M4M from my queue, totally not late or anything :3:

7 DIFFS, HOLY

[Beginner]

1. 00:42:800 (1,2,3) - maybe move that to the middle, so 2 is on the y-axis
2. 01:14:104 (1) - this section seems kinda monotone, maybe add some 4/1 sliders/more repeatsliders for variation
3. 02:04:787 (3) - move that to center, stacking with 02:01:806 (1) -
4. 02:28:638 (1) - same as in the prior Kiai, it just feels kinda boring like this, however i may not be able to judge that properly, since i rarely play beginners anymore

[Easy]

1. 00:26:402 (2,3) - i'd remove that and make it a repeatslider, gives Starters more leeway to misstime their clicks
2. 01:15:595 (3,4) - same here, these are killers if you just started
3. 01:17:831 (2) - with this your bound to feel off because you skip the downbeat after - sure, stupid to fix that without 1/2 use, but like this it feels very weird to me ;w;
4. 02:32:365 (2) - uknoukno, same as before

[Normal]

1. 00:27:520 - are you sure about still skipping downbeats when youre already at Normal? - Sure, your decision, but I think you could expect players to be able to hit that by now ;3 - Not gonna mention others, to avoid cluster
2. 02:05:160 (2) - for this one maybe use 02:02:179 (2) - and mirror it? would look kinda sweet :3

[Advanced]
Should be good

[Hard]

1. 00:41:495 (3) - this is kinda unexpected, there should be something on 00:41:309 - for sure, so either move it, add another one, or rework it
2. 02:34:042 - i'd add a note here
3. 03:04:042 (2) - you have that as a clickable object in Advanced, consider making it circles here too

[Light Insane]

1. 02:39:446 (2,3,4,5,6) - WOAH, now that was kinda unexpected - Expect getting a ton of people failing here, this is quite the diffspike
2. 02:49:135 (3,1) - This is evil, consider ctrl+g'ing on 02:49:508 (1,2) -
3. 03:04:042 (4) - once more, please make that end hittable

[Insane]

1. 00:22:862 (4) - make that 1 repeat maybe

That's about it!
Solid map, nice to see some old styled maps again
GL

Asonate wrote:

M4M from my queue, totally not late or anything :3:

7 DIFFS, HOLY now no one can call me lazy

[Beginner]

1. 00:42:800 (1,2,3) - maybe move that to the middle, so 2 is on the y-axis Fixed~
2. 01:14:104 (1) - this section seems kinda monotone, maybe add some 4/1 sliders/more repeat sliders for variation I'll think about it. There's nothing that really stands out to me though.
3. 02:04:787 (3) - move that to center, stacking with 02:01:806 (1) - I don't see how is helping, but fixed anyway~
4. 02:28:638 (1) - same as in the prior Kiai, it just feels kinda boring like this, however i may not be able to judge that properly, since i rarely play beginners anymore Same response.

[Easy]

1. 00:26:402 (2,3) - I'd remove that and make it a repeat slider, gives Starters more leeway to mistime their clicks Fixed, I'll miss that pattern though.
2. 01:15:595 (3,4) - same here, these are killers if you just started
3. 01:17:831 (2) - with this your bound to feel off because you skip the downbeat after - sure, stupid to fix that without 1/2 use, but like this it feels very weird to me ;w;
4. 02:32:365 (2) - uknoukno, same as before Fixed all~

[Normal]

1. 00:27:520 - are you sure about still skipping downbeats when you're already at Normal? - Sure, your decision, but I think you could expect players to be able to hit that by now ;3 - Not gonna mention others, to avoid cluster
2. 02:05:160 (2) - for this one maybe use 02:02:179 (2) - and mirror it? would look kinda sweet :3 Fixed all~

[Advanced]
Should be good

[Hard]

1. 00:41:495 (3) - this is kinda unexpected, there should be something on 00:41:309 - for sure, so either move it, add another one, or rework it
2. 02:34:042 - i'd add a note here
3. 03:04:042 (2) - you have that as a clickable object in Advanced, consider making it circles here too Fixed all~

[Light Insane]

• 
  This was mapped yesterday... It'll probably be the worst.

1. 02:39:446 (2,3,4,5,6) - WOAH, now that was kinda unexpected - Expect getting a ton of people failing here, this is quite the diffspike Fixed, I decreased the spacing a tiny bit lol.
2. 02:49:135 (3,1) - This is evil, consider ctrl+g'ing on 02:49:508 (1,2) - I moved (3) instead.
3. 03:04:042 (4) - once more, please make that end hittable Fixed~

[Insane]

1. 00:22:862 (4) - make that 1 repeat maybe Fixed~

That's about it!
Solid map, nice to see some old styled maps again
GL

Thanks for modding, I'll mod your map ASAP!

NM from my Queue


I'm tired atm xDDDD sorry for the short mod fun song i said no 3 minute song even your drain time is under it xD you remind me of Gero & Andrea's maps, SYMMETRY! but there is a consideration goodluck

Janpai wrote:

NM from my Queue

General

1. Your preview point is unsnapped idk if it really matters It doesn't matter. It was intentional.

Easy

1. 00:48:017 - Two timing points at the same time is unrankable imo Fixed~
2. 00:31:992 (2) - Remove this note ? since you don't have one in 00:24:911 (1,2) - Fixed~
3. 00:33:483 - I think you should a note here since the vocal something like "seno" is strong Fixed~
4. 01:08:141 (2) - Move to x:331 y:222 ? so that it could be diagonally linear with 01:06:651 (1) - Fixed~
5. In the first chorus part, idk why you put gaps on it, the instrumentals are clearly don't stop at the same time there is a vocal there, I think it wouldn't be a problem if you fill out those I filled in a few, but I like simple rhythms.
6. 01:31:247 (4) - Bring down to the tail of (3) cuz personally I really don't like this kind of flow I don't like how that looks.
7. 01:34:228 (4) - Straight this up like (3) ? since 01:34:974 (1) - is a angled slider then why putting such curve on that slider Fixed~
8. 01:48:390 (2) - Make this a slider because the instrumental is still going on the next white tick or just move 01:49:135 (3) - to 01:48:762 then add a note on the next tick since that is the last tick before break, i prefer that it must be clickable I added the slider, but I kept the clicking.
9. 02:48:017 (3,4) - Blanketing them is not the best choice I don't see why.
10. 02:57:706 (3,1) - If this is a blanket fix it Fixed~

Normal

1. 00:13:918 (2,3) - It is audible that there is a sound at redtick, Make (2) a reverse slider of just add a note at red tick? do the same way to the following beats that are the same with this Fixed as much as possible~
2. 00:22:862 (2,3) - Stack them? That would be one of the only stacks in this diff.
3. 00:26:029 (3,4,5) - Maybe put 00:27:147 (5) - on the red tick and add a note on 00:27:520 because for the vocals and also fits in the instrumental I prefer the current rhythm.
4. 01:16:526 (4) - There is no sound in this red tick but it is at 01:16:899 move this note to 01:16:713 ? There is a sound there.
5. 01:18:516 - why did you ignore this strong downbeat? for vocals
6. 01:23:793 (2,3,4) - I think is better if you make the start of 01:24:166 (3) - a note then add a 1/1 slider at the redtick because it's really obvious that you are following the vocals here that's a good thing though
7. 01:55:843 (1) - This spinner, why it's not equal with the easy diff? easy ends 1 downbeat earlier maybe extend the spinner in easy because the time recovery that you put in this is already enough for the recovery of the easy Fixed~
8. 02:14:849 (3) - Downbeat must be clickable imo. Fixed~

I'm tired atm xDDDD sorry for the short mod fun song i said no 3 minute song even your drain time is under it xD you remind me of Gero & Andrea's maps, SYMMETRY! but there is a consideration goodluck

Thanks for modding!!

Hello~

M4M.

Keep in mind, these are my suggestions, don't change something I mentioned unless it seems good to you!








I actually don't have much to say about this map. Sorry. ;; At least the symmetry is nice. (:

Ayyri wrote:

Hello~

M4M.

Keep in mind, these are my suggestions, don't change something I mentioned unless it seems good to you!

Beginner

Looks fine. (ノ^∇^)

Easy

Looks fine. (ノ^∇^)

Normal

Looks fine. (ノ^∇^)

Advanced

02:49:135 (6,1) - I feel like this would be kind of bad for a newer player to read, since it's the same pattern right after at 02:50:067 (2,3) -
Consider moving 02:49:135 (6) - somewhere inbetween 02:48:017 (5) - and 02:49:508 (1) - I changed the pattern a bit.

Hard

Looks fine. (ノ^∇^)

Lightly Insane

Looks fine. (ノ^∇^)

Insane

Looks fine. (ノ^∇^)

I actually don't have much to say about this map. Sorry. ;; At least the symmetry is nice. (:

Thanks for modding~!!

Famously

00:20:812 (2) - circle then 1/2 slider instead? Weird that you dont make 00:20:998 - clickable.
00:23:421 (1,2) - Spacing is going to be confused for 1/2 even tho this is 1/1.... Try making 1 a 1/2 slider instead.
00:27:334 (4,1) - Again about spacing. Compare with the spacing at 00:26:402 (1,2) - . You're lacking a spacing concept that properly identifies what's 1/2 and whats 1/1 so it creates a confusing spacing for players.
00:32:738 (2,3) - ^ Maybe add a circle on 00:33:297 - .
00:34:228 (2) - 00:35:346 (1,2) - etc... Spacing really needs work.
01:18:762 (2,3,4) - Put emphasis onto 4 instead of 3 with your spacing.
02:04:042 (3,4) - Why the jump here? You don't emphasize the note elsewhere... its like your emphasis isn't consistent either.
02:05:346 (4,5) - ^Like why no jump here?
02:12:241 (1,2,3,4) - You use a much larger spacing for 3 and 4 but theres nothing really emphasized. this is a poor use of symmetry xP.
02:26:961 - and 02:27:147 - Why not make those drum beats clickable?

Actively

00:28:265 (2,3) - This visual just looks really poor for me because the slider directions don't match with the flow.
00:28:638 (3,1) - No jump here?
00:39:446 (6,1) - More spacing because this looks really close to 00:38:141 (1,2) - in terms of spacing.
00:50:067 (5,1) - No jump here? You map a jump elsewhere like 00:53:048 (5,1) -
01:03:669 (1,2,3,4) - This spacing is really confusing. 3>4...

Going to stop... you really need to work on how you spacing things out xP. I would mod more, but this spacing problem is continues to occur. It's hard to mod anything else with this issue.

M4M from my queue

In general, I don't really see the need for so many 3* difficulties. If you're going to have so many difficulties, I'd suggest you at least make the final difficulty harder than 4.11. The difficulty doesn't even make the minimum star rating for insane.



I feel bad for not really finding anything wrong with your map. Probably just a repeat of what Monstrata-sama modded, so you don't need to give me kudosu if you don't want to.

Good luck!

Monstrata wrote:

Famously

00:20:812 (2) - circle then 1/2 slider instead? Weird that you dont make 00:20:998 - clickable.
00:23:421 (1,2) - Spacing is going to be confused for 1/2 even tho this is 1/1.... Try making 1 a 1/2 slider instead.
00:27:334 (4,1) - Again about spacing. Compare with the spacing at 00:26:402 (1,2) - . You're lacking a spacing concept that properly identifies what's 1/2 and whats 1/1 so it creates a confusing spacing for players.
00:32:738 (2,3) - ^ Maybe add a circle on 00:33:297 - .
00:34:228 (2) - 00:35:346 (1,2) - etc... Spacing really needs work.
01:18:762 (2,3,4) - Put emphasis onto 4 instead of 3 with your spacing.
02:04:042 (3,4) - Why the jump here? You don't emphasize the note elsewhere... its like your emphasis isn't consistent either.
02:05:346 (4,5) - ^Like why no jump here?
02:12:241 (1,2,3,4) - You use a much larger spacing for 3 and 4 but theres nothing really emphasized. this is a poor use of symmetry xP.
02:26:961 - and 02:27:147 - Why not make those drum beats clickable?

Actively

00:28:265 (2,3) - This visual just looks really poor for me because the slider directions don't match with the flow.
00:28:638 (3,1) - No jump here?
00:39:446 (6,1) - More spacing because this looks really close to 00:38:141 (1,2) - in terms of spacing.
00:50:067 (5,1) - No jump here? You map a jump elsewhere like 00:53:048 (5,1) -
01:03:669 (1,2,3,4) - This spacing is really confusing. 3>4...

Going to stop... you really need to work on how you spacing things out xP. I would mod more, but this spacing problem is continues to occur. It's hard to mod anything else with this issue.

Spacing

A spacing issue simply means that your spacing is not reflective of the time gap in between objects. Please alter the spacing so that visually, players are able to recognize which objects are 1/2 spaced and which ones are 1/1 spaced. Lets look at some examples if you are unsure!



As you see, visually, this pattern seems straight-forward. Everything looks evenly spaced visually. But wait! 3>4 is not actually 1/2 spaced in timeline, it's 1/1. But because the pattern is arranged like this, players are very likely to click 4 too early, causing them to miss. This is generally confusing to players, and is a spacing issue. You can remedy this by increasing the spacing between 3>4 to make it more obvious to players that there is a 1/1 gap instead of a normal 1/2 gap.

Something like this would work! Now it's obvious that there is more time in between 3 and 4.

Thank you for your mod Monstrata~!!
I think remapping would be the most effective way of fixing the spacing problem, so I'll do that.

Kami-senpai wrote:

M4M from my queue

In general, I don't really see the need for so many 3* difficulties. If you're going to have so many difficulties, I'd suggest you at least make the final difficulty harder than 4.11. The difficulty doesn't even make the minimum star rating for insane.

Famously

00:14:663 (2,3) - blanket properly
00:20:812 (2) - the sound at the slider end is emphasized, so I suggest changing to two single circles to map to that
00:21:930 (1,2,3) - Too close together. Keep in mind that this is the hardest difficulty
00:23:421 (1,2,3) - In the back there are the piano taps in the music. I'd suggest you map to that instead
00:29:197 (4,1) - Make into one long slider if you're mapping to vocals
00:29:383 (1,3) - Blanket properly
00:32:738 (2) - The end of the slider is on an emphasized sound. Strongly recommend that you turn it into a normal slider and a circle
00:36:092 (2,3,4) - Not really mapped to anything I can hear
01:03:856 (2,3) - Blanket slightly off
01:07:210 (2,3) - ^
01:15:036 (4,5) - I suggest you ctrl g this to make it flow better
01:15:595 (1,2,3,4) - Maybe map to music more? I don't really hear anything that warrants these sliders
01:18:017 (4,5) - There's a change in tone for vocals so don't stack these
01:18:576 (1,2) - ^
There's a sound at 1:49:694 that you should map to
01:55:843 (1) - You should actually map here instead of putting a spinner
There's a drum sound at 2:27:147 that's really obvious. Please map to that
02:32:924 (5,1) - Change in pitch = don't stack I'll give you the star because I was unaware of this before you modded. I'll be sure to remember that when remapping and mapping in the future.
02:37:023 (4) - I would make this a jump instead since the vocals are emphasized
02:51:744 (7,8,9,10,11) - Make this curve a bit smoother

Actively

00:31:992 (4,1) - Spacing too far
00:49:321 (3,4) - Spacing
00:52:303 (3,4) - ^

Welp, looking at your changelog, it looks like you're remapping all of them based off spacing, so good luck on that.

I feel bad for not really finding anything wrong with your map. Probably just a repeat of what Monstrata-sama modded, so you don't need to give me kudosu if you don't want to. Noononononononoon don't feel bad. You did nothing wrong. It's my fault for requesting a mod on a WIP mapset and not telling you. Your mod was helpful. KD for you~

Good luck!

Thanks for your mod~!!

Hello! I was directed here by your queue. Apologies for taking so long. Poking around, it looks like you have that remap finished, so I'll assume I'm good to go.

General:
- In this mapset, (at least to me) it looks like you're focusing more on making cool patterns than on the music, especially in the higher difficulties like Actively and Famously. Not that you can't have patterns, but it seems to me like you're forcing the music to fit the patterns, not the other way around.
- Your hitsounds are pretty loud. Where they're at 100% volume, they should probably be somewhere around 75% at most.
- 01:55:843 (1) - This spinner was fine for the first two difficulties, but I'd say start substituting it for other things in all the other difficulties.
- 02:25:657 - I'd try to emphasize the vocal directly right here.

Slowly:

- Honestly, this difficulty seems a little redundant. I don't know about you, but if I had a map that was 1.36 stars, I wouldn't see the need for a map that's 1.11 stars. Although the map does look pretty clean.

Easily:

- 02:25:657 (4) - I'd suggest either making this a slider, or putting in a break afterward. It's extremely abnormal for an Easy to have a pause for that long. That's the only thing I'd suggest, though.

Normally:

- 00:57:706 (1) - I suggest making this a 1/1 slider with a reverse arrow, given that the entire song, you've been matching up with vocals.
- 01:42:241 (4,5,6,7,8) - Long chains of circles like this probably shouldn't be in a Normal difficulty.

Moderately:

- 00:24:166 (4) - Watch your spacing here. This object is really close to (3).

Quickly:

- Your spacing is still all over the place in this difficulty. It's especially prevalent in the Kiai sections.
- 01:43:918 (1) - Weird 3/4 sliders are weird. I'm assuming this wasn't intentional.
- 01:47:644 (3,4,5) - I can't tell what part of the song you're following here.
- 02:33:110 (4) - Ctrl-G this slider to improve flow.
- 02:58:079 (7,1) - A prime and rather obnoxious example of your spacing gone rampant. Jumps like this probably shouldn't be in a Hard difficulty.

Actively:

- 01:42:427 (1,2,3,4) - Instead of making these 1/4 sliders with reverse arrows, try having them be just plain circles with jumps.
- 01:48:390 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - These streams don't seem to follow anything. It seems overmapped to me.
- 03:02:924 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - See above.

Famously:

- There are a whole ton of beats here that should be clickable, but aren't. 00:26:961 (3) - This slider is a fantastic example. The tail of the slider has a strong vocal on it, but what does the head have? As far as I can tell, maybe a weak drum beat. When it comes to sliders, especially in higher difficulties like this, the stronger beats should always be clickable over the weaker ones. This encompasses a lot of the problems I have with this particular difficulty.
- 00:35:533 (2) - There's absolutely nothing in the music right here, yet there's a circle right here. This is what I mean by "forcing the music to fit the patterns." Unfortunately, the music alters itself for no one.
- 02:18:949 (3,4,5,6) - Generally, having the players move in a straight line isn't a good idea. It's less comfortable to play than one would think.

And that's it for me! The lower difficulties look very polished to me! My best advice would be to focus more on the strong beats in the higher difficulties, and adjust your rhythm to emphasize those. Good luck!

The Ash Raichu wrote:

Hello! I was directed here by your queue. Apologies for taking so long. Poking around, it looks like you have that remap finished, so I'll assume I'm good to go.

General:
- In this mapset, (at least to me) it looks like you're focusing more on making cool patterns than on the music, especially in the higher difficulties like Actively and Famously. Not that you can't have patterns, but it seems to me like you're forcing the music to fit the patterns, not the other way around. I'll keep that in mind.
- Your hitsounds are pretty loud. Where they're at 100% volume, they should probably be somewhere around 75% at most. Lowered in most places~
- 01:55:843 (1) - This spinner was fine for the first two difficulties, but I'd say start substituting it for other things in all the other difficulties. I don't think mapping it will be an improvement. Having it mapped in some difficulties and skipped in others looks lazy.
- 02:25:657 - I'd try to emphasize the vocal directly right here. You mean the "ooooooo"? Fixed in some difficulties.

Slowly:

- Honestly, this difficulty seems a little redundant. I don't know about you, but if I had a map that was 1.36 stars, I wouldn't see the need for a map that's 1.11 stars. Although the map does look pretty clean. True, but it's not really causing a problem to have a few more difficulties than necessary. It's much better than not having them. I'll see if anyone else mentions this.

Easily:

- 02:25:657 (4) - I'd suggest either making this a slider, or putting in a break afterward. It's extremely abnormal for an Easy to have a pause for that long. That's the only thing I'd suggest, though. I added another circle.

Normally:

- 00:57:706 (1) - I suggest making this a 1/1 slider with a reverse arrow, given that the entire song, you've been matching up with vocals. Fixed~
- 01:42:241 (4,5,6,7,8) - Long chains of circles like this probably shouldn't be in a Normal difficulty. Fixed very slightly.

Moderately:

- 00:24:166 (4) - Watch your spacing here. This object is really close to (3). Fixed~

Quickly:

- Your spacing is still all over the place in this difficulty. It's especially prevalent in the Kiai sections.
- 01:43:918 (1) - Weird 3/4 sliders are weird. I'm assuming this wasn't intentional.
- 01:47:644 (3,4,5) - I can't tell what part of the song you're following here.
- 02:33:110 (4) - Ctrl-G this slider to improve flow.
- 02:58:079 (7,1) - A prime and rather obnoxious example of your spacing gone rampant. Jumps like this probably shouldn't be in a Hard difficulty. Fixed all~

Actively:

- 01:42:427 (1,2,3,4) - Instead of making these 1/4 sliders with reverse arrows, try having them be just plain circles with jumps. I'm not going to ignore the drums here.
- 01:48:390 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - These streams don't seem to follow anything. It seems overmapped to me. ^
- 03:02:924 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - See above. ^

Famously:

- There are a whole ton of beats here that should be clickable, but aren't. 00:26:961 (3) - This slider is a fantastic example. The tail of the slider has a strong vocal on it, but what does the head have? As far as I can tell, maybe a weak drum beat. When it comes to sliders, especially in higher difficulties like this, the stronger beats should always be clickable over the weaker ones. This encompasses a lot of the problems I have with this particular difficulty. I was following the instruments there. Hmm. Maybe I should still include the stronger vocals. I'll switch around a few things.
- 00:35:533 (2) - There's absolutely nothing in the music right here, yet there's a circle right here. This is what I mean by "forcing the music to fit the patterns." Unfortunately, the music alters itself for no one. Fixed. This was a mistake. I wasn't trying to overmap it.
- 02:18:949 (3,4,5,6) - Generally, having the players move in a straight line isn't a good idea. It's less comfortable to play than one would think. Fixed~

And that's it for me! The lower difficulties look very polished to me! My best advice would be to focus more on the strong beats in the higher difficulties, and adjust your rhythm to emphasize those. Good luck!

Thanks for modding~ ^^

Hi there~

General
Did you map the all diffs? Have you looked through p/4892052? I think some BNs take issue with multiple diffs by same mapper.

Slowly

1. Spacing is inconsistent. I believe all the easy maps should same same spacing throughout? Examples: 00:29:383 (4,1) - spacing decreases, and 00:35:346 (5,1) - increases again

Quickly

1. I noticed some inconsistencies. For the most part, rhythm is identical, but placing four 1/2 circles is much more difficult than placing two 1/2 sliders. Some examples: ( 01:37:955 (1,2,3,4,5) - 02:52:489 (1,2,3,4) - ) These have identical music. The way you mapped it, hitsound will place at same beats, but 01:37:955 (1,2,3,4,5) - is more difficult than 02:52:489 (1,2,3,4) -. I don’t think this is non-negligible. Repeating same flow/pattern will be boring, but I still think we could use more consistency.
   
2. Along the same line, 01:17:085 (1,2,3) - 02:31:620 (1) - has same beats, but they will play very differently.
   
3. 01:18:576 (6,7,8,9,10) - 02:33:110 (4,5,6,7) - Same here, 01:18:576 (6,7,8,9,10) - feels non-negligibly more difficult. Sometimes maps are repetitive and boring, other times inconsistent and confusing. I am not sure where the boundary exactly lies, but I think this diff definitely crossed that boundary toward being inconsistent and confusing.
   
4. And as the final words on this: If one chorus is to be more difficult than other, I think it should be the second chorus. In this diff, first chorus has more clicks, which makes it more difficult to acc and aim.
   
5. 01:39:073 (3,4,5) - 5 is different from 3,4, so I think they shouldn’t be symmetric

Actively

1. 00:55:657 (2,3,4) - 01:07:582 (2,3,4) - I don’t think triangle with same distance fits here nicely here. Symmetric shape with same DS yells identical emphasis, but (based on the music) I think 2 should be emphasized most, 3, and lastly 1.
   
2. 01:02:924 (3,4,5,6,7,1) - 01:05:905 (3,4,5,6) - I think this is more difficult than it deserves
   
3. 01:23:980 (4,5,6,1) - I think flow could be improved. Relatively big jump with with no sharp turn is awkward to hit at this level.
   
4. 01:23:980 (4,5,6,1) - I see a lot of similar patterns in the map, and they almost feel lazy to me. These patterns are frankly just variations of symmetric sliders. I don’t think any of them were terribly misused, but definitely overused IMO. (00:17:458 (1,2,3,4) - 00:48:762 (1,2,3,4) - 01:04:415 (4,5,1,2) - 01:37:955 (1,2,3,4) - etc).
   
5. 01:36:464 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - 02:50:998 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - Too much single tapping, a triple, and stacked notes. This part needs emphasis, but I think it might be too challenging compared to rest of the map.
   
6. 02:35:346 (3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6) - I think this is little too much 1/2 beats, especially compared with 01:20:067 (1,2,3,4,1) -
   
7. 03:03:669 (7,8,9,10,11) - Intentionally wriggly slider? I don’t think it was very effective here.
   
8. 03:02:924 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Consider making these repeating sliders because 1) these 1/4 beats are rather small compared to 03:03:669 (7,8,9,10,11) - , and 2) difficulty reasons.

I mainly focused on Quickly and Actively, because my attention span doesn't last much longer than 1 hour xD

This mod was had more subjective stuff than most other mods I give. I hope you'll find at least some of them helpful /w\. Good luck!

CaffeAmericano wrote:

Hi there~

General
Did you map the all diffs? Have you looked through p/4892052? I think some BNs take issue with multiple diffs by same mapper. I'll remove Slowly and Moderately and add them to the map's description.

Slowly

1. Spacing is inconsistent. I believe all the easy maps should same same spacing throughout? Examples: 00:29:383 (4,1) - spacing decreases, and 00:35:346 (5,1) - increases again Fixed, but this difficulty is being removed.

Quickly

1. I noticed some inconsistencies. For the most part, rhythm is identical, but placing four 1/2 circles is much more difficult than placing two 1/2 sliders. Some examples: ( 01:37:955 (1,2,3,4,5) - 02:52:489 (1,2,3,4) - ) These have identical music. The way you mapped it, hitsound will place at same beats, but 01:37:955 (1,2,3,4,5) - is more difficult than 02:52:489 (1,2,3,4) -. I don’t think this is non-negligible. Repeating same flow/pattern will be boring, but I still think we could use more consistency.
   
2. Along the same line, 01:17:085 (1,2,3) - 02:31:620 (1) - has same beats, but they will play very differently.
   
3. 01:18:576 (6,7,8,9,10) - 02:33:110 (4,5,6,7) - Same here, 01:18:576 (6,7,8,9,10) - feels non-negligibly more difficult. Sometimes maps are repetitive and boring, other times inconsistent and confusing. I am not sure where the boundary exactly lies, but I think this diff definitely crossed that boundary toward being inconsistent and confusing.
   
4. And as the final words on this: If one chorus is to be more difficult than other, I think it should be the second chorus. In this diff, first chorus has more clicks, which makes it more difficult to acc and aim.
   
5. 01:39:073 (3,4,5) - 5 is different from 3,4, so I think they shouldn’t be symmetric Fixed All~!!

Actively

1. 00:55:657 (2,3,4) - 01:07:582 (2,3,4) - I don’t think triangle with same distance fits here nicely here. Symmetric shape with same DS yells identical emphasis, but (based on the music) I think 2 should be emphasized most, 3, and lastly 1. Fixed, I think~
   
2. 01:02:924 (3,4,5,6,7,1) - 01:05:905 (3,4,5,6) - I think this is more difficult than it deserves Fixed~
   
3. 01:23:980 (4,5,6,1) - I think flow could be improved. Relatively big jump with with no sharp turn is awkward to hit at this level. Fixed~
   
4. 01:23:980 (4,5,6,1) - I see a lot of similar patterns in the map, and they almost feel lazy to me. These patterns are frankly just variations of symmetric sliders. I don’t think any of them were terribly misused, but definitely overused IMO. (00:17:458 (1,2,3,4) - 00:48:762 (1,2,3,4) - 01:04:415 (4,5,1,2) - 01:37:955 (1,2,3,4) - etc). This will take some time. >> I'll reduce the frequency of the patterns you mentioned.
   
5. 01:36:464 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - 02:50:998 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - Too much single tapping, a triple, and stacked notes. This part needs emphasis, but I think it might be too challenging compared to rest of the map. Fixed~
   
6. 02:35:346 (3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6) - I think this is little too much 1/2 beats, especially compared with 01:20:067 (1,2,3,4,1) - Fixed~
   
7. 03:03:669 (7,8,9,10,11) - Intentionally wriggly slider? I don’t think it was very effective here. Changed~
   
8. 03:02:924 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Consider making these repeating sliders because 1) these 1/4 beats are rather small compared to 03:03:669 (7,8,9,10,11) - , and 2) difficulty reasons. Fixed~

I mainly focused on Quickly and Actively, because my attention span doesn't last much longer than 1 hour xD

This mod was had more subjective stuff than most other mods I give. I hope you'll find at least some of them helpful /w\. Good luck!

Thanks so much for modding~!! I'll get to your mod as soon as I can.

Hi, sorry for being late.

[Easy]

Generally , this map feels very center heavy. press Ctrl+A to see what I mean; the entire top left and top right corners are ignored. Not sure if this is just your style or something, but it makes the map feel like a donut at times, where you just kinda wrap around the center.

01:17:831 (2,3) - This blanket looks thinner on the right than on the left

01:49:880 - I suggest mapping this downbeat.

01:55:843 (1) - end this on the drum at 01:59:942 - ?

02:36:092 (2,1) - this blanket changes width, keep the distance between the sliders consistent for neatness

Overall, this diff is rather fine but consider the corners thing I mentioned earlier.

[Normal]

This map similarly has the centered feel to it (ctrl+a to see the ignored corners) but its not a huge deal to be honest. I'm not really one to think that it's a problem but beware others may believe so.

00:19:880 (2,3) - not a fan of the way you map this since you're ignoring 00:20:253's sound which you don't do in the other parts

00:23:793 - Why ignore this sound?

01:48:762 - Shouldn't ignore this drum imo

01:49:880 - just like in easy, consider mapping this downbeat

01:55:843 (1) - I suggest ending this at 01:59:942

[Rough]

00:23:793 - as in the other diff I don't think you should ignore this drum

00:41:309 - don't ignore this sound! it's prominent. a hit circle would be great here

01:49:880 - same as other diffs, map this! If you do this, remove the nc on 01:49:135 (1) -

01:55:843 (1) - again as with other diffs, end this on 02:00:688 -

Eh, can't really find a lot with this diff. I disagree with the fact that you mostly mapped vocals because I think the background melody of this song is great and deserves to have the priority when mapping, but that's purely subjective.

For what it is, this diff is rather good.

[Intense]

cs 4.6! woah

Anything I mentioned in previous diffs that applies to all diffs applies to this one as well.

00:47:644 - map this vocal?

Nothing else for this diff specifically.

Good luck!

Hobbes2 wrote:

Hi, sorry for being late.

[Easy]

Generally , this map feels very center heavy. press Ctrl+A to see what I mean; the entire top left and top right corners are ignored. Not sure if this is just your style or something, but it makes the map feel like a donut at times, where you just kinda wrap around the center. Yeah, it is a problem. If I claimed that this is my style, it would be like saying my style is boring to play. I adjusted the pattern during the start of the kiais, but that's all I can do now besides remapping.

01:17:831 (2,3) - This blanket looks thinner on the right than on the left adjusted very slightly

01:49:880 - I suggest mapping this downbeat. That's inconsistent, and since it's a break, it's optional.

01:55:843 (1) - end this on the drum at 01:59:942 - ? Fixed~

02:36:092 (2,1) - this blanket changes width, keep the distance between the sliders consistent for neatness Fixed~

Overall, this diff is rather fine but consider the corners thing I mentioned earlier. Definitely will keep this in mind.

[Normal]

This map similarly has the centered feel to it (ctrl+a to see the ignored corners) but its not a huge deal to be honest. I'm not really one to think that it's a problem but beware others may believe so. I want to fix this, but there's little I can do now except remapping.

00:19:880 (2,3) - not a fan of the way you map this since you're ignoring 00:20:253's sound which you don't do in the other parts Fixed~

00:23:793 - Why ignore this sound? because I'm not following that instrument

01:48:762 - Shouldn't ignore this drum imo ^

01:49:880 - just like in easy, consider mapping this downbeat same reason as easy

01:55:843 (1) - I suggest ending this at 01:59:942 I'd rather follow the lyrics, like most of the map. It can be harder because it's not Easy.

[Rough]

00:23:793 - as in the other diff I don't think you should ignore this drum Fixed, it's more consistent in this difficulty this way ^^

00:41:309 - don't ignore this sound! it's prominent. a hit circle would be great here lyrics

01:49:880 - same as other diffs, map this! If you do this, remove the nc on 01:49:135 (1) - same reason as easy

01:55:843 (1) - again as with other diffs, end this on 02:00:688 - same reason as Normal

Eh, can't really find a lot with this diff. I disagree with the fact that you mostly mapped vocals because I think the background melody of this song is great and deserves to have the priority when mapping, but that's purely subjective. You're right. I should have thought about that when mapping. >> It's too late now.

For what it is, this diff is rather good.

[Intense]

cs 4.6! woah Fixed to 4 what was I thinking?

Anything I mentioned in previous diffs that applies to all diffs applies to this one as well.

00:47:644 - map this vocal? Fixed, but this all has to be stacked on 00:48:017 (3) - this now for spacing

Nothing else for this diff specifically.

Good luck!

Cupholder
Thank you for modding~!!
I'm considering remapping because it would fix the concentration on the middle and the lyrics, but I like the way the map is now, and I don't want to remap again.

Hihi! Nm req from my queueueue

Sorry being late!



Took a quick look at the others and it seems fine.
GL!

_IxApplePie_ wrote:

Hihi! Nm req from my queueueue

Sorry being late!

General

1. 
   the "m" has been cut out a little I'll talk to the sb maker...

Intensely

1. 00:44:104 (1,2) - fix please Please be more specific when you give mods. >> Some mappers won't understand your suggestion if you only say "fix please". You have to describe what the error is, and sometimes how to fix it or why it causes a problem. Judging by context, I think you meant the overlap. Fixed~
2. 01:21:930 (2) - ctrl g? for flow Judging from the difficulty and the lyrics at the moment, I think a flow break is actually good for emphasis here.

Took a quick look at the others and it seems fine.
GL!

Thanks so much for modding~! ^w^

Wow you worked really hard on it I saw your beatmap in a modding queue.I just favourite your beatmap I hope it will help,that's really sad that nobody else did favourite your beatmap :'( sorry for you!

5Atarox wrote:

Wow you worked really hard on it I saw your beatmap in a modding queue.I just favourite your beatmap I hope it will help,that's really sad that nobody else did favourite your beatmap :'( sorry for you!

Thank you so much! ヾ（〃＾∇＾）ﾉ♪

Add Zyl please :3

Zyl wrote:

Add Zyl please :3

Fixed :3

hi
Famously
00:17:271 (5,2) - - These aren't properly stacked... or unstaced it 00:16:899 (3,3) - for consistence
00:29:011 (3,1) - blanket?
00:41:123 (1) - ugly imo
00:47:272 (1,2,3) - unstacked
01:49:135 (7,8,9,10,11) - The pattern desigining is a bit messy here
storyboard:
add flashes
01:14:104 (1) -
02:28:638 (1) -

Sprite,Foreground,Centre,"sb\white.png",320,240
 F,0,74104,74204,0,1
 F,0,74204,77204,1,0
Sprite,Foreground,Centre,"sb\white.png",320,240
 F,0,148638,148738,0,1
 F,0,148738,151738,1,0

white - http://puu.sh/qgJpx/a3a6d70222.png

Good luck.

SherryCherry wrote:

hi
Famously
00:17:271 (5,2) - - These aren't properly stacked... or unstaced it 00:16:899 (3,3) - for consistence
00:29:011 (3,1) - blanket?
00:41:123 (1) - ugly imo no it isn't
00:47:272 (1,2,3) - unstacked
01:49:135 (7,8,9,10,11) - The pattern desigining is a bit messy here
storyboard: I'll leave sb stuff to Zyl

Good luck.

no reply=fixed~!!
Thanks for modding! ^^

SherryCherry wrote:

hi
storyboard:
add flashes
01:14:104 (1) -
02:28:638 (1) -

Sprite,Foreground,Centre,"sb\white.png",320,240
 F,0,74104,74204,0,1
 F,0,74204,77204,1,0
Sprite,Foreground,Centre,"sb\white.png",320,240
 F,0,148638,148738,0,1
 F,0,148738,151738,1,0

white - http://puu.sh/qgJpx/a3a6d70222.png

Good luck.

I don't really see them necessary

m4m~ you did mine already xd

Easily

1. that diff name tho xd
2. 00:15:967 (1,2) - make these parallel
3. 00:17:458 (2,3) - 00:24:166 (3,1) - this is kind of a rough angle and doesn't look very good
4. 00:23:048 (2,3) - looks bad because not pointing directly at 3
5. 00:33:856 (1,2,3) - looks bad because it looks like you went for symmetry~but it isn't symmetrical
6. also because of the pace of the song I would NC this half as much as you are now. because the bpm is really half of what you got
7. 00:30:129 (3,1) - 00:35:346 (3,4,1) - 00:47:644 (2,3) - 00:59:942 (4,1) - 01:15:222 (3,4) - rough angle but looks ok
8. 00:39:818 (1) - the angle both these sides are at should be 1. parallel with 00:41:309 (2) - and 2. somewhat in line with 00:38:328 (2) -
9. 00:45:781 (1) - I appreciate this.
10. 01:24:166 (3,5) - really bad overlap
    you have more rough angles but some people really don't like them ~esp if they don't look good. for the sake of them not playing too well for easy players.

Normally

1. that diff name tho xd
2. 00:27:147 (5) - 00:35:346 (3,4) - 00:47:272 (3) - 00:53:234 (4) - 00:57:706 (1) - 01:06:651 (1) - could improve blanket
3. 01:08:887 (4) - this looks ugly and doesn't play too well
4. 01:22:489 (4) - make a straight line off of 3
5. tbh the kiai should be DS +.1 of normal DS
6. xd dude

short mod bc our styles conflict and I'm not sure what to say about your map(s), I think aesthetics are great and all but too much symmetry/blankets takes away from the quality play-ability wise. penis. Good luck with ranking xd

Pyroflayer wrote:

m4m~ you did mine already xd

Easily

1. that diff name tho xd
2. 00:15:967 (1,2) - make these parallel
3. 00:17:458 (2,3) - 00:24:166 (3,1) - this is kind of a rough angle and doesn't look very good Fixed the first, but I don't see the problem with the second
4. 00:23:048 (2,3) - looks bad because not pointing directly at 3
5. 00:33:856 (1,2,3) - looks bad because it looks like you went for symmetry~but it isn't symmetrical
6. also because of the pace of the song I would NC this half as much as you are now. because the bpm is really half of what you got no thanks
7. 00:30:129 (3,1) - 00:35:346 (3,4,1) - 00:47:644 (2,3) - 00:59:942 (4,1) - 01:15:222 (3,4) - rough angle but looks ok fixed none, they play well enough
8. 00:39:818 (1) - the angle both these sides are at should be 1. parallel with 00:41:309 (2) - and 2. somewhat in line with 00:38:328 (2) - fixed a little
9. 00:45:781 (1) - I appreciate this.
10. 01:24:166 (3,5) - really bad overlap
    you have more rough angles but some people really don't like them ~esp if they don't look good. for the sake of them not playing too well for easy players.

Normally

1. that diff name tho xd
2. 00:27:147 (5) - 00:35:346 (3,4) - 00:47:272 (3) - 00:53:234 (4) - 00:57:706 (1) - 01:06:651 (1) - could improve blanket all fixed
3. 01:08:887 (4) - this looks ugly and doesn't play too well
4. 01:22:489 (4) - make a straight line off of 3 I don't have to
5. tbh the kiai should be DS +.1 of normal DS that makes it harder
6. xd dude

short mod bc our styles conflict and I'm not sure what to say about your map(s), I think aesthetics are great and all but too much symmetry/blankets takes away from the quality play-ability wise. penis. Good luck with ranking xd

No comment=fixed!
Thanks for modding~!!

hi m4m from modreqs


lets get started





[General]
-Rename mp3 to audio to keep organised
-Blankets in hardest diff need to be improved
-when it comes to 'they play well enough' vs 'they look good' I would suggest you take the 'they look good' go around and fix weird slider shapes



[Famously]
00:38:141 (1) - this goes stragitht through a downbeat, which is meant to be clicked
00:38:141 (1,2) - you can fix the blanket here
00:39:818 (1,2) - make these more symetrical
00:44:104 (1) - same thing as before, it goes right through a downbeat
00:44:104 (1,2) - Blanket can be improved, use approach circle as refrence
00:50:626 (2,3) - ^
00:57:147 (2,3) - this blanket is a little better but it could stil be touched up a bit
00:57:706 (1,2) - blanket this, and make 00:57:706 (1) - this a normal curved slider
01:38:700 (3,4) - honestly, improve this blanket
01:48:762 (4) - nc
01:49:135 (7) - nc and fix the shape 01:49:135 (7,8,9,10,11) - of the stream
01:55:843 (1) - this is a long unnecesarry slider, remove it and actually map, it looks like you went full on lazy mode. I mean theres too much vocal action
02:04:787 (1,2,3) - inconsistant spacing
02:27:147 - seems a bit too long, add a break here



[Roughly]
00:37:582 (2) - I think you can make this a completly straight slider
00:57:334 (5,6,1) - blanket is off, fix it
01:08:141 (4,5,6) - this could be a 1/1 reverse slider
01:55:843 (1) - same thing with the last diff, kind of unecesarry
02:02:551 (4,5) - blanket these
02:28:638 (1,2) - this blanket can be improved

Whirl wrote:

hi m4m from modreqs


lets get started





[General]
-Rename mp3 to audio to keep organised why?
-Blankets in hardest diff need to be improved I'll work on this
-when it comes to 'they play well enough' vs 'they look good' I would suggest you take the 'they look good' go around and fix weird slider shapes both are important!



[Famously]
00:38:141 (1) - this goes straight through a downbeat, which is meant to be clicked while clickable downbeats is recommended, it's okay to skip them as long as you're following the song's rhythm. In this case, the held out lyrics is on the red tick just before the downbeat.
00:38:141 (1,2) - you can fix the blanket here changed 1 pixel
00:39:818 (1,2) - make these more symmetrical fixed I think, but it was close enough already
00:44:104 (1) - same thing as before, it goes right through a downbeat same response
00:44:104 (1,2) - Blanket can be improved, use approach circle as refrence fixed~
00:50:626 (2,3) - ^ fixed~
00:57:147 (2,3) - this blanket is a little better but it could stil be touched up a bit fixed~
00:57:706 (1,2) - blanket this, and make 00:57:706 (1) - this a normal curved slider blanket fixed, but there's no need to curve
01:38:700 (3,4) - honestly, improve this blanket fixed~
01:48:762 (4) - nc 1 measure reasoning
01:49:135 (7) - nc and fix the shape 01:49:135 (7,8,9,10,11) - of the stream 1 measure reasoning but sure I can make the stream straight if you want
01:55:843 (1) - this is a long unnecesarry slider, remove it and actually map, it looks like you went full on lazy mode. I mean theres too much vocal action that was a little rude, please look at what the ranking criteria says about spinners: http://puu.sh/qnA7N/da3f30e43c.jpg
02:04:787 (1,2,3) - inconsistent spacing emphasis 02:05:160 - here
02:27:147 - seems a bit too long, add a break here it's unneeded



[Roughly]
00:37:582 (2) - I think you can make this a completely straight slider it is a straight slider? I changed something else
00:57:334 (5,6,1) - blanket is off, fix it it's fine with the stacking
01:08:141 (4,5,6) - this could be a 1/1 reverse slider that would make the difficulty less consistent from the other verse
01:55:843 (1) - same thing with the last diff, kind of unnecessary same response
02:02:551 (4,5) - blanket these It's unneccesary
02:28:638 (1,2) - this blanket can be improved that's not a blanket, I changed it

Thanks for modding~!!

Hello. M4M from #modreqs

Generally
I think that your stats is a bit weird. Try this:

1. Easily: CS:3 AR:3 OD:3 HP:3
2. Normally: CS:3,5 AR:5 OD:5 HP:5
3. Roughly: keep as it is
4. Famously: CS:4,5 AR:8,5 OD:8 or 8,5 HP:7

Easily
00:18:948 (1,2) - improve blanket
01:26:029 (1,2) - ^
00:39:818 (1) - this slider is too much sharp, try make it smoother
01:25:657 (5,1,2,3) - make it like this maybe?
02:25:657 (1,2) - change them into a spinner? I think it would be better, since at (1) we can hear continuous vocal

Normally
01:30:315 (4,5) - improve blanket
02:38:514 - ignoring this feels so weird, especially when it's stacked

Roughly
00:17:458 (5) - NC
00:31:247 (2,3) - unstuck. I think stucking this two 00:30:874 (1,2) - would be more logical
00:57:334 (5,6) - unstuck
01:18:576 (6) - this slider feels a little bit out of place. I think you should delete it and put a note at 01:18:762 - . It's really feels better
01:24:911 (5,6) - three notes on a white ticks would feet here better
01:36:464 (5) - NC
02:59:570 (3,4,5) - move them a little bit further, like here 02:56:029 (2,3) -

Famously
01:17:831 (3,4,5,1) - this pattern feels a bit weird. this should be better (it feels like it was this way earlier, why do you changed it into this?)
01:23:421 (2) - ctrl+g would look more interesting
01:27:520 (1,2,3,4) - try it like this
01:32:551 (2,4) - this feels kinda random. This should be better
01:57:986 - please make this break normal (until 02:01:060 - atleast)
01:11:123 (1,2,3,4,1) - 02:24:166 (1,2,3,4,1) - same patterns? really?

You have interesting style. Good luck!

M4M return mod from queue~
i havent heard GUMI in ages wow

General
-nice storyboard!
-add custom hitsounds? you should also hitsound the drum claps (for example, here 00:15:595)

Famously
00:26:216 (1,2) - flow not great, move 2 up
00:29:756 (2) - fix DS, need to adjust 00:30:501 (4) as well
00:39:632 (4,1) - this jump is a bit too much imo
00:54:725 - add finish
01:20:067 - ^
01:21:557 (1,2,3,4) - spacing looks off here, make sure 3 is the same spacing away from 1,2 as 4 is
01:31:992 - add finish
01:43:918 - ^
01:49:508 (11) - if you want a finish here, use a different sound cuz there isnt a cymbal crash here
02:04:787 (1) - ^
02:07:582 (6,1) - i think this would flow better if the slider went in a counterclockwise motion instead. youll need to change 02:09:259 (1) as well.
02:14:104 (2,3) - this jump is super huge, tone it down
02:16:713 (1) - use different finish sound
02:34:601 - add finish
02:58:452 - ^
03:04:042 - use different finish sound

Easily
-the difficulty difference between non-kiai and kiai-parts seems kinda big. starting from this section 01:00:688 there is a 1 beat break in between every object. but then in the kiai, there are significantly fewer breaks. so i'd suggest either making the kiai have more breaks, or remove some breaks in the section before it.
01:55:843 (1) - spinner feels awkward, try extending it to here? 02:00:315
00:42:800 (1) - add finish
00:54:725 - ^
02:07:769 - ^
02:28:638 - ^
02:40:564 - ^

diffs are very neat, so nice job
good luck~

collector7 wrote:

Hello. M4M from #modreqs

Generally

I guess this is not suppose to be that way?

that's not how it looks on my screen >>
I think that your stats is a bit weird. Try this:

1. Easily: CS:3 AR:3 OD:3 HP:3
2. Normally: CS:3,5 AR:5 OD:5 HP:5
3. Roughly: keep as it is
4. Famously: CS:4,5 AR:8,5 OD:8 or 8,5 HP:7 I did something similar

Easily
00:18:948 (1,2) - improve blanket
01:26:029 (1,2) - ^
00:39:818 (1) - this slider is too much sharp, try make it smoother
01:25:657 (5,1,2,3) - make it like this maybe?
02:25:657 (1,2) - change them into a spinner? I think it would be better, since at (1) we can hear continuous vocal I prefer the current method

Normally
01:30:315 (4,5) - improve blanket
02:38:514 - ignoring this feels so weird, especially when it's stacked

Roughly
00:17:458 (5) - NC 2 measure reasoning
00:31:247 (2,3) - unstuck. I think stucking this two 00:30:874 (1,2) - would be more logical
00:57:334 (5,6) - unstuck
01:18:576 (6) - this slider feels a little bit out of place. I think you should delete it and put a note at 01:18:762 - . It's really feels better I did something similar
01:24:911 (5,6) - three notes on a white ticks would feet here better I prefer the current pattern
01:36:464 (5) - NC
02:59:570 (3,4,5) - move them a little bit further, like here 02:56:029 (2,3) -

Famously
01:17:831 (3,4,5,1) - this pattern feels a bit weird. this should be better (it feels like it was this way earlier, why do you changed it into this?)
01:23:421 (2) - ctrl+g would look more interesting
01:27:520 (1,2,3,4) - try it like this
01:32:551 (2,4) - this feels kinda random. This should be better
01:57:986 - please make this break normal (until 02:01:060 - atleast)
01:11:123 (1,2,3,4,1) - 02:24:166 (1,2,3,4,1) - same patterns? really?

You have interesting style. Good luck!

no reply=fixed, thanks!

Yahuri wrote:

M4M return mod from queue~
i havent heard GUMI in ages wow

General
-nice storyboard! Zyl made the storyboard
-add custom hitsounds? No, lol, telling someone they'd benefit from custom hitsounds is like telling someone they'd benefit from having a storyboard, it's unnecessary you should also hitsound the drum claps (for example, here 00:15:595) I did that and added a lot more volume control

Famously
00:26:216 (1,2) - flow not great, move 2 up I'd rather rotate 00:26:216 (1) - this
00:29:756 (2) - fix DS, need to adjust 00:30:501 (4) as well
00:39:632 (4,1) - this jump is a bit too much imo
00:54:725 - add finish
01:20:067 - ^
01:21:557 (1,2,3,4) - spacing looks off here, make sure 3 is the same spacing away from 1,2 as 4 is It is the same spacing
01:31:992 - add finish
01:43:918 - ^
01:49:508 (11) - if you want a finish here, use a different sound cuz there isnt a cymbal crash here
02:04:787 (1) - ^
02:07:582 (6,1) - i think this would flow better if the slider went in a counterclockwise motion instead. youll need to change 02:09:259 (1) as well. flow change is good because of the new combo and new sound
02:14:104 (2,3) - this jump is super huge, tone it down
02:16:713 (1) - use different finish sound
02:34:601 - add finish
02:58:452 - ^
03:04:042 - use different finish sound I removed the finish whenever you said this

Easily
-the difficulty difference between non-kiai and kiai-parts seems kinda big. starting from this section 01:00:688 there is a 1 beat break in between every object. but then in the kiai, there are significantly fewer breaks. so i'd suggest either making the kiai have more breaks, or remove some breaks in the section before it. Okay, I removed like a few notes from the kiai
01:55:843 (1) - spinner feels awkward, try extending it to here? 02:00:315 Sure
00:42:800 (1) - add finish I'll just hitsound copy from Famously
00:54:725 - ^
02:07:769 - ^
02:28:638 - ^
02:40:564 - ^

diffs are very neat, so nice job
good luck~

no reply=fixed
Thanks for modding~!!

M4M:
Good luck >w<''

All fixed on Roughly, now named Hard.

Map is WIP, being remapped, if you have been asked to mod this, only mod Easy, Normal, and Hard.

eyo, m4m
I do not normally map or mod easier diffs, but here i go xD
sorry, i modded these out of proper order, so sue me xD

Hard
00:41:868 (5,6) - I think it would fit the rythym more to make it a hit circle on the red tick followed by a slider starting on the following white
01:25:657 - sounds weird to me having a slider end here, since it would make much more since for one to start on this strong sound
01:55:843 (1) - i understand why you made a spinner here, it just seems unneccesary and i think just normal hitcircles and sliders would fit better, since the spinner is not really following any particular sound...it is just there if that makes sense
02:54:539 (6) - I think it would be cool if you made the edges of this slider and 02:53:980 (5) - parallel, it would look nicer imo

Normal
I would like to make the same point about the spinner lol, for some reason it bothers me, sort of a personal thing
if you press ctrl+A, i would prefer that it would be more spread out to cover more of the playing area, but since that would require a remap i dont think it is that necessary to do, just felt like pointing it out
01:21:557 (3,4) - just personal thing, i would prefer if the end of 3 lined up more with 4

Easy
Sorry man.......cant find anything wrong here xd

sorry that this was so short, i looked at the maps for a while, and i could not find anything else lol, good job, take a star

[ RSI ] wrote:

eyo, m4m
I do not normally map or mod easier diffs, but here i go xD
sorry, i modded these out of proper order, so sue me xD

Hard
00:41:868 (5,6) - I think it would fit the rythym more to make it a hit circle on the red tick followed by a slider starting on the following white
01:25:657 - sounds weird to me having a slider end here, since it would make much more since for one to start on this strong sound
01:55:843 (1) - i understand why you made a spinner here, it just seems unneccesary and i think just normal hitcircles and sliders would fit better, since the spinner is not really following any particular sound...it is just there if that makes sense
02:54:539 (6) - I think it would be cool if you made the edges of this slider and 02:53:980 (5) - parallel, it would look nicer imo

Normal
I would like to make the same point about the spinner lol, for some reason it bothers me, sort of a personal thing
if you press ctrl+A, i would prefer that it would be more spread out to cover more of the playing area, but since that would require a remap i dont think it is that necessary to do, just felt like pointing it out you're absolutely correct and I should be remapping this difficulty but I'm too lazy at the moment
01:21:557 (3,4) - just personal thing, i would prefer if the end of 3 lined up more with 4

Easy
Sorry man.......cant find anything wrong here xd

sorry that this was so short, i looked at the maps for a while, and i could not find anything else lol, good job, take a star

Fixed everything, thanks for modding ^^

Hi M4M from your queue :3





2016 symmetry mapping, fun stuff.



ohhhhh shit didn't read that insane is being remapped T____T blame me.

LMT1996 wrote:

Hi M4M from your queue :3

Insane

00:24:725 - I'd map the piano triples here, stacked with the sliderhead because you're strictly following the piano on this measure.
00:29:197 (5,1) - It seems like you're following the vocals here, in that case 5 should get the emphasis rather than the downbeat. If you want to switch to the synth line then the jump here shouldn't be this big because the vocal has such a strong emphasis on the red tick and by the time the player gets to the downbeat the momentum is already lost, ie. nerf jump if switching instruments.
00:35:346 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - so there are 2 rhythm patterns here that you can try to emphasise: the synth goes like white -> red -> white tick (00:35:346 (1,4,7) - ) and the drums + vocals go like 1/2s (00:35:346 (1,3,5,7) - ) . The 1/2s play better in general and you can always hitsound the red tick to emphasise the synth on the way. You can map them either 1/2 sliders (which is what I would do) or 1/2 circles like these, but if you choose to map circles you have to make the spacing from red to white ticks somewhat bigger, maybe like , 1.2x , white -> red 1.0x . I'll just tell you now the I'm trying to follow the vocals for the whole map, except for when they're unavailable of course. My reasoning for this pattern was to have the player click for all of the vocal sounds and pitch changes. I'm accelerating the spacing 00:35:346 (1,2,3,4) - here, and decelerating the spacing 00:35:906 (4,5,6,7) - here.
01:05:160 (1,2,3) - these should be grouped together and 4 should be left out, ie. 123 4, instead of 12 34 because the vocal stresses 1 2 3 more than 4. You can make 2 as the mirror for 1 and 3, and then 4 can be somewhat random.
01:17:085 (1,2) - The symmetry here is fun but because 01:16:526 (4,5,6,1) - are really big jumps and you want to make the flow for 1 easy to catch. You can try to like rotate 01:17:085 (1) - 45° clockwise (you can do the same for 2 to preserve symmetry) to curve out flow. If you agree with this suggestion hopefully you can find the same places throughout this map, good thing is your map is like really structured. This section is being remapped :3
01:48:390 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - if you're following the bass synth (which is the only rhythm that has purely 1/2s) then 01:49:694 - there's another note here. This section is being remapped :3
01:57:334 (1,2,3) - and obviously 02:00:315 (1,2,3) - , you probably want to put a reverse arrow on the red tick since the vocal note on the red ticks are definitely not random. ???
02:13:731 - to 02:25:470 - I think you probably should map this section. The break is too long and there's definitely something worth mapping here.
02:48:762 (4,5) - I'm not entirely sure why you want to map circle+reverse slider here, shouldn't 2 1/2 sliders work here? Right so, if you want to follow the piano , yes this works, but then 02:48:016 (1,2,3) - has to follow suit. Right now it sounds to me that you're mixing two lines in one measure It is mapped.

Hard

00:26:029 (2,3) - so yeah it's kinda off-putting for the player here since at this skill level the players are not used to reading red ticks so playing has to be a bit easier (hard to read -> easy to play) has to be a bit easier so I'd avoid like a double (white -> red tick) like this. Something like this? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/5856938 , my design isn't too well thought-out here, just basically the note on the white tick can be a slidertail to help with the player's reading. fixed for different reasons, 00:25:657 - this needed more emphasis
01:16:340 - I usually agree with you not mapping this tick, but it seems like it's way too strong to ignore it here, you can put a circle just below the slider for a blanket.
01:17:831 (3,4) - The vocal on the red tick is actually structured throughout this map so ignoring this tick could make the player think the second circle being the one on the red tick, again reading capabilities for players at this skill level isn't great so let's try to make things easier for them.
01:31:620 (7) - I'd prefer this being a 1/2 slider since the vocal is extended. But if that affects your aesthetics or flow then you should keep it as such.
01:36:837 (2,3) - umm the spacing could be umm, more straightforward here, the player could misread this as 1/1 .
02:51:744 (7,8) - can this be a 1/2 slider? Since 5 1/2s in a row is actually somewhat hard, of course at this skill level. I'm not ruining that pattern though. The difficulty is good, this is supposed to the the hard part.

Normal

00:19:880 (2,3,4) - Umm this is like a difficulty spike (high clicking density) very early on, not to mention the sliderhead is on the red tick. So the slider could have a reverse arrow on white tick and ends on the red tick to reduce the number of circles to click and probably make it easier for the player to read as well. I switched it around a little.

Easy

00:18:948 (1,2) - I know it's a bit boring to have 3/2 reverse sliders all over the place but varying 1/2 gaps on Easy for beginners are really nasty. It plays fine since the player is already used to the rhythm.

2016 symmetry mapping, fun stuff.



ohhhhh shit didn't read that insane is being remapped T____T blame me. Actually you're fine since Insane is remapped except for the copy/paste sections.

No Reply=Fixed, Thanks for modding~!!

]I was going to do a M4M but the map is incredibly well mapped I think I'll just mod it. (Beginner mod, please provide feedback.) General

AImod says the kiai on 01:14:036 isn't snapped, might want to check that.

Easy, Normal, Hard

None, well mapped!


Overall, nice mapset! I'm kinda interested in mapping a LN guestdif but I'm probably too unexperienced .

I still don't know how to format modposts Any help?

ThePyroBear wrote:

]I was going to do a M4M but the map is incredibly well mapped I think I'll just mod it. (Beginner mod, please provide feedback.) General

AImod says the kiai on 01:14:036 isn't snapped, might want to check that.

Easy, Normal, Hard

None, well mapped!

Famous

00:35:346(1,2,3,4,5,6,7) Is overmapped the right word here? I recommend erasing [00:35:346](2,4,6) You're absolutely correct, it is overmapped. I removed the note 00:35:533 - here.
01:24:539(1,2,3,4,5,6) I'm not sure what it's following, the vocals or the melody? I suggest just leaving it blank. Adding a normal slider in its place might work. Drums.
01:36:464(1,2) The same goes for here ^^^
01:34:974(1) The circle doesn't really fit maybe remove it and make the jump into a triangle? There's a pretty clear vocal there.
01:48:390(1,2) Again, except this time, I recommend adding a hitcircle in place of the first kick slider. Drums :3
02:39:073(1,2,3,4,5,6) Again, maybe remove 2,3,5,6 only? Drums :3
01:57:334(1,1,1) Make them half the length and repeat it. Just like [02:07:769](1) I don't see the correlation between those sections.
02:39:073 (1,2,3,4,5,6) Oh hey, this again, just like the earlier suggestions. Drums :3
02:50:998(1,2) You know the drill. Drums :3
03:02:924(1,2) The last one! The same as before. Drums :3

Overall, nice mapset! I'm kinda interested in mapping a LN guestdif but I'm probably too unexperienced . I actually wouldn't be able to tell since I have zero experience with mania.

I still don't know how to format modposts Any help?

If you like the song then please support my project!! https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/5443377/
I'll make you a template for formatting mods. :3
Thanks for modding~!!

Hi~
[box=Normal]
I think inconsistent spacing:
00:15:408 (4) -
00:26:402 (4) -
00:39:446 (4) -
00:42:426 (4) -
00:43:918 (2) -
00:48:762 (1) -
00:54:352 (6) -
01:02:924 (5) -
01:03:669 (1) -
01:10:005 (2) -
01:15:408 (3) -
01:23:793 (2) -
01:24:166 (3) -
01:30:315 (4) -
01:48:017 (4) -
01:49:135 (5) -
02:07:023 (5) -
02:08:887 (2) -
02:18:203 (4) -
02:19:694 (1) -
02:21:185 (3) -

Sorry, if the spacing is only like ~3 grids off, (most of what you pointed out was 0.87x) then the DS is close enough to count. Also, it looks like you only checked this difficulty, and you just looked for this one thing, so no KD.
Regardless, thanks for looking at my map.

Jonawaga wrote:

quote

-SuGon- wrote:

Hi~
[box=Normal]
I think inconsistent spacing:
00:15:408 (4) -
00:26:402 (4) -
00:39:446 (4) -
00:42:426 (4) -
00:43:918 (2) -
00:48:762 (1) -
00:54:352 (6) -
01:02:924 (5) -
01:03:669 (1) -
01:10:005 (2) -
01:15:408 (3) -
01:23:793 (2) -
01:24:166 (3) -
01:30:315 (4) -
01:48:017 (4) -
01:49:135 (5) -
02:07:023 (5) -
02:08:887 (2) -
02:18:203 (4) -
02:19:694 (1) -
02:21:185 (3) -

Sorry, if the spacing is only like ~3 grids off, (most of what you pointed out was 0.87x) then the DS is close enough to count. Also, it looks like you only checked this difficulty, and you just looked for this one thing, so no KD.
Regardless, thanks for looking at my map.

Can I checked other things continue ?

-SuGon- wrote:

Jonawaga wrote:

quote

Hi~
[box=Normal]
I think inconsistent spacing:
00:15:408 (4) -
00:26:402 (4) -
00:39:446 (4) -
00:42:426 (4) -
00:43:918 (2) -
00:48:762 (1) -
00:54:352 (6) -
01:02:924 (5) -
01:03:669 (1) -
01:10:005 (2) -
01:15:408 (3) -
01:23:793 (2) -
01:24:166 (3) -
01:30:315 (4) -
01:48:017 (4) -
01:49:135 (5) -
02:07:023 (5) -
02:08:887 (2) -
02:18:203 (4) -
02:19:694 (1) -
02:21:185 (3) -

Sorry, if the spacing is only like ~3 grids off, (most of what you pointed out was 0.87x) then the DS is close enough to count. Also, it looks like you only checked this difficulty, and you just looked for this one thing, so no KD.
Regardless, thanks for looking at my map.

Can I checked other things continue ?

Of course, just don't look at the ds to much. I recommend you read some of this guide on modding so you can become more aware of what to look for when giving a mod: click here derp

[/quote]
Of course, just don't look at the ds to much. I recommend you read some of this guide on modding so you can become more aware of what to look for when giving a mod: click here derp[/quote]

OK! Thanks!

Hi
[Normal]
According to https://osu.ppy.sh/wiki/Normal
Normal Setup
HP Drain Rate: 5 or below
Circle Size: 3 or 4
Approach Rate: 5 or below
Overall Difficulty: 5 or below

I like your map.(Good!) I can't give u another advice.

-SuGon- wrote:

Hi
[Normal]
According to https://osu.ppy.sh/wiki/Normal
Normal Setup
HP Drain Rate: 5 or below
Circle Size: 3 or 4
Approach Rate: 5 or below Fixed the AR, thanks~
Overall Difficulty: 5 or below
Keep in mind that these are approximates and can be broken as necessary. In this case, I agree with you about the AR.

I like your map.(Good!) I can't give u another advice.

Thanks for modding~!

Done my part i guess

Nerf'ed a bit!

I noticed the name of our collab diff has been changed. I am sorry but please do not use such collab diff name. The reason is just my own preference.
You could use Regraz and Jonawaga's Collab Light Insane or just Collab Light Insane if you think the former would be too long.
Sorry for the inconvenience.
Since this map is graveyarded and maybe you dont want to update it in the near future, it's okay! Please just change the diff name the next time you update it.
Thank you!

Regraz wrote:

I noticed the name of our collab diff has been changed. I am sorry but please do not use such collab diff name. The reason is just my own preference.
You could use Regraz and Jonawaga's Collab Light Insane or just Collab Light Insane if you think the former would be too long.
Sorry for the inconvenience.
Since this map is graveyarded and maybe you dont want to update it in the near future, it's okay! Please just change the diff name the next time you update it.
Thank you!

fixed >///<

This modding thread has been migrated to the new "modding discussions" system. Please make sure to re-post any existing (and unresolved) efforts to the new system as required.