Column :
|1|2|3|4|

Sarahkuai wrote:

FROM THIS THREAD

Column :
|1|2|3|4|

HD

00:00:732 (732|3,832|2) - CTRL + J changed it with column 2 instead
00:13:932 (13932|0,14032|1) - ^ if I did that I'd have 00:13:732 (13732|3,13832|2,13932|1,14032|0) - implying the sound was descending when instead it's actually ascending, represented by 00:13:632 (13632|0,13732|1,13832|2,13932|0,14032|1) -
01:06:532 (66532|1) - move to column 4 (plz don't make chord pattern like, not suitable with the pitch 01:05:632 (65632|0,65632|1,65932|0,65932|1,66232|1,66232|0,66532|1,66532|0) - ) sure
01:09:232 - add 1 note done

overall I don't really see much problems.
well that's all I can do, feel free to reject
GL https://puu.sh/whYom/8a17f24c75.rar

Blocko wrote:

henlo good morning

Using 4K columns: 1|2|3|4

----------

[Hydria's HD]
00:54:632 (54632|2,54832|0) - Rearrange this to 1, 2 respectively. The pitch on 00:53:332 (53332|2,53432|2) - is different from the one at 00:54:532 (54532|2,54632|2) - , so do this suggestion if you want to apply some pitch relevance (and avoid a bit of right hand bias). gonna change it to 4, 1 since I feel that is a better representation of the pitch as shown here (sorry the hand bias is staying for now):


01:09:832 (69832|2) - Move to 4 to give more impact on the ending. Using outer columns puts more emphasis on the chords imo that's fine, done slight pattern readjustment to compensate

---------- https://my.mixtape.moe/kmtazj.rar

Feerum wrote:

Random Mod


Column: | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | cool column 8
======================================================
Red means Unrankable stuff
Big means Important stuff
Normal are Suggestions
// means comments
======================================================

Hello Raveille & Hydria o/
I'm here to check this Map from a Featured Artist. If it's good enough i gonna give it a nomination! oh no
Let's see! don't look

General

Artist: Correct
Title: Correct
Source: Correct
Tags: Maybe add "8-bit" and "8 bit". Some kind of Tags most of Chiptune maps has! rip 16 bit
AiMod: Correct
Background: Cool BG
BPM/Offset: Correct
mp3/Hitsounds: Correct
Other: - same

Hydria's MX

00:04:232 (4232|1) - Would suggest to move it to 1. Feels better and removes 00:04:032 (4032|1,4232|1,4432|1) - . rearranged for PR

00:25:832 (25832|1) - Same goes for this one. sure

00:47:032 (47032|2,47132|2) - Would it be possible to move this jack to the left hand? I missed exactly here. The only one miss at my 2nd and 3rd testplay because of the transition to 00:47:332 (47332|3,47432|3) - is urgh. re-arranged

That's all for Hydria's diff. Pretty cool and challenging difficulty! thanks it's like im experienced or something

Lé Starred don't insult my french heritage






https://my.mixtape.moe/wyzgqk.rar

Feerum wrote:

Random Mod


Column: | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 |
======================================================
Red means Unrankable stuff
Big means Important stuff
Normal are Suggestions
// means comments
======================================================

Hello Raveille & Hydria
I'm here to check this Map from a Featured Artist. If it's good enough i gonna give it a nomination!
Let's see!

General

Artist: Correct
Title: Correct
Source: Correct
Tags: Maybe add "8-bit" and "8 bit". Some kind of Tags most of Chiptune maps has! Dank!
AiMod: Correct
Background: Cool BG
BPM/Offset: Correct
mp3/Hitsounds: Correct
Other: -

EZ

Sooooo. The easy looks overall pretty solid but i'm a bit in doubt of the 1/3 usage here over the whole difficulty. I asked player to test it for me, beginner player, all below 100pp, and they got pretty.. well.. see by yourself:

Score Screens

Okay, these are only two but it gives you a look at how they think about this Map. Maybe it's just my personal preference but such a hard 1/3 usage, especially on 200BPM is really.. not what an Easy should have. I mean if this would be a Normal i wouldn't say a word but please reconsider making it more simple.
Even when the 1/3 Pattern are mapped in a very comfortable way (played with both hands) pattern like 00:00:732 (732|1,832|0) - 00:03:132 (3132|1,3232|0) - and 00:10:332 (10332|2,10432|3) - did make them miss and/or give a 100/200 scoring.
Finger independence is something most of newbie's doesn't have and need to learn.
I mean i don't assume that beginner can S this map immediately, don't get me wrong.

A good solution for this case would be. Go and ask several beginner player to testplay this too. Ask them if they find this fun or maybe too hard. If these player tell you that these pattern are fine to play and make fun, i don't see a reason to change it. If the majority say's it's too hard then you probably know what to do

Another solution would be to add an even easier diff. One which doesn't use any kind of 1/3 pattern. To have a good spread from "No 1/3" to "Some 1/3" to "More 1/3" and "Full of 1/3"

OKAY Now to modding:
After looking several times over the Easy.. nothing more to say xD

I did remove all the 1/3s but added some double notes to make it a little more challenging in the kiai.

NM

00:16:632 - I think you have here a missing note. According to 00:07:032 - added
00:38:232 - Same goes for here. Or was 00:07:032 (7032|1) - wrong and should get deleted? Both ways are fine. added again mm

00:40:432 (40432|3) - Consider to split this into two LN's. You did that even in the Easy. aight

00:56:632 - I am a bit in worry this stream could cause spread problems.. a normal already with such a long 1/3 stream.. mh.. changed to a kinda LN to mini stream patterning

But overall that's all here

HD

The hard looks for me fine too. Nothing really where i would say it's too hard or must be changed. Spread to Normal is good too.

That's all. As i said. I have a problem with the 1/3 pattern usage in Easy difficulty. I mean it's not bad at all.. but ya' know.. it shall be for beginner. In my eyes the best of these solutions would be kinda to add another even easier diff with no 1/3 pattern at all.

Let me know what you think about it!
Lé Starred

Feerum wrote:

Thanks for the reply.
Now i'm happy with the EZ. Yay.

There you go: Bubbled

riunosk wrote:

hey its your boi l8m828 also known as

hydera

just wanted to point out quick things

1. 00:03:232 - seems to be slightly left hand biased here completely intentional
2. 00:05:332 (5332|2,5532|2,5732|2,5932|2) - anchor? fixed
3. 00:07:432 - quite the bias on col 1 2 and 3, col 4 seems pretty lonely song is decreasing in pitch
4. 00:13:432 (13432|2,13632|2,13832|2,14032|2) - anchor? not much you can do based around the patterning choice to fix that without ruining PR
5. 00:15:232 (15232|2,15432|2,15632|2,15832|2) - ^ changed anchor placement
6. 00:18:432 (18432|2,18632|2,18832|2,19032|2,19232|2) - ^ better than the OH trill that would be it's replacement (i tried)
7. 00:21:032 (21032|1,21132|2,21232|1,21332|2,21432|1,21532|2,21632|1,21732|2) - doesn't really seem fitting 00:20:032 (20032|1,20132|2,20232|1,20332|3,20432|2,20532|1,20632|2,20732|1,20832|0,20932|3,21032|1,21132|2,21232|1,21332|2,21432|1,21532|0,21632|1,21732|2,21832|3) - totally unintentional but it seems fine
8. 00:56:732 (56732|0,56832|1,56932|0,57032|0) - seems to be in a continuous motion and doesn't really fit with your jacking patterns? you got me there

owo.osu

Critical_Star wrote:

I'm back from vacation lets do this

Hydria's MX
00:04:832 (4832|3,4932|0) - try LN here to cover this part? or maybe leave a break. it is just snare stream and i suggest to break it here so that player could differentiate the stream sound better start at 00:05:032 - changed and fixed consistency issues
00:26:432 (26432|2,26532|1) - 01:04:832 (64832|2,64932|1) - same here if you agree same
00:35:532 (35532|1,35532|0) - inconsistent with 00:13:932 (13932|0) - stylistic choice (different pitches)





u wu