Just saying that 2-key players always play 1/4 finishes as 1/8, and dK / Kd are actually the harder ones ( explained on my 1st post ), so the current rule is already catering 4-key players moreMakar wrote:
The problem with this is that if it's allowed, then 4-key players will be forced to be able to play in 1/4 on one finger when they weren't before.
As I said, I don't really like the idea of catering to one style over the other; since they are both popular play styles. I'd like more opinions on this.
But still, what you said is a valid point. I'd also like more opinions on how others think, esp the 4-key players
Kind of agree with this. I think there's no solid criteria to judge whether a use of certain 1/4 finishes is appropriate, and so they should better be checked case-by-case. As long as they are used in a reasonable situation, I'm fine with thatTasha wrote:
Honestly I think the xxooX rule is stupid, ooxxX is just as doable for any playstyle. I've personally tested it with 4 finger ddkk, kddk, and 2 finger ddkk, kddk. They can all play them regardless of note colours at the end, some are just slightly harder than others due to requiring 1/8 tapping on the same hand / colour.
A better idea would be to add a guideline / recommendation to not use finishers at the end of a 1/4 stream, but mention they can be used in situations where they will fit.