Blue are apply issue
Red are deny issue
Green use for other option, example like re-design or place/move the note not according issue
7K Reika's Maximum
wow thanks for mod all !!
http://puu.sh/8PCqO.osu
Red are deny issue
Green use for other option, example like re-design or place/move the note not according issue
7K Reika's Maximum
General look:
There’s a lot of elements that are left out or left hanging. For example, some of the song’s element disappear even though you’ve begun using it in a beat. Try to keep all notes to be consistent towards the sound elements and it’s advised to switch to 25% playback speed when editing and listening really closely to get better results. This doesn’t mean that you can’t add variations in your patterns. The map only needs more note placement consistency. The other issue is that you need to test your map so that autoplay can reach its maximum score. Check for misses from autoplay when you map to avoid unrankability. - Sp3ct3r-2k11 this are unexpected because my set never get mods so i don't know this happening, so fixing
- Okay now to be honest, this diff is good, but I feel like this diff is inconsistent, example when 00:13:158 - and 00:13:608 - there is 3 notes, (for strong beat I believe) then here 00:14:008 - and 00:14:408 - not even a single note … when I modding, I observe the mapper style (like : Oh he’s trying to follow the _ , oh he’s doing this because _) and make suggestion which can help him fix his style (?), but I really think your diff is good, so … maybe you’ll consider new “follow-what-to-note” mapping style =w= ~ - ArcherLove im sure this already explained on below
00:11:058 - If the stream is following the drum roll, then a note is needed here. - Sp3ct3r_2k11 fixed
00:13:208 - the chord should start here, at the new timing section beginning - Tear fixed
00:13:808 (13808|1) - Should add a circle here then get the LN to start from 00:13:908 to 00:14:108 if it’s following the lead. http://puu.sh/8HRI6.png for reference. - Sp3ct3r_2k11 i don't make LN's until 00:14:108 - instead 00:14:008 - because on that part is sounded. end of hold note are not making sound
00:13:808 - For all these patterns you have left all the notes and put only that hold, which doesn’t really play that well… Why don’t you use instead a doublet/triplet at 00:13:808 - and 00:13:908 - , for example? It would play quite a lot better, imo! Remember that this applies for all these patterns with just a ½ hold! - -kevincela- fixed all
00:14:408 - There’s a kick down here that has no notes. - ArcherLove fixed
00:15:908 (15908|3,15908|1,16008|6,16008|4,16108|1,16208|1,16308|5) - Might want to change this into a pitch-relevant stair pattern instead of having a minijack. - Sp3ct3r_2k11 changed to stream
00:17:208 - There’s a kick down here that has no notes - ArcherLove fixed
00:18:408 - Same case. Please add the notes to represent the kicks throughout the song if you’re following the kicks. - ArcherLove this part are only focusing main beat, so i leave nothing on other beat
00:18:608 (18608|3,18708|4,18808|5,18908|4,19008|3,19108|2) - This stream didn’t really follow that well the synth there… What about instead trying to use another stream using groups of notes with a transition? I think they follow quite better the synth there! Here’s what I mean: http://puu.sh/8HUeP.jpg - -kevincela- well i think this are not good pitch and that's doesn't better for me, so i changed pitch in my own
00:19:208 - Add a note to emphasise clap in 7 - ArcherLove this part are only focus on main beat, i leave nothing on other beat
00:20:408 - There’s a beat here that has no notes (*dug* sound) - ArcherLove fixed
00:20:808 - Same as above - ArcherLove fixed
00:22:008 - Same as above - ArcherLove fixed
00:25:608 (25608|3,25808|3,26008|3) - moving this to 3rd column would make a better hand balance , and also suit with the pattern in previous columns : 1234567 - Rumia- good idea, but i moving some note to 2nd column
00:27:208 - even if you are following the vocal this beat is still strong , should be a note at least - Rumia- fixed
00:28:708 - Add a note here to show vocal pitch change. - Sp3ct3r_2k11 fixed
00:28:808 (28808|6) - If this is following the vocals, remove since it’s not following anything.. - Sp3ct3r_2k11 added one more note for drum
00:30:808 (30808|0) - LN should end at 00:31:208 and let the other notes follow down the vocals. - Sp3ct3r_2k11 remove LN's because nonsense
00:39:608 (39608|5,39808|1,40208|6) - shouldn’t be double ? on what purpose ? - Rumia- fixed them by remove one note each other
00:44:808 (44808|4) - i think better to move this at 1st column ? since its the repeated bass , same sound as 00:45:008 (45008|0) - , Rumia - i think not because it's with clap sound
00:52:208 (52208|2) - i don’t think this jackhammer fits with the music nor the pattern ? - Rumia- change to trill pattern
00:50:608 - Add a note here to emphasise the kick - ArcherLove added
00:57:158 (57158|4,57958|1,58558|5) - i don’t get this double notes ? it seems like a wrong placement ? - Rumia-
00:51:008 - same as above - ArcherLove added
00:51:308 - same as above - ArcherLove i don't think you're mention to put note here, fixed
00:51:508 - same as above - ArcherLove
00:52:108 (52108|2,52208|2,52308|2) - Why this jackhammer? I really don’t see the need for this one here, especially seeing how the stream plays there… I would personally try to put at least 00:52:208 (52208|4) - to the 5th column to make the density a bit better between the hands - -kevincela- this same issue that already Rumia- mention, it should be fixed
00:53:958 (53958|2) - Remove? I really don’t see why using a double note here while there isn’t really anything to emphasize more than the rest there The same applies for 01:06:358 (66358|3) - ! - -kevincela- not fix
01:07:158 - should be a double notes ? it has strong kick too - Rumia- added
01:13:158 (73158|6,73358|0) - ctrl + j this suits with the rhythm , according to the drum - Rumia- fixed
01:14:858 - should be a note here for the snare - Rumia- fixed
01:15:858 (75858|3) - should be at here 01:15:658 - Rumia- fixed
01:16:258 - add a note for snare - Rumia- fixed
01:16:558 (76558|6) - this one should be at 01:16:458 , right beat placement - Rumia- fixed
01:19:958 - should nave a note if you are following the main beat here - Rumia-added
01:20:258 (80258|5,80358|1) - Again, you should remove these notes as there isn’t anything in particular to emphasize here in the song! no fix- -kevincela-
01:21:958 (81958|2) - move to 1st column ? fits the jack hammer pattern too - Rumia- no fix
01:22:658 - add a note since you are following the main instrument - Rumia-added
01:25:058 (85058|4) - i think this note don’t even have sound ? - Rumia-removed
01:25:858 - and 01:26:358 - should be a note here since you are following the main rhythm - Rumia- added
01:27:458 - here too ,add a note for the instrument - Rumia- added
01:28:958 (88958|2,89058|1,89258|0) - suggesting the note should be like this http://puu.sh/8HUdw.jpg - Rumia- fixed
01:29:658 (89658|4,89858|3) - orz this part don’t even have stream ? i suggest make a double note on 01:29:558 (89558|1,89758|0) - gives a better feeling - Rumia- fixed
01:31:558 - until 01:37:958 - Add more notes for the vocals since the part here is pretty empty - ArcherLove added
01:40:258 (100258|6) - move this note to 4th column for consistency ? - Rumia- nope, thanks
01:40:758 (100758|6) - move this to 6th column fits the pattern better , Rumia- fixed
01:43:558 (103558|6,103958|5) - suggesting to be like http://puu.sh/8HUma.jpg fits your pattern more - Rumia- change in other option
01:46:558 (106558|2,106958|6,107258|0) - suggesting this note to be place like http://puu.sh/8HUrW.jpg , more confortable with the streams pattern and the structure looks a little neater - Rumia- re-arrange in other way
01:47:658 (107658|0) - move this 1 column right ? the pattern looks messy - Rumia- nope
01:48:158 (108158|6) - move one column left ? ^ - Rumia- nope
01:48:358 (108358|3,108458|6) - suggesting this note to be like this http://puu.sh/8HUzy.jpg good pattern too! - Rumia- re-arrange in other way
01:54:358 (114358|5,114458|5,114558|5) - i think better to move this jack hammer to column 1 , its not fair to have 3 jackhammers at right hand on the same section ,also suits with your previous stair , - Rumia- same issue like previous, changed to trill
02:11:158 (131158|5,131158|1) - move this to 1 and 3 ? according to your previous pattern - Rumia- moved to 1st and 5th column
02:22:058 (142058|1,142258|2,142458|0,142658|3) - this hold is inconsistent ? either make it all mini holds or all normal note for this section ? it looks weird - Rumia- making it consistent with previous part, fixed
02:46:258 - *dug* sound, add note - ArcherLove added
02:46:958 (166958|3,167358|3,167758|3,168558|3,168958|3,169358|3) - dont think this repeated note fits the music , Rumia- re-arranged
02:50:358 (170358|6,170758|6,171158|6) - overnote for snare ? - Rumia- re-arranged
02:53:158 - add a note at 3 , this section is getting more intense , the beat is stronger too - Rumia- added
03:11:558 - this stair should be reverse according to pitch , - Rumia-
There’s a lot of elements that are left out or left hanging. For example, some of the song’s element disappear even though you’ve begun using it in a beat. Try to keep all notes to be consistent towards the sound elements and it’s advised to switch to 25% playback speed when editing and listening really closely to get better results. This doesn’t mean that you can’t add variations in your patterns. The map only needs more note placement consistency. The other issue is that you need to test your map so that autoplay can reach its maximum score. Check for misses from autoplay when you map to avoid unrankability. - Sp3ct3r-2k11 this are unexpected because my set never get mods so i don't know this happening, so fixing
- Okay now to be honest, this diff is good, but I feel like this diff is inconsistent, example when 00:13:158 - and 00:13:608 - there is 3 notes, (for strong beat I believe) then here 00:14:008 - and 00:14:408 - not even a single note … when I modding, I observe the mapper style (like : Oh he’s trying to follow the _ , oh he’s doing this because _) and make suggestion which can help him fix his style (?), but I really think your diff is good, so … maybe you’ll consider new “follow-what-to-note” mapping style =w= ~ - ArcherLove im sure this already explained on below
00:11:058 - If the stream is following the drum roll, then a note is needed here. - Sp3ct3r_2k11 fixed
00:13:208 - the chord should start here, at the new timing section beginning - Tear fixed
00:13:808 (13808|1) - Should add a circle here then get the LN to start from 00:13:908 to 00:14:108 if it’s following the lead. http://puu.sh/8HRI6.png for reference. - Sp3ct3r_2k11 i don't make LN's until 00:14:108 - instead 00:14:008 - because on that part is sounded. end of hold note are not making sound
00:13:808 - For all these patterns you have left all the notes and put only that hold, which doesn’t really play that well… Why don’t you use instead a doublet/triplet at 00:13:808 - and 00:13:908 - , for example? It would play quite a lot better, imo! Remember that this applies for all these patterns with just a ½ hold! - -kevincela- fixed all
00:14:408 - There’s a kick down here that has no notes. - ArcherLove fixed
00:15:908 (15908|3,15908|1,16008|6,16008|4,16108|1,16208|1,16308|5) - Might want to change this into a pitch-relevant stair pattern instead of having a minijack. - Sp3ct3r_2k11 changed to stream
00:17:208 - There’s a kick down here that has no notes - ArcherLove fixed
00:18:408 - Same case. Please add the notes to represent the kicks throughout the song if you’re following the kicks. - ArcherLove this part are only focusing main beat, so i leave nothing on other beat
00:18:608 (18608|3,18708|4,18808|5,18908|4,19008|3,19108|2) - This stream didn’t really follow that well the synth there… What about instead trying to use another stream using groups of notes with a transition? I think they follow quite better the synth there! Here’s what I mean: http://puu.sh/8HUeP.jpg - -kevincela- well i think this are not good pitch and that's doesn't better for me, so i changed pitch in my own
00:19:208 - Add a note to emphasise clap in 7 - ArcherLove this part are only focus on main beat, i leave nothing on other beat
00:20:408 - There’s a beat here that has no notes (*dug* sound) - ArcherLove fixed
00:20:808 - Same as above - ArcherLove fixed
00:22:008 - Same as above - ArcherLove fixed
00:25:608 (25608|3,25808|3,26008|3) - moving this to 3rd column would make a better hand balance , and also suit with the pattern in previous columns : 1234567 - Rumia- good idea, but i moving some note to 2nd column
00:27:208 - even if you are following the vocal this beat is still strong , should be a note at least - Rumia- fixed
00:28:708 - Add a note here to show vocal pitch change. - Sp3ct3r_2k11 fixed
00:28:808 (28808|6) - If this is following the vocals, remove since it’s not following anything.. - Sp3ct3r_2k11 added one more note for drum
00:30:808 (30808|0) - LN should end at 00:31:208 and let the other notes follow down the vocals. - Sp3ct3r_2k11 remove LN's because nonsense
00:39:608 (39608|5,39808|1,40208|6) - shouldn’t be double ? on what purpose ? - Rumia- fixed them by remove one note each other
00:44:808 (44808|4) - i think better to move this at 1st column ? since its the repeated bass , same sound as 00:45:008 (45008|0) - , Rumia - i think not because it's with clap sound
00:52:208 (52208|2) - i don’t think this jackhammer fits with the music nor the pattern ? - Rumia- change to trill pattern
00:50:608 - Add a note here to emphasise the kick - ArcherLove added
00:57:158 (57158|4,57958|1,58558|5) - i don’t get this double notes ? it seems like a wrong placement ? - Rumia-
00:51:008 - same as above - ArcherLove added
00:51:308 - same as above - ArcherLove i don't think you're mention to put note here, fixed
00:51:508 - same as above - ArcherLove
00:52:108 (52108|2,52208|2,52308|2) - Why this jackhammer? I really don’t see the need for this one here, especially seeing how the stream plays there… I would personally try to put at least 00:52:208 (52208|4) - to the 5th column to make the density a bit better between the hands - -kevincela- this same issue that already Rumia- mention, it should be fixed
00:53:958 (53958|2) - Remove? I really don’t see why using a double note here while there isn’t really anything to emphasize more than the rest there The same applies for 01:06:358 (66358|3) - ! - -kevincela- not fix
01:07:158 - should be a double notes ? it has strong kick too - Rumia- added
01:13:158 (73158|6,73358|0) - ctrl + j this suits with the rhythm , according to the drum - Rumia- fixed
01:14:858 - should be a note here for the snare - Rumia- fixed
01:15:858 (75858|3) - should be at here 01:15:658 - Rumia- fixed
01:16:258 - add a note for snare - Rumia- fixed
01:16:558 (76558|6) - this one should be at 01:16:458 , right beat placement - Rumia- fixed
01:19:958 - should nave a note if you are following the main beat here - Rumia-added
01:20:258 (80258|5,80358|1) - Again, you should remove these notes as there isn’t anything in particular to emphasize here in the song! no fix- -kevincela-
01:21:958 (81958|2) - move to 1st column ? fits the jack hammer pattern too - Rumia- no fix
01:22:658 - add a note since you are following the main instrument - Rumia-added
01:25:058 (85058|4) - i think this note don’t even have sound ? - Rumia-removed
01:25:858 - and 01:26:358 - should be a note here since you are following the main rhythm - Rumia- added
01:27:458 - here too ,add a note for the instrument - Rumia- added
01:28:958 (88958|2,89058|1,89258|0) - suggesting the note should be like this http://puu.sh/8HUdw.jpg - Rumia- fixed
01:29:658 (89658|4,89858|3) - orz this part don’t even have stream ? i suggest make a double note on 01:29:558 (89558|1,89758|0) - gives a better feeling - Rumia- fixed
01:31:558 - until 01:37:958 - Add more notes for the vocals since the part here is pretty empty - ArcherLove added
01:40:258 (100258|6) - move this note to 4th column for consistency ? - Rumia- nope, thanks
01:40:758 (100758|6) - move this to 6th column fits the pattern better , Rumia- fixed
01:43:558 (103558|6,103958|5) - suggesting to be like http://puu.sh/8HUma.jpg fits your pattern more - Rumia- change in other option
01:46:558 (106558|2,106958|6,107258|0) - suggesting this note to be place like http://puu.sh/8HUrW.jpg , more confortable with the streams pattern and the structure looks a little neater - Rumia- re-arrange in other way
01:47:658 (107658|0) - move this 1 column right ? the pattern looks messy - Rumia- nope
01:48:158 (108158|6) - move one column left ? ^ - Rumia- nope
01:48:358 (108358|3,108458|6) - suggesting this note to be like this http://puu.sh/8HUzy.jpg good pattern too! - Rumia- re-arrange in other way
01:54:358 (114358|5,114458|5,114558|5) - i think better to move this jack hammer to column 1 , its not fair to have 3 jackhammers at right hand on the same section ,also suits with your previous stair , - Rumia- same issue like previous, changed to trill
02:11:158 (131158|5,131158|1) - move this to 1 and 3 ? according to your previous pattern - Rumia- moved to 1st and 5th column
02:22:058 (142058|1,142258|2,142458|0,142658|3) - this hold is inconsistent ? either make it all mini holds or all normal note for this section ? it looks weird - Rumia- making it consistent with previous part, fixed
02:46:258 - *dug* sound, add note - ArcherLove added
02:46:958 (166958|3,167358|3,167758|3,168558|3,168958|3,169358|3) - dont think this repeated note fits the music , Rumia- re-arranged
02:50:358 (170358|6,170758|6,171158|6) - overnote for snare ? - Rumia- re-arranged
02:53:158 - add a note at 3 , this section is getting more intense , the beat is stronger too - Rumia- added
03:11:558 - this stair should be reverse according to pitch , - Rumia-
wow thanks for mod all !!
http://puu.sh/8PCqO.osu