U2 - Sunday Bloody Sunday · forum

Drafura

osu! Alumni

Joined April 2010

Drafura 2010-09-04T05:06:29+00:00

[Hard]
Plus the irc talk about your default spacing some (some wth ?) suggestions :
00:23:786 (1) - Don't fit with the music
00:24:671 (2) - Make a jump ?
00:27:031 (6) - ^
00:31:752 (6) - ^
00:34:112 (1) - ^
00:36:177 (1) - Boring (thibaud's infinite reverse slider inside <- private joke) if you wanna follow the voice here (good idea add a circle at 00:36:472 - then start the slider here 00:36:767 - )
00:40:012 - Seems like something is missing here
00:41:487 (6,7,8) - jump that

00:45:322 (3,4,5) - In the music I hear the drum break here : 00:44:732 -
00:48:272 - Seems like something is missing here
00:49:452 - ^
00:51:075 - ^
00:54:173 (9) - Too short or too long (reverse count I mean), I would suggest make it shorter and map the ticks wich were in the slider with circle or other slider
01:01:253 (6) - Too many reverse, borring
01:09:366 - Seems like something is missing here
01:23:674 (4) - Too many reverse, borring
01:45:210 (2) - Add circle at this position then start your slider here : 01:45:505 -
01:50:815 (4) - Too many reverse, borring
02:06:009 (2) - remove
02:08:516 - Seems like something is missing here
02:10:876 - ^
02:19:579 - ^
02:20:907 (8) - try to follow the idea
02:40:378 (1,1,1) - Jumps ?
02:46:278 (1) - ^
02:59:554 - start slider here ?
03:02:799 - Seems like something is missing here
03:04:126 - ^
03:06:339 - ^
03:24:925 (1,2,3,4) - Jumps !
03:30:235 (1,2,3) - ^
03:32:890 - circle
03:33:185 (6) - Make a slider like the : 03:32:005 (4) -
03:38:496 - Use a circle
03:38:791 - ^
03:39:381 - ^
03:39:676 - ^
03:39:971 - Use a slider finishing at : 03:40:561 -
03:40:856 - Use a circle
04:12:127 (1) - Too many reverse, borring
04:21:420 (1,2) - Weird littles sliders
04:23:338 (5) - Too many reverse, borring

[Normal]
00:55:943 (5) - spacing
01:16:594 (5) - Too many reverse, borring
01:31:049 (1) - ^
01:54:356 (8) - ^
02:09:991 (1) - Dont like it
03:16:959 - start slider here ? And more long / less reverse arrow
03:50:296 (1) - Too many reverse, borring
03:59:442 (7,1,2,3,4,5,6) - maybe a little hard to understand for a normal make it more readable or easy
04:09:767 (5) - Too many reverse, borring

[Easy]
01:05:678 (2) - Recitify the position to avoid the 01:03:318 (8) - slider superposition
01:39:900 (1) - Too many reverse, borring
02:18:252 - stop break here ? i mean it's a good part of the song it's sad to not map it
03:04:864 (2) - fit position with : 03:03:094 (6) - start of this slider

Serval

232 posts

Joined June 2010

Topic Starter

Serval 2010-09-04T18:13:23+00:00

Fix'd !

03:32:890 - circle <== not agree with you, cause we're following kick on this part, and it's a bit disturbing to put a note right here, but, agree with all the other things :p

Nactra

117 posts

Joined November 2008

Nactra 2010-09-04T19:19:20+00:00

weee

Extremoon

9 posts

Joined April 2010

Extremoon 2010-09-04T20:41:52+00:00

Good song,map, stuff ~ ♪

Fight69

1,639 posts

Joined January 2010

Fight69 2010-09-05T14:04:26+00:00

Ze

Waryas

Waryas 2010-09-05T21:23:29+00:00

Great job!

IchiiNiiSan

7 posts

Joined May 2010

IchiiNiiSan 2010-09-06T13:02:53+00:00

Star~

dkun

osu! Alumni

4,486 posts

Joined August 2009

dkun 2010-09-06T21:17:16+00:00

Mmm... U2. :3
Mapset runs fine to me!

Star!

Serval

232 posts

Joined June 2010

Topic Starter

Serval 2010-09-06T21:31:22+00:00

dkun wrote:
Mmm... U2. :3
Mapset runs fine to me!

Star!

Thank you <3

gyt

405 posts

Here since the beginning

gyt 2010-09-06T22:18:45+00:00

Interesting hitsounds, but I don't very like how hit and whistle silent on most of the song.

[Easy]
01:05:088 (1) - place it at the end of slider?
01:47:570 (7) - super-nazi, but.. Can you place it exactly at the end of slider? (for that: delete circle, jump to 01:47:275, place circle at the end of slider, move it to 01:47:570)
04:00:327 (5,6) - such things not for easy, imho. Turn slider to the left and then correct placing.

[Normal]
04:05:637 (2) - turn slider to the left

[Hard]
01:32:229 (8) - turn slider to the right or add repeat [like 04:06:227 (1,1)]
02:18:252 (4) - maybe add some claps
02:22:972 (4,5,6,7,8) - ^

Nice map!

Serval

232 posts

Joined June 2010

Topic Starter

Serval 2010-09-06T22:48:35+00:00

Done !

Thank you !
Kudosus ~

krius_old

277 posts

Joined March 2009

krius_old 2010-09-08T02:44:35+00:00

Star ~

Mutsui

951 posts

Joined February 2009

Mutsui 2010-09-10T12:56:28+00:00

Irc modded

Serval

232 posts

Joined June 2010

Topic Starter

Serval 2010-09-10T12:56:55+00:00

Rick_Astley wrote:
Irc modded

Done

Yuji Tokaji

776 posts

Joined March 2009

Yuji Tokaji 2010-09-11T14:12:30+00:00

Hi ~

Here my mod ~

[Overall]

- First, try to place your pattern with a little more aesthetic.
Your pattern is really ugly, without wishing to offend you.
- Delete .osb in your folder and Full Submit.

[Easy]

- 00:27:326(5) : Finish on the repeat ?
- 00:35:587(3) : Finish it.
- 00:37:357(4) : ^
- 00:38:537(5) : ^
- 00:39:127(6) : ^
- 00:40:307(7) : ^
- 00:40:749(1) : Start at 00:40:602 ; End at 00:43:257.
- 00:46:207(4) : Finish on the repeat ?
- 00:55:648(x) : Add circle ?
- 01:00:958(6) : Finish on the repeat ?
- 01:03:318(8) : ^
- 01:09:808(6) : Finish it ?
- 01:12:758(5) : Delete, make a slider : 01:12:758 - 01:13:939 and finish on the end.
- 01:19:839(1) : Finish instead of whistle ?
- 01:42:260(2) : Finish on the end.
- 01:44:620(5) : Finish it ?
- 01:47:570(7) : ^
- 01:50:815 - 01:57:306 : IMO, you should map this part.
- 02:05:861(x) : Add circle & finish it ?
- 02:11:614(1) : Start at 02:11:466 ; End at 02:15:302, and finish it.
- 02:17:662(3) : Finish on the end.
- 02:20:022(6) : Finish on the repeat.
- 02:21:792(1) : Finish on the end.
- 02:44:803(3) : ^
- 02:56:013(6) : Finish on the repeat.
- 02:57:194(1) : ^
- 02:58:374(2) : ^
- 03:01:914(5) : ^
- 03:03:094(6) : ^
- 03:06:634(4) : ^
- 03:07:814(5) : ^
- 03:20:205(6) : New combo.
- 03:22:565(1) : Remove new combo.
- 03:47:346(1) : Finish on the repeat.
- 03:49:116(2) : Finish instead of clap ?
- 04:10:357(7) : Finish on the repeat.
- 04:12:717(2) : Finish instead of clap ?
- 04:24:518(1) : Finish on the repeat.

[Normal]

- 00:41:487(2) : Finish it ?
- 00:58:303(2) : Spacing.
- 00:58:598(3) : ^
- 00:58:893(4) : ^
- 01:47:570(1) : ^
- 02:10:876 - 02:17:072 : IMO, you should map this part.
- 02:57:194(4) : Finish it.
- 02:58:374(5) : ^
- 02:59:554(6) : ^

Okay, I didn't finish my mod.
Fix this, and I'll star.

EDIT : Star !

sexy-commando

142 posts

Joined April 2010

sexy-commando 2010-09-11T20:43:55+00:00

aujourd'hui c'est sous une pression et une obligation d'une certaine personne que j'écris ce message qui restera(peut-être) dans les annales : alors voilà ....je vais le dire là ...maintenant...à l'instant...
STAR ! (ouhouh, le suspens aura été long !)

AgentYous

131 posts

Joined February 2010

AgentYous 2010-09-11T20:44:16+00:00

On m'a pris en otage

treve de plaisenteries cette mapi est super

Star

Kite

osu! Alumni

1,372 posts

Joined July 2009

Kite 2010-09-19T19:55:25+00:00

star

Nicogeta

28 posts

Joined July 2010

Nicogeta 2010-09-20T00:41:22+00:00

Bon travail

<star>

Mafiamaster

osu! Alumni

3,460 posts

Joined July 2008

Mafiamaster 2010-09-20T15:30:10+00:00

[Easy]
02:02:321 (5) - Add a clap
02:03:501 (7) - ^
02:04:091 (8) - ^ On reverse arrow.
02:18:842 (4) - Clap.
02:20:022 (6) - ^ Only at the beginning of this slider.
02:21:202 (7) - Clap.
02:21:792 (1) - ^ on reverse arrow.
02:28:872 (5) - Clap on the end?
02:31:822 (7) - Clap?
02:37:723 (3) - ^
02:38:903 (5) - ^ at beginning?
02:40:083 (1) - Claps on beginning and ends?
02:44:803 (3) - ^ except for the finish at the end?
02:58:374 (2) - Not really recommended for the easiest difficulty. (Slightly hidden reverse arrow, that kind of thing)

[Normal]
02:41:558 (7) - New combo
02:43:918 (1) - Remove new combo.
02:56:013 (1) - Add a finish.
03:24:335 (7) - New combo.
03:27:285 (1) - Remove new combo.
03:49:116 (6) - Not really good for a normal difficulty either. Most of the slider is hidden.

[Hard]
00:41:487 (7) - New combo.

[Mafiamaster Timing]
2nd non-inherited timing section: (BPM: 101.65 / Offset: 41,467)
You should get someone else to check that timing.

Serval

232 posts

Joined June 2010

Topic Starter

Serval 2010-09-20T15:51:12+00:00

Mafiamaster wrote:
[Easy]
02:02:321 (5) - Add a clap
02:03:501 (7) - ^
02:04:091 (8) - ^ On reverse arrow.
02:18:842 (4) - Clap.
02:20:022 (6) - ^ Only at the beginning of this slider.
02:21:202 (7) - Clap.
02:21:792 (1) - ^ on reverse arrow.
02:28:872 (5) - Clap on the end?
02:31:822 (7) - Clap?
02:37:723 (3) - ^
02:38:903 (5) - ^ at beginning?
02:40:083 (1) - Claps on beginning and ends?
02:44:803 (3) - ^ except for the finish at the end?
02:58:374 (2) - Not really recommended for the easiest difficulty. (Slightly hidden reverse arrow, that kind of thing)

[Normal]
02:41:558 (7) - New combo
02:43:918 (1) - Remove new combo.
02:56:013 (1) - Add a finish.
03:24:335 (7) - New combo.
03:27:285 (1) - Remove new combo.
03:49:116 (6) - Not really good for a normal difficulty either. Most of the slider is hidden.

[Hard]
00:41:487 (7) - New combo.

[Mafiamaster Timing]
2nd non-inherited timing section: (BPM: 101.65 / Offset: 41,467)
You should get someone else to check that timing.

Done, I'll find someone to check that timing ! thank you !

Doomsday

osu! Alumni

1,960 posts

Joined July 2008

Doomsday 2010-09-20T21:59:35+00:00

Alright. These might not be completely perfect, but they're pretty close, and sound good to me. Much better than what is there at least.

Paste this into the [TimingPoints] section of the .osu for each difficulty.

10784,594.059405940594,4,2,1,86,1,0
15536,588.235294117647,4,2,1,86,1,0
20241,589.68058968059,4,2,1,86,1,0
50904,591.133004926108,4,2,1,86,1,0
79278,589.68058968059,4,2,1,86,1,0
88684,588.235294117647,4,2,1,86,1,0
98112,591.133004926108,4,2,1,86,1,0
117028,588.235294117647,4,2,1,86,1,0
138204,592.592592592593,4,2,1,86,1,0
147685,589.68058968059,4,2,1,86,1,0
194859,591.133004926108,4,2,1,86,1,0
204317,592.592592592593,4,2,1,86,1,0
209057,589.68058968059,4,2,1,86,1,0
246796,594.059405940594,4,2,1,86,1,0
251548,591.133004926108,4,2,1,86,1,0
256277,589.68058968059,4,2,1,86,1,0

Serval

232 posts

Joined June 2010

Topic Starter

Serval 2010-09-20T22:17:21+00:00

Thank you <3

Kudosed !

Will be good for now :-)

Mafiamaster

osu! Alumni

3,460 posts

Joined July 2008

Mafiamaster 2010-09-21T00:43:52+00:00

Sorry, just a few more things.

[Hard]
00:27:022 (6) - New combo since it's a jump.
00:31:444 (5) - ^
01:35:448 (3) - Reverse arrow is hidden. Make it visible.

Serval

232 posts

Joined June 2010

Topic Starter

Serval 2010-09-21T00:49:56+00:00

Mafiamaster wrote:
Sorry, just a few more things.

[Hard]
00:27:022 (6) - New combo since it's a jump.
00:31:444 (5) - ^
01:35:448 (3) - Reverse arrow is hidden. Make it visible.

Done

Mafiamaster

osu! Alumni

3,460 posts

Joined July 2008

Mafiamaster 2010-09-21T00:50:28+00:00

Bubbled again!

Ekoro

3,456 posts

Joined March 2010

Ekoro 2010-09-21T19:53:29+00:00

Hey !

GG !

Phantom Miria

Phantom Miria 2010-09-22T02:05:02+00:00

Sorry Serval, totally forgot to Star your map!
I hope this gets ranked soon since it's complete!
go bubble go!

Mashley

2,042 posts

Joined September 2008

Mashley 2010-10-04T17:00:39+00:00

mp3 is TERRIBLE. Technically it's 128kps but it sounds like 64.
Popping for the reasons listed below. Hitsounds could use more work, too, and the map is quite boring.

Easy
00:24:958 (3) - New combo
00:44:417 (1) - 00:45:597 (3) - Add claps for consistency
02:08:792 (5) - New combo
03:01:296 (4) - Spacing
03:24:317 (5) - New combo

Normal
00:29:675 (1) - Remove new combo
00:42:059 (3) - Clap for consistency
00:48:250 (3,4) - Remove the finishes.

Hard
Get rid of all those random jumps. Jumps should always make musical sense. Particularly ones like this 01:10:411 (1,2,3,4,5) -

Mafiamaster, I'm very disappointed with you for bubbling a map with so many obvious issues.

braian5234

230 posts

Joined April 2010

braian5234 2010-10-14T21:09:26+00:00

SSSTTTAARR !

Inozuma

596 posts

Joined June 2008

Inozuma 2010-10-16T22:57:20+00:00

Test timing
Download: U2 - Sunday Bloody Sunday (Serval) [Hard].osu

Mashley

2,042 posts

Joined September 2008

Mashley 2010-11-06T11:28:01+00:00

w/e

Gonzvlo

osu! Alumni

2,896 posts

Joined January 2010

Gonzvlo 2010-11-09T01:58:23+00:00

General:

Delete "Sunday", "Bloody" and "U2" from tags. (Isn't "rock" too generic? Oh well w/e)
Preview time is not the same for all the diffs.(Easy)

Easy:

00:32:027 (1) - Remove New Combo to keep consistency.
02:08:779 (5) - ^
02:43:012 (4,5) - Wtf? Fix spacing.
03:33:184 (2) - "Finish" doesn't fit here imo, change it for "Whistle".
03:38:344 - Why did you use 2x for the end of a spinner, delete this timing section.
03:41:292 - Delete this timing section (read above)^

Normal:

00:11:979 (3,4) - Fix Spacing (This is [Normal], Random jumps should not be used here)
03:28:781 (4,5) - Umm What?, Fix spacing please.
04:26:154 (1) - Start this here: 04:26:301.

Hard:

Oh well
04:29:987 - Add a circle here.

I think this map can be improved a lot with some more modding

Serval

232 posts

Joined June 2010

Topic Starter

Serval 2010-11-09T13:37:11+00:00

Gonzvlo wrote:
General:
Delete "Sunday", "Bloody" and "U2" from tags. (Isn't "rock" too generic? Oh well w/e) Done
Preview time is not the same for all the diffs.(Easy)
Done

Easy:
00:32:027 (1) - Remove New Combo to keep consistency.Done
02:08:779 (5) - ^ Done
02:43:012 (4,5) - Wtf? Fix spacing. Done
03:33:184 (2) - "Finish" doesn't fit here imo, change it for "Whistle".Done
03:38:344 - Why did you use 2x for the end of a spinner, delete this timing section. Done
03:41:292 - Delete this timing section (read above)^
Done

Normal:
00:11:979 (3,4) - Fix Spacing (This is [Normal], Random jumps should not be used here) Done
03:28:781 (4,5) - Umm What?, Fix spacing please. Done
04:26:154 (1) - Start this here: 04:26:301.
Nope, the sunday began on blue tick (if you listen carefully)

Hard:
Oh well What?
04:29:987 - Add a circle here.
Nope. I want this stack be something different than the other stack. Yes, there is a drum snare on this tick, no i won't map it. It doesn't fit well with the end of song.

I think this map can be improved a lot with some more modding