forum

Ichiko - I Say Yes

posted
Total Posts
19
Topic Starter
Kamushi
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
Card N'FoRcE
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
DawnII
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
minyeob
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
Card N'FoRcE
Ok, re-checked.

- Normal:
00:40:75 (6,7,8,9) - not sure about this overlapping. Ask a BAT.
01:15:23 (7) - it's too far.
02:06:25 (4) - make it a little closer to the end of the previous slider.
02:15:59 (3) - two squares to the right (use grid level 3)
02:17:75 (7,8,9) - one square to the left and fix spacing, because there's too much between them.
02:23:49 (1,2,3) - fix spacing here as well.
02:25:65 (4,5,6,1,2,3,1,2,3,4,5,6) - fix spacing for all.

- Hard:
01:17:93 (1,2) - make them closer
01:19:91 (7,8,9,10) - increase spacing here. This really confused me.
01:52:42 (7) - closer to the 6. Right now it seems spaced like 5-6 and it's wrong.
02:19:90 (1) - closer to the 17
DawnII
[Normal]
00:40:75 (6,7) - Too far apart.
00:42:90 (9) - Too far from 8, move 1 grid to left (grid lvl 1).
02:12:72 (1) - Too close to (2).
02:19:18 (10) - Too close to (9).

[Hard]
00:57:996 - A short break would look nice here.
01:02:66 (2) - Too far from (1).
01:06:61 (7) - Too close to (6).
01:10:92 (9) - Too far from (8).
01:14:16 (6,7) - Not a fan of this but you can leave it like this to trip people up.
01:19:91 (7) - Too far from (6).

I'd also like to see more use of hitsounds.
Card N'FoRcE
- Normal:
02:30:68 (7) - move it farther

- Hard:
00:59:43 (1) - make this spinner end at the white line, because it ends a little before XD
01:20:98 (10) - [nazi] move 1 square (grid lv3) to the left.
02:24:93 (1,2,1,2,1) - can you space this last part better? you have all the grid available XD
02:30:50 (1) - make this finish 2/1 later or before. your choice. This way it sounds better.

Can't see any major problems anymore :)
Mogsy
Renumbered both difficulties. So far, I am in the process of modding many other maps, but expect a mod post up later. For now, here's the renumbering.

Just to say, before I make the post: Normal needs a lot of work, IMO.

Download: Ichiko - I Say Yes (Kamyk666) [Hard].osu

Download: Ichiko - I Say Yes (Kamyk666) [Normal].osu
Topic Starter
Kamushi
So... You think the normal should be easy and hard should be normal? It can be... Now i must make a hard and insane difficult. No... I'll make only Hard one :p xD
awp
Yeah, timing's best at 83.5 (or doubled) - right now it's 83.507. I thought Offset was closer to 1960, but osu! reported approximately 6 to 8 seconds late on average, so I take it I'm just wrong - it is better at 1953 where it's more timed to the vocals, which is what the song is timed to anyway.

I thought something was off on Easy, but I reviewed it - I'm just dumb.

Anyhow, I have to agree - Normal was awfully quick for "Normal" and should probably be renamed to Hard. Easy was still pretty easy though - I'm not as eager to see that renamed. If you're doing one more difficulty, fire away - these ones look good.
awp
Time for nitpicks

[Easy]
First off, it needs to be re-snapped after the BPM change. Timing > Resnap all notes at 1/2 or 1/4 divisor should be fine.

00:25:67 (2) - I think this actually sounds better ending a quarter beat later at 27287ms
00:41:11 (7) - The flow feels a bit broken here. Would 00:41:48 sound better?

[Hard]
Again, resnap all notes at 1/4 snap divisor

00:46:33 (3,4) - I can't really say this is wrong, but I think it flows better if you shift these two notes to the right 1/4 beat to 46:51 and 46:87.
02:06:81 (4) - I think this note is supposed to extend to the quarter beat at 2:07:528

Good work, though. Very good work.
Zephyra_old
WOW! nicely done! i really like zero no tsukaima but was pretty dissapointed with the 3rd season... anyways hope more songs are gonna come from u!

Zephyra
awp
Okay you're gonna hate me but I got the wrong offset. 1960 is definitely too early - it should be about 1971. I've tested it rigorously and 1971 feels a bit better.

That's my only nitpick. Meaning the maps look good and you have me to blame for delaying the bubble~
awp
Well, that's all I can do for you - I think it's rankable so bubble away~

EDIT: Oh whups I missed something: you need to resnap all notes.

Select a beat snap divisor of 1/4 and select Timing - Resnap all notes. I think you gotta do it on both difficulties, but Hard for sure.
awp
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
Topic Starter
Kamushi
What you mean? xD
awp
It's part of the ranking process. When a BAT bubbles something, it means they find it OK for ranking. To have the map ranked, another BAT must then also approve of it.

So, think of the bubble as a possible half-rank. But if another mod has problems, they can pop the bubble.
CheeseWarlock
I could complain about hitsounds. Or I could just rank this. I choose the latter. I'm not completely cruel, after all.
ThePassingShadow
Suggested offset of -20 ms.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply