Guest
home
beatmaps
rankings
community
store
help
forum
  1. Forums
  2. Beatmaps
  3. Ranked Beatmaps (Archived)
  4. Beatmap Graveyard

Fool's Garden - Lemon Tree

posted
Total Posts
104
show more
Leorda
4,416 posts
Joined June 2009
Leorda
Annyeonghaesyo!

[General]
1) Source?
2) Remove "Lemon" and "Tree", since that word in Title

[Entrance]
There's some unsnapped notes in timing LOL. Please resnap all note (Timing -> Resnap All Notes -> Yes)
00:29:221 (4) - Make curve?
01:33:802 (1) - Add a whistle hitsound
01:34:639 (2) - New combo
02:14:269 (1) - No new combo

[Standard]
01:06:126 (1) - Offscreen
01:33:803 (1) - Add a whistle hitsound
01:34:641 (2) - New combo
02:33:349 (1) - Offscreen

[Hard core]
01:07:802 (1,2) - Too far between these two
01:33:801 (1) - Add a whistle hitsound
01:34:640 (2) - New combo
01:44:075 (1,2) - Too far between these two
01:51:204 (3,4) - ^
02:35:028 (1,2) - ^

[Extreme]
01:07:802 (1,2) - Too far between these two
01:33:801 (1) - Add a whistle hitsound
01:34:640 (2) - New combo

Bad song.......
STAR
Nakagawa-Kanon
Featured Artist
1,893 posts
Joined March 2009
Nakagawa-Kanon
[인센]
00:16:432 (4,1) - 이런부분이 스페이싱이 문제군요
이런거랑 똑같은거 전부 스페이싱 조절해주세요
00:31:005 (4) - 빨간칸으로

그외에는 트집이 없어보입니다

트집없는이유는 inis 스타일이라서
트집잡기 애매함
Vanmonky
986 posts
Joined June 2009
Vanmonky
As your request.

Read this first for the icon explanation.
- [?] Asking for a second thought.
- [!] Fatal error. You have to fix this for sure.
- [No icon] Only a suggestion.

[General]
1. Remove "Fool's" and "Garden" from tags since they have been covered with the artist name. Add other tags and remember to lowercase all tags.
2. Add "Dish of the Day" to the source. It's the album of the song.
3. The background is too small.
4. Delete all .osb file in the map's folder. [!]
5. The BPM is 143.17 or 143.20, perhaps. Ask the other to confirm the timing for you, perhaps.
6. You're really insipred with the EBA-style map. No offense but this map doesn't really like EBA-style map. Okay, maybe it does on [Hard core] and [Extreme] diff. But, just forget it.
7. I hate copy-paste design. It's boring. No no no.
8. Do not force yourself to make an EBA-style map. Make an RE1359EBA-style map instead.

[Entrance]
-- Could you silence the sliderslide, please?
-- Resnap all objects. Go to Timing > Resnap all notes. [!]
-- No high jump for easy diff. Always use distance snap.
00:24:194 (1) - No high jump. [!]
00:28:382 (2) - Don't do this jump please. [!]
00:30:271 (1,2,3) - Use distance snap. [!]
00:31:737 (4) - No high jump. [!]
00:44:319 (1) - This is a jump. But I think it's okay, perhaps.
00:45:995 (2,1,2,3) - Use distance snap. [!]
00:48:932 - Map this berak. It's odd if you place a break for only one sentence of lyrics.
00:56:061 (3) - This is a jump. Idk if it's okay.
00:57:736 (1,2,3,4,5) - Use distance snap.. [!]
Well, okay. Even I just modded 30% of the diff, I know that the major problem is distance. Fix them and mod your map by yourself. Use distance snap for the easiest diff. No jump allowed. I will not mod the distance error anymore. Fix them yourself.
02:56:831 (1) - Kind of overlapping slider. [!]
02:15:108 - Map this berak. It's odd if you place a break for only one sentence of lyrics.

[Standard]
-- The same problem as [Entrance]. Distance error. But, since this is a normal diff, I will not put my [!] icon here.
00:48:932 - Map this berak. It's odd if you place a break for only one sentence of lyrics.
02:15:108 - ^
02:56:831 (1) - Kind of overlapping slider. [!]

[Hard core]
-- Weird diff name. It must be [Hardcore], right?
02:58:205 (2) - It doesn't fit to the song. Make it shorter (use 1/8), then add one more repeat.
00:48:932 - Map this berak. It's odd if you place a break for only one sentence of lyrics.
02:15:108 - ^
02:56:831 (1) - Kind of overlapping slider. [!]

[Extreme]
- Delete this diff or re-map this diff with brand new pattern. [!]
02:56:831 (1) - Kind of overlapping slider. [!]
No. I won't star. Fix them all first, then ask more people to mod this map. I believe this map will be good one day. You may ask me to re-mod after it.
RE1359EBA
313 posts
Joined February 2009
Topic Starter
RE1359EBA

Leorda wrote:

[Entrance]
01:33:802 (1) - Add a whistle hitsound
01:34:639 (2) - New combo
02:14:269 (1) - No new combo

[Standard]
01:33:803 (1) - Add a whistle hitsound
01:34:641 (2) - New combo

[Hard core]
01:07:802 (1,2) - Too far between these two :arrow: Easily tell is spacing. isn't he?
01:33:801 (1) - Add a whistle hitsound
01:34:640 (2) - New combo[/color]
01:44:075 (1,2) - Too far between these two
02:35:028 (1,2) - ^

[Extreme] :arrow: [Hard core] And equally
RE1359EBA
313 posts
Joined February 2009
Topic Starter
RE1359EBA

dksslqj wrote:

[인센]
00:16:432 (4,1) - 이런부분이 스페이싱이 문제군요
이런거랑 똑같은거 전부 스페이싱 조절해주세요
00:31:005 (4) - 빨간칸으로

그외에는 트집이 없어보입니다

트집없는이유는 inis 스타일이라서
트집잡기 애매함
완벽하게 수정 했습니다.

P.S 난데없어 트집은 도대체...
Astom
1,588 posts
Joined October 2008
Astom
In red maybe important, In blue suggestions

[General]
-LEMON TREE.png, search for a better BG and resize to 1024x768, and try to use a .jpeg img
-Add some tag

[Entrance]
-Acc 100% nice

[Standard]
-Acc 100%
-Don't copy and paste D:

[Hardcore]
-Acc 100% this is not hardcore, pretty easy i think
-Don't copy and paste D:

[Extreme]
-Acc 95% this is not Extreme, pretty easy, I don't get more acc because the overall is high nothing more.

Post again in my queue when your map is already more fun D:
Kecco
908 posts
Joined September 2009
Kecco
Hi.
Nothing has to be modded here, for me~
Star~
Lizbeth
osu! Alumni
1,731 posts
Joined August 2008
Lizbeth
I think you miss the rhythm of the song while mapping this... is important to follow the beats of the song so the map turn comfortable to play.

Here's an example I made based on part of the Extreme diff, following the rhythm as I thought is better. Hope it can be useful. Plz don't look at the chart, only the time line xD

Download: Fool's Garden - Lemon Tree (RE1359EBA) [EXAMPLE].osu
Nyan
1,455 posts
Joined September 2008
Nyan
부활이로군요
그러므로 스타
Senbon
480 posts
Joined September 2008
Senbon
Feel free to take or leave any suggestions. :D

[General]

Find bigger picture.

[Entrance]

00:26:495 (2,3,4) - Hard to read for Easy.
00:28:384 (5) - Remove slider whistle noise.
00:30:271 (1,2,3) - Hard to read as well.
00:46:834 (3) - Remove slider whistle noise.
01:47:009 (2,3,4) - Not vocally snapped on (2) and hard to read.
01:50:785 (1,2,3) - ^
01:54:770 (5) - Move forward to white tick?
02:50:123 (2) - Too far of a jump.

[Standard]

00:23:142 (4) - Replace with whistle.
00:30:271 (1,2,3) - (2,3) are not vocally snapped. Sounds bad too.
00:31:738 (4) - Remove slider whistle noise.
00:46:835 (1) - ^
01:14:304 (2) - Align directly above (1).
01:15:141 (3) - Align directly under (2).
01:50:787 (1,2,3) - Does not sound good using red ticks.
01:55:188 (3) - Remove slider whistle noise.
01:58:123 (4) - ^
02:01:898 (3) - ^
02:21:607 (1,2,3...) - No copy pasting... it gets boring.
02:50:123 (2) - Remove clap on return.
02:54:316 (4) - Remove clap.
02:56:832 (1) - Remove slider whistle noise.
03:02:075 (1) - Move back to white tick and extend to red tick.

[Hardcore]

00:31:738 (5) - New combo.
00:46:835 (2) - Remove slider whistle noise.
00:56:060 (3) - Remove clap on end.
01:00:044 (7) - Finish.
02:50:124 (2) - Remove clap on return.
03:01:865 (1) - Move back to white tick and extend to red tick.
Like I said, copy pasting is booring. :(

[Extreme]

00:31:738 (5) - New combo
00:46:835 (2) - Remove slider whistle noise.
01:20:382 (1) - Remove clap.
03:02:075 (1) - Move back to white tick and extend to red tick.


A few of the things here are the same as [Hardcore], which is really boring. Have variety in between your difficulties.
Also, maybe speed up the slider velocity?
RE1359EBA
313 posts
Joined February 2009
Topic Starter
RE1359EBA

Senbon wrote:

[Entrance]
00:28:384 (5) - Remove slider whistle noise.
00:30:271 (1,2,3) - Hard to read as well.
00:46:834 (3) - Remove slider whistle noise.
01:50:785 (1,2,3) - ^
01:54:770 (5) - Move forward to white tick?

[Standard]

00:23:142 (4) - Replace with whistle.
00:30:271 (1,2,3) - (2,3) are not vocally snapped. Sounds bad too.
00:31:738 (4) - Remove slider whistle noise.
01:50:787 (1,2,3) - Does not sound good using red ticks.
02:50:123 (2) - Remove clap on return.
02:54:316 (4) - Remove clap.
02:56:832 (1) - Remove slider whistle noise.
03:02:075 (1) - Move back to white tick and extend to red tick.

[Hardcore]

00:31:738 (5) - New combo.
00:46:835 (2) - Remove slider whistle noise.
00:56:060 (3) - Remove clap on end.
01:00:044 (7) - Finish.
02:50:124 (2) - Remove clap on return.
03:01:865 (1) - Move back to white tick and extend to red tick.

[Extreme]

00:46:835 (2) - Remove slider whistle noise.
01:20:382 (1) - Remove clap.
03:02:075 (1) - Move back to white tick and extend to red tick.
Niva
Global Moderator
3,196 posts
Joined November 2009
Niva
Another random mod :)

[Entrance]
There are so many unsnapped notes.
00:48:512 (4) - Consider reducing volume for this note?
01:34:641 (2) - Place it in a same height as 01:33:800 (1)
01:37:997 (1) - ^
01:41:348 (1) - ^
02:14:269 (1) - Touching the HP bar, consider moving it lower.
02:14:688 (2) - ^

[Standard]
00:31:108 (3) - Unsnapped note
01:08:220 (2) - Unsnapped note
00:48:723 (3) - Consider reducing volume for this note?
01:00:675 (1) - Move one grid to the right?
02:27:897 (1) - Not quite positioned well... Uh, maybe disable the grid snap for a while and replace this note? Place it perfectly below 02:28:107 (2)
02:54:316 (4) - Change finish into whistle

[Hardcore]
00:26:286 (6) - Unsnapped note
02:55:786 (2) - Unsnapped note
00:48:722 (5) - Consider reducing volume?
01:43:238 (3) and 01:43:657 (5) - Switch hitsound
02:08:189 (4) - Ugly positioning. Place it at a same row as 02:07:980 (3) (if it goes offscreen, just change the slider's curve)
02:52:639 (5) - Remove whistle
02:53:059 (1) - Remove clap, add whistle
02:53:478 (2) - Remove whistle, add clap
02:53:897 (3) - Remove clap, add whistle
02:54:317 (1) - Add clap

[Extreme]
00:26:286 (6) - Unsnapped note
02:55:786 (2) - Unsnapped note
00:22:723 (3) and 00:23:142 (5) - Switch hitsound
00:48:722 (5) - Consider reducing volume?
01:18:705 (7) - Try to hold Shift while positioning for a perfect lining
01:43:656 (5) - Remove whistle, add finish

...You know, don't copy-paste too much. Star
Matma Rex
586 posts
Joined March 2009
Matma Rex
I suggest renaming the diffs like MM said (Breezin', Cruisin', Sweatin', Hard ROCK!).

I think you should not use use clap hitsounds in this map at all. Whistles and finishes sound much better and are enough.

[Extreme]
It's not extreme at all. It's moderately difficult [Hard], and it might even be a [Normal].
02:46:140 (7,8,1) - whoa, dude. That's too much of a jump.
02:06:931, 02:07:350 - add notes here.
02:13:535 (6) - 1/4 earlier.
02:32:091 (5) - ^
You have a lot of places where you should move a note 1/4 earlier. Look thru whole map (in 75/50%, if you need to) and fix them all, please.

02:56:834 (1) - nice, but it can be prettier. Look: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/7496
To get it like that, use File -> Open .osu in Notepad and paste this at the very end of the file, in new line:
88,176,176834,6,12,B|144:168|144:168|208:280|336:272|400:168|400:168|440:176|440:176|392:176|392:176|328:32|176:24|141:170|141:170,2,800,14|14|14
256,192,182075,12,4,185220

[Hardcore]
I understand it's EBA-style, but copypasting entire beatmap and just flipping it is not enough.
Apply the same mods as for [Extreme].
You really should remap it. La Roux - Quicksand is a great example of EBA map with very similar, but a little different Hard and Insane; look at it and get some inspiration. :)

[Standard]
00:43:271 (4) - 1/4 later.
01:58:123 (4,1) - spacing. I suggest to do it this way: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/7497
02:01:898 (3,1) - spacing.
02:33:769 (2,3), 02:35:026 (1,2) - compare spacing.
02:55:784 (1) - 1/2 earlier.

[Entrance]
00:26:497 (2) - 1/2 earlier fits much better.
00:24:191 (1,2,3,4) - spacing.
02:46:557 (1,1,2,1,2,3,4) - spacing.
02:55:575 (5) - 1/2 earlier.


Overall, nice map. Keep going!
Mashley
2,042 posts
Joined September 2008
Mashley
Leave the source blank. Album never goes in there.
Use 700 offset.
For the iNiS feel, use the EBA difficulty names.

Entrance
01:48:891 (5) - Plays better 1/1 earlier imo.

Standard
02:55:155 - Add a note here, it feels empty.

Hardcore/Extreme
Fine
Derekku
COOL DUDE
7,270 posts
Joined March 2009
Derekku
[General]
*Such a tiny background image o-o;
*There are snapping errors on all difficulties.
*This song should be using 1/3 snap ._.
*Offset sounds a bit late, but I'm not sure.

[Entrance]
00:15:803 (2,3) - I suggest using a slider for offbeats like this (not to mention that 3 might sound better on a 1/3 tick..)
00:19:159 (2,3) - ^
00:27:336 (3,4) - Silence here sounds weird, so perhaps make these into a slider (and then do something else after that)
00:30:271 (1,2,3) - maybe make this a repeating slider
00:34:255 (1) - Looks kinda strange being so close to the last slider. How about flipping this to the other corner? (bottom right)
00:35:933 (2,3) - slider please
00:39:288 (2,3) - ^
00:42:643 (2,3) - ^
00:54:382 (1,2) - ^
00:56:061 (3,4) - ^
Stopped here.

Sorry, but the lack of correct snapping is confusing my ears. If you're going to map to the lyrics, then please do it right. This song uses 1/3 in spots, so I'll give you a few examples.

[Extreme]
*Enable 1/3 snap (technically 1/6th since the song seems to use red ticks as well, but 1/3 as simplification for now)
00:54:244 - Add a beat here
00:55:851 (2) - Move forward to the 1/3 tick
00:57:738 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Ridiculously easy for an "extreme" difficulty. Why have four difficulties if they're not even going to get tougher? Add a note 1/3 before each of 2,3,4,5, and then move 6 back 1/3.
Etc.

Again, the difficulty spread is a bit meh. Four difficulties, but the hardest is only a 3.5 star? Plus, they seem to almost be copies of each other, except for added notes, some rotations, and harder difficulty settings. There's so much potential and you're not even mapping as much as you can. I hope I'm not sounding rude, but I think that you still have a bit of work that could be done to this map.
bearing019
osu! Alumni
1,367 posts
Joined June 2009
bearing019
This should be re-mapped to 1/3. Message me when you have that done.
Sonic Fumes
228 posts
Joined November 2009
Sonic Fumes
immediate star
RE1359EBA
313 posts
Joined February 2009
Topic Starter
RE1359EBA
MAP EDIT : BEATMAP SCREEN CHANGE.


↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓


Nakagawa-Kanon
Featured Artist
1,893 posts
Joined March 2009
Nakagawa-Kanon

RE1359EBA wrote:

MAP EDIT : BEATMAP SCREEN CHANGE.

[attachment=1:bf700]LEMON TREE.png[/attachment:bf700]
↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓
[attachment=0:bf700]LEMON TREE.jpg[/attachment:bf700]
그건 맵 소게페이지에 날짜 쓰고 -change bg- 만 하면될듯
Louis Cyphre
2,684 posts
Joined October 2009
Louis Cyphre
[General]
Osb file must be deleted
[Easy]
Beat Map Snap Divisor 1/4
00:16:433 - Move right 1 tick(1/4)
00:19:893 - ^
00:40:021 - ^
00:40:965 - Distance
00:44:424 - ^
00:56:061 - ^
00:58:577 - ^
01:01:513 - ^
01:09:480 - ^
This is easy difficulty, jumps are not allowed. Please recheck Distance Snap.

[Normal],[Hard],[Insane]
Same as in Easy. Check Distance then ask me to recheck.

Oh well. Star.
kino77
909 posts
Joined March 2009
kino77
Hi~!

[General]
You need more clear BG.
Delete .osb file and full submit?
I couldn't understand the way you put hitsound,so I'll shut up.

[Extreme]
You need add note to make the map harder instead of make overall difficulty and HP drain rater higher.

Other fine~
Star~
xierbaliti
osu! Alumni
1,463 posts
Joined August 2008
xierbaliti
-General-
I don't like your spacing and rhythm ;_; Yes there is no big error in the map, but it's not good enough.
You should try to put notes following the song's rhythm.Don't following with vocals all the time ;)
BTW, there's too many random hitsounds here ._.

-Hardcore-
It's "Easycore" not hard ._.
00:26:286 (6) - unsnapped
02:55:786 (2) - ^

-Extreme-
00:26:286 (11) - unsnapped
02:55:786 (2) - ^

well,a encouragement star here.
bearing019
osu! Alumni
1,367 posts
Joined June 2009
bearing019

Louis Cyphre wrote:

[Easy]
Beat Map Snap Divisor 1/4
[color=#0000FF]00:16:433 - Move right 1 tick(1/4)
00:19:893 - ^
00:40:021 - ^
Ignore this, the song is in 1/3 not 1/4 and as such should be mapped accordingly.
RE1359EBA
313 posts
Joined February 2009
Topic Starter
RE1359EBA

xierbaliti wrote:

-Hardcore-
00:26:286 (6) - unsnapped
02:55:786 (2) - ^

-Extreme-
00:26:286 (*11) - unsnapped
02:55:786 (2) - ^
well,a encouragement star here.
*:This is not 11th. This marker number is 6..
Frill
514 posts
Joined March 2010
Frill
[Entrance]

02:44:670 (2) - remove a clap at end

[Standard]

Fun.

[Hardcore]

01:00:673 (1) - remove clap
01:02:560 (5) - add a whistle
01:14:093 (1) - remove clap
02:01:480 (2) - ^
02:07:140 (5) - remove whistle
02:43:833 (6) - add a finish

[Extreme]

01:46:592 (3) - New combo
01:47:431 (1) - remove new combo
01:48:269 (1) - new combo
01:52:044 (1) - Please enlarge it. 01:54:770 end...- and add a whistle

good map~

+Star
RE1359EBA
313 posts
Joined February 2009
Topic Starter
RE1359EBA
[Entrance]

02:44:670 (2) - remove a clap at end

[Hardcore]

01:00:673 (1) - remove clap
01:02:560 (5) - add a whistle
01:14:093 (1) - remove clap
02:01:480 (2) - ^
02:07:140 (5) - remove whistle
02:43:833 (6) - add a finish

[Extreme]

01:46:592 (3) - New combo
01:47:431 (1) - remove new combo
01:48:269 (1) - new combo
01:52:044 (1) - Please enlarge it. 01:54:770 end...- and add a whistle
IceBeam
osu! Alumni
1,958 posts
Joined December 2009
IceBeam
Hello RE1359EBA.

[Entrance]
Way too long for beginner.You don't need to map the whole song,but it's up to you.
00:27:755 (4) - Out of lyrics.Do something else here.Probably change the whole combo moment,from 00:24:191 (1).
00:46:626 - Adding a circle to follow the lyrics?
00:46:834 (2) - Start slider at 00:47:045?
01:02:140 (5) - End it at 01:02:771?

[Standart]
00:46:626 (3) - Add a circle?
00:46:835 (1) - Start slider at 00:47:045?
02:31:882 - I don't like finish hitsound here,maybe change it to whistle?

[Hardcore]
01:15:980 (5) - Add a whistle here.
02:29:785 (5) - ^
03:02:075 (1) - Spinner starts here - 03:01:865.

[Extreme]
03:02:075 (1) - Spinner starts here - 03:01:865.

Well,I don't see much difference between the difficulties,and I don't like long sliders,especially in Hard diffs.Anyway,good luck and have a star~
NotShinta
1,021 posts
Joined September 2009
NotShinta
Yay iNiS style.

General
No, really, album doesn't go in source. Feel free to put it in the Tags though.
Use 2 tick rate, all diffs. iNiS ticks are all evenly placed, so slider ticks like 00:26:288 (2) on Entrance, 00:29:223 (4) on Standard, 00:14:126 (1) on Hardcore are very unauthentic.

Entrance
00:16:433 (3) - Center. Remember to do this to all similar hitcircles too.
02:51:799 (1,2,3,4) - All iNiS sliders have at least 1 tick. Another reason for the 2 tick rate.
02:56:833 (1) - WTF. This is the least iNiS slider I've ever seen. Not only does the slider overlap itself, it's confusing to look at and the start and end points overlap. Plus, it doesn't follow the music at all. Completely redo this.

Standard
02:56:833 (1) - Symmetry.
02:56:832 (1) - Bloody hell. Also, I just noticed it's slider art. Good idea, but not executed well enough.

Hardcore
00:32:997 (4,5) - What these there for
02:56:834 (1) - etc.
And the same for that other diff

Yeah, pretty iNiS. Mostly. Starred.
Mok
1,226 posts
Joined August 2009
Mok
I won't mod this since you didn't followed my rules -.-
-Xero-
526 posts
Joined October 2009
-Xero-
hi,

[general]
maybe add inis as tag?

[easy]
00:47:045 (5) - remove finish + new combo
02:14:269 (1,2) - Remove or map the break.

[normal]
02:14:268 (1,2) - Look at easy. Maybe you can try deleting the 2 only.
02:44:671 (2) - Remove finish and place a finish on the 3.

[hard]
00:26:916 (1) - 1 tick to the left
02:14:270 (8) - New Combo and look at easy/normal

[insane]
02:14:270 (8) - New Combo and ....

+star!
Amethyst Wolf
184 posts
Joined April 2010
Amethyst Wolf
I'm here from Wmf and Vikon's modding queue.

Attention:
If I put a ? there, you can do that if you want.
If I pua a . there, you have to do thet.
All gril change in lv3. Remember follow hitobject's snap.

[General]

[Entrance]
- It this easy? Jump should not be find in esay diff.
00:15:804 (2) Down 2 grid.
00:19:159 (2) ^
00:26:288 (2) spacing
00:27:336 (3) ^
00:27:775 (4) ^
00:30:271 (1,2,3) ^, Forward to 00:30:062, add a circle to 00:31:320
00:35:933 (2) spacing
00:39:287 (2) ^
00:46:416 (3) ^
00:48:723 (6) ^
00:56:061 (3) ^
00:57:739 (1-5) ^
01:01:513 (3,5) ^
01:04:029 (2) ^
01:06:964 (2) ^
.
.
.
.
.
Please attention on spacing. Give up to mod.



Some suggestion:
Easy and Normal not to jump / to change distance spacing.
Have to turn grid snap & distance snap on?
Try to make maps after you play 1000 maps or more.

Finally, work more harder.
RE1359EBA
313 posts
Joined February 2009
Topic Starter
RE1359EBA

Amethyst Wolf wrote:

[Entrance]
- It this easy? Jump should not be find in esay diff.
00:15:804 (2) Down 2 grid.
00:19:159 (2) ^00:26:288 (2) spacing
00:27:336 (3) ^
00:27:775 (4) ^
00:30:271 (1,2,3) ^, Forward to 00:30:062, add a circle to 00:31:320
00:35:933 (2) spacing
00:39:287 (2) ^
00:46:416 (3) ^
00:48:723 (6) ^
00:56:061 (3) ^
00:57:739 (1-5) ^
01:01:513 (3,5) ^
01:04:029 (2) ^
01:06:964 (2) ^
RandomJibberish
osu! Alumni
1,833 posts
Joined August 2009
RandomJibberish
THIS MAP IS IN THE WRONG SNAP

You'll have to modify it a lot, but I assure you to will play 9001 times better if you map it using 1/3 snap

I'll mod it if and when you do so

kthx
ZLOdeuka-
1,442 posts
Joined June 2009
ZLOdeuka-
very unexpected map ~ all of complications a bit went out for scopes.

problems with an spacing ? it can so it must be, but it seems to me for *easy* it too

~star all right
Kiddo-Kun
1,014 posts
Joined May 2009
Kiddo-Kun
This is only half mod~
It's been a long day and I'm tired I'll get to it tommorow
And RandomJibberish is right. You should use 1/3

Lets get down to businesses!

I'duction

A lot of the notes aren't snapped


00:26:288 - Spacing
00:27:755 - Expand by 1/2
00:47:045 - Fix the hit sounds on this slider sounds ugly
00:56:061 - Spacing
01:03:609 - A bunch of claps together like that is ugly IMO
01:08:222 - Should move 3 grids down
01:09:480 - Spacing
01:10:109 - Also should move 3 Grids down




Extreme:

00:25:239 - Spacing
00:36:142 - Add note
01:45:544 - Spacing
02:07:560 - Remove new combo
02:08:189 - Add new combo
02:11:543 - New Combo
02:51:801 - ^


Standard:

00:29:223 - Weird Spacing
00:35:915 - Don't you think this is to close?
00:46:626 - Add note
00:46:836 - Remove note
00:48:723 - Remove clap and maybe add finish
01:01:722 - A bunch of claps together like that is ugly IMO
01:04:658 - Maybe set it back 1/2
01:15:141 - A bunch of claps together like that is ugly IMO
01:49:737 - Weird spacing
02:09:866 - Watch the spacing
02:30:833 - ^
DeletedUser_151115
DeletedUser_151115
Mod! [REQUEST VIA QUEUE]

Anything marked with a * is a suggestion.

[Extreme]
Fine.

[Hardcore]
Fine.

[Standard]
00:59:416 (5,6) - replace 5 with slider and end of slider is replacing 6 *

[I'duction]
Kinda seems like a NORMAL diff, but that's just me.

+Star!~
Vikon
343 posts
Joined December 2008
Vikon
[General]
1) the size of the Background is 974 x 732, try to use a 1024 x 768 or 800 x 600 instead?
2) try to make more different patternm or your map is a bit boring....

[I'duction]
1) resnap all notes plz
00:14:127 (1) the end of the slider is a little bit too high, try to pull it back?
00:17:481 (1) ^
00:20:836 (1) ^
01:02:142 (5) end at 01:02:561 ?
01:06:125 (1) pull it back.?
from 01:33:802 to 01:52:253 , the whole pattern is repeated? make some changes to avoid boredom ?
from 02:08:189 to 02:46:559 , ^

[Standard]
00:31:108 (3) unsnapped note
01:00:046 (6) pull it back?
...... [Standard] is too similar to [I'duction]? may be 1 [E] is enough?
also, the repeat of same patteran may cause boredom.

[Hardcore]
1) resnap all notes
2) the repeat patteran cause boredom.

[Extreme]
1) resnap all notes
2) ......The pattern of this diff is too similar to [Hardcore]? try to make more changes?

sorry for my lazy mod, but the map is not interesting unless you make more change.
you can give me no kudosu if you think my suggestions are useless.
EvianBubble
339 posts
Joined October 2009
EvianBubble
Hi there ... very interesting song you have here :P

I'duction
00:20:836 (1) - This slider goes a bit high, maybe move this lower? Also, spacing between the end of this slider and the next one
00:26:288 (2) - Spacing. Move to the right?
00:34:255 (1) - Same as first comment, except it's a bit low. Move up and left?
00:47:045 (1) - Spacing
01:34:641 (2) - New combo?
01:34:641 (2) until 01:53:931 (end of 4) - The design here is mostly the same as the beginning. You should change it up to make it more interesting and fun to play
02:21:608 (1) until 02:45:720 (end of 2) - Same design again. Do something different
02:49:704 (1, 2, 1 of next combo) - Spacing! This jump is too far for the length and difficulty

Standard
01:34:641 (1) until 01:53:931 (end of 4) - Same as your easier difficulty, you should try to make some new patterns
01:55:189 (3) - This is pretty low. Move this combo up?
02:21:608 (1) until 02:45:720 (3) - Same thing
02:49:704 (1, 2, 1 of next combo) - Spacing again

Hardcore
00:17:272 (4, 1 of next combo) - Spacing, should be the same as (3) to (4) (also apply this to anything else like this, like 00:20:626, etc.)
01:18:496 (6) - Delete this, move the rest of the combo up
01:34:641 (2) - New combo?
01:34:641 (1) until 01:51:624 (6) - Erm, see above comments?
01:52:044 (1) - Shorten this spinner by one or two beats?
02:21:608 (1) until 02:45:720 (6) - Too much copy paste flip is not a good thing!

Extreme
Overall this just feels like wider spaced version of Hardcore with harder difficulty settings. I would suggest re - mapping most of this or at least changing the main patterns, but if not, most of my comments for Hardcore also apply here

The song is pretty good, but overall I feel that the patterns are overused (the result of too much copy pasta?). I think this has a lot of potential, so keep working on it. Good job :)
Armin
osu! Alumni
2,454 posts
Joined May 2009
Armin
Dish of the Day should be a tag, not a Source
And I think this should be mapped in 1/3 D:

[I'duction]

00:30:341 (1,2,3) - Put all these hitobjects 1/3 later
00:54:384 (1,3) - Add some whistles here
01:02:142 (5) - This doesn't fit the rythm. Add a hircircle here: 01:03:190 (x) - or make it 1/2 shorter
01:07:803 (1,3) - Add some whistles here
01:15:561 (5) - Make it 1/2 shorter
01:50:786 (1,2,3) - 1/3 later
01:54:770 (1) - This time I think you should use the DS. Stack this on the next slider?
02:21:608 (1,3) - Whistles
02:30:414 (x) - Add a hitcircle here
02:43:833 (x) - As above
02:33:349 (1,2,3) - Put these in the middle, for the sake of the symmetry

[Standard]

00:30:690 (2,3) - Use the same value of the Ds here (1,0x)
02:06:721 (1) - Spacing, because the pattern is a bit messy

[Hardcore]

00:22:513 (2,3,4,5) - This doesn't fit the vocal voice. Use the 1/3 BSD here
00:26:078 (3,4,5) - As above
00:30:271 (5,7,8) - 1/3 later
and many hitobjects like these ones.
02:06:931 (x) - Add a hitcircle here

[Extreme]

Hard rock versione of the previous diff, I guess. So, see the same suggestions.
Clare
530 posts
Joined October 2009
Clare
hi~~

[I'duction]
00:45:997 (2) - remove whistle in slider

[Standard]
01:08:222 (2,3) - 1 grid up
02:11:543 (5) - new combo
02:35:446 (2,3) - 1 grid up

[Hardcore]
02:11:543 (4) - new combo

[Extreme]
fine

many copy OTL

star
Kurai
osu! Alumni
7,734 posts
Joined March 2009
Kurai
Hi~

[I'duction]
01:37:996 (1) - Move 1/2 earlier

[Extreme]
00:46:626 (4) - Add note
00:46:836 (5) - Move 1/2 later and delete 00:48:303 (6)

Star~
Sallad4ever
2,942 posts
Joined October 2009
Sallad4ever
Hi sorry I'm really late

[General]
- You still have some unsnapped objects on all of your diff so re-snap all notes
- If "Dish of the Day" is the name of the album, then put it in tags not source, see this for more information viewtopic.php?f=6&t=24765
- Copy-paste is okay, but try not to do it all through the diff
- Oh my still not snapped to 1/3, you should snapped it to 1/3 . Example 00:30:271 (1) - this should be snapped to 1/3

Don't give me kds cause I didn't give anything that could improve your map

Good luck
star
Sallad4ever
2,942 posts
Joined October 2009
Sallad4ever
Double post >.<
mm201
osu! Alumni
4,495 posts
Joined August 2008
mm201
Please adjust all the notes to a 1/3 snap. Set the slider at the top right so that it says "1/3." Then nudge all the notes on your timeline that aren't on purple or white ticks so that they are. You'll want to check that it sounds correct and respace bits and pieces.

I've done the first section on Extreme for you and it's attached.

Also, for the lemon slider, consider this:


It's also found within the attached .osu file.

And delete the osb.

Download: Fool's Garden - Lemon Tree (RE1359EBA) [Extreme].osu
DerekMcD
1,484 posts
Joined February 2009
DerekMcD
*Star*
Pokie
osu! Alumni
2,630 posts
Joined December 2009
Pokie
General
  • Resnap all note on all diffs :< They're still unsnapped.

Extreme
  • OA8 doesn't fit D: Maybe reduce to 7?

And that's all :D
Perfect one~ You should find BATs to check your map :D
Garven
osu! Alumni
5,857 posts
Joined January 2010
Garven
As per your second request, heh.

1/3 snap would be sexy.

[Easy]
00:31:739 (4,1) - This is a pretty big jump for the difficulty.

Check AI Mod for that one unsnapped note. :/

That's about it, really.
RandomJibberish
osu! Alumni
1,833 posts
Joined August 2009
RandomJibberish

RE1359EBA wrote:

radically, This map is '1/3 snap'.
but, I shall leave it at that(for 1/2 snap).
because, Big problem not happen setup with 1/2snap.
Uh yeah, I keep hitting it in 1/3 and getting 100s. That's a bit of a problem.

Fixing it wouldn't even take long :/
Shiro
Global Moderator
4,984 posts
Joined May 2009
Shiro
Major issues in the map : change them.
Minor issue in the map : you don't have to follow them exactly, but if you don't, explain why.
Suggestions : those are personal opinions, feel free to follow them or not.
If there's one red line in the whole mod post, or three blue lines, I won't star the map.

MAP IT USING 1/3.

Generally:
This looks like a Beginner difficutly. I won't mod it because I'd rather say nothing than say something wrong.

Mediocrity:
When I played there was something that was really bothering me and I couldn't find what, even retrying the map several times. Then I went in the editor and I discovered this : Most beats are on red ticks. This is counter-intuitive.

Severity:
01:09:061 (2) - Move it a but closer to 3.
01:37:996 (1) - Too far from previous object.
01:41:350 (1) - ^
02:36:286 (2) - Move it a bit closer to 3.

Exteme:
This is basically Severity with harder song setup and sometimes some notes added D: you should remap this
bearing019
osu! Alumni
1,367 posts
Joined June 2009
bearing019
Now you're getting somewhere.

Overall;

Those difficulty names are horrible.

Generally;

00:14:127 (1) - 1/3 longer.
00:16:503 (3) - 1/3 forward.
00:17:481 (1) - 1/3 shorter.
00:19:718 (3) - 1/3 forward.
00:26:567 (2,3,4,5) - Like this;

00:34:255 (1) - 2/3 shorter.
00:36:492 (3) - 1/3 forward.
00:37:610 (1) - 2/3 shorter OR 1/3 longer, whichever you prefer.
00:39:846 (3) - 1/3 later.
00:40:965 (1) - 1/3 longer.
00:47:115 (3) - 1/3 longer.
00:48:653 (4) - 1/3 forward.
00:54:943 (2) - ^
00:56:620 (4) - ^
01:08:362 (2) - ^
01:10:039 (4) - ^
01:15:563 (5) - This is still on the 1/2.
Go through and check your rhythms thouroughly. There's also a lot of 1/2 still around, you should check that out.
Sakura
osu! Alumni
7,979 posts
Joined March 2010
Sakura
[Timing]
I think BPM should be 143.000 flat

[osz File Scan!]
Fine

[General]
Lots of notes feel off, try the BPM i provided

[Extreme]
Circle Size -1
01:44:146 (1) - Out of Bounds.

I'll wait for a fix to the notes or the timing before i continue modding this
Doodley
310 posts
Joined January 2010
Doodley
Sorry for the lateness, I was busy with my skin. Also, if it wasn't already pointed out before, we've got a lot of maps with the same song, with only DJ Mars' version ranked and another one by some other artist, I think. Really popular song.
Despite this, your beatmap seems to go on the backbeat rather than the lyrics, so I guess it's all good in the neighborhood.
I like DJ Mars' version better, though.

Not too many problems, too.

General Notes
I'm not going to check the timing on this because A.) I'm too familiar with DJ Mars's version and D.) It feels fine but odd at the same time, probably because it's 1/3.

Extreme

General Difficulty is pretty damn high with the biggest notes paired with it. It's like...playing Level 20 Tetris with only line pieces. Lower it by two and make the notes smaller by two? Just a suggestion.
02:46:629: Note is crazy far from the last. Flip it vertically and move it up a bit.
02:56:833: Hehe...A lemon slider.

Severity
Is it me or does this difficulty feel harder than Extreme?
This difficulty is also very similar to Extreme.
00:17:481: Note is far from the last. Move it closer and then move 2, 3, 4 so they are closer...perhaps flip 2, 3 and 4?
00:20:836: ^ Same problem.
01:37:996: ^
01:41:350: ^
02:56:833: THIS IS A LIME. NOT A LEMON./joke

Resolutely
No problems.

Generally
No problems.

Star, but please fix those spacing problems.
Daerren
28 posts
Joined January 2010
Daerren
goku modding!


this map has a lot of spacing issues.
im stopping here.
James2250
osu! Alumni
4,059 posts
Joined July 2008
James2250
resize background so it's 800x600
I really don't think the finish hitsounds work well, get rid of most of them apart from the ones at the end of an entire section
resnap all notes on all difficulties

Generally:
overall difficulty+1
Extend these by 1/3
00:14:125 (1)
00:17:477 (1)
00:34:250 (1)
00:37:605 (1)
00:40:959 (1)
01:34:628 (1)
01:37:982 (1)
02:08:171 (1)
02:11:525 (4)
00:36:487 (3) - move 1/4 back
00:39:841 (3) - move 1/4 back
01:06:536 (2) - add note
01:43:573 (2) - move 1/4 back
02:01:882 (3) - ends at an odd place
02:10:407 (3) - move back 1/4
02:55:690 (3) - move to white tick
02:56:389 (4) - add note

On the other difficulties there are still sliders and stuff that are not mapped to 1/3 and similar problems to what I mention here, go through everything and try and change so it all fits the song (there would be a page of modding if I went through it allllll so it would be easier on your part to simply go and check it)
Emdyion
292 posts
Joined October 2009
Emdyion
What DiamondCrash said. Plus, I don't like how you copy and paste patterns. This is nothing like iNiS style.
Especially the sliders. I don't think they are in the right place.
btw BLACKLISTED for not following modding queue rules.
Dusty
870 posts
Joined June 2009
Dusty
The timing and/or note placement on the timeline feels wrong and there's nothing I can do to help that, sorry. ._.
Zelos
1,111 posts
Joined May 2010
Zelos
You did a good job on this map.

However, for future reference, DONT use 1/3 snap on a map if the bpm does not divide by 3. The easy and normal diffs could have been done without the 1/3rd snap.

You made it work though.

Good Luck with this map.
RandomJibberish
osu! Alumni
1,833 posts
Joined August 2009
RandomJibberish

zelos15 wrote:

You did a good job on this map.

However, for future reference, DONT use 1/3 snap on a map if the bpm does not divide by 3. The easy and normal diffs could have been done without the 1/3rd snap.

You made it work though.

Good Luck with this map.
You clearly do not understand what 1/3 is for

kindly STFU
LesTrucsRoses
271 posts
Joined July 2010
LesTrucsRoses
[Generally]
SPOILER
00:30:476 (1,2,3) - Move forward by 1 tick on 1/3 beatsnap.
00:47:528 (3) - Move forward by 3 ticks on 1/3 beatsnap.
00:47:109 (3) - Add a beat here. (Might be too hard for a Easy diff)
01:06:116 (1,2,3) - Move these beats to the right by 1 grid on gridlevel 3.
01:50:840 (1,2,3) - Move forward by 3 ticks on 1/3 beatsnap.
02:06:779 (1,2) - These 2 notes might be too close for an easy diff.

[Resolutely]
SPOILER
00:14:127 (1) - Shorten this slider by 2 ticks on 1/3 beatsnap.
00:17:478 (1) - Shorten this slider by 2 ticks on 1/3 beatsnap.
00:30:478 (1,2,3) - Move forward by 1 tick on 1/3 beatsnap.
01:41:336 (1) - Shorten this slider by 1 tick on 1/3 beatsnap.
02:48:422 (1) - Remove the finish hitsound from the last beat in this slider.

[Extremeity]
SPOILER
00:17:479 (1) - Shorten this slider by 1 tick on 1/3 beatsnap.
00:25:306 (2) - Move this slider forward by 1 tick on 1/3 beatsnap.
00:30:477 (6) - Move this beat back by 1 tick on 1/3 beatsnap.
00:30:756 (7) - Add a beat here.
01:45:809 (2) - Move this slider forward by 1 tick on 1/3 beatsnap.
01:51:120 (4) - 00:30:477 (6) - Move this beat back by 1 tick on 1/3 beatsnap.
01:51:260 (5) - Add a beat here.
RE1359EBA
313 posts
Joined February 2009
Topic Starter
RE1359EBA

LesTrucsRose wrote:

[Generally]
00:30:476 (1,2,3) - Move forward by 1 tick on 1/3 beatsnap.
00:47:528 (3) - Move forward by 3 ticks on 1/3 beatsnap.
00:47:109 (3) - Add a beat here. (Might be too hard for a Easy diff)
01:06:116 (1,2,3) - Move these beats to the right by 1 grid on gridlevel 3.
01:50:840 (1,2,3) - Move forward by 3 ticks on 1/3 beatsnap.
02:06:779 (1,2) - These 2 notes might be too close for an easy diff.

[Resolutely]
00:14:127 (1) - Shorten this slider by 2 ticks on 1/3 beatsnap.
00:17:478 (1) - Shorten this slider by 2 ticks on 1/3 beatsnap.
00:30:478 (1,2,3) - Move forward by 1 tick on 1/3 beatsnap.
01:41:336 (1) - Shorten this slider by 1 tick on 1/3 beatsnap.
02:48:422 (1) - Remove the finish hitsound from the last beat in this slider.
(Just remove 02:49:820. Other(02:49:121, 02:48:422) don't remove sound.)
[Extremity]
00:17:479 (1) - Shorten this slider by 1 tick on 1/3 beatsnap.
00:25:306 (2) - Move this slider forward by 1 tick on 1/3 beatsnap.(Consider)
00:30:477 (6) - Move this beat back by 1 tick on 1/3 beatsnap.
00:30:756 (7) - Add a beat here. (A note(7) move back by 00:30:756)
01:45:809 (2) - Move this slider forward by 1 tick on 1/3 beatsnap.(Consider)
01:51:120 (4) - 00:30:477 (6) - Move this beat back by 1 tick on 1/3 beatsnap.
01:51:260 (5) - Add a beat here. (A note(5) move back by 00:30:756)
Hyguys
1,272 posts
Joined May 2010
Hyguys
General
The map will be more cool with this colors:
Color 1: Yellow
Color 2: Green
Color 3: Brown
Will be like an tree :3

Generally
00:14:125 That slider will be better if it finish on 00:14:845

00:15:802 Not needed Finish , but , wut :3
00:19:899 To late beat , make it a little early.

Resolutely
Change Slider tick rate to 0,5 :3
00:36:347 Make this beat more early .
02:10:687 ^
02:56:808 Remove finish.

Severity
Change Slider tick rate to 0,5 :3
00:22:790 Remove finish :3
00:32:993 (4) (5) Not needed beat.
01:04:858 Make beat early :3
02:32:070 Make beat early
02:56:808 Remove finish

Extremity
Same mods as Severity :3
Vanmonky
986 posts
Joined June 2009
Vanmonky
As your request.
Read this first for the icon explanation.
- [?] Asking for a second thought.
- [!] Fatal error. You have to fix this for sure.
- [No icon] Only a suggestion.

[General]
1. No comment about the hitsound.
2. Better silence the sliderslide.
3. Bad diffs names.
4. Actually, 00:49:345 and 02:15:299 is not a good place for break.

[Generally]
-- There are a lot of 1/3 notes. I don't know if it will be too hard for beginner player.
-- Why must copy-pastah? Are you lack of idea or something?
-- There are so many objects unsnapped. [!]
-- Actually, such this note (00:16:431 (3)) is better placed on 1/4 tick (the red one). I don't know. It may be just me.

00:14:125 (1) - Isn't this slider better if extended one 1/3 tick?
00:17:479 (1) - ^
00:34:250 (1) - ^
00:37:605 (1) - ^
00:45:991 (2) - Reduce one 1/3 tick. [?]
01:34:628 (1) - Isn't this slider better if extended one 1/3 tick?
01:37:982 (1) - ^
02:08:171 (1) - ^
02:11:525 (4) - ^
02:11:525 (4,1) - Swap the new combo.

[Resolutely]
-- Now I really hate how you copy-pasted all things that you feel it's okay.
-- There are some notes which unsnapped. Fix them. [!]

00:14:125 (1,2,3,4) - This pattern fits the song. But you know what? By using this the same pattern on 00:17:479, it don't fit anymore especially with the slider. Please, stop copy-pasting things. This is not iNis map, I can see it clearly.
00:55:773 (1) - Should be placed on 00:55:914.
01:19:533 (4,1) - Swap new combo, maybe?
01:36:585 (3) - Should be placed on 01:36:724, actually.
01:37:982 (1) - Extend this on 01:38:611 (1/4 tick).
01:41:336 (1) - This slider doesn't fit at all.
02:13:622 (1) - Move backward one 1/3 tick.
02:22:986 (1) - Should be placed on 02:23:125.
02:55:830 (1) - Better remove the new combo.

[Severity]
-- There are some notes which unsnapped. Fix them. [!]

00:17:479 (1) - This slider doesn't fit at all.
00:25:166 (2) - Move this forward one 1/3 tick.
00:31:176 (8) - Move backward one 1/3 tick. [?]
00:48:507 (6) - This should be closer to the end of the slider. Fix the distance! [!]
01:04:858 (5) - Move backward one 1/3 tick.
01:20:372 (1) - This should be closer to the end of the slider. Fix the distance! [!]
01:40:078 (5) - Move backward one 1/3 tick.
01:41:336 (1) - This slider doesn't fit at all.
01:45:669 (2) - This slider doesn't fit at all. Move it to 01:45:949 then reduce one 1/3 tick.
02:09:848 (1,4) - Swap new combo.
02:32:070 (5) - Move backward one 1/3 tick.
02:45:487 (5) - ^

[Extremity]
Remove this diff. This is just like the [Severity] diff but with higher OD and smaller hitcircle. [!]

Anyway, there are some notes unsnapped here :p
Star. Actually I still don't want to star this. But since this is far better then it was, I appreciate it. But promise me to fix all of them, especially for the [Extremity] diff.
Last edited by Vanmonky , edited 1 time in total.
RE1359EBA
313 posts
Joined February 2009
Topic Starter
RE1359EBA

VanMoNky wrote:

[Generally]
00:14:125 (1) - Isn't this slider better if extended one 1/3 tick?
00:17:479 (1) - ^
00:34:250 (1) - ^
00:37:605 (1) - ^
(extend one tick.)
00:45:991 (2) - Reduce one 1/3 tick.
01:34:628 (1) - Isn't this slider better if extended one 1/3 tick?
01:37:982 (1) - ^
02:08:171 (1) - ^
02:11:525 (4) - ^
(extend one tick too.)
02:11:525 (4,1) - Swap the new combo.

[Resolutely]
00:14:125 (1,2,3,4) - This pattern fits the song. But you know what? By using this the same pattern on 00:17:479, it don't fit anymore especially with the slider. Please, stop copy-pasting things. This is not iNis map, I can see it clearly.
(▲ I will fit. but, May be take a long time..)
00:55:773 (1) - Should be placed on 00:55:914.
01:19:533 (4,1) - Swap new combo, maybe?
01:36:585 (3) - Should be placed on 01:36:724, actually.
01:37:982 (1) - Extend this on 01:38:611 (1/4 tick).
01:41:336 (1) - This slider doesn't fit at all.
02:13:622 (1) - Move backward one 1/3 tick.
02:22:986 (1) - Should be placed on 02:23:125.
02:55:830 (1) - Better remove the new combo.

[Severity]
00:17:479 (1) - This slider doesn't fit at all.
00:25:166 (2) - Move this forward one 1/3 tick.
00:31:176 (8) - Move backward one 1/3 tick.
00:48:507 (6) - This should be closer to the end of the slider. Fix the distance!
01:04:858 (5) - Move backward one 1/3 tick.
01:20:372 (1) - This should be closer to the end of the slider. Fix the distance! [!]
01:40:078 (5) - Move backward one 1/3 tick.
01:41:336 (1) - This slider doesn't fit at all.
01:45:669 (2) - This slider doesn't fit at all. Move it to 01:45:949 then reduce one 1/3 tick.
02:09:848 (1,4) - Swap new combo.
02:32:070 (5) - Move backward one 1/3 tick.
02:45:487 (5) - ^
00:17:479, 01:41:336 - I will fit, too. but, May be take a long time too..


[Extremity]
Sorry, I not be about to do something remove Extremity diff. :|
[/notice]
Haneii
1,203 posts
Joined November 2009
Haneii
~General~
-Your BG is a weird dimension but I asked someone and they said it was okay. (But it still bugs me :P)
-mp3's are not allowed to exceed 256kbps. Your current mp3 is 320kps. I've re-encoded it for you:
Fools Garden - Lemontree.mp3


~All the difficulties~
- Go over spacing on everything! Too many spacing errors!!!
- overall I guess it isn't so bad, but the maps did feel really repetitive.
- I'm not too sure about some of those 1/3 notes. I did really bad playing on the easy difficulties and I could just blame my ability on standard but I can't help but wonder if some (not all since most are right on the 1/3) of them should be 1/2?


Good luck
kanpakyin
Global Moderator
4,236 posts
Joined June 2010
kanpakyin
Mod...
ReD=I think you should fix this
BluE=Just a suggestion
[Genera]
-the map usually usie 1/4 ,it is odd that you were use 1/3?
-The offset should be778
-using distance snap!!
-pay attention to the spacing,many spacing mistake

[Generally]
00:42:616(2)Remove finish?
01:21:317(.)add a notes here?

[Severity]
00:30:152(5.6.7.8)spacing
00:48:789(6)Remove finish?
01:21:229(.)add a spinner here to 01:22:842
(The lemon is cute in the end>.<Good paint0.0)

[Extremity]
HP-1?
01:20:326(1)remove new conbo?
Guzzzzm4n
177 posts
Joined October 2008
Guzzzzm4n
Hello~

[General]
Add one Slider tick Rate more (2)
In the tags, why not add some more? For example add it the music style of the band

[Generally]
00:54:376 : It would not be correct to use kiai, since it is chorus
01:50:980 : From this time until this (01:50:980) looks weird, try to fix it?
02:06:773 : I think that is shorter than the stream, it is difficult for an easy
02:21:588 : Kiai Again?

[Resolutely]
00:54:376 : Kiai?
01:33:789 : This circle, move it one line further to the right
02:21:588 : Kiai Again?
02:46:405 : This slider move it in 3 times to the left and add a another repetition


[Severity]
00:54:376 : Kiai?
01:33:789 : This circle, move it one line further to the right
02:21:588 : Kiai Again?
02:46:605 : Turn it up a grid is more to this slider, so it is in the same line as the previous circle

[Extremity]
00:54:376 : Kiai Again, and Again and Again :(
01:33:789 : This circle, move it one line further to the right. Again :cry:
02:21:588 : Kiai Again?

That's it, good luck. Star :)
RE1359EBA
313 posts
Joined February 2009
Topic Starter
RE1359EBA

darck360 wrote:

from RE1359EBA : I'm not going to add 'Kiai'. sorry. :|
[General]
Add one Slider tick Rate more (2)
In the tags, why not add some more? For example add it the music style of the band
[Generally]
00:54:376 : It would not be correct to use kiai, since it is chorus
01:50:980 : From this time until this (01:50:980) looks weird, try to fix it?
02:06:773 : I think that is shorter than the stream, it is difficult for an easy

[Resolutely]
01:33:789 : This circle, move it one line further to the right
02:46:405 : This slider move it in 3 times to the left and add a another repetition

[Severity]
01:33:789 : This circle, move it one line further to the right
02:46:605 : Turn it up a grid is more to this slider, so it is in the same line as the previous circle

[Extremity]
01:33:789 : This circle, move it one line further to the right. Again :cry:
Fapfrit
804 posts
Joined December 2009
Fapfrit
Lemon Tree ~ wow

To get started, to correct timing. then put everything on the rhythm and write in queue. I'll help: 3

Timing:
BPM: 143
Offset: 326

Good luck. Star ~
SPOILER
I love this song :D
RE1359EBA
313 posts
Joined February 2009
Topic Starter
RE1359EBA

Famfrit wrote:

I love this song :D
I like this song. too. 8-)
Sandpig
847 posts
Joined September 2010
Sandpig
hi :D

(>'(oo)')> my mod <('(oo)'<)


there is something wrong with your submission and I can only download 2 diff....reupload and full submit your map.

I'll mod these 2 diffs and when you have fixed the submission problem you can send me a PM and I'll mod other 2 diffs if you want.


Severity

it plays really bad because you snap almost all of your notes on 1/3.

I'm going to point out some parts that I feel unplayable

00:29:277 (4,5,6,7,8)
01:01:025 (2,3,4,5)
01:14:451 (2,3,4,5)
01:19:626 (8,9,1)
01:34:032 (1) - move it to 01:33:892
01:45:780 (2,1,2,3,4,5)
01:49:836 (2,3,4,5,6)
02:33:333 (1,2,3,4)

hmm..you really need some work here...


Generally

00:57:808 (1,2,3,4,5) - they are too far away from each other for beginners!
01:11:235 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^
02:04:941 (4,5,6,7) - ^
02:06:899 (1,2,3,4) - I don't think beginners can deal with them
02:24:941 (1,2,3,4,5) - make them closer
02:38:368 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^

that's it
RE1359EBA
313 posts
Joined February 2009
Topic Starter
RE1359EBA

shabao_pig wrote:

[Severity]
00:29:277 (4,5,6,7,8)
01:01:025 (2,3,4,5)
01:14:451 (2,3,4,5)
01:19:626 (8,9,1)
01:34:032 (1) - move it to 01:33:892
01:45:780 (2,1,2,3,4,5)
01:49:836 (2,3,4,5,6)
02:33:333 (1,2,3,4)
During adove note, There is some notes no 1/3 snap.
So, I'm change the some notes 1/3note into 1/2 note.
[Generally]
00:57:808 (1,2,3,4,5) - they are too far away from each other for beginners!
01:11:235 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^
02:04:941 (4,5,6,7) - ^
(I can't understand about why should far this each notes.
This is too plainly to be out of spacing.)
02:06:899 (1,2,3,4) - I don't think beginners can deal with them.
02:24:941 (1,2,3,4,5) - make them closer
02:38:368 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^
Arusha Shuna
1,793 posts
Joined August 2009
Arusha Shuna
Request Accepted
General
>timing is off? I'm not really sure but i had to use -30 to -40 custom offset while testing
>if this is authentic style why don't you rename the diffs to "Breezin', Cruisin', Sweatin', and Hard ROCK!"?
>Remove everything from the tags since album name doesn't belong there and song genre will be set after ranking, and please remove that comma
Generally
uuugh something is horribly wrong with this, but i don't know what
02:06:899 (1,2) - i think they're a little bit hard for an Easy diff
Resolutely
01:02:284 (4,5) - 1 grid to the left
01:15:710 (4,5) - 1 grid to the right
02:42:843 (4,5) - 1 grid to the left
Severity
00:33:471 (4) - remove finish, add whistle
i didn't mod the Extremity diff since the timing is way off, sorry
+1 for the beat placement though
wmfchris
osu! Alumni
5,072 posts
Joined March 2008
wmfchris
[Extremity]
0:32:633 (3) left 1 grid to make it smymetrical

The other diffs are fine.

Sorry that I'm not good at modding authentic style, so I only checks the symmetrical works.
RE1359EBA
313 posts
Joined February 2009
Topic Starter
RE1359EBA

Arusha Shuna wrote:

>timing is off?
What do you strangely mean?
Rucker
Former osu! Champion: OWC#1
561 posts
Joined August 2009
Rucker
lemon tree :O
RE1359EBA
313 posts
Joined February 2009
Topic Starter
RE1359EBA
..
bearing019
osu! Alumni
1,367 posts
Joined June 2009
bearing019
General;

EBA names plz
BPM should be 143.06, Offset should be 745.

Generally;

01:00:186 - Note here.
01:13:612 - ^
01:43:962 (2) - Move back 1/3.
01:46:899 (2) - Move 2/3 forward, end at 01:48:018.
01:55:291 (2) - 1/2 longer (yes this ends on the red tick)
01:58:228 (3) - 1/3 shorter.
02:02:004 (3) - 1/2 longer.
02:06:899 (1) - Delete.
02:21:305 to end - Move forward 1/3.

I'll uh mod the rest once you've changed the BPM.
RE1359EBA
313 posts
Joined February 2009
Topic Starter
RE1359EBA
Red Point : Done.

DiamondCrash wrote:

EBA names plz
from RE' : This map is iNiS but is not EBA style. So, This map don't have to use EBA style.
BPM should be 143.06, Offset should be 745.
I wil change BPM as this word. But, take forever.may be.
Generally;
01:00:186 - Note here.
01:13:612 - ^
01:43:962 (2) - Move back 1/3.
01:46:899 (2) - Move 2/3 forward, end at 01:48:018.(from RE' : 2/3? not 1/ but 2/ ?)
01:55:291 (2) - 1/2 longer (yes this ends on the red tick)
01:58:228 (3) - 1/3 shorter.
02:02:004 (3) - 1/2 longer.
02:06:899 (1) - Delete.
02:21:305 to end - Move forward 1/3.

I'll uh mod the rest once you've changed the BPM.
SapphireGhost
osu! Alumni
2,618 posts
Joined June 2010
SapphireGhost
Generally a lemon
00:44:363 (1) This is the ultimate spacing nazi mod. The last point of this slider has to be moved up one pixel.
Resolutely a lemon
Nothing to say here.
Severity... a lemon?
Hm.

Really, there don't seem to be any issues with this beatmap that are worth harping on. Take a Star and get this ranked.
Yuzeyun
7,650 posts
Joined September 2010
Yuzeyun
Oh my, I think that my modding is already done, I found like 0 errors on the 4 levels. :D

So take this star as a reward becuse you deserve it.

SPOILER
This song is as old as me :)
aesopl19193
572 posts
Joined March 2009
aesopl19193
No comments on your style :D
No problems found

[Easy]
01:55:242 (2) - it is out of the grid area!(End point)

star :)
jericho2442
osu! Alumni
1,918 posts
Joined March 2009
jericho2442
ok this map is totally out of time

this song is based on 1/6 not only 1/3 thus because of that mostly all of your sliders are out of time.

ok ive fixed up one of your diffs with the correct timing, you can then follow that timing for the maps, also DO NOT use this diff, just use it to find the correct timing, all the sliders and spacing is now out (i aint remaking the whole map for you >_<) so fix up your maps with the note timing in this one
Download: Fool's Garden - Lemon Tree (RE1359EBA) [Severity TIMING].osu


call me back once you have finxed the timing on your maps and i will remod
HeatKai
osu! Alumni
2,801 posts
Joined April 2010
HeatKai
Sorry due delay + Exam getting near :o

[General]
Doesn't have insane diff ?
I think the song doesn't need 1/3 and 1/6 beat snap divisor D:
[Generally]
00:15:843 (2,3) - spacing
00:19:198 (2,3) - ^
00:24:231 (1) - so far? try make other pattern :3
00:35:974 (2,3) - spacing :3
00:39:329 (2,3) - ^
00:47:159 (3) - try to make like this :3 http://puu.sh/133y
00:50:654 (N) - add a spinner until 00:52:751
00:57:784 (1,2,3,4,5) - spacing :3
01:11:204 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^
01:20:431 (1) - what is this ? D: put clap only ? :3
01:34:691 (1) - remove new combo
01:55:242 (2) - the end ? =.= whistle + finish ? doesnt sound quite right
01:58:178 (3) - this too
02:01:952 (3) - this too =.=
02:10:550 (3) - i think this circle should be at the right tick D:
02:17:680 (N) - add a spinner until 2:19:987
02:25:020 (1,2,3,4,5) - spacing
after that all the same problem goes again :3
so check for yourself XD
same like before

[resolutely]
00:23:183 (4) - go to red tick
00:36:604 (4) - go to red tick
00:39:959 (4) - ^
00:43:314 (4) - ^
00:50:654 (N) - add a spinner until 00:52:751
01:00:719 (1,2,3) - spacing
02:17:680 (N) - add a spinner until 2:19:987
02:32:359 (3) - go to red tick D:

[Severity]
00:47:089 (5) - start the slider at the red tick end at the white tick.
00:48:766 (6) - go to red tick
01:20:432 (1) - remove new combo and what the again =.=
01:34:691 (1) - remove new combo
01:47:483 (4,5) - go to red tick D:
02:17:680 (N) - add a spinner until 2:19:987
02:31:520 (3,4,5,6) - go to red tick =.=
02:45:780 (6) - ^
02:56:894 (1) - doesn't hit the rhythm =.=

[Extremity]
00:31:151 (8) - go to red tick ~
00:50:654 (N) - add a spinner until 00:52:751
01:20:432 (1) - remove new combo and same =.=''
01:34:691 (1) - remove new combo
02:14:185 (9,10) - doesn't hit the rhythm ?
02:17:680 (N) - add a spinner until 2:19:987
02:32:359 (6) - go to red tick
02:37:322 (4,5) - doesn't hit the rhythm
02:55:007 (3) - go to red tick
02:56:894 (1) - doesn't hit the rhythm

[Overall]
Still need many mods D:
btw , starred ~ *
good luck RE1359EBA :)
theowest
osu! Alumni
6,891 posts
Joined January 2009
theowest
Is it okay if I make a difficulty?
I'll make a hard beatmap... All your beatmaps are ALL easy... Which is not good!
Please let me make a diff.
I will also make a better background for this beatmap too.

You must mod my beatmap too if you want me to mod this beatmap or make a diff for it.
theowest
osu! Alumni
6,891 posts
Joined January 2009
theowest
So I'm guessing I'm not allowed to make a diff?

Dude. For the harder diffs you need to put the beats closer in the timing. It's okay to put the beats for every word he's saying and not just putting a slider where he sings a whole sentence.
ziin
2,632 posts
Joined January 2010
ziin
[generally]
easy difficulties are better if you avoid offbeat stuff like the plague.
00:15:843 (2,3) - slider, add a note at 00:16:682 -
00:36:604 (3) - this and may after it are not on the 1/3, though as I said before, I would make them on the beat.
00:47:159 (3) - these long sliders sound bad when you start them off the beat because the slider ticks will all be off as well.
02:06:776 (1) - should be on a 1/3rd. I would go so far as to say there shouldn't be any notes on the 1/2 (there are, but only because the vocals aren't singing it correctly).

[the rest of them]
more notes and everything I suggested on generally. If you think it sounds weird, don't map it, and map the background instead.
DerekMcD
1,484 posts
Joined February 2009
DerekMcD
Hello, three months of modding??? Aww... :o

That needs a star...
A8mew
74 posts
Joined February 2010
A8mew
Over a year of this map being worked on.

Have a star.
gustjr1997
51 posts
Joined April 2011
gustjr1997
star
Screenagers
42 posts
Joined May 2011
Screenagers
starrrr
Hyguys
1,272 posts
Joined May 2010
Hyguys
Ok time to mod this correctly.
Generally
00:16:542 (3) - Spacing (Nazi)
00:19:897 (3) - Spacing (Nazi)
00:23:253 (3) - Spacing (If you do this it could be better)
00:24:231 (1) - Whistle on the end , but remove clap.
00:27:866 (3) - ^
00:31:780 (4) - 1 grid up
00:55:127 (2) - One tick 1/6 later
00:56:805 (4) - ^
01:07:849 (1) - Spacing

Meh for me other diffs are fine . No kd.
Derekku
COOL DUDE
7,270 posts
Joined March 2009
Derekku
Denied kudosu (again) for unsubstantial mod posts and star posts. Please see this thread for information on when to give kudosu.
BanchoBot
w00t p00t
34,833 posts
Here since the beginning
BanchoBot
This modding thread has been migrated to the new "modding discussions" system. Please make sure to re-post any existing (and unresolved) efforts to the new system as required.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply

0
13 / 104