forum

[Proposal] Force an epilepsy warning on maps with epilepsy-enducing gameplay element

posted
Total Posts
6
Topic Starter
[[[[[[

ranking criteria wrote:

Difficulties that contain repetitive strobes, pulsing images, or rapid changes in contrast, brightness or colour in the storyboard or video must use an epilepsy warning. If the warning interferes with gameplay, audio lead-in must be made longer. Strobing effects at 3 Hz (i.e. 3 flashes per second) and below are unlikely to cause concern. When in doubt, add the warning and confirm its necessity during the modding process.
This rule, for some reason, only apply for map's sb or bg video, and may allow things like gameplay elements that have epilepsy-enducing features to reach it's way to the ranked section (without a marker)

For example: beatmapsets/1689606#osu/3452881

This map has a section at 04:50:849 which is quite epilepsy-enducing with it's kiai flashes, under current ruling the mapper don't have to add an epilepsy warning for the map, in fact that nearly happened

Another example would be: beatmapsets/1329045#osu/2753127

The mapper themself said that the map contain patterns that can be epilepsy-enducing in the description (im pretty sure they're mentioning these sliders 00:33:955 (1) - 00:39:602 (1) - ) again under current ruling the mapper don't have to add an epilepsy warning if the map didn't contain the sb that's also epilepsy-enducing

This new proposal will change the rule to:

ranking criteria wrote:

Difficulties that contain repetitive strobes, pulsing images, or rapid changes in contrast, brightness or colour in the storyboard, video or gameplay element(s) must use an epilepsy warning. If the warning interferes with gameplay, audio lead-in must be made longer. Strobing effects at 3 Hz (i.e. 3 flashes per second) and below are unlikely to cause concern. When in doubt, add the warning and confirm its necessity during the modding process.
(current wording still in wip)

edit history
21/9/2022: add 1 more example cuz i remembered
23/9/2022: fix typo
Kaaruumii
Agreed, I think there should be atleast a

header being used to warn about epilepsy in the description

before even downloading beatmaps (its what I did for my knives and pens beatmap, if you don't see that big warning in the description you might have an eye problem)
chromb

MFGSTC wrote:

Agreed, I think there should be atleast a

header being used to warn about epilepsy in the description

before even downloading beatmaps (its what I did for my knives and pens beatmap, if you don't see that big warning in the description you might have an eye problem)
nah if i don't see the warning in the description i might just be using osu!direct

in-game warning is probably be best way to go.
smolship
Maybe specifically mention kiai flashes in your proposed rule.
Topic Starter
[[[[[[

smolship wrote:

Maybe specifically mention kiai flashes in your proposed rule.
it's already covered in "gameplay element" so i don't think it would've been necessary
Okoayu
archiving this for now as this will be included in the rewrite of the general section of the Ranking Criteria.

Currently we have something like this
  1. Epilepsy warning must be used for beatmap content that...
    1. contains repetitive strobes or pulsing images.
    2. contains rapid changes in contrast, brightness or colour.
    Flashes or colour changes until around 3 changes per second are not likely to cause concern. When in doubt, add the warning and confirm whether it is necessary during the modding process.
I think just clarifying that kiai flashes are also able to trigger this would be sufficient
please let me know if you disagree :)
Please sign in to reply.

New reply