normal]
cause I'm out of timeeee. ><

1. 00:17:256 (3) - rotate a bit (36° by selec centre), it looks better with 00:17:987 (1) - I think done
   (it's ok if it goes 'against the movement' indicated by 00:16:524 (1,2) - cause the slider is so short, you actually don't have to move the cursor, so.. yah. xD)
2. oh, and same about blankets. :b
3. another thing - you have some parts where you follow the vocals and some where you follow the actual beat
   this might be extremely confusing for beginner players, so Idk.. you might wanna take a look at that.
   it's mostly at those white/red tick changes, where you end one object on the red and start the next on a white tick again (or vice versa)
   since you are working on an Easy diff, it's kinda okay.. buuut still. just keep in mind it's hard to read!
4. 02:11:951 (4) - place further up, so you don't break movement/flow so abruptly here ( ~ 296|8) ok
5. 02:15:061 (5) - ctrl+g, adjust following objects? ok
6. 02:24:756 (2,3) - really close, move 3's end a bit to the right? ok

welp, that's all for now. >:

[General]

1. combo colours - this yellow is sooo bright, maybe you find a less neon-like yellow?
   or choose a light blue instead (like the blue something's .. on the right side of the background image.. Idk what it is, but the colour is nice!) ooh nice color
   example

   
   
   and

   [Colours]
   Combo1 : 167,84,63
   Combo2 : 255,255,255
   Combo3 : 142,244,217
   Combo4 : 177,183,165

sooo, yah. overall a really nice mapset!
If you want me to take a look at the Easy map once it's done, just send a pm!

and if you want me to go into detail with the blanket stuff.. just tell me, I can list them up. xb

Good luck with this!!
*squee* ^__^/

1. 04:14:969 (1) - just one spinner is enough, there is no need to use two of them. Players will be tired after playing pretty long map and the second spinner is just too much spinning for poor and tired players. Please, consider removing it!
2. Try disabling Letterboxing (Song Setup > Storyboarding). It kinda hurts your awesome BG.
3. Also, try replacing the blue color with something else it is too bright and doesn't fit with your BG. For example, try my colors. They're not so bright, so players' eyes will not hurt too much.
   
   ugu

   
   

   [Colours]
   Combo1 : 167,84,63
   Combo2 : 223,210,176
   Combo3 : 152,151,137
   Combo4 : 177,183,165

1. You've got plenty of 3/2 and 2/1 gaps between hitobjects. It may confuse players, so I'm asking you to reduce Overall Diff by one tick. It may help beginners to stay alive and enjoy your diff more.
2. 00:14:878 (1,3) - that's kinda nazi, but a lot of your blanket-sliders are imperfect. You can improve them, so your map will look a bit neater.
   Note: let me convince you this can easily convert to this. It won't take to much time, fix your sliders!
3. 00:55:305 (2,3) - this overlap does not look natural here, I'd say that it feels out of place. Try to replace it with something more suitable for your style? example1 or example 2
   Note: 03:36:280 (2,1) - 04:05:548 (2,3) - the same happens here. Maybe I'm just being too picky, but I relly dislike this pattern for some reason.
4. 01:34:085 (1,2) - beginners may accidentally ignore the-reverse arrow and click on (2). Try to avoid that by moving (1)'s tail somewhere else, if it is possible!
   Note: at this point players may get stressed and forget about the reverse-arrow, it is important to keep patterns intuitively playable!
5. 01:53:109 (1) - I'm not sure, but I would remove this new combo. It is not necessary here and it makes your pattern too short. In fact, your comboing looks a bit inconsistent and sometimes even messy. Please, check it once again, I'm sure you'll be able to fix some of the mistakes on your own!
6. 02:26:768 (1) - by the way, you can drag the beginning of the break to the big white line, so it will match with the music better. try to do it, it's easy!
   Note: same applies for all the breaks in all diffs, try dragging them to the downbeats, so they'd match with the music better.
7. 03:05:000 - this green line is totally useless and it is confusing for some modders Try to avoid useless green lines
   
   The diff needs some polishing and maybe some work on comboing. Apart from these things, that's a solid Easy.

1. HP Drain and OD should be set to 4. It will make the mapset a bit better-balanced and it works better with your rhythm. Moreover, that's a default settings for that kind of diffs.
2. 00:33:536 (2,3) - well, shape of the slider can be improved.This is what you can get if you spend 30 seconds to improve the slider. So, please, take your time and work on the sliders. I won't mention the same issue anymore.
3. 00:38:475 (3,1) - the transition from (3) to (1) is pretty hard to understand and flows pretty confusing. How about re-arrangin the pattern? See if you like it or not.
4. 00:56:036 (5,1) - the transition here feels weird. Considr changing it to something more logical? Well, at least try my example!
   Note: same happens a few more times poke me in-game for a detailed flow-mod or try to fix yourself if you agree with me.
5. 01:19:268 (1) - finish sound feels too noisy here. Consider replacing it with a whistle, please!
6. 01:54:573 (1,2,1,2,3) - nazi - maybe it's just me, but this pattern looks really messy and all of the notes are too close to each other. Perhaps, you've used too many 1/2s in a row. Consider simplifying your rhythm here to make the pattern look less complicated.
7. 02:48:719 (3,1,2) - just a little suggestion to improve your pattern.
   
   Example!

   
   

   363,262,168719,2,8,L|173:264,1,180,0|8,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
   101,226,169817,5,0,0:0:0:0:
   177,177,170183,2,0,P|188:248|105:317,1,180,4|8,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:

8. 03:56:402 (5) - the second reverse-arrow appears too late and it is really hard to notice it in ime, that is why such sliders are really tricky/confusing. Please, do not use such sliders for E/N diffs, unless sliders are long enough to be readable!
   
   A little bit more polishing and maybe a few more mods and you'll get an amazing diff! Keep up the good work!

1. This diff is supposed to be hard, so I'd increase HP Drain by one tick to make it really hard for players. Don't worry, the diff is still playable, but with higher Hp it's just a bit more interesting/challenging to play!
2. 00:08:292 (2,3) - just a little spacing mistake, I guess. It is noticeable, so it makes your map look a bit random.
   Note: x1.4 is not big enough to be considered as a ump, so I feel like it's a spacing mistake. It happens with a few more patterns like 00:32:622 (1,2) - so, I'm asking you to fix all similar patterns if you agree with me.
3. 00:36:829 (1,2,3,4) - maybe I just don't understand something, but x1.0 DS is different from what you've ued before in this diff. And it is changing at 00:42:134 (4,5) - again. Perhaps, you've made some spacig mistakes. If it is so - please fix them!
4. 00:58:963 (7) - whoops, overlap with the HP-Bar. Such things are not really important, but it's better if you avoid them, so your map looks much better
5. 01:18:811 (5) - such sliders are fine for this diff, but you can mke them a bit more readable and playable. Take a look here!. Sliders with just one repeat are more readable, so players would prefre them. :3
6. 01:33:353 (3,4) - can you avoid placing a jump here? It doesn't really fits with anything in music and kinda hard to understand. Random jumps can be pretty annoying, y'know.
7. 02:29:695 (1,2,1,2,1) - if only you could improve the blanketing here, I would really enjoy the paattern. Seriously, I like the idea, but sliders are a bit messy.
8. 02:32:439 (5) - there's a missed new combo on the slider, right? A new combo there would make the jump playable + it'll fit with the music and your patterns.
9. 02:35:366 (6) - and one more new combo here to emphasize velocity changes. It'll make the diff intuitively-understandable for low-skilled players.
   
   The diff appears a bit messy and has a couple of comboing mistakes. Sometimes spacing becomes weird, too. But your rhythm and patterns are really interesting and pleasant to play!

1. 00:16:158 (5) - try to use Ctrl+G on this slider, it may give you a bit more interesting flow.
2. 01:04:817 (5,6) - that little spacing mistake spoils the impression from the whole diff. I really do like the diff, but such minor mistakes make me sad
3. 02:12:683 (5) - nazi - meh, dude, such overlaps are the ONLY thing which really needs to be fixed in this diff, imo. I really do LOVE the diff, but minor overlaps are pretty annoying.
   Note: I'm using default skin, but the overlaps are visible with any other skin, too.
4. 03:06:737 (4) - 03:24:664 (6) - a new combo might help players to read this part. Not a big deal, anyway.
5. 03:10:670 (4) - using Ctrl+G on this slider gives you much smoother flow. It is also makes the slider intuitively catchable during gameplay.
   
   I'm impressed with the diff! Really good job!

No Dap wrote:

heavenly6 -> Heavenly6

or not?

Damnae wrote:

No Dap wrote:

heavenly6 -> Heavenly6

or not?

-Bakari- wrote:

Oh my God, that's an impressing mapset!

Randomly picked the map from #modreqs, hope you don't mind my mod.

[General]

1. 04:14:969 (1) - just one spinner is enough, there is no need to use two of them. Players will be tired after playing pretty long map and the second spinner is just too much spinning for poor and tired players. Please, consider removing it! ok sure, removed on all difficulties.
2. Try disabling Letterboxing (Song Setup > Storyboarding). It kinda hurts your awesome BG. done
3. Also, try replacing the blue color with something else it is too bright and doesn't fit with your BG. For example, try my colors. They're not so bright, so players' eyes will not hurt too much. makes sense, thanks for the codes
   
   ugu

   
   

   [Colours]
   Combo1 : 167,84,63
   Combo2 : 223,210,176
   Combo3 : 152,151,137
   Combo4 : 177,183,165

[Easy]

1. You've got plenty of 3/2 and 2/1 gaps between hitobjects. It may confuse players, so I'm asking you to reduce Overall Diff by one tick. It may help beginners to stay alive and enjoy your diff more. changed
2. 00:14:878 (1,3) - that's kinda nazi, but a lot of your blanket-sliders are imperfect. You can improve them, so your map will look a bit neater.
   Note: let me convince you this can easily convert to this. It won't take to much time, fix your sliders!
3. 00:55:305 (2,3) - this overlap does not look natural here, I'd say that it feels out of place. Try to replace it with something more suitable for your style? sure. i chose example 1. example1 or example 2
   Note: 03:36:280 (2,1) - 04:05:548 (2,3) - the same happens here. Maybe I'm just being too picky, but I relly dislike this pattern for some reason. fixed these too.
4. 01:34:085 (1,2) - beginners may accidentally ignore the-reverse arrow and click on (2). Try to avoid that by moving (1)'s tail somewhere else, if it is possible! changed tail to point left.
   Note: at this point players may get stressed and forget about the reverse-arrow, it is important to keep patterns intuitively playable!
5. 01:53:109 (1) - I'm not sure, but I would remove this new combo. It is not necessary here and it makes your pattern too short. In fact, your comboing looks a bit inconsistent and sometimes even messy. Please, check it once again, I'm sure you'll be able to fix some of the mistakes on your own! removed nc. i'll keep an eye out for other combo problems.
6. 02:26:768 (1) - by the way, you can drag the beginning of the break to the big white line, so it will match with the music better. try to do it, it's easy! i'm kinda confused on what to do here :3
   Note: same applies for all the breaks in all diffs, try dragging them to the downbeats, so they'd match with the music better.
7. 03:05:000 - this green line is totally useless and it is confusing for some modders Try to avoid useless green lines removed
   
   The diff needs some polishing and maybe some work on comboing. Apart from these things, that's a solid Easy.

[Normal]

1. HP Drain and OD should be set to 4. It will make the mapset a bit better-balanced and it works better with your rhythm. Moreover, that's a default settings for that kind of diffs. changed
2. 00:33:536 (2,3) - well, shape of the slider can be improved.This is what you can get if you spend 30 seconds to improve the slider. So, please, take your time and work on the sliders. I won't mention the same issue anymore. i tried to fix it but i have no idea how to make good curved sliders.
3. 00:38:475 (3,1) - the transition from (3) to (1) is pretty hard to understand and flows pretty confusing. How about re-arrangin the pattern? sure, thanks for the ideaSee if you like it or not.
4. 00:56:036 (5,1) - the transition here feels weird. Considr changing it to something more logical? Well, at least try my example! ^
   Note: same happens a few more times poke me in-game for a detailed flow-mod or try to fix yourself if you agree with me.
5. 01:19:268 (1) - finish sound feels too noisy here. Consider replacing it with a whistle, please! meh i think it sounds weird both ways but i'll do it your way until i find someway to make it sound better.
6. 01:54:573 (1,2,1,2,3) - nazi - maybe it's just me, but this pattern looks really messy and all of the notes are too close to each other. Perhaps, you've used too many 1/2s in a row. Consider simplifying your rhythm here to make the pattern look less complicated. simplified
7. 02:48:719 (3,1,2) - just a little suggestion to improve your pattern. done. i did it without the code but hopefully i did what you were envisioning
   
   Example!

   
   

   363,262,168719,2,8,L|173:264,1,180,0|8,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:
   101,226,169817,5,0,0:0:0:0:
   177,177,170183,2,0,P|188:248|105:317,1,180,4|8,0:0|0:0,0:0:0:0:

8. 03:56:402 (5) - the second reverse-arrow appears too late and it is really hard to notice it in ime, that is why such sliders are really tricky/confusing. Please, do not use such sliders for E/N diffs, unless sliders are long enough to be readable! suggested in another mod and fixed!
   
   A little bit more polishing and maybe a few more mods and you'll get an amazing diff! Keep up the good work!

[Hard]

1. This diff is supposed to be hard, so I'd increase HP Drain by one tick to make it really hard for players. Don't worry, the diff is still playable, but with higher Hp it's just a bit more interesting/challenging to play! if u say so..
2. 00:08:292 (2,3) - just a little spacing mistake, I guess. It is noticeable, so it makes your map look a bit random. fixed
   Note: x1.4 is not big enough to be considered as a ump, so I feel like it's a spacing mistake. It happens with a few more patterns like 00:32:622 (1,2) - so, I'm asking you to fix all similar patterns if you agree with me.
3. 00:36:829 (1,2,3,4) - maybe I just don't understand something, but x1.0 DS is different from what you've ued before in this diff. And it is changing at 00:42:134 (4,5) - again. Perhaps, you've made some spacig mistakes. If it is so - please fix them!
4. 00:58:963 (7) - whoops, overlap with the HP-Bar. Such things are not really important, but it's better if you avoid them, so your map looks much better fixed
5. 01:18:811 (5) - such sliders are fine for this diff, but you can mke them a bit more readable and playable. Take a look here!. Sliders with just one repeat are more readable, so players would prefre them. :3 sure thing, good to know.
6. 01:33:353 (3,4) - can you avoid placing a jump here? It doesn't really fits with anything in music and kinda hard to understand. Random jumps can be pretty annoying, y'know. ehh I don't think it really feels like a jump too much when you play it but i reduced the spacing a tiny bit.
7. 02:29:695 (1,2,1,2,1) - if only you could improve the blanketing here, I would really enjoy the paattern. Seriously, I like the idea, but sliders are a bit messy. attempted to fix but im sure you already know that i suck at blanketing/making sliders/mapping.
8. 02:32:439 (5) - there's a missed new combo on the slider, right? A new combo there would make the jump playable + it'll fit with the music and your patterns. oh yep. thanks for catching this
9. 02:35:366 (6) - and one more new combo here to emphasize velocity changes. It'll make the diff intuitively-understandable for low-skilled players. oops, forgot about that.
   
   The diff appears a bit messy and has a couple of comboing mistakes. Sometimes spacing becomes weird, too. But your rhythm and patterns are really interesting and pleasant to play!

[Insane]

1. 00:16:158 (5) - try to use Ctrl+G on this slider, it may give you a bit more interesting flow. changed it but i think it has a weird flow to (1). Might change it back if someone suggests to.
2. 01:04:817 (5,6) - that little spacing mistake spoils the impression from the whole diff. I really do like the diff, but such minor mistakes make me sad so sorry . fixed
3. 02:12:683 (5) - nazi - meh, dude, such overlaps are the ONLY thing which really needs to be fixed in this diff, imo. I really do LOVE the diff, but minor overlaps are pretty annoying. im not really too sure what this is overlapping
   Note: I'm using default skin, but the overlaps are visible with any other skin, too.
4. 03:06:737 (4) - 03:24:664 (6) - a new combo might help players to read this part. Not a big deal, anyway. done
5. 03:10:670 (4) - using Ctrl+G on this slider gives you much smoother flow. It is also makes the slider intuitively catchable during gameplay. oh yup, thanks.
   
   I'm impressed with the diff! Really good job!

Speaking aboutthe mapset, it still needs some more work. But it has a lot of potential, can't see what we'll get when the map will be ranked! Star! ~

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Best of luck!

sorry about any mistakes/typos I'm not feeling good now

Kroytz wrote:

[ Normal ]

It might be me but some of the sliders look a little "awkward".

00:01:158 (2,3,4,5) - 3,4,5 need to be adjusted to be 1 space closer to the 2 slider. And the 5 slider angled (like 2) to hit the next. adjusted

00:33:902 (3) - Angled to wrap around the 2. attempted to fix

00:39:756 (1,2,3) - The 1 slider can be lifted up more to create a cleaner blanket for the 2. And the 3 slider gets re-snapped to wrap around 1. New vs Old. In yours you can see 1 & 2 are about one space apart but 2 & 3 are 1/2 apart. And with mine, they're all about one space apart. tried to fix but yeah i suck at using DS and blanketing.
00:42:317 (2,3,4,1, 2) - The 2 slider rotated on its center by ~25 degrees. The 3 (x 159; y251) and 4 (x 112; y327) notes will get re-snapped and the short slider will have a cleaner blanket around the 3. Then the following 2 note can get re-snapped (x 266; y 160). 00:45:426 (3,4) - might have to be adjusted to (x 182; y133). The slider could be fixed a little, rotated ~20 degrees so its parallel to the former slider and mirroring the next. i adopted some of the ideas and put a splash of my own in it.

00:47:256 (2,3) - 2(x:455 y:77 ) & 3(x:347 y:198) creates two clean blankets. done

00:57:317 (2,3,4) - There's something off about the way 3 & 4 are angled against the 2. tweaked a bit

01:15:061 (4,5) - It's a little weird to play when following up from 01:13:963 (2,3) - .i think its fine unless you're talking about that weird DS error. I fixed that.

02:00:244 (2) - (x:129, y:160) angle the last point slightly to wrap around the 1. Reposition 02:01:158 (3) - to (x:272, y:45) and it shouldn't interfere with anything else. done

03:43:414 (2) - Try: 1 beat earlier done
03:44:146 (3) - 1 beat shorter doesn't sound good to me
03:44:878 (4) - 1 beat later ^
03:45:426 (5) - add a half slider at 03:45:244 and check how that sounds. (Could also be for the first chorus but I just noticed it here). Sounds more correct to me. I'm trying to simplify the rhythm

04:01:158 (1) - y:246 done

04:07:744 (4) - x182 y:290 ^
_____

There are probably more sliders that could be fixing but I didn't want to have to change everything about your map. And if anything, it was a little more minute than the ones I listed above.

• 
  [General]
  Normal hit sound sounds better than soft
  
  [Insane]
  OD7→8
  HP7→6
  01:12:683 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1) - looks weird
  02:48:536 (2,3,4) - over mapped
  02:54:481 (4) - reason?
  03:06:737 (1,2,3,4,5) - those jumps feels bad
  03:06:737 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3) - ↑
  04:09:116 (1) - how about end at 04:19:451
  00:09:024 (1) - no finish
  00:10:670 (6) - ↑
  01:03:353 (5,6) - DS2.1 just way too op
  01:24:573 (5,6,7) - jumps here plz
  01:27:683 (3,4) - ↑
  01:38:841 (5,6) - no jump here
  02:10:122 (3) - out of screen
  02:52:561 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - I don't recommend up to down
  This map have some problem with NC

- D a s z x - wrote:

• 
  [General]
  Normal hit sound sounds better than soft
  
  [Insane]
  OD7→8
  HP7→6 gonna need more opinions on this
  01:12:683 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1) - looks weird changed it
  02:48:536 (2,3,4) - over mapped its not really challenging to play it so i don't think its overmapped
  02:54:481 (4) - reason? i think it sounds better with that there
  03:06:737 (1,2,3,4,5) - those jumps feels bad doesn't feel bad to me
  03:06:737 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3) - ↑ ^
  04:09:116 (1) - how about end at 04:19:451
  00:09:024 (1) - no finish finish fits here
  00:10:670 (6) - ↑
  01:03:353 (5,6) - DS2.1 just way too op 2.1x DS isn't op at all in an Insane
  01:24:573 (5,6,7) - jumps here plz gonna keep as is
  01:27:683 (3,4) - ↑
  01:38:841 (5,6) - no jump here ^
  02:10:122 (3) - out of screen i see it in test play o.o
  02:52:561 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - I don't recommend up to down why not? i think its fine
  This map have some problem with NC i'll try to fix some stuff

Bad mod can't help sry

Endemic wrote:

From #modreqs
[Easy]

More spinners is the only thing i can suggest can't really find anywhere to fit spinners

[Normal]

02:51:097 (3,1) - move them forward 1/2 a beat and space them like this http://puu.sh/87C2u.jpg sounds cool, thanks.

[Hard]

I cant really see anything

[Insane]

Maybe HP8 still debating on changing difficulty setup

00:57:317 (2,3) - make this a 1/1 slider then a circle on the next white line, like this http://puu.sh/87zSp.jpg i was trying to follow the vocals but yeah this sounds better.

01:58:780 (1,2) - Delete The second note and make the slider a long one I liked how the old one played but this sounds better T_T

02:20:731 (1,2) - change this to http://puu.sh/87Akc.jpg instead of the 2 short sliders and put a new combo on the circle after it changed my way

03:59:512 (4,5) - Change this to this http://puu.sh/87AO3.jpg im just gonna keep it how it is

03:28:231 (6,7) - Delete 7 and put a long slider on 6 gonna keep this one as is

eeezzzeee wrote:

Hi, from modding queue. Hello

[Easy]
OD = 2~3 I'm gonna stick with the OD that Bakari gave me to use.

[Normal]
00:02:622 (5) - i think this would sound better without clap on 2nd hit I think it's necessary because it matches the sliders and circles before it.
00:35:366 (2,3,4) - remove clap on (2) add to first hit of (4) Sounds right to me as it is now but I noticed I had a clap on the tail of (2) which shouldn't be there.
02:16:341 (2) - try using 2 3/2 sliders here instead since i think the vocal ends at 02:17:622 Done
04:05:548 (5,1) - try adding claps ^
04:08:475 (5,6) - ^ ^

[Hard]
HP = 5~6 Going to keep what Bakari gave me but I'll change it if it keeps me from getting this ranked.
00:02:622 (7) - try adding claps here Yeah idk what's happening, osu like deleted the hitsounds from some of the sliders and circles. Fixed
00:03:719 (2) - clap at 1st hit of slider ^
00:06:646 (1) - ^ ^
00:09:939 (4) - clap 2nd hit of slider ^
00:19:451 (1) - random normal sampleset here Yeah I was testing something out and forgot to remove it.
01:00:975 (5,6,7) - (6) makes this a weird pattern.. make it part of (7), OR make more circles here then reverse slider instead of just 1, OR completely remove (6) Going to keep for now, pattern looks fine to me.
02:08:109 (1) - clap Done
02:14:512 (2) - clap 2nd hit of slider Done
02:17:073 (5) - try a clap at the 2nd hit of slider, i think it sounds better when it starts at the 1/2 I don't here a clap to map here.
02:31:158 (1,1,2) - make (1),(1) one combo and start next combo on (2) I don't understand what you're trying to say
02:49:817 (1,2) - this is overlapping, maybe try like this? Did this on purpose. Why does no one like this? T_T

SPOILER

03:06:646 (5,6,7) - these should be closer to each other since this is hard. also remove a clap at the end of (6) I've seen something similar on a ranked mapset Hard difficulty before so I think it'd be fine here too. Mine alrady has (6) without claps.
03:29:146 (3) - try ctrl + g Already flows well for me.
04:02:622 (4) - remove clap 1st hit of slider Done.

[Insane]
I see some other mods talk about diff settings and you wanted more opinions on this. I think HP=7, OD=7~8 would be good Thanks for your opinion

00:30:975 (1,2) - i think you intended to stack this but its not stacked! check Fixed.
00:57:866 (3) - clap Done.
01:45:609 (7,1) - stack Fixed
02:10:487 (1,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - maybe make this one combo Fixed. Idk what I was thinking there lol.
02:33:536 (4,5) - stack Fixed.
03:11:402 (1,2) - stack They were already stacked for me but I found some other stacking problems around here.
03:25:305 - 03:28:963 - try dividing the combos like this, NC at 03:26:585 (5) - 03:27:683 (4) - Fixed it my way but I think I might've made it worse lol.
03:56:768 (4,5) - there's nothing in the music for this jump to be longer than the other ones... but this is up to you Fixed the pattern a little.

I didn't really look through easy even though I said I would do all your diff's, sorry That's fine. I technically broke your 4 minute drain time rule so I'm just glad you modded it at all
(this is why I normally don't do 4 minute + maps!)

That's all! Hope this helps and best of luck
cool song too!

Knotts wrote:

02:31:158 (1,1,2) - make (1),(1) one combo and start next combo on (2) I don't understand what you're trying to say

eeezzzeee wrote:

Knotts wrote:

02:31:158 (1,1,2) - make (1),(1) one combo and start next combo on (2) I don't understand what you're trying to say

Now that I look at it this is terribly worded lol. Sorry about that

I think I meant remove the NC on 02:31:707 (1) - and add NC on 02:31:890 (2) -
Since that is the way the combos are at 02:29:695 (1,2) - and 02:30:426 (1,2) -

1. Artist: Tommy heavenly⁶
2. Romanised Artist: Tommy heavenly6
   http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tommy_heavenly6

1. 00:04:817 (5) -I was expecting a jump here, since the music is strong and you did jumps with the others similar sounds, try something similar to this:
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 00:07:561 (4,5) - this blanket is really off, use the approach circle of 4 to improve it
3. 00:10:670 (6) - If you are aiming to stack this with previous 00:09:573 (2,3) - try to do it better
4. 00:13:414 (1) - this slider doesn't fit the music, mainly cuz you're mapping a repeat in a stanza, beats like 00:13:597 - need a click action to represent better the music and bring a better gameplay experience IMO, try this:
   
   SPOILER

   
5. 00:25:670 (2,3,4) - stack this properly, look really bad in game IMO
6. 00:28:780 (2) - witht his slider you're ignoring the important beat in 00:28:963 with drums and vocals, I know you really want to keep that pattern, try this:
   
   SPOILER

   
   
7. 00:51:280 (4) - mmm this rhythm doesn't follow the song nicely IMO, mainly cuz you are ignoring the important music and vocals in 00:51:463 -, this can work better:
   
   SPOILER

   
8. 00:57:317 (2,3) - you have some more blankets that can be better, I really don't want to point them, but I feel is somethink that you should fix by yourself before this get ranked
9. 01:21:829 (2,2) - stack this properly
10. 01:25:122 (1,4) - yep, you have some more bad stacks like this one, they can be consider nazis, but look bad in game <: I suggest you to take a look in your map and fix this small things for the sake of a better design
11. 01:39:573 (1) - similar to 00:13:414 -, just remove the repeat and add a circle in 01:39:939 - you'll follow the music better
12. 01:43:963 (3,4,5,6,7) - here you're starting all the slider in weak beats and they end on the stronger ones, and for better rhythm sliders should start with heavy beats, my suggestion:
    
    SPOILER

    
13. 02:36:097 mmm I really don't like your mini break here, that part can be mapped properly IMO, but this is my personally opinion since I dislike breaks /me hides
14. 02:58:140 should be a triplet here <:
15. 03:42:134 (6) - this slider is kinda hard to read due to it have more repeats than the others ones, also I feel the constant 1/4 drums there will be represent better as a circle stream imo

1. HP 7 is too much for a Hard diff, also is the same one as Insane diff, reduce the HP to 6 here for better diff spread
2. 00:06:097 (4,1) - same as Insane about some blankets, try to improve them before some one come to bubble this <3
3. 00:23:292 (1,4) - try to avoid the overlap here it doesn't look good for me
4. 00:24:939 (1) - same problem as insane in 00:13:414
5. 00:32:622 (1,2,3) - you have some not properly stacks in the whole diff, but will be really nazi to point all of them, take a quick look in this diff and fix them c:
6. 00:37:744 (4,1) - this slider with multiple repeats is stacked in the other one and that's not cool in my opinion, sine there is not way to know how many repeats it have, will be cool if you space it properly like you did with 00:37:744 (4,1) -
7. 01:00:975 (5,6,7,1) - I feel this part is really hard to be played for a Hard diff, what about to change the rhythm to a more suitable one? my suggestion:
   
   SPOILER

   
8. 01:05:548 (1,2) - stack this properly hue
9. 01:07:012 (6,1) - same as 00:37:744 -, also I feel 2 repeat sliders fit better the music, as my previous example ^
10. 01:11:951 (6,1) - swap NC
11. 01:18:536 (4,5,6) - I don't get your rhythm here, since the first repeat is starting in a blue tick and it will make it really hard to play, try this:
    
    SPOILER

    
12. 01:19:451 (1) - the spinner should start 1/4 back in 01:19:359 -, following the hold feeling of the vocals which is starting in 01:19:268
13. 01:30:609 (1,1) - same as 00:37:744
14. 02:05:548 (5,1) - ^
15. 02:23:109 (6,1) - ^
16. 02:34:908 (5) - the previous hitburst of 02:34:908 (5) - overlap the repeat of 02:34:908 (5),try to rearrange some stuff and make it noticeable
17. 02:52:561 (4,1) - 02:52:561 (4,1) -
18. 03:12:683 (4,5,6) - probably too difficult for a hard diff imo, try this instead:
    
    SPOILER

    
19. 03:17:805 (2,5) - avoid the overlap if is posible
20. 03:18:811 (5,1) - same as 00:37:744
21. 03:24:573 (5,6) - ^
22. 03:30:426 (7,1) - ^
23. 03:47:987 (5,1) - Yeah this one play better cuz you're using a properly spacing instead of the stack, in this way you can follow the approach rate to read how many repeats it have
24. 03:59:786 (5,6,7,1) - this look really hard to play, but probably is fine as it is

1. 00:14:329 (5,1) - you have some not properly stacks in the whole diff, but will be really nazi to point all of them, take a quick look in this diff and fix them c:
2. 00:33:536 (2,3) - you have some more blankets that can be better, I really don't want to point them, but I feel is somethink that you should fix by yourself before this get ranked
3. 02:20:914 (3,2) - try to avoid the overlap here, doesn't look good imo
4. 02:27:866 (4,1) - is the first time you're using this kind of pattern I thing, I prefer if you stalk them instead to be consistent with the whole diff
5. 02:34:817 (4,1) - I feel this pattern really difficult to do for non experienced players, use a properly spacing instead IMO.
6. 02:45:792 (2,3,4) - similar as above, I feel a simple rhythm will be more suitable for this diff, try this:
   
   SPOILER

   
7. 02:56:036 this slider if offscreen, you should do something about this.
8. 04:02:622 (3,1) - same as hard diff, avoid staking repeat sliders, use a properly spacing instead, also is consistent with the whole diff

1. OD 1 is free acc, even for an Easy diff, use OD2 for better spread and for balance the settings
2. 03:39:939 (1,2) - spacing ~
3. 03:39:939 (1,2) - same as others diffs be sure to improve and fix some bad stacks and blankets
4. 01:35:548 (2,1) - I like your idea here, but I feel you can improve the blanket and shape of boths sliders
5. 01:51:646 (1) - rhythm here doesn't sound nice, since you're following the vocals most of the time, that's why this can be confuse for new players, try this instead (like you did here 02:22:195 (1) - ):
   
   SPOILER

   

Natsu wrote:

Hi from my Queue

General:

1. Artist: Tommy heavenly⁶
2. Romanised Artist: Tommy heavenly6
   http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tommy_heavenly6 fixed

Insane:

1. 00:04:817 (5) -I was expecting a jump here, since the music is strong and you did jumps with the others similar sounds, try something similar to this yeah i fixed this the previous mod:
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 00:07:561 (4,5) - this blanket is really off, use the approach circle of 4 to improve it fixed i think. i suck at blanketing.
3. 00:10:670 (6) - If you are aiming to stack this with previous 00:09:573 (2,3) - try to do it better fixed
4. 00:13:414 (1) - this slider doesn't fit the music, mainly cuz you're mapping a repeat in a stanza, beats like 00:13:597 - need a click action to represent better the music and bring a better gameplay experience IMO, try this: done
   
   SPOILER

   
5. 00:25:670 (2,3,4) - stack this properly, look really bad in game IMO fixed in previous mod
6. 00:28:780 (2) - witht his slider you're ignoring the important beat in 00:28:963 with drums and vocals, I know you really want to keep that pattern, try this: ehh the pattern isn't that important, remapped it.
   
   SPOILER

   
   
7. 00:51:280 (4) - mmm this rhythm doesn't follow the song nicely IMO, mainly cuz you are ignoring the important music and vocals in 00:51:463 -, this can work better: remapped
   
   SPOILER

   
8. 00:57:317 (2,3) - you have some more blankets that can be better, I really don't want to point them, but I feel is somethink that you should fix by yourself before this get ranked
9. 01:21:829 (2,2) - stack this properly fixed
10. 01:25:122 (1,4) - yep, you have some more bad stacks like this one, they can be consider nazis, but look bad in game <: I suggest you to take a look in your map and fix this small things for the sake of a better design fixed. i'll keep my eyes out for more
11. 01:39:573 (1) - similar to 00:13:414 -, just remove the repeat and add a circle in 01:39:939 - you'll follow the music better remapped
12. 01:43:963 (3,4,5,6,7) - here you're starting all the slider in weak beats and they end on the stronger ones, and for better rhythm sliders should start with heavy beats, my suggestion: remapped
    
    SPOILER

    
13. 02:36:097 mmm I really don't like your mini break here, that part can be mapped properly IMO, but this is my personally opinion since I dislike breaks /me hides I want at least one break so players can readjust themselves and this happened to be the least significant part of the song to me.
14. 02:58:140 should be a triplet here <: but I like how this plays T_T
15. 03:42:134 (6) - this slider is kinda hard to read due to it have more repeats than the others ones, also I feel the constant 1/4 drums there will be represent better as a circle stream imo done

Hard:

1. HP 7 is too much for a Hard diff, also is the same one as Insane diff, reduce the HP to 6 here for better diff spread okay fine i'll revert back to 6
2. 00:06:097 (4,1) - same as Insane about some blankets, try to improve them before some one come to bubble this <3 okay T_T
3. 00:23:292 (1,4) - try to avoid the overlap here it doesn't look good for me fixed
4. 00:24:939 (1) - same problem as insane in 00:13:414 fixed but i dont really like what i did with it. i'll revise later
5. 00:32:622 (1,2,3) - you have some not properly stacks in the whole diff, but will be really nazi to point all of them, take a quick look in this diff and fix them c: i think i've fixed all of them
6. 00:37:744 (4,1) - this slider with multiple repeats is stacked in the other one and that's not cool in my opinion, sine there is not way to know how many repeats it have, will be cool if you space it properly like you did with 00:37:744 (4,1) - you posted the same times :3
7. 01:00:975 (5,6,7,1) - I feel this part is really hard to be played for a Hard diff, what about to change the rhythm to a more suitable one? my suggestion: done
   
   SPOILER

   
8. 01:05:548 (1,2) - stack this properly hue
9. 01:07:012 (6,1) - same as 00:37:744 -, also I feel 2 repeat sliders fit better the music, as my previous example ^ ^
10. 01:11:951 (6,1) - swap NC ^
11. 01:18:536 (4,5,6) - I don't get your rhythm here, since the first repeat is starting in a blue tick and it will make it really hard to play, try this: done
    
    SPOILER

    
12. 01:19:451 (1) - the spinner should start 1/4 back in 01:19:359 -, following the hold feeling of the vocals which is starting in 01:19:268 yeah i thought so aswell
13. 01:30:609 (1,1) - same as 00:37:744 ok
14. 02:05:548 (5,1) - ^ ^
15. 02:23:109 (6,1) - ^ ^
16. 02:34:908 (5) - the previous hitburst of 02:34:908 (5) - overlap the repeat of 02:34:908 (5),try to rearrange some stuff and make it noticeable Not really sure what you're asking me to do
17. 02:52:561 (4,1) - 02:52:561 (4,1) - ?
18. 03:12:683 (4,5,6) - probably too difficult for a hard diff imo, try this instead: fixed but ill probably change the pattern soon
    
    SPOILER

    
19. 03:17:805 (2,5) - avoid the overlap if is posible fixed
20. 03:18:811 (5,1) - same as 00:37:744 ok
21. 03:24:573 (5,6) - ^ ^
22. 03:30:426 (7,1) - ^ ^
23. 03:47:987 (5,1) - Yeah this one play better cuz you're using a properly spacing instead of the stack, in this way you can follow the approach rate to read how many repeats it have
24. 03:59:786 (5,6,7,1) - this look really hard to play, but probably is fine as it is looks fine to me

Normal:

1. 00:14:329 (5,1) - you have some not properly stacks in the whole diff, but will be really nazi to point all of them, take a quick look in this diff and fix them c:
2. 00:33:536 (2,3) - you have some more blankets that can be better, I really don't want to point them, but I feel is somethink that you should fix by yourself before this get ranked
3. 02:20:914 (3,2) - try to avoid the overlap here, doesn't look good imo gonna keep this as it is for now before im too lazy to change
4. 02:27:866 (4,1) - is the first time you're using this kind of pattern I thing, I prefer if you stalk them instead to be consistent with the whole diff ok
5. 02:34:817 (4,1) - I feel this pattern really difficult to do for non experienced players, use a properly spacing instead IMO. ok
6. 02:45:792 (2,3,4) - similar as above, I feel a simple rhythm will be more suitable for this diff, try this: done
   
   SPOILER

   
7. 02:56:036 this slider if offscreen, you should do something about this. it's not offscreen for me
8. 04:02:622 (3,1) - same as hard diff, avoid staking repeat sliders, use a properly spacing instead, also is consistent with the whole diff ok

Easy:

1. OD 1 is free acc, even for an Easy diff, use OD2 for better spread and for balance the settings done
2. 03:39:939 (1,2) - spacing ~ fixed
3. 03:39:939 (1,2) - same as others diffs be sure to improve and fix some bad stacks and blankets
4. 01:35:548 (2,1) - I like your idea here, but I feel you can improve the blanket and shape of boths sliders
5. 01:51:646 (1) - rhythm here doesn't sound nice, since you're following the vocals most of the time, that's why this can be confuse for new players, try this instead (like you did here 02:22:195 (1) - ): ok
   
   SPOILER

   

Nice mapset! GL in rank Thanks

Kenssai wrote:

M4M request :3!!

[Easy]
00:46:890 (3) - to 00:46:707 ?
00:47:256 (1) - start at 00:47:073 to 00:47:622
00:55:305 (2) - delete slider, replace it by a circle and put it at 00:55:487
00:56:036 (3) - start it at 00:55:853 to 00:56:402
00:58:597 (2) - replace by slider 00:58:231 to 00:58:597
01:10:305 (2) - delete, move 01:10:670 (1) to 01:09:939 to 01:11:036, reverse the slider at 01:10:487
01:51:646 (1,2,3,4) - move it at 01:51:463
02:00:426 (1) - start at 02:00:244 + same length
02:02:987 (3,1) - start at 02:02:805
02:14:695 (2,1) - start at 02:14:512
02:16:341 (2,1) - too close, might scare beginner
02:22:195 (1) - start at 02:22:012 to 02:22:744
02:23:109 (2) - make it a cicle at that time
02:23:841 (1) - no reverse and start it at 02:23:475 to 02:24:573
02:26:768 (1) - start it at 02:26:585 to 02:26:951
02:27:500 (2) - delete circle and put a slider instead that start at 02:27:317 to 02:27:683
02:54:207 (2) - end at 02:54:939
03:27:866 (2,1) - start it at 03:27:683
03:51:280 (3,1) - start it at 03:51:097

sorry, no change in Easy

[Normal]
00:20:914 (1) - make it one tick longer i prefer to stop on the clap
00:23:109 - add a circle i'd rather avoid making this harder
00:50:914 (2) - put it at 00:50:731 i'm gonna keep as is
01:02:622 (2) - put it at 01:02:439 ^
01:45:061 (3) - no reverse, end at 01:45:426 ^
02:14:329 (3) - change to to a slider start at 02:14:146 to 02:14:512 ^
02:57:500 (2) - make it one tick longer i want to end the slider on the clap
03:08:475 (2) - change to a normal slider start at 03:08:292 to 03:08:658 i did this so it'd be easier to hitsound :3
03:20:183 (2) - change it to a slider that start at 03:20:000 to 03:20:366 ^
03:31:890 (2) - change it to a slider that start at 03:31:707 to 03:32:073 ^

no change in Normal

[Hard]
00:19:451 (1,2,3,4) - could make a jump i prefer anti-jumps
00:23:292 (1) - reverse slider, it will have the same length sure
01:35:183 (4) - replace the start and end by circle fine as is
01:35:548 (1,2,3,4) - make a jump same reason as last time
01:38:292 (5) - make this 2 tick longer so delete this 01:38:658 (1) i'd be missing some beats then
01:47:256 (1,2,3,4) - make a jump same reason as above
01:50:000 (5) - make this 2 tick longer so delete this 01:50:366 (1) same reason as above
01:52:926 (6) - make this 2 tick longer so delete this 01:53:292 (1) ^
01:53:475 (2) - delete this and use the 3 tick for 3 circles fine as is
02:17:987 (1) - no reverse, so slider will be halfed and add 4 circles afterit follows the music nicely as it is
02:54:481 - add circle here i don't hear anything to map there
02:54:664 - ^ ^
03:59:786 (5) - replace slider by 3 circles i prefer my way
04:02:896 - add circle here i don't hear anything to map here
03:36:189 - ^ ^
04:02:622 (4) - replace slider by 3 prefer as is circles

[Insane]
00:33:536 (4) - stop it at 00:33:719 and add a circle here 00:33:902 i think its fine as is because its not that significant of a sound and it'd match the vocals better
00:53:658 - add another circle here~ there's no sound to support a circle there
01:09:207 (6) and 01:09:390 (7) - switch places I feel like its fine as is
01:42:408 - add circle here i don't hear any sounds to map here either
03:01:890 (6) - make it shorter to 03:02:073 same as 00:33:536
03:02:256 - add a circle
03:02:622 (8) and 03:02:987 (1) - switch place fine as is

No change here either

Good luck for ranking it xD

Naitoshi wrote:

Yo dude, you asked me for a nazi. Ask and ye shall receive... but you forgot that I'm still bad at modding So pretty much all of this is aesthetics... (which I kinda feel bad for buuuut w/e)

[Easy]
00:22:195 (2) - I'm not sure if this was meant to be a blanket or not, but you should make it one (approach circle for guidance)

Bad example box

00:24:939 (2,1) - You could curve one more to look like it blankets 2

this is also a bad example cause I lazy

If you use this example then you will have to adjust other things to keep ds constant.

00:42:683 (2,3) - this blanket is off by 2 pixles. you could remove grid snap and set the bottom anchor on 2 to 297 , 144

SPOILER

00:58:963 (3) - make this less curved for a better blanket

01:19:268 (1) - this isn't symmetrical, move the red tick closer to the slider head. Even if it was intentional, it'd probably look better if it was symmetrical

01:35:548 (2,1) - so close but not quite :<

01:52:378 (2,4) - this overlapping doesn't look great

02:00:426 (1) - red just a tiny bit closer to slider head

02:33:353 (2) - a bit less curved for a better blanket

02:35:366 (1) - why finish this slider end?

02:44:329 (1,2) - a bit closer? you'd only have to move 2's middle anchor

eeex

02:49:817 (3,1) - lol by one pixel I won't ask you to change this, just putting out this extreme super nazi

02:58:963 (1) - maybe have this a bit higher so it doesn't overlap with 02:57:134 (2) - this is noticeable in game

03:24:573 (2,1) - eh this just looks a bit shloppy is all

03:27:866 (2,1) - fix blanketo

03:47:073 (2,1) - maybe not have these overlap?? somehow?

03:51:280 (3,1) - also a bit off

03:55:670 (2,3) - less curved for a better blanket

annd ohnnnn to the next diff

[Normal]
00:07:744 (3,4) - less curvature for a better blanket

00:14:329 (5,1) - lol it's ok, slider ends never stack properly cause gay =-= I hate this problem

00:20:914 (1,3) - just a bit off. Move 1's lower anchor to the left just a tinnssie bit like one px

00:39:756 (1,2) - probably intentional, buut it could be a blanket if you wanted it to be

00:47:987 (3,2) - ohhh more curvature for a better blanket

more bad examples from the wizard of band examples

01:19:268 - maybe you could add a circle here and then have the spinner go right after it? I dunno I feel that it should be clicked

01:49:634 (2,3) - just a bit off, use approach circle for guidance

02:02:805 (1,3) - I can't tell if these were meant to be or not. But you could :>

02:07:195 (3,1) - same with these. for this one then the 3 could be more curved for a better blanket

02:28:048 (1) - more curved for a better blanket

OMG THIS IS THE SH*TTIEST EXAMPLE SO FAR

02:53:109 (1,3) - these overlap a bit

02:58:048 (3) - you could make sliders like these less lop-sided if ya know what I mean:

they could look a bit better is all

03:36:280 (3) - less curved for better blanket on slider end

These examples keep getting worse

04:00:244 (4,1,2,1) - these overlaps could be confusing for players to play and they don't look to great imo... you should space these sliders out

[Hard]
00:07:012 (2,3) - It's not a blanket right now but it could be

eh still bad ex

00:11:219 (1,2,3,4) - Try to have even spaced circles? It looks kinda shloopy

not bad example

00:12:866 (2,3) - blanket a bit off, use 3 approach circle for guidance

00:29:695 (1,2) - ^ same

rawr

00:43:231 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - use ds to space these evenly, looks kinda shlooepmdk

00:51:463 (4,5) - fix blanket approachie for guidie

00:52:195 (1,5) - this is a weird overlap, not asking you to fix it, just throwing it out there

00:54:024 (2,3) - off blanket, use slider follow circle for guidance

Randy pls

00:57:317 (2,3) - fixie fixie

01:00:244 (3,4) - this too if it's suppose to be one

02:21:829 (2,3) - notable one. use approachie

02:29:695 (1,2,1,2,1) - I'm not sure if this is rankable or not @-@ ... don't mind me actually. it plays fine

02:41:402 (1,2) - Usssseeeee the slider follow circle for guidance

02:47:256 (2,3) - how about copy and paste one of these for the other one? It looks weird that they're different sliders

rawr

03:26:585 (3,4) - probably wasn't meant to be a blanket, but could be

03:52:926 (5,6) - fixie

04:01:890 (2) - nice blanket

onnn to the first diff I saw oeeoeopeaeo

[Knottsane]
00:07:561 (4,5) - could be better but close enough...

00:23:841 (1) - adjust this to blanket 00:23:109 (4) - better

00:31:158 (2,3,4,5) - you probably won't change this: just pointing out that they aren't parallel

00:46:707 (8,1) - weird overlap

00:52:378 (7,8,9,1) - yes these could all be better too

00:52:378 (7,9) - and btw these don't stack

01:19:817 (2,3,4) - really Randy? I smiley face? too pro 4 me

01:21:463 (1,4) - overlapss

01:50:183 (1,2,3,4,5) - this is confusing to play mostly because of the 2 is stacked with the slider end of 5... you can fix this like this

ctrl g all the circasldie

if you use this example, you'll have to adjust the other thing after 5 so it isn't such a big jump

02:14:878 (6,1) - fixie, almost

02:28:048 (4,2) - overlap, could place 2 and the stream lower to avoid it

03:08:658 (3,4,5) - just throwing this overlap out dere too

03:43:780 (6,1) - fix blanket

04:04:634 (5,1) - ^ if meant to be



whewww obviously I didn't cover alllll of the blankets but that was a good sum of them. I think you should take the time to go over your entire mapset and just nazi it too. If you have questions ask me in game o3o I'll probably point out some other things I didn't cover cause... I wasn't sure of myself?

Knotts wrote:

Fixed everything except for the things that I didn't fix.

No Dap wrote:

IRC mod

SPOILER

11:32 Knotts: yo, im ready for that mod
11:32 No Dap: give me a second
11:41 No Dap: can you np
11:41 *Knotts is listening to [http://osu.ppy.sh/b/396366 Tommy heavenly6 - PAPERMOON]
11:44 No Dap: can just irc mod
11:44 No Dap: i don't see a lot
11:44 Knotts: alright sure
11:44 No Dap: 00:17:987 (1,2) - something happened here
11:45 No Dap: spacing 
11:46 Knotts: duno how that happened. fixed
11:47 No Dap: 00:23:841 (1) - shouldn't this end on red tick?
11:47 No Dap: oh nvm
11:47 No Dap: 00:29:329 (3) - clap ?
11:47 Knotts: added
11:49 No Dap: 01:03:170 (1) - is this NC pattern change on purpose?
11:49 Knotts: oh, just changed it right now :3
11:50 No Dap: you deleted it?
11:50 Knotts: changed the NCs around
11:50 No Dap: I would keep the same pattern
11:50 No Dap: which seems to be every 2 tanza
11:50 No Dap: like 00:57:317 (1,2,3,4) - 
11:51 No Dap: 00:54:390 (1) - thi well
11:51 No Dap: your kiai NC seems a bit inconsistent
11:51 No Dap: they are consistent in the kiai but why the change?
11:52 No Dap: combos are too short and it's making kiai easier
11:52 Knotts: yeah idk, i have no idea how to combo
11:52 No Dap: do you see big white ticks
11:52 No Dap: on the timeline
11:53 No Dap: http://puu.sh/8hEr2.jpg this is your NC pattern
11:53 No Dap: every 2 big white tick NC
11:53 No Dap: 00:38:475 (1,2,3) - 
11:53 No Dap: 00:41:402 (1,2,3) - 
11:53 No Dap: all before until kiai
11:54 Knotts: so i was doing it right there ^?
11:54 No Dap: yeah
11:55 No Dap: 00:50:183 (1,2,3,4) - this was fine
11:55 No Dap: but
11:55 No Dap: 00:53:841 (2,1) - from here
11:55 No Dap: evreything changed
11:55 No Dap: 00:56:036 (3) - NC should start here
11:55 No Dap: not 00:54:390 (1) - 
11:55 No Dap: 00:58:963 (3) - same reason
11:55 No Dap: no nc here 00:57:317 (1) - 
11:56 No Dap: its not a big deal but you're giving way too much HP for plyaers
11:56 Knotts: alright so im basically counting any white ticks and putting a NC on the 9th one
11:56 No Dap: and they are too short
11:56 No Dap: yes
11:57 Knotts: what about 01:13:597 (1,2,3)  - that kinda breaks the pattern
11:58 Knotts: do i just restart my count from 01:17:622 (1) 
11:58 No Dap: yeah
11:58 No Dap: 01:17:622 (1) - 
11:59 No Dap: 01:33:719 (3) - clap?
11:59 No Dap: or was this intentional
12:00 Knotts: sometimes osu deletes my hitsounds when i update :3
12:00 No Dap: lol
12:01 No Dap: 01:51:097 (4,1) - do you have any other stacked notes?
12:02 Knotts: nope zzz
12:02 No Dap: then it's probably a good idea not to have any
12:03 No Dap: you're already using lots of notes that start on red tick (because of music :3) so it's already pretty complex for beginners
12:03 No Dap: id prefer if you don't stack
12:15 Knotts: alright i pretty much fixed all the comboing in Easy
12:16 No Dap: 02:04:634 (2) - shouldn't there be clap on end
12:16 No Dap: feels really empty
12:17 Knotts: sounds weird with a clap on the end though
12:18 No Dap: probably becuase vocal starts on02:05:548 -  
12:18 No Dap: 02:05:731 - but i do hear clap on the bgm
12:19 Knotts: well if you say so i guess ill put it 
12:20 No Dap: 02:16:341 (2) - this reverse 
12:20 No Dap: makes 1/2 on02:16:341 (2) - 02:16:341 (2) - 
12:20 No Dap: wot
12:20 No Dap: 02:17:805 - 02:17:987 - 
12:20 No Dap: how about this http://puu.sh/8hGfI.jpg
12:20 No Dap: 02:17:622 - vocal ends here also
12:22 Knotts: what do i do about 02:16:341 (1)  - just remove the repeat?
12:22 No Dap: remove repeat
12:22 No Dap: 02:17:622 - and add a circle
12:23 No Dap: you might have to tweak this whole part a little 
12:23 No Dap: starting 02:15:061 (1) - here i guess
12:25 Knotts: fixed
12:26 No Dap: 03:35:366 (1) - le spacing
12:27 No Dap: other than that easy seems god
12:27 No Dap: good
12:28 *No Dap is editing [http://osu.ppy.sh/b/388445 Tommy heavenly6 - PAPERMOON [Normal]]
12:28 No Dap: let me know when youre ready
12:28 Knotts: ready
12:29 No Dap: 00:26:585 (2) - spacing
12:29 Knotts: fixed
12:29 No Dap: 00:29:695 (1,2,3) - this part sounds off to me
12:30 No Dap: http://puu.sh/8hGTo.jpg i find this more fitting
12:30 No Dap: 00:30:609 - because this drum sounds strong to me 00:30:609 - 
12:36 Knotts: well i g2g out to eat.. again. just post this and anything else you want on thread
12:36 No Dap: ok

[Normal]

1. 00:42:683 (2) - check spacing here fixed previously
2. 02:11:219 (3) - this clap on tail doesn't sound very fitting removed
3. 02:15:975 (1) - check spacing here fixed
4. 02:45:792 (3) - consider adding finish on tail. as it is clearly in the bgm added
5. 02:55:670 (1) - this shouldn't be a big deal, but why the inconsistent spacing? adjusted
6. 03:42:134 (3) - I don't see why you would start this slider here. starting 03:41:951 - would follow vocal more.
   I would do this done
   
   SPOILER

   
7. 03:43:414 (2) - this clap on tail doesn't sound fitting removed
8. 03:48:353 (4) - forgot clap? oops

[Hard]

1. Seems pretty challenging. Consider reducing HP by 1 tick for smoother play changed this too many times; im just gonna stick to 6 until a BAT tells me otherwise
2. 00:19:451 (1,2,3,4) - I personally don't think this is a good place to put anti jump. as you are ignoring all those drums in the music. But it's your choice keeping for now. i like me some anti jumps
3. 00:23:292 (1) - missing clap on head fixed
4. 00:25:305 (2) - clap doesn't sound good here removed
5. 00:39:756 (2,3,4) - this flow is awkward. I'd move 00:40:305 (3) - like this for better flow mehh i think its fine but i think i tweaked it a little. i dont remember what i had before lol.
   
   SPOILER

   
6. 01:00:975 (5) - clap doesn't sound good here removed
7. 01:01:890 (1,2) - this jump seems a bit harsh for a hard diff i don't think 2.0x DS is too big a jump for a hard but i'll reduce it if it comes up again
8. 01:13:597 (1) - to 01:17:987 (3) - , I think if you put clap on every white tick, it would follow music better as you did on all other diffs done
9. 01:23:109 - no need to start break here. just start it here 01:22:378 - and if you did this on any other diff consider fixing them too fixed on Hard and Normal
10. 01:35:548 (1,2,3,4) - same as i pointed out on 00:19:451 (1,2,3,4) - same
11. 01:47:256 (1,2,3,4) - ^ ^
12. 01:58:231 (2) - delete clap? ok
13. 02:31:890 (1,2,3) - add clap? ^
14. 02:34:634 (4) - you should add clap on tail because it sounds very weird only having them on 02:34:908 (5) - ^
15. 03:02:439 (5) - clap on tail as music? ^
16. 03:32:439 (4) - this clap on tail sound wierd removed
17. 03:56:768 - 03:56:951 - 03:57:134 - add clap? done
18. 03:58:231 (7) - there should be clap according to music i added a clap and finish
19. 04:07:926 (7,8,9) - consider reducing spacing a bit here. They seem too harsh for an ending reduced

[Insane]

1. OD 8 ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥
2. 00:43:231 (4) - this stacked note feels really weird and also giving bad flow. I'd prefer if you just stack on 00:42:683 (3) - tail i did something else, hopefully i didn't make it worse.
3. 00:44:146 (9) - delete clap? sounds wierd i have a clap on 00:43:963 (9) and they have identical sounds so it'd only make sense to have a clap on both
4. 00:51:097 (3) - forgot clap on tail oops
5. 00:54:024 (3,4) - This would be better to play and more intuitive if you let players click on vocal like this. done
   
   SPOILER

   
6. 00:54:756 (6,7) - ^ ^
7. 01:12:500 (7,8) - flow here seems a bit awkward. If you agree, don't hesitate to rearrange them i like it as it is now but i fixed that ugly blanket to something less ugly.
8. 01:15:975 (6) - clap missing according to 02:32:073 - yup
9. 02:14:878 (6,1) - stack nazi. stack on 02:13:414 (1) - ? it wasnt meant to be a stack but i guess it is now
10. 02:31:158 (5) - clap missing on tail fixed
11. 02:34:634 (3) - consider adding clap here also. as i said in hard diff 02:34:634 (4) - okie

Good luck

Yuzu- wrote:

Hey~ From my modding queue

Easy

1- 00:03:170 (1) - Try to curve this a bit more. Should be going right into 2 but it's missing it for just a bit adjusted
2- 00:14:878 (1,2,3) - try to have 00:14:878 (1) blanketing 00:16:524 (2), if you find a way to do it without ruining the structure with 00:16:890 (3). that's what i was thinking at first but i couldnt find a way but after looking at it again i easily did it :3
3- Maybe remove NC from 00:53:109 (1) and put it on 00:54:390 (3), then remove NC on 00:56:036 (1) i'm having a NC every two stanzas so i'm gonna keep as is to keep my comboing consistent (unless i'm doing it wrong).
4- 01:48:719 (1) - Could be a bit better curved. adjusted a little
5- 02:17:987 (3) - invert concavity? i think this is fine as it is
6- 03:03:170 (2) - Since there's no real pattern involved with 03:03:170 (2), improve this curve into 03:04:085 (3) adjusted

Probably one of the smallest mods on an Easy difficulty I've done so far. Good job.

Normal

1- 00:02:622 (5) - Improve curve adjusted
2- 00:04:817 (3) - ^ on both i think these are fine
3- 00:26:036 (4) - ^ ^
4- 00:28:231 (3) - ^ ^
5- 00:56:036 (1) - ^ too curved. since 00:55:670 (5) is there, you'll have to change 00:56:036 (1) so that the blanket stays and the curve is fixed. Since 00:56:951 (2,3) could be better as well, do this: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/1537439. Not perfect, but best possible solution. adjusted
6- 01:10:122 (5) - lower slider direction and it'll be just fine i think i did what you were asking me to do
7- 01:40:487 (2) - just a liiiitle bit more curved adjusted
8- 02:03:353 (1,2) - Rotate 02:03:353 (1) clockwise, readjust 02:04:085 (2) and rotate it clockwise as well, and you'll keep the 2-slider pattern and have 02:04:085 (2) going into 02:04:634 (3) just fine. i think its fine but next time can you post a screenshot so i can see what you were envisioning? it'd be really helpful!
9- 02:16:341 (2) - Oops, too curved. i think it flows fine even curved like this
10- 03:45:792 (1) - could be a bit more curved. adjusted a little

Just small things, overall it's a great difficulty as well.

Great song, great maps~ Good luck, and have a sparkling star~

Mao wrote:

Req by PM, sorry for the delay :c

1. Unrankable Issue
2. Recommended to fix
3. Highly Suggested
4. Suggestion
5. Just my own opinion / Comment

General

1. Delete the .osb file from your folder.

Easy

1. 00:04:085 (2,3,4) - I'd suggest you mapping this like you did for 00:09:939 (2,3) - . This sounds a lot better! did something similar i think
2. 00:53:841 (2,3) - The polarity issue beteen these could easily be fixed if you map it like: done
   
   Screenshot

   
3. The overall map is okay to me even though I don't really like your timeline. I don't know, it just uses so much red tick stuff which is due to the song but you've already used a lot of red ticks in your Normal and this easy contains just a few less. You can try to avoid mapping that many red ticks. Lemme take an example:
   01:11:951 (3) - If you lsiten to the music you can hear that the vocals for example are pretty strong on the previous white tick. So we can map the strong vocals on this one and ignore them at the following red tick.
   
   Screenshot

   
   Another thing bothering me is that you really seem to love S-Shaped Sliders but they always look a bit messy in your map, so I'll give you a little advice how to make S-Sliders look good C:
   
   Screenshot

   
   Legend to the above Screenshot

   Green - try to keep these lines parallel
   Pink - About the same distance from the borders
   Brown - The middle line should go through the slider tick (you have to estimate it's location if it isn't there)
   Purple - Try to keep the last anchor point on the centre of the slider's tail

Normal

1. 00:21:829 (2) - I actually missed this note due to it being on the red tick. It felt kinda weird to me, probably because it's a polarity issue. Maybe something as shown in the screenshot below could help. done
   
   Screenshot

   
2. 00:26:585 (1) - 1,30 DS far away from the previous one? o-o Consider changing this. It looks and palys a bit weird due to the rest having a consistent spacing. oops, fixed
3. 01:37:926 (2,3) - The stack here feels a bit weird here. You always stacked notes that were 1/2, so it might confuse newer players to have a 1/1 stack here. changed
4. 02:15:975 (1) - Same as I said before. I find this a bit weird to hit, so it'd suggest you placing a 1/2 slider from the previous white tick to this red tick. ^
5. 02:18:536 (5) - Shorten this to the red tick since the vocals on the red tick are really strong. There wont be any polarity issues either. Same goes for 02:19:268 (1) - done
   
   Screenshot

   
6. 03:05:000 (6) - Unneeded inherited section *o* deleted
7. 03:14:512 (2) - +0,05 to your usual spacing. Don't you think it's a bit high spaced? Consider adjusting the spacing here a bit for better readability for newer palyers. reduced spacing
8. 03:23:292 (2) - Why is the spacing to the next object so low? Might be confusing for newer players. oops, fixed
9. 03:41:951 (4) - Move this to 199|165 to get a kind of circular movement for better flow C: done
10. Seems nice to me. I don't like having 1/1 and 1/2 stacks in one and the same Normal since it can confuse some newbies but well, keep it if you want.

Hard

1. I don't know, HP6 is a bit High. I'd suggest you to decrease it by one because it is such an easy diff :c too many suggested changes at this. im just going to keep it at 6 until a BAT tells me otherwise
2. 00:04:634 (4) - Try to keep the spacing consistent here. A jump from the previous tick over to here doesn't really fit to me especially since the following big white tick has a way bigger emphasis, so why aren't the distances consistent here? there isn't a jump here
3. 00:11:219 (7,8,9,10) - A real square would increase the look of this pattern a lot since these look a bit as you tried to do a square but failed. Use "Create Polygon Circles".
4. 00:16:341 (4) - Again this unconsistent spacing. I've also got a little suggestion here in terms of placement: adjusted
   
   Screenshot

   
5. 00:33:536 (3,4) - These objects are 1/2 and aren't stacked properly. Looks pretty messed up in play.fixed
6. 00:58:963 (1) - Move to something about 317|25, make some adjustements and see, it will be an equal triangle C: done
7. 01:45:792 (1) - Why does this use the old slider algorithm? idk but i fixed
8. 02:34:634 (7,8) - The transition here confused me a bit in playtest. Clicking on the blue tick feels a bit unnatural to me here since the emphasis on the white tick is stronger than on the blue one. Consider changing the timeline as I show in the screenshot below. done
   
   Screenshot

   
9. 02:43:414 (4) - The gaps between the objects are almost the same but timeline based the previous is 1/2 and the following is 1/1. I thought the next object was 1/2 so I was kinda confused after I noticed it was 1/1. Consider making a bigger gap here. i meant for it to kinda play like an anti jump
10. 02:49:817 (8,1) - Make these two parallel. since so many people requested i guess ill finally make them parallel
11. 03:36:829 (10,11,1) - These aren't stacked properly. Especially for 1/4 it's really weird x-x
12. 03:55:122 (2,3,4) - This looks a bit messy due to 3 completely different slider shapes trying to look like being rotated. How about using one slider rotated instead of 3 different sliders? done
13. 03:59:786 (9) - Stack issue to the following object is pretty weird with 1/4 :C fixed
14. There are loads of parts that I wasn't able to enjoy while playing due to some messed up spacing. In normal spacing patterns there is a variation from +-0,10 DS which shouldn't be the case for these patterns. I mean it's a Hard and jumps are okay, but distance variation like this looks really messy and random to me since I didn't really found out about a scheme. There were the same parts mapped with completely different spacing, varying the spacing even in curves of circles. Well I guess it's just not my taste :/

Insane

1. 00:18:536 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - Is it just me or didn't you use "Create Polygon Circles" here? If you didn't consider using it! only 00:18:719 (3,4,5,6,7) - is supposed to be a pentagon and it looks fine to me
2. 00:28:963 (8) - This slider looks kinda like a ball. Consider changing the strack as I show in the screenshot below for better aesthetics. adjusted a little
   
   Screenshot

   
3. 00:34:085 (5,6,7) - The variation of Spacing here compared to 00:33:170 (2,3) - stood out to me a lot while playing. I don't really see an increase in the music that tells you to vary the spacing here. Maybe change it for consitency. i reduced the spacing a little
4. 00:36:646 - According to your usual clap pattern there should be a clap here, don't you think so? i don't use a clap pattern, i just put one whenever i hear one and i dont hear one there
5. 01:03:719 (7,8) - These are basically almost the same as 00:52:012 (5,6,7) - , so why didn't you map it like this? If you take a look at 01:03:719 (7) - you can hear that the vocals are really strong on the red tick the slider ends on. So in my opinion it would be better if you map it with a circle, as you did before. i'm gonna keep as is for not but i guess if someone brings it up again i'll change it. i dont think its too necessary to copy other sections on Insanes too often.
6. 01:36:280 (8,9) - These sliders don't really fit each other to me because the one is curved a lot as the other is almost straight. I'd suggest you to replace 9 with a rotated version of 8 or you just simply curve 9 a bit more. done
7. 02:35:366 (1) - This is a nice slider but maybe it could be even better giving the first part which is straight by now a little curve. done
8. 02:42:866 (4,5) - The spacing here felt a bit weird to me due to the 5 being so close to 4. Using a DS from 1,25 or so as you did before could work here as well.
   [/color]
9. 02:51:829 (5,7) - As much as I can see you've spaced these 2 like a stream, but why didn't you use the same spacing for 02:52:561 (1) - ? It would make the transition look a lot better and cleaner here. it looks the same to me. if you could provide a screenshot of what you were thinking of i'd appreciate it
10. 03:09:390 (5) - The spacing here isn't constant with the others! You've used 0,80 DS for 1/4 stuff like this. Why did you use 0,40 here? Consider changing it to 0,80.
11. 03:25:305 (1) - ^
12. 03:28:780 (3) - Replacing this with a 120° rotated version of 03:28:414 (2) - could make a better trnasition here if you place it a bit higher than the old one for a kind of circular movement C:
    
    Screenshot

    
13. 03:35:183 (4) - Maybe you can stack this with 03:33:719 (8) - :c
14. 03:59:512 (8,9,10,11) - Spacing these all with 0,80 would make the part more consistent since it's all 1/4 it should be spaced the same way! spaced
15. Nice Stream Shapes and overall flow! Some spacing is a bit unconsitent and feels a bit random to me though :c

Please reply! I hope it was helpful and good luck! :3

• here's my mod !!
  
  General
  
  so, lets take conclusion for all of your map.
  
  1. slightly improve hitsound, it makes map better than just a silent hit following song rhytm.
  2. at some point, you seems slightly not following the song.

CDFA wrote:

Dank.

Insane:
00:02:439 (1) - It's sort of weird how this end on the blue tick, but it'd be weird to start the stream on the blue tick too. weird indeed
00:07:744 (5) - This would probably be better being more cohesive with the previous notes in the combo, rather than just being a random curve slider. yeah i was waiting for someone to tell me this sucked. changed.
00:24:939 (4) - Remove the clap since it doesn't go with the timing? idk how that got there. removed
00:39:207 (4) - It might be cool to reimagine this so it's not so boxy. It's a tight curve for the wrist to make and looks and plays better if it's not overlapping with (1) curved it up and no overlap
00:44:878 (2,3,4,5) - This is cool and all but like what purpose does it have? It may be me being stuck in 2012, but pointless jumps are sort of odd, especially for a transitional unhitsounded area. get with the time pls, its 2014... changed T_T
01:03:170 (4,5,6) - This sort of bugs me because you're following the drums here, but there's no real drum action, but (6) is so far away from (5). It's sort of unfitting. ok
01:15:244 (6) - Same as before, random jump in a pretty not so impactful area (Also it's not centered with the two diagonal lines ) i reduced the spacing a bit so it doesn't play like a jump. i think.
From this point onward, just gonna skip making this post super huge and i'll say that jumps should have a purpose. "Making it harder" isn't really a valid excuse ;w;.
01:30:975 (1) - This is a cool slider but (2) has no coherence to it. If this was going in sort of a path, this would be fine, but they're just begging to be made parallel.
01:51:463 (1) - Parallell ;w; i actually prefer to have this not parallel because it looks/flows cool to me.
02:17:987 (1) - Sort of bugs me because directionally I want to go to the left, but I'm jerked both to the right and down, neither of which I naturally want to go to. idk how the slider got curved but i made it parallel instead
02:36:463 - Go ahead and map this ;w;. I know that it's cool to have breaks and all and I totally agree but like it just is sort of a weird place to put it. i thought it was a pretty solid spot to put a break but i guess not. i guess my maps not that hard so no one needs a break anyways.
03:01:158 (7) - Even out the spacing go go go ;w; them ghost be moving my stuff.
03:09:024 (4) - No fun overlap ;www; i think its fun but i guess if someone else tells me it sucks i'll change it
03:22:012 (10) - ;W; i'm sorry T_T
03:28:780 (3) - Raise this up so (2) and this are making a U shape

Hard:
00:19:451 (1,2,3,4) - This would actually be pretty cool except that you've already established a sort of flowy drum-based kind of thing here, so this just feels out of place.
00:53:109 (1) - I'm actually completely fine with the whole diamond pattern, just center this so it looks pretty ;w; ok done
Second chorus is suspiciously copy-paste ;w;. but i didn't copy paste anything T_T
03:09:024 (5) - its ok make the triangle u can do it i think i did it but who knows.
03:30:426 (7) - ^ ^
03:44:695 (5) - Even out this spacing fixerino

Normal:
Huge diff jump ;w; dont say this pls. i don't want to remap
Not much specific

Easy:
01:53:841 (4) - Make these matchsies ;w; done

1. 00:35:000 (3,2) - move to x: 288, y:160
2. 01:40:670 (3,1) - not sure about this

1. 00:38:475 (1,2) - hard for beginner? this is the only time you use this overlay pattern in the whole song
2. 02:20:914 (3,4,1) - looks nice but can be confusing

1. 01:41:951 (5,1, 2) - use Ctrl+H for slider 1 (and other objects as needed) and stack circle 2 to previous circles?
2. 01:57:500 (1,4) - make this flow better
3. 02:30:426 (1) - Ctrl+G here

1. Everything looks OK!

Project Railgun wrote:

hello i am railgun

[Easy]

1. 00:35:000 (3,2) - move to x: 288, y:160 moved to stack properly
2. 01:40:670 (3,1) - not sure about this should be fine

[Normal]

1. 00:38:475 (1,2) - hard for beginner? this is the only time you use this overlay pattern in the whole song i'll change it if it comes up again
2. 02:20:914 (3,4,1) - looks nice but can be confusing ^

[Hard]

1. 01:41:951 (5,1, 2) - use Ctrl+H for slider 1 (and other objects as needed) and stack circle 2 to previous circles? fixed my own way
2. 01:57:500 (1,4) - make this flow better flows fine
3. 02:30:426 (1) - Ctrl+G here that'd make the flow really bad to play

[Insane]

1. Everything looks OK!

Good luck~

[Colours]
Combo1 : 149,74,55
Combo2 : 202,180,119
Combo3 : 230,115,0
Combo4 : 0,145,145 

waxman wrote:

QQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQQ

[Insane]

00:27:683 (4,5) - too far. 00:27:683 (4) - x:412 y:52 i think this is fine for now
00:30:426 (3,4) - take more distance. like 00:29:695 (1,2,3) done
00:47:256 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - SD 1.2x? fixed a little
01:15:792 (9,10) - take more distance.
01:36:097 (7,8) - miss spacing? take more distance increased

01:50:183 (6) - NC. because longest white line is here. im following a pattern of a NC every 2 stanzas
01:51:097 (11) - NC ^
01:51:463 (1) - remove NC^
02:04:634 (5) - NC. because SD of 02:04:634 (5,6,7) is different from 02:03:353 (1,2,3,4). and you added Finish on the beginning of 02:04:634 (5) i think you're talking about SV? if you are they have the same SV
02:08:109 (5) - NC? you know ^
02:14:512 (8) - x:168 y:120. Those spacing will be fine. cuz shape of 02:13:414 (4,5,6,7,8) is strange. instead i stacked on other circle
02:28:048 (4) - stack on 02:26:585 (10)? The end position of 02:28:048 (4) will be low. i think its fine as is
02:35:274 (11,1) - I think regular spacing is better. ?
02:59:512 (2,3) - move to x:330 y:310? For avoiding to overlap on 02:58:506 (9,10,11,12,13). i think its fine. the NC colors are really different so its easy to distinguish
03:07:286 (4) - Whistle it doesn't sound like a whistle would fit here
03:07:469 (5) - ^ ^
03:07:652 (6) - ^ ^
03:07:652 (6,1) - I like this one.(High recommended) looks weird to read, gonna keep as is.

bad image

03:08:292 (2,3,4) - like this? i think my way flows better

bad image

03:59:512 (8) - delete Clap? on end of slider
04:04:634 (5,6) - take mode distance changed

[Hard]

00:56:951 (2) - move to x:336 y:304 that'd ruin my jump and stack :3
00:57:866 (4) - move to x:176 y:336 that'd mess up the blanket
01:00:244 (4) - NC. cuz those spacing is different from here, and you added finish too. i dont think its necessary, i'll stick to a NC every 2 stanzas.
01:08:658 (2) - move to x:400 y:192. those spacing will be fine. instead i just stacked this on 8
01:11:951 (4,5) - rather shorter spacing. 1.24x DS isn't really that big of a space
01:12:683 (6) - NC i dont think its needed, it'd ruin my pattern of a NC every 2 stanzas
01:45:061 (7,8) - too close? i think its fine
02:05:548 (8,1) - too far, isn't it? i evened out the spacing
02:56:036 (1,2,3) - like this? no i meant for it to be like this

bad image

I'm done.
GOOD LUCK

1. 00:11:219 (7,8,9) - just a note here see these how you have big sounds on (7),(8) and (9)? it's really anti climatic to make the jumps a smaller distance from (8) to (9)
2. 00:16:524 (6) - i think this flows better if you curved the slider like this instead
   
   SPOILER

   
3. 00:17:439 (9) - this reverse slider just feels awkward as there is a strong vocal sound on the reverse
4. 03:39:756 (1) - ^ same idea
5. 03:45:609 (1) - ^
6. 03:51:463 (1) - ok in general, just keep finish notes on slider heads or circles >_<
7. 00:25:305 (6,7) - imo, this would look better if you had copied one of the sliders
8. 00:28:963 (8,9) - ^
9. 01:02:805 (3,4) - ^ (also fun fact, if you ctrl g the sliders back and forth it would fix up your slider points )
10. 03:59:512 (8,9) - ^
11. 00:31:158 (5,6) - can you make these more diverse? they're not suppose to be parallel but since they're so close to being parallel it's a bit bothering lol
12. 00:31:890 (7,8) - ^
13. 00:35:914 (3) - ctrl g MIGHT give a bit better flow and less awkward gameplay
14. 01:06:097 (4) - ^
15. 00:36:463 (4,6) - blanket owo?
16. 01:16:341 (1,2) - ^
17. 01:54:573 (1,2) - ^
18. 03:54:573 (1,2) - ^
19. 00:44:146 (11) - reposition this somewhere else as currently, the flow into (1) is not that great
20. 00:44:878 (2,6) - not too important but u could consider stacking
21. 01:03:719 (6,1) - ^
22. 01:01:341 (2,3,4,5) - ahh can u make this curve smoother >_<?
23. 01:07:195 (3,4,5,6) - ^
24. 01:21:646 - tbh i think this should be a circle for better emphasis instead of a slider end
    this also applies to other similar parts
25. 01:23:841 - ^
26. 01:41:951 (6) - i recommend you place it like this, that way it blankets (7) and also kinda gets blanketed by (5)
    
    SPOILER

    
27. 01:49:817 (5) - this isn't a very good place for a passive slider (strong beat on end)
28. 01:52:378 (4,5) - ^
29. 02:36:097 (3,4) - ^
30. 01:54:207 (4,5,6,7) - for these you can probably replace with 2 1/4 sliders so you can put some indication on the vocals
31. 02:36:097 (3,4) - how bout this? (dw about 4 going off screen, it won't be in game play)
    
    SPOILER

    
32. 03:41:219 (4,5,6) - keep spacing consistent?
33. 03:57:317 (1,4) - i think you should space out
34. I just realized, you have no breaks o_O i would REALLY strongly recommend you to add one or two

1. 00:01:524 (4,5,6) - how bout one of those triangle pattern things here? (copy one slider rotate 120, repeat once more)
2. 00:05:548 - same as in insane, i feel like a circle would be better for this
3. 00:17:256 (7,8) - again, copy paste one of the sliders, ctrl hj
4. 00:31:890 (8,9) - ^
5. 02:01:707 (5,6) - ^
6. 03:52:195 (2,3) - ^
7. 00:19:451 (1,2,3,4,1) - antijumps here feel a bit awkward >_< i dunno how to explain it. I just don't really feel the music stopping or slowing down you know what i mean?
8. 00:23:841 (1) - ctrl g will give better flow here
9. 01:19:268 - i feel like there needs to be a circle with NC here instead
10. 01:35:548 (1,2,3,4,1) - same as before, also, move (1) up a bit to make a straight line lol
11. 01:47:256 (1,2,3,4,1) - ^
12. 02:16:341 (4) - make this first curve with 2 slider points istead- makes blanket better. Also, expose the tail a bit more
13. 03:35:366 (4) - ^
14. 02:33:353 (3,6) - space out?
15. 03:32:439 (4,6) - ^

1. 00:30:426 (2) - move this 1/2 back and extend 00:29:695 (1) - by 1/2
2. 00:48:536 (4,1) - not a good overlap
3. 00:50:731 - with the second kiai, you placed a 1/1 slider here so i think you should do that here too
4. 03:31:707 - ^
   same goes with every other similar place
5. 03:01:890 (1,3) - again, the copy pasting thing
6. 03:03:902 (4) - this may be a bit confusing as there isn't a strong indication in the music for this circle
7. 03:11:585 - map this guitar out pls

1. 00:19:451 (2,1) - u could blanket the head of (1) with the last little curve of (2)?
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 00:32:622 (1,2) - blanket?
3. 01:50:000 (3) - btw the quality of your waves could be improved. do something more like this
   
   SPOILER

   
4. 02:54:207 (2) - ^here too
   
   SPOILER

   
   just improve all your wave sliders a bit lol

Really really good mapset! gogo rank it !

Kibbleru wrote:

m4m i guess owo
lol i ended up modding first

[Insane]

1. 00:11:219 (7,8,9) - just a note here see these how you have big sounds on (7),(8) and (9)? it's really anti climatic to make the jumps a smaller distance from (8) to (9) okie, spaced some more.
2. 00:16:524 (6) - i think this flows better if you curved the slider like this instead yup, changed
   
   SPOILER

   
3. 00:17:439 (9) - this reverse slider just feels awkward as there is a strong vocal sound on the reverse it doesn't sound awkward to me but ill go ask around about this later.
4. 03:39:756 (1) - ^ same idea yeah i understand this one
5. 03:45:609 (1) - ^ ^
6. 03:51:463 (1) - ok in general, just keep finish notes on slider heads or circles >_< ok
7. 00:25:305 (6,7) - imo, this would look better if you had copied one of the sliders done
8. 00:28:963 (8,9) - ^ ^
9. 01:02:805 (3,4) - ^ (also fun fact, if you ctrl g the sliders back and forth it would fix up your slider points ) ^ (:o didn't know that)
10. 03:59:512 (8,9) - ^ ^
11. 00:31:158 (5,6) - can you make these more diverse? they're not suppose to be parallel but since they're so close to being parallel it's a bit bothering lol fixed it up
12. 00:31:890 (7,8) - ^ ^
13. 00:35:914 (3) - ctrl g MIGHT give a bit better flow and less awkward gameplay doesn't feel awkward to play for me.
14. 01:06:097 (4) - ^ did this one
15. 00:36:463 (4,6) - blanket owo? fixed
16. 01:16:341 (1,2) - ^ this one's not really meant to be a blanket but i fixed it up a little
17. 01:54:573 (1,2) - ^ fixed
18. 03:54:573 (1,2) - ^ ^
19. 00:44:146 (11) - reposition this somewhere else as currently, the flow into (1) is not that great true dat
20. 00:44:878 (2,6) - not too important but u could consider stacking i remapped this part with your other suggestion.
21. 01:03:719 (6,1) - ^ i dont think this one's necessary since a good amount of time's already passed
22. 01:01:341 (2,3,4,5) - ahh can u make this curve smoother >_<? fixed i just learned about convert slider to stream xD
23. 01:07:195 (3,4,5,6) - ^ ^
24. 01:21:646 - tbh i think this should be a circle for better emphasis instead of a slider end
    this also applies to other similar parts true, true
25. 01:23:841 - ^ ^
26. 01:41:951 (6) - i recommend you place it like this, that way it blankets (7) and also kinda gets blanketed by (5) ok
    
    SPOILER

    
27. 01:49:817 (5) - this isn't a very good place for a passive slider (strong beat on end) im gonna keep this for now so i can keep my pentagon :3
28. 01:52:378 (4,5) - ^ ehh idk, i like the way it plays and it doesn't sound noticeably bad to me
29. 02:36:097 (3,4) - ^ ^
30. 01:54:207 (4,5,6,7) - for these you can probably replace with 2 1/4 sliders so you can put some indication on the vocals i like it, cool idea though i may have ruined your idea with my crappy placement. i'll probably end up rearranging it later.
31. 02:36:097 (3,4) - how bout this? (dw about 4 going off screen, it won't be in game play) ok
    
    SPOILER

    
32. 03:41:219 (4,5,6) - keep spacing consistent? fixed
33. 03:57:317 (1,4) - i think you should space out done
34. I just realized, you have no breaks o_O i would REALLY strongly recommend you to add one or two yeah i had a break before but CDFA told me to just map it and now idk what to do anymore.

[Hard]

1. 00:01:524 (4,5,6) - how bout one of those triangle pattern things here? (copy one slider rotate 120, repeat once more) ehh i think its fine as it is, i'm not really sure what you're envisioning though.
2. 00:05:548 - same as in insane, i feel like a circle would be better for this done
3. 00:17:256 (7,8) - again, copy paste one of the sliders, ctrl hj ok
4. 00:31:890 (8,9) - ^ ^
5. 02:01:707 (5,6) - ^ i think this one looks fine
6. 03:52:195 (2,3) - ^ ^
7. 00:19:451 (1,2,3,4,1) - antijumps here feel a bit awkward >_< i dunno how to explain it. I just don't really feel the music stopping or slowing down you know what i mean? i'll keep for now because im too lazy to change but if oneee more person to complains about this ill change.
8. 00:23:841 (1) - ctrl g will give better flow here i guessss
9. 01:19:268 - i feel like there needs to be a circle with NC here instead okay i changed
10. 01:35:548 (1,2,3,4,1) - same as before, also, move (1) up a bit to make a straight line lol ^
11. 01:47:256 (1,2,3,4,1) - ^ ^
12. 02:16:341 (4) - make this first curve with 2 slider points istead- makes blanket better. Also, expose the tail a bit more i dont really understand, sorry :3
13. 03:35:366 (4) - ^
14. 02:33:353 (3,6) - space out? ok
15. 03:32:439 (4,6) - ^ ^

[Normal]

1. 00:30:426 (2) - move this 1/2 back and extend 00:29:695 (1) - by 1/2 im guessing you meant forward, fixed.
2. 00:48:536 (4,1) - not a good overlap i dont think you can really notice it in game
3. 00:50:731 - with the second kiai, you placed a 1/1 slider here so i think you should do that here too i did something, idk if its what you wanted though
4. 03:31:707 - ^ ^
   same goes with every other similar place
5. 03:01:890 (1,3) - again, the copy pasting thing fixed
6. 03:03:902 (4) - this may be a bit confusing as there isn't a strong indication in the music for this circle changed
7. 03:11:585 - map this guitar out pls ok

[Easy]

1. 00:19:451 (2,1) - u could blanket the head of (1) with the last little curve of (2)? oh cool, done
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 00:32:622 (1,2) - blanket? fixed a little
3. 01:50:000 (3) - btw the quality of your waves could be improved. do something more like this yeah i've been struggling with these
   
   SPOILER

   
4. 02:54:207 (2) - ^here too ^
   
   SPOILER

   
   just improve all your wave sliders a bit lol i'll go fix them later, i really need to go do hw lol

Really really good mapset! gogo rank it !

take a star or 2

enmyuuuU wrote:

Hello from my queue


[Easy]

SPOILER

nice

[Normal]

SPOILER

nice map!
damn me sliderbreaking ._.

[Hard]

SPOILER

-this diff is really good and well-made

[Insane]

SPOILER

-Flow is ok
-don't have anything to say, but this map need some 'refining' (dunno how to say it, lol) maybe trying some non-mainstream pattern. It's reaaally long and I would got bored in short time.


[Overall]
-really nice hitsounds! I love it!
-good difficulty spreads nice job
-technically this mapset is really good!
-I love this song really I am a big fan of The brilliant Green (=tommy heavenly6)


sorry for being nazi ._. anyway good luck and good job there!

Nada Dabuh wrote:

for normal:
00:18:719 (3) is short try to extend it a bit till 00:19:268 ? i think it's better, because there is a beat that you shouldn't ignore.
Nice work also good luck !! okay i deleted some stuff, extended the slider, and moved stuff around.

Knotts wrote:

Am I supposed to give kudos for this? yolo.

1. 00:11:951 (1,2,3,4) - imo the jump should occur from 3->4 instead of from 1->2 since 4 has a pretty strong beat there and a hitsound to support it. It will also be more consistent with the jump to 00:13:597 (6)
2. 00:19:451 (7) - remove clap? it sounds a bit odd there imo, and when i remove the hitsound, there isn't a particularly strong beat there
3. 00:19:085 (5) - but add clap here? rhythmically this hitsound pattern sounds better to me, up to you though
4. 00:22:195 (5) - remove clap on tail for same reasons?
5. 00:22:926 (8,9) - maybe swap these on timeline? flows better for me, yes i know it's a conventional star pattern e_e
6. 00:25:670 (6) - to make the pattern neater, consider moving this left a bit so it doesn't touch 00:24:939 (4), the overlap is noticeable even with AR9
7. 00:36:463 (4,5,6) - consider making the pattern neater by adjusting like so? http://puu.sh/8BeC6.jpg
8. 00:37:652 (1) - as far as i can hear, there's no sound here, consider removing
9. 01:09:024 (6,7,8,9) - how about this rhythm to better fit the vocals and music? http://puu.sh/8BeRg.jpg
10. 01:11:951 (6,7,8) - this doesn't flow too well for me, it's kind of an abrupt change in direction from CCW to CW, not sure what you can do without touching the next few circles though :/
11. 01:17:256 (3,4,5) - the jump between 3->4 is quite large and doesn't really suit the vocals personally. I think a better jump would be 4->5 since that's when she starts singing again
12. 01:26:219 (3) - for neatness purposes, stack this on the tail of 1?
13. 01:26:402 (4,5) - the angle between these 2 is quite sharp doesn't flow too well, how about http://puu.sh/8Bf8g.jpg
14. 01:27:500 (7,8,9) - i think the pattern would be neater if the spacing was equal here
15. 01:28:963 (3) - consider making this slider curved this way to better lead into the next pattern and imo a straight slider looks pretty severe there LOL http://puu.sh/8Bfe8.jpg
16. 01:30:244 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1) - might seem nitpicky, but these aren't parallel
17. 01:34:085 (1) - i think it'd be cool to have a jump here! Maybe like this? http://puu.sh/8BfkZ.jpg
18. 01:37:926 (3) - to better fit vocals, i suggest breaking this up into a 1/2 slider and then a circle
19. 01:38:475 (4) - ah her voice is vibrating here, but i don't think a 1/4 repeat slider fits here. Actually, the drums are pretty strong here, why not map 2 circle jumps?
20. 01:45:426 (7,1) - woah this jump is quite large and it's not even the kiai yet! try this? http://puu.sh/8Bfwf.jpg
21. 01:46:433 (4) - i understand her voice is vibrating here, but i think this part could be much more clearer if you simply removed this note, and if you like, you can put a jump here
22. 01:50:183 (6,7,8,9,10) - this variation of a star pattern plays kinda oddly for me, and the main reason is that 8 has a really strong beat here, which you emphasized using a clap, yet the spacing between 7->8 is smaller than from 9->10. Maybe you can make this a regular star pattern, or do another circle jump pattern?
23. 01:51:463 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - consider swapping rhythms around to better fit vocals? http://puu.sh/8BfTe.jpg
24. 01:54:573 (1) - move this down & left a bit so it's not so close to the previous slider?
25. 01:56:585 (6,7,8) - i think this rhythm would suit the music better: http://puu.sh/8BfZG.jpg
26. 01:59:786 (7,8,9,10,11,12,13) - this straight stream doesn't flow too well from 6, which is a curved slider, how about following 6's curve and making the stream curve in a circular way? or maybe a wave
27. 02:02:256 (5) - angle the slider left some so it intersects 4 right in the middle? http://puu.sh/8Bg3P.jpg
28. 02:03:170 (7,1) - not sure if it's a good idea to stack 7 and 1, 1 seems pretty powerful and strong, i think it should stand alone
29. 02:05:366 (7) - maybe have this slider blanket 6?
30. 02:08:109 (5,6,7,8,9,10,1) - just a comment that i think this is a relatively nice looking and flowing jump!
31. 02:20:000 (7) - maybe angle slider this way for better flow? http://puu.sh/8Bgl7.jpg
32. 02:21:646 (3,4) - maybe ctrl+G these two for a zigzag feeling that plays a bit better than what you currently have
33. 02:28:597 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - for neatness, move these so they don't overlap? http://puu.sh/8Bgwl.jpg the slider in the pic doesn't blanket the previous one, but the rest of the stream does sorry
34. 02:32:439 (1) - the slowdown doesn't really fit the music here even with the long drawn out vocals, it sorta reduces the momentum built up from kiai
35. 02:33:353 (2,3) - i think ctrl+G would improve the flow of this pattern cause it would lead directly from 1, and the back and forth pattern would be super cool
36. 02:35:366 (1) - here as well, don't think this 0.75x SV section fits too well, the constant drums makes this section quite powerful
37. 02:43:963 (6,2) - personally i think these would work better as complete antijumps, meaning stacking directly on the previous sliders ends
38. 02:48:628 (6) - i can see where you're coming from with this 1/4 rhythm, but i don't think there's really a 1/4 beat here justifying this circle
39. 02:50:183 (1) - with such a long slider at low SV, it's important to make the blanket nice and tidy since the player will see it for a longer period of time than usual, here's an example: http://puu.sh/8BgNi.jpg Use the approach circle as a guide when making blankets
40. 03:02:622 (3) - clap on head to match beat in music
41. 03:05:823 (4) - drum finish on tail? would sound pretty cool
42. 03:07:286 (4,5) - drum claps on heads & tails would sound neat here
43. 03:09:024 (4) - maybe separating this from 3 would look nicer, here's a suggestion: http://puu.sh/8Bh2l.jpg oops they're not parallel sorry
44. 03:14:329 (2,3) - try this instead? http://puu.sh/8Bh50.jpg looks nicer imo
45. 03:15:609 (6) - this overlap looks quite messy, how about this? http://puu.sh/8Bh6y.jpg
46. 03:24:664 (1,2,3) - personally i think a regular stream would work better here D:
47. 03:29:329 (5) - place it like this for better flow? (plus X jumps are cool) http://puu.sh/8Bhab.jpg
48. 03:38:292 (4,5,6) - imo the rhythm should be slider-circle-circle to better fit vocals
49. 03:45:426 (11) - clap on head to maintain consistent hitsound pattern

1. 00:07:012 (3) - how about playing up and left a bit for a nice triangle pattern?
2. 00:12:866 (3) - down and left for ^
3. 00:22:195 (4) - blanket previous slider for neatness http://puu.sh/8Cq7p.jpg
4. 00:36:829 (4,5) - swap on timeline to better match vocals & so the strong beat is on slider head instead of tail
5. 00:39:207 (3,4,5) - hmm not sure i understand why you chose to stack these D: imo it would be clearer if you unstacked
6. 01:11:951 (4) - to make this pattern neater, this can blanket 3 a bit better
7. 01:13:231 (10) - clap on head & tail to emphasize strong beat?
8. 01:15:792 (7) - maybe clap on head & tail too?
9. 01:17:256 (4) - maybe angle this so it blankets 5 so the direction change isn't too sharp?
10. 01:42:500 (1,2,3,4) - since drums are soft here, and this is a hard, why not make this a 1/4 repeat slider
11. 01:42:866 (1) - clap on repeat?
12. 01:45:792 (1) - move left a bit for consistent spacing
13. 02:17:530 (7) - having the slider start on a blue tick makes this play a bit oddly for me, how about reducing the slider by one tick and having it move 1/4 over to next red tick
14. 02:25:122 (3,4,5,6) - this diamond looks quite squashed D: maybe even out the spacing some? http://puu.sh/8CqV7.jpg
15. 02:34:817 (7) - add claps on white ticks too? it sounds funny having claps on blue ticks cause it sounds offbeat
16. 02:45:792 (5,6) - remove clap from 5's tail and put on 6's tail instead ot better match the music
17. 02:56:951 (3) - this jump is rather high for the slow part, how about http://puu.sh/8Crrr.jpg
18. 03:03:902 (3) - maybe clap on each repeat of the slider starting on the first white tick?
19. 03:14:512 (3,4) - maybe blanket these better for a neater look D:
20. 03:18:811 (7) - same comment as before
21. 03:30:426 (7) - avoid a messy overlap with 4 by making a diamond with the previous sliders? http://puu.sh/8CrBj.jpg
22. 03:47:622 (5,6) - similar concept here! X jumps are great
23. 03:59:512 (8,9,10,11) - this plays quite oddly for me rhythmically for some reason... ic an't really put my finger on it, but consider just having 1 1/4 repeat slider starting at 03:59:695 leading into 04:00:244 (1)
24. 04:04:817 (6) - remove clap from head for consistency
25. 04:07:926 (7) - hmm i don't really hear a finish or cymbal sound in the bg, remove finish?

1. 00:14:329 (5,1) - a bit minor but not properly stacked
2. 00:24:390 (2,3) - to better fit vocals, try this rhythm? http://puu.sh/8CswY.jpg
3. 00:26:768 (1) - finish on head
4. 00:30:426 (2) - i know you're adding a clap for the beat in the bg, but maybe it'd be more consistent to add it on the tail instead
5. 00:32:622 (1,2) - just a suggestion, why not extend the first slider to where 2 is (so a 5/2 slider) to match vocals?
6. 00:36:097 (3,4) - maybe this rhythm would fit with vocals better: http://puu.sh/8Cw4N.jpg
7. 00:57:317 (3,4) - this pattern looks quite uneven, maybe adjust like so? http://puu.sh/8Cw8x.jpg
8. 01:01:890 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1) - hmmm, you may want to make the rhythm here similar to that of 00:50:183 (1,2,3,4,5,6). The notes here are mostly on white ticks, while the pattern in the beginning of kiai were all on red ticks. It'd make your map feel more unified & cohesive if you had a consistent rhythm imo
9. 01:12:866 (5) - maybe add drum finish here?
10. 01:39:390 (4) - since she doesn't start singing at the red tick, i suggest deleting the repeat and moving the slider to next white tick
11. 01:53:109 (5,6) - would fit vocals better imo if these were just 1/1 sliders 1/1 apart
12. 02:07:195 (3) - remove clap from tail, sounds out of place i think
13. 02:09:939 (1) - don't think this NC is needed D:
14. 02:11:951 (4) - NC here instead of at 02:13:048 (1)? It's a new verse & new big white tick
15. 02:15:975 (1) - don't think this NC is necessary, but NC should be added at 02:17:987 (4), since that's when she repeats the chorus again
16. 02:19:268 (1) - if you follow above suggestion, remove NC from here~
17. 02:31:890 (2) - clap here for strong beat?
18. 02:35:366 (3) - seems odd for this slider to be this long, it stops before she stops singing, how about adding a circle here and then a spinner 1/2 beat afterward, ending at 02:37:012?
19. 02:42:866 (4) - this 1/2 slider doesn't fit the music imo, maybe follow the long vocals and either make this a 1/1 slider or have it end where 5 is
20. 02:45:792 (3) - for consnistency, remove clap from head & maybe add at tail
21. 02:59:695 (2) - hmmm just a suggestion, move this circle 1/2 over for vocals
22. 03:00:244 (3) - would fit vocals better to extend this by 1/2, fits better imo
23. 03:01:890 (1,2,3,4) - the rhythm here seems quite abrupt and choppy compared to the long and drawn out vocals D: longer sliders would fit this section better personally
24. 03:30:792 - maybe add a note here? the previous slider seems to end at kinda a weird spot imo
25. 04:06:097 (6) - NC here?

1. 00:16:890 (3) - consider extending this slider to next white tick, it feels more complete imo since it lasts as long as the singer's voice
2. 00:32:622 (1) - maybe extend this slider to next red tick for same reason
3. 01:44:695 (3) - extend to white tick for ^ i'll stop mentioning these, since you probably wanted to emphasize the heavy beats in the background. Personally, I think this abundance of 3/2 rhythms might be too confusing for beginners, but your call
4. 02:21:646 (4) - kinda far from 3, move it closer to maintain distance snap :O

Raose wrote:

Hi! o/ You requested a map from either my/Love/dkun/Frostmourne/Oracle/Atrue's userpages!!! Your mod is long overdue sir.

[General]

Err, combo colors seem to be different in the diffs, at least between Easy and the rest. Consider making them the same, especially since you're the one who made all the diffs!
[Insane]

It's not really necessary to NC everytime you start a stream
mostly just flow & neatness issues, you'll learn both as you go along, no worries new mapper! This is a pretty solid set for someone as new as yourself *_* fighto!

eh, guess i should start organizing my mod better

1. 00:11:951 (1,2,3,4) - imo the jump should occur from 3->4 instead of from 1->2 since 4 has a pretty strong beat there and a hitsound to support it. It will also be more consistent with the jump to 00:13:597 (6) fixed
2. 00:19:451 (7) - remove clap? it sounds a bit odd there imo, and when i remove the hitsound, there isn't a particularly strong beat there removed
3. 00:19:085 (5) - but add clap here? rhythmically this hitsound pattern sounds better to me, up to you though i think it'd be strange to delete the other clap because it didn't have a strong beat and add one here since this doesn't have a strong beat either :3
4. 00:22:195 (5) - remove clap on tail for same reasons? ok
5. 00:22:926 (8,9) - maybe swap these on timeline? flows better for me, yes i know it's a conventional star pattern e_e oh yup. flows better
6. 00:25:670 (6) - to make the pattern neater, consider moving this left a bit so it doesn't touch 00:24:939 (4), the overlap is noticeable even with AR9 done
7. 00:36:463 (4,5,6) - consider making the pattern neater by adjusting like so? http://puu.sh/8BeC6.jpg done
8. 00:37:652 (1) - as far as i can hear, there's no sound here, consider removing if i listen to it a 25% i can hear sound there
9. 01:09:024 (6,7,8,9) - how about this rhythm to better fit the vocals and music? http://puu.sh/8BeRg.jpg done
10. 01:11:951 (6,7,8) - this doesn't flow too well for me, it's kind of an abrupt change in direction from CCW to CW, not sure what you can do without touching the next few circles though :/ changed since this was the second time this was brought up
11. 01:17:256 (3,4,5) - the jump between 3->4 is quite large and doesn't really suit the vocals personally. I think a better jump would be 4->5 since that's when she starts singing again fixed i think.
12. 01:26:219 (3) - for neatness purposes, stack this on the tail of 1? done
13. 01:26:402 (4,5) - the angle between these 2 is quite sharp doesn't flow too well, how about http://puu.sh/8Bf8g.jpg i can't tell if that's a straight slider or not because that glare is right in the center but i adjusted my slider.
14. 01:27:500 (7,8,9) - i think the pattern would be neater if the spacing was equal here done
15. 01:28:963 (3) - consider making this slider curved this way to better lead into the next pattern and imo a straight slider looks pretty severe there LOL http://puu.sh/8Bfe8.jpg done
16. 01:30:244 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1) - might seem nitpicky, but these aren't parallel fixed i think
17. 01:34:085 (1) - i think it'd be cool to have a jump here! Maybe like this? http://puu.sh/8BfkZ.jpg done
18. 01:37:926 (3) - to better fit vocals, i suggest breaking this up into a 1/2 slider and then a circle done
19. 01:38:475 (4) - ah her voice is vibrating here, but i don't think a 1/4 repeat slider fits here. Actually, the drums are pretty strong here, why not map 2 circle jumps? done
20. 01:45:426 (7,1) - woah this jump is quite large and it's not even the kiai yet! try this? http://puu.sh/8Bfwf.jpg done
21. 01:46:433 (4) - i understand her voice is vibrating here, but i think this part could be much more clearer if you simply removed this note, and if you like, you can put a jump here done
22. 01:50:183 (6,7,8,9,10) - this variation of a star pattern plays kinda oddly for me, and the main reason is that 8 has a really strong beat here, which you emphasized using a clap, yet the spacing between 7->8 is smaller than from 9->10. Maybe you can make this a regular star pattern, or do another circle jump pattern? fixed i think
23. 01:51:463 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - consider swapping rhythms around to better fit vocals? http://puu.sh/8BfTe.jpg done
24. 01:54:573 (1) - move this down & left a bit so it's not so close to the previous slider? done
25. 01:56:585 (6,7,8) - i think this rhythm would suit the music better: http://puu.sh/8BfZG.jpg done
26. 01:59:786 (7,8,9,10,11,12,13) - this straight stream doesn't flow too well from 6, which is a curved slider, how about following 6's curve and making the stream curve in a circular way? or maybe a wave ehh i think this is fine but i changed the end slider to be straight.
27. 02:02:256 (5) - angle the slider left some so it intersects 4 right in the middle? http://puu.sh/8Bg3P.jpg
28. 02:03:170 (7,1) - not sure if it's a good idea to stack 7 and 1, 1 seems pretty powerful and strong, i think it should stand alone done
29. 02:05:366 (7) - maybe have this slider blanket 6? ehh i dont think its worth changing it
30. 02:08:109 (5,6,7,8,9,10,1) - just a comment that i think this is a relatively nice looking and flowing jump! yay
31. 02:20:000 (7) - maybe angle slider this way for better flow? http://puu.sh/8Bgl7.jpg i like it
32. 02:21:646 (3,4) - maybe ctrl+G these two for a zigzag feeling that plays a bit better than what you currently have done
33. 02:28:597 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - for neatness, move these so they don't overlap? http://puu.sh/8Bgwl.jpg the slider in the pic doesn't blanket the previous one, but the rest of the stream does sorry fixed
34. 02:32:439 (1) - the slowdown doesn't really fit the music here even with the long drawn out vocals, it sorta reduces the momentum built up from kiai fixed
35. 02:33:353 (2,3) - i think ctrl+G would improve the flow of this pattern cause it would lead directly from 1, and the back and forth pattern would be super cool done
36. 02:35:366 (1) - here as well, don't think this 0.75x SV section fits too well, the constant drums makes this section quite powerful okay i changed
37. 02:43:963 (6,2) - personally i think these would work better as complete antijumps, meaning stacking directly on the previous sliders ends done
38. 02:48:628 (6) - i can see where you're coming from with this 1/4 rhythm, but i don't think there's really a 1/4 beat here justifying this circle ok deleted
39. 02:50:183 (1) - with such a long slider at low SV, it's important to make the blanket nice and tidy since the player will see it for a longer period of time than usual, here's an example: http://puu.sh/8BgNi.jpg Use the approach circle as a guide when making blankets fixed, idk what happened to that blanekt lol
40. 03:02:622 (3) - clap on head to match beat in music oops, fixed
41. 03:05:823 (4) - drum finish on tail? would sound pretty cool done
42. 03:07:286 (4,5) - drum claps on heads & tails would sound neat here sure thing.
43. 03:09:024 (4) - maybe separating this from 3 would look nicer, here's a suggestion: http://puu.sh/8Bh2l.jpg oops they're not parallel sorry idk, even though i said i'd change this if someone brought it up again i dont want to part with it T_T
44. 03:14:329 (2,3) - try this instead? http://puu.sh/8Bh50.jpg looks nicer imo
45. 03:15:609 (6) - this overlap looks quite messy, how about this? http://puu.sh/8Bh6y.jpg done
46. 03:24:664 (1,2,3) - personally i think a regular stream would work better here D: done
47. 03:29:329 (5) - place it like this for better flow? (plus X jumps are cool) http://puu.sh/8Bhab.jpg done
48. 03:38:292 (4,5,6) - imo the rhythm should be slider-circle-circle to better fit vocals done
49. 03:45:426 (11) - clap on head to maintain consistent hitsound pattern done

[Hard]

Overall I think this diff is quite jumpy for a Hard! Nothing wrong with that, but try not to make your jumps quite so large sometimes

1. 00:07:012 (3) - how about playing up and left a bit for a nice triangle pattern? done
2. 00:12:866 (3) - down and left for ^ ^
3. 00:22:195 (4) - blanket previous slider for neatness http://puu.sh/8Cq7p.jpg
4. 00:36:829 (4,5) - swap on timeline to better match vocals & so the strong beat is on slider head instead of tail ^
5. 00:39:207 (3,4,5) - hmm not sure i understand why you chose to stack these D: imo it would be clearer if you unstacked ^
6. 01:11:951 (4) - to make this pattern neater, this can blanket 3 a bit better fixed i think
7. 01:13:231 (10) - clap on head & tail to emphasize strong beat? oops, fixed
8. 01:15:792 (7) - maybe clap on head & tail too? ^
9. 01:17:256 (4) - maybe angle this so it blankets 5 so the direction change isn't too sharp? done
10. 01:42:500 (1,2,3,4) - since drums are soft here, and this is a hard, why not make this a 1/4 repeat slider ^
11. 01:42:866 (1) - clap on repeat? ^
12. 01:45:792 (1) - move left a bit for consistent spacing ^
13. 02:17:530 (7) - having the slider start on a blue tick makes this play a bit oddly for me, how about reducing the slider by one tick and having it move 1/4 over to next red tick i made the repeating slider into a triplet instead but im not sure if that's the right thing to do :3
14. 02:25:122 (3,4,5,6) - this diamond looks quite squashed D: maybe even out the spacing some? http://puu.sh/8CqV7.jpg done
15. 02:34:817 (7) - add claps on white ticks too? it sounds funny having claps on blue ticks cause it sounds offbeat ^
16. 02:45:792 (5,6) - remove clap from 5's tail and put on 6's tail instead ot better match the music ^
17. 02:56:951 (3) - this jump is rather high for the slow part, how about http://puu.sh/8Crrr.jpg ^
18. 03:03:902 (3) - maybe clap on each repeat of the slider starting on the first white tick? ^
19. 03:14:512 (3,4) - maybe blanket these better for a neater look D: ^
20. 03:18:811 (7) - same comment as before ^
21. 03:30:426 (7) - avoid a messy overlap with 4 by making a diamond with the previous sliders? http://puu.sh/8CrBj.jpg ^
22. 03:47:622 (5,6) - similar concept here! X jumps are great ^
23. 03:59:512 (8,9,10,11) - this plays quite oddly for me rhythmically for some reason... ic an't really put my finger on it, but consider just having 1 1/4 repeat slider starting at 03:59:695 leading into 04:00:244 (1) took your idea
24. 04:04:817 (6) - remove clap from head for consistency ok
25. 04:07:926 (7) - hmm i don't really hear a finish or cymbal sound in the bg, remove finish? ^

[Normal]

Distance snap isn't really required, but it's strongly recommended, especially for a Normal diff! There's a couple spots where your sliders are too far from each other. Check AiMod (Ctrl+Shift+A to see where)
Hmmm your comboing seems slightly off in some sections. Mappers usually (but not always) combo every 1 to 2 measures, as indicated by the large white ticks. It'd be a good idea to follow that rule as it gives the map a sense of good pacing and consistency!

1. 00:14:329 (5,1) - a bit minor but not properly stacked fixed
2. 00:24:390 (2,3) - to better fit vocals, try this rhythm? http://puu.sh/8CswY.jpg done
3. 00:26:768 (1) - finish on head ^
4. 00:30:426 (2) - i know you're adding a clap for the beat in the bg, but maybe it'd be more consistent to add it on the tail instead ^
5. 00:32:622 (1,2) - just a suggestion, why not extend the first slider to where 2 is (so a 5/2 slider) to match vocals? ^
6. 00:36:097 (3,4) - maybe this rhythm would fit with vocals better: http://puu.sh/8Cw4N.jpg i agree
7. 00:57:317 (3,4) - this pattern looks quite uneven, maybe adjust like so? http://puu.sh/8Cw8x.jpg fixed
8. 01:01:890 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1) - hmmm, you may want to make the rhythm here similar to that of 00:50:183 (1,2,3,4,5,6). The notes here are mostly on white ticks, while the pattern in the beginning of kiai were all on red ticks. It'd make your map feel more unified & cohesive if you had a consistent rhythm imo done
9. 01:12:866 (5) - maybe add drum finish here? sure
10. 01:39:390 (4) - since she doesn't start singing at the red tick, i suggest deleting the repeat and moving the slider to next white tick this sounds fine to me
11. 01:53:109 (5,6) - would fit vocals better imo if these were just 1/1 sliders 1/1 apart done
12. 02:07:195 (3) - remove clap from tail, sounds out of place i think ok
13. 02:09:939 (1) - don't think this NC is needed D: oops, it looks like i messed up my comboing pattern :3
14. 02:11:951 (4) - NC here instead of at 02:13:048 (1)? It's a new verse & new big white tick okie
15. 02:15:975 (1) - don't think this NC is necessary, but NC should be added at 02:17:987 (4), since that's when she repeats the chorus again done
16. 02:19:268 (1) - if you follow above suggestion, remove NC from here~ ^
17. 02:31:890 (2) - clap here for strong beat? ok
18. 02:35:366 (3) - seems odd for this slider to be this long, it stops before she stops singing, how about adding a circle here and then a spinner 1/2 beat afterward, ending at 02:37:012? ok
19. 02:42:866 (4) - this 1/2 slider doesn't fit the music imo, maybe follow the long vocals and either make this a 1/1 slider or have it end where 5 is ended where 5 was
20. 02:45:792 (3) - for consnistency, remove clap from head & maybe add at tail done
21. 02:59:695 (2) - hmmm just a suggestion, move this circle 1/2 over for vocals ^
22. 03:00:244 (3) - would fit vocals better to extend this by 1/2, fits better imo ok
23. 03:01:890 (1,2,3,4) - the rhythm here seems quite abrupt and choppy compared to the long and drawn out vocals D: longer sliders would fit this section better personally fixed
24. 03:30:792 - maybe add a note here? the previous slider seems to end at kinda a weird spot imo ok
25. 04:06:097 (6) - NC here? done

[Easy]

Overall, some awkward 3/2 rhythms and gaps. Might be just a difference in preferences though!

1. 00:16:890 (3) - consider extending this slider to next white tick, it feels more complete imo since it lasts as long as the singer's voice done
2. 00:32:622 (1) - maybe extend this slider to next red tick for same reason ^
3. 01:44:695 (3) - extend to white tick for ^ i'll stop mentioning these, since you probably wanted to emphasize the heavy beats in the background. Personally, I think this abundance of 3/2 rhythms might be too confusing for beginners, but your call ok
4. 02:21:646 (4) - kinda far from 3, move it closer to maintain distance snap :O oops idk what happened here

Goodluck on your set! =w= Sorry the mod was long

1. i think the combo colour3 are a little dark for me,(149,226,255)may fit the bg better.

1. 00:00:792 (2,4) - you can take sometimes to fix the stack iusses like this,it may make your mapset cleaner and more readable.
2. 00:03:170 (1) - try to put this slider on the right side of the playfield to avoid the overlap,may be like this.
   SPOILER

   
3. 00:27:500 (3,4) - i think this rhythm may fit the vocal better
   SPOILER

   
4. 00:37:744 (7,1) - when people play the diff and meet those two note,they may feel that sldier7's end is stack with slider1,so ctrl+g slider7 maybe a better choose for this part.
5. 00:46:341 (7,8,9) - balance the distance between 7,8,9.
6. 00:50:731 (2,3) - make 2,3 parallel to 00:50:183(1) may better to me.
7. 01:00:792 (5) - try to put at (357,230) so 5,6 may looks like symmetry.
8. 01:04:817 (1) - move to(470,157) for better blanket.
9. 01:31:707 (3,4) - try this rhythm here?
   SPOILER

   
10. 01:42:500 (8) - there is no need to use a kick-sldier here imo.
11. 02:28:048 (4,5) - Let them symmetry with 02:26:768(1),maybe like this
    SPOILER

    
12. 02:30:426 (1,1) - remove nc
13. 02:43:414 (4) - make this slider end in 02:43:780 make better to me.
14. 02:54:939 (6,7) - this overlap is not a good choice cause there are almost no same overlap in the whole diff,so just stack them under 02:54:939(6) or put them somewhere else.
15. 03:44:878 (6,7) - make a better blanket like this
    SPOILER

    
    ,remember move 03:45:609(8) a bit right to avoid overlap.
16. 04:07:012 (4) - remove finish maybe 0.0

1. 00:04:085 (3) -make the end of 00:04:085(3) stack with the end of 00:03:170(1)？
2. 00:12:683 (3,4) - there is no reason to use such a big ds here.
3. 00:13:597 (6) - How about this？:
   SPOILER

   
4. 00:28:963 (8) - 1 grid right for blanket.
5. 01:06:097 (4) - ^
6. 01:11:402 (4) - use ctrl+g to increase the distance of 3,4 and 4,5
7. 01:15:426 (7) - (152,224)may better to me.
8. 01:36:646 (9) - try this?
   SPOILER

   
9. 02:11:036 (5,6) - you can change the position of those two circle to make a better partten.
   SPOILER

   
10. 02:35:274 (11,1) - samll distance issue.
11. 02:39:207 (3) - change this sldier into two to fit the rhythm.
    SPOILER

    
12. 02:47:073 (7) - remove this circle?
13. 03:06:463 (6,1) - swap nc.
14. 03:39:024 (7) - i may put this circle around (9,152).
15. 03:56:219 (5,6) - i think there are no need to make a jump between 03:55:853(4,5) according to the music,so you can use ctrl+g to fix the ds.
    SPOILER

    

Melt wrote:

Hi
request from queue

[General]

1. i think the combo colour3 are a little dark for me,(149,226,255)may fit the bg better. hmm i need some more opinions on combo colors T_T

[Hard]

1. 00:00:792 (2,4) - you can take sometimes to fix the stack iusses like this,it may make your mapset cleaner and more readable. fixed all of them i think
2. 00:03:170 (1) - try to put this slider on the right side of the playfield to avoid the overlap,may be like this. done
   SPOILER

   
3. 00:27:500 (3,4) - i think this rhythm may fit the vocal better
   SPOILER

   done
4. 00:37:744 (7,1) - when people play the diff and meet those two note,they may feel that sldier7's end is stack with slider1,so ctrl+g slider7 maybe a better choose for this part. done
5. 00:46:341 (7,8,9) - balance the distance between 7,8,9. fixed
6. 00:50:731 (2,3) - make 2,3 parallel to 00:50:183(1) may better to me. done
7. 01:00:792 (5) - try to put at (357,230) so 5,6 may looks like symmetry. ok
8. 01:04:817 (1) - move to(470,157) for better blanket. ok
9. 01:31:707 (3,4) - try this rhythm here?
   SPOILER

   ok
10. 01:42:500 (8) - there is no need to use a kick-sldier here imo. i hear it in the bg and i dont want to use that long of a circle stream on Hard
11. 02:28:048 (4,5) - Let them symmetry with 02:26:768(1),maybe like this ok
    SPOILER

    
12. 02:30:426 (1,1) - remove nc its for the pattern :3 No one else brought this up so i'll keep for now
13. 02:43:414 (4) - make this slider end in 02:43:780 make better to me. ok
14. 02:54:939 (6,7) - this overlap is not a good choice cause there are almost no same overlap in the whole diff,so just stack them under 02:54:939(6) or put them somewhere else. idk i really like this :3
15. 03:44:878 (6,7) - make a better blanket like this ok
    SPOILER

    
    ,remember move 03:45:609(8) a bit right to avoid overlap.
16. 04:07:012 (4) - remove finish maybe 0.0 i hear a finish here.

[Insane]

1. 00:04:085 (3) -make the end of 00:04:085(3) stack with the end of 00:03:170(1)？ok
2. 00:12:683 (3,4) - there is no reason to use such a big ds here. there's a drastic change in the music
3. 00:13:597 (6) - How about this？ok:
   SPOILER

   
4. 00:28:963 (8) - 1 grid right for blanket. ok
5. 01:06:097 (4) - ^ ^
6. 01:11:402 (4) - use ctrl+g to increase the distance of 3,4 and 4,5 that feels weird to play for me
7. 01:15:426 (7) - (152,224)may better to me. ok
8. 01:36:646 (9) - try this?
   SPOILER

   ok
9. 02:11:036 (5,6) - you can change the position of those two circle to make a better partten. ok
   SPOILER

   
10. 02:35:274 (11,1) - samll distance issue. fixed
11. 02:39:207 (3) - change this sldier into two to fit the rhythm. done
    SPOILER

    
12. 02:47:073 (7) - remove this circle? ill keep for now because it lands on a clap
13. 03:06:463 (6,1) - swap nc.i put a NC there to indicate the slider stream
14. 03:39:024 (7) - i may put this circle around (9,152). ok
15. 03:56:219 (5,6) - i think there are no need to make a jump between 03:55:853(4,5) according to the music,so you can use ctrl+g to fix the ds. ok
    SPOILER

    

That's all from me
Good luck :3