Ok mentor checking go!
[General](TV Edit)? What's the difference between that and (TV size)?
Also shouldn't it be Buttefly instead of Butter-Fly?
[Easy]Well, technically it's a fine difficultly but for an Easy it's awfully hard to follow.
I took a little play on it and tried my best at just trying to follow the song (That I haven't heard before) and not thinking at the approach circles/spacing and I didn't fare so well.
ReplayI kinda felt like slower slider velocity would fit here but it might be just me.
The Overall difficulty is awfully high for an Easy and is even bigger than the AR, why?
I guess the somewhat small circle size for an Easy is to keep constant with the other difficulties right?
00:43:654 (1) - This strikes me as it could be centered a lot better, Just try to horizontally flip it until it's centered.
01:10:745 (8) - This circle is just out of place, please remove it.
01:16:200 (1,2) - (Suggestion) Add a clap at the first repeat and at the slider end at both sliders
Well as I said above, it's pretty hard to follow, I think this difficulity would be much better if you kept it more simple and maybe only used 1/1.
It's a ok Easy for those that knows this song by hard, but those that don't it's less forgiving and a lot of newer osu! players probably never heard it.
[Normal]Replay(I admit I was extra clumsy this playthrough <-< 00:42:564 (5) isn't hard to read at all.
00:17:836 (1) - Starting on a red tick is very confusing especially on the easier difficulties., I would say moving it 1/2 forward on the timeline would work much better
00:27:109 (1) - This would be much better as 1/2 or 1/1 longer. It just sounds wrong right now.
00:31:291 (4,5,6) - It's very awkward that you switched to what to map to here, especially because you stopped mapping to the vocals in the middle of the line/combo/whatever. It's even more weird that you map the first time it is that way but not the second time.
00:40:018 (4,5,6) - Can't you map it like 00:38:745 (1,2,3) instead. It's pretty much the same thing so different mapping so close to each other felt awkward.
00:46:745 - (Suggestion) Maybe add a circle here. (If you do that add a new combo on that and remove the new combo on the circle after it.
00:50:382 and 00:51:109 - (Suggestion) Add circles here.
01:11:473 (1,2) - (Uber nazi mode) Move one grid to the right so it's more centered.
01:16:200 (1,2) - (Suggestion) Add a clap at the first repeat and at the slider end at both sliders
[Taiko Hell]Taiko modding is far from anything for me as I hate the mapping style in them, but it striked me that there would be good with some more finishes in the difficulty. 00:26:745 (24), 00:27:473 (3) and 00:28:018 (6) - Would for an example be great places to add finishes on.
Otherwise I guess I can't comment on it much unless I would go into my standard taiko map rage but I felt:
00:06:382 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16) (And all the other patterns like this) is extra stupid as it has a very long unfitting stream and then a part when there even could be more beats and it would work nicely, atleast a circle at 00:08:200 with a clap.
[Hard]Replay (If you wanna see how bad I am)
Undoubtedly the best difficulty in the set. The patterns and rhythm are pretty good.
Just like in Easy, why does this have higher OD than AD, I don't think it needs that.
The hitsounds felt a bit random here, claps usually doesn't fit on 1/2's and 1/4's and the whistles felt like they were often where they wasn't needed, might do a hitsound mod alone later if you want.
00:18:200 - Add circle
00:46:564 and 00:46:745 - Add circles here please (And if you do that, add a new combo at the first circle and remove the new combo at 00:47:109 (1))
00:49:654 (1,2) - I find this anti-jump just weird, I think moving 00:50:018 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8) down some grids would be a much better option than having that anti-jump.
01:11:473 - This soft hitsound section just feels out of place, I think you would be better without it as it doesn't even exist in the other difficulties.
01:13:473 (10) - I think it would be better if you removed this circle imo.
01:16:200 (1,2) - (Suggestion) Add a clap at the first repeat and at the slider end at both sliders.
Well, not bad- I liked Hard and Normal was decent, Easy felt though as it could be a bit more newcomer friendly and Taiko is... Taiko.
Oh well.
*star*