Chaos wrote:

From mod queue =]

Freedom

Change recommended
Idea/Thought

00:00:082 - The red and green lines differing in volume is unrankable, iirc. Fixed on all diffs
00:01:796 (1,2,3,4,5) - Inconsistent mapping with 00:08:653 (1,2,3) for the same phrase in the music. Wouldn't feel the need to point this out except that the rest of the mapping is very consistent when repeating sections of music. I'm sure this difference is intentional, and there's no necessity to change it, but wanted to point it out to make sure. Just realized that these are really out of place now that you've mentioned it. Changed pattern
00:26:117 - I see you deleted the circle you originally had here due to Delis' suggestion. Personally I'd keep the circle since the music is strong here just before the vocals. But in keeping with Delis' suggestion which you applied, I'm going to instead recommend the following below:
00:25:796 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Remap this a bit so that (2,3) are spaced like the rest of the combo here instead of stacked. I think that making (4,5) a slider would be better for mapping to the vocals, but this isn't a necessary change if you don't want to. Nice idea. Reworked that small part
00:28:367 (5,6) - (6) should be a slider end from (5) imo as there isn't any strong sound in the music here. Reworked this part too
00:30:939-00:34:367 - Just wanted to say this section is really cool Thanks! :3
00:32:224 (1,2,3,4) - I see that you use a stack here, whereas in the same musical section later on at 01:48:082 (1,2) you use sliders. Intended? (I personally like the sliders better used later on) Intended to do this
00:39:510 (1,1) - Maybe delete the circle and move the spinner onto that tick since there's no active sound there. Functionally is the same as what you have but fits better to the music imo. I just prefer when streams end on an odd number. Maybe I'll change this later if someone else points this out. Also it's just because I suck at even numbered streams
00:59:224 (3,4) - Map this to the 1/2 vocals here? Definitely different than the normal vocals throughout the Kiai. The sliders are following the 1/2
01:07:153 (2,4) - Musically, I don't like the use of circles here since there's only vocal fading out. No need to change as pattern and play are perfectly fine, simply making a remark if you happen to like the idea.
01:41:224 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Same idea as 00:25:796 Fixed too
01:53:653 (1,2,3,4) - This feels like a rather sharp turn in this stream. Didn't really bother me in testing it but consider smoothing this part out a bit? Reworked stream path
02:15:510 (6,7,8) - Same DS for each jump here? Would be practically the same in playability but a cleaner approach for the 3 drum hits here, imo. Reworked jump pattern
02:23:653 (7,8,1) - IMO the slider should just be circles. Nothing musically suggests the use of a slider here. I wanted like a last note for the map and I just find the slider most suitable here.

I'll be sure to look once you reply to this mod and make sure everything is clear, regardless of what you choose to apply changes to. gl with ranking

Shmiklak wrote:

M4M

Hi!

General

1. -

Easy

1. 00:48:082 (1,2) - fix blanket Fixed
2. 01:32:653 (1,2) - I don't sure but they looks different Checked with ctrl+h, they're perfectly symmetrical

Normal

1. I don't sure about using 1/4 in this diff :/ Eventhough the beat snap divisor is 1/4, there are no 1/4 notes in this diff
2. 00:29:224 (3,1) - Stack they Nope

Sorry, but I can't found more D:
Hope will be ranked because nice song! Good luck!

Behonkiss wrote:

General

There are a lot of short, straight horizontal sliders that are slightly slanted up or down, and look a little odd as a result. I'd recommend either making them perfectly straight or increasing their slants. I just prefer them slightly slanted instead of making them perfectly straight
Higher difficulties have several instances of new combos starting in the middle of quick streams of notes, which is strange.
00:30:939 - 00:37:367: Maybe add some other hitsounds once the music starts ramping back up in this section? Added some hitsounds at that part
01:46:367 - 01:52:796: See above. Same thing

Easy

02:13:796 (1): The lower end might look more visually appealing if you move it to the left a little more. It's fine as it is

Hard

02:04:153 (1): This feels strange as a new combo. Removed NC

The other three difficulties don't have any unique problems. I apologize that I don't have a ton to say, but this is a really well done map that's lacking in genuine flaws.

Reditum wrote:

dam what is this bernie sanders

Overall:
Might wanna cut the mp3 since it's just a repeated loop? Maybe not

Extra:
00:01:367 (3) - why is this spaced out so much farther than (1) and (2)? Fixed
00:34:367 - no hitsounds for the claps here? Put hitsounds there for every diff
00:39:510 (1) - softwhistle pls Done

Very nice map Thanks!

Insane:
00:00:724 (2) - prefer not to have this overlap No change

Hard:
nice

Normal:
nice

Easy:
00:20:653 (1) - the curves are so slight that they look really uncertain. Make the curves sharper so they can be properly seen as curves. Curved more

very nice mapset go get it bubbled lmao Workin' on it

Janpai wrote:

M4m from your queue

General

1. Why didn't you map the whole of the mp3? This might be an
   
   unrakable issue, you should cut your mp3 I cut the mp3. Had to deal with some timing stuff. Hope my offset is correct :/

Easy

1. 00:00:082 (1) - For my own taste, I don't like this slider art No change
   
   maybe try this http://puu.sh/n0cpb/ef30dd2752.jpg
2. 00:03:510 (1) - Here also http://puu.sh/n0cus/4ea0a72a73.jpg No change too
3. 00:30:082 (4) - Nazi suggestion, maybe make this a simple curved
   
   slider and be blanketed with 00:29:224 (3) ? I can't blanket (3) here
4. 00:41:224 (1,2) - Fix blanket They are already perfectly blanketed
5. 00:44:653 (1) - Try this http://puu.sh/n0cIZ/49ee481193.jpg Sure
6. 02:08:653 (3) - You can turn this into normal curved slider Nope. The corner is for the kick sound

Normal

1. I think placing/ending notes/objects on blue ticks are
   
   prohibited in normals, you can try many improvision, I can clearly
   
   hear that you were right on the beat but new players might be
   
   confused Many people already commented on this so I decided to change this at last. Gonna fix this but I feel kinda lazy now so I'll fix this tomorrow :3 Fixed!
2. 00:00:082 (1,2,3) - Instead of this, you can place 1 1/2 and 1
   
   slider here as well as 00:01:796 (1,2,1) , 00:01:796 (1,2,1) ,
   
   00:05:224 (1,2,3) (If you wanted to)

Kinda lazy to do more mods Maybe I'll continue next day or idunno

XDDD don't kds if not helped

Miss Mandii wrote:

M4M From your Que

General:

SPOILER

When you adopt spinner, please put the setting of the volume for spinners at 20%. (For all difficulties) I can't really see why would I need to do this

Easy:

SPOILER

No issues found
01:39:546 (1) - like the mustache sliders :3

Normal:

SPOILER

00:00:118 (1) - slider end is not snapped
00:00:760 (2) - ^
00:01:832 (1) - ^
00:03:546 (1) - ^
00:05:260 (1) - ^
00:05:903 (2) - ^
00:06:975 (1) - ^
00:08:689 (1) - ^
00:09:332 (2) - ^
00:10:403 (1) - ^
00:11:046 (2) - ^
00:12:118 (1) - ^
00:12:760 (2) - ^ (please consult AI mod) Oh man... I'm really sorry for making you go through all those terrible sliders. There's something wrong with the SV change after I cut the mp3. I also reworked that part cuz of the blue tick stuff from the previous mods. Everything fixed now


00:01:832 (1) - slider is not snapped/ also extend slider by 1 tick currently off beat (trust me ) Ex 00:15:546 (1,2) - this one is perfect follow how you have these sliders.
00:02:475 (2) - ^
00:03:546 (1,2) - ^
00:06:975 (1,2) - ^
00:12:118 (1,2) - ^ Yup yup I know. That part now has a brand new pattern


00:44:689 (1) - i would change this slider so it stays on the white ticks only, due to it being a Normal map you want to strongly follow the beat, too not confuse new players.
00:48:118 (1) - ^
00:51:546 (1) - ^
00:53:260 (1) - ^
00:54:975 (1) - ^
00:58:403 (1) - ^
01:01:832 (1) - ^ Well for this I wanted them to be different from the Easy diff. Besides there kinda is a beat on the red tick and I'm sure beginners can play that just fine

01:20:689 (1) - Please add at least 4 beats in between spinners. (this is a factor of the un-rank-able for easy/ normal Diff) Spinners can start right after a note it's just the note after the spinner that needs to be spaced at least 4 beats (for Easy) and 2 beats (for Normal)

Please use distance snap for:
00:48:975 (2) - ^
00:52:403 (2) - ^
00:54:118 (2) - (consult AI Mod for these :3 ) AiMod didn't point these and I do use DS for those. It's just a little different because of the 'Tiny' grid snap

Hard:

SPOILER

00:29:260 (5) - NC
00:32:689 (3) - ^
00:38:689 (3) - ^
01:54:118 (3) - ^ All of these would make the combo too short imo

00:55:832 (3,4) - I would suggest not stacking these notes, due to confusing players into thinking its a stream not tap? I'll keep this in mind but for now no change
01:00:546 (3) - ^ This stack is to represent the whole beat temporary 'stop' in the music

01:31:618 (2) - i would remove this and 01:30:975 (1) - change this to a repeater slider and add a single note to here 01:31:939 (2) - due to it following a different beat, not the vocals Are you sure you have the correct time stamp here? There's no vocals in this part and what you suggested didn't fit this part at all

Insane:

SPOILER

00:15:546 (1) - would go on a 1/8 and move forward by 1 tick (if your following the vocals try and see?)
00:16:135 (2) -
00:16:832 (3) -
00:18:975 (1) -
00:21:332 (2) - Umm there's no actual vocals here and going into 1/8 beat here seems really off-timed and irrelevant for this part

00:28:189 (4,5,6) - over mapped 00:28:296 (5) - i would remove the 5 It's not overmapped actually. You can hear the triple note in the music

01:06:118 (5) - NC Combo would be too short
01:07:832 (5) - ^ ^
01:08:689 (1) - Remove NC This is to give emphasize on the downbeat
01:44:689 (5) - NC Combo would be too short

Be Free:

SPOILER

01:08:689 (1) - Remove NC Same thing as Insane
01:12:118 (1) - ^ Done
01:15:546 (1) - ^ ^
01:54:975 (1) - ^ No change

01:07:832 (5) - NC Combo would be too short
02:23:260 (5) - ^ No change. The last NC is to emphasize the last note

No further issues where found, Snapping and notes placement is good.

Best of luck in ranking

Kocari wrote:

[Freedom]

00:03:868 (2,2) - Single notes on blue tick is a no-no. I would recommend using repeats here instead. Also the others as well but tbh Idk how I would describe it as. It's just how the song is and I used repeats at other parts of it
00:30:546 (4) - Feels like a random hitsound to me because it doesn't match up with the sound in the music Removed
00:30:975 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2) - I recommend spacing this out, it's very cluttered and the 1/2s don't play as freely since everything is so close and the flow doesn't quite compensate with how little area you're given to play this out Gonna keep this for now
00:34:403 (1,2,3,4) - All the sudden 1/1 sliders doesn't really provide much for the music - Another rhythm you can use to progress the song instead of slowing it down http://puu.sh/n5VKq/1f59168a81.jpg Same for this
00:37:832 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1) - Stream doesn't quite compensate as well, the song is getting more dynamic but it's the same throughout the whole entire stream and then that last 4 notes looks strange - Stuff like this to progress with the music http://puu.sh/n5VTN/0af62a3878.jpg Changed stream
00:42:975 (1,2) - Try moving these around http://puu.sh/n5YjQ/3a9ef90dc7.jpg - This feels and plays relatively better Changed pattern
00:52:403 (3) - This slider shape makes this part look very bad imo. Too much unnecessary slider movements Fixed
01:08:260 (6,7) - Doesn't quite flow well. Look at where the tail on (6) is pointed and look at the follow point to (7) It's better to have a single motion instead of just to play the 1/2 fast to then hit the next note that is at an awkward location - But that's just me Changed pattern for flow
01:49:832 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - Quite excessive on the NC. Not really necessary NC every 4 notes
01:53:260 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1) - I like this one better
Some unclean sliders that I didn't want to mention because its all nit picking from me after that

[Insane]

00:00:118 (1,2) - Are overlaps like these beneficial? Look at how clean other possibilities are http://puu.sh/n5WDU/169a7ac592.jpg Fixed
00:15:118 (3,2) - This as well - It's insane difficulty. You have plenty of space to add things on here, especially because this song is only 140bpm - Then again it's probably just me Fixed
00:20:475 (3) - We trying to make a normal difficulty? You can definitely add a little more space here Fixed
00:28:189 (4,5,6) - Maybe move so it flows into it better http://puu.sh/n5WQr/4f37874013.jpg I made it like counter curve here
02:03:332 (5,1,3) - You can definitely blanket this. Fits very well Already blanketed it. Improved it a bit

[Hard]

01:18:546 (4) - That anchor slider doesn't really do anything. Rather just make it a curve slider I prefer having varied sliders
01:20:689 (1,2) - Same as ^ here
01:46:403 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Claps here doesn't sound good since these single notes resemble it but don't have actually hitsounds implemented 01:42:975 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - Best to just to start the claps after this 01:49:832 (1) - Fixed
01:54:118 (3) - No clap on head. Different from the rest. I recommend to add it on Added clap
01:57:118 (2) - Flow breaks off here. Other possibility you can try http://puu.sh/n5Xnp/f5607523f1.jpg Fixed
02:03:332 (5,1,2,3,4,5,6) - Very hidden. I mean it's hard to play and to tell which note is coming next. I would advise to definitely move things around here. [/color]
02:20:689 (1,2,3) - Making this more linear would look nice http://puu.sh/n5Xvr/4e38561f12.jpg No change

[Normal]

00:00:118 (1) - You can map the way it sounds instead of using 3/4 sliders but tbh it's fine either way
00:30:975 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,1,2) - What? This whole rhythm is reversed. It's best to start out with 1/1s then build up to single notes instead of making it the way it is now Fixed rhythm on buildup
00:57:975 (3) - Same with the other diffs, why the sudden anchor? This follows the same concept yet it doesn't have a red anchor 00:56:260 (3) - Same reason as in Hard
01:10:403 (1) - Placed at a strange area to start NC. Try http://puu.sh/n5XSD/1fde9e0280.jpg and you can keep the 3 notes linear I intentionally broke flow here
02:12:118 (1,2) - Holy... what is this flow I don't really know. Space is quite limited here :/
02:21:975 (6,1) - Flow like this http://puu.sh/n5Y6y/19ca3be2e4.jpg Done

AIBat v3.1 wrote:

[General]

Background
bg.jpg is 1366x768, which differs from the recommended size of 1024x768.

[All .osu Files]

Kiai
Inconsistency in Kiai Times:

- [Easy] :
Kiai #1: Starts on 00:41:260, ends on 00:53:260
Kiai #2: Starts on 00:54:975, ends on 01:08:689
Kiai #3: Starts on 01:56:689, ends on 02:09:975
Kiai #4: Starts on 02:10:403, ends on 02:24:118

- [Freedom] :
Kiai #1: Starts on 00:41:260, ends on 00:53:260
Kiai #2: Starts on 00:54:975, ends on 01:08:689
Kiai #3: Starts on 01:56:689, ends on 02:09:975
Kiai #4: Starts on 02:10:403, ends on 02:24:118

- [Hard] :
Kiai #1: Starts on 00:41:260, ends on 00:53:260
Kiai #2: Starts on 00:54:975, ends on 01:08:796
Kiai #3: Starts on 01:56:689, ends on 02:09:975
Kiai #4: Starts on 02:10:403, ends on 02:24:118

- [Insane] :
Kiai #1: Starts on 00:41:260, ends on 00:53:260
Kiai #2: Starts on 00:54:975, ends on 01:08:689
Kiai #3: Starts on 01:56:689, ends on 02:09:975
Kiai #4: Starts on 02:10:403, ends on 02:24:118

- [Normal] :
Kiai #1: Starts on 00:41:260, ends on 00:53:260
Kiai #2: Starts on 00:54:975, ends on 01:08:689
Kiai #3: Starts on 01:56:689, ends on 02:09:975
Kiai #4: Starts on 02:10:403, ends on 02:24:118

[Easy]

Audio Lead-In
There is only 118 ms of audio lead-in, which is less than the minimum of 2000 ms.

[Freedom]

Audio Lead-In
There is only 118 ms of audio lead-in, which is less than the minimum of 2000 ms.

Snapping

Unsnapped inherited (green) sections at:
00:13:796 - snap to 00:13:832

[Hard]

Audio Lead-In
There is only 118 ms of audio lead-in, which is less than the minimum of 2000 ms.

[Insane]

Audio Lead-In
There is only 118 ms of audio lead-in, which is less than the minimum of 2000 ms.

[Normal]

Audio Lead-In
There is only 118 ms of audio lead-in, which is less than the minimum of 2000 ms.

WazZzaA123 wrote:

[Freedom]
00:39:546 (1) - This note shouldnt be there delete it Done
02:21:118 (3) - I think this is offgrid Fixed

[Insane]
Nothing to see major just check big white tick

[Hard]
Make sliders more smooth
02:04:403 (1) - NC Done

AIBat v3.1 wrote:

[General]

Background
bg.jpg is 1366x768, which differs from the recommended size of 1024x768. If I'm not mistaken most BGs now are the dimensions that I'm using anyways

[All .osu Files]

Kiai
Inconsistency in Kiai Times:

- [Easy] :
Kiai #1: Starts on 00:41:260, ends on 00:53:260
Kiai #2: Starts on 00:54:975, ends on 01:08:689
Kiai #3: Starts on 01:56:689, ends on 02:09:975
Kiai #4: Starts on 02:10:403, ends on 02:24:118

- [Freedom] :
Kiai #1: Starts on 00:41:260, ends on 00:53:260
Kiai #2: Starts on 00:54:975, ends on 01:08:689
Kiai #3: Starts on 01:56:689, ends on 02:09:975
Kiai #4: Starts on 02:10:403, ends on 02:24:118

- [Hard] :
Kiai #1: Starts on 00:41:260, ends on 00:53:260
Kiai #2: Starts on 00:54:975, ends on 01:08:796
Kiai #3: Starts on 01:56:689, ends on 02:09:975
Kiai #4: Starts on 02:10:403, ends on 02:24:118

- [Insane] :
Kiai #1: Starts on 00:41:260, ends on 00:53:260
Kiai #2: Starts on 00:54:975, ends on 01:08:689
Kiai #3: Starts on 01:56:689, ends on 02:09:975
Kiai #4: Starts on 02:10:403, ends on 02:24:118

- [Normal] :
Kiai #1: Starts on 00:41:260, ends on 00:53:260
Kiai #2: Starts on 00:54:975, ends on 01:08:689
Kiai #3: Starts on 01:56:689, ends on 02:09:975
Kiai #4: Starts on 02:10:403, ends on 02:24:118

Fixed this

[Easy]

Audio Lead-In
There is only 118 ms of audio lead-in, which is less than the minimum of 2000 ms.

[Freedom]

Audio Lead-In
There is only 118 ms of audio lead-in, which is less than the minimum of 2000 ms.

Snapping

Unsnapped inherited (green) sections at:
00:13:796 - snap to 00:13:832 Fixed

[Hard]

Audio Lead-In
There is only 118 ms of audio lead-in, which is less than the minimum of 2000 ms.

[Insane]

Audio Lead-In
There is only 118 ms of audio lead-in, which is less than the minimum of 2000 ms.

[Normal]

Audio Lead-In
There is only 118 ms of audio lead-in, which is less than the minimum of 2000 ms.

Added some audio lead-in. It didn't make any difference tbh. But I still added them for the sake of it

I didnt see anything major, maybe i'm jsut bad after all anyway theres your mod
Sorry short mod

-[H13]- wrote:

Small mod, again ;/ Where did this mod even come from lol. You already modded my map and I didn't actually request you for a second mod

[General]
Add "aero chord" "klaypex" and "be free" for tags. I don't think song title and artist name is allowed in tags
Is the offset wrong for anyone else? Idk if it's just me or no one has noticed yet... offset should be 76 or something around that. Around 76 is too early. I changed to 90 and it sounds much better than the the current offset

[Freedom]
00:14:475 (3) - Too high imo. Recommended to move the whole triangle down. Done
00:20:475 (4,1) - I might be too picky for this one, but I think it'd be better if it were a slider. No change
00:25:832 (1,2) - ^^ Same as above
00:35:218 (3) - Too high imo, again. Just select 00:34:361 (1,2,3,4) and move it abit lower and I think you should be good. Done
00:41:218 (1,2) - The distance 1 - 2 is abit weird for the time given. For an almost 4.5 star map I would decrease the distance between the slider end and the next circle. It's a perfectly normal spacing for a 1/2 beat
00:48:504 (2) - You should move this down a bit. Down a bit
01:35:647 (5,6) - There I go being picky again. They look kinda ugly imo. Maybe change the slider vel for those 2 through the "Add Inheriting Section" setting. No change for this

All the mods for Freedom difficulty are pretty much suggestions, you don't need to use them all if you don't like them obviously.
The mods on "General", though, should be taken into consideration.