Kytoxid wrote:

[General]

00:51:002 - Personally, I couldn't read this at all; a bit too dark; blended too well and flashed too quickly. Plus, there are no kawaii jumps on Tiny Dream. This actually wasn't really done yet; it was fixed already.

[Tiny Dream] As it was stated, Tiny Dream isn't done yet.

Consider increasing circle size. Done

00:20:039 (1,1,2,3) - A few too many finishes here. Fixed

Remove the excess timing sections after the end if you'd like. It will go through the whole map. There won't be any excess timing sections.

[Dreamer]

00:02:084 (5,5) - Don't like the slider ticks very much. =/ It was bothering me too, btw. Fixed.
00:37:041 (2) - Very hard to see that this is a slider. Fixed
01:13:095 (1) - Consider mapping this spinner, and instead putting one on the fade-out; it sounds a bit weird right now, although it's okay. Fixed

[Mafiamaster's Nightmare] (not a very nightmare-ish song. XD)

00:42:006 (6) - Didn't like the looks of this slider.

Warning SB isn't late, of course it's not. I crashed and burned there, but it's fun.

Star~

EEeee wrote:

Roxkyuubi's Illusion
01:11:094 (1) - a bit hard to see where it stars, is there a way to separate the start and end point? Fixed~

DJPop wrote:

~Roxkyuubi's Illusion~
01:07:066 (1) - start on white tick Not really my style but did it ^^
01:10:053 (1) - not recommend for spinner here Ok. Made a spinner here =/

1. Offset 1950

1. Awesome~

1. 01:07:014 (1) - Remove new combo (?)

1. 01:05:054 - Why is that arrow here (?) It's really not necessary at all.

Shinxyn wrote:

omfg, holy crap, the video quality is awesome >:
Lol, I got tricked by the very first second of the video, IT LOOKS LIKE A SPINNER!! D:!

Tiny Dreamer-
Okay, since I see no -problems-, I'm ganna ultra nazi

SPOILER

00:16:279 (6) - disagree with this whistle, I prefer if the vocal was brought out more than the hitsound, remove? (maybe add a whistle to the end of 5's slider though)
00:20:041 (3) - finish hitsound too strong on this part, whistle works here >:
00:22:548 - ^
00:27:205 (4) - same as 16:279
00:28:997 - remove whistle here, it kinda interferes with the sound in the music 1/2 later >:
00:37:057 (1,2) - take out one or two whistles here please? (I was thinking just 00:38:132's)
00:56:402 (1) - sooo why no hitsounds when the music got a bit more intense? >:
00:59:089 (1) - ^
01:07:507 (1) - remove finish plz
01:10:373 (3) - ^

Fake Dreamer o-o Pink jumps warning...

SPOILER

00:28:817 (4) - down one tick,00:28:997 (5) - down two ticks... or is the spacing supposed to get closer...? >:
01:03:387 (2) - this was the only slider-slide-whistle I heard (in this diff), please remove
Hmm... xD the rest of the hitsounds sound fine to me

Roxkyuubi's-

SPOILER

00:06:786 (5,6) - this part would sound better (and for me, play better) if it sounded like 00:03:920 (5,6,7)'s
01:07:149 (1,2) - .... finish+whistle? sounds kinda... strong >: (try having just whistle on 1, and just finish on 2?)
01:10:015 (1,2) - ^?
I think you used a bit too much whistles before the music picked up... >:

Mafiamaster's-

SPOILER

;_; were there this many whistles before... oh well....
00:47:088 (7) - new combo please
00:49:954 (7) - ^
00:52:103 (1) - ^
00:58:730 (3) - mmm wouldn't this sound better if it was 1/2 shorter? (judging from your hitsound usage)
RAWRRRRR THE LAST "note" IS A LIEEEEEE (I still spun ) darn video >_>

*cough* horrible mod *cough*

Oh yea, remove "star.png", it doesn't do anything for beatmap skin

haisha_ wrote:

:)

: i dunno why, it feels weird for me.. it doesn't seem off but it still feels ORZ ;_; I already gave up. It's too erratic lol
Tiny:
00:21:474 [2,3] just move it up one tiny square... Fixed
01:01:775 [2,3] two tiny squares to the left please >_< Fixed

Illusion:
00:46:550 [8] wanna add a new combo? up to you.. Not Fixed
00:49:416 [8] ^ Fixed
00:54:611 [7] new combo Fixed
00:54:790 [1] no new combo Fixed
00:58:014 [8] new combo? up to you\ Not Fixed

Star ~ Thanks

Sushi971 wrote:

[Tiny Dream]
00:27:205 (4) - move 1 grid up and left for it to look nicer. Fixed
00:33:295 (7) - move 1 grid up. follows pattern. Fixed

[Fake Dreamer]
00:25:593 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - if that was supposed to be symetric, you missed it. Fixed
01:12:343 (2,5) - nazi symetry. Fixed

[Roxkyuubi's]
Fine~

[Mafia's]
Fine!

You have my star. Thanks

woodrockman wrote:

I made this as taiko map.
Can you include this in the beatmap set?

With your permission, i will upload the osu file. XD



This is my map.
http://www.mediafire.com/?d0jzd4yknwv

Paulo8624 wrote:

woodrockman wrote:
Really long post


Sorry, this map already has too many diffs, and I don't think this music needs a taiko-only map. Maybe consider uploading one on your own.

Lokamp wrote:

Tiny Dream
00:16:279 (6) - for an Easy mode, this beat can be quite tricky... remove it, please. Fixed
00:26:668 (3) - no whistle on this slider's start Fixed

Fake Dreamer
That was sweet! Thanks ;*

rohkyuubi's Illusion
Very nice Thanks ;*

Mafiamaster's Nightmares
Except for some strange hitsounds choises, it'r really good! Thanks ;*

The skin was really awesome, just as the guest modes! One last thing, before starring:

Paulo8624 wrote:

woodrockman wrote:
Really long post

Sorry, this map already has too many diffs, and I don't think this music needs a taiko-only map. Maybe consider uploading one on your own.

...Listen, I don't think that 5 modes in a map are borderline... Beatmap Approval Team members are usually against 6+ modes map.
I've anyways checked woodrockman's mode and I partially agree with you: the chorus itself is really funny, but for the previous part playing can't be as funny as the other modes due to rapid BPM even before the kiai time...
Apart that, the Taiko mode is really well done. If you change your mind about that mode or something else tell me that, ok? Okay, after a second look, I added wood's Taiko mode.

MarioBros777 wrote:

Modding a map that I should have done years ago.

*sigh*

Seriously, that Taiko diff is awesome. woodrockman does a lot of good maps and 6+ IS the actual limit of how many difficulties a ranked map should have. Though it is very...frowned upon...having 5 difficulties but I'm not going to stop you either way. Personally, I think the Taiko difficulty should be added. Look up there.

If I were to say a difficulty that was the most fun to play, I would say Fake Dreamer would be. Thanks! *-*

Nevertheless, here is the actual modding.

Do you really need "Card Captor Sakura" as the tag? It's already in the source. Fixed

[Tiny Dreamer]

01:07:32 (2) - Remove hitcircle...possibly... Hm, I don't think so. It really fits, like, "Ki-i-tooooo"~

[Fake Dreamer]

01:07:32 (2) - Same as Tiny Dream Same as Tiny Dream

[Roxky's Illusion]

Rokyubbi technically had jumps at 01:03:20. So you might want to put the "Jumps Ahead" SB Added

01:05:89 (3,4) - Whistles could be used here. (Just the start of 4.) Fixed

[Mafiamaster's Nightmare]

What a way to break the mood, Mafiamaster. Is that good or bad? ><"

01:17:35 (6) - Add whistle? Added

I'll get back to this.

Lokamp wrote:

The image below is self-explanatory.
Aim for the rank, skilled mapper!

VanMoNky wrote:

As Lokamp's request.

Read this first for the icon explanation.
- [?] Asking for a second thought.
- [!] Fatal error. You have to fix this for sure.
- [No icon] Only a suggestion.

[General]
1. Lowercase all tags. Remove "anime" from tags since you can set this map's genre to anime song. Fixed
2. The maximum size of comboburst is 500x768 but your comboburst is 550x768. Fix this. [!] Was it REALLY needed? Just 50px... but fine, fixed.
3. I love Sakura! My favorite anime when I was a child. Yeah, mine too
4. Are you sure about the timing? The BPM is rather odd. It should be 167.50. Idk. Don't mind it. This is best guess I could find, though

[Tiny Dream]
00:16:637 - Mind if I ask you to add break here? Fixed
00:21:832 (3) - Distance error. Fixed
00:22:906 - Mind if I ask you to add break here? Fixed

[Fake Dreamer]
00:16:637 - Mind if I ask you to add break here? Fixed
00:22:906 - ^ Fixed

[Wood's Taiko Hope]
Nice.

[Roxkyuubi's Illusion]
No problem.

[Mafiamaster's Nightmares]
00:54:611 (1) - I hate such this pattern. It looks like 1/2 stream for me. Is it just me or what? Hm. Any suggestion? I think it's fine, to be honest
01:13:956 (1,2) - Swap the combo. Fixed

Star. But I have to pop out the bubble due to the unrankable comboburst. Call me back for pubble after you confirm this mod. Okay ;D

Was it REALLY needed? Just 50px... but fine, fixed.

Hm. Any suggestion? I think it's fine, to be honest.

Astom wrote:

[General]
-Run AIMod

Star

Sakura301 wrote:

ok let's see

[Tiny Dream]
Yay finally someone with an Easy diff that i dont feel like falling asleep on I should learn to make better Easies myself :< thanks

[Fake Dreamer]
00:50:670 The jump warning appears too far away from the play zone and it's too small, i didnt see it :< http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8413 also why do you need a jump warning? the star pattern is a pretty normal pattern imho Fixed. Made ir appear before, and i'm keeping the warning just to be safe =p
01:10:910 I did see this warning, however i could barely read it, it appears for too short time then rolls, until like the jumps appear? http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8414 Fixed. Doesn't roll anymore, and appears a little earlier.

[Wood's Taiko Hope]
Fine Thanks =]
(wait did i just mod a Taiko diff?)

[Roxkyuubi's Illusion]
01:02:671 - Is there any point in SBing a jump warning? a Hard diff is supposed to have jumps anyways, and there were jumps earlier that werent SBed and i could read em perfectly as well Removed =]

[Mafiamaster's Nightmares]
Spooky name o.o hehehe like always mafiamaster's maps are awesome, good job

Wee really nice map, Good job! +Double Star! Good Luck!~ Thanks ^^

Paulo8624 wrote:

Sorry if anyone was STILL waiting for this to be ranked. This has been a REALLY busy semester at school.
However, my classes end @ 26/11, then I will be able to get back to work on this.
I really appreciate if you are still visiting this thread. :]