1 (diamant66) (#2)

Murumoo

The bold use of LN and mini jack was impressive.
The overall difficulty tends to be overmapping and there is a full LN part with severe spikes, but
If I compromise a little on this part, I think it will be improved.
Since the sv value is also well entered, I don't think there is any problem with the rest.
Personally, I would like to give an additional point to the challenging mapping suitable for the contest.

Rankability (25) : 22
Musical Relevance (25) : 22
Originality (25) : 24
Personal Impression (25) : 24
Total = 92

Paran

In some parts like 00:41:874 (41874|2,42047|3,42220|1) this, the snap did not fit. In addition, Like 01:12:249 until 01:13:637 this part, there is a section that changes rapidly from 1/4 snap to 1/6 snap. So it felt too difficult for the insane difficulty. However, it was very impressive and consistent that I used a lot of long notes to express various sounds.

Rankability (25) : 22
Musical Relevance (25) : 22
Originality (25) : 21
Personal Impression (25) : 23
Total : 88

Result = 180

2 (Nabi-) (#3)

Murumoo

This is a case that has a very good balance.
In particular, the use of 1/8 such as 00:40:255-00:40:949-came personally impressive.
However, there are some parts used as ghost notes due to the mapper's a little exaggerated interpretation in a special part.
ex 01:04:301 (64301|1,64648|2)-same as
I think it's more perfect if you tweak these parts a bit and give a compromise to fit the RC and guideline.

Rankability (25) : 21
Musical Relevance (25) : 22
Originality (25) : 23
Personal Impression (25) : 23
Total : 89

Paran

In some parts like 01:04:301 (64301|1,64648|2) this, ghost notes were found and there were LNs with an incorrect starting point like 00:39:908 (39908|1,39908|0) this. There were also inconsistent parts like 01:05:053 (65053|1,65053|0,65139|3,65139|2) 01:06:440 (66440|3,66440|2,66527|0,66527|1) this. But overall, it was woven into an easy to play patterns, and I can found 00:29:330 (29330|1,29330|0,29504|1,29504|3,29504|0,29677|1,29677|0,29850|1,29850|0,30024|0,30024|2,30197|0,30197|1,30197|3,30371|0,30371|3) these originality patterns. So if you take enough time to check the problems after completing the map, you can expect a more advanced appearance.

Rankability (25) : 20
Musical Relevance (25) : 20
Originality (25) : 20
Personal Impression (25) : 21
Total : 81

Result : 170

3 (Yukari_Sama) (#1 Winner)

Murumoo

Overall, it has been neatly mapped without much discussion.
However, due to the nature of contest, you have to see how differently you show your mapping style from other people.
It was difficult to find a special original in this part.
Personally, I think if I used sv or LN more boldly, I could give a much better score.

Rankability (25) : 23
Musical Relevance (25) : 23
Originality (25) : 20
Personal Impression (25) : 21
Total : 87

Paran
There are no consistency issues, ghost notes, or snap issues. Overall, the initial part using jack, vocal-oriented expressions, understatement, and the way the song was developed were impressive. However, when the mood of the song changes, I am sad that it would have been better to make a more colorful change based on 00:28:463 this line. Other than that, it was a neat mapping.

Rankability (25) : 25
Musical Relevance (25) : 25
Originality (25) : 22
Personal Impression (25) : 23
Total : 95

Result : 182

4. (Virtue-) (#3)

Murumoo

Overall, the clean and fairly heavy use of the sv was impressive.
There is not much to point out overall, but it was a bit disappointing that the rest of the pattern was used slightly softly.
I think the point is to differentiate from other participants by performing the maximum possible mapping due to the special nature of contest. Among them, sv may need some numerical compromise, but I think he showed his original well.

Rankability (25) : 22
Musical Relevance (25) : 21
Originality (25) : 23
Personal Impression (25) : 21
Total : 87

Paran

No ghost notes or snap issues were found and I could find some original patterns. However, it is unfortunate that there are inconsistent parts. Looking at 00:17:712 until 00:28:116 this part, 00:17:885 (17885|1,18059|3)-00:19:272 (19272|2,19359|3,19446|1,19533|0) 00:21:527 (21527|1,21700|2) 00:22:047 (22047|2,22220|0,22307|1,22394|2,22394|3) These inconsistent drum representations are continue. The same goes for 00:28:463 until 00:38:868 this part. If you wanted to express 00:30:631 this line, like 00:31:151 00:32:018 00:33:232 these lines should also be expressed which is same sound. It would be nice if you pay more attention to consistency while making the map.

Rankability (25) : 25
Musical Relevance (25) : 18
Originality (25) : 20
Personal Impression (25) : 20
Total : 83

Result = 170

5. (McEndu) (#5)

Murumoo

Overall, the neat use of LN was impressive.
However, in some areas, it was regrettable that there was a little lack of differentiated parts due to the special nature of contest.
While playing, the interpretation of 00:40:255 (40255|3,40428|3,40602|1,40775|0)-and 00:41:642 (41642|1,41902|2,42163|3)-was different. It's a little disappointing. I think it was cleaner to follow the vocal regularly as it is a rather difficult part to express the background sound.

Rankability (25) : 23
Musical Relevance (25) : 21
Originality (25) : 21
Personal Impression (25) : 21
Total : 86

Paran

Mapper's unique expressions can be found in various parts of the map, and the attempt to represent the sound as accurately as possible was very impressive. However, the expression ending at 1/8 line instead of 1/4 line where 00:16:758 (16758|1) this LN ends can be a unique pattern of Mapper's own, but it can also be a problem for snapping and can be overly difficult. I also noticed a problem where the snap of the LN was not correct at 00:40:255 (40255|3,40428|3,40602|1,40775|0) here. The correct LN starting points for that part are 00:40:515 00:40:689 00:40:862 these lines. It's very good thing to try to capture as much sound as possible into the map as accurately as possible, but snapping and consistency should also be considered.

Rankability (25) : 18
Musical Relevance (25) : 20
Originality (25) : 23
Personal Impression (25) : 18
Total : 79

Result = 165

1 (Remilistrasza) (#4)

Murumoo

It was a very impressive use of LN.
Overall, there is a point where the use of LN changes randomly, but
Rather, even that was okay.
What I felt during the actual play was that this map you made was quite impressive.
Because it is the most original among the submission maps of this contest and left an impression on me
i want to continue to support your mapping of this style.

Rankability (25) : 21
Musical Relevance (25) : 24
Originality (25) : 25
Personal Impression (25) : 25
Total : 95

Paran

The intention that you tried to express as much variety as possible is good, but there are many parts that are inconsistent because of that. For a few examples, 00:09:006 (9006|1,9106|2,9206|1,9206|0) 00:12:206 (12206|1,12306|2,12406|3,12406|1) 00:15:406 (15406|1,15506|2,15606|1,15606|0) these parts all have the same sounds, but only this part 00:15:406 (15406|1,15506|2,15606|1,15606|0) uses 00:15:406 (15406|1) this LN. I can understand what 00:15:406 (15406|1) this LN is trying to express, but this is definitely unnecessary and inconsistent expression. Also in 00:08:006 (8006|0,8206|0,8406|0,8606|0) this part you want to express the same sound using 4 note stacks, but in 00:11:206 (11206|0,11406|0,11606|0) this part suddenly changed 3 note stacks, and in 00:14:406 (14406|0,14606|1,14806|1) this part I can't even find the original structure. If you use different expressions while expressing the same sounds, it becomes difficult to know which sound is expressed, and it makes feel that the notes are placed randomly. It's nice to show Mapper's unique ingenuity, but consistent expression should also be considered in the ranks.

Rankability (25) : 22
Musical Relevance (25) : 12
Originality (25) : 20
Personal Impression (25) : 15
Total : 68

Result = 163

2 (Mirea) (#2)

Murumoo

Appropriate use of minijack and overall balance was an impressive map.
However, it is correct that the snap at the beginning is used as 1/3, and unlike the front part, the rear part slightly reduces the use of LN.
I think there is a point that has become clear.
However, considering that it is still neat overall, I think it was a fairly stable mapping.

Rankability (25) : 22
Musical Relevance (25) : 21
Originality (25) : 23
Personal Impression (25) : 22
Total : 88

Paran

There was no ghost note, but the snap at the beginning of the song didn't fit. Not 1/8 snap, it's 1/6 snap. 00:48:006 (48006|3,48006|0,48006|1,48306|0,48306|1,48406|2,48406|0,48406|3) The expression that emphasized this type of vocal was impressive and mapper's own unique patterns were also can found.However, expressed after the Kiai part was awkward because 01:14:191 (74191|2) 01:15:782 (75782|1) these LNs weren't emphasized enough and the length was different. The sound that can be emphasized seems to be a better map if it is emphasized more.

Rankability (25) : 20
Musical Relevance (25) : 22
Originality (25) : 23
Personal Impression (25) : 22
Total : 87

Result = 175

3 (Kyousuke-) (#1 Winner)

Murumoo

It was positive for me that the color of the front part and the back part were different.
It was also impressive to me that I tried to overcome the front part, which may seem plain at first, with triple jack and LN.
It was impressive to me that the strong expression in the kiai part was very strong, and there is not much to point out overall.

Rankability (25) : 23
Musical Relevance (25) : 23
Originality (25) : 23
Personal Impression (25) : 23
Total : 92

Paran

No ghost notes or snap issues were found, but personally, 00:06:606 (6606|1,6706|1,6806|1) these jack expressions felt weird. Of course, I understand that it was the same sound and intentionally placed in the same column, but in reality the pitch is slightly different and the same sound is expressed in a stair pattern from 00:19:406 (19406|3,19506|2,19606|1) this part where the vocal starts. And there were also some inconsistencies in the drum expression. Looking at 00:48:206 (48206|0,48206|2,48306|1,48306|3,48406|0) this part, it is 00:48:306 00:48:406 these two lines where there is a clear drum sound, but 00:48:406 this line is expressed as a single, rather 00:48:206 this line without a drum sound is expressed as a double. 00:48:806 This line also has no drum sound, but it is expressed as a double. These irregular drum expressions are not consistent.

Rankability (25) : 25
Musical Relevance (25) : 18
Originality (25) : 21
Personal Impression (25) : 20
Total : 84

Result = 176

4 (AyeAries) (#3)

Murumoo

Overall, I think it's a good dif.
In particular, I think the mapping using 12 and 34 doubles to divide the left and right hand arrangement was quite good.
However, as it is a contest, I think it would have been better if I had actively used a more orginal pattern or sv.
Also 00:04:806 (4806|3,5072|1)-is thought to be a ghost. Even if there is sound, it is unclear and it is clearly different from the sound in the previous part that was used more clearly.

Rankability (25): 22
Musical Relevance (25): 20
Originality (25): 20
Personal Impression (25): 21
Total: 83

Paran

No ghost notes or snap issues were found. The restrained expression with using single notes more than long notes was impressive, and the pattern itself is also neat and the composition is look so fine. However, it is unfortunate that a similar pattern continued to this line over 30 seconds from the beginning of the song, and Mapper's unique pattern was hardly found in subsequent parts. It will be a better map if you try various attempts while focusing on your strength, a neat mapping style.

Rankability (25) : 25
Musical Relevance (25) : 22
Originality (25) : 18
Personal Impression (25) : 20

Total : 85

Result = 168