vincerio wrote:

here my suggestions
[General]
I'm quite worrying about mp3 quality.... 128kbps is fine... but this one result in a poor quality D:.... have to say, Im lazy... changing mp3 file means changing all time sections, plus i find the audio file is good.. lets w8 for others's opinion :S
Tag : Hangul (korean name for rainbow) done
fix kiai issue? activate kaia for kiai burst is not bad...but it would be nice if you put it at all chorus... i dont really like kiai, put it at all chorus will annoy me when playing it...

[Easy]
00:20:014(2) - replace this one y? O_o
02:59:144(3) - new combo it's fine here imo

[Normal+] This one can refer as HARD k, It's about name = = since a lot of ppl complain about it i think i sould use custom name or my diff = =
put + in diff name never names you can over do that...
Seriouly.... the silder velocity is so high to call this one as normal diff and i saw that there are some jumping notes... ( beyond normal diff criteria already )
Drain rate +1 AR +1 you will get HARD diff with the same previous score...
less than 3 star easier diff is enough to get ranking
if you follow this you can add some notes and add more cool trick :3
00:28:~00:42: - feel so empty? why no hitsound here? It's fine, i'll w8 for more ideas

[Hard] This mapset is Insane 8/8/8 orz
HP drain -1 please.... the score will be the same with more playable and survival rate kk
00:26:970(7) - a bit offscreen... replace this one you have a lot of playfield to deal with this one... fixed
00:27:405(1,2) - remove whistle? nope
00:28:~00:42: - feel so empty? why no hitsound here?
00:59:144(2,3,4) - not fit at all? how about delete 00:59:253(3) and add note at 00:59:362 It's ok
02:42:188( 1,1,1,1,1,1) - This so mean with this drain rate.... people will lose 50% of HP before the reached at 02:49:144... not fair to play D: kk I changed HP drain

Nicely done~
good luck with this ^^

Shulin wrote:

General:

All diffs: 00:28:275 to 00:55:666 ~ why didn't you add any claps? There are good places for them ^_^ done

Soft:

-- Stack leniency -2 ~ it improves the appearance of some of the stacks like 00:18:492 (2,1,2) - in game. k
-- Overall Difficulty + 1? fixed

00:24:796 (1,2) - I think it might be better to follow the vocal here. done ^^
00:30:448 (2) - Move up 2 grids [Grid 4] kk
00:42:188 (1) - That's one huge spinner, maybe you could end it about 00:45:666 and map something after? oops fixed
01:20:448 (2,3) - Might be best to follow the vocal. ^
01:30:883 (1) - Another huge spinner ._. (same suggestion end at 01:34:362 and map?) ^
02:14:362 (4) - I think mid chorus is an odd place for a break. eer..
02:54:362 (4,5) - Might be better to follow the vocal here (I think it would be easier for new players xD) done

Just opinions ~ good map ^_^

Advance:

-- This should be Advanced. oops lol
-- Stack leniency -2?
-- HP Drain + 1?

02:14:362 (3) - Strange place for a break >.< Can't I be lazy for once? ;_;
02:54:362 (4,5) - Following the vocal would sound better here. (Or something like [Special]) fixed
03:15:449 (6,1) - It'd be cool if you used a slider like [Soft] instead of a gap between the notes ^^ oh I forgot about this, hold on....= =....= =.....= =... k updated

Nice map.

Special:

02:01:101 (3) - Remove whistle from the slider? it's fine imo
02:13:927 (1,2) - Remove finish. done
02:14:362 (3) - Still think this is a strange place for a break xD T_T

Just opinions, good luck and star.

winber1 wrote:

Soft
01:34:796(1) - start a 2/1 clap pattern (whistles are fine) oops forgot to add hitsound lol
02:29:796(2) - maybe start this note at 02:30:014 (the music stresses this beat more than 02:29:796 no, it's fine here (imo)

Advanced
01:31:318(1) - start a 2/1 clap pattern here (whistles seem fine)
02:26:318(x) - add a note here? feels weird to have this 3/2 space here done


Special
00:29:237(7) - 2 grid left k
00:44:579(2) - Maybe it's just me and my bad sightreading skills, but I barely got a 50 on this when the pattern first appeared (all other instances I understood the pattern). So possibly just make combo 1 a reverse slider or move "2" somewhere else... not a big deal, though. I dont think that's a problem, but I fixed it though
02:02:622(2,3) - remove whistles from end of these sliders
02:07:622(1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4) - why so many whistles? it might fit better to come up with a pattern for the whistle that lasts to about 02:14:362, or just not have the whistles at all. (i came up with a patttern with whistle at 2:07:622, at 02:08:275, at 02:08:709 [3/2, 1/1, 3/2] and repeat to 02:14:362, but you're gonna have to make a whistle as a slidertick, which is kinda annoying) just a suggestion though...
hm, I removed some whistles, hope it would work
02:09:144(x) - add a note here? mhm
02:38:492(2) - 4 grids right 1 down to match combo 4 at 02:36:535 done

Cool map. So many colors
i also love the custom whistle sound

Star~

wmfchris wrote:

[Special]
try to resnap in grid lv4 so that the spacing will be looked better :3 I'll only mention some spacing which needs to be moves 2+ grids
00:27:840 (3,7) stack them actually I was trying to stack (7) with (9) :S
00:41:318 (2) - x:136, y:252 done
00:52:079 (4) - up 1 grid lv4 grid k
01:30:883 (1) - the third slider point down 1 grid lv4 fixed lol
quite fine

[advanced]
01:03:709 (3) - right+down 1 gird lv 4 k

no spacing problems for me at all, well done.

star

[Shalon] wrote:

Hi.

[General]

Delete the Osb file. y? O_o

[Soft]

00:42:188 (1) - this slider is too close with the next circle for easy diff. u mean...spinner?O_o well i dont think new players see it that hard, they can totally clear that spinner be4 reaching the next combo

00:56:101 - What's this so littler kiai? It's kiai burst

01:30:883 (1) - this slider is too close with the next circle for easy diff. ^

01:41:318 (3) - make it more circular than more good to look ? k

02:00:448 - What's this so littler kiai? ^

03:03:057 (1) - this slider is too close with the next circle for easy diff.^

[Advanced]

* You should check the timing sections that have very short kiai. I write it on the Soft diff's mod, plz check it. It made it for kiai burst

Good job. Map looks very Qute.

[Speacial]

00:39:035 (4) - stack it perfectly with 00:38:709 (3) done

00:48:057 (4) - this and 00:48:492 (5) - this slider's are not perfectly parallel. 1 grid down the end of 00:48:492 (5). lol k fixed

Other's fine. good job

-kevincela- wrote:

Hi
[Soft]
00:37:622(3): put it under the slider done
01:21:101(3):can you put it like this (http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/52727)? woot.... ok

[Advanced]
Very good,i didn't find nothing wrong

[Special]
01:31:535(2):put the note under the slider? eer no. it's fine here
03:15:883(6):can you put it like this (http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/52730)? fixed

Sorry if i didn't find a lot of things,but this map is very well made!So,star~

DragonSparta wrote:

Soft
HP Drain -1 and Overall Diff +1 it's fine
00:15:014 (2) - Add finish
00:16:753 (3) - Add finish and some other parts where you may add finish thx for the suggestions about adding finish, i'll add them somewhere else ^^, not these places ^^
01:05:666 (2) - Move one grid left k
02:14:362 (1) - Too far from the previous note fixed
02:59:579 (4) - Add finish

Advanced
Overall Diff -1 no it's fine
00:51:353 (2) - Move two grids left done
00:59:597 (4) - Add finish
01:44:796 (X) - Add a note with a finish done

Special
HP Drain +1
02:59:579 (1) - Too near the previous note fixed o_o
_______________________________________________
Havva star

SamiPale wrote:

Hi, mod by request

[General]
Nowadays slidertick sound cannot be muted, so delete the soft-slidertick.wav and soft-slidertick2.wav is better Dont get it... y? O_o I didnt put slidertick there accidentally o_O
I've found that you use bg as storyboard element, I'm not sure if it's ok ah.. me either = =

[Soft]
02:13:927(4) - Add clap? done

[Advanced]
00:43:927(1,2,3,4,5) - Make them like this? k
01:10:014(1),01:16:970(2),01:23:927(1) - Add finish? done
02:14:362(3) - Add finish? nope ^^

[Special]
01:10:014(1),01:16:970(2) - Add finish? k
02:00:883(2) - Add whistle? no i think it's fine here
02:17:405(3) - Missed clap? my bad
02:54:579(1),02:54:796(1),02:55:231(2,4) - Just a suggestion, add clap? good suggestion ^^ fixed
02:59:144(3) - Missed whistle? again..my bad
03:15:231(4),03:16:101(6) - Just a suggestion, add whistle? sound weird, im gonna leave it like that

I think the star rating not means the diff spread, it's ok
good song and good map

kazumikos wrote:

[General]
Nowadays slidertick sound cannot be muted, so delete the soft-slidertick.wav and soft-slidertick2.wav is better Dont get it... y? O_o I didnt put slidertick there accidentally o_O

SamiPale wrote:

kazumikos wrote:

[General]
Nowadays slidertick sound cannot be muted, so delete the soft-slidertick.wav and soft-slidertick2.wav is better Dont get it... y? O_o I didnt put slidertick there accidentally o_O

sorry my fault

IceBeam wrote:

[Soft]
00:14:362 (1) - Finish?
00:21:318 - ^
00:28:275 (1) - ^
02:00:448 - ^
02:54:144 (1) - New combo?
02:54:144 (4,5) - I suggest you to use soft section or lower volume,cause note hits sound too loud and rough here.
02:59:579 - Finish?

[Advanced]
00:14:362 (1) - Finish?
00:21:318 - ^
00:28:275 - ^
01:11:753 (2) - ^
01:13:492 (1) - ^
01:16:970 (1) - ^
01:18:709 (4) - ^
01:58:709 (1,2,3,4) - Lower volume/soft sampleset?
02:21:318 (1) - Finish?

[Special]
00:14:362 (1) - Finish?
00:21:318 - ^
00:28:275 - ^
00:42:188 (1) - ^
00:49:144 (1) - ^
01:32:622 (1) - Hm,it's kinda close to previous object,like a trap.I had problems with it.
01:44:796 - Add a note maybe?
02:42:188 (1,1,1,1) - These notes kill half HP bar,everytime,so it may cause mass kills.All I can suggest is to make a break at least after 02:42:188 (1) note.

Otherwise map is simply awesome,I really like it,and whole mapset as well.
Deserves a star~

kinda made me confused x_x i cant remember where i fixed where i didnt +_+ Those r useful though, ty

kazumikos wrote:

SamiPale wrote:

sorry my fault

sorry I forgot kudos ;_;, didnt mean to ;_;

KanaRin wrote:

Good job XD
I can't find mistake
star~

kanpakyin wrote:

KanaRin wrote:

Good job XD
I can't find mistake
star~

BakaRin 030

[General]
No scource? Idk the source .. plz tell me if u found one

[Soft]
00:36:535(2.3)-Will make the players confuse fixed
00:42:188(x)-Hate long spinner to much...it can make the players boring. This is easy diff and that spinner's not long O_o
01:05:666(2)-(Nazi)Make it more beautiful? I like it that way
01:15:231(1.2.3)-Add finish? no, I added whistle and i think it's fine here
01:30:883(x)-Same as 00:42:188 again, it's not long... if I make it shorter someone's definitely gonna mod "that spinner is too short for easy diff" (lol) plus I want nothing else but a spinner at there , sorry I wont delete it
03:03:057(x)-^and too close with (3) fixed distance

[Advanced]
00:17:840(3.4)-Make it more symmetrical?fixed ( i think? O_o)
00:39:905(2)-Why use soft hitsound here? ...idk = = becuz I need soft slidertick? I think Normal hitsound is more suitable
01:20:231(1.2.3)-Hairlike spacing mistake..Better to fix this I think it doesnt matter = =... but well, i fixed it
01:45231(x)-Weird break. where else can I put break?
02:24:362(x)-Better to add a note here. done
Quite good!!

[Special]
00:22:622(8.9.10)-Weird triplet..I suggest you put the triplet on the red line. I made triplet follow the instrument
00:24:362(5.6.7)-^^
01:41:318(5.1)-swap new combo It's fine imo
01:45:014(x)-Weird break.
Cool~

Map is fine>_<
**Star

NatsumeRin wrote:

Red: You must fix this.
Blue: You'd better do sth with this imo.
Green: Just suggestions.

[Soft]
01:20:231 (2,3) - whistle at the beginning done
02:05:666 (4) - split this into 2 sliders (1/2*3 + 1/2 *4)? done
02:18:275 (3) - new combo k
02:24:579 (1,2,3) - whistle at the beginning done~
02:41:753 - add a note? done

[Advanced]
00:24:579 (1,2,3) - whistle at the beginning fixed ^^
00:43:927 (1,2,3,4,5) - a suggestion fixed
01:00:883 (4,5) - should stack these two sliders to keep consistency? uhm.. I'll just leave it there, it's fine imo
01:19:144 (5,1) - spacing fixed
01:20:231 (1,4) - whistle done
02:26:318 (4) - move 1/2 later (remove clap) kk ^^
02:54:362 (4,5) - finish done

[Special]
HP-1. HP is fine i think
00:19:579 (1,2,3,1,2) - for this part, consider a combo trick (A-A-A-A)? (but take care, once you used this technique, any new combo change before this note would ruin everything= =). stack the AAAA note if you use this. nice trick, thx ^^
00:53:927 (5,1) - spacing fixed
01:20:231 (1,3,1) - whistle (3 is at the beginning) done
02:19:579 (1,2,3) - i think you should switch the place of 2 & 3 to keep the jump feeling, not only for 2-3 ok

really nice done.

Sallad4ever wrote:

sorry for the late reply kazumi m(_ _)m

[General]
- SB element shouldn't be larger than 800x600, that said you should re size mid.jpg done
- I'm guessing that Rainbow is the name of the group so if you can, maybe add the name of the girls who sing this in the tags mm I thought artist's name doesnt need to add in tags

[Soft]
00:35:666 (2) - uhh..did you forgot the clap? yea i did lol
00:38:709 (2,3,4,5) - if you can please add hitsound in these notes (maybe use finish or whistle for all of them?) I want to, but dont know how to add :S
02:25:448 (2) - the clap in the slider tick is not appropriate. If you following a 2/1 clap pattern, the clap should be in 02:26:101 my bad =P

[Advance]
00:39:579 (2,3) - the silenced repeat in these 2 sliders is not a good idea. Put the timing section for the slidertick exactly on it not on the slider repeat. If the repeat sound weird with the clap slidertick, I suggest to remove the clap like in Special diff, not silencing the repeat
k fixed
00:41:970 (4) - change into these rhythm? done

02:24:579 (2) - hmm..a weird jump imo fixed
02:28:275 (1,1,1) - Brilliant!!!<3
03:04:144 (3) - add circle? hm? o_O
03:07:405 (3) - add another repeat? k
03:11:535 (1) - the space before this kinda lack some rhythm, maybe add circles in 03:11:101 & 03:11:318 done
03:13:275 (1) - add a normal-whistle at the start? k
03:14:144 (3) - ^
03:15:014 (1) - finish the spinner forgot lol

[Special]
00:21:318 (2) - maybe NC this too, make sure to use purple if you did so I did NC for AAAA (lol), and i believe there'r only 4 A xD
01:01:753 (2) - stack it perfectly under the slider plz :3 done
01:44:796 (1) - I think this NC is unnecessary, remove it? k
02:00:666 (2) - add whistle at the start. I suggest to add some more whistle in this section, something like:

SPOILER

02:05:231 (2) - add whistle at the end
02:06:318 (4) - ^
02:06:970 (6) - add whistle at the whole slider (don't mind the double hitsound)
02:12:405 (4) - ^
02:13:275 (6) - ^

=> all fixed ^^
02:28:275 (1) - increase the volume in this timing section by 1 tick, do it for all timing sections in the rap part k

I'm so jealous of you
I want to have my own style too
Great map~
~STAR

pieguy1372 wrote:

Soft:

00:28:709 (2) - (nazi) Not symmetrical k
00:59:579 (3) - Align with (2)? [/color]
01:58:709 (1) - (nazi) Not symmetrical lol done (i think so = =)
02:10:014 (4) - Center this between (3) and (5) k
02:10:448 (5) - Move it down one level 4 grid done
02:56:101 (1) - Too close to (2) fixed

Advanced:

00:41:318 (1) - Move down one level 4 grid (1) is stacked with (2), so.. :
01:19:144 (5) - (nazi) Not symmetrical k

Special:

02:23:927 (2,3,4) - Uneven :DDDD k fixed
02:32:622 (7,8,9,10,11) - ^ k
02:41:101 ~ 02:49:144 - Even if you hit all the notes here the life bar goes down by half due to the HP drain. D: come one~ no one can easily die becuz of that? = = (after they passed streams, jumps, etc)

Nice map! *stars*

Thx for modding

eldnl wrote:

[Soft]

00:30:014 (1) Remove new combo done
00:36:318 (1) ^ k
00:52:188 (4) 2 Grid up, 2 Grid left. (Level Grid 3) y? o_o
00:59:579 (3) New combo k
01:00:014 (1) Remove new combo done
01:04:796 (3) New combo k
01:05:231 (1) Remove new combo k
01:08:275 (4) New combo+ no need, I think
01:44:796 (4) New combo It's used to be a new combo there = =, someone told me to remove, hm...
02:05:666 (4) ^ no, it's fine here
02:24:144 (x) Add a note k
02:37:405 (4) New combo k


[Advanced]

01:44:796 (6) New combo just like [Soft]

Fine.

[Special]

00:59:579 (x) Add a note with new combo Ah I think it's ok without a note here
01:23:927 (7) New combo nope ^^
01:41:318 (5) ^ y?
01:41:535 (1) Remove new combo no o_o
01:44:796 (9) New combo ~_~
02:26:318 (1) Remove new combo It's ok here
02:26:535 (2) New combo ^
03:02:622 (1) Remove new combo done
03:03:057 (2) New combo k
03:16:318 (x) Suggestion ok ^^

SPOILER

Star ~

Thx~~

ziin wrote:

[soft]
after playing it I seriously doubt I'll find anything in the later difficulties.

so star, I can already tell this is going to be a best of 2011.

The only thing I can mention is that A.png is cut off on the sides, but you can't notice when playing:


I didn't notice anything terribly wrong with it, and I'm not going to mention the nazis I noticed because they're so minor. My personal gripe is the overmapped sections (00:22:731 (6) on insane for example) where there's nothing happening in the background but you put a a note there anyway. Won't stop it from getting ranked, and won't stop me from giving you a star though.

Giorgos wrote:

General:
Put your Audio Lead-in (Seconds) on : 1,6 seconds (on all difficulties!)
And one advice - Put countdown too (don't forget to do it on all difficulties)

Soft:
00:20:883 - finish this repeat slider in : 00:21:753
00:23:057 - finish this slider in: 00:23:492
00:26:535 - well,on this difficulty it is not good to use 1/4 Beat Snap Divisor. Finish this slider in: 00:27:405
00:28:709 - finish this slider in: 00:29:579
00:32:188 - finish this slider in: 00:33:057
00:34:796 - finish this slider in: 00:35:231
it will take a lot of time to write about these sliders,because there are lots of them here. Just change them - they must not fiinsh on blue line!
01:18:492 - delete one repeat slider here,and start your slider from: 01:18:709
that is all about this difficulty I like it,nicely done

Advanced:
00:50:014 - add here a circle
01:12:405 - delete here repeat slider and put just a simple slider. this slider has to end in: 01:13:057
01:20:014 - put a circle here

Special:
02:33:166 - add here a circle
02:33:275 - start this slider in: 02:33:492. and finish it in: 02:33:709

Garven wrote:

Om nom nom

[Soft]
00:46:101 (1) - Way too soon after a spinner for the easiest difficulty.
01:34:796 (1) - ^
01:38:275 (2) - Add whistle to the end?
01:58:709 (1) - Maybe silence ticks during the quiet part of the song until it picks up again at 01:59:579 - ?
02:28:275 - No fountain here?
03:08:709 (1) - Too soon after spinner, yeah.
thx, i fixed all ^^
[Advanced]
02:28:275 (1,1,1) - If you could make these symmetrical, it'd be awesome. aaa, it's hard....;_;

[Special]
00:53:927 (5) - Maybe lower this a little bit? Looks like it's kind of crooked compared to the curve. k

Good stuff here!

Thx Garven~~

Leorda wrote:

Howdy

General
1) Do you didn't noticed that A.png is cut off? http://puu.sh/Zhm yea.. ziin also told me about this, but imo it's not a problem since no one notice when playing o_O
2) Why "Hangul" is in tags? someone told me so... hm it's korean name of rainbow, otherwise i have no idea o_o

Soft
00:18:492 (2) - Try make a slider like this http://puu.sh/ZaX to make a delicilous blanket combo. If you change this, you will see the approachcircle in 00:19:579 (1) are stick in slider lines at 00:19:362 sorry but this is my mapping style
00:28:275 (1,2) - How about you make a blanket combo? If you do, make sure slider lines in 00:28:709 (2) is stick the approachcircle in 00:28:275 (1), example http://puu.sh/Zb2 ^
00:42:188 (1) - Add finish? it's fine here
00:57:840 (1) - In tail of slider, the line are not stick to the approachcirle in 00:57:188 (3), try make it like this http://puu.sh/Zb5 k
01:21:970 (1) - Add finish? k
01:30:883 (1) - ^ nope
01:58:709 (1) - Make a slider like this? http://puu.sh/Zbm done
02:28:275 (1,2) - It's kinda weird slider.... Change something? i dont think so lol

Advanced
00:17:840 (3,4) - I think Cutting Slider will be cool for this slider, for example http://puu.sh/ZgV i dont really like cutting slider, but well...
01:11:318 (1) - I think I dislike overlapped by 01:10:014 (2) but I like it
01:19:144 (5,6) - I think this is better if you changing, because it's according to the vocal, though http://puu.sh/Zh9 done
01:21:970 (1) - Add finish? k
01:39:144 (2) - Not stack perfectly with 01:37:840 (1) fixed
01:58:709 (1,2,3,4) - Using a soft hitsound are better, since the song are quiet it's still ok with normal imo
02:29:796 (1,1) - Removing new combo for this is better nope ^^

Special
• Why this diff is turn on the countdown? But the others are turn off my bad
00:16:535 (4,5) - If the player turn off the snaking slider at option mode, it could be confusing for player (and me). Try changing something neat and visible [color=#FF4040]I turned snaking slider off and see no problem :S so..
00:20:666 (1,1,1) - This combo are make no sense for me. If you think you enable this 3 objects for jumps, I think you don't need to[/color] well i made new combo there for these AAAA , A = purple
00:26:535 (6) - New combo? done
00:27:405 (1) - Remove new combo? done
00:28:275 (5) - New combo? done

My fucking apologize for long mod

k ths for modding

Garven wrote:

[Advanced]
01:20:231 (1,2,3) - Mm, I didn't like how this stack gets positioned. Maybe move it down and right or a different spot altogether so it doesn't do that overlap with the slider?

Lemme know if you do a fix or not and I'll bubble. Don't bother with kudosu.

Edit:

Nom.

:U

Beuchi-chan wrote:

Hello~ I know you posted on the queue, sorry for being so late ;_;

Anyways... here's my mod!

~Storyboard~
- The max. size for storyboard elements is 800x600. You'll have to resize the background. Still, it's recommended to use 640x480 images for fullscreen, so you should use that one xP (if you resize mid too it would be nice~)
- Now let's see: if you resize BG and mid, you'll need to fix all the pulses of the background and re-scale the darker one (you won't need to use any scaling now for this one though), but I don't think that would be so hard to do... right? o.o Call me if you have any problems~
- You should probably re-allign all of A's actions... Sometimes it's fine, but sometimes it's noticeable it isn't alligned, it isn't at the same coordinates everytime =( The correct ones are 316,235

~Special~
00:16:753 (5) - Maybe make this a New Combo? The jump is kind of sudden and a bit confusing, adding a New Combo might make it better to see...
00:59:253 (3,4) - Maybe stack this under the slider endpoint?

The other diffs are fine~
Pretty nice map! [Advanced] is awesome, but unfortunately I have to pop this because of the storyboard =(
Call me whenever it's fixed!


EDIT: All done and this is great <3 RE-BUBBLED!

kazumikos wrote:

SS