At the very least, the first pattern should be changed. It's so very noticably off.LuigiHann wrote:
I like to think I did the best I could with what I had to work with
Granted the map was kind of a joke to begin with but it came out kind of nice
forum
Imogen Heap - The Fire (Approval)
posted
Total Posts
79
uh
Topic Starter
All this talking and you're not actually giving me bpm and ms offset values so what is the pointJarby wrote:
At the very least, the first pattern should be changed. It's so very noticably off.LuigiHann wrote:
I like to think I did the best I could with what I had to work with
Granted the map was kind of a joke to begin with but it came out kind of nice
yes.TKiller wrote:
uh
Because I have the funny idea that you'd be better off placing a new offset on every note. In any case, 00:10:317 (2,4) - Move 1/8 back and it sounds drastically better.LuigiHann wrote:
All this talking and you're not actually giving me bpm and ms offset values so what is the point.
Why is it approved? Jesus... Why can't good maps get ranked and this map actually gets it? K I won't say how bad this is.
sorry for the offtopic and everything. Jsut my personal opinion.
sorry for the offtopic and everything. Jsut my personal opinion.
This map is much much older than whatever you linked
Wait what?
How you can dislike this is completely beyond me
best map ever
best map ever
Odd thing to be approved
No srsly, don't mind you disliking this but I would like to start getting reasons.
Why I'm thinking that this thread won't end well?
The timing, which is off. The spacing, which is really bad. The whole map is the reason.NotShinta wrote:
No srsly, don't mind you disliking this but I would like to start getting reasons.
I feel the timing is a bit awkward, but the spacing was perfectly fine.
No idea what your gripe is with the spacing but the timing seems fine
00:10:396 (2) - too late
00:11:264 (4) - same
00:17:818 (1) - too soon
00:18:450 (2) - too late
00:19:397 (5) - same
etc etc..
00:11:264 (4) - same
00:17:818 (1) - too soon
00:18:450 (2) - too late
00:19:397 (5) - same
etc etc..
Then you're probably disabled. If it was any other mapper, there would be no way this map could be approved.Mashley wrote:
No idea what your gripe is with the spacing but the timing seems fine
Won't post here again, sorry. I'm just so pissed off...
What.Natteke wrote:
The spacing, which is really bad.
No seriously. what.
So yeah this can't end well
It must be a joke, right?
Why would it betieff wrote:
It must be a joke, right?
I'm seeming too defensive here I'll stop
Yes. It's a joke.LuigiHann wrote:
Granted the map was kind of a joke to begin with but it came out kind of nice
not like I really complain, but this gets ranked and that Teta's Desu mix map is counted unrankable. Either decide on something, either...
Play Time: 01:48TKiller wrote:
not like I really complain, but this gets ranked and that Teta's Desu mix map is counted unrankable. Either decide on something, either...
Length of the song is totally rankable. Desu is what, 15 secs? Also we already discussed this some time ago...
And yes, I don't think this is going to end well either :/
i'm beginning to wonder if it's even worth the two seconds it takes to read your posts anymoreTKiller wrote:
not like I really complain, but this gets ranked and that Teta's Desu mix map is counted unrankable. Either decide on something, either...
"I SAY SPACING IS BAD THEREFORE UNRANK RIGHT AWAY"Natteke wrote:
Then you're probably disabled.Mashley wrote:
No idea what your gripe is with the spacing but the timing seems fine
Won't post here again, sorry. I'm just so pissed off...
People are allowed to have opinions. The majority of peoples' thoughts on this map just contrast your own. We don't call you incapable of mental capabilities because you don't like it (well, I certainly don't). I personally find the spacing intuitive, but that's just my view.
Excuse me, princess, if something isn't up to your personal standards.
Is it more fun to play like this compared to if i had to stick to the guidelines?Not very fun for playing, but I really enjoy the music.
Hope there would be more piano music like this...
So you don't see a resemblance between the issues both this maps cause?Ephemeral wrote:
i'm beginning to wonder if it's even worth the two seconds it takes to read your posts anymoreTKiller wrote:
not like I really complain, but this gets ranked and that Teta's Desu mix map is counted unrankable. Either decide on something, either...
You know what, nevermind those last 2 posts, I guess I'm too drunk to write my thoughts properly.
But still, this map is not timed right. It's absolutely off-piano at some parts.
It also wonders me how much of people "liking" this map and commenting on it *really* tried playing it. We all've seen the scoredoard.
Just try going to taiko, putting relax on and closing your eyes. Click right when you hear a piano note. The number of 100s scored would be impressive enough.
But still, this map is not timed right. It's absolutely off-piano at some parts.
It also wonders me how much of people "liking" this map and commenting on it *really* tried playing it. We all've seen the scoredoard.
Just try going to taiko, putting relax on and closing your eyes. Click right when you hear a piano note. The number of 100s scored would be impressive enough.
Alternatively, raise the hitsound volume and press play in the editor.
As much as I can understand that quite some people enjoy to have a really different map to play I cannot understand how it is approvable. The spacing itself seems rather generic and the map doesn't really offer a special gameplay. The real problem would be the timing though, people already mentioned this and I agree that using 1/8 ticks and very low overall difficulty might make this playable, but it still doesn't seem timed correctly. Is this really rankable? Or did people just want to have something really different approved?
Does anybody remember To Zanarkand and how the first version was not rankable cause almost every beat had it's own offset? I'm pretty sure that 'To Zanarkand' could also "work" with one single offset using 1/8 ticks and very low overall setting, just as much as this map here.
Does anybody remember To Zanarkand and how the first version was not rankable cause almost every beat had it's own offset? I'm pretty sure that 'To Zanarkand' could also "work" with one single offset using 1/8 ticks and very low overall setting, just as much as this map here.
Boo hoo
Stop taking shit so seriously guys it's fucking boring
Stop taking shit so seriously guys it's fucking boring
Joking around is ok. But ranking is serious. Or why else do we have the MAT/BAT and ranking guidelines?Mashley wrote:
Boo hoo
Stop taking shit so seriously guys it's fucking boring
. . . Lets rank everything!!!!!!!!! *runs*Mashley wrote:
Boo hoo
Stop taking shit so seriously guys it's fucking boring
This.Dangaard wrote:
Joking around is ok. But ranking is serious. Or why else do we have the MAT/BAT and ranking guidelines?Mashley wrote:
Boo hoo
Stop taking shit so seriously guys it's fucking boring
I have to agree with Dangaard
I don't understand you guys. This is unrankable, then just nrank it.
I'd love to contribute myself into making this map rankable but right now it looks like everyone is fucking okay with a ranked map using completely wrong timing.
I'd love to contribute myself into making this map rankable but right now it looks like everyone is fucking okay with a ranked map using completely wrong timing.
As a player, I think the map is crap.
Slow, boring, really off timing, and short
Useless post is useless, but might as well post my opinion anyway.
Slow, boring, really off timing, and short
Useless post is useless, but might as well post my opinion anyway.
Topic Starter
Okay.TKiller wrote:
I don't understand you guys. This is unrankable, then just nrank it.
I'd love to contribute myself into making this map rankable but right now it looks like everyone is fucking okay with a ranked map using completely wrong timing.
Help me out dudes
I'll probably still leave the overall difficulty and hitsounds as low as they are now, but I do agree that the timing should be as precise as possible before getting this re-approved. I myself have no ear for timing at all, and will blindly (deafly?) accept whatever somebody that I trust tells me is right, so hopefully people can come to a consensus on this.
I'll get into this when I get home, so probably tomorrow. You could ask someone like Zekira to help you.
I like this :)
I'll see if I can help with the timing.
edit: Currently working on it...
I'll see if I can help with the timing.
edit: Currently working on it...
Here it is.
I made it as accurate as I could. Whenever the piano played chords, I used the highest note as a reference.
I only adjusted timings and slider lengths, not positions, so distance snapping might have to be redone.
Download: Imogen Heap - The Fire (LuigiHann) [Piano].osu
I made it as accurate as I could. Whenever the piano played chords, I used the highest note as a reference.
I only adjusted timings and slider lengths, not positions, so distance snapping might have to be redone.
Download: Imogen Heap - The Fire (LuigiHann) [Piano].osu
Rest in peace, sweet prince.~
I can't fix that
The map was approved and then unranked by moving to Pending back due the criticisms about the horrible Timing and the Map itself.
Also what I've noticed:
- The Map was seriously ranked.
- 0_o isn't a MAT anymore.
- OMG Takuma got a new Avatar OMGOMGOMG
Also what I've noticed:
- The Map was seriously ranked.
- 0_o isn't a MAT anymore.
- OMG Takuma got a new Avatar OMGOMGOMG
this map is a true example of art >: I wish it was approved
Jarby informed of this. Compared to much of what's ranked these days, the map's perfectly readable. However, I wouldn't approve it. Not by a long shot.
At least it isn't 'Roze.'
At least it isn't 'Roze.'
i want to bump this just to ask why this is my 2nd highest pp score if it's been unranked forever
i don't even remember playing this on ctb
This modding thread has been migrated to the new "modding discussions" system. Please make sure to re-post any existing (and unresolved) efforts to the new system as required.