chouyaa wrote:

I WANNA BEEEEEEEEEE FAMOUSSSS
NANANANANANANANANA~

Advanced

ADVANCED

00:32:152 (32152|2,32495|2,32838|2,33181|2,33524|2) - anchor. rearrange. fixed. moved 00:32:495 (32495|2) - this to c2

00:03:524 (3524|2,3867|0) - unsure what does this notes stand for, if u are following 'synths', then it should be deleted because there's no different melody on the red thick.
the synths are getting higher from 00:03:352 - to 00:03:695 - and 00:03:695 - 00:04:038 - which have a clear different with 00:00:781 (781|1,1124|3,1467|2) -
here, i assumed that u are following the synth because u didnt map the guitar melody at 00:02:152 - 00:02:495 - 00:02:838 - because they have no synth. ahhh i see. fixed.

00:04:552 - the same thing with the one above, if u are following the synth, then should be a note here.
the synth sounds clearly. fixed

00:05:924 - suggestion > https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10028012
more neat and makes the spread more balance. also try to avoid 00:05:067 (5067|2,5409|2,5752|2,5924|2) - oooh this suggestion is a lot better. changed.

00:16:724 (16724|3,17067|3,17409|3,17752|3,18095|3) - anchor. changed it to a point of where its not too bad

00:21:352 (21352|2,21524|2) - this stack makes zero sense since u didnt do any stack at 00:20:838 - 00:21:009 - 00:21:181 - which have the same drum.
will be more fits if u make a note at 00:21:695 - and 00:21:867 - get stacked considering the drum here 00:21:867 - is more louder and a bit different with the others below. i see, changed

00:23:409 (23409|3,23581|2,23581|1) - this notes are kinda weird and i often stumbled here because of the movement.
also its a bit imbalace compared with 00:24:781 (24781|3,24952|1,24952|0) - .
try to arrange like https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10029553 that's a lot better. fixed.

00:27:009 (27009|2,27352|2,27695|2,27867|2) - isnt it too heavy on col 3? 00:27:695 - suggestion > https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10029687 oooh nice

00:37:981 (37981|0,38324|0,38667|0,39009|0,39352|0) - u can make this better. i see. fixed

so here 00:39:867 (39867|0) - there's a note, then the others same minor sound 00:41:238 - and 00:42:609 - didnt have a note on each of them.
there should be a note as well. unless they have no sound at all such as 00:42:952 - 00:43:981 - fixed

Normal

00:21:009 (21009|1,21181|1,21352|2,21524|2,21695|3,21867|3) - eh are u sure with this jacks in 'normal' diff? its pretty difficult for normal, u didnt even do any jack at 'advanced'. yeah i dont know why i have them wtf fixed

00:12:438 - add a note here? there's a loud sound. changed

00:15:867 - you certainly can add a note here for that sound. also its kinda empty on that section. fixed it and some notes changed, with fixing some patterns

00:18:952 - 00:19:295 - will be better if u put a note on each of them, its pretty awkward to play if u ignore them but the same kicks above suddenly layered. check > 00:19:467 (19467|3,19638|2) - fixed

00:24:781 - add a note here to give more emphasize since the layering on this section is kinda monoton. oh yeah and you can hear a clear not there. fixed

00:33:009 (33009|0) - ghost note. didnt hear any sound there. it would be nice if u replce 00:32:838 (32838|3) - into a LN to cover that guitar melody. i like it, fixed

00:36:438 - 00:37:467 - 2 notes? loud snares. changed

00:48:781 (48781|1) - move to col 4, kinda empty there. agreed, changed

i wanna be famous~~~~ me too

goodluck <3 same to you <3

_Stan wrote:

Hi~ coming from my queue.

Crumpet's Hard

1. Hitsounds: Inconsistent with other diffs
   thats not my problem
   
   
2. 00:15:009 (15009|0) - This note's position is awkward, cuz after it, you should hit same col here 00:15:352 - just a 1 white line, you can 00:14:667 (14667|2) - move this to col [1] then 00:15:009 (15009|0) - move this to col [4], will reduce the pressure of left hand in jack
3. 00:29:752 (29752|0,30095|3) - same problem
   
   yes i understand what your saying, yes it does feel a tiny bit awkward but doing what your saying will just break the current pattern ive got going, so no
   
   
4. 00:29:752 (29752|0,30095|3) - 00:29:752 (29752|0,30095|3) - double here
   
   they are?
   
5. 00:38:495 (38495|1) - delete it, the raeson is same with Adv
   
   why would i remove a note that has meaning?
   
6. 00:43:124 - 00:43:809 - make 4, have cymbal sound
   
   UNPREDICTABLEEEE
   
7. 00:49:981 - double it, you did there 00:52:724 - why not here ( I'll ignore same problems later )
   
   the one you timestamped should of been a double, but thats the only one

I really really really like this song! REALLY!
hope can see this map get reanked
good luck~

CrumpetFiddler wrote:

Update

https://puu.sh/z8iyU/b6f32ba43e.osu (copy paste it in url)

_Stan wrote:

Hi~ coming from my queue.

col |1|2|3|4|

Easy

1. Hitsounds: Why your Easy diff have different hs setting with Normal ok yeah i suck with hitsounding but i will fix
   -
2. 00:06:267 (6267|3) - I dont know the meaning of this note, especially check with your Normal, In Normal here have no note. So why make them different even Easy have one more note here than Normal yeah I agree, fixed.
3. 00:06:952 - Add a note, I think you miss a beat sound agreed
4. 00:09:695 - Add a note, in this part ( from 00:05:752 - to 00:11:238 - it's section of this song, so your setting here should be same ), I mean, if you 00:08:838 (8838|1,9009|0,9181|2) - catch all 3 beat you should keep same here 00:09:695 - in this section. i see. yeah, when I first started this diff, it had a lot of inconsistencies. trying to fix them up now.
5. 00:10:724 - Add a note, reason is same with above sure
6. 00:12:095 (12095|0) - Check your Normal, redundant? ah yeah, thanks
7. 00:15:867 - Add a note maybe nah I think its with just the 1/1 notes
8. 00:27:438 (27438|3) - Maybe it's wrong position which should start at 00:27:352 - LOL wtf how did i miss this
9. 00:32:324 - 00:32:667 - add a note and delete 00:32:495 - i like it, changed
10. 00:36:095 (36095|0) - redundant here deleted

Normal

1. Hitsounds: check with your other diffs, it's different ( like 00:00:609 (609|1) - in NM is soft-hit but in HD is W ) ill see about getting this fixed
   -
2. 00:15:181 - Miss a note? yep
3. 00:35:924 - add a note here, ad for me I think it's same heavy 00:35:924 - and 00:36:438 - , why different quantity fixed

Advanced

1. Hitsounds: Inconsistent with other diffs ye
   -
2. 00:00:438 - idk the meaning of this blank fixed
3. 00:38:495 (38495|1) - I recommend delete this note, cuz First, it's so weaken here the sound, We can ignore it, Second, could make a pulse here to ready for next part, player will feel better i like your reasoning, fixed.
4. 00:52:895 - I can hear a beat here me too

I really really really like this song! REALLY!
hope can see this map get reanked
good luck~ thank you! glad you like it! trying my hardest to go for rank. your mod was very helpful!

Frim4503 wrote:

Col : 1|2|3|4|5|6|7

Crumpet's Hard

• 
  Why clap and whistle have the same hitsound ????
  To be honest you can improve this diff a lot
  Example make this 00:06:609 (6609|3) –to double since it has same sound like 00:06:438 (6438|3,6438|0) –

1. 00:07:981 (7981|2,8324|2) -^same
2. 00:43:124 –you can make this 4 notes since it has cymbal in it
3. 00:43:467 -00:43:809 –
4. 00:44:495 (44495|1,45181|1) –you can make this double for clap example : 00:49:981 (49981|2,49981|1) –

Sorry cant give a proper mod since this map need a lot of remap
You can try learning by playing mania mode specific
Or asking feedback from player

Good luck
Mod Done

Frim4503 wrote:

Normal

1. 00:23:409 –add note here to cover those whistle added
2. 00:24:781 -00:26:152 - added
3. 00:46:552 (46552|3) –mvoe to col 1 for balance ok

Sorry cant give a proper mod since this map need a lot of remap
You can try learning by playing mania mode specific
Or asking feedback from player

unsure what you mean by this. Im not the best player, but i think i have enough experience to know mania. I believe you're talking about crumpet's diff which is "bad" but it does follow the song like intended. If it was "bad" or unplayable, I wouldn't have added it anyways. I will fix hitsounding though, as I know its a problem and somewhat inconsistent.

Good luck thanks
Mod Done

Frim4503 wrote:

Sorry cant give a proper mod since this map need a lot of remap what do i think about this, "a lot of remap" sounds the map is too bad and unacceptable for ranked status. but here, u didnt specify what diff that needs to get remap and why. it will just makes what u were saying is opinionated and unreasoned. leave a comment without any reason like this is really pointless and rude.

You can try learning by playing mania mode specific couldnt understand what does it mean exactly, seems like u underestimate the map and the mapper as well. in short, its offending.
Or asking feedback from player

Good luck
Mod Done

Frim4503 wrote:

lmao
a lot of people triggered
sorry for unclear reason that i said before
but what i mean by remap is becuz the flow of patern is same like i see a few years ago (2012 or 2013 stlye) when i was start mapping.
and that something i try before (a lot of BAT or BN say it was bad and force me to remap)
and now i will give you a proper mod to clear this misunderstand since i didnt give you a proper reason.
its not like i disrespect you or insult you as fellow mapper.

Frim's mod stuff

Crumpet's Hard

1. 00:00:267 (267|0) - this is too weak for hard diff comparing it to advanced. example https://puu.sh/z9m1v/bda7405b98.png
2. 00:05:752 - then you can make this part triple for cymbal
3. 00:06:609 (6609|3,6952|3) - i feel its better if you can make these note double since it a whistle. also in prev section you use double for it 00:06:438 (6438|3,6438|0,7124|1,7124|2) -
4. 00:22:038 - 00:22:209 - i suggest to add LN here since the sound is doesnt end but its change direction
5. 00:22:209 - i recommend to add 1/2 LN in this section since its has same patern like before and too repetitive. example https://puu.sh/z9meW/8ef63e90c2.png
6. 00:28:038 - make this section use same formula as before. double for whistle and clap, single for hithat and triple for cymbal
7. 00:39:867 (39867|1,41238|3) - i dont understand what this LN followimg :/. at least you can follow vocal in here imo
8. 00:44:495 - you should make clap double in here since you make double in some part >> 00:49:981 (49981|2,49981|1) - 00:52:724 (52724|1,52724|2,53409|3,53409|2) -
9. 00:59:319 (59319|1) - you can make it double

Normal

1. 00:03:009 (3009|2) - dunno why you make it a note but i prefer to make it to LN since it have same sound as before
2. 00:16:724 (16724|3,17409|0,18095|1) - better to make this double. same sound with 00:16:381 (16381|1,16381|2,17067|2,17067|1,17752|3,17752|2) - cuz you did it in same part 00:33:181 -
3. 00:45:181 (45181|1,45181|0,46552|2,46552|0) - dunno why you make this double for clap but you leave the other part single :/
4. 00:44:495 (44495|3,45867|1) - you should make this double too since it has a clap sound in there
5. 00:53:752 (53752|1) - make double since it more strong than prev cymbal

this is the reason why i say need a remap
sorry for the problem that i cause
it was my mistake for not say my reason

good luck

You missed my point. i dont care that you think the map needs a remap, thats purely opinionated.

"You can try learning by playing mania mode specific" Thats why i reacted. Dont post smart ass remarks

"but what i mean by remap is becuz the flow of patern is same like i see a few years ago (2012 or 2013 stlye) when i was start mapping.
and that something i try before (a lot of BAT or BN say it was bad and force me to remap)" This confuses me a bit, I am not YOU, if a bn comes along and absolutely despises the map. they can suggest a remap if they'd like, but as it stands it already follows a 'mostly' consistent beat

newbandpro wrote:

From my modding queue


00:55:124 (55124|1) - Move this to 00:55:081 for consistency with Advanced
00:56:802 (56802|3) - Again,move to 00:56:749 for consistency
I Intentionally wanted to kinda avoid these but its pretty important sadly. applied

Couldn't really find too many things,the map seems to be fine
Good luck and hopefully you'll be famous one day

newbandpro wrote:

From my modding queue

Advanced

00:01:981 - 00:03:009 - This part should contain a constant 1/4 rhythm just like 00:00:267 (267|3,438|1,609|2,781|1,952|0,1124|3,1295|1,1467|2,1638|3) if you're following the guitar makes sense, added and rearranged
00:04:724 - You missed a LN here fixed

Couldn't really find too many things,the map seems to be fine
Good luck and hopefully you'll be famous one day i hope so, thank you for the mod!

Frim4503 wrote:

lmao
a lot of people triggered
sorry for unclear reason that i said before
but what i mean by remap is becuz the flow of patern is same like i see a few years ago (2012 or 2013 stlye) when i was start mapping.
and that something i try before (a lot of BAT or BN say it was bad and force me to remap)
and now i will give you a proper mod to clear this misunderstand since i didnt give you a proper reason.
its not like i disrespect you or insult you as fellow mapper.

talk to Crumpet about it. your mod kinda ticked him off. i wanna just get this ranked ya feel?

Crumpet's Hard

• 
  
  [notice]

  Normal

1. 00:03:009 (3009|2) - dunno why you make it a note but i prefer to make it to LN since it have same sound as before not exactly. I want to follow the "whirring" noise (dont know how to describe it lol) but I feel a note adds emphasis to the other guitar coming in that you hear and the drum as well.
2. 00:16:724 (16724|3,17409|0,18095|1) - better to make this double. same sound with 00:16:381 (16381|1,16381|2,17067|2,17067|1,17752|3,17752|2) - cuz you did it in same part 00:33:181 - oh you're right, fixed
3. 00:45:181 (45181|1,45181|0,46552|2,46552|0) - dunno why you make this double for clap but you leave the other part single :/ unsure what you mean by this. I'll try fix it if you can tell me what the "the other part single" is
4. 00:44:495 (44495|3,45867|1) - you should make this double too since it has a clap sound in there oooh i like it, fixed
5. 00:53:752 (53752|1) - make double since it more strong than prev cymbal ok

this is the reason why i say need a remap
sorry for the problem that i cause
it was my mistake for not say my reason

good luck thx

Frim4503 wrote:

Crumpet's Hard

1. 00:00:267 (267|0) - this is too weak for hard diff comparing it to advanced. example https://puu.sh/z9m1v/bda7405b98.png
   
   i disagree
   
2. 00:05:752 - then you can make this part triple for cymbal
   
   no because i never do this anywhere else
   
3. 00:06:609 (6609|3,6952|3) - i feel its better if you can make these note double since it a whistle. also in prev section you use double for it 00:06:438 (6438|3,6438|0,7124|1,7124|2) -
   
   this makes no sense, i'm following the prominent beat, in this case its every second note, making what you highlighted doubles makes absolutely no sense
   
4. 00:22:038 - 00:22:209 - i suggest to add LN here since the sound is doesnt end but its change direction
   
   Thats what the ln on col 1 does, the one on col 3 emphasises the louder sound before cutting off and letting the other ln finish the sound
   
5. 00:22:209 - i recommend to add 1/2 LN in this section since its has same patern like before and too repetitive. example https://puu.sh/z9meW/8ef63e90c2.png
   
   i myself quite like the simplicity and repetition the song has, also thats basically exactly what advanced has done, which id like my diff to not resemble at all
   
   
6. 00:28:038 - make this section use same formula as before. double for whistle and clap, single for hithat and triple for cymbal
   
   already explained myself here
   
7. 00:39:867 (39867|1,41238|3) - i dont understand what this LN followimg :/. at least you can follow vocal in here imo
   
   that ln follows the guitar sound to act as a smoother transition, basically the same thing is done here 00:43:809 (43809|1) - except muuuch more audible
   
8. 00:44:495 - you should make clap double in here since you make double in some part >> 00:49:981 (49981|2,49981|1) - 00:52:724 (52724|1,52724|2,53409|3,53409|2) -
   
   This was something i spent a lot of time on. The sounds aren't quite the same, the second clap you linked, is significantly stronger than the first few
   
9. 00:59:319 (59319|1) - you can make it double
   
   um no. theres nowhere near enough sound to dignify a double
   

good luck

Fahrie6775 wrote:

sorry for long respond ;-;

yet ur map is already gud
can't find anything wrong or just my feelin' ;-;

GL >w<

FAMoss wrote:

hitsound is done
set by using .. > Compose > Sample import

https://puu.sh/zejEG/3ee0f7ad9f.osz

good luck, go rank !!! <o/

chouyaa wrote:

rank when?

error_exe777 wrote:

lets go

h

[General]

1. Uhh, is it just me or is the video not working? i cant see it (and yes i have show video on) yeah wtf? thanks for mentioning, unsure what happened.
   edit: just found out the video is gone...? but i got it back with proper offset too.
   
   
2. Almost certain 00:59:319 (59319|2) - this LN ends on the blue tick after constant replaying with the playback rate, i think it should end right here and the LN for the guitar should start here instead.

considering this has had loads of modding already i doubt ill be able to find much

[Advanced]

00:37:295 - this should probably be a single and have 00:37:638 - since 00:37:638 - is a stronger sound, and you dont really want such a long jumptrill sure, also changed a bit of the patterning above so some columns aren't too crowded.

00:55:124 - same suggestion in crumpets diff with the grace notes, but probably more simplified here for the lower diff i guess agreed, take a look at what i did though, i think they're ok but some confirmation would be nice.
[Normal]

00:53:752 (53752|3,53752|1,53752|0) - should probably be a double since advanced uses it as a double you're right... but i do have one LOL https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10567968

[Easy]

00:32:838 (32838|0) - should be an LN for consistency with 00:27:352 (27352|3) - and with the normal diff oops fixed.

00:59:319 (59319|1) - even with this LN snapped to the 1/4th, the release of it is too complex for an easy diff, as new players arent really accustomed to any snap above 1/2 so should probably simplify it by snapping to the 1/1 i can agree with this, fixed

and if you have any sort of metadata source that would be ideal errrr https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/616440#osu/1301500 basically the only metadata source i have. although, i think its fine. it even includes the different show names when the show went through a different season. if you have anything else to add in terms of metadata, hmu on discord or osu, i'll add it.

error_exe777 wrote:

lets go

[Crumpet's Hard]

ur diff sucks remap kthx

fuk u

[00:16:724 - uhhhh spread between this and advanced is literally the same and considering you are the top diff, would make the most sense to buff it some more to widen the gap that doesnt exist

I mean, there's no real way to widen this without having notes where they aren't suppose to, this is pretty much the only occurrence of this so i think its fine

00:20:838 (20838|0,20838|2,21009|1,21009|3,21181|2,21181|0) - not the biggest of deals but the pattern could be more varied, and could show the drum beats by doing something like this http://prntscr.com/iwotnb as the repeating drums are on the latter two drums

Did something similar, but not exact

00:33:181 - yeah same

same deal

00:37:467 (37467|1,37638|2) - these should ideally be made doubles as they are stronger than the drums you charted with doubles beforehand eg 00:36:781 (36781|2,36781|0,36952|1,36952|3) -

u rite, fixed

00:46:209 (46209|0,46381|3,46552|0,46724|3,46895|0) - of all the columns, you decide to use literally half smh. nah but seriously, should probably avoid this since variation

used more of the cols, makes more sense than it did

00:55:081 (55081|1,55124|3,55124|0) - alright so the height of the guitar rolls dont even start until the white tick so starting the grace beforehand is not ideal. to properly represent the guitar, should probably map it to a 1/6th or 1/8th interval, possibly like so http://prntscr.com/iwozj6 and something similar for the other instances

got you

00:58:480 (58480|3,59319|1) - you actually hate me. since the guitar for 00:58:480 (58480|3) - actually ends around 00:59:833 - or so it would be wise to have the two LNs end at the same point to keep it a hindrance to gameplay cause at the moment there is nothing to suggest the weird cutoff from the other one


Easy fix

k so im too lazy to read all of the arguments but im assume its all settled down now, right?

All sorted i think

error_exe777 wrote:

[All Diffs]

The 1/12th LN at the end of the map is like, probably a timing error more than an unorthodox snap. Try moving the timing point to 00:59:296 - and snapping to 1/4th instead oh my god, thats a lot better. seriously. fixed for all

[Normal]

00:44:495 (44495|3,44495|2) - should be a double right? the other instances use singles (eg 00:45:867 - 00:47:238 - ) nice catch, fixed

00:53:752 (53752|1,53752|3,53752|0) - i dont really understand your reply to this point, this should be a double as the advanced diff also uses a double. its backwards cause the advanced diff is meant to be using harder techniques than a normal diff oh i see, misunderstood you on accident. fixed.

00:59:284 (59284|0) - should probably also simplify this LN to the 1/1 (after the timing change above) since its also quite a low diff and 1/4th is probably still a bit too complex for a player of that level ye

[Easy]

Just clarifying, this LN's end 00:59:319 (59319|1) - should be simplified to 1/1 after the timing change as well fixed.

[Hitsound]

00:37:638 - should be an extra note for the W here only added a W to crumpet's diff cuz hes the only one who has a double there.

chouyaa wrote:

meet me again
so unpredictable asked me to mod this soon because it's going for bubble
oh my god how many times i have mod this set too much

1|2|3|4

easy

00:04:724 (4724|0) - move to col 3? seems kinda empty there. sure

00:14:495 (14495|0) - delete. no drum. fine

00:31:295 - add a note for more emphasis? just the same like 00:28:552 - ok

00:35:067 - ^ damn how do i miss these, fixed

00:45:009 (45009|1) - this note has no emphasis. it should probably on 00:44:667 - for kick. agreed

normal

00:16:038 (16038|2) - this guitar melody shouldn't be mapped imo. in this stanza, you are only following the drums entirely.
so it will be confusing to map the guitar suddenly and in fact you didn't map the similar sound at 00:13:295 - yes and no. yes you are right, but i wont add it. The reason for this is I think the guitar makes a great indication of build-up. yes i was only following the drums earlier, but the change on the emphasize with the guitar makes a clear indication to the player that the next part they will play into is different from what they just played. i think if it were just the drums, i think it wouldn't make much of a good build-up.

00:20:838 - will be great to make it single because this section introduces a new percussion play which you map the loud snare at 00:21:181 - 00:21:524 - as a double.
the sound at 00:20:838 - itself is too weak to be a double. i would have to disagree here, i feel as if the drum here is emphasized enough to make it a double. it's shows a change in patterning and emphasize on the drums when the vocals cut off here. thus why i think a double is justifiably.

00:27:695 - to 00:33:181 - in this part, the map is constantly layering the sounds every 1/1 snap no matter the sounds.
a little issue at 00:32:324 - and 00:32:667 - when you mapped the kick suddenly in the same section where you ignored the similar sound at 00:29:581 - and 00:29:924 -
what I suggest here, personally I prefer to map the kick at red thicks in emphasizing the drum as you did at 00:32:324 -
this will be fit to the sound itself. wow really surprised you caught this. definitely added, i also like it because it's a change of pattern instead of it being just notes on 1/1 during that whole section. also added the hitsound 'W' to each of them.

advanced

00:19:467 - pretty sure it should be a single since the drum isn't that loud compared with 00:18:781 - plus it doesn't have any cymbal
the sound itself is the same with 00:19:295 - after I heard carefully.

00:20:152 - ^ same issue i disagree with this point and the point above this one. even though it may not be emphasized like the tick you suggested, it's definitely more emphasized that a lot of the other ticks. I also think just having singles just doesn't fit the part to be honest and doubles fit a lot nicer than single would.

00:21:867 (21867|2) - this will be a lot better on col 4 considering both fingers at the left hand are hitting notes and holds a LN.
moving the note next to right and giving a space between the double on left will make up a better play comfortability because of the hands balance at the end of jumptrill. gonna have to disagree with you here. i purposely left column 4 open so it gives the player enough time to hit the LN. either way if i moved it column 4, the LN is right above it so it makes this uncomfortable pattern right after the roll.

00:44:152 - should probably triple here, there's actually a little cymbal the same like 00:38:667 - agreed, i think this part should emphasize that the map is going into kiai time and a triple should do nicely. added it to column 1 and moved 00:44:495 (44495|0) - to column 4 so it doesn't make a stack of 3 of 1/1 on column 1.

might be the last mod from chouyaa for this set lol you have modded this set so much, i can't how many times we iirced about this map.
goodluck <3 gl on ur maps too