Honestly, the decision between slaini and Jess is kinda a difficult one, my votes have been because of PoE this whole game though...
forum
Carbon-14 Mafia! [Town Win]
posted
Total Posts
463
I think Jess will be a better vote if sLaiNi pushes it.
Let's say, at this moment I am definitely fine with a Jess lynch if she does not finally start talking.Hika wrote:
I think Jess will be a better vote if sLaiNi pushes it.
For this game thought, I don't like the statement, that "lynching a town who is not helping to win is not bad", because every misslynch is crucial for town in this mini setup without protective PR.
To make it clear:
Jess explain yourself and finally make some indepth reads.
@Hika My biggest scumread ATM would be Jess and I have a very strong feeling that there's scum between MB and xiz, while I strongly tend to xiz.
Jess explain yourself and finally make some indepth reads.
@Hika My biggest scumread ATM would be Jess and I have a very strong feeling that there's scum between MB and xiz, while I strongly tend to xiz.
^sLaiNi wrote:
Jess explain yourself and finally make some indepth reads.
@Jess, I'll give you a chance before I start thinking that you're 100% scum.
If you are a PR, reveal yourself and RC, and if not, at least give us some reads.
MBomb
Topic Starter
Vote Count 1.04
[0] Hika --
[2] -[Jess]- -- sLaiNi, Xiz (L-2)
[0] sLaNi --
[0] - Magic Bomb - --
[1] Xiz -- -[Jess]-
[0] Static Noise Bird --
[0] Gumica --
[0] No Lynch --
Not Voting -- Static Noise Bird, Gumica, - Magic Bomb -, Hika
With 7 alive, it's 4 to lynch.
[0] Hika --
[2] -[Jess]- -- sLaiNi, Xiz (L-2)
[0] sLaNi --
[0] - Magic Bomb - --
[1] Xiz -- -[Jess]-
[0] Static Noise Bird --
[0] Gumica --
[0] No Lynch --
Not Voting -- Static Noise Bird, Gumica, - Magic Bomb -, Hika
With 7 alive, it's 4 to lynch.
No, I don't think she'll say anything different. Meh. This is the most frustrating part about a game. Won't even call in a replacement ...
I am at school now,post later.
MBomb
MBomb
I might not be here later either. I haven't sleept for the last 48 hours. I'm killed. So just in case:
Vote: Xiz
Vote: Xiz
Give me some times, I have back to school.
DoneHika wrote:
^sLaiNi wrote:
Jess explain yourself and finally make some indepth reads.
@Jess, I'll give you a chance before I start thinking that you're 100% scum.
If you are a PR, reveal yourself and RC, and if not, at least give us some reads.
So first at all,I am a VT.Second here is my read:
(Scum)sLaiNi<Xiz<Gumi<Hika<MB(town)
I'm assuming your reasons for these reads, especially scum ones are over the same reasons as other people mentioned?
You're voting Xiz, yet your biggest scumread is sLaiNi?
Where is SNB on your list?
You're voting Xiz, yet your biggest scumread is sLaiNi?
Where is SNB on your list?
I am fixing now ;w;Gumica wrote:
I'm assuming your reasons for these reads, especially scum ones are over the same reasons as other people mentioned?
You're voting Xiz, yet your biggest scumread is sLaiNi?
Where is SNB on your list?
ummm
Deadline is September 25 at 7:30PM EST (UTC-4)7:30PM EST (1:30AM Central Europe, or 0:30AM for you in UK)
omg i forgot SNB. He is null-[Jess]- wrote:
So first at all,I am a VT.Second here is my read:
(Scum)sLaiNi<Xiz<Gumi<Hika<MB(town)
LoLz I just post the first part,here is the explain,
sLaiNi - I can't explain.Just look at his posts,He is very scummy.And he just like to push me to lynch(because I am the most easiest lynch).
Xiz - he just like a newbie scum,Pushing a easy mislynch .
Gumi - gut feeling,also I am a she
SNB - also gut feeling
Hika - She read my as town,So i will trusting she is town
MB - no time to explain.
unvote
vote:sLaiNi
That it.
If I die,please lynch Xiz,thanks.
MBomb
Topic Starter
Vote Count 1.05
[0] Hika --
[2] -[Jess]- -- sLaiNi, Xiz (L-2)
[1] sLaNi -- -[Jess]-
[0] - Magic Bomb - --
[1] Xiz -- Gumica
[0] Static Noise Bird --
[0] Gumica --
[0] No Lynch --
Not Voting -- Static Noise Bird, - Magic Bomb -, Hika
With 7 alive, it's 4 to lynch.
[0] Hika --
[2] -[Jess]- -- sLaiNi, Xiz (L-2)
[1] sLaNi -- -[Jess]-
[0] - Magic Bomb - --
[1] Xiz -- Gumica
[0] Static Noise Bird --
[0] Gumica --
[0] No Lynch --
Not Voting -- Static Noise Bird, - Magic Bomb -, Hika
With 7 alive, it's 4 to lynch.
@Ace, So Jess is a doublevoter? :3Ace Timing wrote:
Vote Count 1.05
[0] Hika --
[2] -[Jess]- -- sLaiNi, Xiz (L-2)
[1] sLaNi -- -[Jess]-
[0] - Magic Bomb - --
[2] Xiz -- -[Jess]-, Gumica (L-2)
[0] Static Noise Bird --
[0] Gumica --
[0] No Lynch --
Not Voting -- Static Noise Bird, - Magic Bomb -, Hika
With 7 alive, it's 4 to lynch.
Topic Starter
[insert sarcastic comment here]Gumica wrote:
@Ace, So Jess is a doublevoter? :3Ace Timing wrote:
Vote Count 1.05
[0] Hika --
[2] -[Jess]- -- sLaiNi, Xiz (L-2)
[1] sLaNi -- -[Jess]-
[0] - Magic Bomb - --
[2] Xiz -- -[Jess]-, Gumica (L-2)
[0] Static Noise Bird --
[0] Gumica --
[0] No Lynch --
Not Voting -- Static Noise Bird, - Magic Bomb -, Hika
With 7 alive, it's 4 to lynch.
Considering she just roleclaimed VT and is now apparently a doublevoter, lel....
:^)
:^)
Wut, was it a mod mistake or is she really DV, thought this is an open game
Topic Starter
what error?
There is no error. All roles are in the Sample PMs.Ace Timing wrote:
[1] sLaNi -- -[Jess]-
MBomb
wutGumica wrote:
@Ace, So Jess is a doublevoter? :3Ace Timing wrote:
Vote Count 1.05
[0] Hika --
[2] -[Jess]- -- sLaiNi, Xiz (L-2)
[1] sLaNi -- -[Jess]-
[0] - Magic Bomb - --
[2] Xiz -- -[Jess]-, Gumica (L-2)
[0] Static Noise Bird --
[0] Gumica --
[0] No Lynch --
Not Voting -- Static Noise Bird, - Magic Bomb -, Hika
With 7 alive, it's 4 to lynch.
Lolz
I am NOT a dv orz
I am NOT a dv orz
you know, just the fact that he has a vote both on sLaiNi and Xiz...
囧rzGumica wrote:
you know, just the fact that he has a vote both on sLaiNi and Xiz...
Mod fix it please
MBomb
It's just a mod error. It's open setup so just chill out my love bugs. :*
Yeah well.. I wasn't trying to be mean =) I just put it in a sarcastic way, in a way which apparently wasn't taken lightly 
Anyways, 7 hours or so remain.
imho Jess's post makes little to no difference to me, but the majority of you should've changed your votes now, the votes which were based on pressuring Jess.
Anyways, 7 hours or so remain.
imho Jess's post makes little to no difference to me, but the majority of you should've changed your votes now, the votes which were based on pressuring Jess.
MBomb
As far as I know, no other people voted for that reason other than me, and I've already stated why I'm keeping my vote on her.Gumica wrote:
Yeah well.. I wasn't trying to be mean =) I just put it in a sarcastic way, in a way which apparently wasn't taken lightly
Anyways, 7 hours or so remain.
imho Jess's post makes little to no difference to me, but the majority of you should've changed your votes now, the votes which were based on pressuring Jess.
I will not around the deadline tho,I was still asleep.
sLaiNi said that too.
And I'm pretty sure Xiz had the same kind of idea behind his vote, since he never said anything (but then again, he never really gave any propper explanation for any other of his votes..)
And I'm pretty sure Xiz had the same kind of idea behind his vote, since he never said anything (but then again, he never really gave any propper explanation for any other of his votes..)
@Mod, is it really meant to have 2 votes of Jess on 2 different persons?
Yeah I said that it was a pressure vote, but at some point I stated that it's a real vote now.
Yeah I said that it was a pressure vote, but at some point I stated that it's a real vote now.
MBomb
MBomb
As far as I can see, this is the only indication that your vote isn't just a pressure vote and even this isn't that strong.sLaiNi wrote:
@Mod, is it really meant to have 2 votes of Jess on 2 different persons?
Yeah I said that it was a pressure vote, but at some point I stated that it's a real vote now.
sLaiNi wrote:
Let's say, at this moment I am definitely fine with a Jess lynch if she does not finally start talking.Hika wrote:
I think Jess will be a better vote if sLaiNi pushes it.
For this game thought, I don't like the statement, that "lynching a town who is not helping to win is not bad", because every misslynch is crucial for town in this mini setup without protective PR.
MBomb
MBomb
I'd still prefer Jess as a sacrificial lynch any day over SNB. I'd prefer to check him out later tbh.
MBomb
I see what you did there- Magic Bomb - wrote:
And unlike Jess I eat and type at the same time :^)
MBomb
All Xiz had said at this point is his points leading up to him thinking either Slaini or Jess are scum, which didn't seem to even be that confusing, and seemed like genuine scumhunting, at least in my eyes.Static Noise Bird wrote:
I think it's a bit early to call this, but Xiz is scum. AFAIK he's only causing confusion or just otherwise sincerely playing bad.
The other one could be anyone.
Firstly, Gumica had only made 4 posts at this point, 2 of which were joke posts. Secondly, assuming someone who always plays badly is scum because they're playing badly is stupid logic.Static Noise Bird wrote:
Gumica is town. treebomb seems to be building wishful conspiracies which is not exactly helpful.
Jess is playing bad like always so I'm assuming they're scum as always.
Yet he never actually did, despite the fact this was the second time he hinted at the fact he thought Xiz was scum, and had no other scum reads that he even mentioned.Static Noise Bird wrote:
Considering voting Xiz for now.
After this, it's all just "lurking, lurking, trying to make this post not look like a prod dodge, lurking".
MBomb
Lawl, there is an equal counterwagon.- Magic Bomb - wrote:
Oh also the lack of counterwagon in response to jess is worrying.
I mean, I already tried to counter it , not by voting but by observation and crap.
I want to wait for Xiz first. If he doesn't show up, Jess goes first.
MBomb
MBomb
Well, you don't need a counterwagon to express an opinion. Me and Hika have both expressed opposition to lyching Jess.
Anyways, yeah, I was actually thinking of SNB yesterday, since he said he'd post his thoughts on the recent posts, but he never did.
Anyways, yeah, I was actually thinking of SNB yesterday, since he said he'd post his thoughts on the recent posts, but he never did.
By "we" in Xiz bandwagon you mainly mean just me, since i'm the only one on it;
- Irrational Switching
- Voting Jess for ??
- 46h inactivity
- Not really contributing in any way
- Irrational Switching
- Voting Jess for ??
- 46h inactivity
- Not really contributing in any way
Waiting for his defense.- Magic Bomb - wrote:
Wait why are we watiing for xiz, just his reason for voting Jess or is there something else (I do agree with this but for a different reason).Hika wrote:
I want to wait for Xiz first. If he doesn't show up, Jess goes first.
MBomb
Topic Starter
Xiz has been prodded.
Yes, I know I forgot the Bold.Ace Timing wrote:
Xiz has been prodded.
@Mod, is it supposed to be like that, that Jess has 2 votes on 2 different persons?
Topic Starter
Hasn't been 36 hours yet~
@Mod: Votecount please
Saying nothing is more of an answer than I need.
My vote will stay on Jess no matter what happens. She is a double voter, claimed VT and the mod said that all role pm's are in the first post.
Town:
VT
Seer
Cop
Scum:
"Randomly assigned"
When joining the game I thought, that this was meant to be "the scum members are randomly assigned", but I seem to have been wrong there.
My vote will stay on Jess no matter what happens. She is a double voter, claimed VT and the mod said that all role pm's are in the first post.
Town:
VT
Seer
Cop
Scum:
"Randomly assigned"
When joining the game I thought, that this was meant to be "the scum members are randomly assigned", but I seem to have been wrong there.
I meant this one.Ace Timing wrote:
- Mafia Goons or Werewolves are chosen randomly by the mod pregame
MBomb
He ran over it like twice too so idk...
I've had a bad headache for 5 or 6 days now but it's starting to get easy on me during nights (with an exception of yesterday).
Might be voting Jess in a minute.
Might be voting Jess in a minute.
Easy there. I saw it as genuine confusionmaking, you saw it as scumhunting. If you and Xiz both end up flipping scum, now I wouldn't be surprised anymore.- Magic Bomb - wrote:
All Xiz had said at this point is his points leading up to him thinking either Slaini or Jess are scum, which didn't seem to even be that confusing, and seemed like genuine scumhunting, at least in my eyes.Static Noise Bird wrote:
I think it's a bit early to call this, but Xiz is scum. AFAIK he's only causing confusion or just otherwise sincerely playing bad.
The other one could be anyone.
Gumica seemed townish by default. Secondly, if anyone took that seriously, I'm sorry. Meta is a retarded argument in the first place, and I'm always using it ironically. Good thing you got that.- Magic Bomb - wrote:
Firstly, Gumica had only made 4 posts at this point, 2 of which were joke posts. Secondly, assuming someone who always plays badly is scum because they're playing badly is stupid logic.Static Noise Bird wrote:
Gumica is town. treebomb seems to be building wishful conspiracies which is not exactly helpful.
Jess is playing bad like always so I'm assuming they're scum as always.
You didn't get the "considering" part, now did you?- Magic Bomb - wrote:
Yet he never actually did, despite the fact this was the second time he hinted at the fact he thought Xiz was scum, and had no other scum reads that he even mentioned.Static Noise Bird wrote:
Considering voting Xiz for now.
After this, it's all just "lurking, lurking, trying to make this post not look like a prod dodge, lurking".
My reads on everyone got hazier afterwards (pretty sure I mentioned that, of course you didn't quote that because it wasn't relevant to your "scumhunting" post here), which is why I never voted him.
I'm only now getting more sure about you and Xiz again, possibly Jess too. If the scumteam falls completely or even partially outside you three, good job scum.
Not proofreading this because my headache is returning, damn it.
Gumica's posts seem overall less aggressive but also info-emptier than Xiz's very aggressive start, so it does also make sense Gumica is a more possible candidate for a scum than Xiz.
Hika is absolutely null to me currently.
Gotta re-read Slaini and Gumica now.
Hika is absolutely null to me currently.
Gotta re-read Slaini and Gumica now.
It's only supposed to have 2 scums...atleast I am sure there is nothing to missunderstand regarding this, while we missunderstood the roles.Static Noise Bird wrote:
I'm only now getting more sure about you and Xiz again, possibly Jess too. If the scumteam falls completely or even partially outside you three, good job scum.
I wish you that your headache gets better and I will go to bed now, as I get an headache, too and I am really tired.
See you in two days, hopefully.
MBomb
This is the only post even close to saying your reads were getting hazier, and I'm pretty sure it's a lot easier and makes a lot more sense to take this as "less confident about the people I was reading as scum".Static Noise Bird wrote:
Getting more and more confident about Jess (once again) and less confident about pretty much everyone else.
MBomb
MBomb
So wait, what you're saying is "Oh, MB and Xiz are probably scum together, but Xiz is less likely to be scum than other people". Are you implying that I'm scum with someone else, or there's a different scum team?Static Noise Bird wrote:
Gumica's posts seem overall less aggressive but also info-emptier than Xiz's very aggressive start, so it does also make sense Gumica is a more possible candidate for a scum than Xiz.
Gumica stated interest in lynching Xiz while not forming any kind of wagon successfully, so it's likely they both can't be scum.
Other than that, I can already see no hunt process involved in the rest of his good amount of posts. Perfectly reminds me of someone else who indeed was scum in an earlier game this year.
Other than that, I can already see no hunt process involved in the rest of his good amount of posts. Perfectly reminds me of someone else who indeed was scum in an earlier game this year.
I meant if none of the three I mentioned are scum, then I'm surprised. But then again my reads just changed after re-reading Gumica and Xiz.sLaiNi wrote:
It's only supposed to have 2 scums...atleast I am sure there is nothing to missunderstand regarding this, while we missunderstood the roles.
Mostly because you're really just trying to look for evidence, while I'm trying to help town as best as I can.- Magic Bomb - wrote:
And just wondering, are you scumreading me just because I'm voting you, or is there some other reason?
Vote: Gumica
You know, differing opinions and such. I guess that's why you voted me in the first place, too.
MBomb
Surely, getting evidence is the best way to help town, if you can find something incriminating for someone, you can find the scumteam? Either way, I find that vote interesting, ik why you did it because you stated earlier, but I didn't expect it.Static Noise Bird wrote:
Mostly because you're really just trying to look for evidence, while I'm trying to help town as best as I can.- Magic Bomb - wrote:
And just wondering, are you scumreading me just because I'm voting you, or is there some other reason?
Vote: Gumica
I wasn't expecting Gumi vote either. You really don't think Jess is good enough for a lynch?
MBomb
Xiz may not show up. I'm gonna drop my vote on Jess if he doesn't though. Who is against this?
MBomb
I'll be here until deadline. I have my eyes on this on purpose.
Topic Starter
This refers to whether the scum team is werewolf or mafia.sLaiNi wrote:
I meant this one.Ace Timing wrote:
- Mafia Goons or Werewolves are chosen randomly by the mod pregame
Lack of hunting you say? Hmm. I don't know what you define as a hunting proccess. You think the key is always a direct agrression?
I think it's more about gathering and assessing informartion. Besides, unlike the majority here, I wasn't hunting inactive folks, but rather going after the one that seemed the most scummy through their posts at the time (Xiz). But then again, half of the players were kind of inactive, including yourself, so I guess it's hard for you to understand.
Hmm hmm
I think it's more about gathering and assessing informartion. Besides, unlike the majority here, I wasn't hunting inactive folks, but rather going after the one that seemed the most scummy through their posts at the time (Xiz). But then again, half of the players were kind of inactive, including yourself, so I guess it's hard for you to understand.
Hmm hmm
MBomb
Then Jess if we are already on it... I'm still watching the clock.
MBomb
I'm scared to hammer that lol. I still have my doubts...
MBomb