Nymph_ wrote:

Hi Nymph here~ and request got from: Kanon's Mod Queue~

General:
BG1 seems to be a bit odd for me, for the proportion seems a bit strange, so maybe fix it a little ? Just need to increase the height imo.　I took the original one and cut off most of the background XD

Easy:
00:57:305 (5) - I don't really like nazi but this spacing is really a little ugly 　Moved a little, but still the pattern.
others fine~

Hard:
I suggest more soft-whistles on this diff, seems the hitsounds now is a little too simple.　Yes, it's simple, but I'll stay the same for now.
00:42:861 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Because seeing you changed to normal hitsound at here:00:42:861 (6), Then I suggest all of these using normal hitsound, and cancel the clap hitsounds. And consider add a volumn increasing here seems to be very nice.　That's not really what I want, but still thanks for the suggestion, instead of that, I increased the volumes only.
00:43:833 (3) - add note here　Fixed
01:16:194 (8) - finish instead of whistle?　Fixed

Good luck~

RinNa wrote:

:3

flatps wrote:

Star~

Leorda wrote:

Hello

General
* I'm not sure if Outro video is safe　It's prefectly safe.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

Easy
00:31:194 (5) - Make sure the sliderbody is visible for easy diff, this will be easier to see for beginner player if you change this　Fixed
00:40:083 (4) - ^　I'll keep this for now
01:15:083 (3) - ^　^

------------------------------------------------------------------------

Hard
* AR -1?　No, but thanks for your suggestion.

00:33:694 (6,1) - No anti-jump please　Fixed
00:40:083 (1) - I think this slider is pretty silly　Changed it to 2 circles.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

cya　Bye ;D

Rukarioman wrote:

General:
- BG1 has wrong aspect ratio. it should be 1024x768. At the moment it is at 1024x759.　I just deleted BG1.
- Why do you really need two different BGs? Got a good explanation?

Hard:
Use tick rate 2 like Normal did?　Fixed
00:33:694 (6,1) - Please get rid of that anti-jump. Plays and looks fairly bad.　Fixed

Easy was rather boring, in terms of rhythm but the other were pretty cool. Especially Insane. Gonna recheck this　I know my Easy is boring ;__; thanks for your mod.

Leorda wrote:

Winber1's Insane
01:02:027 (6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14) - Not sure if 1/8 streams are unrankable

Haku's Normal
* Are you overusing the kiai ._.? Seriously It's not called overusing, seriously. It's called overusing when you use fountains in a contnued pulse-like manner.
* I think this Slider Velocity is high than Hard diff It's nothing, it's more about how you mapped than what setting you used that decide the difficulty.

00:51:194 (4) - Remove finish
00:57:583 (1) - Remove clap
00:59:250 (4) - Not stack perfectly with tail slider it's 0.02 O.O and it's considered unecessary nazi, since it don'tchange much because of auto-stacking
01:18:694 (1) - Too near from spinner, it's inappropriate for normal diff (?) (look the timeline) Following music make it easier

Haku's Normal:
This diff still has all the kiai fountains, and the other diffs don't. Please remove them. It's not called overusing, seriously. It's called overusing when you use fountains in a contnued pulse-like manner. i used 4 fountains that are godly placed, plus them don't prevent the player from seeing the notes. Plus it's a Guideline and not even a rule, that I broke for a good reason: making the map better. So i won't remove it.

winber1 wrote:

In all honesty, I don't think those fountains fit as well as they could. The music just isn't epic enough in those few places in comparison to the rest of the section at least in my opinion. However, they are logically placed and are consistent to a specific pattern in the music, so I have no problem with them being there. I myself wouldn't really want to add it in, but I don't think it's a problem having different kiai times if it is the mappers decision to do so.

although i do not consider it overusing kiai times, i also do not consider them the best use of fountains. That's basically my view.

Well, i guess the final decision goes to gina. If she wants to add the kiai fountains in her difficulties, I will gladly follow. If not, well, i'll just leave it as is then lol.

gina91189 wrote:

or even just go back to the original kiai we had before

winber1 wrote:

gina91189 wrote:

or even just go back to the original kiai we had before

omg yes :3

i don't find anything wrong with long kiai times ._.

Rukarioman wrote:

Looks alright now. The kiai makes sense and it's okay because the different kiai is on a guest mapper diff.
Bubbled.

EDIT: someone made me notice that the custom hitclaps have too much silence in the beginning, which makes them lag the offsets and let it feel wrong.

jericho2442 wrote:

fixed hitsounds
http://puu.sh/3RHe
http://puu.sh/3RHh

just replace them

stiss wrote:

so good song
fighting for star
good luck.
your cute girl!!

Rukarioman wrote:

Alright now everything should be fine. Re-Bubbled.

Look at this message.
Do you think it's too short?
...
Well, then you're a hypocrit.
:3

Rukarioman wrote:

hypocrit.

kevinli111 wrote:

NICE MAP xDD 我才剛剛學到如何star別人的map而已 xDD

kanpakyin wrote:

Bubble了..加油找bat lol
好把...
預先恭喜

SapphireGhost wrote:

When I downloaded this to mod, I only got [Easy] and [car's Taiko]! Not sure why this happened but you might want to ask someone else if they get the same thing.

SapphireGhost wrote:

Great, I can do a full mod now. Also, most of this is overlap stuffs that you don't have to change.

[General]
Tick Rate: It's good to use the same Tick Rate for each difficulty, it keeps things consistent and there are sliderticks where there should be.　There would be too many for Easy then, so changed Taiko's only.

[Hard]
00:47:861 (2,3,4,5,6) - Remove the slight overlap here. (Stacking causes (2,3,4) to hit (5).)　I guess there are fine there ... ? So no changed.
00:54:527 (3) - It would also be nice to remove the overlap with (1) here.　Fixed

Looks good! Have a regular star and also a kudosu star for the self-pop.　Thanks for the stars, but you also pointed out a big problem for me >w<, so I won't really care about this self-popped.

Suzully wrote:

Steins;Gate! o.o　　　　
I hope bubble come back 　　　　

[Haku's Normal]
I'm not a big fan of the kiai bursts, but it's ok.
01:15:639 (3) - Maybe take this out from under the slider? I think it looks better.

Evil_Twilight wrote:

觸口羊好萌
觸口羊好觸
角蜀咩好神
角蜀咩好O

jericho2442 wrote:

fix your comboburst-0 and comboburst-2 size as i told you in irc,
make combo color 3 and 4 abit more different because at the moment when kiai hits they are waaaay too hard to notice a difference.

Insane
00:17:027 (2,3,4,5,1) - this spacing plays bad, the jump on (5,1) is identical spacing but different timing to the spacing at (2,3) i really advise to space (5,1) closer like the timing asks for

--------------------------
fix them and i will rank, popping untill so it dont get ranked with the two general problems