forum

osu! World Cup 2020 - Discussion Thread

posted
Total Posts
66
Topic Starter
WalterToro
Wiki | Livestream


Welcome to the osu! World Cup 2020 Discussion Thread.
Here you can discuss everything related to the biggest country-based osu! tournament.

Notable changes:

  1. Warmups are removed from the matches
  2. Added extra timer rules when picking and getting ready
More changes might be added here so check this space!
lardon
I'm curious as to why warmups are removed? The new timer rules make sense though.
Brown Guy 2

lardon wrote:

I'm curious as to why warmups are removed? The new timer rules make sense though.
If warmups are vetted before hand I don't see why there would be a problem?
Topic Starter
WalterToro

lardon wrote:

I'm curious as to why warmups are removed? The new timer rules make sense though.
  1. Takes a lot of time
  2. Download speeds for some people makes this even longer
  3. Teams should be already be warmed up and some warmups does the opposite
  4. Some of the warmups are plain awful memes that are borderline inappropriate
There are other reasons but this was the main discussion.
lardon
thanks for the answer, I can get behind these reasons
reflection
"While this competition is planned as a 4 versus 4 setup, this may change depending on the number of incoming registrations."

I'm assuming you don't mean to scale up the number of players per roster (this would be really sick if you did though), so please don't lower the amount. Eight is a low number for some of these teams as is.
AstrZt
rip warmups and fun

I mean I guess we’re trying to make this as professional as possible but just feels sadge not being able to see epic warmups
Topic Starter
WalterToro

Apraxia wrote:

"While this competition is planned as a 4 versus 4 setup, this may change depending on the number of incoming registrations."

I'm assuming you don't mean to scale up the number of players per roster (this would be really sick if you did though), so please don't lower the amount. Eight is a low number for some of these teams as is.
Never over 4v4, but in the strange case we dont have enough players (not only on this cup but on any world cup) we have this line in case we need to re-scale the tournament. Shouldnt be a thing on OWC afaik.
MyAngelAnton
Can i stream and comment tournament on my own twitch channel for the russian guys?
KaitoH2O
les fockin goe
PainTensei
Couldn't you ask a team to 'lock in' their warmup map an X amount of days before the match?

You could let someone quickly check it for inappropriate stuff, hand it out to the opponent team beforehand so there is no possible long download and every player can decide for themselves if they think it's worthy of playing.
Topic Starter
WalterToro

PainTensei wrote:

Couldn't you ask a team to 'lock in' their warmup map an X amount of days before the match?

You could let someone quickly check it for inappropriate stuff, hand it out to the opponent team beforehand so there is no possible long download and every player can decide for themselves if they think it's worthy of playing.
The experience has shown that people doesnt want to spoil the surprise and most of the warmups are uploaded in a time range of 1 hour to 5 mins before the match (there are people who literally wait to be in the room to upload the map).
Locking the map doesnt help too as some team warmups depends on what they wanna test and they might actually change opinion depending on who is available to play or if they dont feel confident on something in that moment.
DeletedUser_259972

WalterToro wrote:

PainTensei wrote:

Couldn't you ask a team to 'lock in' their warmup map an X amount of days before the match?

You could let someone quickly check it for inappropriate stuff, hand it out to the opponent team beforehand so there is no possible long download and every player can decide for themselves if they think it's worthy of playing.
The experience has shown that people doesnt want to spoil the surprise and most of the warmups are uploaded in a time range of 1 hour to 5 mins before the match (there are people who literally wait to be in the room to upload the map).
Locking the map doesnt help too as some team warmups depends on what they wanna test and they might actually change opinion depending on who is available to play or if they dont feel confident on something in that moment.
The experience was based on that there wasn't any time limit to submit their warmups. By sharing the warmup link ONLY to the designated streamer, referees, and the opponent, the chance of it leaking out to livestream viewers and "spoiling the surprise" is pretty low imo. If they wanted to keep the surprise from the opponent... well... too bad. It's for the sake of smooth progression of the tourney.
Also, players uploading warmups right before the deadline is natural. However, it won't affect the tournament since you can set the deadline a few days before the match so that everyone involved would have already downloaded it.
For teams that use warmups strategically to test opponent's skills, it could be a bummer to not be able to apply the current situation to their choice, as you've mentioned. There's plenty of other resources that they can use though, such as the opponent's best plays, past matches, and so on, so I believe it won't affect them as much as you worried. And they won't have to worry about their own team composition, because it has no effect on match scores and its purpose is to just "warm up."

Finally, as a former player in the tournament and as a viewer, warmup is a GREAT way to pre-hype the players and the viewers if it's a "geniune" pick, or to just entertain the viewers and relax the nerves a bit before the match if it's a "meme" pick. Either way, it's a 7-year-old custom that everyone has accustomed to and enjoyed. Really hope you would reconsider and bring warmups back to the people who want it.
Ousaka_Akane
How can I request to be a part of the staff?
I want to stream OWC in china Using osu!Lazer because the current streaming guy is still using old tournament client
and I'd like to let Chinese players have a better experience watching this game without using Virtual Private Networks to connect to Twitch.

If availiable, I would also like to get the Background Videos that you guys used, to improve my streaming performance in OWC.
Mr HeliX
Yeah removing warmups is a very sad decision imo. They’re a great way for a team to show their creativity or to have some fun before the match and to remove that just because you don’t seem to like it or because it’s “just memes” is incredibly sad. Let players have their fun and relaxing time before their possibly very stressful match. If they don’t need it they’re always free to skip it. Have teams submit their warmups before the match and almost all your issues are fixed.

Warmups are also useful to make sure your setup is working properly. Wouldn’t be the first time joining a multi lobby crashes the game or fucks up your settings somehow.
youtoo12
Lol
RoIada z Miesem
No warmups, no fun allowed anymore huh
PainTensei

Jakads wrote:

WalterToro wrote:

PainTensei wrote:

Couldn't you ask a team to 'lock in' their warmup map an X amount of days before the match?

You could let someone quickly check it for inappropriate stuff, hand it out to the opponent team beforehand so there is no possible long download and every player can decide for themselves if they think it's worthy of playing.
The experience has shown that people doesnt want to spoil the surprise and most of the warmups are uploaded in a time range of 1 hour to 5 mins before the match (there are people who literally wait to be in the room to upload the map).
Locking the map doesnt help too as some team warmups depends on what they wanna test and they might actually change opinion depending on who is available to play or if they dont feel confident on something in that moment.
The experience was based on that there wasn't any time limit to submit their warmups. By sharing the warmup link ONLY to the designated streamer, referees, and the opponent, the chance of it leaking out to livestream viewers and "spoiling the surprise" is pretty low imo. If they wanted to keep the surprise from the opponent... well... too bad. It's for the sake of smooth progression of the tourney.
Also, players uploading warmups right before the deadline is natural. However, it won't affect the tournament since you can set the deadline a few days before the match so that everyone involved would have already downloaded it.
For teams that use warmups strategically to test opponent's skills, it could be a bummer to not be able to apply the current situation to their choice, as you've mentioned. There's plenty of other resources that they can use though, such as the opponent's best plays, past matches, and so on, so I believe it won't affect them as much as you worried. And they won't have to worry about their own team composition, because it has no effect on match scores and its purpose is to just "warm up."

Finally, as a former player in the tournament and as a viewer, warmup is a GREAT way to pre-hype the players and the viewers if it's a "geniune" pick, or to just entertain the viewers and relax the nerves a bit before the match if it's a "meme" pick. Either way, it's a 7-year-old custom that everyone has accustomed to and enjoyed. Really hope you would reconsider and bring warmups back to the people who want it.
I agree with Jakads; warmups are great to create hype and entertainment for the viewers. So please reconsider this OWC to try out stricter rules for warmups instead of completely removing them. If the new rules don't work out, then remove them in OWC2021?
SUPERNOOB20
Bruh, I've never watched an OWC before. Been waiting all year long... just for warmups getting removed? D:

BTW, just noticed this is my first post ever in a forum WTF
Hana Uzaki
Warmups are not a must have, but removing them is like leaving a piece of history behind... I see why you guys think it had to be made, but to be franc, one of the most memorable moments of the OWC are the meme warmups, even if they are not very professional, it let's players have fun with the game before going full serious mode for the tournament and it eases viewers into the stream and builds up hype, going at it since the very start will feel like too much, too fast by comparison now...
Damarsh
Something that I am curious about is how the tactical timeout effects the match:

If for example the tactical timeout is called with a minute remaining of the map pick, does that pause the pick timer and allow teams to extend their pick time or do they still have to pick a map (within the initial 2 minute timer) and then the tactical timeout is used after the pick has been selected?
zonelouise
get out of qualifiers or forever cursed
PuffBuck
I'm delighted to see that the warmup discussion is being carried out in such a civil manner. Very proud! I'm positive that they will be back with time.

I don't doubt that this year's OWC will be another wild and exciting one! I wonder what the upsets will be.

See you in the Twitch chat! You're welcome to message me if you need any assistance. New or veteran, doesn't matter. I'm always happy to be of service!
Big Bad Wolf
.
Cybertec
Hey is there anyway to see wich players a already in the teams or is it still not safe?
PuffBuck

Cybertec wrote:

Hey is there anyway to see wich players a already in the teams or is it still not safe?
It's still being settled. Keep check on the wiki for the final rosters!

Update: It's now up here! --> help/wiki/Tournaments/OWC/2020
jakk
year of the estonians
adia
It is a pity that Kazakhstan does not participate!
PuffBuck

adia wrote:

It is a pity that Kazakhstan does not participate!
Maybe another year! That would be fun!
Kobba
when are the support banners coming around
PuffBuck

Corvidae wrote:

when are the support banners coming around
Pretty sure it's from Round of 16, like usual!
xxnoobxx
Any idea when the qualifier results will be released?
Andy26
OWC Discord server?
PuffBuck

xxnoobxx wrote:

Any idea when the qualifier results will be released?
It's planned to start at 20 UTC today, over here: https://www.twitch.tv/osulive

Andy26 wrote:

OWC Discord server?
Not OWC specific, but included! https://discord.com/invite/0Vxo9AsejDkGlk3H
rubyRain
Guys, where can I find qualifiers results?
Lollps
How is a battle going up, like 4 vs 4 or any other way?
PuffBuck

rubyRain wrote:

Guys, where can I find qualifiers results?
They might be in the public Discord server linked above. If not, they should be available on the statistics sheet when it's made. That will be linked on the wiki page.



Lollps wrote:

How is a battle going up, like 4 vs 4 or any other way?
It is 4vs4, correct. More details can be found on the wiki page.
BlehMyMommy
Where and when will we know the bracket stages of Round of 32, Round of 16, etc ?
Pressed Soda
Where can I submit my map to the OWC's mappool?
Frikandel
Where can I find the results of the qualifiers? Why is that so hard to find?

help/wiki/Tournaments/OWC/2020 this page doesn't show it where else can I look?
lardon
#48 croatia #47 latvia #46 colombia #45 thailand
#44 hungary #43 switzerland #42 vietnam #41 uruguay
#40 peru #39 lithuania #38 denmark #37 czech republic
#36 belgium #35 spain #34 slovakia #33 portugal
#32 malaysia #31 philippines #30 austria #29 turkey
#28 ukraine #27 mexico #26 estonia #25 israel
#24 finland #23 argentina #22 singapore #21 chile
#20 indonesia #19 italy #18 netherlands #17 norway
#16 romania #15 taiwan #14 china #13 sweden
#12 united kingdom #11 japan #10 hong kong #9 brazil
#8 australia #7 france #6 russia #5 south korea
#4 germany #3 poland #2 canada #1 united states

for the results
chencliff
osu! World Cup 2020 - Challonge: https://challonge.com/OWC2020

Brackets! Brackets! Brackets! ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
KIMSEJEONG
RIP South Korea though. litteraly the hardest possible path...
UK -> Germany -> US
(if the favourites win their games)
Lefafel
What's with the total lack of information on the wiki (or other official sources)? It's wednesday night and we have no
- qualifier results or stats
- RO32 mappool
- bracket

Only source of any official info that I've been able to find was the results/showcase livestream. You can't seriously expect that's sufficient.

Really starting to feel like this tournament has completely abandoned the spectators.
PuffBuck

Lefafel wrote:

What's with the total lack of information on the wiki (or other official sources)? It's wednesday night and we have no
- qualifier results or stats
- RO32 mappool
- bracket

Only source of any official info that I've been able to find was the results/showcase livestream. You can't seriously expect that's sufficient.

Really starting to feel like this tournament has completely abandoned the spectators.
Feel free to ask questions and give feedback, but please avoid saying such unnecessary things. It's both rude and inaccurate. Since you have been involved as a staff member yourself quite a lot, you should know that staff are humans with their own circumstances. If you feel that you can contribute to improve things, you are always welcome to reach out.

I do agree that it would be proper for information to be added ASAP, which is not always possible. One reason is that reschedules can be requested until 23:59 UTC on Wednesdays (though a mistake in the wiki states otherwise right now) and to keep things less confusing, a bigger wiki update is being made once they have been settled. Let's be patient and respectful.

We are always working on improving things and if you compare the times they work to when they don't, things are running very smoothly as a whole, which is another reason to not throw out statements as soon as something is lacking.

You can usually find links faster through the Twitch channel, because I update them as soon as I have them myself, usually before the wiki updates are pushed. In case anyone wants to have the results quickly, the VOD is available.

Giving feedback through me personally or the Discord server is a possibility.

With that, please mind what you say. We always welcome feedback. All I'm asking for is keeping it as respectful and civil as possible.
Lefafel

PuffBuck wrote:

Lefafel wrote:

What's with the total lack of information on the wiki (or other official sources)? It's wednesday night and we have no
- qualifier results or stats
- RO32 mappool
- bracket

Only source of any official info that I've been able to find was the results/showcase livestream. You can't seriously expect that's sufficient.

Really starting to feel like this tournament has completely abandoned the spectators.
Feel free to ask questions and give feedback, but please avoid saying such unnecessary things. It's both rude and inaccurate. Since you have been involved as a staff member yourself quite a lot, you should know that staff are humans with their own circumstances. If you feel that you can contribute to improve things, you are always welcome to reach out.

I do agree that it would be proper for information to be added ASAP, which is not always possible. One reason is that reschedules can be requested until 23:59 UTC on Wednesdays (though a mistake in the wiki states otherwise right now) and to keep things less confusing, a bigger wiki update is being made once they have been settled. Let's be patient and respectful.

We are always working on improving things and if you compare the times they work to when they don't, things are running very smoothly as a whole, which is another reason to not throw out statements as soon as something is lacking.

You can usually find links faster through the Twitch channel, because I update them as soon as I have them myself, usually before the wiki updates are pushed. In case anyone wants to have the results quickly, the VOD is available.

Giving feedback through me personally or the Discord server is a possibility.

With that, please mind what you say. We always welcome feedback. All I'm asking for is keeping it as respectful and civil as possible.
Note: as of this post, the RO32 mappool has been updated onto the wiki, along with a link to a challonge bracket. So now we're "only" missing the actual qualifier results. A schedule was also updated, though it can't be considered final as the rescheduling window has not yet closed.

I don't think anything I said was unnecessary, or out of line. If you're so familiar with my contributions to the community, you'd know I don't censor my thoughts for the sake of your feelings. In fact, I find such an approach quite unpleasant and detrimental to the discourse.

If it's more people you need, just openly ask for more help. I saw many people make their own brackets, mappool listings, qualifier result tables etc. within hours of the showcase stream. It's not a lot of work, nor does it take any significant qualifications. Just. Ask. For. Help.
If it's the wiki update process itself that's the issue, then you need a secondary, actually functional platform for sharing info. I would suggest the OP of this thread, for example. The bottom line is, it's unacceptable to not have any of this stuff available this far into the week.

I specifically did not include lack of schedules in my OP, since I'm aware of the rescheduling rules (It would be fine to just have the match pairings listed with a TBD for the match times, for example). Those of us who actually need that info earlier, can generally get it by asking the relevant players for it.

This is only the second week of OWC2020, and both weeks we saw a major lapse in communication towards the public. I dearly hope it doesn't turn into 3 out of 3 next week, but surely you can see why some of us are sceptical at this point.
chencliff
PuffBuck

Lefafel wrote:

Note: as of this post, the RO32 mappool has been updated onto the wiki, along with a link to a challonge bracket. So now we're "only" missing the actual qualifier results. A schedule was also updated, though it can't be considered final as the rescheduling window has not yet closed.

I don't think anything I said was unnecessary, or out of line. If you're so familiar with my contributions to the community, you'd know I don't censor my thoughts for the sake of your feelings. In fact, I find such an approach quite unpleasant and detrimental to the discourse.

If it's more people you need, just openly ask for more help. I saw many people make their own brackets, mappool listings, qualifier result tables etc. within hours of the showcase stream. It's not a lot of work, nor does it take any significant qualifications. Just. Ask. For. Help.
If it's the wiki update process itself that's the issue, then you need a secondary, actually functional platform for sharing info. I would suggest the OP of this thread, for example. The bottom line is, it's unacceptable to not have any of this stuff available this far into the week.

I specifically did not include lack of schedules in my OP, since I'm aware of the rescheduling rules (It would be fine to just have the match pairings listed with a TBD for the match times, for example). Those of us who actually need that info earlier, can generally get it by asking the relevant players for it.

This is only the second week of OWC2020, and both weeks we saw a major lapse in communication towards the public. I dearly hope it doesn't turn into 3 out of 3 next week, but surely you can see why some of us are sceptical at this point.
While I agree that feelings shouldn't be prioritized over facts, I am a strong believer of emotional intelligence. To claim that a tournament, aka the staff team, has "abandoned the spectators" over a wiki update is not only disproportionate but also incorrect, which was a point I had hoped you would pick up on as a member of staff yourself. That also answers why it might have come off as censoring, something I'm actively working against.

If you would consider yourself abandoning spectators over making a mistake, I find that unhealthy. If not, why would we?

The other situation (if we're thinking about the same one), I have no involvement in.

I think community driven contributions are great. At the same time, we are currently in a position where most links need to be hosted by our staff team for the channel and that goes for the wiki too. This is something I can bring up for discussion. For the discussion threads, it's not an issue at all. We have several areas that are always looking for more people and I recommended it to you personally since you are displeased with how things are being run right now. I believe in being the change you want to see. I am a moderator and that's the only area that I'm in change of, so anyone interested in helping has to reach out to our managers.

Knowing the internal circumstances, I don't think it's unacceptable. I do agree that things could work better and as I mentioned, we are always working towards improvement. If it's about bringing in staff for wiki commitment, then there's a process to it, which is outside of my area of responsibility.

I do understand the frustrations people are experiencing and I don't plan to brush their feelings off. I simply want a kinder world. We are all in this crazy world together and people are trying hard to balance their work with hosting tournaments and managing their personal lives. That's why I have an issue with statements like "Really starting to feel like this tournament has completely abandoned the spectators". It makes it sound intentional.

Us being understaffed is something that I have been aware off since I started almost 2 years ago and as I mentioned, it's not my thing to handle unless it's for the Twitch chat, so I can't comment more on that than I already have.

I hope this answers some of your thoughts and that we understand each other a little bit better. I do appreciate your points and civil manner, so thank you for that.
chencliff
Oh wait, for the brackets, use this link instead: https://challonge.com/OWC_2020 (for those who are lazy to search on wiki)
The link I posted earlier is not founded on the osu! website.
For whatever reason, I think WalterToro created another link to the bracket...

Basically, this link, (most recent one), with an underscore symbol, _ , is founded on the osu! website while the link that was posted earlier without an underscore symbol is taken by someone else...
adia

PuffBuck wrote:

adia wrote:

It is a pity that Kazakhstan does not participate!
Maybe another year! That would be fun!
Yes, that would be fun!
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply

/