forum

Inconsistency in Genre/Language field

posted
Total Posts
2
Topic Starter
dopaminos
I may be wrong, because i didn't see any RC line about this, but, let me show you something.
beatmapsets/36319#osu/403050 Genre - Electronic (D'N'B), which is correct.
beatmapsets/710848#osu/1502678 Genre - Anime, which is NOT correct obviously.

I didn't found anything in RC about Genre/Language but... What if we will get some Rock/Polish song remixed to Instrumental/Trance and... it should have original song meta? In my opinion that's kinda weird and need some clarification or even RC proposal like
  1. If song is being a remix of song with different Genre or Language, it should use ... (idk)
A - metadata of the original song
B - metadata of the remix

Am i right, that nothing tells about how to fill this field correct?
I just feel really weird about new Fallen Angel beatmap and Pirahna (just first two examples)

If we will use option A, Pirahna Should be Pop or Rock if we will look on the original song



upd proposal
Eni
Agree that some clarification would be nice. I feel like genre/language should come from the remix/cover instead of the original song since that's what people hear.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply