Right now, the Ranking Criteria has certain specific sections for audio quality on song compilations or medleys. However perhaps something like this could be added specifically for:
I'm not including more specific stuff about the transitions or mixing, since that would be covered in this part.
I've tried to be as precise as possible, since adding something regarding song quality can quickly devolve into subjectiveness. I also think if this proposal were to be implemented, it should be for mashup-style songs and not *all* songs, since certain artists could use dissonant chords in their original work for highlighting areas of the song.
Audio RC guideline proposal wrote:
Song mashup style tracks should aim to be mixed with proper tuning between the keys of the songs used. Chord progressions should ideally be in tune or harmonic between the two songs, and no abrupt cuts should happen in the mashup that modify the intended structure of the original songs.
I'm not including more specific stuff about the transitions or mixing, since that would be covered in this part.
Audio RC wrote:
Song compilations or other medley-style tracks should aim to be cleanly mixed with proper transitions, and should not include abrupt breaks or long fades between different songs. The songs used for the compilation should be similar in audio quality, volume and length.
I've tried to be as precise as possible, since adding something regarding song quality can quickly devolve into subjectiveness. I also think if this proposal were to be implemented, it should be for mashup-style songs and not *all* songs, since certain artists could use dissonant chords in their original work for highlighting areas of the song.