forum

[added] [osu!taiko Proposal] Clarify the meaning of "simplistic" in lower difficulties' RC

posted
Total Posts
14
Topic Starter
Hivie

Kantan RC wrote:

If a 1/2 pattern is used, the patterns must stay simplistic and be followed by a rest moment. Finisher notes must not be used in patterns as such. For songs that follow a swing beat, this limit is 1/3.

Futsuu RC wrote:

If a 1/3 pattern is used, the patterns must stay simplistic. Finisher notes must not be used in patterns as such.
for the longest time (multiple years), we've been treating simplistic as no finishers, and no color changes, we modded around that and reset nominations because of that too. feels odd to not have that change reflected in the RC because it's currently causing confusions right now.

Proposal


The following wording adjustment would solve this issue and reflect our current standards:

Kantan Proposal wrote:

If a 1/2 pattern is used, the patterns must stay simplistic and be followed by a rest moment. Color changes, or finisher notes must not be used in patterns as such. For songs that follow a swing beat, this limit is 1/3.

Futsuu RC wrote:

If a 1/3 pattern is used, the patterns must stay simplistic. Color changes, or finisher notes must not be used in patterns as such.
enneya
yea
Erowdi
I agree! <3
BlackBN
yea more clear
Burak
totally makes sense so yes
HEAVENLY MOON
yeah agreed
meiqth
Fully agree, especially given I had the wrong interpretation of "simplistic" for over a year while being a BN.

The comma in the specifics seems unneeded though, aside from that it seems perfect!
davidminh0111
Much clearer explanation to the main point.
Doug
It was a little hard to understand what "simplistic" meant, I agree with the changes.
Ideal
clarification is always good, so yep
maxie
I 100% agree the clarification makes it much simpler to understand
Greenshell
yea seems good
Topic Starter
Hivie
after checking with other taiko nats, i went ahead and made a PR: https://github.com/ppy/osu-wiki/pull/8906
aceticke
Late, but agree.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply