my opinion on this matter, is that removing it entirely is pointless as it does help at times where language/genre on the site being slow to get added and also it being useful to be able to have genres being searchable in-game. what i do think should be added to this is some more common stuff people do add onto tags like album names or different names for tv shows/games, like for example a romanised name or translated name instead of just having the japanese in the source field. (even though from the current gudeline says adding sources to the tags seems to be discouraged even though people do it all the time for better searchability?)
about the whole 'making it a rule thing' that seems really forced as guidelines do a good enough job already and if it's not enforced well enough that's just a matter of people not enforcing guidelines as they should be doing. and then the off chance that it's like some genre that's hard to identify/specific sub genre seems like a really big rabbit hole to try to enforce.
about the whole 'making it a rule thing' that seems really forced as guidelines do a good enough job already and if it's not enforced well enough that's just a matter of people not enforcing guidelines as they should be doing. and then the off chance that it's like some genre that's hard to identify/specific sub genre seems like a really big rabbit hole to try to enforce.