Guest
home
beatmaps
rankings
community
store
help
forum
  1. Forums
  2. Other
  3. Otaku Culture

Manga Suggestion Thread

posted
Total Posts
308
show more
Green Platinum
2,660 posts
Joined July 2011
Green Platinum
Well that just comes with the change in medium. Whether the live-action is incredible or not that doesn't change the anime (so what does quality drop have to do with anything?)
I'd rather see companies making a risk adapting something of actual entertainment value rather than stick with the generic safe option for the 99th time.
Liiraye
1,354 posts
Joined December 2011
Liiraye
Like I said, other discussion. However, if they would go all out I'm fine with it, but looking at the history of adaptations they seldom do. Adaptations often cut corners in obvious places and just makes one cringe. I surely hope it won't be a low budget film if anything...
Green Platinum
2,660 posts
Joined July 2011
Green Platinum
I don't think I need to tell you that Chihaafuru is a adaption.I'd rather actually see the film before I make any claims about it cutting corners but the series is award winning and popular, doesn't need much of a FX budget and has a small cast are all factors that work in this films favour.
dartmonkey4
35 posts
Joined July 2014
dartmonkey4
Kimi wa Midara na Boku no Joou is pretty nice.
I read it for the 'story' ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
Negi
8 posts
Joined July 2015
Negi
I'm not searching for a suggestion but I'm here to suggest a title "UQ Holder"
Genre: Shounen, Action, Supernatural
Status: Ongoing
MAL: http://myanimelist.net/manga/57765/UQ_Holder!
Give it a try!
Ochinchi-sama
178 posts
Joined April 2015
Ochinchi-sama
If you're into harem ecchi shit and you're a perverted old neckbeard I suggest you read 'Minamoto-kun Monogatari'.

It's about a pretty-faced dude who lives with his hot aunt. He is trying to conquer his fear of girls because he was bullied a lot in junior-high cos the girls were jealous of his looks.

His aunt is obsessed with 'the tale of genji', the story of a pretty-faced prince who banged 14 different women. The dude reminds his aunt of genji because of his feminine beauty. To help the MC conquer his fear of girls, the aunt is trying to reenact the tale of genji by getting him laid with 14 different women.

-Not for kids.
-Ongoing.
-Go fuck yourself you creeps.
Raiken-
632 posts
Joined June 2013
Raiken-
Suggest me a good romance manga with a nice art
AznRice
7 posts
Joined August 2013
AznRice

Raiken- wrote:

Suggest me a good romance manga with a nice art
Taiyou no Ie
Nisekoi
Saenai Kanojo no Sodatekata

Ecchi Romance:

Domestic na Kanojo
Re:Marina
Monster Musume (Rom-Com with ecchi)
Kurochiie
754 posts
Joined April 2014
Kurochiie
Are you guys into gore mangas?
Check these out. You guys should try these:

Mahou Shoujo of the End
Dolly Kill Kill
Ajin
Meikyuuiri Tsumi
382 posts
Joined July 2010
Meikyuuiri Tsumi
I'm also going to suggest something.

Densha Otoko

It's actually a very lovely romance manga. Give it a try, you'll see for yourself.
Kyozoru
334 posts
Joined August 2015
Kyozoru
Haikyuu Second season
Ochinchi-sama
178 posts
Joined April 2015
Ochinchi-sama
Something that would make me mentally unstable? Something that will give me da good ol' PTSD. It can be a psychological horror or something so depressing that it could make you want to kill yourself. I'd prefer the latter at the moment but a recommendation for the former would be appreciated as well. Also, no one-shots. Read too many of those.
Come[Back]Home
1,790 posts
Joined October 2011
Come[Back]Home
Well, i bought "The Breaker" and "The Breaker New Waves" and i must say its fucking awesome!!!
The fights are drawn so well, and the character development is fucking cool!
I recommend it to everyone who likes Action, Martial Arts and a main character who'll kick ass when its needed!!!
_mortis
10 posts
Joined December 2015
_mortis

Ochinchi-sama wrote:

Something that would make me mentally unstable? Something that will give me da good ol' PTSD. It can be a psychological horror or something so depressing that it could make you want to kill yourself. I'd prefer the latter at the moment but a recommendation for the former would be appreciated as well. Also, no one-shots. Read too many of those.
Same.
Senia-
30 posts
Joined October 2013
Senia-

_mortis wrote:

Ochinchi-sama wrote:

Something that would make me mentally unstable? Something that will give me da good ol' PTSD. It can be a psychological horror or something so depressing that it could make you want to kill yourself. I'd prefer the latter at the moment but a recommendation for the former would be appreciated as well. Also, no one-shots. Read too many of those.
Same.
Maybe
This
Works
TehDanimal
3 posts
Joined March 2015
TehDanimal
Anyone reading ReLIFE? I love the concept of it. It also tackles slice of life by establishing harsh realities and relationship scenarios that exist in Japanese society. Dark depression, suicide, loneliness, jealousy, stoicism, injustice, sexism, etc. I love reflecting on slice of life manga but it may not be for everyone. Hopefully, there are individuals who can share in my joy for ReLIFE. Definitely not for the faint of heart. It's manga that's in full color too which is quite rare; colors may seem a bit flat and dull in some chapters but I think it reflects each scene's tone well. What do you guys think?
chaee
chaee

Ochinchi-sama wrote:

Something that would make me mentally unstable? Something that will give me da good ol' PTSD. It can be a psychological horror or something so depressing that it could make you want to kill yourself. I'd prefer the latter at the moment but a recommendation for the former would be appreciated as well. Also, no one-shots. Read too many of those.
Fuck man
Aomi
1,993 posts
Joined August 2013
Aomi
I probably read like only one manga that wasn't even finished so I'm new to all this.

I'd like some good manga recommendations for the horror/romance/drama genre; thanks.
Sallad4ever
2,917 posts
Joined October 2009
Sallad4ever

Aomi wrote:

I probably read like only one manga that wasn't even finished so I'm new to all this.

I'd like some good manga recommendations for the horror/romance/drama genre; thanks.
There are many title already recommended by previous poster on this thread, so I'll just add a bit

For Horror try Hepatica, it's not a supernatural one so there won't be any ghost or some kind also It's already completed. Hi score girl is a unique one for a romance. The way it use classic games as one of the element of the story is awesome, provided you like games though.

Warning though, both of them have a rather "unique" art so try not to have high expectation on that part. (The story is still good though)
Kafein_old_1
Kafein_old_1
Need some romance manga with a male point of view (basically shounen or seinen). I'd really like it if the story has a bit of realistic touch to it, meaning no "stunningly hot/cute girls fall in love with loser MC for no apparent reason" or other stuff like that. Main examples of what I want are Kimi no Iru Machi, Good Ending, and Bitter Virgin.

Here's my MAL for the list of manga I've already read: http://myanimelist.net/mangalist/fatal_tragedy



Also accepting yuri suggestions if you know some. hahahaha
TehDanimal
3 posts
Joined March 2015
TehDanimal

lynyrd47 wrote:

Need some romance manga with a male point of view (basically shounen or seinen). I'd really like it if the story has a bit of realistic touch to it, meaning no "stunningly hot/cute girls fall in love with loser MC for no apparent reason" or other stuff like that. Main examples of what I want are Kimi no Iru Machi, Good Ending, and Bitter Virgin.

Here's my MAL for the list of manga I've already read: http://myanimelist.net/mangalist/fatal_tragedy



Also accepting yuri suggestions if you know some. hahahaha

Good Ending was really good. Have you read Citrus yet? It's a good yuri title imho.
Kafein_old_1
Kafein_old_1

TehDanimal wrote:

lynyrd47 wrote:

Need some romance manga with a male point of view (basically shounen or seinen). I'd really like it if the story has a bit of realistic touch to it, meaning no "stunningly hot/cute girls fall in love with loser MC for no apparent reason" or other stuff like that. Main examples of what I want are Kimi no Iru Machi, Good Ending, and Bitter Virgin.

Here's my MAL for the list of manga I've already read: http://myanimelist.net/mangalist/fatal_tragedy



Also accepting yuri suggestions if you know some. hahahaha

Good Ending was really good. Have you read Citrus yet? It's a good yuri title imho.
I have but I think it's still currently publishing. I want titles that are already finished so I can binge-read them from start to finish. :lol:
aynoz
34 posts
Joined February 2014
aynoz

lynyrd47 wrote:

Need some romance manga with a male point of view (basically shounen or seinen). I'd really like it if the story has a bit of realistic touch to it, meaning no "stunningly hot/cute girls fall in love with loser MC for no apparent reason" or other stuff like that. Main examples of what I want are Kimi no Iru Machi, Good Ending, and Bitter Virgin.

Here's my MAL for the list of manga I've already read: http://myanimelist.net/mangalist/fatal_tragedy



Also accepting yuri suggestions if you know some. hahahaha
I think Domestic na kanojo might suit your taste.
Bitari_old
Bitari_old
Anyone reading "Their Story" :?:
Rurree
1,291 posts
Joined June 2014
Rurree

lynyrd47 wrote:

Need some romance manga with a male point of view (basically shounen or seinen). I'd really like it if the story has a bit of realistic touch to it, meaning no "stunningly hot/cute girls fall in love with loser MC for no apparent reason" or other stuff like that. Main examples of what I want are Kimi no Iru Machi, Good Ending, and Bitter Virgin.

Here's my MAL for the list of manga I've already read: http://myanimelist.net/mangalist/fatal_tragedy



Also accepting yuri suggestions if you know some. hahahaha
Haven't checked your list but I liked..

Koe no Katachi
Hetakoi
Onanie Master Kurosawa
Chikan Otoko
I"s
Boku no Hatsukoi wo Kimi ni Sasagu
*will probably add more once I remember stuff*
Otaku One
125 posts
Joined December 2015
Otaku One
Mmm... What a shame people are not asking for a manga suggestion now... Maybe I'll do.

Would like a Comedy/Harem/Romance/Slice of Life Manga or just plain Cute girls doing cute things manga. And I would like few cliches as possible.

Here's mah manga list if ya wanna see: http://myanimelist.net/mangalist/OtakuOne
blissfulyoshi
osu! Alumni
4,755 posts
Joined July 2008
Topic Starter
blissfulyoshi

Otaku One wrote:

Mmm... What a shame people are not asking for a manga suggestion now... Maybe I'll do.

Would like a Comedy/Harem/Romance/Slice of Life Manga or just plain Cute girls doing cute things manga. And I would like few cliches as possible.

Here's mah manga list if ya wanna see: http://myanimelist.net/mangalist/OtakuOne
You read a lot of 4-komas and comedy, so going from there.
Mikakunin de Shinkoukei (Engaged to the Unidentified)
Cafe Detective Club
Gekkan Shoujo Nozaki-kun
Isshuukan Friends
Rulia Nya!!
Saki (If you enjoy it, then read the many spinoffs)
School! Scoop?
Wa!
Yandere Kanojo
Zettai Reiiki

Before I go onto more haremy type stuff, can you tell me what you're looking in that genre because your post is fairly vague.
Otaku One
125 posts
Joined December 2015
Otaku One

blissfulyoshi wrote:

Otaku One wrote:

Mmm... What a shame people are not asking for a manga suggestion now... Maybe I'll do.

Would like a Comedy/Harem/Romance/Slice of Life Manga or just plain Cute girls doing cute things manga. And I would like few cliches as possible.

Here's mah manga list if ya wanna see: http://myanimelist.net/mangalist/OtakuOne
You read a lot of 4-komas and comedy, so going from there.
Mikakunin de Shinkoukei (Engaged to the Unidentified)
Cafe Detective Club
Gekkan Shoujo Nozaki-kun
Isshuukan Friends
Rulia Nya!!
Saki (If you enjoy it, then read the many spinoffs)
School! Scoop?
Wa!
Yandere Kanojo
Zettai Reiiki

Before I go onto more haremy type stuff, can you tell me what you're looking in that genre because your post is fairly vague.
Just a Harem. With tsunderes. With a loli. With an average girl... And no Onodera-type girl.

Btw, thanks! Gonna read it all later... With no sleep of course!
blissfulyoshi
osu! Alumni
4,755 posts
Joined July 2008
Topic Starter
blissfulyoshi

Otaku One wrote:

Just a Harem. With tsunderes. With a loli. With an average girl... And no Onodera-type girl.

Btw, thanks! Gonna read it all later... With no sleep of course!
Sorry for taking so long. Was lazy and took me a while to figure out how to approach your list. Like your earlier stuff, I'll try to stick to more lighthearted SoL stuff. However, I'll probably going to shotgun my recommendations from there.

Doubt!
Josei Danshi
Kimiiro Focus (I mostly only enjoyed this because I used to do photography and laughed at how ridiculous some things were
Kiss Death (Definitely a lot more on the actiony side)
Maga Tsuki

And MU dies on me... Tell me what you like, and I'll see if I can give better recommendations from there.
Otaku One
125 posts
Joined December 2015
Otaku One

blissfulyoshi wrote:

Sorry for taking so long. Was lazy and took me a while to figure out how to approach your list. Like your earlier stuff, I'll try to stick to more lighthearted SoL stuff. However, I'll probably going to shotgun my recommendations from there.

Doubt!
Josei Danshi
Kimiiro Focus (I mostly only enjoyed this because I used to do photography and laughed at how ridiculous some things were
Kiss Death (Definitely a lot more on the actiony side)
Maga Tsuki

And MU dies on me... Tell me what you like, and I'll see if I can give better recommendations from there.
Finished reading Doubt!, it was pretty funny and cool, I thought Toudou Asuka was his sister but it turned out to be Aya after all.

LOLIS. TSUNDERES. And... dun dun dun... Wait, what the hell, I should just check my MAL Profile to see what do I like...

Tsunderes,lolis,cliches,yanderes,catgirls, and plot twists. kk den.
Kiririn-shin
24 posts
Joined August 2013
Kiririn-shin
Can anyone suggest me some manga to read? XD

Genres: Romance, Comedy, Slice of Life, Drama

Like School rumble, Suzuka, Kimi no Iru Machi, Good Ending, Koe no Katachi

Thanks :D
aynoz
34 posts
Joined February 2014
aynoz

Kiririn-shin wrote:

Can anyone suggest me some manga to read? XD

Genres: Romance, Comedy, Slice of Life, Drama

Like School rumble, Suzuka, Kimi no Iru Machi, Good Ending, Koe no Katachi

Thanks :D
Yankee kun to Megane chan
Yamada kun to 7 nin no Majo

However you might already know these series since they're well known.
Fourth
76 posts
Joined April 2015
Fourth
Need tons of manga to read in case of boredom while I'm transferred to another country.

Genres: Comedy, Fantasy, Sci-fi, Action, Slice of life, Romance, School
(Something like Super Radical Gag Family, Berserk, Kuma Miko, Saint Seiya)
Kiririn-shin
24 posts
Joined August 2013
Kiririn-shin

aynoz wrote:

Kiririn-shin wrote:

Can anyone suggest me some manga to read? XD

Genres: Romance, Comedy, Slice of Life, Drama

Like School rumble, Suzuka, Kimi no Iru Machi, Good Ending, Koe no Katachi

Thanks :D
Yankee kun to Megane chan
Yamada kun to 7 nin no Majo

However you might already know these series since they're well known.
Yeah you're right i have already read those mangas. Thanks for suggesting tho XD :)
Kiririn-shin
24 posts
Joined August 2013
Kiririn-shin

Fourth wrote:

Need tons of manga to read in case of boredom while I'm transferred to another country.

Genres: Comedy, Fantasy, Sci-fi, Action, Slice of life, Romance, School
(Something like Super Radical Gag Family, Berserk, Kuma Miko, Saint Seiya)
You might as well try reading Renai Boukun, ReLife, Kimi no Iru Machi, Suzuka, Fuuka :D
Jinn
59 posts
Joined May 2015
Jinn
gun x clover all the way baby
R-unknown
85 posts
Joined December 2015
R-unknown
i like a manga that have complicated story, intelligent main character, and contain some psychological tips that can implemented in real life not purely implemented of course
for example is doubt! or TWGOK that have wonderfull story and have cool coller collest main chara :)
anyone can give me recommendation ? :D
Mogsy
osu! Alumni
3,450 posts
Here since the beginning
Mogsy

R-unknown wrote:

i like a manga that have complicated story, intelligent main character, and contain some psychological tips that can implemented in real life not purely implemented of course
for example is doubt! or TWGOK that have wonderfull story and have cool coller collest main chara :)
anyone can give me recommendation ? :D
The best one I can think of off the top of my head (that I'm not caught up on) is Liar Game. I'd say to give that a shot, it's pretty dang intense.

So I'll bite the bullet here. Give me a romantic comedy. Preferably following these guidelines:
  1. Preferably a shoujo or jousei.
  2. Less-disgusting relationship dynamics, unless they're used to demonstrate how disgusting those dynamics are.
  3. Pretty art style.
  4. Not adapted from a light novel.
I'm looking for more stuff along the lines of My Love Story (Ore Monogatari).
R-unknown
85 posts
Joined December 2015
R-unknown

Mogsworth wrote:

R-unknown wrote:

i like a manga that have complicated story, intelligent main character, and contain some psychological tips that can implemented in real life not purely implemented of course
for example is doubt! or TWGOK that have wonderfull story and have cool coller collest main chara :)
anyone can give me recommendation ? :D
The best one I can think of off the top of my head (that I'm not caught up on) is Liar Game. I'd say to give that a shot, it's pretty dang intense.

So I'll bite the bullet here. Give me a romantic comedy. Preferably following these guidelines:
  1. Preferably a shoujo or jousei.
  2. Less-disgusting relationship dynamics, unless they're used to demonstrate how disgusting those dynamics are.
  3. Pretty art style.
  4. Not adapted from a light novel.
I'm looking for more stuff along the lines of My Love Story (Ore Monogatari).
ok, i will give it a try :oops:
hm.. a romantic comedy manga that have pure love and following your guidelines..
already read Tonari no Kashiwagi-san ? but its not shoujo or jousei
memecena
45 posts
Joined May 2016
memecena
is there a mystery/psychological that i cant stop reading manga.
RynaHitsune
57 posts
Joined September 2011
RynaHitsune

memecena wrote:

is there a mystery/psychological that i cant stop reading manga.

For Mystery/Psychological genre, I'm going to recommend the Umineko no Naku Koro Ni series.
It's a pretty long one, since the manga has 8 series. Starting from http://myanimelist.net/manga/3749/Umineko_no_Naku_Koro_ni_-_Episode_1__Legend_of_the_Golden_Witch (Episode 1) to http://myanimelist.net/manga/34053/Umineko_no_Naku_Koro_ni_Chiru_-_Episode_8__Twilight_of_the_Golden_Witch (Episode 8), totaling 50 volumes of books overall.
You might have heard of the anime. Well, the anime adaptation is pretty bad but the manga is great.
I think you should give it a try.
Last edited by RynaHitsune , edited 3 times in total.
Rurree
1,291 posts
Joined June 2014
Rurree
Come[Back]Home
1,790 posts
Joined October 2011
Come[Back]Home
If anyone is interested in Martial Arts and awesome characters then I suggest "The Breaker" and "Breaker New Waves". I just bought almost all the volumes and I must say that it is one of the best Martial Arts Manga out there, so please give it a try if you know enjoy the Genre!

Genre: Action, Romance, Drama, Shounen, Psychological

Label (I only know the german one): Tokyopop
Fenneca
33 posts
Joined June 2014
Fenneca
Looking for a harem manga that I happened upon a few months ago but forgot to put on my reading list. Childhood friend is a serial killer, sempai is a rich girl who stalks MC, little sister goes Yandere at the mere mention of other women, Megane is a hardcore M, Narcoleptic is obsessed with finding out who serial killer is, Vampire girl drinks MC's blood for sustinance, and I can't remember the name of the Series to save my life. Anyone with knowledge on what i'm looking for would be greatly appreciated.
blissfulyoshi
osu! Alumni
4,755 posts
Joined July 2008
Topic Starter
blissfulyoshi

Fenneca wrote:

Looking for a harem manga that I happened upon a few months ago but forgot to put on my reading list. Childhood friend is a serial killer, sempai is a rich girl who stalks MC, little sister goes Yandere at the mere mention of other women, Megane is a hardcore M, Narcoleptic is obsessed with finding out who serial killer is, Vampire girl drinks MC's blood for sustinance, and I can't remember the name of the Series to save my life. Anyone with knowledge on what i'm looking for would be greatly appreciated.
Abnormal-kei Joshi?
Fenneca
33 posts
Joined June 2014
Fenneca

blissfulyoshi wrote:

Abnormal-kei Joshi?
Yes, thank-you
Caput Mortuum
1,854 posts
Joined March 2016
Caput Mortuum
Currently reading "Not Lives". Basically a battle royale style story but still quite interesting to me.
Peronsoda
19 posts
Joined February 2014
Peronsoda
Any good mangas about music?`
blissfulyoshi
osu! Alumni
4,755 posts
Joined July 2008
Topic Starter
blissfulyoshi

Peronsoda wrote:

Any good mangas about music?`
What part about music are you looking for?

Something based on bands and rock like Fuuka (probably way too happy go lucky, and definitely not what I consider good)

Something more focused on the casual life with music involved like k-on?

Something more about romance that develops during musical activities like Nodame Cantabile?

Admittedly, I probably won't be much help since I don't read many works involving music, but it'll probably help to narrow down your preferences a bit.
Peronsoda
19 posts
Joined February 2014
Peronsoda
Hmm i finished watching Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso which i liked and i guess i want to read a manga in style with " Nodame Cantabile"
Im looking for a manga where the character(s) are striving towards becoming really good in an instrument/singing, romance is a plus but i can live without it.

And now i have to read or watch Nodame Cantabile ^^ thnx
Alysia_old_1
243 posts
Joined April 2016
Alysia_old_1
Fruits Basket by Natsuki Takaya is the place to be
R-unknown
85 posts
Joined December 2015
R-unknown
any good manga with intelligent main character ?
similar to Doubt! (AMANO Sakuya), Kaguya-sama wa Kokurasetai, TWGOK
Luqanted
825 posts
Joined November 2013
Luqanted
this is pretty random but

GUYS I RECOMMEND DEADTUBE :D
Lord Timzki
54 posts
Joined September 2014
Lord Timzki
Horimiya bc y not
Luqanted
825 posts
Joined November 2013
Luqanted
is Horimiya still on-going?
Alysia_old_1
243 posts
Joined April 2016
Alysia_old_1
Like in the anime suggestion thread prison school is really good (a bit more adult though)
RokkaAstrea
98 posts
Joined July 2016
RokkaAstrea
Does anyone know manga similar to Pandora Hearts?
It's a sort of Historical Fiction, with plot twists everywhere =3=
Caput Mortuum
1,854 posts
Joined March 2016
Caput Mortuum
Grand Blue, a comedy slice of life focusing on the life of a college boy in a diving club. Ranks pretty high on MAL.
Green Platinum
2,660 posts
Joined July 2011
Green Platinum
Any 1970's Shoujo or Josei manga that I can read the entirety of?
Or Vampires with no qualms about sexuality (willing to have sex scenes etc.) and horror without garbage shounen/seinen plots.
Fantastic paneling like in Swan is also desirable.

Thanks anyone who can help.
YotSugoiDX
18 posts
Joined August 2017
YotSugoiDX
Cory in the manga
Softwarm
56 posts
Joined April 2014
Softwarm
Hello dead thread, I present you with something I highly recommend.
Ender Lain
822 posts
Joined January 2015
Ender Lain
Seraph of the End, Hayate the combat butler, Aldnoah Zero (+ 2nd season), Tokyo Ghoul, Girls und Panzer

Which one is the best?
Softwarm
56 posts
Joined April 2014
Softwarm

Izect Ztenz wrote:

Seraph of the End, Hayate the combat butler, Aldnoah Zero (+ 2nd season), Tokyo Ghoul, Girls und Panzer

Which one is the best?
If you're asking for a recommendation, you've not produced any list of past stories you've read for someone else for use in helping you out man. (Read the OP!) I have not read anything of these stories (though I did watch Aldnoah.Zero, and I wouldn't recommend it), so I am not the person to ask.
blissfulyoshi
osu! Alumni
4,755 posts
Joined July 2008
Topic Starter
blissfulyoshi

Izect Ztenz wrote:

Seraph of the End, Hayate the combat butler, Aldnoah Zero (+ 2nd season), Tokyo Ghoul, Girls und Panzer

Which one is the best?
Probably better to post in the anime suggestion thread (t/90118) and not the manga suggestion thread if you wanted answers about anime.

As to answer your question, you probably better give a criteria as to say what is the best for you because the genre of those series vary greatly.
Green Platinum
2,660 posts
Joined July 2011
Green Platinum

blissfulyoshi wrote:

Izect Ztenz wrote:

Seraph of the End, Hayate the combat butler, Aldnoah Zero (+ 2nd season), Tokyo Ghoul, Girls und Panzer

Which one is the best?
Probably better to post in the anime suggestion thread (t/90118) and not the manga suggestion thread if you wanted answers about anime.

As to answer your question, you probably better give a criteria as to say what is the best for you because the genre of those series vary greatly.
I was wondering if Aldnoah and GuP even had manga. Never seen them around.
blissfulyoshi
osu! Alumni
4,755 posts
Joined July 2008
Topic Starter
blissfulyoshi

Green Platinum wrote:

I was wondering if Aldnoah and GuP even had manga. Never seen them around.
I was wondering too, so I looked it up

Aldnoah: (there is a link to sequals and spinoffs too, but none are scanlated)
https://www.mangaupdates.com/series.html?id=113037

GuP: (has a lot of spinoffs)
https://www.mangaupdates.com/series.html?id=78531
Green Platinum
2,660 posts
Joined July 2011
Green Platinum
Not surprised about GuP. Aldnoah struck me as more a shitty LN kinda story.
Ender Lain
822 posts
Joined January 2015
Ender Lain

blissfulyoshi wrote:

Izect Ztenz wrote:

Seraph of the End, Hayate the combat butler, Aldnoah Zero (+ 2nd season), Tokyo Ghoul, Girls und Panzer

Which one is the best?
Probably better to post in the anime suggestion thread (t/90118) and not the manga suggestion thread if you wanted answers about anime.

As to answer your question, you probably better give a criteria as to say what is the best for you because the genre of those series vary greatly.
"Anime Suggestion Thread"


*also i wanna bought Girls und Panzer and AZ Second Season too...


blissfulyoshi
osu! Alumni
4,755 posts
Joined July 2008
Topic Starter
blissfulyoshi

Izect Ztenz wrote:

"Anime Suggestion Thread"
Sorry about that, my mistake. I haven't read the manga form of all of these.

Personally, I would suggest reading the original source material for anything because any other adaptation is usually just a retelling using what they know from a different source. With that said, here is the list of their original forms:
Seraph of the End - manga
Hayate the Combat Butler - manga
Aldnoah Zero - anime
Tokyo Ghoul - manga
Girls und Panzer - anime

So for Aldnoah Zero and Girls und Panzer, I suggest you should watch the anime for full enjoyment. As for the rest, depends on your taste. Seraph of the End takes a while to develop to something decent. Hayate is great comedy, but it does get a little repetitive toward the end and it helps a lot to know the references as they aired. Tokyo Ghoul, well I never read it.
Green Platinum
2,660 posts
Joined July 2011
Green Platinum
Seraph gets good? ... NANI?
blissfulyoshi
osu! Alumni
4,755 posts
Joined July 2008
Topic Starter
blissfulyoshi

Green Platinum wrote:

Seraph gets good? ... NANI?
I personally thinks it gets better, but I do agree that it is not the author's best work.
CringyWeabo
16 posts
Joined May 2015
CringyWeabo
Now i dont acctualy read manga but i wana get in to it...
so since i cant say what i normally read since i dont.
Whats a manga that i can start with?
Husa
176 posts
Joined April 2016
Husa
idk but this is really good everyone, https://myanimelist.net/manga/107138/Te ... Care_of_Me >///<
zetsuchanyami
26 posts
Joined July 2017
zetsuchanyami
I really liked The Promised Neverland, it's a great manga.
Otakutims
1 post
Joined June 2017
Otakutims
I actually bought the manga called "Kodomo no Jikan(こどものじかん)" or in English Children's Hour. I did not finish the manga because there were only vol 1-6 available hard copy in my local book store. Even though I only read vol 1-6, I think Children's Hour is a great manga in terms of story.

(spoiler alert)
Children's Hour is about a teacher named Daisuke Aoki. He is a 23 years old teacher, who teaches grade–schoolers. Throughout his days, he always end up in a embarrassing(?) situation with rin, who is one of the student of Aoki. Those embarrassing situation includes kissing and some skinships (スキンシップ), which means "non-sexual touching between very close platonic friends" according to urban dictionary. Eventually, Aoki finds out why she act this way and soon he started to care about her and almost love her....

I know some people are disgust about how Kodomo no Jikan, the author, draw a lewd loli. One might even say it is straight up lolicon doujinshi(同人誌), but I still respect him because the visual and the entertainment (° ͜ʖ°). Plus, I personally like lolis because of their cuteness😏😏😏. I rate this manga 8/10 and I would recommend this to loli lovers :D
Caput Mortuum
1,854 posts
Joined March 2016
Caput Mortuum
hey please post here guys me need some fresh mango during this pandemic

also some manga review from me:
Raw Hero. It's from the same guy who made Prison School. In short, it's a story about a poor man with 2 young siblings trying to find work, and due to some circumstances, became a spy to infiltrate a villain organization. As you would expect from the author, it's really ecchi heavy and is probably borderline hentai.

It's a pretty funny manga if I say so, but god I hate the love triangle trope that's going on right now and I hope it ends soon. I just hope the author doesn't kill it like he did with Prison School.

All in all, I recommend to give it a go if you like Prison School.
Asphiee
1,458 posts
Joined January 2020
Asphiee
Oversimplifying review

Berserk - epic plot (waaay better than anime)
Psyren - anime adaptation material (i've read darwin's game before it got an anime, it was decent enough to keep me reading but not good really)
GTO series - want some comedy and feels, read this then (way better then anime)
Ajin - some parts arent in anime, as usual for an adaptation
Citrus - for yuri lover
Solo Leveling - want an overpowered main character without no clear conflict (self vs self , self vs people shit) then read this, recommended for those who doesnt love plots (its manwha)
One punch man - unlike solo leveling, the main character has conflict which is getting recognition he deserves
YuriCam: Yurika no Campus Life - if you just want a pure yuri plot every chapter then just have fun reading this
Beelzebub - just read this, really
Liar Game - r.i.p
Philosophia - yuri <3

i know this isnt helpful, but who cares...
nahumGTM
2 posts
Joined May 2020
nahumGTM
Ola o///o
Captainkonata
1 post
Joined October 2020
Captainkonata
hewo :3
MangaGrumpy
371 posts
Joined May 2022
MangaGrumpy
The Splatoon manga is really good I guess
TheAngryNerd101
274 posts
Joined February 2021
TheAngryNerd101
Kengan Ashura is a really fun one. Quite similar to Baki with the whole underground fighting thing, plenty of badass characters with cool fighting styles and abilities along with some really great action scenes and choreography. Great art as well. Sad how the anime skipped a bunch of fights and was done in mediocre 3D CG.
npc_BeaniCraft
472 posts
Joined October 2021
npc_BeaniCraft
it's probably been said a billion times before. but noragami!
Stomiks
9,038 posts
Joined March 2021
Stomiks
Bloom into you just read it it's fucking great
DM FOR MUTUAL
612 posts
Joined March 2021
DM FOR MUTUAL

Stomiks wrote:

Bloom into you just read it it's fucking great
I wholly vouch for this.
Vickywar
11 posts
Joined August 2019
Vickywar

yoony1 wrote:

Stomiks wrote:

Bloom into you just read it it's fucking great
I wholly vouch for this.
Same here really good manga!!!
Aireunaeus
3,104 posts
Joined December 2021
Aireunaeus
i'd suggest you guys read Evangelion. It's better than the manga
Stomiks
9,038 posts
Joined March 2021
Stomiks
You talking about the original drafts lmao
Aireunaeus
3,104 posts
Joined December 2021
Aireunaeus

Stomiks wrote:

You talking about the original drafts lmao
huh no way theyre drafts 😯
Last edited by Aireunaeus , edited 1 time in total.
Stomiks
9,038 posts
Joined March 2021
Stomiks

Aireunaeus wrote:

Stomiks wrote:

You talking about the original drafts lmao
huh no way theyre drafts 😯
No I was talking about how you said that the manga was better when you already said to read evangelion. So I was thinking if your referring to the original drafts of the manga.
Aireunaeus
3,104 posts
Joined December 2021
Aireunaeus

Stomiks wrote:

Aireunaeus wrote:

Stomiks wrote:

You talking about the original drafts lmao
huh no way theyre drafts 😯
No I was talking about how you said that the manga was better when you already said to read evangelion. So I was thinking if your referring to the original drafts of the manga.
no way i said manga. I meant better than the anime lmao
Last edited by Aireunaeus , edited 1 time in total.
anaxii
15,180 posts
Joined December 2022
anaxii
Btw this is not a suggestion but I just finished reading Metamorphosis... and I don't recommend it to anyone.
DO NOT READ THIS.
Reyalp51
966 posts
Joined April 2021
Reyalp51

I AM VERY SMART wrote:

Btw this is not a suggestion but I just finished reading Metamorphosis... and I don't recommend it to anyone.
DO NOT READ THIS.
how old were you again lmao
Stomiks
9,038 posts
Joined March 2021
Stomiks

Reyalp51 wrote:

I AM VERY SMART wrote:

Btw this is not a suggestion but I just finished reading Metamorphosis... and I don't recommend it to anyone.
DO NOT READ THIS.
how old were you again lmao
This kid is not above 15
Reyalp51
966 posts
Joined April 2021
Reyalp51

Stomiks wrote:

Reyalp51 wrote:

I AM VERY SMART wrote:

Btw this is not a suggestion but I just finished reading Metamorphosis... and I don't recommend it to anyone.
DO NOT READ THIS.
how old were you again lmao
This kid is not above 15
well tbh when i was a kid my sis show me a video of a guy trapped in an elevator that ate his own shit so he is probably fine
Stomiks
9,038 posts
Joined March 2021
Stomiks

Reyalp51 wrote:

Stomiks wrote:

Reyalp51 wrote:

I AM VERY SMART wrote:

Btw this is not a suggestion but I just finished reading Metamorphosis... and I don't recommend it to anyone.
DO NOT READ THIS.
how old were you again lmao
This kid is not above 15
well tbh when i was a kid my sis show me a video of a guy trapped in an elevator that ate his own shit so he is probably fine
Different strokes for different folks I guess
Isatuyu
32 posts
Joined July 2020
Isatuyu
"I Am a Hero" by Hanazawa Kengo. Although I'm not really recommend it for everyone (because the seinen demographic and a "questionable" ending to "some") it was a trip for me. A really good trip. Especially if you into the apocalyptic and philosophical setting
anaxii
15,180 posts
Joined December 2022
anaxii

Stomiks wrote:

Reyalp51 wrote:

I AM VERY SMART wrote:

Btw this is not a suggestion but I just finished reading Metamorphosis... and I don't recommend it to anyone.
DO NOT READ THIS.
how old were you again lmao
This kid is not above 15
Wrong
DM FOR MUTUAL
612 posts
Joined March 2021
DM FOR MUTUAL
Just finished reading Lucifer and the Biscuit Hammer. Pretty fun, check it out.

The following is a vague review type thing with some of my thoughts and some things you might want to know before jumping in. There won't be any spoilers, but don't read the contents of this box if you want to go in completely blind.
I guess I'd say it's a shounen battle manga from 2005 with a focus on (non-conflict) character drama with a tight-knit, interesting plot. It's also fully completed.

I don't know how to explain it better but it has an indie game feel to it, like if a frontline, long-running popular series are triple A games, then this could be described as an indie game. It's fairly succinct with a very clear vision, and also a bit rough around the edges in a way that you might say is charming.

I think a lot of the "rough around the edges" feel comes from the fact that this has a mid 2000s shounen aesthetic, with art, humour, tropes and I guess "wacky, light-hearted vibes" from that era which does definitely comes off as dated. I do personally enjoy this aesthetic though because it's pretty uniquely wacky compared to modern stuff.

I especially enjoyed the plot and how tight it was, there were quite a lot of small details that would come back later in the story, it didn't feel like anything was wasted. It's pretty clear that everything was planned out pretty meticulously before the author started writing, and even though the execution from the planning to the actual manga may not have been perfect, it was still pretty cool.

If it didn't really for me, I can see how some people might find this story or at least parts of this story very personally touching because of what it's about.

Some other things you might wanna know before starting:

- If you do decide to read this in an unofficial manner, note that the unofficial English translation of volume 4 available online is kinda questionable, so just steel yourself for that. Otherwise it's pretty decent.

- There's some pretty uncouth humour with panty shots (of a high-school girl) and stuff, which I feel ties into that mid-2000s aesthetic I talked about before. It's mostly just humour and isn't a focus for the vast majority of the manga, but if it's something that's a massive turn-off then maybe avoid this. (Also don't start to read this if you're in public like I did)

- You might recognise this because it had a recent-ish anime adaptation which is currently sitting at 5.64 stars on MAL. Dunno what's up with that, the manga itself is rated way higher. I guess the anime adaptation was just uniquely horrible or something, so don't let that deter you from reading the manga.

I enjoyed doing this so I think I'll do another one of these if I find a noteworthy manga that might be underlooked or not well known.
Last edited by DM FOR MUTUAL , edited 1 time in total.
hipster
83 posts
Joined September 2022
hipster
READ COROIKA NOW !!!
anaxii
15,180 posts
Joined December 2022
anaxii

fruitsycat wrote:

READ COROIKA NOW !!!
OKKKK
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply

0
197 / 308