Hello~ Mod as requested through forum PM~
[General]
- Unrankable issues
- My opinion which I highly recommend changing it
- Just small suggestions/nazi
[General]
- The red line could go to 00:00:477 - this point, no point bringing the offset 4 beats back. It still won't mess up the downbeat and upbeat measures, so it should be fine, unless it is intended.
- Pretty sure the AudioLeadIn should be increased by 1000, the song starts really early.
- Other than that, look fine. I hope you are adding combo colours and video~
- 00:39:905 (3) - Just being nitpicky about the flow here, this could possibly lean towards the left, taking in the account of the curve from the previous slider.
- 00:44:620 (4) - I seriously don't like to make blanket mods... But this one just struck me hard.
- 00:48:048 (2,3) - These 2 looks really close together. I can see that you are trying to keep a linear flow for 00:46:763 (1,2,3) - , but in fact these could looks better when they are further apart for better playability. Well I guess I am being sensitive to things...
- 00:57:477 (2,1) - Just saying, these 2 could be the same shape, I think it would look better with these 2 being the same shape (and symmetrical at same time)
- The difficulty is really well done, can't point out much
- 00:10:763 (1) - Ok I get the long sliders and all (I like your diffs
), but this seems not right... This slider skips out important beats especially at 00:11:620 - .
- 00:26:191 (1) - Hmm... Rather a sharp curve at the end of this slider... Well you may keep this if you insist, but I feel that sharp angle curve which completely goes in the opposite direction from the slider doesn't play out nicely on normal, it is kind of hard to read the repeat ;-; Instead, this could be symmetrical :
- Well what can I say, good difficulty
- 00:34:655 - If 00:31:227 (7) - this was emphasized, this place should be also emphasized for the consistency.
- 00:45:048 (1,2) - These notes have strong beats on them, but yet they don't really have the same or a higher DS than 00:43:334 (1) - , which was pretty much weaker. These 2 notes should have 2.0x DS, and instead 00:43:334 (1) - this note should have smaller DS on it, but I guess you could keep it for the pattern.
- 00:56:191 (3,4) - Swap the hitsounds on these for the consistency from the previous part. Or if you want to emphasize the vocals, using soft whistles will do the job.
- 01:06:048 (5,6) - Flow doesn't really look too good here, you could instead go make a parallel pattern off these :
- Well overall the hitsounds on kiai could be improved using some whistles, and some flow issues could be addressed too. Still, good job on this difficulty
- 00:41:405 - Feels weird to leave this out as you didn't leave this beat out on 00:39:691 - , or are you just following the vocals for this part?
- 00:41:620 (1) - You should keep the momentum from the previous flow, this slider should be above 00:41:191 (8) - instead of being below.
- 00:42:048 (2,3,4) - I don't really hear any instruments or beats which justifies (3)... You could keep the consistency, so deleting (3) and instead placing it back at 00:42:370 - will sound more nicer.
- 00:52:763 (4) - Being nitpicky here, but the flow would be better if this was pointing directly at 00:53:191 (5) - .
- 01:06:477 (4) - But for this one though... Straight slider on a sqaure pattern doesn't look that much pleasing... You could again make this point towards (5), or instead go for variety and make this into a triplet.
- Well no definite issues on this difficulty. just being me bad at modding insane
- 00:13:763 - Just mentioning this, this green line isn't snapped.
- 00:26:191 (1,2,3,4) - Not really sure, but players should be able to notice the difference between 1/1's distance and 1/2's distance, right now this pattern (1/1) is having techincally the same DS as all other 1/2 patterns in this section. You could further reduce these notes' distance, or make a trap :
- 01:15:477 (7,1) - Would look better if these were having the same shape.
- No definite issues on this difficulty too. again being bad on modding insane