Natsu wrote:

SPOILER

Bakari wrote:

How did we come to the point when Normals can be mapped entirely in 1/2 while BPM is over 100? It's never been okay and should not be okay now. Singletapping 1/1 at the speed of 244 BPM wouldn't be allowed, this is pretty much the same and should never be allowed, too.

I feel this way and I personally don't want to tolerate this kind of Normals in Qualified/Ranked sections.

1/2 can and should be used here, but it doesn't mean that the entire thing has to use consistent 1/2 beat, leave that up to hards.

I think you really need to learn that normals aren't easy diffs, Normals are the middle point between hard and normal diff, New players play easy diffs advanced players play normal diffs, normal diffs are the jump to hard diffs (hard diffs usually even use 1/4 rhytms(, normal diffs like this one do a better transition than you Easy-normal diff, I don't get where you come from with this idea lately, but I really hope you don't force people in your way, if you think a normal diff should be mapped in a dirty ay with overlaped 1/2s and mostly 1/1 its fine, but this is your opinion, and if you notice the maps that usually follow your ¨normal diff theory¨ are the ones with poor spread. I saw a case from you yesterday at : p/4888410/

Please don't impose your thinking, if you really want to make this a rule then please open a discussion, the current normal diff is a true normal diff, overlaps make things confused.

Anyways the current spread its super balanced, why you want to add another diff?? to have a spread like 1--2--3-----4------5, current one its really balanced 1---2---3----4

really I want to talk about this, because I dont want to be mapping easy diffs as normals later...

Edit: beginners plays beginners diffs and eays diffs, normal diffs are for the players that want to go to the next step, playing constant 1/2s (at low bpm like this) its a must, or you want them to hit in the face when they meet jumps and 1/4s at hard diffs? because under your logic that what u will get bad balanced diffs

we did talk a bit more with Bakari on IRC and we come to the conclusion that making the non kiai parts less dense (not constant 1/2 rhythm) its the better option that you have here for normal diff, anyways gl with this

mgmn wrote:

Hey~
from my modding queue =D

Since you are a pretty skilled mapper with over 60 ranked maps, I don't think I can give you that many tips, but I try to do my best. (ง •̀_•́)ง

[Shad012ha's Easy]

Some obvious things
02:52:118 (4) - Checking AI mod, you can see, that the object end isn't snapped.

02:55:069 (3) - ^

Fix all

Things that could be changed

I'm not a good mapper, so I can't give a lot of tips '^^

The Kiai times on this difficulty are... special. Leaving a full beat gap between short Kiai times is a nice concept, as there isn't alot happening in the song at that time, but I think, that they could merge into three big Kiai times.
Just to make it simpler. but hey what do I know lol

00:39:702 - That jumpscare in the SB.
Maybe an epilepsy warning?
oh yes！
I'm not a big hitsounding pro, but I think, that if you raise the volume of the hitsounds during the Kiai times could make the map sound better.

And yea. That's it. Pretty flawless difficulty. Great job!

[Normal]

Some obvious things
There aren't unsnapped objects this time, so that is a nice thing.

Things that could be changed

Hitsounds are all really nice.

Kiai times are still like in the Easy diff. Playing with Storyboard enabled and Background to around 85% gave me a headache after playing the map two times, so please put the epilepsy warning in the beginning. c:

adjust some
I couldn't really find alot of things that should/could be changed.
Really nice map!

Naotoshi wrote:

why anime bg.. -_-

snow theme skin make no sense, this song is not about snow...? i think you could just delete it lol fix~

[insane]
00:23:472 (3,4) - ctrl g makes more sense? cuz there is a rly loud drum sound there and nothing on 00:23:718 (4) -

01:16:587 (2,3) - actual triple here could be nicer

01:28:390 (4,1) - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8970949 this rhythm makes a lot more sense to follow the drums

01:49:292 (4) - making clickable triple could be nicer cuz it is 2 vocals?

02:48:308 (1,2) - ctrl g rhythm? fits drum better

03:04:906 (1,1) - i wish you could do something more interesting here ;w;(　´_ゝ｀) sorry this what I can do best.............
fix all
[hard]
01:20:522 (4,5,6) - spacing seems suddenly very big

01:24:456 (5,6,7) - same

03:17:570 (1,2) - nc here on 2 seems better..hmmm personally I dont really like one color overlap another color so...

nice diff

[easy]
Shad012 told me I can help him to change so...
00:28:390 (2) - 1/1 repeat?
for vocal

01:09:210 (4,5) - plz blanket ;w; ...I try my best ;-;！！！！

01:13:145 (1) - all other diff have break here, i know it's shadowland part but still, following other diffs should be break here imo
cause it was shown be tooooooooo short when I add break on here...and it may because the low sv
check aimod, unsnap + some minor easy DS issuefix all

Naotoshi wrote:

hm

look fine, except
01:28:390 (4) - this rhythm, i suggest circle on white tick then slider start on blue tick. since there's a double in the drum, like at 00:23:472 (3,4) -


also, you could add "shadowland" and "beren" to tags

Beren wrote:

ヽ(*´Д｀*)ﾉ