forum

WOODKID - Iron

posted
Total Posts
75
show more
Kibbleru
m4m

[Ringating's insane]
  1. 00:24:371 (3,1) - consider stacking?
  2. 00:28:062 (3,4,5,6) - kinda hard to read
  3. 00:31:292 (3) - when it gets to this part, i feel like you need a way to emphasize more, yes, although it is mapped out, i feel like there are ways that you can emphasize this loud base drum sound. For example, you can make them sliders or something, otherwise, you can make a certain pattern that emphasizes these sounds better.
  4. 00:46:057 (4) - again, i feel like these are not emphasized enough, they seem "hidden" within the patterns
  5. 00:41:212 (7,7) - stack better
  6. 00:47:210 - you didnt even map such a strong sound here
  7. 00:56:669 (2) - just a tip, when you have sliderpoints like this going every where and such, you can ctrl g the slider and it will autofix all your messy slider points :D, when i first discovered this i was like omgaslkjdsahas.
  8. 01:02:206 (2,3,4,5,6) - you could make this into a short stream instead of stacking i think
  9. 01:00:129 - also rhythm is pretty boring at this part, hopefully u can add a few sliders or something to make it interesting
  10. 01:12:356 (6,7) - jumps get dramatically bigger here without a good reason
  11. 01:39:579 (4,6) - not the prettiest overlap
  12. 02:15:106 (8) - i feel like you can stack this to somewhere other than a note in the middle of a stream lol
  13. 02:16:144 (2) - how bout this?
  14. 02:19:951 - add circle
[Insane]
  1. 00:33:138 - same issue as with ringating's insane, you could emphasize these better
  2. 00:34:291 (9) - the end of a triplet doesn't really emphasize such a strong sound well
  3. 00:43:058 (4) - u should use red anchors
  4. 00:46:979 (6) - passive slider doesn't really fit here (passive slider; strong sound at end)
  5. In general the rhythm is pretty boring, but I guess I'm in no position to say that xD, bleh we chose horrible songs to map i guess lol?
  6. 01:51:806 - this sound should be mapped with a circle not a slider tail
    (note be sure to read a bit from the GD mod too because you have some same mistakes)
  7. 01:55:958 - add note?
  8. 01:56:189 (3,4) - passive slider :(
  9. 02:13:491 - SV change a bit too dramatic compared to the changes in the music
[Hard]
  1. 00:15:835 - for the first little section here, i noticed that you did use some variety in your rhythm with sliders and such but changes in rhythm should have a pattern too, not just randomly. :P or you can gradually change it thats fine too
  2. 00:33:138 - same issue as with insane and probably will apply to normal/easy too
  3. 00:42:135 (2) - again the thing about passive sliders
  4. 01:05:666 (1) - sv change makes no sense
  5. 01:27:813 - put circle here instead
  6. 02:43:482 (1,2,3) - try this rhythm
    many repetitive mistakes not gunna state them ._.
[Normal]
  1. 01:00:129 - i got a lag spike when i reached this part remap
    lol jk
  2. 01:11:895 (2) - start this slider 01:12:126 - stronger sound here
  3. 01:30:120 (2,3,4) - hard for beginners
  4. 01:31:504 - like repetitive mistakes man... cmon map these out plz
[Easy]

  • Hmm easy seems fine
Now you're probably wondering why i'm not commenting anything about patterns and placement, that's because i find it hard to suggest patterns without incorporating my own mapping style into it >_<
Ringating

Kibbleru wrote:

[Ringating's insane]
  1. 00:24:371 (3,1) - consider stacking? note 2 is stacked on it, with 1 and 3 symmetrically spaced from it
  2. 00:28:062 (3,4,5,6) - kinda hard to read fixed
  3. 00:31:292 (3) - when it gets to this part, i feel like you need a way to emphasize more, yes, although it is mapped out, i feel like there are ways that you can emphasize this loud base drum sound. For example, you can make them sliders or something, otherwise, you can make a certain pattern that emphasizes these sounds better. something this broad would require an entire remap, and I don't think it's a huge enough problem for that (will keep in mind if I make other maps, though)
  4. 00:46:057 (4) - again, i feel like these are not emphasized enough, they seem "hidden" within the patterns ^
  5. 00:41:212 (7,7) - stack better fixed
  6. 00:47:210 - you didnt even map such a strong sound here was following vocals. If I went out of my way to map every single deep drum beat it would get repetitive.
  7. 00:56:669 (2) - just a tip, when you have sliderpoints like this going every where and such, you can ctrl g the slider and it will autofix all your messy slider points :D, when i first discovered this i was like omgaslkjdsahas. :o neat, thanks for the tip
  8. 01:02:206 (2,3,4,5,6) - you could make this into a short stream instead of stacking i think fixed
  9. 01:00:129 - also rhythm is pretty boring at this part, hopefully u can add a few sliders or something to make it interesting having a slider represent 2 notes would make them seem like they should sound different, but none of those 7 notes are unique in the song so I don't think it's necessary
  10. 01:12:356 (6,7) - jumps get dramatically bigger here without a good reason fixed
  11. 01:39:579 (4,6) - not the prettiest overlap fixed w/ some stacking on other things
  12. 02:15:106 (8) - i feel like you can stack this to somewhere other than a note in the middle of a stream lol it's not arbitrary, really. That note is the point of inflection for the stream's curve, and I think that makes it significant enough to stack on
  13. 02:16:144 (2) - how bout this? fixed
  14. 02:19:951 - add circle fixed
Topic Starter
pishifat
anything not mentioned was changed

Kibbleru wrote:

m4m

[Insane]
  1. 00:33:138 - same issue as with ringating's insane, you could emphasize these better following vocals for the most part in these situations, and since it's mapped, it wouldn't fit very well to start those as slider heads or something. if i were to also make every drum hit a slider head or something it would be extremely repetitive and boring
  2. 00:34:291 (9) - the end of a triplet doesn't really emphasize such a strong sound well when the end of a triplet is the end of a vocal phrase, it probably shouldn't really be emphasized
  3. 00:43:058 (4) - u should use red anchors
  4. 00:46:979 (6) - passive slider doesn't really fit here (passive slider; strong sound at end) vocals doe
  5. In general the rhythm is pretty boring, but I guess I'm in no position to say that xD, bleh we chose horrible songs to map i guess lol?
  6. 01:51:806 - this sound should be mapped with a circle not a slider tail
    (note be sure to read a bit from the GD mod too because you have some same mistakes)
  7. 01:55:958 - add note? following the bass drum that part. if i were to map the other thing it would just be an object every white/red tick constantly
  8. 01:56:189 (3,4) - passive slider :(
  9. 02:13:491 - SV change a bit too dramatic compared to the changes in the music
[Hard]
  1. 00:15:835 - for the first little section here, i noticed that you did use some variety in your rhythm with sliders and such but changes in rhythm should have a pattern too, not just randomly. :P or you can gradually change it thats fine too
  2. 00:33:138 - same issue as with insane and probably will apply to normal/easy too same response as those
  3. 00:42:135 (2) - again the thing about passive sliders
  4. 01:05:666 (1) - sv change makes no sense turn on the videozor and it will
  5. 01:27:813 - put circle here instead
  6. 02:43:482 (1,2,3) - try this rhythm
    many repetitive mistakes not gunna state them ._.
[Normal]
  1. 01:00:129 - i got a lag spike when i reached this part remap
    lol jk
  2. 01:11:895 (2) - start this slider 01:12:126 - stronger sound here
  3. 01:30:120 (2,3,4) - hard for beginners if that's so, i'd consider taking a look at your mapset's normal GD. it's a lot harder than that constantly :P
  4. 01:31:504 - like repetitive mistakes man... cmon map these out plz
[Easy]

  • Hmm easy seems fine
Now you're probably wondering why i'm not commenting anything about patterns and placement, that's because i find it hard to suggest patterns without incorporating my own mapping style into it >_<
samplefish
Pishifat pls
896315876132
lol :)
Pieetrr
The insane maps of this are just too amazing to not get a chance to get ranked
Topic Starter
pishifat
on your left, you'll see me being retarded while trying to map

on your right, you'll see nominators placing bubbles and hearts
Cancel

pishifat wrote:

on your left, you'll see me being retarded while trying to map

on your right, you'll see nominators placing bubbles and hearts
-Kanzaki
Place holder this song epic
Okoratu
man the video was the best part of the old set
I'm kinda sorry for this comment
Topic Starter
pishifat
ringating was the best part of the old set tbh
thinking.gif where:(
Xinely

  • Easy
  1. 01:19:055 (2) - following your flow from previous slider, i think flow would be better with move this circle to 108,220. yeah just my tasteeee
  2. 01:57:825 (4) - literally same as above
  3. 02:48:132 (3,4,1) - just feel a bit weird from (3)'s tail to (4) and (1)'s head.. how about make them have flow like http://puu.sh/jLgAw.jpg ?


  • Normal
  1. 01:57:825 (6,1) - just my taste that instead of zig zag i prefer to ctrl+g these circles. just tasteeeeee again
  2. 02:25:517 - the drum isnt strong but i still can hear it clearly, how about map it with 02:25:055 (3) - slider repeat?


  • Hard
  1. 01:05:094 (2) - time to nazi? ok 0,63x and 0,69x arent really consistent /runs
  2. 02:33:709 (2) - same as above. between 0,42x and 0,46x
  3. 01:58:286 - why not to add note here? you have a circle for Normal diff


  • Insane
  1. 02:06:017 (3,4,5,6) - just the flow from these a bit not well for me.. what i only can suggest 02:06:017 (3,4) - up these a bit? http://puu.sh/jLiwY.jpg

best shit mod ever
you know already that you should poke me back
Topic Starter
pishifat
did everything but the second one on normal. ending on the stronger drum just sounds better to me for some reason, which is why it's like that on hard/insane too
Xinely
why not
-Kanzaki
Milan-
WE CHANGED THE ARTIST NAME CUZ WH NOT

SPOILER
Nagato~: where's meta from
pishizor.: meta for
pishizor.: 1:41 PM - pishizor.: meta for
Nagato~: iron
pishizor.: hmm
pishizor.: i wonder
Nagato~: 01:21:248 - did u want to silence these or
pishizor.: right
pishizor.: yes
pishizor.: made preparations then did nothing awesome
Nagato~: nice job
Nagato~: you just earn a kudosu
Nagato~: now i wonder why you didnt low hp
pishizor.: hp very imporant
Nagato~: didn't use*
pishizor.: are you gonna rank that map
pishizor.: cuz my supporter ran out
pishizor.: and it says i can only have 6 pending maps
pishizor.: but iwant to upload another map
pishizor.: so it's buy supporter or get map ranked
Nagato~: wait

Nagato~: you know, im a bad bn
pishizor.: definitely
Nagato~: i found nothing besides that thing
Nagato~: and the metadata
pishizor.: good thing you questioned metadata
pishizor.: cuz looks like artist should be WOODKID
Nagato~: REALLY?
Nagato~: O
pishizor.: caps make it look so bad
pishizor.: title is same tho
pishizor.: http://www.label-gum.com/collections/al ... den-age-cd
Nagato~: Yoann Lemoine
pishizor.: caps title is from http://www.woodkid.com/ and https://twitter.com/Woodkid
pishizor.: thats his name i guess
Nagato~: it's french
Nagato~: oh
pishizor.: dis guy
pishizor.: too inconsistent
pishizor.: knevermind
pishizor.: caps for sure
Nagato~: ok

pishizor.: it was from a trailer
Nagato~: oh
pishizor.: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7Vu-7LEgVRs
pishizor.: which is why i thought it was Woodkid
pishizor.: description tho says WOODKID
pishizor.: or no
pishizor.: this video says WoodKid
pishizor.: even more confusing
Nagato~: where does it say the artist
pishizor.: "More from WOODKID"
pishizor.: description
Nagato~: oh
Nagato~: that
pishizor.: links to the guy's youtube channel
pishizor.: which has a lot of WOODKID and a lot of Woodkid
pishizor.: but more WOODKID
Nagato~: OK
Nagato~: SO DO IT
Xinely

Xinely wrote:

why not
Stefan
Wow, a Woodkid map. That's really cool.
meii18
I saw it graveyard months ago and now I'm glad to see this qualified.I listened this song first time at the summer of 2013 at TV xD. Congratz man! =w=)b
maTiGaming03
jak ty dzik
Please sign in to reply.

New reply