forum

Hommarju feat. R.Cena - Chousai Kenbo Sengen

posted
Total Posts
136
show more
Avedas
This needs a star. :)
Laurier
star~★
Peace_old_1
:D
Angeloid_Alpha
star
vodichka
*
Colin Hou
[General]:
  1. the BG has a strange aspect ratio, seems like you resized 16:10/16:9 image to 4:3?
  2. 00:26:672 ~ 00:36:272 (T) - this part sounds empty in all diffs, try use some soft-hitwhistles? (when I beat the notes, I can't feel/hear them, that's a bit weired)
  3. 01:38:672 ~ 01:48:272 (T) - ^
[Hard]:
  1. 00:12:197 (T) - move the volume/hitsounds settings to the red line and delete this one.
  2. 02:40:772 (3,4) - 3 grids down?
other diffs seems fine for me, have a star!
Apricot
:oops: :oops:
spark_sk
Masana
nice :)
tobaku2784
nicemap yeah! :3
Mitiai
Kawaii song :3333
Masquerade
godsong and godmap!
gogo~
PeaChick
star ~ :D
Nivra
star
maxvsnoiz
star~(●・ω・)ノ。、::。.::・'゜☆
Hakeru
ほし
Minty Gum
I was stalking you since I liked Exec_Cosmoflips so much, and as expected, all of your maps are great :D This deserves to be ranked, of course, so here's a star~
pekos
star
Sir Minelli
Hello,


[General]

02:38:672 - Why would you finish the kiai right at the middle of the spinner? Stars stopped coming out from the cursor while I was playing :(
02:17:072 - Add a finish sound here in all of the difficulties. It's where kiai timing begins.
Normal difficulty is a tad hard.


[Easy]

Aesthetic suggestions~

00:52:472 (2) - Align with fading: 00:50:072 (2) - (One grid down does the job)
01:19:472 (1) - Slider's position breaks the smoothness of play. How about this:
02:23:072 (2) - Align with fading: 02:20:672 (3) - (One grid up does the job)


[Normal]

According to the rythm:
01:40:472 (1) - Undo new combo, then: 01:41:372 (7) - New combo, then: 01:42:272 (1) - Undo new combo, then: 01:43:172 (6) - New combo, then: 01:43:472 (1) - Undo new combo.

Aesthetic suggestions~

00:14:672 (3) - One grid left to align with (2)'s hitcirlce


[Hard]

00:31:172 (5) - New combo
00:39:872 (1) - Undo new combo, then: 00:40:772 (10) - New combo.
01:07:472 (5) - Minor spacing
01:18:272 (1) - Undo new combo, then: 01:19:172 (7) - New combo.
01:22:922 (6) - New combo.
01:52:622 (8,1,2,1,2) - To match this pattern's combo style, do the following:
01:43:172 (9) - New combo, then: 01:43:772 (1) - Undo new combo, then: 01:44:372 (4) - New combo.
To match the following kiai pattern's combo style, do the following:
02:16:772 (8) - New combo, then: 02:17:372 (1) - Undo new combo, then: 02:18:272 (6) - New combo.

Aesthetic suggestions~

01:13:622 (1) - Align with fading: 01:12:272 (1) -


[Insane]

00:32:522 (5) - New combo.
Warning: The following combo changes will create large intuitive spacing jumps. The combo changes are correct according to the rythm, even though, you might want to edit a couple of patterns if you feel that the jumps are way too much.
01:12:572 (1) - Undo the new combo, then: 01:13:322 (8) - New combo.
01:14:372 (9) - New combo, then: 01:14:672 (1) - Undo new combo.
01:15:422 (7) - New combo, then: 01:16:172 (1) - Undo new combo.
01:16:622 (7) - New combo, then 01:17:072 (1) - Undo new combo, then: 01:17:972 (10) - New combo, then: 01:18:272 (1) - Undo new combo.
01:21:422 (6) - New combo, then: 01:21:872 (1) - Undo new combo, then: 01:22:922 (8) - Undo new combo, then: 01:23:222 (1) - Undo new combo.

Ok from here on, there are some combo changes that you might want to consider editing regarding the rythm.

Unfortunately I ran out of time and gotta go. If you need another mod, feel free to pm.


Good luck, and this earned a star.
Topic Starter
galvenize
Thanks, applied most of the changes in all diff except in insane where I'd like to keep the combos the way they are at the moment.
Verdisphena
:oops:
NatsumeRin
good.
tyokokoa
:)
Faust
untz untz untz untz
-Chance-
:)
Squidifications
☆★☆~
lolcubes
Hey galvenize!
Here's some stuff. Opinions and suggestions will be in green, and you can just ignore them if you don't care.

[Insane]:
  1. Difficulty: OD-1. Streamy maps with OD8 are just ridiculous if you ask me. Don't think people will SS this, apart from the usual 2-3 ones.
  2. 00:59:522 (4) - This note brings out lots of hatred from me. :D Even with 300s turned off it was really hard to notice. I like your patterns but if you can, please fix this so it's atleast a little visible, a 1-2 grid4 move just so you can see a glimpse of it would be really nice.
  3. 01:50:372 (5) - Clap at the start of the slider?
  4. 02:39:872 (1,2,3,4) - These notes are silenced. That's unrankable. Please make them hearable.
  5. 02:41:147 - Add a timing section here which removes the kiai. Afaik, unclosed kiai isn't allowed. Or, if your intention was to end it on the previous timing section (which I assume so, looking at the other diffs), just end it on the previous section without adding this one, but don't forget to enable it on the timing section @spinner before.
[Hard]:
  1. Slightly hard for a hard, looks more like a standard insane diff. Looking how Insane is harder, I guess that's fine. ,_,
  2. 00:56:672 (7) - Add a clap at the end of the slider?
[Normal]:
  1. 01:49:472 (1,2,3,4) - Fix the spacing in the combo, 2 looks unsnapped in a weird way.
  2. 02:08:972 (1) - Don't think you really need a new combo for this. I see you have many new combos which could be removed but they make sense more or less, this one doesn't that much.
[Easy]:
  1. 00:42:872 (3) - Maybe remove this note? It kinda feels odd because there isn't one @00:41:672.
[General]:
  1. While the background's dimensions are alright, the picture feels like it was widescreen and then it just got compressed to 4:3 ratio. Such slim Kyouka doesn't look that good. :D If possible try to find a better background for this mapset, just a suggestion (I couldn't find one ;_;).
A short mod, because there wasn't anything to mod. Maybe try to reduce the number of new combos in Normal, but I don't think they're wrong, so...
Good luck.~ :3
Topic Starter
galvenize

lolcubes wrote:

Hey galvenize!
Here's some stuff. Opinions and suggestions will be in green, and you can just ignore them if you don't care.

[Insane]:
  1. Difficulty: OD-1. Streamy maps with OD8 are just ridiculous if you ask me. Don't think people will SS this, apart from the usual 2-3 ones.
    The less SS there are, the better. I always prioritize a high OD. DR is at 6, allowing more people to clear the map which I think is more important than having tons of SS's.
  2. 00:59:522 (4) - This note brings out lots of hatred from me. :D Even with 300s turned off it was really hard to notice. I like your patterns but if you can, please fix this so it's atleast a little visible, a 1-2 grid4 move just so you can see a glimpse of it would be really nice. Stacking notes is what makes it insane, streams aside.
  3. 01:50:372 (5) - Clap at the start of the slider? nice
  4. 02:39:872 (1,2,3,4) - These notes are silenced. That's unrankable. Please make them hearable. Indeed, fix'd
  5. 02:41:147 - Add a timing section here which removes the kiai. Afaik, unclosed kiai isn't allowed. Or, if your intention was to end it on the previous timing section (which I assume so, looking at the other diffs), just end it on the previous section without adding this one, but don't forget to enable it on the timing section @spinner before. little mistake, fix'd
[Hard]:
  1. Slightly hard for a hard, looks more like a standard insane diff. Looking how Insane is harder, I guess that's fine. ,_,
  2. 00:56:672 (7) - Add a clap at the end of the slider?
[Normal]:
  1. 01:49:472 (1,2,3,4) - Fix the spacing in the combo, 2 looks unsnapped in a weird way. mkay
  2. 02:08:972 (1) - Don't think you really need a new combo for this. I see you have many new combos which could be removed but they make sense more or less, this one doesn't that much. ye, removed
[Easy]:
  1. 00:42:872 (3) - Maybe remove this note? It kinda feels odd because there isn't one @00:41:672. If i remove it, there would be a huge empty space.
[General]:
  1. While the background's dimensions are alright, the picture feels like it was widescreen and then it just got compressed to 4:3 ratio. Such slim Kyouka doesn't look that good. :D If possible try to find a better background for this mapset, just a suggestion (I couldn't find one ;_;).
A short mod, because there wasn't anything to mod. Maybe try to reduce the number of new combos in Normal, but I don't think they're wrong, so...
Good luck.~ :3
Musty
epic o.o
Ragdoll96
;)
ibavnoci
:)
Norn_NNN
:) :) :)
Sherry
star~ ;)
Elfice
\:D/
LuPiiTa
yay~!
1clickper10second
nice map
Acyfd
:)
Gorlum
Platinum map
fushianatan
star!
Kawayi Rika
:) good map
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply