forum

Project Railgun's Road to BN queue (std) (closed)

posted
Total Posts
51
Topic Starter
Eni
Post your cool maps here. Looking for sets to nominate.

Modding log: https://railgun.site/log/

Mod for mod maps (Past/Present/Future BNs only): https://railgun.site/nominate/

Accepted maps (These seem nomination-worthy with some effort):



Decent/Good maps (These are good enough that I studied them in more detail. Some of them are better than others):



Rejected maps (Your maps need to be better than this. For an idea of what I'm looking for, would your map place high in a mapping contest?)

Shige-Tori[a]

NM Request


Song Name: Interlude (feat. SOOTHEMILY & Xinevsky)
Artist: 3R2
Genre: Instrumental / Electronic
Length: 1:53
BPM: 170
Difficulty: 4 [N|H|I|E]
Status: Pending
Here is map page.
nishihara
Xelasto
sytho
FreezingAnimenz
aura
KennethBBG
i know you prefer full spread. but still plz have a look on my new map
link: beatmapsets/1570433#osu/3206846
Topic Starter
Eni

Shige-Tori[a] wrote:

NM Request


Song Name: Interlude (feat. SOOTHEMILY & Xinevsky)
Artist: 3R2
Genre: Instrumental / Electronic
Length: 1:53
BPM: 170
Difficulty: 4 [N|H|I|E]
Status: Pending
Here is map page.
Rejected with explanation beatmapsets/1564147/discussion/-/generalAll#/2592379

turtatical wrote:

beatmapsets/1568500
or
beatmapsets/1544887
1st rejected since WIP, 2nd rejected with explanation beatmapsets/1544887/discussion/-/generalAll#/2592395

Xelasto wrote:

Hiya!

beatmapsets/758749#osu/1595879

Thanks :)
Rejected with explanation beatmapsets/758749/discussion/-/generalAll#/2592421

Sytho wrote:

beatmapsets/1566796#osu/3199130
gl
I modded this one, but I'm not interested in nominating. beatmapsets/1566796/discussion/-/generalAll#/2592479

FreezingAnimenz wrote:

beatmapsets/1566750#osu/3199021

Thanks
Rejected with explanation beatmapsets/1566750/discussion/-/generalAll#/2592495

PurpleUmbrella wrote:

beatmapsets/1569351#osu/3204760

Ty :D
Rejected with explanation beatmapsets/1569351/discussion/-/generalAll#/2592531

kennethggb wrote:

i know you prefer full spread. but still plz have a look on my new map
link: beatmapsets/1570433#osu/3206846
Rejected since WIP

Send more maps, please!
0Depso
LeomineXD
HabiHolic
Nyukai
Hiroto-
XXBALT_
beatmapsets/1568717/discussion/3203045/general/pending

Just tell me if u think the finished difs are rankable(ignore the lack of hitsounds).
Thanks!
_kenny
beatmapsets/1528110#osu/3126074

Thank you for your opinion:)
bluirre
Vanya
xd Muslim
beatmapsets/1562849#osu/3191446 (warning it’s generic) but banger song TY :)
Topic Starter
Eni

Depsor122 wrote:

beatmapsets/1559777#osu/3185980
nm
Rejected since WIP

LeomineXD wrote:

beatmapsets/1536020#osu/3140734

Thanks
I think this is a cute map, although I am not interested in nominating it. beatmapsets/1536020/discussion/-/generalAll#/2593122

HabiHolic wrote:

beatmapsets/1569376#osu/3206755
Seems clean however I am not interested in nominating it since I want more creativity in the higher diffs.

Nyukai wrote:

beatmapsets/1570375#osu/3206726 Thanks in advance!
Rejected since I'm not interested in this set enough to mod it in detail. The Insane GD is cute, but the other difficulties could be better.

Hiroto- wrote:

beatmapsets/1535671#osu/3140150 thx
Rejected since top (only diff by host) needs more work. I like the effort for top and think you can be a pretty insane mapper if you keep mapping. The kiai was pretty cool.

XXBALT_ wrote:

beatmapsets/1568717/discussion/3203045/general/pending

Just tell me if u think the finished difs are rankable(ignore the lack of hitsounds).
Thanks!
Rejected since WIP

kennyistmull wrote:

beatmapsets/1528110#osu/3126074

Thank you for your opinion:)
Rejected with explanation beatmapsets/1528110/discussion/-/generalAll#/2593235

bluirre wrote:

cheers beatmapsets/1570222#osu/3206416
Seems like a high effort 30 second set however I'm not interested in nominating.

Vanya2 wrote:

beatmapsets/1566413#osu/3198445

thanks
Rejected since WIP. Video looks cool and I would love to mod a map of this song but the map relies on conventions instead of using more advanced ideas a more experienced mapper can achieve.

xd Muslim wrote:

beatmapsets/1562849#osu/3191446 (warning it’s generic) but banger song TY :)
Rejected since the only difficulty the host mapped (Insane) is riddled with issues, and the GDers are either inexperienced or mapping in such a safe way that they have no unique style.

Send more maps, please!
QuintecX
beatmapsets/1558927#osu/3184335

id appreciate any feedback you have in general even if reject, thanks :)
Sarawatlism
this kinda make me confusing why this is a BN queue. u have plan to join BN soon?

im just curious lol
Ilay
Akaynn
BM Request
Artist: V O E
Title: Giants
Tags: DnB drum and bass voe english male female vocals telomic tevlo
BPM: 174
Filesize: 8676kb
Play Time: 03:29
Difficulties Available:
Awoken (5,83 stars, 807 notes)
Aerous
Topic Starter
Eni

QuintecX wrote:

beatmapsets/1558927#osu/3184335

id appreciate any feedback you have in general even if reject, thanks :)
Rejected with explanation beatmapsets/1558927/discussion/-/generalAll#/2595892

Sarawatlism wrote:

this kinda make me confusing why this is a BN queue. u have plan to join BN soon?

im just curious lol
A few reasons:

1. I want to practice rejecting maps since I used to mod all maps.
2. I want to see what kinds of requests BNs get so I can understand why BNs reject so often
3. I'm looking for cool sets to use as mapping inspiration, although I haven't found any yet

Ilay wrote:

beatmapsets/1521890#osu/3174919 thanks
This one seems like a decent high quality set. It has some issues but I'll try to mod it in detail.

FlyZag wrote:

BM Request
Artist: V O E
Title: Giants
Tags: DnB drum and bass voe english male female vocals telomic tevlo
BPM: 174
Filesize: 8676kb
Play Time: 03:29
Difficulties Available:
Awoken (5,83 stars, 807 notes)
Rejected with explanation beatmapsets/1390184/discussion/-/generalAll#/2595941

Aerous wrote:

beatmapsets/1561963#osu/3189824
Rejected since I think the maps can be much better than they are now. I might mod it later but I don't feel good about the maps in their current state.

Send more maps, please!

To do: Ilay
Appetible
Star Stream
onnisama
beatmapsets/1522201#osu/3133499

NM, thanks in advance.
P_O
iamVill
Charitish
beatmapsets/1522272#osu/3169602

NM pls, ty in advance
xd Muslim
beatmapsets/1479659#osu/3035398
NM, collab map, thanks!
catch the ExGon
beatmapsets/1554044#osu/3175014 NM or m4m, pm me if you want
Tankuwi
beatmapsets/1204672#osu/2508446 trying to find smb who'll enjoy psytrance low bpm

Project Railgun wrote:

2. I want to see what kinds of requests BNs get so I can understand why BNs reject so often
Most of my reqs get rejected bcause of the song choice mainly. :(
Ryaldin
Topic Starter
Eni

Appetible wrote:

beatmapsets/1526251#osu/3122495 Thank you!
I modded this one but I'm not interested in pushing it. Good luck! beatmapsets/1526251/discussion/-/generalAll?user=2620107

Star Stream wrote:

beatmapsets/1432678#osu/3158941
thanks
I modded Normal and I'll mod the other diffs later beatmapsets/1432678/discussion/3194958/timeline#/2603218

onnisama wrote:

beatmapsets/1522201#osu/3133499

NM, thanks in advance.
Rejected with explanation beatmapsets/1522201/discussion/-/generalAll#/2599742

P_O wrote:

beatmapsets/1510878#osu/3093864

NM Thank you
I modded Easy and Normal I might mod more later. It seems like a nice and unique set! beatmapsets/1510878/discussion/3206619/timeline#/2603240

iamVill wrote:

beatmapsets/1553322#osu/3173658
Ty!
This looks like decent quality mapping. It seems very nice and unique! I don't feel comfortable modding it, but good luck finding 2 BNs!

Charitish wrote:

beatmapsets/1522272#osu/3169602

NM pls, ty in advance
Rejected since the map is too basic for my liking and the top difficulty is AR9.4 on a slow song/map. I checked out the lower diffs and they also have issues. Keep mapping and you'll make something even better than this!

xd Muslim wrote:

beatmapsets/1479659#osu/3035398
NM, collab map, thanks!
Rejected with explanation beatmapsets/1479659/discussion/-/generalAll#/2599804

catch the ExGon wrote:

beatmapsets/1554044#osu/3175014 NM or m4m, pm me if you want
This one seems very nice! Good job with the mapping / hitsounds / storyboard / etc. There are a lot of open mods so I'm not interested now, but feel free to post this map in my queue again later.

Tankuwi wrote:

beatmapsets/1204672#osu/2508446 trying to find smb who'll enjoy psytrance low bpm

Project Railgun wrote:

2. I want to see what kinds of requests BNs get so I can understand why BNs reject so often
Most of my reqs get rejected bcause of the song choice mainly. :(
Your map looks pretty solid! Yeah I can see how BNs would reject based on song choice since it's less fun if you're modding a song that doesn't interest you as much. I'm not interested in it enough to mod it but nice hitsounds and good luck finding 2 BNs!

Ryaldin wrote:

beatmapsets/1348716#osu/2792729

maybe :)

thx!
Seems like a decent map. I thought it was clean but I think it can be even better with more experience and more attention to detail for song expression. Not interested enough to mod it, but good luck!

Open again, send your cool maps!
-Flashlight-
hi, looking for nm!
beatmapsets/1575645#osu/3216904
thanks!
StripedGoose
Aoba Suzukaze
AmkDonitrikz
TheKingHenry
Heyo
Map
NM ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Thank you
Cubeisme
alevi
AW721

NM REQUEST

Song: kagirinaku bken ni chikai sam
Artist: Niji no Conquistador
Length 5:15
BPM:193
Diff: 1 [ok]
Link: beatmapsets/1575153#osu/3216031

Thank you 😊

i didnt find a good bg YET, also i cant think of a good diff name :(((
Okoayu
If you derail this thread again i'll personally attempt hitting you with a hammer

I'll jsut leave this map here in case you want to mod it beatmapsets/1406043#osu/2899404
Dinotronik
DecayAnt
beatmapsets/1564954#osu/3195758
Fully hitsounded, nc'd, etc. Modded by a couple others.
NM
Stompy_
beatmapsets/1572589#osu/3216061

Hey hey! Would appreciate if you could mod this!

Song Title: Kanousei (TV Size)
Artist: Argonavis
BPM: 122
Genre: J-Rock

:D thank you if you do!
Red Nerd
NM REQ

beatmapsets/1398820#osu/2910760

Tech jump based map
BPM: 155 ( half of it is 1/4, half is 1/3 )

Hopefully my first ranked beatmap :^)
Topic Starter
Eni

-Flashlight- wrote:

hi, looking for nm!
beatmapsets/1575645#osu/3216904
thanks!
I'll mod this one since the map looks pretty good.

StripedGoose wrote:

beatmapsets/1521307#osu/3113518
NM, Thank you
Nice song, I'm not interested in modding though.

Aoba Suzukaze wrote:

beatmapsets/1551194#osu/3169876

Thank you so much!
Rejected since WIP (although there are a lot of mods some parts can be better, so try focusing on improving your mapping style by making another map).

AmkDonitrikz wrote:

beatmapsets/1567977#osu/3201434

NM, thank youu!!
Rejected since no combo colors. I did look at it a bit though, try using more advanced mapping ideas.

TheKingHenry wrote:

Heyo
Map
NM ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Thank you
Seems alright but I'm not a fan of the simpler design decisions used in the slower parts of the map. Not interested enough to mod it.

Cubeisme wrote:

beatmapsets/1576016#osu/3217705

Thank you!!
Nice song / background but there's too many issues with the actual maps (e.g. finish spam).

alevi wrote:

beatmapsets/1568908#osu/3203938 nm ty
I like this map enough to mod it, it seems fun to play as well.

AW721 wrote:

NM REQUEST

Song: kagirinaku bken ni chikai sam
Artist: Niji no Conquistador
Length 5:15
BPM:193
Diff: 1 [ok]
Link: beatmapsets/1575153#osu/3216031

Thank you 😊

i didnt find a good bg YET, also i cant think of a good diff name :(((
Not interested sorry. It's harder for me to judge WIP maps or maps without lower diffs (unless top is really good).

Okoratu wrote:

If you derail this thread again i'll personally attempt hitting you with a hammer

I'll jsut leave this map here in case you want to mod it beatmapsets/1406043#osu/2899404
I will mod this one since it seems pretty nice.

Dinotronik wrote:

beatmapsets/1463818#osu/3070936
nm tq
I like PandaHero's diff but I'm not interested in the other ones.

DecayAnt wrote:

beatmapsets/1564954#osu/3195758
Fully hitsounded, nc'd, etc. Modded by a couple others.
NM
Not interested sorry. Looks decent but I don't usually jam to this.

Stompy_ wrote:

beatmapsets/1572589#osu/3216061

Hey hey! Would appreciate if you could mod this!

Song Title: Kanousei (TV Size)
Artist: Argonavis
BPM: 122
Genre: J-Rock

:D thank you if you do!
Pointed out some general concerns in top beatmapsets/1572589/discussion/3216061/general

Red Nerd wrote:

NM REQ

beatmapsets/1398820#osu/2910760

Tech jump based map
BPM: 155 ( half of it is 1/4, half is 1/3 )

Hopefully my first ranked beatmap :^)
Looks decent. Not interested in the song enough to mod it, but good luck finding 2 BNs!

Closed for now.

To do: -Flashlight-, alevi, Okoratu
Please sign in to reply.

New reply