forum

"This score doesn't look right" Thread

posted
Total Posts
2,149
show more
Roddie

mikhe wrote:

James2250 wrote:

He is banned now~

None of this ever happened :D
Sure? -3-
http://osu.ppy.sh/u/supaaa

Oh wow.... xD
Zekira
So we now apparently now that osu! can handle up to 65535 combo...?

...seriously how the hell do people break these things o_o
kaouji
hacker the communication data packets and upload to the server.
how to deal with the guy?
he play with proxy and useless to ban his IP.
Beuchi

Lunah wrote:

But if "this multiaccount" is a multiaccount of a cheater ?

i quote DB, moderator always say to go here
I don't really think a moderator would tell you to post here since this thread is to report scores, as it says on its title...

Intermezzo, on another page on this thread wrote:

Guys this is not the thread to argue suspicions or to spot multi accounts.
You can post multiaccounts as long as they have something related to bugged/suspicious scores.
Avatare
no matter what you think beauchi something. Then Mods have asked people to come here to report multiaccounts. I see this as a "spot a cheater" thread. I would imagine most others do too.
Bass
Stop shitting bout this, that Refresh = Defresh. I requested yaya to !multi Refresh and:





Anyway yeah, Refresh should be banned.
8Ball
refresh = frill
Ibuki Suika
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/13223
#1 BinJip


In 1hour,A→S,#30→#1?
HID?

I think I need a video...
I do not think someone can HIDfc this 7minutes song in 1 hour
dNextGen

wuliang wrote:

http://osu.ppy.sh/s/13223
#1 BinJip
[attachment=0:bd7f0]QQ スクリーンショット.png[/attachment:bd7f0]

In 1hour,A→S,#30→#1?
HID?

I think I need a video...
I do not think someone can HIDfc this 7minutes song in 1 hour
100% legit i think



he played that song over 120 times

and i spectated him in that time

also BinJip is one of the skilled player but not famous like cookie,shagg dll
KRZY

wuliang wrote:

http://osu.ppy.sh/s/13223
#1 BinJip
[attachment=0:6346f]QQ スクリーンショット.png[/attachment:6346f]

In 1hour,A→S,#30→#1?
HID?

I think I need a video...
I do not think someone can HIDfc this 7minutes song in 1 hour


Please, just because you can't doesn't mean others can't either.

There are people who can HD FC songs on their first tries (/me stares at Lyby), it is NOT cool to accuse everyone for everything.

Also, if you are going to cheat, why make that #30 record in the first place?





Also2, I didn't knpw Binjip had done that. GJ to him.
Ibuki Suika

dNextGen wrote:

100% legit i think



he played that song over 120 times

and i spectated him in that time

also BinJip is one of the skilled player but not famous like cookie,shagg dll
All right
if you spectated him in that time,
I Believe ;)
kaouji

KRZY wrote:

Please, just because you can't doesn't mean others can't either.

There are people who can HD FC songs on their first tries (/me stares at Lyby), it is NOT cool to accuse everyone for everything.

Also, if you are going to cheat, why make that #30 record in the first place?
if i'm going to cheat,i will use 200PC to play by hand,just cheat in the last time.
that's why and it can't be a reason to proof it's nothing wrong,right?
Orkel
Okay how the hell is this possible:

http://osu.ppy.sh/p/beatmap?b=52735&m=1

Rokodo's taiko flashlight/hidden/hardrock S, the notes are completely invisible so it means that he either has memorized the entire map down to each taiko beat position and color, or he cheats. Go watch it and see for yourself.
Zetta

Orkel wrote:

Okay how the hell is this possible:

http://osu.ppy.sh/p/beatmap?b=52735&m=1

Rokodo's taiko flashlight/hidden/hardrock S, the notes are completely invisible so it means that he either has memorized the entire map down to each taiko beat position and color, or he cheats. Go watch it and see for yourself.
I don't think Rokodo would hack to be honest as he sort of has a reputation around here.

BUT. Having watched the replay it does seem a little fishy especially combined with the fact that the song is nowhere to be found in his historical statistics page.

Though, he IS rank 16 on Taiko and regarded as "one of the best"
KRZY

kaouji wrote:

KRZY wrote:

Please, just because you can't doesn't mean others can't either.

There are people who can HD FC songs on their first tries (/me stares at Lyby), it is NOT cool to accuse everyone for everything.

Also, if you are going to cheat, why make that #30 record in the first place?
if i'm going to cheat,i will use 200PC to play by hand,just cheat in the last time.
that's why and it can't be a reason to proof it's nothing wrong,right?
Fair point.
maay

Orkel wrote:

Okay how the hell is this possible:

http://osu.ppy.sh/p/beatmap?b=52735&m=1

Rokodo's taiko flashlight/hidden/hardrock S, the notes are completely invisible so it means that he either has memorized the entire map down to each taiko beat position and color, or he cheats. Go watch it and see for yourself.
Interesting.
Well, I've noticed he has tons of HD+FL scores on insane maps but I can't tell whether he took the time to memorize all of those maps or if he is just using two pcs. Respect to him if he actually took the time to memorize all of the maps in which he has HD+FL scores.
SilentWings_old
Can't you just write down/record down the notes on paper or something for taiko?
pieguyn
I thought everyone already talked about Rokodo and found he used a double monitor in order to FC maps with hidden+flashlight (but also that it was apparently allowed...? I consider it cheating but that doesn't seem to be the general consensus).

Also, for other instances of this, I should point out that hidden+flashlight is easy enough on Taiko as long as you memorize the whole thing.
maay

pieguy1372 wrote:

it was apparently allowed...?
but that's completely stupid
dNextGen

SuperMaay wrote:

but that's completely stupid
where is the stupid point of using 2 pc/monitor
Gomo Psivarh

dNextGen wrote:

SuperMaay wrote:

but that's completely stupid
where is the stupid point of using 2 pc/monitor
IMO,using 2 computers to play FL+Hid is just cheating.
Rokodo
Cheating is defined as:
a) Manipulation of the osu! client.
b) Use of macros to enable automated full combo sequences.

I have done neither of these things.
youngdow
Rokodo doesn't use hack ^^;

This argument has been already discussed and concluded, I hope people don't bring this up anymore :)
maay

Gomo Psivarh wrote:

IMO,using 2 computers to play FL+Hid is just cheating.
Same. I believe Taiko wasn't meant to be played that way. He gets a huge advantage over other players (he plays with 1,18x while the others play with 1x), which is why I consider it cheating, too.
Hakurei Reimu
http://osu.ppy.sh/b/66441
#1 HR+FL+DT in easy SS
#2 HR+FL in normal SS

only just one time?

Teras

SuperMaay wrote:

Gomo Psivarh wrote:

IMO,using 2 computers to play FL+Hid is just cheating.
Same. I believe Taiko wasn't meant to be played that way. He gets a huge advantage over other players (he plays with 1,18x while the others play with 1x), which is why I consider it cheating, too.
Well. All the asian players have one of those drum things that we can't use. Fair enough
Teras

a139838457 wrote:

http://osu.ppy.sh/b/66441
#1 HR+FL+DT in easy SS
#2 HR+FL in normal SS

only just one time?
That's not even a strange score lmao.
Melancholy
a
maay

Teras wrote:

Well. All the asian players have one of those drum things that we can't use. Fair enough
What prevents you from getting one from playasia or such? I'd rather use a special keyboard if I were to play Taiko, though. Tatacons seem to be quite tiring...
Lunah_old

Rokodo wrote:

Cheating is defined as:
a) Manipulation of the osu! client.
b) Use of macros to enable automated full combo sequences.
.
so, Moneto& co and who use the "cheat" for play in flashlight don't are cheaters (i don't say nothing about that because someone in staff asked me), they don't manipulate the osu client :0 , i think using 2 computer / monitors is unfair , or macros in taiko D: much players use it, but anyone care about ban or do other

i'm not accusing anyone, i think only, who all controlls this game need do something ..
maay
I believe they did manipulate the osu! client... from what moneto said, he made the osu! window transparent. Also, he hacked the client so he could open 2 of it, so he did manipulate osu!, after all.

But using two computers to get 1,18x multiplier for free in Taiko is just as lame imo.
dNextGen

SuperMaay wrote:

I believe they did manipulate the osu! client... from what moneto said, he made the osu! window transparent. Also, he hacked the client so he could open 2 of it, so he did manipulate osu!, after all.

But using two computers to get 1,18x multiplier for free in Taiko is just as lame imo.
the bolded sentence refers to ?_?
Rokodo

SuperMaay wrote:

he hacked the client so he could open 2 of it, so he did manipulate osu!, after all.
Uhh no.

2 clients can be opened using common sense on the same computer, no manipulation of the programming code itself, it is just an exploit of the way windows operating systems work.

Using a certain program to make one of the osu! windows transparent to play "through" it for osu! standard can be considered manipulation of the client however.

All that is done for taiko is to run the windows side by side, no manipulation. Besides, there is nothing to stop ANYONE recording an autoplay video and playing alongside that in a media player.
maay
What's your point? The client was manipulated, after all.

dNextGen wrote:

the bolded sentence refers to ?_?
To the ones who use two computers to use Hidden + Flashlight at Taiko. They use one computer with offline + no mods and the other one with the desired account and hidden + flashlight mods. Then they just press enter at the same time on both computers and just play on the hidden + flashlight computer's keyboard while looking at the monitor that has no mods.

It works pretty much like that, I guess. The only disvantage on this is that your offset will go off a bit.
dNextGen

SuperMaay wrote:

What's your point? The client was manipulated, after all.


To the ones who use two computers to use Hidden + Flashlight at Taiko. They use one computer with offline + no mods and the other one with the desired account and hidden + flashlight mods. Then they just press enter at the same time on both computers and just play on the hidden + flashlight computer's keyboard while looking at the monitor that has no mods.

It works pretty much like that, I guess. The only disvantage on this is that your offset will go off a bit.
you never fail to amuse me
maay
thanks

pieguyn

Rokodo wrote:

Cheating is defined as:
a) Manipulation of the osu! client.
b) Use of macros to enable automated full combo sequences.

I have done neither of these things.
Er.... lol

What you're doing may not be listed here, but seriously? Something like that obviously gives you an unfair advantage and kills the point of using hidden+flashlight in the first place, thus it shouldn't even need to be listed there (in my opinion at least)
maay
Yeah, I still don't get how it is allowed...

Should what he does be allowed, let it benefit all of the players and not only the ones who can afford a second computer - get rid of hidden and flashlight mods in Taiko and increase the base score multiplier from 1,00 to 1,18x. Lol.
Rokodo
The client is not being manipulated. Making a copy of the client to play on the same computer, reading notes off the second client window, is not manipulation.

It can be considered the same as writing the notes down on a sheet of paper and playing off that, such as a pianist would play.

This is why I am saying that you cannot define this as cheating, it is merely a tactic.

You can't discriminate against people for having some common sense.
Orkel

Gomo Psivarh wrote:

IMO,using 2 computers to play FL+Hid is just cheating.
It's a loophole in the current definition of cheating, which makes it TECHNICALLY perfectly fine, but MORALLY it is wrong and should be disallowed.
deadbeat
until you show where in the rules is says you CAN'T use a second monitor/computer, its not cheating
Rokodo

Orkel wrote:

Gomo Psivarh wrote:

IMO,using 2 computers to play FL+Hid is just cheating.
It's a loophole in the current definition of cheating, which makes it TECHNICALLY perfectly fine, but MORALLY it is wrong and should be disallowed.
At least I'm admitting I have used 2 program copies in the past for this. Think of the people who don't.
Who is the worst here?

Please grow a pair.
deepsea
So we are comparing who is lame and who is lamer here?

Please no.

The topic wrote:

"This score doesn't look right" Thread
Discussing of definition of cheating isn't nothing relate to the topic so I won't stop this atm.
But please don't go out of topic.

Nothing direct to anyone, just a reminder. have fun guys.
Alace
this story told us
if you want to be #1
make more money
KRZY

Alace wrote:

this story told us
if you want to be #1
make more money

Alace wins.
Zekira
Or you know just memorize it :P

Rotter ftw
Orkel

Rokodo wrote:

At least I'm admitting I have used 2 program copies in the past for this. Think of the people who don't.
Who is the worst here?

Please grow a pair.
Are you seriously telling me to grow a pair because I'm complaining about an unfair advantage? Get off your high horse and realize that what you're doing is utterly unfair to anyone who plays the game normally. You will get flak for it from real players who use skill to hidden or flashlight and not double programs. You admit it, yes, that is good but doesn't make it any less lame. I'm not able to stop you due to not being peppy, but someday I'm sure the rules will change.


deepsea wrote:

So we are comparing who is lame and who is lamer here?

Please no.

The topic wrote:

"This score doesn't look right" Thread
Discussing of definition of cheating isn't nothing relate to the topic so I won't stop this atm.
But please don't go out of topic.

Nothing direct to anyone, just a reminder. have fun guys.
yea I'll stop for now, got better stuff to do than point out unfair shit, if this is what the devs want their game to have then so be it
VelperK
Claudia_old
uhm maybe i'm being stupid because it's 22:00, but what are we supposed to be looking at?
Firo Prochainezo

E-Hooker wrote:

uhm maybe i'm being stupid because it's 22:00, but what are we supposed to be looking at?
The AgainFlyingKid user might be a hacker. He's only lvl 3 and he SS an Insane CTB map.
Lybydose

Firo Prochainezo wrote:

He's only lvl 3 and he SS an Insane CTB map.
osu! level =/= CTB level
Firo Prochainezo

Lybydose wrote:

Firo Prochainezo wrote:

He's only lvl 3 and he SS an Insane CTB map.
osu! level =/= CTB level
Oh yeah, forgot about that.

58 lvl uh. Nothing suspicious then.
maay

Firo Prochainezo wrote:

Nothing suspicious then.
are you kidding

That guy joined 2 weeks ago. So far only 4 people have managed to FC that map, while 3 of them are inside the top 5 and considered to be among the best players. I haven't watched the replay but the map's quite popular so judging by the score list I'd say it's hard as fuck. That guy's just probably a multi...
KRZY

dNextGen wrote:

Beuchi-chan wrote:

Guys, please, stop making multiaccount reports on this thread.

This thread is to report bugged/suspicious scores on maps, not for saying X guy has a multiaccount. If you want to report a possible multiaccount, contact with a moderator.

Thanks.
dNextGen

Beuchi-chan wrote:

"This score doesn't look right"
"This score
score
Guys, please, stop making multiaccount reports on this thread.

This thread is to report bugged/suspicious scores on maps, not for saying X guy has a multiaccount. If you want to report a possible multiaccount, contact with a moderator.

Thanks.
Zekira
Open a new sticky thread titled ["This guy is a cheater" Thread]? :P
KRZY

Zekira wrote:

Open a new sticky thread titled ["This guy is a cheater" Thread]? :P

inb4 thread gets locked within a week due to flaming
Lunah_old
a war .. rofl
Claudia_old

SuperMaay wrote:

Firo Prochainezo wrote:

Nothing suspicious then.
are you kidding

That guy joined 2 weeks ago. So far only 4 people have managed to FC that map, while 3 of them are inside the top 5 and considered to be among the best players. I haven't watched the replay but the map's quite popular so judging by the score list I'd say it's hard as fuck. That guy's just probably a multi...
it's a bit of a stretch sure, but i've been playing CtB for about that time and I can FC some hard maps.

so idk, derp.

prolly one of those nolifing koreans or something
KRZY

E-Hooker wrote:

prolly one of those nolifing koreans or something
Watch your mouth, buddy.
Claudia_old

KRZY wrote:

E-Hooker wrote:

prolly one of those nolifing koreans or something
Watch your mouth, buddy.
not you obv.
not my fault that there are seriously some people from asia that are hardcore osu! nuts
Meikyuuiri Tsumi
He did play it 48 times... It's not like he did it on the first try or something. That would certainly be suspicious, seeing that he's only been here for 2 weeks.

Besides, Chinese are very good at gaming so I'm not surprised.
omegaflo
http://osu.ppy.sh/u/481799

http://osu.ppy.sh/b/64558

I Lol'd on the replay, Auto pilot, full Miss, but SS score o/

this is full of win.
dNextGen

omegaflo wrote:

http://osu.ppy.sh/u/481799

http://osu.ppy.sh/b/64558

I Lol'd on the replay, Auto pilot, full Miss, but SS score o/

this is full of win.
xD
VelperK
Claudia_old

VelperK wrote:

http://osu.ppy.sh/p/beatmap?b=40017&m=1

http://osu.ppy.sh/u/462570

:roll:
Weird LOL

why would you want a hack like that...?
Froslass
Huuuh, what actually happened? His stats are gone or something?
Hakurei Reimu
Hakurei Reimu
#1

The guy, which I've mentioned last time, has cheated again
Derekku

omegaflo wrote:

http://osu.ppy.sh/u/481799

http://osu.ppy.sh/b/64558

I Lol'd on the replay, Auto pilot, full Miss, but SS score o/

this is full of win.
hahahaha oh wow.
balvag

Hakurei Reimu wrote:

http://osu.ppy.sh/b/65285

#7

mod:none
erm...#7 is me and i have 3 mods on :o
pieguyn
The guy at #1 used to be #7. Hakurei Reimu meant the guy currently at #1. :o
balvag

pieguy1372 wrote:

The guy at #1 used to be #7. Hakurei Reimu meant the guy currently at #1. :o
Ohh, alright.Just saw my name here and I was like "wtf" ? :P
Arctic Cress
Got more taiko scores with more combos than the song has.

http://osu.ppy.sh/p/beatmap?b=29033&m=1, both seed2978 and diaswong with 110/90 combos

Also, quoting my post from two weeks ago that nothing has been done for.

Arctic Cress wrote:

Two people with score combos higher than the song has, in taiko mode.

http://osu.ppy.sh/p/beatmap?b=8498&m=1, ddrddr125 with 451/381 combos.

and

http://osu.ppy.sh/p/beatmap?b=1360&m=1, mikanshuukei with 98/78 combos.

both scores should be removed.
Shino


http://osu.ppy.sh/p/beatmap?b=33185&m=2
Double qqqqxz LOL

(He doesn't know how this is done. #4 score needs to be deleted.)
Shinde
http://osu.ppy.sh/b/41197

Cyborg's #1 on Intense.
Roddie

crowzen2 wrote:

[attachment=0:456fc]capture.jpg[/attachment:456fc]

http://osu.ppy.sh/p/beatmap?b=33185&m=2
Double qqqqxz LOL

(He doesn't know how this is done. #4 score needs to be deleted.)
Wtf... O_o

Oh and Shinde;

KRZY wrote:

This has been discussed already in this thread. That score is not a cheat, but a glitch in the system. Check his replay and you will see that he achieves a normal score.
kvnyaoi
my old score wasn't deleted ?_?
http://osu.ppy.sh/p/beatmap?b=64027&m=1
Lunah_old
Hello, he again ..

http://osu.ppy.sh/s/16916 (TAIKO 1st place) http://osu.ppy.sh/u/203721

another stream 1/8 SS'ed (+SUDDEN DEATH ROFL) [350 BPM this time] always gameplay like AUTOKEY

SPOILER
I asked opinion of many good and expert players of taiko, almost all think he is cheating
Avatare
kanopu is not cheating hes just a very very good taiko player. Ive watched him many times, and ive seen no indication of him cheating. Ofcourse i can't say with 100% that he isn't but who can except for himself (and maybe peppy?) But i strongly believe he is not cheating.
A good friend of mine osu wise.
Hakeru

Shinde wrote:

http://osu.ppy.sh/b/41197

Cyborg's #1 on Intense.
Cyborg is not cheating .. Cyborg using tablet btw ..

Avatare wrote:

kanopu is not cheating hes just a very very good taiko player. Ive watched him many times, and ive seen no indication of him cheating. Ofcourse i can't say with 100% that he isn't but who can except for himself (and maybe peppy?) But i strongly believe he is not cheating.
A good friend of mine osu wise.
agree with this one ..
maybe Kanopu playing taiko arcade ver ..
so.. he used to play taiko in osu too :)
Lunah_old
I think only peppy can say that .. i asked him for make a Live Stream video (Free) or for make a video-gamplay, he said me no :3 so, idk what to think
KRZY

Lunah wrote:

I think only peppy can say that .. i asked him for make a Live Stream video (Free) or for make a video-gamplay, he said me no :3 so, idk what to think

It is a known issue; in the meantime, i think it is best if you stop bringing this up constantly :P
Meikyuuiri Tsumi
http://osu.ppy.sh/p/beatmap?b=35829&m=2

Why there are both of my records displayed? #46 should be deleted.
I mean, it's not a big deal or anything; and I looked in the list of maps in which scores were reset and it isn't there so I don't know what the problem is. But still, others may have this kinda problems too. Not that they are necessarily problems ;)

ShanaTan
Yeah I noticed the same thing on http://osu.ppy.sh/p/beatmap?b=41954&m=1 when I beat my old record but it's gone now, I'm sure the same thing will happen to you =P
Meikyuuiri Tsumi
Oh, okay thanks :)
I thought that it was more complicated.
Avatare
yeah because you ask him in pm all the time. writing to him like you were in love. "you are so good" and stuff. i would say no to you aswell if it was me. and there might be other reasons for him saying no to be watched by a complete stranger just because one man thinks he cheats well lets it out at least. and making it a big deal. have some dignity.
Claudia_old
hello.

http://osu.ppy.sh/?p=profile&u=500935

Sorry, but I don't think 11 days and 500 gameplays makes a person this good.
James2250

E-Hooker wrote:

hello.

http://osu.ppy.sh/?p=profile&u=500935

Sorry, but I don't think 11 days and 500 gameplays makes a person this good.
Some people are just naturally talented at games like this (not me)
The maps they played weren't that hard, they all just had a high score so it "could" be done
Lunaba
I'm cheater or what? :(
Claudia_old
eh, always worth looking into.
Shinde

Roddie wrote:

Oh and Shinde;

KRZY wrote:

This has been discussed already in this thread. That score is not a cheat, but a glitch in the system. Check his replay and you will see that he achieves a normal score.
The replay is fine, but the score is glitched. u_u I was saying to fix that. If you're not supposed to report glitched scores here, then I guess I misposted.

Hakeru Prismriver wrote:

Cyborg is not cheating .. Cyborg using tablet btw ..
I never said he was. ._.
Hakeru
@Shinde

oh lol .. i thought you said that cybord is cheating ..

my bad ;)
Lunah_old

Lunaba wrote:

I'm cheater or what? :(
YYYAYY ~
Orkel
Multi account and likely cheater spotted!

http://osu.ppy.sh/u/481799

2 plays - Lunatica - Words Unleashed [Armageddon]

And #1 with SS, on a SUPER insane map like that. Riiiiiiiiiiiiight.
Claudia_old

Orkel wrote:

Multi account and likely cheater spotted!

http://osu.ppy.sh/u/481799

2 plays - Lunatica - Words Unleashed [Armageddon]

And #1 with SS, on a SUPER insane map like that. Riiiiiiiiiiiiight.
Also if you look at his playcount, it's 163 but his ranked score is only 3 million, with 19 million total. If he did that awesome and has 163 gameplays, his total score shouldn't be that crappy and his ranked score shouldn't be that low.

Although in all fairness most of the maps he plays are fairly easy, except for the Armageddon which is certainly not legit [or at least, from a D to an SS in the same day?]
Colin Hou

E-Hooker wrote:

Orkel wrote:

Multi account and likely cheater spotted!

http://osu.ppy.sh/u/481799

2 plays - Lunatica - Words Unleashed [Armageddon]

And #1 with SS, on a SUPER insane map like that. Riiiiiiiiiiiiight.
Also if you look at his playcount, it's 163 but his ranked score is only 3 million, with 19 million total. If he did that awesome and has 163 gameplays, his total score shouldn't be that crappy and his ranked score shouldn't be that low.

Although in all fairness most of the maps he plays are fairly easy, except for the Armageddon which is certainly not legit [or at least, from a D to an SS in the same day?]
And he got an SS in his second try on that map! That's absolutely cheat.
Froslass
http://osu.ppy.sh/b/7957

Multi account + Spin cheat maybe?

#1, #2, #3 and #5 have the EXACT SAME crazy spin and well, they have similar nicknames and are from the same country, so i guess yea lol


Pretty old scores btw
Roddie
Another one. O_o

For Taiko this time.

Edit: I'm not saying Rucker is multi-accounting, but its that bug where it shows two of Rucker's records being displayed.
ShanaTan
http://osu.ppy.sh/p/beatmap?b=46969&m=1

This one is definately fishy, the 311 combo record was set 35 mins ago so it's not old and I just played a full score HR SS with only a 246 max combo >.<
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply