What I propose is to create two subcategories for loved, these subcategories are not intended to affect any aspect of the game, only in the selection, since I have seen two very different sets in the loved maps, these would be the challenging and enjoyable, the challenging As its name, it would seek the objective for people who seek new challenges with difficult patterns or resistance among others, and enjoyable ones, seek the objective for casual people or want to have fun with a map, these types of maps can have aspects of storyboard, sync, some patterns, among others, in which these types of maps are to find a remarkable experience among the others for the players. And finally, in case the map contains a combination of the two types (which are rare but there is), it should predominate in the enjoyable subcategory.

These two subclassifications are intended to bring a more direct search to the maps, and thus make it easier to search for these two types of personnel, but they will still be within the loved category.
These categories can be proposed for the votes of loved, where the user must choose between whether the map represents a challenge to the player, is it a map that seeks a pleasant experience and that stands out among the classified maps, or a map that does not deserve loved ( something that I have seen little in these months that I started playing ...)

And to add, I think that this measure (if it is accepted), can begin to be implemented in the next votes, to begin to improve the experience in loved ones.
An example of each subcategory would be:

-For the subcategory loved challenging: beatmapsets/384166#osu/839569

-For the subcategory loved enjoyable: beatmapsets/731899#osu/1544408





And this I think would be all, it is an idea that I think can help the beloved category, and I think this topic has not been discussed (in my search I did not find forums talking about beloved subcategories :/), thank you very much for your attention ^ ‿ ^

There is quite some subjectivity between challenging and enjoyable. Maps can be challenging and enjoyable. There need to be well defined criteria that can used to determine which category the map falls under.

abraker wrote:

There is quite some subjectivity between challenging and enjoyable. Maps can be challenging and enjoyable. There need to be well defined criteria that can used to determine which category the map falls under.

That is why there is public voting, since from what I understand, the loved maps must first be approved to appear in the voting, and I think that after that filter, voters will have the ability to choose the map's subcategory loved (this in a subjective way, but always taking the majority of the votes ...)

What if beatmapsets/384166#osu/839569 was voted enjoyable and beatmapsets/731899#osu/1544408 voted as challenging? People will attempt to troll the system eventually.