Static Noise Bird wrote:

Timing check via request~

I think the BPM for the second part plays and sounds better with 142 BPM and earlier offset, around 18060. Also delete the last timing section, and snap them into this offset.

-Kirito wrote:

hi Arnold0
(P o M u T a) From Mod team/M4M(Taiko/Osu), guest diff (Taiko/Osu/CTB)
Please ignore my modding!

[General]
#2 BPM 142.500 offset 18109 - BPM and Offset is not correct. I'll wait what the GD mappers think because I think actual is good

[Normal]
00:12:766 - Circle add? or 00:11:534 (1) - Arrow, generated by the synthesis. Circle added
00:19:750 (4) - Arrow delete slides a fixed length (http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/567322) Okey
00:21:017 - Circle add? I did not liked the sound of the circle alone, so I've added a slider which start here 00:20:806 and end where you say

[Insane]
00:23:975 - 00:24:081 - Will help put more circles in the stream here. Fixed
00:31:581 (1) - In lieu of this http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/567300 I think the spinner here folowing the long sound in the music is good so no change
00:41:933 - Circle add? No I don't like how a circle sound here during the fade out.

p.s This brought new files from YouTube.
mp3 file DL
you can ignore this. Sorry I don't take, because the quality is not so good, and the music don't realy sound the same (Taking files from youtube I not a good idea I think too)

Ranked hope!

Thanks for mod

• Easy
  
  00:36:651 - Delete everything after that. The mp3 stops fading out. And finish with a spinner: 00:34:961 (1)
  
  Normal
  
  00:18:271 (2) - Delete that.
  00:36:651 - Delete everything after that. The mp3 stops fading out. And finish with a spinner: 00:34:961 (1)
  
  Hard
  
  00:25:665 (3,4,5) - Its hidden. Place it elsewhere.
  00:36:651 - Delete everything after that. The mp3 stops fading out. And finish with a spinner: 00:34:961 (1)
  
  (Sorry, i'm not that good with insanes.)

Cancel wrote:

Hi. From modding queue.

• 
  
  Normal
  
  00:18:271 (2) - Delete that. Oops misplaced slider start here. Removed (Because if fixed it had to be on a blue tick), and I've added just a note where the end of this slider was, because with nothing it sound too empty
  00:36:651 - Delete everything after that. The mp3 stops fading out. And finish with a spinner: 00:34:961 (1) Why? I think mapping to the end of the fadeout is okey, and doing that would reduce draining time, which is already realy short (Recommanded minimum is 45sec, this already is 41 )

Good Luck!

-Kirito wrote:

hi Arnold0
(P o M u T a) From Mod team/M4M(Taiko/Osu), guest diff (Taiko/Osu/CTB)
Please ignore my modding!

[General]
#2 BPM 142.500 offset 18109 - BPM and Offset is not correct. i think strangely

[PMT's Hard]
00:23:130 (5) - NC?
00:31:581 (1) - Spinner end : 00:33:271 - ?
00:41:299 - Circle add?
All no chenge. it's fine.
Ranked hope!

Cancel wrote:

Hi. From modding queue.

Hard

00:25:665 (3,4,5) - Its hidden. Place it elsewhere.
00:36:651 - Delete everything after that. The mp3 stops fading out. And finish with a spinner: 00:34:961 (1)
i not understand All no chenge.

(Sorry, i'm not that good with insanes.)[/list]

Good Luck!

BounceBabe wrote:

Hi from the Queue!

General

Add a Kiai part ? Here maybe 00:36:651 - Done on my diffs

Normal

00:31:581 (1) - Players need time to prepare for next element, make this shorter one white tick or better make a slider i suggest to make a slider though since it would be too short if you shorten the spinner Fixed by long slider

Insane

00:07:835 (1) - Remove NC add NC on 00:08:246 (3) - Done

Nothing more, good luck

1. 00:40:031 to end - I really recommend reducing the volume faster and lower, probably making the last bit 5%. The current volume decreases aren't enough and at the end of the song the hitsounds are loud and sound very bad when the music begins to fade away, especially when you include claps.

1. 00:23:130 (3,4) - This rhythm will make beginners very confused because you stop following the melody line at the 3 and you have this awkward pickup slider with the 4 that brings us back. We should just keep following the melody, just another long slider would do fine imo.
   
   
   
   
2. 00:36:651 (1,2) - These sliders look very bad together Moway. >< Can you try making a two slider pattern that fits together a bit better just like you did at 00:24:820 (1,2)?

1. 00:01:260 (1,2) - To me, it's very awkward to have the downbeat that starts the song be on the end of the slider 1. It would be much better if you had the same idea here that you do in your insane diff. Shorten the 1 to end at 00:01:465 and move the 2 to 00:01:671 and have it end at 00:02:287. This rhythm will be much more intuitive to play and will fit the song very well. It's alright to have a 1/2 slider in the normal diff.
   
   
   
   
2. 00:06:602 (8,9) - This rhythm is very awkward to me because the music at 00:06:602 makes me feel like we should have a slider because it's a held note after a series of short notes. Try switching the position of the 8 and 9 on the timeline here so we can have a slider on that held note.
   
   
   
   
3. 00:07:835 (1,2) - Again I really recommend using the same rhythm as 00:01:260 (1,2). It would play so much better.
   
   
4. 00:41:510 (3) - It's a bit strange that you have broken the pattern here. To follow the music better, maybe move this slider to 00:41:721 and shorten it to end at 00:42:144 and add a circle at 00:41:510.

1. 00:01:671 - You're missing a finish here on this downbeat like all the other diffs have to start the song.
   
   
2. 00:08:246 - Missing finish on this downbeat according to patterns in other diffs.
   
   
3. 00:17:287 (1) - Maybe add a finish to the end of this slider like you have in the insane diff.
   
   
4. 00:36:651 (1) - I think a finish would sound very nice on the head here to start the phrase.

1. 00:04:958 (1) - Maybe add a finish to the head just like the insane diff has. It sounds very nice with he flux in the music imo.
   
   
2. 00:08:246 (1) - Maybe add a finish here like the other diffs have. Again I think it sounds very nice.

1. 00:15:643 (2) - This 1/4th slider is a bit awkward to me because it's not really following anything in the music. It would be better as a 1/2 slider to fit the melody line there just like you've done with 00:14:821 (1,3,4).
   
   
   
   
2. 00:14:821 (1,2,3) - Maybe make the spacing constant here. Right now spacing is less from the 1 to the 2 and it's a bit strange.
   
   
3. 00:18:271 (2,3) - This rhythm is not following the rhythm correctly imo. The 3 should be at 00:18:482 to follow the drums correctly.
   
   
   
   
4. 00:24:820 (5,6,7,8,9,1,2,3,4,5) - This section is really awkward to play imo because for the first combo you are following the drums, and then in the second combo you suddenly switch to the melody and it's very confusing. It's strange to read the 00:25:031 (6,7) because polarity is not good. How about following the melody starting at the 00:24:820 (5) with some nice sliders?
   
   
   Something like that would be much nicer to read and play imo.
   
   
5. 00:31:158 (5) - Maybe for a bit better flow you could move this slider upwards so that it flows into the center of the grid and becomes a nice reflection of the 4.
   
   
   
   
6. 00:36:862 (2,3) - I suggest the same rhythm change here that I did at 00:18:271 (2,3) because it's the same section of music.
   
   
7. 00:38:658 (5) - Again it would follow the rhythm of the song much better if the 5 were at 00:38:764 and was a 1/2 slider.
   
   
8. 00:39:398 (7,4) - To me, it's a bit strange that spacing increases here for these circles. I think it would be better if they were 1.3 snap.

1. 00:36:651 (1) - Hm, maybe have a finish on the head to start the phrase stronger just like PMT did in his diff.
   
   
2. 00:18:799 (4) - The finish on the head here is a bit strange. I doesn't really fit the music imo and you didn't use one at 00:37:390 (4). I'd say remove it here.

Doomsday wrote:

Timing check! (sorry for the delay; looks like other people checked it out before me D:)

Either way, the timing looks about right. All I can suggest is a (very) minor offset change to the 2 timing points you have:

BPM: 146.00 Offset: 1669 (-2 to current offset)
BPM: 142.00 Offset: 18057 (-3 to current offset)

Good luck! (Don't kudosu this post. Not worth it)

UnitedWeSin wrote:

Hello Arnold0~
Modding from my queue.
Sorry for the huge delay. ><

[PMT's Hard]

Hitsounds

1. 00:04:958 (1) - Maybe add a finish to the head just like the insane diff has. It sounds very nice with he flux in the music imo.
   
   
2. 00:08:246 (1) - Maybe add a finish here like the other diffs have. Again I think it sounds very nice.

All fixed. nice suggesution
Ok, sorry if it's not helpful, I can't really get into this song.

UnitedWeSin wrote:

Hello Arnold0~
Modding from my queue.
Sorry for the huge delay. ><

[Moway's Easy]

Map Design/Rhythm

1. 00:23:130 (3,4) - This rhythm will make beginners very confused because you stop following the melody line at the 3 and you have this awkward pickup slider with the 4 that brings us back. We should just keep following the melody, just another long slider would do fine imo.
   
   
   fixed
   
   
2. 00:36:651 (1,2) - These sliders look very bad together Moway. >< Can you try making a two slider pattern that fits together a bit better just like you did at 00:24:820 (1,2)? fixed

Ok, sorry if it's not helpful, I can't really get into this song.

00:24:820 (5,6,7,8,9,1,2,3,4,5) - This section is really awkward to play imo because for the first combo you are following the drums, and then in the second combo you suddenly switch to the melody and it's very confusing. It's strange to read the 00:25:031 (6,7) because polarity is not good. How about following the melody starting at the 00:24:820 (5) with some nice sliders?
(click to toggle)

Something like that would be much nicer to read and play imo.

Quiz-chan wrote:

Didn't take an in-dept look but your map makes a commendable impression.
One thing bothering me is that in PMT's Hard (for instance), the diff is ending with the music fading out.
But nothing else has come to my eyes. For now.

pimpG wrote:

hi there

checking the timing again

00:18:057 move this timeline to 00:19:747
because 00:18:057 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - are part of the 146 bpm timeline....i mean resnap them after moving the timeline

sounds better, ask static noise bird and/or Doomsday if you are not sure

good luck

Quiz-chan wrote:

Didn't take an in-dept look but your map makes a commendable impression.
One thing bothering me is that in PMT's Hard (for instance), the diff is ending with the music fading out.
But nothing else has come to my eyes. For now.

BounceBabe wrote:

Hi, Recheck!

General

You didnt set any combo colours

Insane

Spacing is inconstistent, i advise you to improve it with one distance setting

00:07:525 (4) - Circle doesnt fit, delete Fixed
00:06:805 (2,3) - Spacing Fixed
00:07:627 (5,6) - ^ 1,28 instead of 1,30 ... Don't fix
00:20:486 (3,4) - ^ Fixed
00:21:226 (6,1) - ^ Fixed
00:28:937 (7,1) - Unstack them, plays better Fixed
00:37:071 (3,4,5) - Spacing difference, inconstistent spacing Fixed
00:40:028 (1,2,3) - ^ Fixed

No more, GL

pimpG wrote:

from popner's special rules queue

PMT's Hard

00:22:916 (4) - new combo here? combo is too long
00:29:042 (3) - imo you should make slider end at 00:29:465 and make a circle at 00:29:676 i think the current long slider breaks the flow and does not fits music well
..........
00:31:578 (1) - i think you should make spinner end at 00:33:268 - you are skipping rhythm with this really long spinner, everything since 00:33:479 could be mapped. that would make more sense imo
..........
00:36:226 (2) - why finish in this slider? well i hear a strange noise here (something like ocean waves ?) but i dont think it should be considered in the hitsounding, imo better let this without any hitsound
00:36:648 (1,2) - i think you should not use this "+" shape with this notes. its a different rhythm from the previous combo and i think it will flow better as unstacked sliders
00:38:338 (7) - new combo here? combo is too long

good luck

pimpG wrote:

from popner's special rules queue

general

Inconsistency in PreviewTime:

Insane : 18107
Moway's Easy : 18057
Normal : 18057
PMT's Hard : 18057

i dont plan to force my last timing check here, but as i said before everything between 00:18:057 - and 00:19:747 - is a bit off
please get other timing checks. timing is very important[/color]

normal

lots of unsnapped notes here.. click resnap all notes and then check aimod or aibat
o_O how that appened ?! Fixed
00:04:342 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - this stream is too long. the difficulty here is too high comparing to most parts in this normal please consider making them more simple, also the next and previous combo are following almost the same rhythm but they are a lot simple. Deleted a note and moved a slider but I don't know how to make more easier than this without having empty sounds.
00:14:821 (3) - new combo here since its a different rhythm than 00:13:177 (1,2) - Fixed
00:17:287 (1) - slider end is after the timeline and its unsnapped, its unrankeable issue and it must to be fixed But it sound perfect... Timing isue no change until I got new timing checks
00:24:395 - circle here or a half beat slider at 00:24:183 ? rhythm is simple here comparing to most parts in this normal Circle added
00:24:817 (1) - finish in slider start ? Okey
00:31:581 (6) - ^^
00:31:581 (6) - new combo here and remove in next note since its a new rhythm Done
00:34:961 (3) - new combo for the same reason above Done


insane

00:05:984 (7) - new combo Done
00:06:600 (1) - remove new combo Done
00:07:833 (5) - new combo Done
00:08:244 (1) - remove new combo Done
00:10:915 (8) - new combo Done
00:11:326 (9) - i think you should remove slider end and make spinner start at 00:11:634 . it will follow music better Yep
00:14:819 (1,2,3) - i think this pattern does not fits the music well. try this http://puu.sh/2oBYf or try the same as pmt's hard I think fine but slider (2) was too long (1/2 instead of 1/4 ) so it sound good after fixing slider (2) without touching other things for me.
..........
00:16:258 (4) - i think this circle is not necessary here, the rhythm you are follopwing in this combo ends at 00:16:052 and the next rhythm starts at 00:16:463 so the circle is not following anything at all. making this a small pause fits well the music Sound empty without it, so I keep it (Also it folow the sounds folowed by slder (1) and note (3) too)
..........
00:28:831 (6) - new combo Done
00:29:042 (1) - remove new combo Done
00:29:571 (2) - new combo Done
00:29:887 (1) - remove new combo Done
00:41:507 (6,7) - make a circle at 00:41:930 yep

good luck

Static Noise Bird wrote:

~popner's q~

[PMT]
00:09:888 (6,7) - Touching, move 6 or 7 away. This is No problem overlap.
00:22:282 (3) - Endpoint x244 y140 if you'd like a blanket there. nice suggestion fixed.
00:29:042 (3) - This long slider doesn't fit in a part like this. fmm, Finally Done.



good luck

1669,410.958904109589,4,1,0,70,1,0
14819,400,4,1,0,70,1,0
16419,410.958904109589,4,1,0,70,1,0
18062,422.535211267606,4,1,0,70,1,0

1. 00:16:052 - end spinner here, then add notes here 00:17:285 | 00:17:696
2. 00:34:958 (1) - changed to half-beat slider.

1. 00:05:573 (5) - curved the other way round, and move up a bit
2. 00:10:093 (6) - curved this more.
   
3. 00:13:175 (1) - remove nc

1. 00:02:696 (1) - new combo
2. 00:09:066 (6,7,8) - how about this
   
3. 00:23:127 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - these pacement can be better than this
4. 00:27:775 (1) - remove nc
5. 00:28:197 (3) - new combo
6. 00:28:831 (1) - remove nc
7. 00:29:571 (1) - ^
8. 00:29:887 (3) - new combo

Froztic wrote:

hi, from popner's queue

all are suggestions unless underline.


[PMT's Hard]
00:42:141 (6) - ctrl+h ? spacing 0.25 o.o sorry, no change ;_;

nice diff here. thanks~

GL

Static Noise Bird wrote:

~popner's q~


[Normal]
00:19:324 (3,4) -
okey

00:24:395 (5) - Consider adding a clap. yep
00:27:775 (1,2,3,4,5) - Consider removing some of the claps.yep
00:34:958 (1) - Move it so (3)'s end won't touch this one's track. Huh it's soo small? it make it 2 (or 3 don't remenber) grid down like this it looks fine so I wont change more
00:36:648 (1) - Ugly shape. Fixed

[Insane]
00:18:268 (2) - x356 y208 Okey
00:27:141 (5) - Better just use a normal curve here. Fixed
00:38:761 (5,6,7,8) - This long straight lines aren't a good choice, make something creative. Changed a little

good luck

Froztic wrote:

hi, from popner's queue

all are suggestions unless underline.

[General]
• uncapital Of in the title. i'm not sure about Megaman

[Timing]
remove all red timing sections and use this one

1669,410.958904109589,4,1,0,70,1,0
14819,400,4,1,0,70,1,0
16419,410.958904109589,4,1,0,70,1,0
18062,422.535211267606,4,1,0,70,1,0

don't forget to snap other inherited timing sections


[Normal]
kiai : 00:18:057 - 00:24:817

1. 00:05:573 (5) - curved the other way round, and move up a bit
2. 00:10:093 (6) - curved this more.
   
3. 00:13:175 (1) - remove nc

^ done all

[Insane]
kiai : 00:18:057 - 00:24:817 Yep

1. 00:02:696 (1) - new combo Yep
2. 00:09:066 (6,7,8) - how about this Done something similar
   
3. 00:23:127 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - these pacement can be better than this IDK how to change these and I don't think they are so bad... Will change if some more complain
4. 00:27:775 (1) - remove nc yep
5. 00:28:197 (3) - new combo yep
6. 00:28:831 (1) - remove nc yep
7. 00:29:571 (1) - ^ yep
8. 00:29:887 (3) - new combo yep

GL

on edit: forget to add timing mod.

LKs wrote:

hi

[general]

if the GD mappers don't mind, setting kiai-times for their diffs? IDK I'll ask them if they want to use a differant one before.

00:17:285 (1) - Unsnapped slider (end) in normal Timing issue

notes sound very off around the second red section, try this http://puu.sh/2qslC Tryed but nope after that some sliders sound realy off

[Insane]

placement:

00:01:258 (1,2,3,4) - trying to convey some conception about placement. I rotated and reshaped slider1 and then let spacing between 123 even http://puu.sh/2qrqR refer to the pic it's almost the same with yours but it looks more symmetrical, solid and satisfactory, since the structure appears Think fixed
00:03:312 (4,5,6) - spacing 1.28 is awkward, with this spacing you can neither steer clear of overlaps nor you can have a nice overlap, pThink fixedter it's an alignment of curve it looks not good. http://puu.sh/2qrAD this is what we tend to put, although it's normal, it plays solid. ofc I'm not letting you change all 1/4s in your map, you can keep it in mind and use it later Okey I tried to do the same as yours
00:04:340 (1,2,3) - ^again, bad flow as well. another way here can help you set a proper spacing. http://puu.sh/2qrEl people's reaction toward imbalanced SV:spacing are various, sometimes the discrepancy is great, but for this map it's not Because of spacing issues after changing the one before I touched this but idk if it's okey
00:05:984 (1,2,3) - patterns like this always been omitted. I used blank line depicting your trace and blue line to depict the ideal one. the difference is minor but things get changed massivelyhttp://puu.sh/2qrNk actually if you map anything this is a useful tip IDK if fixed but changed
00:08:449 (4,5,6,7,8) - ^ think of cursor's movement while playing this, is this the best way in visual and playing? IDK if fixed but changed a little
00:09:477 (1,2,3) - ^ the slider is curved and two notes parallel to x axis IDK what's wrong so no change now
00:09:888 (2,3,4,5,6,7,1,2) - ^ sadly, I can't figure out what' your logic while mapping. notes formed an acute angle but sliders are slightly curved, inregardless of they are curved randomly I wanted to change dirrection. I changed a little positions of notes so they are not stright line, idk if this okey or not è_é

Easy is fine. Hard and Normal have some tiny issues I mentioned above, go refine the placement :3

Aunxfb wrote:

Hi, from popner's special mod queue
-------------------------------------------------------------

[General]
Audio File -While I understand that the fadeout is from the game itself, I don't like it very much at
all. How about an alternative? >Mediafire Link<
Note: This is from [Rockman EXE 5DS & 6 Music Encyclopedia] Don't want to change now (also having bad connexion now so I don't want to lose time with downloads)

Bg - looked kinda deformed to me, how about change to http://static.minitokyo.net/downloads/1 ... 1307334626 or http://static.minitokyo.net/downloads/4 ... 1967893423 ? Or you can just resize the original background with maintained aspect ratio
Link dead and also my friend did this BG using photoshop so no change


[Insane]
00:09:066 (6,7,8,1) - how about change to 00:09:272 (6) - ,00:09:374 (7) - ,00:09:477 (1) - instead? like:http://puu.sh/2rLu8/c290bd8e40 , it matches the music better imo. Okey
00:13:792 (2,3) - how about change into stacks? It's common to see stacks in Insane difficulty, but this map seem to have less of them. I realy don't like this kind of 2 notes 1/4 stacks while playing myself so nope
00:16:874 (2) - ^ Stacks with 3 notes works so yep
00:19:535 (1) - ^ Okey
00:29:042 (6,7,8,1) - add circle on those 1/4 ticks to make it a stream? I don't think it fit

[PMT's Hard]
Can't find anything

[Normal]
00:06:395 (7) - make it into slider that ends at 00:06:600 - ? Nope becaute there is already many 1/2 before so it let a little pause to the player
00:24:817 (1,2) -a little empty in between, add a note or two?(eg:add a circle here 00:25:873 - and here 00:26:085 - ) Nope because of the sound I folowed and it's normal so a little break is not bad
00:36:648 (1,2) - ^ ^
00:38:338 (3,1) - ^^

[Moway's Easy]
Can't find anything

Pretty good already, Gl for Rank

Arnold0 wrote:

Revive...
Still need a good timing ..............

Arnold0 wrote:

I realy should revive this if someone think he can found good timing please help ^.^

JhowM wrote:

BPM: 146 at 23 ms offset
BPM: 142 at 19543 ms offset

JhowM wrote:

Arnold0 wrote:

I realy should revive this if someone think he can found good timing please help ^.^

JhowM wrote:

BPM: 146 at 23 ms offset
BPM: 142 at 19543 ms offset

may put it 3 ms earlier

Arnold0 wrote:

EDIT : Addind a red line at 19754 - 142bpm by P o M u T a advice, to keep the white lines at the good place.

P o M u T a wrote:

umm,
00:41:536 - After this time heard bit off. not perfect.