forum

Standart for FA Tag.

posted
Total Posts
3
Topic Starter
fergas
> If the song mapped is a licensed one in the featured artist library, featured artist must be added to tags.

This sentence construction looks a bit wrong. According to logic it dont takes cases if song isn't featured but artist is. I mean this sentence only works in one direction but should be worked in both i guess.

My recomendation to change sentence like:
>Featured artist must be added to tags only if the song mapped is a licensed one in the featured artist library.

Little permutation which changes a lot cause i it was kinda problem for me while ranking:
beatmapsets/1286665/discussion/-/generalAll#/2050233
Song isn't featured but artist is, so i didn't used osu! in source cause of another rule but decided to repsect artist leaveing fa in tags which accroding RC isn't prohibited, but in fact it is.
clayton
the words you're looking for are "if and only if", because you want to imply two things:

- the map has FA tag if the song is licensed (this is what the original rule says)
- the song is licensed if the map has FA tag (this is what pishi decided)
Topic Starter
fergas
Yeah, this is one righter pretext.
I just want to make things clear till a lot of bn missunderstand that rule otherwise i won't made that thread. Also trying to check my own map for such moments and didnt get rule in right way. Daycore let me understand that featured song != featured artist. I think peoples who not mapping for mapper guild don't really understand that(based on my example).
I know this is not often we can meet such moments but still they are exist.
Also want to be sure there will be no effect for bns cause of dq who nominated my map ;w;
Please sign in to reply.

New reply