I don't like the idea of No-Lynching D1. Seems we learned nothing the whole day.
@Abraker: please use preview on your posts for correct formatting ;_;
I'm keeping my vote on Hika because I still think it's the best candidate for a D1 lynch. I haven't done anything "game-changing" because so far I am not sure on my reads and I don't want to mess up this early. I would agree with a foxtrot lynch too.
I do find interesting how Ace still hasn't cleared this up, and that goes along with the "care-free" attitude I mentioned in my reads - scum players often try to clear themselves up of any suspicion.abraker wrote:
Perhaps. It bothers me like a needle poking at skin.Zexion wrote:
About Ace: Okay, but that's just your interpretation. Maybe you're just exaggerating.
@Abraker: please use preview on your posts for correct formatting ;_;
I don't think activity is that good of an indicator. Scum could try to be overly active in order to make themselves town leaders and go for lynching strong talkers or the like.abraker wrote:
Zexion Q&AJust like how Ace kept the vote on Hika even though he read her as town. Though I should ask, for what reason did you keep your vote for?
Reaction testing. No one followed up sadly. I was hoping to get direct opinions on Hika's playstyle.
You saying that Dawnsday is over-analyzing comes with a negative connotation indicating he is doing something wrong. Dawsday's conclusion was that Lincolm's color thing was a flawed attempt. If you agreed that it is a flawed attempt, then why bother indicating he is doing something wrong? He could have said that the analysis if bs, but he agrees that it was flawed. Therefore, I have reason to believe Zexion thinks Lincolm's color thing has some meaning. So it's contradiction in belief or zexion didn't bother interpreting the entire thing and just picked the strongest bit of it to comment upon.
I meant what I meant. I don't see why is this relevant at all.
To quote someone who later said, "These kind of posts make me wonder how to reply. I understand having a busy life, but it's better just to say "prod dodge" rather than repeating stuff, trust me, it goes a long way in mafia games." Other than that, I am scratching my head on why he thinks zekks's dumb actions are more important than my self vote.
I was actually criticizing the people who strongly town-read you despite your self-vote by those comments. (IIRC John did that, Dawnsday too I think) Zekks' claim was by far a stronger issue, and we already discussed why was that.
null, cleared misunderstanding, but then in regards to going all the way to the end with the self-vote. What does that make me now? Also concerning the last bit where you asked questions to John and Dawn, your ISO shows little content due to your inactivity. Why should I think you are town?
Zexion like to contradict himself a lot, though it's not necessarily indicative of scum behavior. I feel he is helplessly stepping on landmines as he struggles with irl stuff.
I'm not saying you should town-read me for all my posts, what I'm saying is that it's just a lazy excuse not to read me at all. I would totally understand if I only had like 5 posts overall or if all of them were fluff, but (I think) they're not. Real life is OP.
To answer the first part directed toward me, these is just my analysis on individual's actions and my thoughts on their possible thoughts. I will definitely be going back to my ISOs for even deeper analysis of possible player-player interactions. It's hard to do those if you don't have a concentrated ISO to work with since piecing together scattered info is a nightmare.
Second part I know isn't sarcasm and is legit. Hika did accidentally vote causing a town lynch. This is why my suspicion is more on Ace than it is on Hika.
Though, Hika, I am trying to find that game to prove it and can't find it. I vaguely recall it had to do you lynching Jesse, but I am not sure if I am mixing stuff up. Maybe you can find?
Reads make sense
I don't 100% agree with your methods but I'm replying anyways because I value your effort in making these deep analysis.
To summarize my thoughts, zexion def shows his experience in his posts and comes on to make good points. He doesn't seem to be moving the game forward into any biased direction, questioning only scratches the surface and lets others to further mine them down. If what Ace is true, and that he can be as inactive as scum, this is really an issue.
I'm keeping my vote on Hika because I still think it's the best candidate for a D1 lynch. I haven't done anything "game-changing" because so far I am not sure on my reads and I don't want to mess up this early. I would agree with a foxtrot lynch too.