sukiNathan wrote:

[HanZer's Insane]

1. 00:21:954 (1,2) - Spacing is a bit weird compared to 00:16:101 (1,2) and 00:19:027 (1,2)
2. 00:38:784 (3,4) - Move this somewhere else as a pair so 00:38:784 (3) isn't covered by 00:38:052 (1)
3. 00:42:076 (2) - Bump this up a tiny bit with 00:41:710 (1) so it looks neater without the tiny overlap onto 00:42:442 (3)
4. 01:42:259 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - fun pattern owo

[Reunion]

1. 00:01:467 (1,2,3,4) - This sequence is repeated 8 times throughout the start, it's fine but some reverse sliders or something like that would be nice for variety ._.
2. 00:24:881 (1) - Use finish instead?
3. 01:08:418 (3) - Why not add finish on the head if you used it on 00:24:515 (7)
4. 01:56:893 (3) - Add clap?
5. 02:08:601 (5) - ^

You can have a star since I didn't find much I guess :c

1. The company that made Deemo is named Rayark games, not Rayark. So you should add games.
2. The song comes from Collection 1: Deemo selection. So suggested tags: collection, collection_1 and selection.
3. Rayark Games made also Cytus, older brother of Deemo. Why not add Cytus in tags?

Pappy wrote:

Oh also I saw some tags that you can use.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

1. The company that made Deemo is named Rayark games, not Rayark. So you should add games.
2. The song comes from Collection 1: Deemo selection. So suggested tags: collection, collection_1 and selection.
3. Rayark Games made also Cytus, older brother of Deemo. Why not add Cytus in tags?

Why Winek in tags? He made any diff?

cytusmusic wrote:

i don't know how to mod just a quick question uwu

[reunion]

01:43:906 -- this stream is hard to play, the electric guitar solo doesn't match up well with it and the background rhythm isn't really audible.
If there were another, more enjoyable way to map this, I would definitely do it but for now, there seems to be a guitar stream here and so I mapped it :< [btw I kno that 01:43:906 (1) might be an awk start to the stream, but it fits the guitar, so tap the slider with the less dominant key first then stream or whatever]
01:49:942 (1,2) -- why are these two notes here? they don't seem to have any place in the song.
I'm guessing that you're referring to 01:49:759 (1,2) instead of 01:51:223 (1,2) (which happens to be where your link is redirected ) Anyway, there are two cymbal clashes in the background, not the music, that I'm mapping

JeZag wrote:

so I guess I'm finally ready for a re-mod =o=

1. letterboxing during breaks just cuts off bg girl's face so maybe don't do that
2. winek being an inspiration isn't really a reason to include him in the tags. you don't see hanzer putting fanzhen in all his maps' tags right yea no
3. preview point unsnapped :/
4. um the "wav" folder in your beatmap folder... do something about it. right now the hitsounds inside aren't used cuz they're in that folder. if you do plan on using them, they blend so much with the song that they provide no feedback at all, so that wouldn't really work. deleting the drum-hitnormal file and allowing the default drum hitnormal to be used would fix that
5. kiai in reunion/easy are different from normal/intermediate/hard. needs to be the same for all diffs except the gd
6. should be using the standard silent hitsound instead of those weird ones you're using now. get it here
7. OD on normal/intermediate/hard should be increased by 1. reunion could also be 8

1. 00:02:930 (2,1) - 00:17:198 (2,3) - 01:10:247 (3,1) - 02:13:174 (3,4) - spacing inconsistencies
2. 01:08:052 (1,2) - probably should swap new combos. it's acceptable at like 00:41:710 (1,2) - since vocal phrases are separated on the place you have a new combo, but in this instance that's not a thing. also it's the same as 02:08:052 (4,1) - musically (despite pitch whatever) and combos are good there so
3. 01:14:637 (1) - don't need the new combo since you don't include one on 02:14:637 (5) - 01:38:052 (5) - which are the same sort of thing. other diffs don't include new combos on this either. dunno why spinner should indicate new combo or not
4. 01:38:235 (1) - 5% volume on this spinner makes no sense. here music is continuing and you've just got silent spinner on a loud part. leaving it at 40% volume is k
5. 01:51:223 (1,2,3,4) - spacing is so broken damn
6. 02:14:820 (1) - would make sense to increase volume to like 20% and have a whistle. piano sound yes

1. 00:16:102 (1,2) - 01:57:991 (3,1) - spacing inconsistencies
2. 00:39:881 (2,4) - stackign of these = super confusing. just anything so they aren't stacked would work
3. 01:14:820 (1) - 01:38:235 (1) - 02:14:820 (1) - same as easy. silent spinner stuff pointless. also whistle on the first and last ones piano
4. 01:06:223 (2,3,1) - arrangement of stuff here is also unnecessarily confusing. like anything where things aren't spaced so they're almost on top of each other is fine
5. 01:32:198 (1,2,3) - adjusting your spacing to look like it did with the regular slider velocity would just work better (that would be 1.4x spacing) https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2802702

1. spinners
2. 01:01:466 (1,2) - 01:03:479 (3,4) - spacing inconsistencies
3. 00:58:906 - seems really weird to not cover this. it's like reflective with 00:57:442 - which you have covered. second kiai also covers both. i dunno what you'd do about a pattern there but something should happen. a possibility
4. 01:26:339 - should probably snap the unsnappedline
5. 01:50:857 (4,1) - stacking is kind of not great when you're breaking spacing like this :/ would be better to just ignore the stack completely since it's not gonna be noticeable ingame and use 1.5x spacing like the other 1/1 gaps before this
6. 01:58:174 (4) - rhythm here just seems weird cuz of the passive end. something like this would work. removing the reverse on 4, moving 1 back by 1/2 and stacking a circle on 2.

1. spinnerssssss

2. previous mod wrote:

   00:01:471 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - whole section has a lot more object density than it really should. it's pretty much the same as the section starting at 00:13:178 (1) - yet the music is waaaaaaaaaaay different. the "reunion" difficulty even has less movement than this, which is not right at all. you'll probably want to create less intense rhythms here.

   this still applies. overmapping in a hard diff while insanes don't is just not a thing
3. 00:13:174 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,1,2,3) - so much congestion here that it's a major pain to read. like you're sticking everything in 1/4 of the playfield and every object overlaps. some major rearranging needs to be done. would also be good to include spacing variation of some sort since you start doing that everywhere after these objects :/
4. 00:17:564 (1,2) - would be easier to read that this is a jump by moving 1 further away from 00:17:198 (3) - . right now it just looks like a 1/1 gap cuz everything prior to this was distance snapped. remap the intro bit up to here if you really need to cuz it's worse than like everything that comes afterwards
5. 00:24:881 (1) - you've got rhythmic gaps during the four measures starting here, then the four measures starting at 00:30:735 (1) - have no gaps at all. makes no sense since the song is the exact same in both places
6. 00:25:247 (2,3) - would be easier to read that this isn't a jump by moving 3's head further from 2's tail. like 1.4x spacing is good so it's the same as the previous 1/1 gap
7. 00:35:857 (3,4,1) - large jumps between multiple circles on hards uh not gonna go well. something like this would work, or anything that
8. 00:36:223 (1,5) - should swap new comboz
9. 00:43:540 (5,1) - if your comboing around here is supposed to be following vocal phrases, combos here should be swapped
10. 00:50:491 (2,3) - these kind of 1/4 jumps in hard diffs not gonna work. needs to be consistent spacing for the entire 1/4 crap
11. 00:53:418 (3,4) - spacing should be reduced. something like this would work well.
12. 01:02:747 (1,3) - new combos should be swapped
13. 01:02:747 (1,2,3) - pretty sure you didnt intend for these to underlap with 01:02:198 (3) - . stack is evil. something should be moved
14. 01:02:931 (3,4) - spacing shoudl be reduced. something like this is possible
15. 01:10:248 (1,2,3) - something about spacing toolarge. moving 01:09:699 (3,1) - to the right and getting rid of 01:10:613 (2) - with a reverse on 1 is an alternative
16. 01:12:259 (2,3) - 01:12:991 (4,1) - jumps that rely entirely on momentum change don't really work very well. like anything else would work. literally anything
17. 01:27:259 (1,3) - shoudl swap new comboz
18. 01:28:723 (1,2) - zzzz^ if you were trying to follow vocal phrases it doesn't work when you start doing downbeat comboing right afterwards :/
19. 01:32:564 (2) - would be cooler if more to the left to avoid overlap with 4
20. 01:35:674 (3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - pretty much all the spacing here is too much. i can't say it any other way
21. 01:56:162 (2,3,4,5) - spacing should be reduced. stacking 2 and 4 may not work. having 4 closer to 5 would be more practical. or somthing like this which is like move everything
22. 02:02:565 (4) - 02:03:296 (2) - 02:03:845 (4) - 3 objects stacked in the same place so soon after each otehr super confusing. anything else would be better with less object congestion. extremely large spacing around all of this doesn't help either
23. 02:10:796 (3,4) - spacing something between 4 and stream too large this
24. 02:11:345 (1,5) - should swap new combos
25. 02:13:174 (1,2,3,4) - so um most people i ask say this is pretty hard to read and combobreaking on the last objects is not so good. anything that gives the same effect as this just without the overlapping slider ends would be great. pattern is too cool to rank

1. 00:45:369 (1) - if this section's comboing is following the vocals, new combos should be on 00:46:466 (3) - and 00:47:564 (3) - instead of 00:46:101 (1) - and 00:47:199 (1) -
2. 00:56:710 (8) - should probably new combo for the major sv change
3. 01:26:345 (1,2,3,4) - spacing here seems weird. if you wanted a jump from 3->4, make that clearer. constant spacing between them is also ok
4. 02:17:564 (1) - would work better as a straight slider cuz curve of 3 makes everything look gross.
5. 00:36:588 (1) - drums go into a half bpm sort of thing here, so lowering sv is expected. can just lower the sv multiplier to 1.25x and recalculate slider lengths, then you'll be good without any remapping bs. if you wanted to go lower though please do

pishifat wrote:

3 years later and the offbeat stream at 01:43:906 (1) - is now rankable

JeZag wrote:

so I guess I'm finally ready for a re-mod

[general]

1. letterboxing during breaks just cuts off bg girl's face so maybe don't do that fixed
2. winek being an inspiration isn't really a reason to include him in the tags. you don't see hanzer putting fanzhen in all his maps' tags right yea no fixed
3. preview point unsnapped :/ fixed
4. um the "wav" folder in your beatmap folder... do something about it. right now the hitsounds inside aren't used cuz they're in that folder. if you do plan on using them, they blend so much with the song that they provide no feedback at all, so that wouldn't really work. deleting the drum-hitnormal file and allowing the default drum hitnormal to be used would fix that fixed
5. kiai in reunion/easy are different from normal/intermediate/hard. needs to be the same for all diffs except the gd fixed
6. should be using the standard silent hitsound instead of those weird ones you're using now. get it here fixed
7. OD on normal/intermediate/hard should be increased by 1. reunion could also be 8 fixed

[easy]

1. 00:02:930 (2,1) - 00:17:198 (2,3) - 01:10:247 (3,1) - 02:13:174 (3,4) - spacing inconsistencies oops fixed
2. 01:08:052 (1,2) - probably should swap new combos. it's acceptable at like 00:41:710 (1,2) - since vocal phrases are separated on the place you have a new combo, but in this instance that's not a thing. also it's the same as 02:08:052 (4,1) - musically (despite pitch whatever) and combos are good there so fixed
3. 01:14:637 (1) - don't need the new combo since you don't include one on 02:14:637 (5) - 01:38:052 (5) - which are the same sort of thing. other diffs don't include new combos on this either. dunno why spinner should indicate new combo or not idk so fixed
4. 01:38:235 (1) - 5% volume on this spinner makes no sense. here music is continuing and you've just got silent spinner on a loud part. leaving it at 40% volume is k fixed
5. 01:51:223 (1,2,3,4) - spacing is so broken damn oops fixed
6. 02:14:820 (1) - would make sense to increase volume to like 20% and have a whistle. piano sound yes im going to have to ask you later about this

[normal]

1. 00:16:102 (1,2) - 01:57:991 (3,1) - spacing inconsistencies oopsies fixed
2. 00:39:881 (2,4) - stackign of these = super confusing. just anything so they aren't stacked would work fixed
3. 01:14:820 (1) - 01:38:235 (1) - 02:14:820 (1) - same as easy. silent spinner stuff pointless. also whistle on the first and last ones piano i'm going to have to ask for clarification again
4. 01:06:223 (2,3,1) - arrangement of stuff here is also unnecessarily confusing. like anything where things aren't spaced so they're almost on top of each other is fine fixed
5. 01:32:198 (1,2,3) - adjusting your spacing to look like it did with the regular slider velocity would just work better (that would be 1.4x spacing) https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/2802702 fixed

[intermediate]

1. spinners going to need to ask
2. 01:01:466 (1,2) - 01:03:479 (3,4) - spacing inconsistencies oops
3. 00:58:906 - seems really weird to not cover this. it's like reflective with 00:57:442 - which you have covered. second kiai also covers both. i dunno what you'd do about a pattern there but something should happen. a possibility give me a while to figure what to do with this
4. 01:26:339 - should probably snap the unsnappedline fixed
5. 01:50:857 (4,1) - stacking is kind of not great when you're breaking spacing like this :/ would be better to just fixedignore the stack completely since it's not gonna be noticeable ingame and use 1.5x spacing like the other 1/1 gaps before this
6. 01:58:174 (4) - rhythm here just seems weird cuz of the passive end. something like this would work. removing the reverse on 4, moving 1 back by 1/2 and stacking a circle on 2. fixed

[reunion]

1. 00:45:369 (1) - if this section's comboing is following the vocals, new combos should be on 00:46:466 (3) - and 00:47:564 (3) - instead of 00:46:101 (1) - and 00:47:199 (1) - fixed
2. 00:56:710 (8) - should probably new combo for the major sv change fixed
3. 01:26:345 (1,2,3,4) - spacing here seems weird. if you wanted a jump from 3->4, make that clearer. constant spacing between them is also ok completely unintended so fixed
4. 02:17:564 (1) - would work better as a straight slider cuz curve of 3 makes everything look gross. I'll reconsider
5. 00:36:588 (1) - drums go into a half bpm sort of thing here, so lowering sv is expected. can just lower the sv multiplier to 1.25x and recalculate slider lengths, then you'll be good without any remapping bs. if you wanted to go lower though please dofixed

[]

so all the diffs are good except hard. apply whatever you want and we'll see what needs to be changed from there

HanzeR wrote:

*HanzeR uses revive on JeZag*

HanzeR wrote:

6 months ago

Okoratu wrote:

what exactly is a BAT we got rid of that term more than 6 months ago are you from the past
didn't we also hax the damn mp3 in order to avoid that???

JeZag wrote:

So how 2 rank this? ><

pishifat wrote:

JeZag wrote:

So how 2 rank this? ><

how2rank

JeZag wrote:

A little BAT once told me that the drum section "doesn't work" because its untimed, while the stream is snapped, which is an "unrankable" feature. Should I just bug other BATs?
QQ

pretty sure the stream it's fine, but it's the guitar past 02:20:491 (1) - that's fucked. if you wanted to be super safe, you could end the insanes where the other diffs end... or you could not and i'll bubble anyway idc qats can deal with it

replace your two sliderslides with this http://up.ppy.sh/files/blank.wav (you said you fixed this from the last mod but you didnt pls)
both kiais on normal, intermediate, and hard end later than they should. same goes for second kiai on easy.... this was also in the last mod cmon dood

easy:
01:54:149 (1) - will need a "clearer sliderbody." just make that little corner visible and it's 100% rankable

normal:
02:06:406 - should be mapped just like every other measure that's covering this tick in the kiai
00:31:284 (3) - 01:03:479 (2) - 02:00:004 (1) - same thing as the sliderbody on normal -- make the corner bs more visible and it's k

intermediate:
00:58:540 (1,2) - triggered me then i noticed i mentioned it in the last mod and you said youd fix it bUT YOU DIDNT
01:14:637 (6) - 02:04:393 (1) - yeah uh dont stack these 2hidden for this level of difficulty

hard:
01:49:759 (4,5,6) - combo consistency tho 00:49:759 (1,2,1,2,3) -

hanzer:
smd

reunion:
00:50:857 (5,6) - hardcore 1/4 when there isnt even 1/2 here not gonna work. a 1/2 slider is the most you can do probably, or what you did before the second kiai 01:50:857 (6) - with just a circle and 1/1 gap
theres like a whole section unsanpped wtf open aimod

there's some other stuff that i dont really like but i dont really care at this point either. if it gets dq'd for anything (if you can mange to find another bn lol), we can deal with it then

pishifat wrote:

on intermediate, you forgot a new combo on 00:58:540 (5) - when fixing the thing and now your colorhax are broken
and you also forgot the second stack thing on this diff gg

alsooo you only replaced the first sliderslide, whereas sliderslide2 also needs to be using hte other file

alsoooo your kiais are all messed up still pleaseeeeeeeeeee

pishifat wrote:

pleaseeeeeeeeeee

pishifat wrote:

if someone says hanzer's stream is unrankable i will cry

JeZag wrote:

Especially Oko, Pishi, and HanzeR <3