forum

An osu! Mafia - TOWN WIN

posted
Total Posts
381
show more
Mashley
Wojjan y u so suspicious?
Wojjan
Because I'm the only one who's saying shit.
Mashley
That was bloody fast :O
Well, I guess I'd agree with you that 4 or 5 mafia seems most likely, you never really know though :\
Vote adam2046. He was too quick to jump from his first randovote to the player who's actually starting discussion. To randovote is one thing, but to change it so quickly makes me raise an eyebrow. Well, we'll see.
MDuh
oh cool, a very widespread vote situation at the very first day..
DeathxShinigami
Wojjan HAS TO BE by far the most productive Mafia player :o
Quaraezha
These people haven't posted yet:

pieguy1372, dkun, 0_o, and iMuffin

It is possible that they have no idea the game is already going on
or they are purposely lurking and try not to put any suspicion on them.
I'm just sayin'.

Also, Wojjan is pretty suspicious to me too, but he has a good point though.
Not quite sure about adam though.
Kitsunemimi
Dude, they have a week to post, they just want to see how stuff plays out for the first little while, so they don't make a dumb decision on the first day. Either that, or they actually don't know for some reason, but it's not like it really matters that much.
Wojjan
Lurking is far from a stable scumtell, especially on day one, and I don't really like your apparent voteshoving. If you suspect someeone, at least tell us why, or it's better just to keep your mouth shut for the time being. Just sayin'.

Mash, I don't think adam was remotely serious when he was voting for me on criticising my spelling of italian words. It's a random vote like any other, maybe just to provoke.

I'm really not liking all this nonsense about innocents and guilties, Quaraezha, so I'll cut you short by saying that it make you look like a mafia member. Those OMGUS foses towards anyone who raised an eyebrow against you didn't help. If we're going to use a lynch today (and I still adamantly preach any no lynch to be useless in an open setup) we can just as well lynch you.

A Vote on Quaraezha.
DeathxShinigami
In a way it's like all of the newcomer players ARE MAFIA!
Mashley
It could be in this very room... It could be you! It could be me! It could even be...
0_o
Posting to say that I'm here and have been following the thread. Haven't formed any solid opinions yet since people find pretty much anything suspicious on Day 1, but I'll be sure to pipe in if I have anything to say.
Claudia_old
Also, just saying, but Wojjie is probably right on the number of mafia. I don't quite see how pointing that out is suspicious, but then again...this is Mafia.
rust45

Quaraezha wrote:

rust45 wrote:

Vote: E-Hooker
I'm not found of hookers.
What is this, I don't even
I meant to say I wasn't fond of hookers, but it doesn't really matter anyway due to the fact that it was a random vote.
Wojjan
Oh hey facebro, good to see you paying attention. Do you think Quaraezha is suspicious? Like if you had to call something right now. Scum or town?
Kokizi
^Answering this question anyway.

Judging from the other mafia games I have played with him, he's a townie.

He's always been like that whenever there's a mafia game, and he always ends up being lynched. you can check #filipino sub forum if want evidence

but who knows. he might be mafia.
DeathxShinigami
The filipino players probably all work together @_@...
Kokizi

DeathxShinigami wrote:

The filipino players probably all work together @_@...
it would've been great if we were allowed to do so.
0_o

Wojjan wrote:

Oh hey facebro, good to see you paying attention. Do you think Quaraezha is suspicious? Like if you had to call something right now. Scum or town?
Well he did get a little defensive when he got two random votes for him, but I've never played with him before so for all I know he could just be a naturally paranoid mafia player. Haven't looked at the filipino games Bakaloid mentioned yet, but at this moment there isn't enough against him to make me think he's scum.

BakaloidSky wrote:

DeathxShinigami wrote:

The filipino players probably all work together @_@...
it would've been great if we were allowed to do so.
You would

if you were mafia.
MDuh

BakaloidSky wrote:

^Answering this question anyway.

Judging from the other mafia games I have played with him, he's a townie.

He's always been like that whenever there's a mafia game, and he always ends up being lynched. you can check #filipino sub forum if want evidence

but who knows. he might be mafia.

metagaming is always bad
Topic Starter
NoHitter
VOTE COUNT
Quaraezha (2) - E-Hooker, Wojjan
E-Hooker (1) - rust45
Kitsunemimi (1) - MDuh
MDuh (1) - Kitsunemimi
Wojjan (1) - adam2046
adam2046 (1) - Mashley

Not Voting (7) - pieguy1372, dkun, BakaloidSky, 0_o, iMuffin, Quaraezha, DeathxShinigami
0_o

MDuh wrote:

BakaloidSky wrote:

^Answering this question anyway.

Judging from the other mafia games I have played with him, he's a townie.

He's always been like that whenever there's a mafia game, and he always ends up being lynched. you can check #filipino sub forum if want evidence

but who knows. he might be mafia.

metagaming is always bad
Actually it IS quite useful. We shouldn't assume he's a townie because of his behaviour, but if that's how he acts when he's pro-town then his behaviour should not be taken as a scum tell.

Disclaimer: I still haven't read the previous games, though I probably will at some point (unless someone wants to save me the trouble and verify it themselves).
Topic Starter
NoHitter
Prodded dkun, pieguy1372 and iMuffin
dkun
sorry, school issues.
will be more active.

:?
Wojjan
Why did you even let pieguy join I only know him as the guy who drops out of stuff.
Topic Starter
NoHitter
In hindsight, I should have made everyone confirm first before starting the day.
DeathxShinigami
pieguy is literally as useless of a player as me!
pieguyn

Wojjan wrote:

Why did you even let pieguy join I only know him as the guy who drops out of stuff.
D:

Anyway, responding to prod. I haven't read the thread yet though so I'll do that later.
iMuffin
I got prodded and i liked it
Claudia_old
any way we can sticky this thread?

i'm a lazy mofo and hate having to look a fourth of the way down page 1 to find it
pieguyn

Mashley wrote:

That was bloody fast :O
Well, I guess I'd agree with you that 4 or 5 mafia seems most likely, you never really know though :\
Vote adam2046. He was too quick to jump from his first randovote to the player who's actually starting discussion. To randovote is one thing, but to change it so quickly makes me raise an eyebrow. Well, we'll see.
I don't think his vote of Wojjan was entirely serious, so vote: Mashley

Regarding Quaraezha, I don't think he's necessarily mafia, but he's definitely being rather cautious. I dunno if he's trying to blend in or just new though.
Wojjan
As I already said (and I'm not usually one to fall into reptition) Quaraezha strikes me as either scum or aux. But in retrospect, it's best to err on the side of caution and let the ordeal be for now. Tentative Unvote, for now, because it wasn't that good play of me to riff on someone's posting habits of whom I've never seen a mafia post.

Regarding Mashley, I guess he's being sheepish and "oh lol what's going on" but I remember Two getting up in his grill for that and IIRC correctly he flipped town that game.

Now can you super sleuths detect why I FOS mashley after that?
0_o

Wojjan wrote:

Now can you super sleuths detect why I FOS mashley after that?

Mashley wrote:

Wojjan y u so suspicious?
Because he's on to you.
iMuffin
well i like to be different sooooo vote: dkun
adam2046

iMuffin wrote:

well i like to be different sooooo vote: dkun
You know who's different?
That's right, The Mafia.
Topic Starter
NoHitter
VOTE COUNT
Quaraezha (1) - E-Hooker
E-Hooker (1) - rust45
Kitsunemimi (1) - MDuh
MDuh (1) - Kitsunemimi
Wojjan (1) - adam2046
adam2046 (1) - Mashley
Mashley (1) - pieguy1372
dkun (1) - iMuffin

Not Voting (6) - dkun, BakaloidSky, 0_o, Quaraezha, DeathxShinigami, Wojjan
DeathxShinigami
iMuffin has currently voted for dkun yet on the not voting list. Just saying.
iMuffin
I'm just so muffiny that i get two votes
Kokizi
*bump*

since it took me nearly 30 seconds to find this one. don't wanna see it get buried
Mashley
fyi I pretty much voted for adam to keep the discussion going. It worked, I guess. But since everyone's up in arms about it I'll Unvote
dkun

adam2046 wrote:

iMuffin wrote:

well i like to be different sooooo vote: dkun
You know who's different?
That's right, The Mafia.
Vote iMuffin
Wojjan
Yes, we definitely need more OMGUS votes.
DeathxShinigami
Wow, lack of critical thinking much? Then again expect me to throw a vote that will be subjected to death as well.
Claudia_old
But that makes a good Mafia game!
DeathxShinigami
Vote: dkun

Mostly likely going to end up as inactive as pieguy but there is no straightforward evidence now to lynch someone so may change my vote later on...
Mashley
inb4 dkun imuffin and pieguy are the entire mafia
Wojjan

Mashley wrote:

inb4 dkun imuffin and pieguy are the entire mafia
but you metnioned only three names I'm pretty sure everyone could agree with 4 in the game and maybe youre purposefully only listing three name to make it seem you don't know how many there are are you the fourth mafia member mash HUHHHHHHH?
dkun

DeathxShinigami wrote:

Vote: dkun

Mostly likely going to end up as inactive as pieguy but there is no straightforward evidence now to lynch someone so may change my vote later on...
your reasoning sucks as much as you do
Mashley

Wojjan wrote:

Mashley wrote:

inb4 dkun imuffin and pieguy are the entire mafia
but you metnioned only three names I'm pretty sure everyone could agree with 4 in the game and maybe youre purposefully only listing three name to make it seem you don't know how many there are are you the fourth mafia member mash HUHHHHHHH?
But only 3 people were poked ;_;
rust45
Anyway I'm gonna unvote for now and stay neutral in current situation as it seems to be based completely off of WIFOM. Which I suppose is what the first day is typically full of.
Wojjan
rust for mafia much?
DeathxShinigami
Wojjan totally not a townie?!

You know how many times I got backstabbed by you?!
Topic Starter
NoHitter
VOTE COUNT
dkun (2) - iMuffin, DeathXShinigami
Quaraezha (1) - E-Hooker
Kitsunemimi (1) - MDuh
MDuh (1) - Kitsunemimi
Wojjan (1) - adam2046
Mashley (1) - pieguy1372
iMuffin (1) - dkun

Not Voting (6) - BakaloidSky, 0_o, Quaraezha, Wojjan, Mashley, rust45

Prodded adam2046, 0_o, Kitsunemimi, pieguy1372, MDuh, and Quaraezha

Also let me clarify something, after your third prod, if you still become inactive, I'll replace or modkill if there is no replacement.
Quaraezha
Vote: Wojjan
DeathxShinigami
God dammit with the capitalized X in my name and with myself appearing twice (once for voting and other for not voting)
Topic Starter
NoHitter
Fixed (again).
Kokizi
I like how this mafia game is going.
Quaraezha

BakaloidSky wrote:

I like how this mafia game is going.
The votes are so random, almost everyone has been voted once. lol
adam2046

rust45 wrote:

Anyway I'm not going to do anything today because I don't want to attract any attention at all.
Kitsunemimi

NoHItter wrote:

Prodded adam2046, 0_o, Kitsunemimi, pieguy1372, MDuh, and Quaraezha[/b]
Also let me clarify something, after your third prod, if you still become inactive, I'll replace or modkill if there is no replacement.
:?
0_o
ow
pieguyn
:cry:

rust45 wrote:

Anyway I'm gonna unvote for now and stay neutral in current situation as it seems to be based completely off of WIFOM. Which I suppose is what the first day is typically full of.
Without voting anyone, we can't find out anything, and if you want to stay neutral that just makes you mafia. unvote Mashley, vote rust45
adam2046

pieguy1372 wrote:

if you want to stay neutral that just makes you mafia.
This statement. It makes you mafia.
Unvote
Vote: pieguy
0_o
so E-Hooker

sup
MDuh
sorry about not posting for 48 hours.. I wasn't at home for the whole day yesterday (yes it already 12:14am when I'm posting this)

oh well, Votes are rly are so random at this point..
But even at day 1.. I spotted 1 or 2 of the vote changes are probably a precautionary measure to not reach a max of 3 votes at someone.. I may be totally wrong but arguing to each other are 1 of the old tricks to camouflage themselves to be townie's..
0_o
MOD: I propose that we be given a bit more leeway regarding prods, having to post every 48 hours seems pretty harsh (and at this rate half of us are going to be gone by the end of the second day).

The other games had it so prods had to be requested, and replacements were only made if the prod was not responded to within 48 hours. This sounds like a more reasonable system imo.
Claudia_old
Ohey, 0_o, wuddup.

Also, unvote in the meantime.
Wojjan
If I had to make a guess right now rust, Quaraezha, E-Hooker and Mashley are mafia. I'm most certain of rust.

Vote This

It's the color of rust

SPOILER
It's also the color of the mafia :o
0_o

Wojjan wrote:

If I had to make a guess right now rust, Quaraezha, E-Hooker and Mashley are mafia. I'm most certain of rust.

Vote This

It's the color of rust

SPOILER
It's also the color of the mafia :o
You've explained your thoughts on the other two, but why E-Hooker? Lurking? Or just intuition?
Wojjan
To quote one of the best and at the same time worst mafia players I've had the honor of dealing with, yes, "women's intuition."
Claudia_old
Yes, women's intuition also told me to unvote.

Wojjie so suspicious!
rust45

pieguy1372 wrote:

:cry:

rust45 wrote:

Anyway I'm gonna unvote for now and stay neutral in current situation as it seems to be based completely off of WIFOM. Which I suppose is what the first day is typically full of.
Without voting anyone, we can't find out anything, and if you want to stay neutral that just makes you mafia.
People obviously responded to what I said so it's still possible to find out stuff. And of course I only got responses because of the statement I made, what about the other people who aren't voting, are they mafia for the same reason?

adam2046 wrote:

rust45 wrote:

Anyway I'm not going to do anything today because I don't want to attract any attention at all.
If that were true, I would not had made the statement, I wanted to see how people would respond.
adam2046

rust45 wrote:

If that were true, I would not had made the statement, I wanted to see how people would respond.
Honestly, you can say that about anything.
Everyone should vote rust today because he is definitely mafia and I am totally not mafia and everyone who disagrees is wrong.
Just seeing how people respond.
Topic Starter
NoHitter
VOTE COUNT
dkun (2) - iMuffin, DeathXShinigami
rust45 (2) - pieguy1372, Wojjan
Wojjan (1) - Quaraezha
Kitsunemimi (1) - MDuh
MDuh (1) - Kitsunemimi
iMuffin (1) - dkun
pieguy1372 (1) - adam2046

Not Voting (5) - BakaloidSky, 0_o, Mashley, rust45, E-Hooker

Prodded Mashley, iMuffin and dkun



0_o wrote:

MOD: I propose that we be given a bit more leeway regarding prods, having to post every 48 hours seems pretty harsh (and at this rate half of us are going to be gone by the end of the second day).

The other games had it so prods had to be requested, and replacements were only made if the prod was not responded to within 48 hours. This sounds like a more reasonable system imo.
I guess that would be more reasonable. Starting now, prods must be requested - minimum time before a person may be prodded is 48 hours. Also resetting the number of prods already garnered in light of this.

DEADLINE IS ON MAY 21, 1:30 PM UTC.
rust45

adam2046 wrote:

rust45 wrote:

If that were true, I would not had made the statement, I wanted to see how people would respond.
Honestly, you can say that about anything.
Everyone should vote rust today because he is definitely mafia and I am totally not mafia and everyone who disagrees is wrong.
Just seeing how people respond.
Well if I'm mafia... Vote: rust45

Also, I won't even be on the day that the day will end, oh well.
Mashley
Yeah I'm still here guys I just had nothing to say for the last 48 hours :P
Wojjan is jumping to all sorts of conclusions considering it's day 1, but whatever
iMuffin
That tickles
0_o
vote iMuffin

Also rust's defeatist attitude is a bit unsettling... unless he's just trolling, but nonetheless voting for yourself when you're on the hotseat with only a day to go is quite the bold statement.
Wojjan
rust is not a defeatist. Voting yourself is a desperate attempt at making people second-guess their vote because suddenly that person is closer to lynching. That or having people believe you're a troll. Either way you're hazardous to the game.

Can I vote him again?
Claudia_old
Sorry, rust, but you're terribly suspicious. Not necessarily following in the pieguy logic that 'everybody who stays neutral is Mafia', but your comments are quite HMMM-inducing. [Also you randomly voted then unvoted for me then voted for yourself.]

Your Jedi mind tricks won't work on me! Vote rust45
Mashley
Either rust is a really bad mafia or a really really bad townie... meh. Not voting because I'm a rebel.
0_o
Only 7 hours left guys...
MDuh
hmmm.. Bakaloidsky not voting?
that's weird..
going for the silent one to save yourself?
DeathxShinigami
You know... Bad Player > Someone you personally dislike

Which means...

Unvote

Vote: rust45
rust45
You know, there could be other reasons for me voting for myself other than being a defeatist. You do realize we have no idea what the roles are? And just so you know, I was hoping to spark conversation to root out the real scum, but it seems you just want to all bandwagon on me. Doesn't matter too much though, considering that an innocent usually gets lynched first.
MDuh
I would /facepalm so hard if jester was included in this game
rust45
Still possible, and this will be my last post here until the day ends as I need to sleep and I'm busy all tomorrow.
DeathxShinigami

rust45 wrote:

You know, there could be other reasons for me voting for myself other than being a defeatist. You do realize we have no idea what the roles are? And just so you know, I was hoping to spark conversation to root out the real scum, but it seems you just want to all bandwagon on me. Doesn't matter too much though, considering that an innocent usually gets lynched first.
Then you would might as well claim role if you would want to prevent your own lynch. Unless I dunno the game ends after you do perish~
Topic Starter
NoHitter
VOTE COUNT
rust45 (5) - pieguy1372, Wojjan, rust45, E-Hooker, DeathXShinigami
iMuffin (2) - dkun, 0_o
dkun (1) - iMuffin
Wojjan (1) - Quaraezha
Kitsunemimi (1) - MDuh
MDuh (1) - Kitsunemimi
pieguy1372 (1) - adam2046

Not Voting (2) - BakaloidSky, Mashley

WITH 14 ALIVE, IT TAKES 8 TO HAMMER.
adam2046
You know I was joking when I said everyone should vote rust, right?
Wojjan

rust45 wrote:

You know, there could be other reasons for me voting for myself other than being a defeatist. You do realize we have no idea what the roles are? And just so you know, I was hoping to spark conversation to root out the real scum, but it seems you just want to all bandwagon on me. Doesn't matter too much though, considering that an innocent usually gets lynched first.
There's that word again.
Mashley
Yeeeeaaaah rust I'm not seeing how voting for yourself routes out the 'real scum'. It just makes you look like a crazy.
Not that it'll make a difference at this stage, but Vote rust45
dkun
well then

/prod
rust45
Well I got up earlier than expected so I have time to make one last post.

I'm going to role claim townie and unvote, but I doubt that will save. However, before I get lynched I'd like to say that I wasn't really trying this game and the reason why I made me look suspicious was to help the other townies and aux roles with finding the scum with how I reacted, this was probably a bad way to go about it, but if it helped, it helped.

Oh yeah, Vote: Wojjan
You're the most suspicious to me atm, always being agressive.
Topic Starter
NoHitter
FINAL VOTE COUNT OF THE DAY
rust45 (4) - pieguy1372, Wojjan, E-Hooker, DeathXShinigami
iMuffin (2) - dkun, 0_o
Wojjan (2) - Quaraezha, rust45
dkun (1) - iMuffin
Kitsunemimi (1) - MDuh
MDuh (1) - Kitsunemimi
pieguy1372 (1) - adam2046

Not Voting (2) - BakaloidSky, Mashley
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The day started off with everyone accusing each other. Votes were cast almost on everyone. No one was sure who did it. At the end of the day however, rust45 had gotten suspicious. Why would he ask himself to be killed? Is he really suicidal?

When everybody finally decided to throw him off a cliff, rust chickened out. He quickly made a dash to the beach.There he spotted a palm tree. He climbed it and announced that he would be staying there. Perhaps he didn't want to die after all? Sadly, someone else anticipated that. Everyone was shocked to see the tree tilting to the side and falling down.

It was apparent that someone had cut the tree partly the previous night, so that it would fall down when someone climbed on it. Whoever did it had to have an axe with him/her - probably the same one used to kill the captain. It was apparent that rust wouldn't have climbed the tree if he knew it would fall down.

A search of his clothes confirmed it too. His wallet contained a calling card saying that he was the owner of some fast-food chain. It was clear that he was innocent after all.
rust45 - Townie - flattened by a tree - DAY 1. (Lynched)

As the sun set, everybody decided to head back to their makeshift shelters. An atmosphere of hopelessness filled the air. They were sure that someone else would die the next day.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

IT IS NOW NIGHT 1.
DEADLINE OF ALL NIGHT ACTIONS IS IN 1 DAY.
ALL ACTIONS NOT SENT WILL BE INTERPRETED AS A "NO ACTION".

Topic Starter
NoHitter
Clarification on the PM regarding the start of Night.
I sent the PM to everyone, but by BCC by mistake.
Topic Starter
NoHitter
It was around 12AM. adam2046 decided to get things over with. It all started when the captain died. adam decided that at least one of them on the island was a killer. Nobody else but himself could be trusted. He had to kill all of them. Luckily he himself had a gun he managed to hide under his clothes when he washed up on the beach. It even had a silencer - how lucky of him. He could now kill without anyone else hearing it. Though he only had six bullets left, that would be enough to get him to the end.

As adam was heading to the beach, pondering who to kill, an unknown figure approached him from the back and hit him on the head with something. Surprised by the blow, adam quickly turned around and instinctively pulled the trigger multiple times. The unknown figure, though shocked at the sight of the gun, managed to grab adam's arm and tried to wrest the gun away just as adam shot the bullets.

The result was a body with many bullet wounds, and a somewhat shocked unknown figure.

adam2046 - Serial Killer - shot with his own gun - NIGHT 1. (Nightkill)

Next morning, everyone gathered to the beach and saw adam's body. A search revealed a gun with no bullets left and a diary. Written in it was adam's plan to kill everyone. They all agreed that though adam was hostile to them, it was far from over.

DAY 2 HAS NOW STARTED.
DEADLINE IS IN ONE WEEK.

MDuh
oh great Serial Killer is dead.. -1 worries for townies..
now the question is.. Is there a reverser role present? (I'm not famliar with mafia games, only TWG)
Topic Starter
NoHitter
This game is a closed set-up.
No information on the roles and set-up will be given.
DeathxShinigami
If anything judging from the PM I received at night I'm going to...

Vote: pieguy1372
MDuh
don't worry NoHitter, I'm aware that roles won't be revealed so I'm putting the community to this question..
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply